The sixth Chapter. The two main grounds, on which the supremacy usurped by the Pope, doth lie. The former, that there should be one Bishop over all in earth: 1 because Christ said, There shall be one flock, and one pastor; 2 and among the Jews there was one judge, and hie Priest. The later, that the Pope is that one Bishop: 3 because Peter was Bishop of Rome, (as some say,) 4 and the Pope succeedeth Peter. Both examined, and showed to fail in the proof of the Popes supremacy.The sixth Chapter. The two maine groundes, on which the supremacie vsurped by the Pope, doth lie. The former, that there should be one Bishop ouer all in earth: 1 because Christ said, There shall be one flocke, and one pastor; 2 and among the Iewes there was one iudge, and hie Priest. The later, that the Pope is that one Bishop: 3 because Peter was Bishop of Rome, (as some say,) 4 and the Pope succeedeth Peter. Both examined, and shewed to faile in the proofe of the Popes supremacie.
pp. 230–452703 passagespart 3 of 18
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Rainoldes. But nLyra, and Caietan (as worthy men, as they who compiled the Gloss, if you will hear men) do say that by the judge is meant the civill magistrate, even as I say. Which sense of the place is so plain & certain: that Carolus Sigonius, the Popes own historian (in
lately he set forth at Bononia, with approbation of the Bishop, and holy Inquisition, and dedicated to Pope Gregory the thirteenth, affirmeth that the king is meant by the judge in that place of Deuteronomy. It may be, M. Hart, that sith you were beyond-sea, they have bethought them selves: and seeing that your Gloss doth go against the text, they will no longer stand unto
⟨p. 252⟩
it. Indeed, if the supremacy belong to the judge▪ the Prince hath greater right thereto then the Pope. For it is certain (as I have declared by circumstances of the scripture,) that the Priest was not meant by the judge.
Rainoldes. But nLyra, and Caietan (as worthie men, as they who compiled the Glosse, if you will heare men) doo say that by the iudge is meant the ciuill magistrate, euen as I say. Which sense of the place is so plaine & certaine: that Carolus Sigonius, the Popes owne historian (in oa booke which *lately he set foorth at Bononia, with approbation of the Bishoppe, and holy Inquisition, and dedicated to Pope Gregory the thirtéenth, affirmeth that the king is meant by the iudge in that place of Deuteronomie. It may be, M. Hart, that sith you were beyond-sea, they haue bethought them selues: and seeing that your Glosse doth goe against the text, they will no longer stand vnto ⟨p. 252⟩it. Indéede, if the supremacie belong to the iudge▪ the Prince hath greater right thereto then the Pope. For it is certaine (as I haue declared by circumstances of the scripture,) that the Priest was not meant by the iudge.
nComment. in 17. Deut,
oDe repub. Hebraeor. lib. 6. cap. 7.
*In the year of Christ. 158••In the yeare of Christ. 158••
Hart. It skilleth not to my purpose, whether he were, or no. It sufficeth me, that he who refuseth to obey the Priest, must die, by the law. Which is enough to prove the sovereignty of one Priest.
Hart. It skilleth not to my purpose, whether he were, or no. It sufficeth me, that he who refuseth to obey the Priest, must die, by the law. Which is enough to proue the soueraintie of one Priest.
Rainoldes. Not so. For the name of Priest (in this law) doth signify the Priests. Which is clear, by reason that the punishment of the transgressor hath a relation to the law: and the law doth will men to go to pthe Priests: the Priests, it saith, as of many; not, as of one, the hie Priest. Wherefore, in giving sentence of death against him, who disobeyeth the Priest; it meaneth the Priests: according to *a kind of speech, wherein the whole is noted by the part. As afterward likewise, qentreating of the duty and right of the Priests, it noteth them in general by name of the Priest.
Rainoldes. Not so. For the name of Priest (in this law) doth signifie the Priestes. Which is cléere, by reason that the punishment of the transgressor hath a relation to the law: and the law doth will men to go to pthe Priests: the Priestes, it saith, as of many; not, as of one, the hie Priest. Wherefore, in giuing sentence of death against him, who disobeieth the Priest; it meaneth the Priestes: according to *a kind of spéech, wherin ye whole is noted by the part. As afterward likewise, qentreating of the duetie and right of the Priestes, it noteth them in generall by name of the Priest.
Hart. But here, upon mention of the Priest, it followeth: who doth serve the Lord thy God. By the which title the hie Priest may seem to have been namely noted, and severed from the rest.
Hart. But here, vpon mention of the Priest, it foloweth: who doth serue the Lord thy God. By the which title the hie Priest may séeme to haue béene namely noted, and seuered from the rest.
Rainoldes. He might so, were it not that the same title is also given rafterward to Priests, generally: yea, where this matter is touched 2again of purpose, the Lord thy God hath chosen the Priests, the sons of Levi, to serve him, and to bless in the name of the Lord; and by their word shall every controversy, and every plague be tried.
Rainoldes. He might so, were it not that the same title is also giuen rafterward to Priestes, generally: yea, where this matter is touched 2againe of purpose, the Lord thy God hath chosen the Priestes, the sonnes of Leui, to serue him, and to blesse in the name of the Lorde; and by their word shall euery controuersie, and euery plague be tried.
Hart. Yet you will grant, (I trust,) that amongst the Priests there was one chief: yea, even in this matter of highest judgement in doubtful causes. Which, (in tthe same place of Scripture that you brought to expound this,) is showed by king Jehoshaphat: saying unto them, to whom that judgement was committed; Amarias the Priest shall be the chief over you in matters of the Lord.
Hart. Yet you will graunt, (I trust,) that amongst the Priestes there was one chiefe: yea, euen in this matter of highest iudgement in doubtfull causes. Which, (in tthe same place of Scripture that you brought to expound this,) is shewed by king Iosaphat: saying vnto them, to whom that iudgement was committed; Amarias the Priest shall be the chiefe ouer you in matters of the Lord.
Rainoldes. This I will grant you. But you must grant me also, that look what is given to him, amongst the Priests, in matters of the Lord, that is, in ecclesiastical: the same, amongst the judges, is given to Zebadias in matters of the king, that is in ⟨p. 252⟩civil causes. For, Jehoshaphat doth say as well the one, as the other. So that (to come now to the later point of your lame similitude,) if Christians must have a sovereign Bishop over all, because the Jews had one chief Priest ▪ then Christians must have a sovereign Prince over all, because the Jews had one chief judge. And as all harder causes, at least of religion must be referred to the Pope: so all of civill matters must be referred to the Emperor. And as, amongst the Jews, the Priest and judge were resident in the place which the Lord had chosen: so the Pope and the Emperor must both abide in Rome. Which uPope Paul the third did fear that Emperor Charles the fifth would have done. But he sent for the French men to keep him out. If Gregory (that now is Pope) be better minded, and will resign his civill State unto the Emperor with the Palace of Vatican, and Castle of Saint Angelo: then may the reason, which you ground upon the law in Deuteronomy, serve you with greater show. Howbeit, even in that case it would rather further the Emperor then the Pope: because it mentioneth the judge, as one; the Priests, as many.
Rainoldes. This I will graunt you. But you must graunt me also, that looke what is giuen to him, amongst the Priestes, in matters of the Lord, yt is, in ecclesiastical: the same, amongst the iudges, is giuen to Zebadias in matters of the king, that is in ⟨p. 252⟩ciuil causes. For, Iosaphat doth say as well the one, as the other. So that (to come now to the later point of your lame similitude,) if Christians must haue a soueraine Bishop ouer all, because the Iewes had one chiefe Priest ▪ then Christians must haue a soueraine Prince ouer all, because the Iewes had one chiefe iudge. And as all harder causes, at least of religion must be referred to the Pope: so all of ciuill matters must be referred to the Emperour. And as, amongst the Iewes, the Priest and iudge were resident in the place which the Lord had chosen: so the Pope and the Emperour must both abide in Rome. Which uPope Paule the third did feare that Emperour Charles the fifth would haue done. But he sent for the French men to kéepe him out. If Gregorie (that now is Pope) be better minded, and will resigne his ciuill State vnto the Emperour with the Palace of Vaticane, and Castell of Saint Angelo: then may the reason, which you ground vpon the law in Deuteronomie, serue you with greater shew. Howbeit, euen in that case it would rather further the Emperour then the Pope: because it mentioneth the iudge, as one; the Priestes, as many.
uOnuphrius in vit. Pont. Pauli tert. Pontifex ex quibusd•m C• saris verbis veritus, ne Caesar Romae diu commoratus eius occupandae illecebtis caperetur, clam Bellai•m & Stephanum Columna, ut in Italian Gallos accirent, emisit.Onuphrius in vit. Pont. Pauli tert. Pontifex ex quibusd•m C• sa•is verbis veritus, ne Caesar Romae diu commoratus eius occupandae illecebtis caperetur, clam Bellai•m & Stephanum Columna, vt in Italia• Gallos accirent, emisit.
Hart. It is not necessary for the government of the common-wealth among Princes, that any one of them be Prince over all. But as the king of Judah was in his own kingdom: so every Prince is highest in his own dominion.
Hart. It is not necessary for the gouernment of the common-wealth among Princes, that any one of them be Prince ouer all. But as the king of Iuda was in his owne kingdome: so euery Prince is highest in his own dominion.
Rainoldes. Neither it is necessary for the administration of the Church, amongst Bishops, that any one of them be Bishop over all. But as the hie Priest was chief over the Jews, so is every Bishop over his own charge.
Rainoldes. Neither it is necessarie for the administration of the Church, amongst Bishops, that any one of them be Bishop ouer all. But as the hie Priest was chiefe ouer the Iewes, so is euery Bishop ouer his owne charge.
Hart. Nay, the case of the Church and common-wealth herein are unlike, and different. Because that common-weals may be upholden, although they be governed not only by diverse kings, and civill magistrates, but also by diverse ordinances and laws. But the Church as it hath one faith, in all Christians: so ought it to have the same laws and ordinances of religion in all countries.
