The eighth chapter. The authority 1 of traditions and fathers pretended to prove the Popes supremacy: in vain; beside the scripture, which is the only rule of faith. The Fathers, 2 being heard with lawful exceptions that may be justly taken against them, 3 do not prove it. As it is showed, first, in Fathers of the Church of Rome. By the way, 4 the name of Priest, the Priestly sacrifice of Christians, the Popish sacrifice of Mass-priests, the proofs brought for the Mass, the substance and ceremonies of it, are laid open. And so it is declared that 5 neither the ancient Bishops of Rome themselves, 6 nor any other Fathers do prove the Popes supremacy.The eighth chapter. The autoritie 1 of traditions and fathers pretended to proue the Popes supremacie: in vaine; beside the scripture, which is the onely rule of faith. The Fathers, 2 being heard with lawfull exceptions that may be iustly taken against them, 3 doo not proue it. As it is shewed, first, in Fathers of the Church of Rome. By the way, 4 the name of Priest, the Priestly sacrifice of Christians, the Popish sacrifice of Masse-priestes, the proofes brought for the Masse, the substance and ceremonies of it, are laid open. And so it is declared that 5 neither the auncient Bishops of Rome themselues, 6 nor any other Fathers do proue the Popes supremacie.
pp. 452–651695 passagespart 11 of 18
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Rainoldes. I have showed, how. And if you see it not: cthe veil may be the cause, which is very likely to be laid on your heart in reading of the new testament, as it was on the heart of others, in reading of the old. For the thing is plain of it self, and evident, that the spiritual sacrifices which the Jews offered, as namely their prayers, did not discharge their duty but they must offer carnal also; and that not every where, but in the place that God had chosen. In so much, that albeit they might pray in all places lawfully, as we may, yet must they come thither to worship God dat certain times: and Daniel, though he could not because of their captivity, yet ⟨p. 570⟩chad his windows open toward Jerusalem, when he prayed: and the faithful wept by the rivers of Babylon, fhow should we sing the lords song in a strange land? and the princely Prophet lamented that his banishment did keep him gfrom appearing there, and longed hto behold the power and glory of God, as he beheld it in the sanctuary; and being sick as it were iwith the love of his tabernacles, yea kfainting with desire of coming to his courts and laltars, he pronounced them mblessed who dwell in that house, yea, nwho may come unto it, yea othough they travail hardly thereto through dry places, pto present themselves before God in Zion. Whereas Christians, of the other side, qneither have those altars or offerings made thereon to join with their spiritual rsacrifice of praise, and they may ssing the songs of the Lord tin all places. No land is strange: no ground unholy. Every coast is Jewry, and every town Jerusalem, and every house Zion, and uevery faithful company, yea xevery faithful body a temple to serve God in. The Christian worship then doth differ even in prayers from that of the Jews, both in respect of the temple, ywhich they had a regard to: and of the ceremonies of the law, which they were bound therewith to keep. Wherefore, as zthe ministry of the new testament, that is, of them who taught the gospel, came after the ministry of Priests in the old, and yet both old and new are the Lords testament: so might and did the worship of God amongst Christians in spirit and truth come after the worship of God amongst the Jews, though yet they both did worship God spiritually. For the Jews before did worship in the temple with the ceremonies of the law:
Rainoldes. I haue shewed, how. And if you sée it not: cthe vaile may be the cause, which is very likely to be laide on your heart in reading of the new testament, as it was on the heart of others, in reading of the olde. For the thing is plaine of it selfe, and euident, that the spirituall sacrifices which the Iewes offered, as namely their prayers, did not discharge their duetie but they must offer carnall also; and that not euery where, but in the place that God had chosen. In so much, that albeit they might pray in all places lawfully, as wée may, yet must they come thither to worship God dat certaine times: and Daniel, though hée could not because of their captiuitie, yet ⟨p. 570⟩chad his windowes open toward Ierusalem, when hee praied: and the faithfull wept by the riuers of Babylon, fhow should we sing the lords song in a strange lande? and the princely Prophet lamented that his banishment did keepe him gfrom appeering there, and longed hto behold the power and glory of God, as he beheld it in the sanctuary; and being sicke as it were iwith the loue of his tabernacles, yea kfainting with desire of coming to his courts and laltars, he pronounced them mblessed who dwell in that house, yea, nwho may come vnto it, yea othough they trauaile hardly thereto through drye places, pto present themselues before God in Sion. Whereas Christians, of the other side,
as when athe Priest was burning incense at the altar in the inner part thereof, bthe multitude of the people were praying in the outer. And the Christians after did pray without incense in any place, the people and Pastor all together: as cthe Apostles with the disciples, and (d according to their instruction) ethe primitive Churches practise show. But these points of difference between us and them be perhaps the harder for you to understand, because your Popish worship is so like the Jewish, both for the temple, and the ceremonies, that you may justly think their worship was in spirit and truth as much as yours. For as the Priest with them was severed from the people by the division of ⟨p. 567⟩the sanctuary and court of the temple: fso with you, by the chancel and body of the church. As with them ghe burned incense at the altar: hso with you he doth. As with them ihe was clad in an Ephod, a mitre, a broidered coat, a girdle, a breastplate, and a robe, and they who served him were in their linen coats too: kso with you he must have an amice, an alb, a girdle, a fanel, a chasuble, and a stole, and they who are about him have surplices, yea copes also. Their Priests had la laver whereat they must wash before they sacrificed: mso have yours. Your nveil between the quire and the altar in lent, resembleth otheirs, that severed the holy place from the most holy. Your ppyx with the sacrament, and their qark with the mercy seat; your rphylactery with Saints relics, and their 18pot with Manna; your tmonstrance with the host, and utheir table with the show-bread; your xholy oil of balm, and ytheirs of myrrh with spices; ztheir purifying water made of the ashes of an heifer, and ayours of other ashes with water, wine, and salt; btheir fire sent from heaven, and cyours fetched *thence by art; their drod of Aaron, and eyour cross of Christ; finally, fyour candles, or tapers, or torches, and gtheir candlestick with lamps, do match one an other in proportion of rites: nay, you surpass them in your candles. For htheirs were lighted in the night: iyours, in the day too. Theirs, in the temple only: yours, kabroad also. Theirs, before the Lord: yours, lbefore images. Theirs, in one manner: yours, mwith great variety. Theirs, in small number: yours, at ntimes, and places, as many as the sand of the sea.
