33 By these places we perceive, that the Lords death was throughly foreknown, and understood, and did in no respect infringe the liberty, either of Christ, or of the father. Therefore Cicero, otherwise a very learned man, is greatly to be wondered at: 1against whom Augustine, in his fift book De civitate Dei, especiallie in the ninth & tenth chapters, earnestly disputeth concerning this question. The controversy dependeth upon this, that in the latter book De divinatione, all things are refelled, which were brought by Quintus, Ciceros brother, in the former book. And Cicero endeavoureth by all means, to overthrow all predictions of things to come, and of the prescience of God. Therefore Augustine affirmeth, that the Astrologians had reasons, which were better to be borne withal, than his: because, though they attribute overmuch unto the stars, yet they take not away all divination and prescience. 2And a certain Physician (as the same Augustine declareth in his book of confessions) being a grave man, and one that detested Astrology; when he was demanded, how it came to pass that Mathematicians did prophesy so many truths, he durst not (contrary unto all histories and experience) deny every divination; but he answered, that a certain destiny was spread over things: and he affirmed, that it was not incredible, but that reasonable souls did after a sort feel it. Surely there is nothing to be found more repugnant, 3than of the one side to affirm God to be; and on the other side to take from him the prescience of things to come. The prophet Isaiah would these things to be so firmly knit together, as he said; Show us what things shall come to pass, 4and we will declare you to be gods. But that Cicero had small knowledge, and no good judgement of God; it appeareth by his book, which he intituled ⟨p. 277⟩De natura deorum: wherein, disputing under the person of Cotta, he striveth utterly to take away the nature of God.
33 By these places we perceiue, that the Lords death was throughlie foreknowne, and vnderstood, and did in no respect infringe the libertie, either of Christ, or of the father. Therefore Cicero, otherwise a verie learned man, is greatlie to be woondered at: 1against whom Augustine, in his fift booke De ciuitate Dei, especiallie in the ninth & tenth chapters, earnestlie disputeth concerning this question. The controuersie dependeth vpon this, that in the latter booke De diuinatione, all things are refelled, which were brought by Quintus, Ciceros brother, in the former booke. And Cicero indeuoreth by all meanes, to ouerthrowe all predictions of things to come, and of the prescience of God. Therefore Augustine affirmeth, that the Astrologians had reasons, which were better to be borne withall, than his: bicause, though they attribute ouermuch vnto the starres, yet they take not awaie all diuination and prescience. 2And a certeine Physician (as the same Augustine declareth in his booke of confessions) being a graue man, and one that detested Astrologie; when he was demanded, how it came to passe that Mathematicians did prophesie so manie truths, he durst not (contrarie vnto all histories and experience) denie euerie diuination; but he answered, that a certeine destinie was spred ouer things: and he affirmed, that it was not incredible, but that reasonable soules did after a sort féele it. Surelie there is nothing to be found more repugnant, 3than of the one side to affirme God to be; and on the other side to take from him the prescience of things to come. The prophet Esaie would these things to be so firmelie knit togither, as he said; Shew vs what things shall come to passe, 4and we will declare you to be gods. But that Cicero had small knowledge, and no good iudgement of God; it appéereth by his booke, which he intituled ⟨p. 277⟩De natura deorum: wherein, disputing vnder the person of Cotta, he striueth vtterlie to take awaie the nature of God.
- 1Augustine against Cicero.
- 2Augustines example of a Physician
- 3If he be God he foreseeth things to come.
- 4Isaiah. 41, 23.Esai. 41, 23.