Hart. Nay, the case of the Church and common-wealth herein are vnlike, and different. Because that common-weales may be vpholden, although they be gouerned not onely by diuerse kings, and ciuill magistrates, but also by diuerse ordinances and lawes. But the Church as it hath one faith, in all Christians: so ought it to haue the same lawes and ordinances of religion in all countries.
Rainoldes. This difference and unlikeness between the Church and common-wealth, is lesser then you imagine, if it be marked well. For justice, and right, in giving every one his due, should have the same place in the common-wealth, which faith and religion claimeth in the Church. Now, as in religion there ⟨p. 254⟩are some things of substance, and some of ceremony: so there are some points essential in justice, and some accidental. The essential points of justice are the same in laws of all common-wealths. For what is *a law, but a divine ordinance, commanding things honest, and forbidding the contrary? The accidental points do and may vary according to circumstances of places, times, and persons. So laws of religion must be the same for substance in all Christian Churches: in ceremonies they may differ, as in xthe primitive Church they did. Wherefore the same faith, and laws of religion do no more enforce all churches to obey one Bishop, then the same right and ordinances of justice do require one Prince to rule all common-wealths. But what soever your fancy make you think of this point: the place in Deuteronomy adjudging them to death who disobey the Priest, can not help your fancy, though it had been meant of no other Priest, but of the high Priest only. For Christ, when he sent his Apostles to preach the Gospel, said unto them: yWhosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart out of that house, or that city, shake of the dust of your feet. Truly I say unto you, it shall be easier for them of the land of Sodom and Gomorrah in the day of judgement, then for that city. Which words being spoken to all the Apostles, not to Peter only, and therefore belonging to all their successors, as well as to Peters: do show that every Bishop, hath as great authority given him by Christ, as the Priest had by that law in Deuteronomy. In so much that zCyprian doth allege it often, (by a better reason of proportion then yours,) to prove the authority of Bishops each in several over the flocks committed to them.
Rainoldes. This difference and vnlikenes betwéene the Church and common-wealth, is lesser then you imagine, if it bee marked well. For iustice, and right, in giuing euery one his due, should haue the same place in the common-wealth, which faith and religion claimeth in the Church. Now, as in religion there ⟨p. 254⟩are some things of substance, and some of ceremonie: so there are some pointes essentiall in iustice, and some accidentall. The essentiall pointes of iustice are the same in lawes of all common-wealthes. For what is *a law, but a diuine ordinance, commanding thinges honest, and forbidding the contrarie? The accidentall pointes doo and may vary according to circumstances of places, times, and persons. So lawes of religion must be the same for substance in all Christian Churches: in ceremonies they may differ, as in xthe primitiue Church they did. Wherefore the same faith, and lawes of religion do no more inforce all churches to obey one Bishop, then the same right and ordinances of iustice do require one Prince to rule all common-wealthes. But what soeuer your fansie make you thinke of this point: the place in Deuteronomie adiudging them to death who disobey the Priest, can not helpe your fansie, though it had béene meant of no other Priest, but of the high Priest onely. For Christ, whē he sent his Apostles to preach the Gospell, said vnto them: yWhosoeuer shall not receaue you, nor heare your wordes, when yee depart out of that house, or that city, shake of the dust of your feete. Truely I say vnto you, it shall be easier for them of the land of Sodome and Gomorrha in the day of iudgement, then for that citie. Which wordes being spoken to all the Apostles, not to Peter onely, and therefore belonging to all their successors, as well as to Peters: doo shew that euery Bishop, hath as great authoritie giuen him by Christ, as the Priest had by that law in Deuteronomie. In so much that zCyprian doth alleage it often, (by a better reason of proportiō then yours,) to proue the authoritie of Bishops each in seuerall ouer the flockes committed to them.
*C••. de Legib. lib. 1. •. Nam & […] legib•s.C••. de Legib. lib. 1. •. Nam & 〈…〉 legib•s.
xEuseb. histor. eccles. l. 5. c. 23. Socrat. histor. eccles. l. 5. c. 21.Euseb. histor. •ccles. l. 5. c. 23. Socrat. histor. •ccles. l. 5. c. 21.
Hart. And what if a matter of religion be harder then Bishops each in several be able to decide it? What if they disagree, and will not yield one to another? Doth not wisdom show, that there must be a chief judge to end the controversy? to keep the truth of faith, and peace of the Church, that it be not pestered with heresies and schisms?
Hart. And what if a matter of religion be harder then Bishops each in seuerall be able to decide it? What if they disagree, and will not yéeld one to another? Doth not wisedome shew, that there must be a chiefe iudge to ende the controuersie? to keepe the truth of faith, and peace of the Church, that it be not pestered with heresies and schismes?
Rainoldes. The wisdom of God hath committed that chieftie of judgement (so to call it) not to the sovereign power of one, but to the common care of many. For when there was a controversy in the Church of Antioch about the observation ⟨p. 255⟩of the law of Moses, some Jews teaching contrary to that which Paul and Barnabas taught: athey ordained that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem to the Apostles and Elders about that question. And so by their common agreement and decree, the controversy was ended, the truth of faith kept, and peace maintained in the Church. After which example, bthe Bishops (that succeeded them) made the like assemblies, on the like occasions: and by common conference took order for such matters, both of doctrine, and discipline, as concerned in common the state of their Churches. So did the Apostles and Apostolic men provide against schisms & heresies. Their wisdom reached not unto your policy of one chief judge.
Rainoldes. The wisedome of God hath committed that chieftie of iudgement (so to call it) not to the soueraine power of one, but to the common care of many. For when there was a controuersie in the Church of Antioche about the obseruation ⟨p. 255⟩of the law of Moses, some Iewes teaching contrarie to that which Paule and Barnabas taught: athey ordeined that Paule and Barnabas, and certaine other of them, should go vp to Ierusalem to the Apostles and Elders about that question. And so by their common agreement and decrée, the controuersie was ended, the truth of faith kept, and peace maintained in the Church. After which example, bthe Bishops (that succéeded them) made the like assemblies, on the like occasions: and by common conference tooke order for such matters, both of doctrine, and discipline, as concerned in common the state of their Churches. So did the Apostles and Apostolike men prouide against schismes & heresies. Their wisedome reached not vnto your policie of one chiefe iudge.
Hart. The profit of Councils and Synods of Bishops is very great, we grant. For many eyes see more then one. But it will be greater, if they be all counsellors unto one governor, then if they govern each his own, and all in common. For reason doth teach us, that the regiment of one, which we call a monarchy, is better and worthier then the regiment of many: as the Philosophers show, who write of Common-weals.
Hart. The profit of Councels and Synods of Bishops is very great, we graunt. For many eyes see more then one. But it wil be greater, if they be all counsellors vnto one gouernor, then if they gouerne eche his owne, and all in common. For reason doth teach vs, that the regiment of one, which wee call a monarchie, is better and worthier then the regiment of many: as the Philosophers shew, who write of Common-weales.
Rainoldes. Reason, is a notable help of mans weakness, if it be obedient to faith, as a handmaid; not rule it, as a mistress. And humane arts, wherein the Philosophers have seen many sparkles of the truth of God by the light of reason, are profitable instruments to set forth the truth, so far as they have peace, not war, with Gods word. But if the Philosophers have erred, as cnatural men, who neither do conceive the things of the spirit of God, nor can know them; if reason have her eyes (as it were) dazzled, because dthe light shineth in darkness, and the darkness did not comprehend it: then is it to be feared eleast, as the Serpent seduced Eve through his subtlety, so he beguile you by reason; and you forget that lesson of the holy Ghost, 4beware least there be any man that spoil you through philosophy. Which I say not so much in respect of this point of the Church government, as of your whole doctrine: a mighty ground whereof in your Schoolmen, is philosophy; and gyour Jesuits challenge doth offer to prove it by natural and moral reason. For ⟨p. 256⟩here if I would justify the cause by Philosophers, it is easily showed, that the Churches state is a most perfect monarchy: wherein Christ is king; his laws, are the scriptures; his officers, are the Bishops; not ordained to be assistants unto one deputy, but to be deputies all them selves, even hPastors of his flock, & iguides & krulers of his Church. Howbeit, if it differ from the kingly states of worldly common-weals, which philosophy writeth off, as it doth in part: Philosophers must not marvel, sith lChrist hath declared his kingdom is not of this world. Indeed, the Apostles thought of such a kingdom: mbut Christ said, it should not be so amongst them, as with the Princes of the Gentiles. Which sentence of Christ your Popes not understanding, and weening the Apostles to be forbidden nothing but an heathnish tyranny, and liking well a monarchy because Philosophers praise it: they have raised a nvisible monarchy of their own, in stead of Christs monarchy; and have changed his kingdom, which is not of this world, into a worldly kingdom, the kingdom of the Romans, as oa Jesuit calleth it. Neither contenting them selves with such a kingdom, as Princes of the Gentiles had: they make them selves Princes *over all the kingdoms and nations of the earth.
Rainoldes. Reason, is a notable helpe of mans weakenes, if it be obedient to faith, as a handmaide; not rule it, as a maistresse. And humane artes, wherein the Philosophers haue séene many sparkles of the truth of God by the light of reason, are profitable instruments to set forth the truth, so farre as they haue peace, not warre, with Gods worde. But if the Philosophers haue erred, as cnaturall men, who neither doo conceiue the things of the spirit of God, nor can know them; if reason haue her eyes (as it were) dazeled, because dthe light shineth in darkenesse, and the darkenesse did not comprehend it: then is it to be feared eleast, as the Serpent seduced Eue through his suttletie, so he beguile you by reason; and you forget that lesson of the holy Ghost, 4beware least there be any man that spoyle you through philosophie. Which I say not so much in respect of this point of the Church gouernment, as of your whole doctrine: a mightie ground whereof in your Schoolemen, is philosophie; and gyour Iesuites challenge doth offer to proue it by naturall and morall reason. For ⟨p. 256⟩here if I would iustifie the cause by Philosophers, it is •asily shewed, that the Churches state is a most perfite monarchie: wherein Christ is king; his lawes, are the scriptures; his officers, are the Bishops; not ordained to bée assistantes vnto one deputie, but to be deputies all them selues, euen hPastors of his flock, & iguides & krulers of his Church. Howbeit, if it differ from the kingly states of worldly cōmon-weales, which philosophie writeth off, as it doth in part: Philosophers must not maruel, sith lChrist hath declared his kingdōe is not of this world. Indéede, the Apostles thought of such a kingdome:
oFrancis. Turrian. de eccle. & ordin. minist. eccl. l. 1. c. 2.
