Hart. We do not abuse the credit of the Fathers to persuade an error: but as we endeavour to follow them in truth, so allege we them to prove the truth by them. And howsoever you avoid the place of S. Paul, where it is said, we have an altar: the prophecy of Malachi, that in every place there is sacrificed and offered a clean offering to God, must needs belong to the very and outward sacrifice of the Mass, not to spiritual sacrifices. Which because that reverend man, D▪ Allen, whose treatise of the Mass is such a moat in your eye, adoth prove by six reasons, 1the pith whereof he greatly praiseth: I will bring them forth in his own words, that you may yield the rather to them. First therefore, the word to sacrifice and to offer, being used by it self 2without a term abridging it, is taken in the scripture always properly for the act of outward sacrifice. But when it is said, the sacrifice of praise, the sacrifice of crying, the sacrifice of contrition, and the like: it is perceived easily by the words annexed that they be taken improperly. Secondly, this sacrifice, of the which the Prophet speaketh, is one: but spiritual sacrifices there are so many as there are good works of Christian religion. Thirdly, this is the proper and peculiar sacrifice of the new law, and the Gentiles, not of the Jews. But spiritual sacrifices of prayers and works are common to the Jews with us. Fourthly, this that Malachi meaneth doth succeed the sacrifices of the Jews, and is offered in their stead: but prayer, fasting, and the works of charity do not succeed any, but are joined and coupled to every kind of sacrifices. Fifthly, our works (chiefly in the judgement of heretics) are defiled, howsoever they seem beautiful: but this Prophetical offering is 3clean of it self, and so clean of it self in comparison of the old sacrifices, that it cannot be polluted any way by us or by the worst Priests. For here, in our testament, they cannot choose all the best to them selves, and offer to the Lord for sacrifice the feeble, the lame, and the sick, as before in the old: because there is now one sacrifice so appointed, that it cannot be changed; so clean, that no work of ours can distaine it. Finally, the Fathers, and all that ever have expounded this place of purpose catholicly, have expounded it of the sacrifice of the Mass:
Hart. We do not abuse the credit of the Fathers to perswade an errour: but as we endeuour to folow them in truth, so alleage we them to proue the truth by them. And howsoeuer you auoide the place of S. Paule, where it is said, we haue an altar: the prophecie of Malachie, that in euery place there is sacrificed and offered a cleane offering to God, must néedes belong to the verie and outward sacrifice of the Masse, not to spirituall sacrifices. Which because that reuerend man, D▪ Allen, whose treatise of the Masse is such a moate in your eye, adoth proue by sixe reasons, 1the pith whereof he greatly praiseth: I will bring them forth in his owne wordes, that you may yéelde the rather to them. First therefore, the word to sacrifice and to offer, being vsed by it selfe 2without a terme abridging it, is taken in the scripture alwaies properly for the act of outward sacrifice. But when it is said, the sacrifice of praise, the sacrifice of crying, the sacrifice of contrition, and the like: it is perceiued easily by the wordes annexed that they be taken improperly. Secondly, this sacrifice, of the which the Prophet speaketh, is one: but spirituall sacrifices there are so many as there are good workes of Christian religion. Thirdly, this is the proper and peculiar sacrifice of the new law, and the Gentiles, not of the Iewes. But spirituall sacrifices of praiers and workes are common to the Iewes with vs. Fourthly, this that Malachie meaneth doth succéede the sacrifices of the Iewes, and is offered in their stéede: but praier, fasting, and the workes of charitie doo not succéede any, but are ioined and coopled to euerie kinde of sacrifices. Fifthly, our workes (chiefely in the iudgement of heretikes) are defiled, howsoeuer they séeme beautifull: but this Prophetical offering is 3cleane of it selfe, and so cleane of it selfe in comparison of the olde sacrifices, that it cannot be polluted anie way by vs or by the woorst Priests. For here, in our testament, they cannot choose all the best to them selues, and offer to the Lord for sacrifice the féeble, the lame, and the sicke, as before in the old: because there is now one sacrifice so appointed, that it cannot be chaunged; so cleane, that no worke of ours can distaine it. Finally, the Fathers, and all that euer haue expounded this place of purpose catholikely, haue expounded it of the sacrifice of the Masse:
- aAlan. de Eucharist. sacrific. cap. 5.
- 1Argumenta valida, & pla•é bona.
- 2Sine termino d•minuente.
- 3Per•se munda est, & ita per se m•nda.