as when athe Priest was burning incense at the altar in the inner part therof, bthe multitude of the people were praying in the outter. And the Christians after did pray without incense in any place, the people and Pastour all together: as cthe Apos•les with the disciples, and (d according to their instruction) ethe primitiue Churches practise shew. But these points of difference betweene vs and them be perhaps the harder for you to vnderstand, because your Popish worship is so lyke the Iewish, both for the temple, and the ceremonies, that you may iustly thinke their worship was in spirit and truth as much as yours. For as the Priest with them was seuered from the people by the diuision of ⟨p. 567⟩the sanctuarie and court of the temple: fso with you, by the chancell and body of the church. As with them ghe burned incense at the altar: hso with you he doth. As with them ihe was clad in an Ephod, a miter, a broydered coate, a girdle, a brestplate, and a robe, and they who serued him were in their linen coates too: kso with you he must haue an amice, an albe, a girdle, a fanel, a chisible, and a stole, and they who are about him haue surplesses, yea copes also. Their Priestes had la lauer whereat they must wash before they sacrificed: mso haue yours. Your n
And what should I speak of the rest of the things in which you do not only follow their ceremonies, but also go beyond them? Your oconsecrating of Bishops, of churches, of altars, of pattens, of chalices, and other instruments of your Priesthood, by anointing them, paccording to the order of Aaron and the tabernacle. Your qshaving, as of rLevites; your simagery, as from tSolomon; your uhallowing of men, xbelles, yashes, zboughs, abread, bthe ⟨p. 568⟩paschal Lamb, cthe paschal taper, dagnus-deis (and what not?) with eexorcized water: wherewith almost all things are purged by your law, as fby theirs with blood. Your purifying (as gthey called it) or (as you term it) hreconciling of a churchyard, or other sacred place, if it be polluted. In conclusion, to pass over your ifestival days, exceeding theirs in kshadows; your lmystical devises in sacraments, to their pattern; your mpontifical robes, in figures incomparable, in number double unto theirs; and infinite solemnities of your nhiest Priest, who oentereth *once a year into the place most holy, pas did the high Priest of the Jews: your daily sacrifice of the Mass, though inferior to qtheirs in that it is no burnt offering, wherein yet I marvel you came no nearer them, for as rthey kept fire on the altar always, sso do you require it, and what should you have fire upon your altar as they had, unless you burn as they did? but your daily sacrifice of the Mass is celebrated in such Levitical sort, as if you contended to set forth a Jewish worship more lively then the Levitical Priests could. In attire like them, in mysteries above them, in torders more exquisite, in ucautels more diligent, in furniture abundantly: in lifting up the whole host, and not (as xthey) a part of it, in yringing of the sacring bell to countervail ztheir trumpets: in washing often, in blessing and crossing, in censing often, in soft speech and whispering, in kissing of the amice, kissing of the fanel, kissing of the stole, kissing of the altar, kissing of the book, kissing of the Priests hand, and kissing of the pax: in smiting and knocking, in gesturing by rule and measure, in bowing and ducking, in spacing forward, backward, and turning round about, and traversing of the ground: beside the sweet music of aorgans, and so forth, where it may be had, as in bthe temple it might. I doubt not, M.
And what should I speake of the rest of the things in which you do not onely folow their ceremonies, but also go beyond them? Your oconsecrating of Bishops, of churches, of altars, of patens, of chalices, and other instruments of your Priesthood, by anointing them, paccording to the order of Aaron and the tabernacle. Your qshauing, as of rLeuites; your simagery, as from tSalomon; your uhalowing of men, xbelles, yashes, zboughes, abread, bthe ⟨p. 568⟩paschal Lambe, cthe paschal taper, dagnus-deis (and what not?) with eexorcized water: wherwith almost all thinges are purged by your law, as fby theirs with blood. Your purifying (as gthey called it) or (as you terme it) h
yOn Ash•-wednesday. Durand. l. 6. c. 28.On Ash•-wensday. Durand. l. 6. c. 28.
zOn Palm-sunday. Durand. l. 6. c. 67.On Palme-sunday. Durand. l. 6. c. 67.
al. 4. c. 53.
bl. 6. c. 86.
ccap. 80.
dcap. 79.
eMissal Rom. reformat. a Pio quinto. Sacerdotal Rom. eccles. edit. a Samarin. part. 2.Missale Rom. reformat. a Pio quinto. Sacerdotale Rom. eccles. edit. a Samarin. part. 2.
Hart, but you are persuaded that this kind of service in your Church is Christian: and such, that if our selves were present at the doing, the solemn doing of it, specially at Christmas, Easter, and such other more festival times, the most of our stony hearts would melt for joy, as your cBristow writeth. But in very truth it is more then Jewish: and his conceit thereof is childish, and carnal. For although it might be delightful to the flesh, the eyes with gallant sights; the ears, with pleasant sounds; the nose▪ with fragrant ⟨p. 567⟩savours; the mind, with show of godliness, to him that doth not understand: yet da spiritual man would be grieved at it, as ePaul was in Athens, and lament that the people should do•te upon that by which they are fnot edified, and weep over them as gChrist over Jerusalem, O if thou hadst known at least in this thy day those things which belong unto thy peace: but now are they hidden from thine eyes. The Lord htake away this veil from your heart, if it be his good pleasure: that you may see at length what it is to worship him in spirit and truth, and when you see it, do it.