*Super gentes & regna, saith Pope John the two & twentieth in extravagant. commun.Super gentes & regna, saith Pope Iohn the two & twētieth in extrauagant. commun.
Which is a greater monarchy then Philosophers like off: as I could prove out of them, if the Popes cause were to be handled in their schools. But because I list not to trifle out the time with idle discourses about points of State; as your pRabbins do, to prove that a monarchy is the best regiment: therefore against such reasons I lay that exception which qTertullian did of old against heretics: What hath Athens to do with Jerusalem? the school of philosophy with the Church of Christ? The duty of Christians is to search and weigh in matters of faith, not what reason, but what religion; not what the Philosophers, but what the Prophets, & Apostles; not what mans fancy, but what the Spirit of God doth say. And so the former parts of your main argument for the Popes supremacy, are too weak to prove it. The last is weaker then they both. For, that there should be one chief and highest Pastor of the Church in earth: it hath some reason by philosophy. That Peter was appointed by Christ to be that one: it hath some show of scripture. But that the Pope succeedeth Peter therein, it ⟨p. 257⟩hath no show of scripture; and (I trow) you will not prove it by philosophy.
Which is a greater monarchie then Philosophers like off: as I coulde proue out of them, if the Popes cause were to be handled in their schooles. But because I list not to trifle out the time with idle discourses about pointes of State; as your pRabbines doo, to proue yt a monarchie is the best regiment: therefore against such reasons I laye that exception which qTertullian did of olde against heretikes: What hath Athens to do with Ierusalem? the schoole of philosophy with the Church of Christ? The duetie of Christians is to search and weigh in matters of faith, not what reason, but what religion; not what the Philosophers, but what the Prophets, & Apostles; not what mans fansie, but what the Spirit of God doth say. And so the former parts of your maine argument for the Popes supremacie, are too weake to proue it. The last is weaker then they both. For, that there should be one chiefe and highest Pastor of the Church in earth: it hath some reason by philosophie. That Peter was appointed by Christ to be that one: it hath some shew of scripture. But that the Pope succéedeth Peter therein, it ⟨p. 257⟩hath no shew of scripture; and (I trow) you will not proue it by philosophie.
pSand. visib. monar. l. 3. c. 3 Bellar. controvers. 4. quaest. 1.Sand. visib. monar. l. 3. c. 3 Bellar. controuers. 4. quaest. 1.
Hart. That the Pope succeedeth Peter therein:1 it is a clear case. For sEusebius writeth, that Peter, having laid the foundation of the Church of Antioch, (where he sate seven years) went to Rome: & (preaching the gospel there five and twenty years) continued Bishop of that city. Now, the Pope is Bishop of Rome: that you grant. Then I conclude thereof, that he succeedeth Peter. For Peter continued Bishop of that city, as it is witnessed by Eusebius.
Hart. That the Pope succéedeth Peter therein:1 it is a cléere case. For sEusebius writeth, that Peter, hauing laide the foundation of the Church of Antioche, (where he sate seauen yeares) went to Rome: & (preaching the gospell there fiue and twentie yeares) continued Bishop of that citie. Now, the Pope is Bishop of Rome: that you graunt. Then I conclude thereof, that he succedeth Peter. For Peter continued Bishop of that citie, as it is witnessed by Eusebius.
Rainoldes. I desired that I might hear, Thus saith the Lord: and you told me that I should hear it. In the first part of your argument, you fell from it, to, Thus saith the Pope. In the next you mended it, with, Thus say Philosophers. Now you prove the last, by, Thus saith Eusebius. And this is more sightly somewhat, then the former: but no stay of faith, without the word of God.
Rainoldes. I desired that I might heare, Thus saith the Lord: and you told me that I should heare it. In the first parte of your argument, you fell from it, to, Thus saith the Pope. In the next you mended it, with, Thus say Philosophers. Now you proue the last, by, Thus saith Eusebius. And this is more sightly somewhat, then the former: but no stay of faith, without the word of God.
Hart. You ought not to cast off Eusebius so lightly, as though he were of no credit. For he is the best and ancientest historian of all that have travelled in setting forth the stories of the Church of Christ. And the pains, the diligence, the reading and judgement, which in his Chronicle he showed, was great and wonderful. In so much that gCanus is persuaded of him, that no ecclesiastical Greek or Latin author could have left more excellent monuments of times.
Hart. You ought not to cast off Eusebius so lightly, as though he were of no credit. For he is the best and auncientest historian of all that haue traueled in setting forth the stories of the Church of Christ. And the paines, the diligence, the reading and iudgement, which in his Chronicle he shewed, was great and wonderfull. In so much that gCanus is perswaded of him, that no ecclesiastical Gréeke or Latin autor could haue left more excellent monuments of times.
Rainoldes. I like of Eusebius, as of a good historian: and I allow the praise given him by Canus. But hCanus hath a good conclusion withal, touching both him, and all historians, to wit, that *beside the writers of the scripture, no historian can be sure; that is to say, able to make sure and certain proof in Divinity. A thing so apparent and evident of it self, that he saith, it is not to be confirmed with his proofs. Only, he rehearseth to the same effect a true & pleasant speech of iFlavius Vopiscus: who, beginning to write stories, said that he enterprised it the more boldly, because he should have companions in lying; sith he knew no historian, that had not lied in somewhat. Now, if this be incident unto all historians, except them of scripture: who wrote by the Spirit of God, and not of man: then Eusebius also, though a good historian, might be subject ⟨p. 274⟩to it. Which you must the rather be persuaded of him, because kPope Gelasius (in a Council of seventy Bishops) reproved his story, as faulty. Which reproof your lCanus alloweth as just, & giveth reasons of it: namely, for mhis reporting of Christs epistle to Agbarus, and nhis avouching many things by Clemens Alexandrinus; whereas the fable of the one, and the works of the other are reproved by othe Council,
Rainoldes. I like of Eusebius, as of a good historian: and I allow the prayse giuen him by Canus. But hCanus hath a good conclusion withall, touching both him, and al historians, to wéet, that *beside the writers of the scripture, no historian can be sure; that is to say, able to make sure and certaine proofe in Diuinitie. A thing so apparant and euident of it selfe, that hée saith, it is not to be confirmed with his proofes. Onely, he reherseth to the same effect a true & pleasant spéeche of iFlauius Vopiscus: who, beginning to write stories, said that he enterprised it the more boldly, because he should haue companions in lying; sith he knew no historian, that had not lyed in somewhat. Now, if this be incident vnto all historians, except them of scripture: who wrote by the Spirit of God, and not of man: then Eusebius also, though a good historian, might be subiect ⟨p. 274⟩to it. Which you must the rather be perswaded of him, because kPope Gelasius (in a Councell of seuentie Bishops) reproued his storie, as faultie. Which reproofe your lCanus alloweth as iust, & giueth reasons of it: namely, for mhis reporting of Christes epistle to Agbarus, and nhis auouching many things by Clemens Alexandrinus; wheras the fable of the one, and the works of the other are reproued by othe Councell,
hcap. 4.
*Praeter autotores sacros nullus histori•us certus esse potest, id est, idoneus ad faci endam certam in Theologia fidem.
iIn vit. […].In vit. 〈…〉.
kDist. 15. c. Sanc•• Romana.
l[…]. 11. cap 6.〈…〉. 11. cap 6.
mEuseb. histo. eccles. l. 1. c. 14.
nl. 1. c. 1. and so forth commonly.l. 1. c. 1. and so forth cō monly.
Hart. These faults, and the rest, that Canus doth touch, are in the history of Eusebius: which yet not only Canus but the Council also commend, as not to be refused altogether. But that which I alleged is in the Chronicle of Eusebius: a book, neither noted so by the Council, and greatly praised by Canus.
Hart. These faultes, and the rest, that Canus doth touch, are in the historie of Eusebius: which yet not onely Canus but the Councell also commende, as not to be refused altogither. But that which I alleaged is in the Chronicle of Eusebius: a booke, neither noted so by the Councell, and greatly praysed by Canus.
