Rainoldes. Yet were this also a blemish of the Council, to condemn a Pope in stead of an heretic. But they have not deserved to be touched with it. For, the 1former epistle, upon the proof whereof they did proceed to sentence, they saw it conferred with the authentical Latin copy, & found it to agree. Beside that, ythe author whom your selves allege to clear Honorius, confessed it to be Honorius his own: and he confessed it then, when the secretary of Honorius, who wrote it with his own hand, was alive, of good account, and bare witness of it. The 3later was approved to the Council, as the former: though they ⟨p. 297⟩stood less about it, as needing less inquiry, when he was now already cast. But it hath all presumptions for it, so probable, that not as much as aPighius could suspect it, though he suspected the other. Neither do I think that father Robert thought them in deed to be counterfeited. But as a man that is in danger of drowning doth snatch at every bulrush to save his life, if it may be: so he, seeing the Pope made subject to heresy by the sixth general Council, doth catch at every fancy, whereby he hath some hope to help him. The fancy of Pighius is, that the Council did not condemn Honorius: the copies of it are corrupted. bAndradius checketh that, and saith he was condemned: but the Council erred in condemning him, as judging him to err, who did not. cTorrensis varieth from them both, and cometh in with a finer quirk: to wit, that Pope Honorius did consent with heretics, but, as a private man; and not, as Pope. This dCanus, and Alfonsus, and Harding rest upon, and eGenebrard after them: who addeth yet withal (for fear of the worst) that the heretical epistles of Honorius were counterfeited perhaps. All these hath Father Robert, and flitteth up and down, to this, to that, amidst them: at the last, as one half gone and past sense, he layeth hold on the weakest, even on the bulrush of Pighius. Now, if that of Pighius be so inconvenient, that the force of truth doth drive you back from it: you must retire also from that, as inconvenient, whereof it doth follow. That is the false principle, wherein you join with him, and fhe thereon doth reason thus: Christ prayed for the Pope, in that he prayed for Peter, his faith not to fail: therefore the Pope cannot err. The Pope cannot err: therefore Pope Honorius was not an heretic.
Rainoldes. Yet were this also a blemish of the Councell, to condemne a Pope in steede of an heretike. But they haue not deserued to be touched with it. For, the 1former epistle, vpon the proofe whereof they did proceed to sentence, they saw it conferred with the authētical Latin copie, & found it to agrée. Beside that, yye autor whom your selues alleage to cléere Honorius, confessed it to be Honorius his owne: and he confessed it then, when the secretarie of Honorius, who wrote it with his owne hand, was aliue, of good account, and bare witnesse of it. The 3later was approued to the Councel, as the former: though they ⟨p. 297⟩stoode lesse about it, as néeding lesse inquiry, when he was now alreadie cast. But it hath all presumptions for it, so probable, that not as much as aPighius could suspect it, though he suspected the other. Neither do I thinke that father Robert thought them in déede to be counterfeited. But as a man that is in daunger of drowning doth snatch at euery bulrush to saue his life, if it may be: so he, seing the Pope made subiect to heresie by the sixth generall Councell, doth catch at euerie fansie, whereby he hath some hope to helpe him. The fansie of Pighius is, that the Councell did not condemne Honorius: the copies of it are corrupted. bAndradius checketh that, and saith he was condemned: but the Councell erred in condemning him, as iudging him to erre, who did not. cTorrensis varieth from them both, and cometh in with a finer quirke: to wéete, that Pope Honorius did consent with heretikes, but, as a priuate man; and not, as Pope. This dCanus, and Alfonsus, and Harding rest vpon, and eGenebrard after them: who addeth yet withall (for feare of the worst) that the hereticall epistles of Honorius were counterfeited perhaps. All these hath Father Robert, and flitteth vp and downe, to this, to that, amidst them: at the last, as one halfe gone and past sense, he layeth hold on the weakest, euen on the bulrush of Pighius. Now, if that of Pighius be so inconuenient, that the force of truth doth driue you backe from it: you must retire also from that, as inconuenient, whereof it doth folow. That is the false principle, wherein you ioyne with him, and
- 1Sext. synod. Constantinop. act. 12.
- yMaximus in disputat. contr. Pyr•hum.
- 3Sext. synod. Constantinop. action. 13.Sext. synod. Constantinop. •ction. 13.
- aHierar. […]. ib. 4. cap •.Hierar. 〈…〉. ib. 4. cap •.
- bDefens. […]. Trident. lib. 2.Defens. 〈…〉. Trident. lib. 2.
- cDe sext. sept. & octau. Synod.
- dIn the places afore quoted.
- eCh•onog•. lib. 3.
- fPighius pr• fat. in diatrib. & in dia••ibe de actis sext. & se••. Synod.