Hart, but you are perswaded that this kind of seruice in your Church is Christian: and such, that if our selues were present at the doing, the solemne doing of it, specially atChristmas, Easter, and such other more festiual times, the most of our stonie hartes would melt for ioy, as your cBristow writeth. But in verie truth it is more then Iewish: and his conceit thereof is childish, and carnal. For although it might be delitefull to the flesh, the eies with galant sightes; the eares, with pleasant soundes; the nose▪ with fragrant ⟨p. 567⟩sauours; the minde, with shew of godlines, to him that doth not vnderstand: yet da spiritual man would be grieued at it, as ePaule was in Athenes, and lament that the people should do•te vpon that by which they are fnot edified, and wéepe ouer them as gChrist ouer Ierusalem, O if thou hadst knowne at least in this thy day those things which belong vnto thy peace: but now are they hidden from thine eyes. The Lord htake away this vaile from your heart, if it be his good pleasure: that you may see at length what it is to worship him in spirit and truth, and when you sée it, doo it.
Hart. There is a veil rather of presumption over your heart, who condemn the Catholic ceremonies as Jewish: then of ignorance over ours, who embrace them as Christian. For ithe Council of Trent, which was gathered together and guided by the holy Ghost, hath accursed them who say that the received and approved rites of the Catholic Church, used in the solemn ministering of sacraments, may be despised. And those of the blessed sacrifice of the Mass, whereat your spite is greatest, kthe holy Fathers of that Council have showed to be grounded on the tradition of the Apostles, not on the law of Moses. For as much (say they) as the nature of men is such, that it cannot be lifted up easily to the meditation of divine things without outward helps: therefore our holy mother the Church hath ordained certain rites, to wit, that some things should be pronounced in the Mass with a soft voice, and some things with a louder. Moreover she hath used ceremonies too, as namely mystical blessings, lights, incense, vestments, and many other such things, *by the discipline and tradition of the Apostles: to the end that both the majesty of so great a sacrifice might be set forth, and the minds of the faithful might be raised up by these visible signs of religion and godliness to the contemplation of most high things which do▪ lye hidden in this sacrifice. These are the Councels words. Whereby you may perceive, that the rites and ceremonies used at the Mass, are not Jewish, but Apostolic: as (if need were) it might be showed in particulars, of incense, by S. lDenis; of lights, by S. mAustin; of the rest, by other Fathers.
Hart. There is a vaile rather of presumption ouer your heart, who cōdemne the Catholike ceremonies as Iewish: then of ignorance ouer ours, who embrace them as Christian. For ithe Councell of Trent, which was gathered togither and guided by the holy Ghost, hath accursed them who say that the receiued and approued rites of the Catholike Church, vsed in the solemne ministring of sacraments, may be despised. And those of the blessed sacrifice of the Masse, whereat your spite is greatest, kthe holy Fathers of that Councell haue shewed to be grounded on the tradition of the Apostles, not on the law of Moses. For as much (say they) as the nature of men is such, that it cannot be lifted vp easily to the meditation of diuine things without outward helpes: therefore our holy mother the Church hath ordeined certaine rites, to weete, that some things should be pronounced in the Masse with a soft voice, and some things with a lowder. Moreouer she hath vsed ceremonies too, as namely mystical blessings, lightes, incense, vestiments, and many other such things, *by the discipline and tradition of the Apostles: to the ende that both the maiestie of so great a sacrifice might be set forth, and the minds of the faithful might be raised vp by these visible signes of religion and godlines to the contemplation of most high things which doo▪ lye hidden in this sacrifice. These are the Councels words. Whereby you may perceiue, that the rites and ceremonies vsed at the Masse, are not Iewish, but Apostolike: as (if neede were) it might be shewed in particulars, of incense, by S. lDenys; of lightes, by S. mAustin; of the rest, by other Fathers.
Hart. I, even of them too: as basely and scornfully as you speak of them. Nor yet are these of ours like in all respects to those which the Priests did wear amongst the Jews. From whom in other points our ceremonies differ also. As for example, their nincense was a perfume most precious: oours, is simple frankincense. Their plights must be of pure oil: qours are of wax, and may be of other stuff indifferently. Which sith it is likewise apparent in the rest, as you must needs confess, at least for sundry of them: you are to blame greatly to reproach the ceremonies of the Church as Jewish.
Hart. I, euen of them too: as basely and scornfully as you speake of them. Nor yet are these of ours like in all respectes to those which the Priestes did weare amongst the Iewes. From whome in other pointes our ceremonies differ also. As for example, their nincense was a perfume most pretious: oours, is simple frankincense. Their plightes must be of pure oyle: qours are of waxe, and may bee of other stuffe indifferently. Which sith it is likewise apparant in the rest, as you must néedes confesse, at least for sundrie of them: you are to blame greatly to reproch the ceremonies of the Church as Iewish.
Rainoldes. Nay, you did mistake me, if you thought I meant that they are all Jewish, or Jewish absolutely. For I must needs confess that some of them are Heathnish rather then Jewish. As namely the shaving of your Priests crowns: after the manner of rPriests of Isis in Egypt. Your lighting of candles on Candlemas-day:s which came from the Februall ceremonies of the Romans. Your painting or graving of the images of men: ta thing that Christians took 1by custom of the Heathens. Your 2censing of images, and setting tapers before them: uas the Romans also did, when they were Heathens. To be short, the whole substance of your image-worship, xyour kissing, kneeling, & creeping to the image of the cross, like ySicilians to Hercules; your images borne in procession, like to the zGrecians idols; your pilgrimage to Saints images, where they are most famous, as aour Lady of *Lauretto, like bDiana of Ephesus, with infinite such other fancies, do resemble lively the Heathnish rites of Paganism, and grew by likelihood from the Heathens. But I▪ because the temple of Solomon had images, although not of men; the Levites had shaving, although not of crowns; the tabernacle had lights, although not in the day time, much less at the beginning of February more then other times: did speak of your Popish rites herein as Jewish, to make the best of them. And for all the difference that you find betwixt them, of wax in yours, and oil in theirs; and their perfume, and your frankincense; though cfrankincense was mingled with their perfume also, and dmade an incense too without it; but granting this difference betwixt them ⟨p. 572⟩to the uttermost: yet are yours Jewish in the kind thereof, because they are shadows such as were the Jewish. And it is likely, that they who devised them did fetch them out of Moses, as they who defend them do ground them upon Moses. For the fairest colour that either Bishop eDurand, or fothers set upon them, is, that God ordained them in Moses law. As gPope Innocentius saith that the Catholic Church doth hold that Bishops ought to be anointed, because the Lord commanded Moses to anoint Aaron and his sons: and again, that temples, and altars, and chalices ought to be anointed, because the Lord commanded Moses to anoint the tabernacle, and ark▪ and table with the vessels.