Rainoldes. The man is one, who wrote them both: and might be overseen, as in the one, so in the other. Yea pCanus himself, who praiseth his Chronicle, yet praiseth it with this exception, that neither all things which Eusebius there reporteth, are true. But men may find some things which may be worthily and truly blamed. As, for example, that he writeth, that Sennacherib who besieged Jerusalem, and Salmanassar who took Samaria, were one, and the same man. Which thing to be contrary to the holy scripture qS. Jerome hath showed. Now this, which I stick at in the Chronicle of Eusebius, is such an other oversight: and may be as worthily reproved, as that of Canus; because it is no less against the scripture then that. For whereas he saith, that Peter, having laid the foundation of the Church of Antioch, (where he sate *seven years) went to Rome, & preaching the Gospel there five and twenty years continued Bishop of that city: Peter (by this account) should have gone to Antioch about the fourth year after Christs death, and there abode seven years, even till the second year of Claudius the Emperor, in which he went to Rome. But the scripture showeth, that Paul (who was rnot presently converted after Christs death) yet safter three years found Peter at Jerusalem : & Peter, after that, abode within tthe coasts of Jewry, first uat Lydda, then xat Joppe, then at yCaesarea, then zat Jerusalem, where aHerod cast him into prison, in the second or third year of Claudius, as it is likely, (for bhe died cin the fourth:) when, dthe Church of Antioch was in the mean season both planted and ⟨p. 275⟩watered by others, not by Peter. Wherefore, the former branch of that which Eusebius reporteth touching Peter, that he had sate seven years at Antioch, in the second year of Claudius, is flatly contrary to the scripture. The later is as contrary, that from that year forward he did sit at Rome five and twenty years, that is, all his life time, till he was put to death by Nero. For, (to grant the uttermost, which may have any show of reason,) admit, that he was cast by Herod into prison, in the first year of Claudius; before which he could not; for *Claudius gave the kingdom of Jewry to Herod. When the Angel had delivered him out of prison, ehe went into an other place: whether to Rome or to Antioch, or perhaps to neither, the scripture leaveth it uncertain;
Rainoldes. The man is one, who wrote them both: and might be ouerséene, as in the one, so in the other. Yea pCanus himselfe, who praiseth his Chronicle, yet praiseth it with this exception, that neither all thinges which Eusebius there reporteth, are true. But men may find some thinges which may bee worthily and truely blamed. As, for example, that he writeth, that Sennacherib who besieged Ierusalem, and Salmanassar who tooke Samaria, were one, and the same man. Which thing to be contrarie to the holy scripture qS. Ierom hath shewed. Now this, which I sticke at in the Chronicle of Eusebius, is such an other ouersight: and may be as worthily reproued, as that of Canus; because it is no lesse against the scripture then that. For whereas he saith, that Peter, hauing laid the foundation of the Church of Antioche, (where he sate *seuē yeares) went to Rome, & preaching the Gospell there fiue and twentie yeares cōtinued Bishop of that city: Peter (by this account) should haue gone to Antioche about the fourth yeare after Christs death, and there abode seuen yeares, euē till the second yeare of Claudius ye Emperour, in which he went to Rome. But ye scripture sheweth, yt Paule (who was rnot presently conuerted after Christes death) yet safter three yeares found Peter at Ierusalē : & Peter, after that, abode within tthe coastes of Iewrie, first uat Lydda, then xat Ioppe, then at yCaesarea, then zat Ierusalem, where aHerode cast him into prison, in ye second or third yeare of Claudius, as it is likely, (for bhe died
*In the Chronicle of Eusebiu• it is [•ive and twenty:] through the fault of the printers or written copies which they followed. For (by the count of years, and consent of writers who seem to follow him) it should be seven only.In the Chronicle of Eusebiu• it is [•iue and twentie:] through the fault of the printers or writen copies which they folowed. For (by the count of yeares, and consent of writers who seem to folow him) it should be seuen onely.
but, by the Chronicle of Eusebius, either to Antioch or to Rome. If he went to Antioch, and there abode some years, before he came to Rome: then is the second year of Claudius past, and his abode at Rome could not be five and twenty years. Now, it is certain that he went to Antioch at that time or some other. For fthe scripture witnesseth that Paul did there reprove him. But if that were some other time, and from his prison in Jerusalem he went straight to Rome: yet neither could he so be five and twenty years there. For after he came thither, a time must be found wherein he was at Antioch; and an other time wherein he was at gBabylon; & an other time, wherein he was at hJerusalem, at the Council of the Apostles; and some years after that, iwhen Paul wrote to the Romans, kamongst the chief, whom he saluted, he named not Peter; and some years after that, when Paul lcame prisoner to Rome, when he mabode there certain years, when he nwrote many epistles thence, Peter is not mentioned, nay those things are mentioned which would be stains of his Apostleship, if he had been at Rome. For, oPaul saith of others, these only are my work-fellows unto the kingdom of God, which have been a comfort to me:, & pat my first answering, no man assisted me, but all forsook me: I pray God it be not laid unto their charge. Of the which reasons, though some are but probable, yet some are sure proofs, that Peters continuance at Rome was not such, as is reported by Eusebius. And this is so manifest, that, to say nothing of qancienter writers, who (to make the scriptures agree somewhat better with his five and twenty years abode ⟨p. 260⟩at Rome,) brought him thither later, and gave him longer time of life: Onuphrius Panuinius, a Friar of your own, most devout to the Pope, most skilful in antiquities and stories of the Church, acknowledgeth and confirmeth it. For, in the discourses of his Annotations on rPlatina, printed at Venice, & afterward at Cologne: 1it is most clear (saith he) and surely known by the Acts of the Apostles, and Pauls epistle to the Galatians, that, for nine years after Christs death, until the second year of the reign of Claudius, Peter never went out of Jewry. Wherefore if he came to Rome, at that time, as it is agreed amongst all authors that he did:
but, by the Chronicle of Eusebius, either to Antioche or to Rome. If he went to Antioche, and there abode some yeares, before he came to Rome: then is the second yeare of Claudius past, and his abode at Rome could not bee fiue and twentie yeares. Now, it is certaine that he went to Antioche at that time or some other. For fthe scripture witnesseth that Paule did there reproue him. But if that were some other time, and from his prison in Ierusalem he went straight to Rome: yet neither could he so be fiue and twentie yeares there. For after hée came thither, a time must be found wherein he was at Antioch; and an other time wherin he was at gBabylon; & an other time, wherin he was at hIerusalem, at the Councell of the Apostles; and some yeares after that, iwhen Paule wrote to the Romans, kamongst the chiefe, whom he saluted, he named not Peter; and some yeares after that, when Paule lcame prisoner to Rome, when he mabode there certaine yeares, when he nwrote many epistles thence, Peter is not mentioned, nay those thinges are mentioned which would be staines of his Apostleship, if he had béene at Rome. For, oPaule saith of others, these onely are my worke-fellowes vnto the kingdome of God, which haue bene a comfort to me:, & pat my first answering, no man assisted me, but all forsooke me: I pray God it bee not laid vnto their charge. Of the which reasons, though some are but probable, yet some are sure proofes, that Peters continuance at Rome was not such, as is reported by Eusebius. And this is so manifest, that, to say nothing of qauncienter writers, who (to make the scriptures agrée somewhat better with his fiue and twentie yeares abode ⟨p. 260⟩
it followeth of necessity, 2that he did not sit seven years at Antioch before he came thither, but that his sitting at Antioch was some other time. Which thing I have resolved on, thus, by the testimony of most ancient writers. He did come to Rome the second year of Claudius. From which time there are to the time of his death about five and twenty years. Wherein, although the ancient writers do say that he sate at Rome: yet doth it not follow thereof that he abode still in the city. For in the fourth year after his coming thither, he returned to Jerusalem: and there was present at the Council of the Apostles. 3Thence he went to Antioch, and there continued seven years; until that Nero was Emperor. In the beginning of whose reign, he came again to Rome: where he repaired the Roman church, which was decaying. And after that 4when he had travailed almost throughout all Europe, he returned to Rome in the last year of the reign of Nero, and there was put to death. This is the confession of your own Onuphrius, made perhaps against the hear (as I may term it:) but the light of truth and scripture forced him to it. Whereby you may perceive that when Eusebius wrote, that Peter sate, first, seven years at Antioch, and five and twenty at Rome, after: that befell to him, which 4Thucydides saith of the old stories of the Grecians; men receive reports of things done before them from hand to hand, one from another, 5without examining & trying them. Some, through a desire (as it is likely) of honouring the Sees of Antioch & Rome, hearing that S. Peter had preached in them both, devised that he sate seven years in the one, and five and twenty in the other. Eusebius fell upon it, ⟨p. 261⟩and wrote it in his Chronicle without farther trial. But if he had tried it by the touchstone of scripture: he would have cast it off, as counterfeit. Which I think the rather, because in his story the mentioneth the coming of Peter to Rome as out of Jury, not from Antioch, for his first coming thither in the time of Claudius: and for his coming thither again in Neros time, uhe showeth out of xOrigen that it was toward his end, when he had preached the gospel to the Jews in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia. Wherefore sith Eusebius doth in his story dissent from his Chronicle, and in his Chronicle dissent from the scripture:
it followeth of necessitie, 2that hee did not sit seuen yeares at Antioche before he came thither, but that his sitting at Antioche was some other time. Which thing I haue resolued on, thus, by the testimonie of most auncient writers. He did come to Rome the second yere of Claudius. From which time there are to the time of his death about fiue and twentie yeares. Wherin, although the auncient writers do say that he sate at Rome: yet doth it not folow thereof that he abode still in the citie. For in the fourth yeare after his comming thither, he returned to Ierusalem: and there was present at the Councell ofthe Apostles. 3Thence he went to Antioche, and there continued seuen yeares; vntil that Nero was Emperour. In the beginning of whose raigne, he came againe to Rome: where hee repaired the Romane church, which was decaying. And after that 4when hee had traueiled almost throughout al Europe, he returned to Rome in the last yeare of the raigne of Nero, and there was put to death. This is the confessiō of your owne Onuphrius, made perhaps against the heare (as I may terme it:) but the light of truth and scripture forced him to it. Wherby you may perceiue that when Eusebius wrote, that Peter sate, first, seuen yeares at Antioch, and fiue and twentie at Rome, after: that befell to him, which 4Thucydides saith of the old stories of the Grecians; men receyue reportes of thinges done before them from hand to hand, one from another, 5without examining & trying them. Some, through a desire (as it is likely) of honouring the Sees of Antioche & Rome, hearing that S. Peter had preached in them both, deuised that he sate seuen yeares in the one, and fiue and twentie in the other. Eusebius fell vpon it, ⟨p. 261⟩and wrote it in his Chronicle without farther tryall. But if he had tryed it by the touchstone of scripture: hée would haue cast it off, as counterfeite. Which I thinke the rather, because in his storie the mentioneth ye coming of Peter to Rome as out of Iurie, not from Antioche, for his first coming thether in the time of Claudius: and for his coming thither againe in Neros time, u
2Antiochiae septem annis non sedisse ante aduentum ad urbem.Antiochiae septem annis non sedisse ante aduentum ad vrbem.
3Inde Antio••iam prosec•us septem ibidem annis permansit.
4Peregrination per universam Europam fere suscepta.Peregrinatio•e per uniuersam Europam fere suscepta.
Hart. To talk about the years of Peters coming to Rome, or his continuance there, I am not disposed. I leave it to them, who list to search antiquities. But that he was in Rome, it is a thing undoubted: the scripture doth witness it. For in the first epistle of his, the fifth chapter, ythe Church (saith he) saluteth you, that is in Babylon, coelect, and Mark my son. Where your Protestants show them selves (as in all places, that do make against them) to be most unhonest and partial handlers of Gods word. The ancient Fathers, namely zS. Jerome, aEusebius, bOecumenius, and many moe agree, that Rome is meant by the word Babylon here also, as cin the Apocalypse: saying plainly that S. Peter wrote this epistle at Rome, which is called Babylon for the resemblance it had to Babylon that great city in Chaldea (where the Jews were captives) for magnificence, monarchy, resort and confusion of all peoples and tongues, and for that it was, before Christ and long after, the seat of all Ethnic superstition and idolatry, & the slaughter-house of the Apostles & other Christian men, the heath• Emperors then keeping their chief residence there. This being most plain & consonant to that which followeth of S. Mark, whom all the ecclesiastical histories agree to have been Peters scholar at Rome, & that he there wrote his gospel: yet you, *fearing hereby the sequel of Peters or the Popes supremacy at Rome, deny that ever he was there, or that this epistle was written there, or that Babylon doth here signify Rome. But you say that Peter wrote this epistle at Babylon in Chaldea, though you ⟨p. 262⟩never read either in scriptures, or other holy or profane history, that he was ever in that city. But see your shameless partiality. Here, Babylon (say you) is not taken for Rome: because it would follow that Peter was at Rome, and so forth. But in the Apocalypse, where all evil is spoken of Babylon, there you will have it signify nothing else but Rome, and the Roman church also, not (as the Fathers interpret it) the temporal state of the heathen Empire there. So do you follow in every word no other thing, but the advantage of your own heresy. Which is most notorious by this, that you hold that Peter was neve• at Rome. Wherein you pass your selves in impudency. For it is against all the ecclesiastical histories, all the Fathers Greek and Latin, cTheodoret, dProsper, eS.
Hart. To talke about the yeares of Peters coming to Rome, or his continuance there, I am not disposed. I leaue it to them, who list to search antiquities. But that he was in Rome, it is a thing vndoubted: the scripture doth witnesse it. For in ye first epistle of his, the fifth chapter, ythe Church (saith he) saluteth you, that is in Babylon, coelect, and Marke my sonne. Where your Protestants shew them selues (as in all places, that doo make against them) to be most vnhonest and partiall handlers of Gods worde. The auncient Fathers, namely zS. Ierom, aEusebius, bOecumenius, and many moe agrée, that Rome is meant by the worde Babylon here also, as cin the Apocalypse: saying plainely that S. Peter wrote this epistle at Rome, which is called Babylon for the resemblance it had to Babylon that great citie in Chaldaea (where the Iewes were captiues) for magnificence, monarchie, resort and confusion of all peoples and tongues, and for that it was, before Christ and long after, the seate of all Ethnike superstition and idolatry, & the sl•ughter-house of the Apostles & other Christian men, the heath• Emperours then kéeping their chief residence there. This being most plaine & consonant to yt which foloweth of S. Marke, whom all the ecclesiasticall histories agree to haue béene Peters scholer at Rome, & that he there wrote his gospell: yet you, *fearing hereby the sequele of Peters or the Popes supremacie at Rome, deny that euer he was there, or that this epistle was writen there, or that Babylon doth here signifie Rome. But you say that Peter wrote this epistle at Babylon in Chaldaea, though you ⟨p. 262⟩neuer read either in scriptures, or other holy or prophane history, that hee was euer in that citie. But sée your shamelesse partialitie. Here, Babylon (say you) is not taken for Rome: because it would folow that Peter was at Rome, and so forth. But in the Apocalypse, where all euill is spoken of Babylon, there you will haue it signifie nothing else but Rome, and the Romane church also, not (as the Fathers interprete it) the temporall state of the heathen Empire there. So do you folow in euery word no other thing, but ye aduantage of your own heresie. Which is most notorious by this, that you hold that Peter was neue at Rome. Wherein you passe your selues in impudencie. For it is against all the ecclesiasticall histories, all the Fathers Gréeke and Latin,
*As the Rhemists say: who charge the Protestants with all this, in their Annotat. on • Pet. 5.13. and Rom. 16.16.As the Rhemists say: who charge the Protestants with al this, in their Annotat. on • Pet. 5.13. and Rom. 16.16.
Leo, fS. Austin, gOrosius, hS. Chrysostom, iS. Epiphanius, kPrudentius, lOptatus, mS. Ambrose, nS. Jerome, oLactantius, pEusebius, qS. Athanasius, rS. Cyprian, sTertullian, tOrigen, uIrenaeus, xHegesippus, yCaius and Papias, the Apostles own scholars, and Dionysius the Bishop of Corinth, zIgnatius, athe holy council of Chalcedon, and many others. Yea Peter him self (according to the judgement of the Fathers, as I have showed) confesseth that he was at Rome, calling it Babylon.
Leo, fS. Austin, gOrosius, hS. Chrysostome, iS. Epiphanius, kPrudentius, lOptatus, mS. Ambrose, nS. Ierom, oLactantius, pEusebius, qS. Athanasius, rS. Cyprian, sTertullian, tOrigen, uIrenaeus, xHegesippus, yCaius and Papias, the Apostles owne scholers, and Dionysius the Bishop of Corinth, zIgnatius, athe holy councell of Chalcedon, and many others. Yea Peter him selfe (according to the iudgement of the Fathers, as I haue shewed) confesseth that he was at Rome, calling it Babylon.
Rainoldes. Here is a grievous crime, wherewith you charge our Protestants, of shameless partiality. But whether show them selves more partial and unhonest handlers of Gods word, our Protestants, or your Papists: you are too partial (M. Hart) to judge. There is a just judge who will reveal it in that day, before the eyes of all men: and in the mean season he doth reveal it daily, to them whom he maketh wise to try spirits, & to discern the truth from error. As for this particular, wherein we seem to you most unhonest and partial, that in Peters epistle we take the word [Babylon] properly, for the city of that name in Chaldea; and in the Revelation we say that it signifieth Rome, figuratively: we do not this for any advantage of heresy, as you falsely charge us, but in sincerity before God. For in the Revelation, in which there are as many bmysteries as words, and words applied commonly to allegories and figures: Rome might be fitly meant by the name of Babylon. And that it was so, it appeareth by the circumstances: if not, of cthe seven hills, whereon ⟨p. 263⟩Rome was built, (and dJerome gathereth it thereof;) yet of ethe great city, which reigneth over the kings of the earth, which in S. Johns time was Rome; fthe Fathers so interpret it; you say it, and subscribe unto it. But, in all the rest of the new Testament, where things are plainly spoken off, it si• teth most with reason that the word Babylon be taken in his proper meaning: the text doth force it in gother places; and, in that epistle of Peter it is the likelier, because hthe like speeches in superscriptions, in salutations, in dates of epistles, are elsewhere meant simply. In the Revelation, ithe great city is called spiritually Sodom. In kPeters epistle, we take the name of Sodom properly. Is it partiality in us, to take it so? Or were it not a folly in you to reprove it? But this is the matter belike, which pincheth you, that in the Revelation, where all evil is spoken of Babylon, we will have it signify nothing else but Rome, and the Roman Church also, not the temporal state of the heathen Empire there, as the Fathers interpret it. The Fathers then interpret it of Rome, you confess. If you condemn us for interpreting it so: you must condemn them with us. If you say that we do not therein, as they, because we expound it of nothing else but Rome, and they not so: you slander us.
Rainoldes. Here is a gréeuous crime, wherewith you charge our Protestants, of shamelesse partialitie. But whether shew them selues more partiall and vnhonest handlers of Gods word, our Protestants, or your Papistes: you are too partiall (M. Hart) to iudge. There is a iust iudge who will reueale it in that day, before the eies of all men: and in the meane season he doth reueale it dayly, to them whom he maketh wise to trie spirites, & to discerne the truth from errour. As for this particular, wherein we séeme to you most vnhonest and partiall, that in Peters epistle we take the word [Babylon] properly, for the citie of that name in Chaldaea; and in the Reuelation wee say that it signifieth Rome, figuratiuely: we do not this for any aduantage of heresie, as you falsely charge vs, but in sinceritie before God. For in the Reuelatiō, in which there are as many bmysteries as wordes, and wordes applyed commonly to allegories and figures: Rome might be fitly meant by the name of Babylon. And that it was so, it apperéeth by the circumstances: if not, of cthe seuen hils, wheron ⟨p. 263⟩Rome was built, (and dIerom gathereth it thereof;) yet of ethe great citie, which raigneth ouer the kinges of the earth, which in S. Iohns time was Rome; fthe Fathers so interprete it; you say it, and subscribe vnto it. But, in all the rest of the new Testament, where things are plainely spoken off, it si• teth most with reason that the word Babylon be taken in his proper meaning: the text doth force it in gother places; and, in that epistle of Peter it is the likelier, because hthe like spéeches in superscriptions, in salutations, in dates of epistles, are elsewhere meant simply. In the Reuelation, ithe great citie is called spiritually Sodom. In k
For lsome of us expound it of the city of the Devil, that is, the society and company of all the wicked, as some of them do. And what doth it advantage you, or your quarrel, if, as by mJerusalem is meant the city of God, that is, the society and company of all the faithful: so Rome, an other Babylon, do note the Devils city, as a figure and sampler of it? For, in this sort also will Babylon be Rome still. Wherein, that you may learn the less to carp at us, hearken to nyour Jesuit: who having showed, that the whore which sitteth on the seven hills, is (in *some mens judgment) the city of the Devil, which often times is called Babylon, and set against Jerusalem, the city of God, that is, the Church: but in my judgement (saith he) it is better to understand the city of Rome by the whore, as oTertullian and pJerome do. To whom he might have added qsundry of the Grecians: and rS. Austin also. But they interpret it (you say) of the temporal state, not ecclesiastical; of the Roman Empire, not of the Roman Church, as we do. No marvel. For in their •aies the Church did differ from the Empire: the Empire, wicked; ⟨p. 264⟩Church, godly. In ours it is not so. The state ecclesiastical is changed into the temporal: the Church hath swallowed up the Empire; and what the Roman Empire was, that now the Roman Popedo e is. Wherefore when we apply the mystery of Babylon to the Church of Rome: we apply it still (as the Fathers did) to the temporal state, if not of an heathen Empire there, yet of a Christian waxing heathnish. There we see sa purple whore, sitting upon many waters, drunken with the blood of Saints, and with the blood of Christs martyrs, having a golden cup in her hand, full of abominations and filthiness of her whoredom. tSanders, the greatest patron of the Popes monarchy, doth prove out of Tertullian, that where there is the greatness of the kingly city, where the pride of the Empire, where the persecution of Christians doth rage: there is Babylon, no doubt, there is the great city, there is that woman which sitteth upon peoples, nations, and languages, with whom the kings of the earth do commit whoredom, and the inhabitants of the earth are drunken with the wine of her whoredom. Now Rome in these respects was Babylon (as he construeth it) while the heathen Emperors obtained the temporal state there, not since the Popes have had it.