Rainoldes. Nay, you did mistake me, if you thought I meant that they are all Iewish, or Iewish absolutely. For I must néedes confesse that some of them are Heathnish rather then Iewish. As namely the shauing of your Priests crownes: after the maner of rPriestes of Isis in Egipt. Your lighting of candels on Candlemas-day:s which came from the Februall ceremonies of the Romans. Your painting or grauing of the images of men: ta thing that Christians tooke 1by custome of the Heathens. Your 2censing of images, and setting tapers before them: uas the Romans also did, when they were Heathens. To be short, the whole substance of your image-worship, xyour kyssing, kneeling, & creeping to the image of the crosse, like ySicilians to Hercules; your images borne in procession, like to the zGrecians idols; your pilgrimage to Saintes images, where they are most famous, as aour Ladie of *Lauretto, like bDiana of Ephesus, with infinit such other fansies, doo resemble liuely the Heathnish rites of Paganisme, and grew by likelyhood from the Heathens. But I▪ because the temple of Salomon had images, although not of men; the Leuites had shauing, although not of crownes; the tabernacle had lightes, although not in ye day time, much lesse at the beginning of Februarie more then other times: did speake of your Popish rites herein as Iewish, to make the best of them. And for all the difference that you find betwixt them, of waxe in yours, and oyle in theirs; and their perfume, and your frankincense; though cfrankincense was mingled with their perfume also, and dmade an incense too without it; but granting this difference betwixt them ⟨p. 572⟩to the vttermost: yet are yours Iewish in the kinde thereof, because they are shadowes such as were the Iewish. And it is likely, that they who deuised them did fetch them out of Moses, as they who defend them doo ground them vpon Moses. For the fairest colour that eyther Bishop eDurand, or fothers set vpon them, is, that God ordeined them in Moses law. As gPope Innocentius saith that the Catholike Church doth holde that Bishops ought to be anointed, because the Lord commanded Moses to anoint Aaron and his sonnes: and againe, that temples, and altars, and chalices ought to be anointed, because the Lord commanded Moses to anoint the tabernacle, and arke▪ and table with the vessels.
aLeand. Albe•t. descript. Italiae. Histor. S. Mariae Lauret. script. ab Hier. Angelit. ad Clement. sept.
*A town in Italy, where there is a temple of the blessed Virgin, more celebrated with lying miracles, and thereupon with resort of men: then her temple was at Walsingham in England, of which Erasmus writeth in Colloqu. Pe•egrinat. religionis ergo.A towne in Italie, where there is a temple of the blessed Virgin, more celebrated with lying miracles, and thereupon with resort of men: then her temple was at Walsingham in England, of which Erasmus writeth in Colloqu. Pe•egrinat. religionis ergo.
Hart. But Pope Innocentius addeth, that the sacrament of unction (or anointing) doth figure and work an other thing in the new testament then it did in the old. And thereof he concludeth that they lye who charge the Church with Judaizing (that is, with doing as the Jews did) in that it celebrateth the sacrament of unction.
Hart. But Pope Innocentius addeth, that the sacrament of vnction (or anointing) doth figure and worke an other thing in the new testament then it did in the old. And thereof he concludeth that they lye who charge the Church with Iudaizing (that is, with doing as the Iewes did) in that it celebrateth the sacrament of vnction.
Rainoldes. Yet Pope Innocentius doth not bring that difference between the Jews and you, that your holy unction is made of oil, and balm, where theirs was made of oil & myrrh with other spices. He knew that the difference of this or that ingredient in the stuff of it would not clear your Church from Judaizing in the kind of the purgation, that is, the rite whereby you sanctify Priests and altars. No more, then if you should sacrifice a dog, and say that you do not therein as the Jews did, because they did sacrifice, not dogs, but sheep & oxen. As for the difference by which the Pope severeth your unction from theirs, that yours doth work and figure an other thing then theirs did: first, it wrought as much in their altars, as in yours, for any thing that I know. Secondly, it figured in their Priests the gifts of the holy ghost: which he saith it doth in yours. Thirdly, were it so that it had an other either work or meaning with you then with them, as after a sort it hath, both in respect of hhim, who ordered theirs; and ithe cause, why: yet might the ceremony be Jewish notwithstanding. For (I trust) you will not maintain but it were Judaism for your Church to sacrifice ka lamb in burnt offering, though you did it to signify, not Christ that was to come, las the Jews did, ⟨p. 573⟩but that Christ is come, and mhath by his passion both entered in himself and brought in others to his glory. At the least, S. Peter ndid constrain the Gentiles to Judaize, (as you term it,) when they were induced by his example and authority to allow the Jewish rite in ochoice of meats. Yet neither he, nor they allowed it in that meaning, which it was given to the Jews in. For it was given them pto betoken that holiness, and qtrain them up unto it, which Christ by his grace should bring to the faithful. And Peter knew rthat Christ had done this in truth, and staken away that figure, yea, tthe whole yoke of the law of Moses: which point he taught the Gentiles also. Wherefore, although your Church do keep the Jewish rites, with an other meaning then God ordained them for the Jews, as Pope Innocentius saith, to salve that blister: yet this of Peter showeth that the thing is Jewish, and you do Judaize who keep them.