For lsome of vs expound it of the citie of the Deuill, that is, the societie and companie of all the wicked, as some of them do. And what doth it aduantage you, or your quarell, if, as by mIerusalem is meant the citie of God, that is, the societie and companie of all the faithfull: so Rome, an other Babylon, doo note the Deuils citie, as a figure and sampler of it? For, in this sort also will Babylon be Rome stil. Wherein, that you may learne the lesse to carpe at vs, hearken to nyour Iesuit: who hauing shewed, that the whoore which sitteth on the seuen hils, is (in *some mens iudgment) the citie of the Deuil, which often times is called Babylon, and set against Ierusalem, the citie of God, that is, the Church: but in my iudgement (saith he) it is beter to vnderstand the citie of Rome by the whoore, as oTertullian and pIerom doo. To whom he might haue added qsundry of the Grecians: and rS. Austin also. But they interpret it (you say) of the temporall state, not ecclesiasticall; of the Romane Empire, not of the Romane Church, as we doo. No maruaile. For in their •aies the Church did differ from the Empire: the Empire, wicked; ⟨p. 264⟩Church, godly. In ours it is not so. The state ecclesiasticall is chaunged into the temporall: the Church hath swallowed vp the Empire; and what the Romane Empire was, that now the Roman Popedo e is. Wherefore when we apply the mysterie of Babylon to the Church of Rome: we apply it still (as the Fathers did) to the temporall state, if not of an heathen Empire there, yet of a Christian waxing heathnish. There we sée sa purple whoore, sitting vpon many waters, droonken with the blood of Saintes, and with the blood of Christs martyrs, hauing a golden cuppe in her hand, full of abominations and filthines of her whooredome.
lBabylonis nomine, Satanae congregation• significat: sed eam potissimu• quae ab ecclesia Romana pend•• In exposit ecclesiast. Nou. Test. excerpt […] probat. Theologis ab A•gustino Marlora••.Babylonis nomine, Satanae congregation• significat: sed eam potissimu• quae ab ecclesia Romana pend•• In exposit ecclesiast. Nou. Test. excerpt 〈…〉 probat. Theologis ab A•gustino Marlora••.
But let the states of the Popedom and of the Empire be compared; and the stories of uthe Emperors, who reigned there before the Popes, and of xthe Popes (who have succeeded them) be examined: and if it be not found that the Papal state hath matched the Imperial in greatness of power, in pride of dominion, in persecuting of Christians; then let us be judged to vary from the Fathers in giving Rome the name of Babylon. Else are we cleared by verdict of Sanders from that wherewith you charge us, of expounding it to the advantage of our heresy: and you must pronounce that we deal uprightly with the name of Babylon, in the Revelation. As for our usage of it in the epistle of Peter: the reasons which you bring to prove a fault therein, may serve for our acquittal. You say, that we never read either in scriptures, or other holy, or profane history, that Peter was ever in the city of Chaldea, which is named Babylon. A simple proof, if we had not. For, the Apostles, being sent to yall nations, were in many cities, wherein we never read they were. And yet we ⟨p. 265⟩have read in Methodius (an ancient bishop, and historian) alleged by zMarianus Scotus, that Peter did preach the gospel in 1Babylon: that is, either the city, or at least the country; and where they preached in the country, they did it in the chief and mother-city commonly. But the ancient Fathers, namely S. Jerome, Eusebius, Oecumenius, & many moe agree, that Peter meant Rome by the word Babylon. They deliver it, I grant: but they received it from Papias, a man, though you commend him for the Apostles own scholar, yet aof very small judgement: who, mistaking the meaning of the Apostles speeches in 2a matter of greater weight, deceived many Fathers that followed him for his antiquity, as both bEusebius and cJerome do report of him. The less strange it is, if they believed him, and others them, in this point, of no such importance. But, it is consonant to that which followeth of Mark: whom all the ecclesiastical histories agree to have been Peters scholar at Rome, and that he there wrote his gospel. And dthis doth come from Papias also, by one as good as himself, even by Clemens Alexandrinus. Wherefore, I know, what credit it hath; what truth, I know not. For if eCassiodorus, fRhegino, gAdo, and hall the ecclesiastical histories have erred, in saying that Peter did abide at Rome five and twenty years;
But let the states of the Popedome and of the Empire be compared; and the stories of uthe Emperours, who raigned there before the Popes, and of xthe Popes (who haue succéeded them) be examined: and if it be not found that the Papall state hath matched the Imperiall in greatnes of power, in pride of dominion, in persecuting of Christians; then let vs be iudged to varie from the Fathers in giuing Rome the name of Babylon. Els are we cleered by verdit of Sanders from that wherewith you charge vs, of expounding it to the aduantage of our heresie: and you must pronounce that we deale vprightly with the name of Babylon, in the Reuelation. As for our vsage of it in the epistle of Peter: the reasons which you bring to prooue a fault therein, may serue for our acquitall. You say, that we neuer read either in scriptures, or other holy, or prophane history, that Peter was euer in the citie of Chaldaea, which is named Babylon. A simple proofe, if we had not. For, the Apostles, being sent to yal nations, were in many cities, wherein we neuer read they were. And yet we ⟨p. 265⟩haue read in Methodius (an ancient bishop, and historian) alleaged by zMarianus Scotus, that Peter did preach the gospell in 1Babylon: yt is, either the citie, or at least the countrie; and where they preached in the countrie, they did it in the chiefe and mother-citie commonly. But the ancient Fathers, namely S. Ierom, Eusebius, Oecumenius, & many moe agree, that Peter meant Rome by the word Babylon. They deliuer it, I graunt: but they receyued it from Papias, a man, though you commend him for the Apostles owne scholer, yet aof verie small iudgement: who, mistaking the meaning of the Apostles spèeches in 2a matter of greater weight, deceyued many Fathers that followed him for his antiquitie, as both bEusebius and c
1Babylon•a▪ taken •y others, for the country: by sundry w•iters ec•lesias•• call, •or the c• tie of Babylon. Hist. eccle. •useb. Rufin. interpret. l. •. cap. 1•. August. in Psal. 26. & 61. de •ivitat. De• l. 18. cap. 2. Joseph. antiquit. Judaic. l. 20. c. 18 Prosper in dimid. Temp. cap. 7. & lib. senten. ex August. se•t. 221. Oath. Frising. chron lib. 7. cap. 3.Babylon•a▪ taken •y others, for the countrie: by sundrie w•iters ec•lesias•• call, •or the c• tie of Babylon. Hist. eccle. useb. Rufin. interpret. l. . cap. 1. August. in
which error they were carried into by iEusebius, or whosoever first reported it: why might they not also be deceived in this point by the report of Papias, or some who had it from Papias? Though, if it be true, that S. Mark was Peters scholar at Rome: yet this proveth not, that he meant Rome by the name of Babylon. For Peter saith only, the Church which is in Babylon, & Mark my son salute you. Now Mark (as kyour Papias also doth report) did follow and accompany Peter in his travel. So that he might be with him as well at Babylon in Chaldea, as in Italy at Rome. Wherefore whether Peter were at Rome or no: the proof thereof resteth upon humane histories. For this of Gods word, whereby you would prove it fain, saith nothing for it. Which la learned man of our side having weighed, and seeing mthe dissension of writers touching the time that he came to Rome; ⟨image 135⟩and knowing by nthe scripture that their speech of his abode in Rome, is false; and marking the shameful practise of the Romanists in oforging tales for their advancement, as Constantine's donation; and spying some such forgery amongst their monuments of Peter, pas Linus fable of his death; and finding qhis martyrdom mentioned by rJerome and Lyra, in such sort, as though he had been crucified by the Scribes and Pharisees: he was brought (by these & the like persuasions) into this opinion, that Peter never came to Rome. If you ask my judgement: I think he was deceived therein. And so do many mo. None of all the Protestants, swho have dealt in writing of histories & Chronicles, to my knowledge, (t one excepted) denieth, that he was at Rome. They who are straitest in it, do say uit may be doubted, it is no article of our faith: and xeither he was not there, or at another time then most authors think, and less then five and twenty years. Wherein, what do they say, but that which is most true and manifest? The greater wrong you do us, to charge us in general, that we hold that Peter was never at Rome. And, to aggravate the matter you muster up the names of the ancient Fathers, as though we did band our selves against them all. Whereas in very deed, ythey, whom you count our captains, do therefore grant Peter to have been at Rome, because the ancient Fathers affirm it so with one consent. Yea zsome of them (expounding those same words of Peter) apply the name of Babylon to Rome, as you do:
which errour they were caried into by iEusebius, or whosoeuer first reported it: why might they not also be deceyued in this point by the report of Papias, or some who had it from Papias? Though, if it be true, that S. Marke was Peters scholer at Rome: yet this proueth not, that he meant Rome by the name of Babylon. For Peter saith onely, the Church which is in Babylon, & Marke my sonne salute you. Now Marke (as kyour Papias also doth report) did follow and accompanie Peter in his trauel. So that he might be with him as well at Babylon in Chaldaea, as in Italie at Rome. Wherefore whether Peter were at Rome or no: the proofe therof resteth vpon humane histories. For this of Gods word, whereby you would proue it faine, saith nothing for it. Which la learned man of our side hauing weighed, and séeing mthe dissension of writers touching the time that hee came to Rome; ⟨image 135⟩and knowing by nthe scripture that their spéeche of his abode in Rome, is false; and marking the shamefull practise of the Romanists in oforging tales for their aduancement, as Constantines donation; and spying some such forgerie amongst their monuments of Peter, pas Linus fable of his death; and finding qhis martyrdome mentioned by rIerom and Lyra, in such sort, as though he had béene crucified by the Scribes and Pharises: he was brought (by these & the like perswasions) into this opinion, that Peter neuer came to Rome. If you aske my iudgement: I thinke he was deceiued therein. And so doo many mo. None of all the Protestants, swho haue dealt in writing of histories & Chronicles, to my knowledge, (t
iIn Chron.