Rainoldes. Yet Pope Innocentius doth not bring that difference betwene the Iewes and you, that your holy vnction is made of oyle, and balme, where theirs was made of oyle & myrrhe with other spices. He knew that the difference of this or that ingredient in the stuffe of it would not cléere your Church from Iudaizing in the kinde of the purgation, that is, the rite whereby you sanctifie Priests and altars. No more, then if you should sacrifice a dogge, and say that you doo not therein as the Iewes did, because they did sacrifice, not dogges, but shéepe & oxen. As for the difference by which the Pope seuereth your vnctiō from theirs, that yours doth worke and figure an other thing then theirs did: first, it wrought as much in their altars, as in yours, for any thing that I know. Secondly, it figured in their Priests the giftes of the holy ghost: which he saith it doth in yours. Thirdly, were it so that it had an other either worke or meaning with you then with them, as after a sort it hath, both in respect of hhim, who ordered theirs; and ithe cause, why: yet might the ceremonie be Iewish notwithstanding. For (I trust) you will not maintaine but it were Iudaisme for your Church to sacrifice ka lambe in burnt offering, though you did it to signifie, not Christ that was to come, las the Iewes did, ⟨p. 573⟩but that Christ is come, and mhath by his passion both entred in himselfe and brought in others to his glorie. At the least, S. Peter ndid constraine the Gentiles to Iudaize, (as you terme it,) when they were induced by his example and autoritie to allow the Iewish rite in ochoise of meates. Yet neither he, nor they allowed it in that meaning, which it was giuen to the Iewes in. For it was giuen them pto betoken that holines, and qtraine them vp vnto it, which Christ by his grace should bring to the faithfull. And Peter knew rthat Christ had doon this in truth, and staken away that figure, yea, tthe whole yoke of the law of Moses: which point he taught the Gentiles also. Wherefore, although your Church doo kéepe the Iewish rites, with an other meaning then God ordeined them for the Iewes, as Pope Innocentius saith, to salue that blister: yet this of Peter sheweth that the thing is Iewish, and you doo Iudaize who kéepe them.
Hart. S. Peter did not err in faith, but in behaviour, when he withdrew him self from eating with the Gentiles. For that was a default in conversation not in doctrine, as uTertullian saith. Neither doth S. xAustin think otherwise of it.
Hart. S. Peter did not erre in faith, but in behauiour, when he withdrew him selfe from eating with the Gentiles. For that was a defaute in conuersation not in doctrine, as uTertullian saith. Neither doth S. xAustin thinke otherwise of it.
Rainoldes. I grant. For he offended not in the truth of the gospel, but yin walking according to it, that having lived before not as the Jews, but Gentile-like, yet zthen he left the Gentiles for fear of the Jews, and adissembled his judgement touching that point of Christian doctrine. But this doth so much more convince both your Church of Judaizing in her ceremonies, and your doctrine of corrupting the gospel with that leaven. For if S. Peter bwas to be condemned, as causing them to Judaize, whom through infirmity he drew by example to play the Jews in one rite: what may your Church be thought of, which of settled judgement doth move and force Christians to play the Jews in so many? And he did acknowledge the truth of the doctrine by silence, and submission, when S. Paul reproved him. But cPope Innocentius saith that they lye who touch your Church for it. Wherefore the Pope, or rather the Popes and Papists all, who maintain the doctrine of the Trent-Council approving both dthe rest of your Jewish rites, and namely ethat of unction confirmed out of Moses by Pope Innocentius: they do not offend as the true Apostle of Christ ⟨p. 574⟩S. Peter did; but as the false Apostles, fwho troubled the Galatians, and perverted the gospel by mingling of the law with it.
Rainoldes. I graunt. For he offended not in the truth of the gospel, but yin walking according to it, that hauing liued before not as the Iewes, but Gentile-like, yet zthen hee left the Gentiles for feare of the Iewes, and adissembled his iudgement touching that point of Christian doctrine. But this doth so much more conuince both your Church of Iudaizing in her ceremonies, and your doctrine of corrupting the gospell with that leauen. For if S. Peter bwas to be condemned, as causing them to Iudaize, whom through infirmitie he drew by example to play the Iewes in one rite: what may your Church be thought of, which of setled iudgement doth moue and force Christians to play the Iewes in so many? And he did acknowledge the truth of the doctrine by silence, and submission, when S. Paul reproued him. But cPope Innocentius saith that they lye who touch your Church for it. Wherefore the Pope, or rather the Popes and Papists all, who maintaine the doctrine of the Trent-Councell approuing both dthe rest of your Iewish rites, and namely ethat of vnction confirmed out of Moses by Pope Innocentius: they doo not offend as the true Apostle of Christ ⟨p. 574⟩S. Peter did; but as the false Apostles, fwho troubled the Galatians, and peruerted the gospell by mingling of the law with it.
Hart. But, (as I have showed out of ithe Council of Trent,) the ceremonies which we use in the sacrifice of the Mass, as namely mystical blessings, lights, incense, vestments, and many other such things, came all not from the false but from the true Apostles. And if there be any which they ordained not: that might be ordained by 1our holy mother the Church. As it was, that some things should be pronounced in the Mass with a soft voice, & some things with a louder. For such is the nature of men, that it can not be lifted up easily to the meditation of divine things 2without outward helps. Which reason, added by the Council, doth warrant all our rites both of the Churches ordinance, and the Apostolic tradition against your cavils and surmises.
Hart. But, (as I haue shewed out of ithe Councell of Trent,) the ceremonies which we vse in the sacrifice of the Masse, as namely mysticall blessinges, lightes, incense, vestiments, and many other such thinges, came all not from the false but from the true Apostles. And if there be any which they ordeined not: that might be ordeined by 1our holy mother the Church. As it was, that some thinges should be pronounced in the Masse with a soft voice, & some thinges with a lowder. For such is the nature of men, that it can not bee lifted vp easily to the meditation of diuine thinges 2without outward helpes. Which reason, added by the Councel, doth warrant all our rites both of the Churches ordinance, and the Apostolike tradition against your cauils and surmises.