kEuseb. hist. ecclesiast. l. 3. c. 36.
lVi•• cus Velenus, in opusculo inscripto, Petrum non venisse Romam, ne •ue illi• passum.
mpersuas ▪•.
npe•s. 3.4.10.12. & 13.
opers. 18.
ppe•s. 16.
qpe•s. 17.
rComme•tar. •n Matthae. c. 23
sCarrion & Melanchthon in Chron. lib. 3. Pantaleon in Chronographia. Vadian. epitome trium terrae partium, in Italia. M. Fox in his ecclesiastical history.Carion & Melanch•hon in Chron. lib. 3. Pantaleon in Chronographia. Vadian. •pitome trium terrae partium, in Italia. M. Fox in his ecclesiasticall historie.
tBalaeus in Act. Rom. pont. lib. 1. in praefat.
uFunccius con meant▪ in Chronolog. lib. 5.Funccius cō ment▪ in Chronolog. lib. 5.
some, who allow not of that exposition, yet grant he was at Rome. And so the reproach of shameless partiality which you cast on us, redoundeth on your selves. For if you had any modesty and equity, you would never say, that we deny Rome to be meant by Babylon, because it would follow that Peter was at Rome, and so forth. Specially, sith neither all of us deny it: and many who deny it, yet deny not but Peter was at Rome. But whereas you add, that we deny it, fearing hereby the sequel of Peters or the Popes supremacy at Rome:a therein you pass your selves in impudency. For we do confess, (and you too) I trust, that bPeter was at Joppe. And do we (or rather you) fear hereby the sequel of Peters or the Popes supremacy at Joppe.
some, who allow not of that exposition, yet graunt hée was at Rome. And so the reproch of shamelesse partialitie which you cast on vs, redoundeth on your selues. For if you had any modestie and equitie, you would neuer say, that we denye Rome to be meant by Babylon, because it would follow that Peter was at Rome, and so forth. Specially, sith neyther all of vs deny it: and many who denye it, yet deny not but Peter was at Rome. But whereas you adde, that we deny it, fearing hereby the sequele of Peters or the Popes supremacie at Rome:a therein you passe your selues in impudencie. For we doo confesse, (and you too) I trust, that bPeter was at Ioppe. And doo we (or rather you) feare hereby the sequele of Peters or the Popes supremacie at Ioppe.
Rainoldes. But you can not prove it by those words of Peter, which you would ground it on: although it were granted that he meant Rome by Babylon. For the most that might be proved so thereby, is, that he was at Rome. Which furthereth no more the Pope of Rome then of Joppe. And thus you may see, what tragedies you make for how small trifles: when you lay so heinous a crime to our charge for denying that, which although we grant, we neither win, nor lose by it.
Rainoldes. But you can not proue it by those words of Peter, which you would ground it on: although it were graunted that he meant Rome by Babylon. For ye most that might be proued so therby, is, yt he was at Rome. Which furthereth no more the Pope of Rome then of Ioppe. And thus you may sée, what tragedies you make for how small trifles: when you lay so heinous a crime to our charge for denying that, which although we graunt, we neyther winne, nor lose by it.
Rainoldes. I perceive the Pope must fetch his supremacy from earth and not from heaven. You are fallen again, from scripture, to Eusebius. Against whose authority I might take exception, because he saith that Peter continued bishop of Rome, preaching the gospel there, five and twenty years: which I have proved to be untrue. Though, (if I may speak mine own conjecture of it,) the difference of the Chronicle and history of Eusebius concerning that point, doth move me to think, that it was not written by Eusebius, but by Jerome. For che, in translating the Chronicle of Eusebius, did interlace some things which seemed to be omitted: *chiefly, in the Roman story. Now Jerome might receive it from dDamasus bishop of Rome: on whom ehe attended as a secretary. And Damasus was not so void of all affection, but fhe could be content to advance the credit of his own See by helping it to be reputed the bishoply See of Peter. But whether Eusebius, or Jerome, or Damasus, or whosoever have said that Peter was a Bishop: either they used the name of [Bishop] generally, and so it proveth not your purpose; or if they meant it, as commonly we do, they missed the truth. For generally, 1a Bishop, is an overseer. In which signification it reacheth to all, who are put in trust with oversight & charge of any thing: as gEleazar is called Bishop of the tabernacle; & Christ, hthe Bishop of our souls. But, in our common use of speech it noteth him, to whom the oversight & charge of a particular Church is committed: such as were the Bishops of iEphesus, of kPhilippi; and they whom Christ calleth lthe Angels of the Churches. Now Peter was not Bishop after this ⟨p. 268⟩later sort: for he was an Apostle, and 2the Apostles were sent to preach to all the world. Wherefore when the Fathers said, he was a Bishop: either they meant it in the former sense, or ought to have meant it. This is somewhat harder to be perceived by Jerome: but others open it more plainly. For mhe reckoneth Peter the first Bishop of Rome; Linus, the second; Cletus, the third; Clemens, the fourth, and so the rest successively: as likewise, nin Antioch, Ignatius, the third; whereby Evodius is the second; oand Peter, the first. But pEusebius nameth Evodius, the first Bishop of Antioch; Ignatius, the second: and qIrenaeus nameth Linus, the first Bishop of Rome; *Cletus the second; and so forth.
Rainoldes. I perceyue the Pope must fetch his supremacie from earth and not from heauen. You are fallen againe, from scripture, to Eusebius. Against whose autoritie I might take exception, because he saith that Peter continued bishop of Rome, preaching the gospel there, fiue and twentie yeares: which I haue proued to be vntrue. Though, (if I may speake mine owne coniecture of it,) the difference of the Chronicle and historie of Eusebius concerning that point, doth moue mee to thinke, that it was not writen by Eusebius, but by Ierom. For che, in translating the Chronicle of Eusebius, did enterlace some thinges which séemed to be omitted: *chiefely, in the Roman storie. Now Ierom might receiue it from dDamasus bishop of Rome: on whom ehe attended as a secretarie. And Damasus was not so voide of all affection, but fhe could be content to aduance the credit of his owne Sée by helping it to be reputed the bishoply See of Peter. But whether Eusebius, or Ierom, or Damasus, or whosoeuer haue saide that Peter was a Bishop: either they vsed the name of [Bishop] generally, and so it proueth not your purpose; or if they meant it, as commōly we do, they missed the truth. For generally, 1a Bishop, is an ouerseer. In which signification it reacheth to all, who are put in trust with ouersight & charge of any thing: as gEleazar is called Bishop of the tabernacle; & Christ, hthe Bishop of our soules. But, in our cōmon vse of spéech it noteth him, to whō ye ouersight & charge of a particular Church is committed: such as were the Bishops of iEphesus, of kPhilippi; and they whom Christ calleth lthe Angels of the Churches. Now Peter was not Bishop after this ⟨p. 268⟩
cHieron. praefat. in Eusebij Chron.
*In Romana maximé historia.
dIn pontificali.
eHieron. epist. 11. ad Ager. & l. 2. contra Rufinum.
fTheodoret. histor. ecclesiast. l. 5. c. 9. Sozom. l, 6. c. 23. Ammia•. Mar•ellin. l. 27.
1[Greek or Hebrew] whence the Latin (Episcopus) & our English word (Bishop) are derived.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 whence the Latin (Episcopus) & our English word (Bishop) are deriued.
gIn the Greek translation o• the Seventy interpreter•, Numb 4.16.In the Greek translation o• the Seuentie interpreter•, Numb 4.16.
Whereby they declare, that (in their judgement) although Peter preached at Antioch and Rome both, yet he was neither Bishop of Antioch, nor Rome, as usually that name is taken. Yea they distinguish the Bishops, and the Apostles therein purposely. For rIrenaeus saith, that the two 1Apostles, namely Peter and Paul, when they had founded and taught the Roman Church, committed 2the Bishoply charge thereof to Linus. And he repeateth often in reckoning up the Bishops, (as doth sEusebius also) that they were such, and such, in order, and number, from the Apostles. And tRufinus writeth, that Linus and Cletus were Bishops while Peter lived: that they might have 1the care of the Bishoply charge, and he might do 2the duty of the Apostleship. Which is confirmed farther by uEpiphanius. Who, though he say that Peter and Paul were both Apostles & Bishops in Rome: yet he saith withal that there were other Bishops of Rome, while they lived; because that 1the Apostles, went often into other countries to preach Christ; & the city of Rome might not be without 2a Bishop. As if he should have said, that a Bishops duty doth bind him to attend the Church, whereof the holy Ghost hath made him overseer. Now, though the Apostles Peter and Paul did perform that duty to the Church of Rome, while they abode there: yet because it was the charge of their Apostleship to preach to others also, therefore they went thence to other coasts and nations, and left the Roman charge to the Bishop of Rome. And so you may learn by the Fathers them selves, that when they termed any Apostle a Bishop of this or that city, as namely, S. Peter of Antioch, or Rome: they meant it in ⟨p. 269⟩a general sort, and signification, because he did attend that Church for a time, and supplied that room in preaching of the Gospel, which Bishops did after. But as the name of [Bishop] is commonly taken for the overseer of a particular church, and pastor of a several flock: so Peter was not Bishop of any one city, and therefore not of Rome.