Rainoldes. Alas. And see you not how giddily the Council doth bring in that reason, that because our nature doth need outward helps, therefore some things should be pronounced softly, some aloud? For the very chiefest of the outward helps, which God hath ordained to raise our minds from earth to heaven, is kthe hearing of his word. His word is rehearsed in the Epistle, the Gospel, the Canon, and other parts of the Mass. The Mass lyou forbid to be said in the vulgar or mother tongue of the people: so that if all were 3cried as loud as Baals service, the people could not understand it. Yet not content with that, you will a part of it to be said with a soft voice, that the poor souls may not as much as hear it. Wherefore the reason which your Council maketh for that Massing-rite, is this in effect, that because the blindness and coldness of men doth need to be lightened and warmed by Gods word▪ which is rehearsed in the Mass: therefore a part of it must be pronounced with a soft voice, that they ⟨p. 575⟩may not hear it; part with a louder, but in a strange tongue, that, although they hear it, they may not understand it. And was there not a mighty spirit of giddiness in the Princes of Trent, that made them write so drunkenly? Yea, mwith a curse to seal it too?
Rainoldes. Alas. And sée you not how giddily the Councell doth bring in that reason, that because our nature doth neede outward helpes, therefore some things should be pronounced softly, some aloude? For the very chiefest of the outwarde helpes, which God hath ordeined to raise our mindes from earth to heauen, is kthe hearing of his word. His word is rehersed in the Epistle, the Gospell, the Canon, and other partes of the Masse. The Masse lyou forbid to be saide in the vulgar or mother tongue of the people: so that if all were 3cryed as loude as Baals seruice, the people could not vnderstand it. Yet not content with that, you will a part of it to bee saide with a soft voice, that the poore soules may not as much as heare it. Wherefore the reason which your Councell maketh for that Massing-rite, is this in effect, that because the blindenesse and coldnesse of men doth neede to be lightened and warmed by Gods worde▪ which is rehearsed in the Masse: therefore a part of it must be pronounced with a soft voyce, that they ⟨p. 575⟩may not heare it; part with a lowder, but in a strange toong, that, although they heare it, they may not vnderstand it. And was there not a mightie spirit of giddines in the Princes of Trent, that made them write so droonkenly? Yea, mwith a curse to seale it too?
Hart. They curse him who saith that the rite of the Roman Church, whereby part of the Canon and the words of consecration are uttered with a soft voice, is to be condemned: or that the Mass ought to be celebrated only in the vulgar tongue. And great reason why.
Hart. They curse him who saith that the rite of the Roman Church, whereby part of the Canon and the words of consecration are vttered with a soft voice, is to be condemned: or that the Masse ought to be celebrated onely in the vulgar toung. And great reason why.
Rainoldes. No doubt. For as nthe Jews, when they could not justify their wilful withstanding of the Son of God, agreed, that if any man confessed him to be Christ, he should be excommunicated: so by like reason your Judaizers of Rome do ban and curse us, when they cannot justify their impudent customs and corruptions against us.
Rainoldes. No dout. For as nthe Iewes, when they could not iustifie their wilful withstanding of the Sonne of God, agréeed, that if any man confessed him to be Christ, he should be excommunicated: so by like reason your Iudaizers of Rome doo banne and curse vs, when they cannot iustifie their impudent customes and corruptions against vs.
Rainoldes. Catholic, and religious, to keep the Saints of God from hearing of Gods word? Catholic, and religious, to have the Church-service in a tongue which the Church, the faithful people, understand not?
Rainoldes. Catholike, and religious, to kéepe the Saintes of God from hearing of Gods word? Catholike, and religious, to haue the Church-seruice in a tongue which the Church, the faithfull people, vnderstand not?
Hart. Yea, Catholic, and religious, if you mark the reasons which they give thereof. For of othe one, they show, that the Church hath ordained it: of pthe other, that the Fathers thought it not expedient it should be had in the vulgar tongue.
Hart. Yea, Catholike, and religious, if you marke the reasons which they giue thereof. For of othe one, they shew, that the Church hath ordeined it: of pthe other, that the Fathers thought it not expedient it should be had in the vulgar toung.
Rainoldes. Not the ancient Fathers? Why, qthey are clear for it: and ryounger Fathers too. Yea, Fathers both, and children, I mean the whole Churches, of all nations, in the old time; of many, even till this day: as namely of the sSyrians, tArmenians, uSlavonians, xMuscovites, and yEthiopians.
Rainoldes. Not the ancient Fathers? Why, qthey are cleere for it: and ryonger Fathers too. Yea, Fathers both, and children, I meane the whole Churches, of al nations, in the old time; of many, euen till this day: as namely of the sSyrians, tArmenians, uSlauonians, xMoscouites, and yEthiopians.
qJustin. Mart. apolog. 2. Tertullian. in apologet. Cyprian. de orat. Dom. Euseb. hist. eccles. l. 7. c. 8. Augustin. de catechizand. rudib. cap. 9.Iustin. Mart. apolog. 2. Tertullian. in apologet. Cyprian. de orat. Dom. Euseb. hist. eccles. l. 7. c. 8. Augustin. de catechizand. rudib. cap. 9.
rIsidor. de of•ic. eccles. l. 1. c. 10. Cyrillus, Aen. Silu. hist. Bohem. cap. 13. Jo. Beleth de divin. of•ic. in proem. Lyra in 1. Cor. 14. Caietan. opusculor. Tom. 3. tractat. 15.Isidor. de of•ic. eccles. l. 1. c. 10. Cyrillus, Aen. Silu. hist. Bohem. cap. 13. Io. Beleth de diuin. of•ic. in prooem. Lyra in 1. Cor. 14. Caietan. opusculor. Tom. 3. tractat. 15.
sLiturg. Basil. ex version. Syr. quam vocant Anaphoram.
Hart. What so ever Churches or Fathers do, or have done: it seemed not expedient to the Fathers assembled in the Council of Trent. And they, being Bishops and Pastors of the Church, might take order for rites and ceremonies of the Church by zyour own confessions.
Hart. What so euer Churches or Fathers doo, or haue doon: it seemed not expedient to the Fathers assembled in the Councell of Trent. And they, being Bishops and Pastours of the Church, might take order for rites and ceremonies of the Church by zyour owne confessions.