Whereby they declare, that (in their iudgement) although Peter preached at Antioche and Rome both, yet he was neither Bishop of Antioche, nor Rome, as vsually that name is taken. Yea they distinguish the Bishops, and the Apostles therein purposely. For rIrenaeus saith, that the two 1Apostles, namely Peter and Paule, when they had founded and taught the Romane Church, committed 2the Bishoply charge therof to Linus. And he repeateth often in reckening vp the Bishops, (as doth sEusebius also) that they were such, and such, in order, and number, from the Apostles. And tRufinus writeth, that Linus and Cletus were Bishops while Peter liued: that they might haue 1the care of the Bishoply charge, and hee might do 2the duetie of the Apostleship. Which is confirmed farther by uEpiphanius. Who, though hée say that Peter and Paule were both Apostles & Bishops in Rome: yet hee saith withall that there were other Bishops of Rome, while they liued; because that 1the Apostles, went often into other countryes to preach Christ; & the city of Rome might not be without 2a Bishop. As if he should haue said, that a Bishops duetie doth bind him to attend the Church, whereof the holy Ghost hath made him ouerseer. Now, though the Apostles Peter and Paule did performe that duetie to the Church of Rome, while they abode there: yet because it was the charge of their Apostleship to preach to others also, therefore they went thence to oth•r coastes and nations, and left the Romane charge to the Bishop of Rome. And so you may learne by the Fathers thē selues, that when they termed any Apostle a Bishop of this or that citie, as namely, S. Peter of Antioche, or Rome: they meant it in ⟨p. 269⟩
rAduers. h•r. lib. 3. cap. 3.
1Apostoli.
2Episcopatum.
sHistor. eccles, l. 3. c. 2. & 19. l. 4. c. 1. & 5. l. 5. c. 1. &c.
Hart. Yet the Bishops of Rome did succeed Peter: even by the testimony of the same authors namely of Irenaeus, Eusebius, 1and Epiphanius, in the places by you alleged.
Hart. Yet the Bishops of Rome did succéede Peter: euen by the testimonie of the same autors namely of Irenaeus, Eusebius, 1and Epiphanius, in the places by you alleaged.
Rainoldes. They did succeed Peter, as Bishops an Apostle: and they did succeed him in Rome, as other Bishops did in other cities. Wherefore if the Bishop of Rome by this succession have right to the supremacy: what hath the Bishop of Antioch? For he succeeded Peter too.
Rainoldes. They did succeede Peter, as Bishops an Apostle: and they did succéede him in Rome, as other Bishops did in other cities. Wherefore if the Bishop of Rome by this succession haue right to the supremacie: what hath the Bishop of Antioche? For he succeeded Peter too.
Hart. The Bishop of Antioch did succeed Peter, while Peter lived yet, and had not left his right. But the Bishop of Rome succeeded him, when he died: and thereby was advanced unto that supremacy, which Peter kept while he lived.
Hart. The Bishop of Antioche did succéede Peter, while Peter liued yet, and had not left his right. But the Bishop of Rome succéeded him, when he died: and thereby was aduanced vnto that supremacie, which Peter kept while hee liued.
but Christ saide, it should not be so amongst them, as with the Princes of the Gentiles. Which sentence of Christ your Popes not vnderstanding, and wéening the Apostles to be forbidden nothing but an heathnish tyrannie, and liking well a monarchie because Philosophers prayse it: they haue raised a
visible monarchie of their owne, in steede of Christes monarchie; and haue chaunged his kingdome, which is not of this world, into a worldly kingdome, the kingdome of the Romanes, as
the Church of Antioche was in the meane season both planted and
⟨p. 275⟩
watered by others, not by Peter. Wherefore, the former braunch of that which Eusebius reporteth touching Peter, that he had sate seuen yeares at Antioche, in the second yeare of Claudius, is flatly contrarie to the scripture. The later is as contrary, that from that yeare forward he did sit at Rome fiue and twentie yeares, that is, all his life time, till he was put to death by Nero. For, (to graunt the vttermost, which may haue any shew of reason,) admitt, that he was cast by Herode into prison, in the first yeare of Claudius; before which he could not; for
at Rome,) brought him thither later, and gaue him longer time of life: Onuphrius Panuinius, a Frier of your owne, most deuout to the Pope, most skilfull in antiquities and stories of the Church, acknowledgeth and confirmeth it. For, in the discourses of his Annotations on
it is most cleere (saith he) and surely known by the Actes of the Apostles, and Pauls epistle to the Galatians, that, for nine yeares after Christes death, vntill the second yeare of the raigne of Claudius, Peter neuer went out of Iewry. Wherfore if he came to Rome, at that time, as it is agreed amongst all autours that he did:
Origen that it was towarde his end, whē he had preached the gospell to the Iewes in Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia. Wherefore sith Eusebius doth in his storie dissent from his Chronicle, and in his Chronicle dissent from the scripture:
Peters epistle, we take the name of Sodom properly. Is it partialitie in vs, to take it so? Or were it not a folly in you to reproue it? But this is the matter belike, which pincheth you, yt in the Reuelatiō, where all euill is spoken of Babylon, we will haue it signifie nothing else but Rome, and the Romane Church also, not the temporall state of the heathen Empire there, as the Fathers interprete it. The Fathers then interprete it of Rome, you confesse. If you condemne vs for interpreting it so: you must condemne them with vs. If you say that we do not therein, as they, because we expound it of nothing els but Rome, and they not so: you slaunder vs.
Sanders, the greatest patron of the Popes monarchie, doth proue out of Tertullian, that where there is the greatnesse of the kingly citie, where the pride of the Empire, where the persecution of Christians doth rage: there is Babylon, no doubt, there is the great citie, there is that woman which sitteth vpon peoples, nations, and languages, with whom the kinges of the earth doo commit whooredom, and the inhabitants of the earth are droonken with the wine of her whooredome. Now Rome in these respects was Babylon (as he construeth it) while the heathen Emperours obtained the temporall state there, not since the Popes haue had it.
•evel. 17.4.•euel. 17.4.
tDe visib. Mo•a•. lib. 8. cap. 8.
Ierom doo report of him. The lesse strange it is, if they beléeued him, and others them, in this point, of no such importance. But, it is consonant to that which followeth of Marke: whom all the ecclesiastical histories agree to haue beene Peters scholer at Rome, and that he there wrote his gospel. And
this doth come from Papias also, by one as good as himselfe, euen by Clemens Alexandrinus. Wherefore, I know, what credit it hath; what truth, I know not. For if
. & 61. de •iuitat. De• l. 18. cap. 2. Ioseph. antiquit. Iudaic. l. 20. c. 18 Prosper in dimid. Temp. cap. 7. & lib. senten. ex August. se•t. 221. Oth. Frising. chr•n lib. 7. cap. 3.
a[Greek or Hebrew]. Euseb. l. 3. c. 36.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Euseb. l. 3. c. 36.
2The fancy of the Millenaries, or Chiliasts as they were called.The fansie of the Millenaries, or Chiliasts as they were called.
bHistor. ecclesiast. l. 3. cap. 36.
cDe scriptor. ecclesiast. in verbo Papias.
dEuseb. histor. ecclesiast. lib. 2. cap. 15. Hieron. de scriptor. eccle•. verbo Marcus.
eIn Chronic.
fChronic. l. 2.
gAdo Vienn. breu. Chr. aet. 6.
hBede in Martyrolog. Maria•• Scot. Chron. lib. 2. Martin. Polon. s•ppu•• P•nt. Roman. Platina de vit. Pont. and the rest.Beda in Martyrolog. Maria•• Scot. Chron. lib. 2. Martin. Polon. s•ppu•• P•nt. Roman. Platina de vit. Pont. and the rest.
one excepted) denyeth, that he was at Rome. They who are straitest in it, doo say
either he was not there, or at another time then most autors thinke, and lesse then fiue and twentie yeares. Wherein, what doo they say, but that which is most true and manifest? The greater wrong you doo vs, to charge vs in general, that we holde that Peter was neuer at Rome. And, to aggrauate the matter you muster vp the names of the ancient Fathers, as though we did bande our selues against them all. Whereas in verie déede,
the Apostles were sent to preach to all the world. Wherefore when the Fathers said, he was a Bishop: either they meant it in the former sense, or ought to haue meant it. This is somewhat harder to be perceiued by Ierom: but others open it more plainely. For
[Greek or Hebrew], so called, as chosen to be sent ••road to preach to e•ery creature. Mark. 3.14. & 16.15.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, so called, as chosen to be sent ••road to preach to e•ery creature. Mark. 3.14. & 16.15.
mHieronym. de scriptor. e• cle. verbo, Clemens.
nverbo, Ignatius.
overbo, Simon Pet.
pIn chronic. & histor. l. 3. c. 19
qAduers. haere. l. 3. cap. 3.
*Who is called Anacletus, by Irenaeus and Eusebius.
a generall sort, and signification, because he did attend that Church for a time, and supplyed that roome in preaching of the Gospel, which Bishops did after. But as the name of [Bishop] is commonly taken for the ouerseer of a particular church, and pastor of a seuerall flocke: so Peter was not Bishop of any one citie, and therefore not of Rome.