Rainoldes. They might. But our confessions withal should have taught them, that as they may provide for athings ⟨p. 576⟩to be done with comeliness and in order: so their rites and ceremonies must be ball to edify. Which the Trent-fathers observed not in this rite, of having the service in a strange tongue, as themselves acknowledge. For cthey write expressly, that 1although the Mass contain great instruction of the faithful people, yet the Fathers have not thought it expedient 2that it should be sung or said every where in the vulgar tongue. Whereof this is the meaning, to open it in plainer words, that the corrupt custom of the Church of Rome, praying, and reading the scriptures in a strange tongue, in deed doth not edify: yet must stand for policy, to keep their Churches credit. For if they should yield that they have erred in one thing, men would doubt perhaps that they might err in more. And this do they farther bewray by the other point of uttering the words of consecration *secretly, that the faithful may not hear them. For in saying that dthe Church hath ordained that rite, they do closely grant that Christ ordained it not. Nay, etheir own men teach that fthe example of Christ, and gthe order of his Apostles, with hthe Fathers too, is manifest against it. Beside that, in calling it ia rite of the Church of Rome, they signify that other Churches do not use it, no not kthe Greek Church. And yet against the practise of Churches, of Fathers, of Apostles, and of Christ, they say that a dumb show (which lcrept in by custom) was ordained by our holy mother the Church: and, as men resolved to wallow in their own vomit, they curse him whosoever he be that shall condemn it.
Rainoldes. They might. But our confessions withall should haue taught them, that as they may prouide for athings ⟨p. 576⟩to be doon with comelines and in order: so their rites and ceremonies must be ball to edifie. Which the Trent-fathers obserued not in this rite, of hauing the seruice in a straunge tongue, as themselues acknowlege. For cthey write expressely, that 1although the Masse containe great instruction of the faithful people, yet the Fathers haue not thought it expedient 2that it should be soong or said euerie where in the vulgar tongue. Whereof this is the meaning, to open it in plainer words, that the corrupt custome of the Church of Rome, praying, and reading the scriptures in a straunge tongue, in deede doth not edifie: yet must stand for policie, to keepe their Churches credit. For if they should yéeld that they haue erred in one thing, men would dout perhaps that they might erre in more. And this doo they farther bewray by the other point of vttering the words of consecration *secretly, that the faithfull may not heare them. For in saying that dthe Church hath ordeined that rite, they doo closely graunt that Christ ordeined it not. Nay, etheir owne men teach that fthe example of Christ, and gthe order of his Apostles, with hthe Fathers too, is manifest against it. Beside that, in calling it ia rite of the Church of Rome, they signifie that other Churches do not vse it, no not kthe Greeke Church. And yet against the practise of Churches, of Fathers, of Apostles, and of Christ, they say that a dumbe shew (which lcrept in by custome) was ordeined by our holy mother the Church: and, as men resolued to wallow in their owne vomit, they curse him whosoeuer he be that shall condemne it.
a1. Cor. •4. ve•. •0.
bver. 26.
cSess. 22. cap. 8.
1••tsi: non tamen.
2Ut vulgari passim lingua celebraretur.Vt vulgari passim lingua celebraretur.
*Secreté profer• verba consecrationis, Ho• est corpus meum. In Canon. Missae.
dConcil. Trident. Sess. 22. c. 5.Concil. Tridēt. Sess. 22. c. 5.
eThom. Aquin. Sum. Theolog. part. 3. quaest. 7•. art. 1. D. Harding in his answer to the 16. art. of B. Jewels challenge.Thom. Aquin. Summ. Theolog. part. 3. quaest. 7•. art. 1. D. Harding in his answere to the 16. art. of B. Iewels chalenge.
hAmbros. de sacrament. lib. 4. c. 5. Leo Serm. 6. de •eiun•o 7. men•is. Justinian. in Authent. 137. §. Ad haec jubemus.Ambros. de sacrament. lib. 4. c. 5. Leo Serm. 6. de •eiun•o 7. men•is. Iustinian. in Authent. 137. §. Ad haec iubemus.
kChrysost. Li•urgia. Bessario de sacrament. •ucharist.
lAs Pope In•ocentius the third saith in his treatise of the Mysteries of the Mass. lib. 3. cap. 1.As Pope In•ocentius the third saith in his treatise of the Mysteries of the Masse. lib. 3. cap. 1.
Hart. Although Christ (we grant) did utter the words of consecration openly; and the Apostles, and Fathers, and other Churches also have kept the same rite: yet the Church of Rome is not to be condemned for taking order to the contrary. For rites may be changed as it shall seem best to them who govern the Church: and there was great reason why they should change this, to wit, mleast those words so holy and sacred should grow into contempt, whiles all in a manner knowing them, through common use, would sing them in the streets and other places not convenient. In the which respect perhaps they thought good also that the Mass and Matins, and all the Church-service should rather be in Latin, then in the vulgar ⟨p. 577⟩tongue. For of familiar use there groweth contempt: and men are wont to wonder at things which they know not; thing• common are despised.
Hart. Although Christ (we grant) did vtter the words of consecration openly; and the Apostles, and Fathers, and other Churches also haue kept the same rite: yet the Church of Rome is not to be condemned for taking order to the contrarie. For rites may be changed as it shall séeme best to them who gouerne the Church: and there was great reason why they should change this, to weete, mleast those words so holy and sacred should grow into contempt, whiles all in a maner knowing them, through common vse, would sing them in the streetes and other places not conuenient. In the which respect perhaps they thought good also that the Masse and Mattins, and all the Church-seruice should rather be in Latin, then in the vulgar ⟨p. 577⟩tongue. For of familiar vse there groweth contempt: and men are wont to wonder at things which they know not; thing• common are despised.
mThe reason, that Pope Innocentius the third (in the same place) giveth of it.The reason, that Pope Innocentius the third (in the same place) giu•th of it.
Rainoldes. A great oversight of our Saviour Christ, who willed his Apostles nto speak that in the light, which he had told them in darkness; and, what they heard in the ear, that to preach on the houses. For men would despise his gospel, if they knew it: as they do meat who have it. And what meant S. Paul to disclose othe words of consecration to the Corinthians? Yea, in their vulgar tongue too? And that with instruction, pto show forth th• Lords death until he came, as oft as they received the sacrament? Did he go about to bring the words of consecration, and death of Christ, into contempt? Or was not Innocentius the Pope borne yet, of whom he might have learned that they must be uttered not only in a strange tongue, but also closely and in silence, least men, if they hear them, do know them through use, and sing them in the streets? But will you see? Your qFathers of the Trent-council were overshot a little, when they ordained that Pastors and all who have cure of souls should 1often times expound (by them selves, or by others,) somewhat of those things which are read in the Mass: and rexplain the scripture to the faithful people 2in their mother tongue. In the Latin tongue if they had willed them to to do it, the order had agreed better with your doctrine: the people would have wondered at it. Now the knowledge of it is like to breed contempt. Beside there is danger, least, by hearing of it often times expounded, men become to wise, and smell out your abuses. The less they do know: the fitter to be Papists. For signorance is the mother of Popish devotion: as tknowledge is the nurse of Christian religion.
Rainoldes. A great ouersight of our Sauiour Christ, who willed his Apostles nto speake that in the light, which he had told them in darknes; and, what they heard in the eare, that to preach on the howses. For men would despise his gospel, if they knew it: as they doo meate who haue it. And what meant S. Paule to disclose othe words of consecration to the Corinthians? Yea, in their vulgar tongue too? And that with instruction, pto shew foorth th• Lords death vntill he came, as oft as they receiued the sacrament? Did he go about to bring the words of consecration, and death of Christ, into contempt? Or was not Innocentius the Pope borne yet, of whom he might haue learned that they must be vttered not onely in a strange tongue, but also closely and in silence, least men, if they heare them, do know them through vse, and sing them in the streetes? But wil you sée? Your qFathers of the Trent-councel were ouershot a litle, when they ordeined that Pastours and all who haue cure of soules should 1often times expound (by them selues, or by others,) somewhat of those things which are read in the Masse: and rexplane the scripture to the faithful people 2in their mother tongue. In the Latin toong if they had willed them to to do it, the order had agréed better with your doctrine: the people would haue wondred at it. Now the knowlege of it is like to breede contempt. Beside there is danger, least, by hearing of it often times expounded, men become to wise, and smell out your abuses. The lesse they doo know: the fitter to be Papists. For signorance is the mother of Popish deuotion: as tknowlege is the nurse of Christian religion.
Hart. We acknowledge that uignorance is the mother of all errors: neither do we seek to nuzzle Christians in it, but to wean them from it, as those decrees of the Council do sufficiently show.
Hart. We acknowlege that uignorance is the mother of all errors: neither do we séeke to noosell Christians in it, but to weane them from it, as those decrées of the Councell do sufficiently shew.
Rainoldes. They show sufficiently that you profess so: but how well you seek it, the former decrees of the rites, by which the people is nuzzled in ignorance, do more sufficiently show. Nether is it likely that all Pastors and Curates shall have skill ⟨p. 578⟩and leisure to expound the scripture to the people often. It may be that the service, read, and heard in a known tongue, would teach them more in a day, then some of them will in a month. Or if every Church had as good a Pastor, as Paul wisheth Timothy to be, that would xdivide the word of truth a right: yet they, being used yto hear the scripture read, should understand him better, as zthe Jews did Paul, and be (through Gods grace) athe readier bto believe him. And sith cthe Trent-fathers declare this expounding therefore to be needful, least Christs sheep be famished, or dthe young children ask bread & no man break it to them: it had been their duty withal to consider that God would have the table of his children furnished with this bread eplenteously, and as fDavids table with a cup running over, to keep them in good liking, not only that they be not famished. At least, howsoever they smooth their practise in this point, it is sure that their reason is beside all reason, when gthey say that because the nature of men doth need outward helps for raising of it up to think upon the things of God, therefore hath the Church ordained those rites, that some things in the Mass should be pronounced with a soft voice, and some things with a louder: the one, not to be heard; the other, not to be understood. And yet herein their dealing is the more plain, that they do acknowledge the Church to have ordained these rites. For if they would have hardened their faces, and said, that they received them from the Apostles by tradition: they might as well have said it, and proved it as soundly, as they do of others, lights, incense, vestments, and all the rest of their beggary.
Rainoldes. They shew sufficiently that you professe so: but how well you séeke it, the former decrées of the rites, by which the people is nooseled in ignorance, do more sufficiently shew. Nether is it likely that all Pastours and Curates shall haue skil ⟨p. 578⟩and leasure to expound the scripture to the people often. It may be that the seruice, read, and heard in a knowen tongue, would teach them more in a day, then some of them will in a moonth. Or if euerie Church had as good a Pastour, as Paule wisheth Timothee to be, that would xdiuide the word of truth a right: yet they, being vsed yto heare the scripture read, should vnderstand him better, as zthe Iewes did Paule, and be (through Gods grace) athe readier bto beleeue him. And sith cthe Trent-fathers declare this expounding therefore to be néedefull, least Christs sheepe be famished, or dthe young children aske bread & no man breake it to them: it had béene their dutie withall to consider that God would haue the table of his children furnished with this bread eplenteously, and as fDauids table with a cup running ouer, to kéepe them in good liking, not onely that they be not famished. At least, howsoeuer they smooth their practise in this point, it is sure that their reason is beside all reason, when gthey say that because the nature of men doth neede outward helpes for raysing of it vp to think vpon the things of God, therefore hath the Church ordeined those rites, that some things in the Masse should be pronounced with a soft voice, and some things with a lowder: the one, not to be heard; the other, not to be vnderstood. And yet herein their dealing is the more plaine, that they doo acknowlege the Church to haue ordained these rites. For if they would haue hardned their faces, and said, that they receiued them from the Apostles by tradition: they might as well haue said it, and proued it as soundly, as they doo of others, lightes, incense, vestiments, and all the rest of their beggerie.
Hart. Beggary call you that, which setteth forth the blessed sacrifice of the Mass with so comely ceremonies, to the consolation and instruction of the faithful?
Hart. Beggerie call you that, which setteth foorth the blessed sacrifice of the Masse with so comely ceremonies, to the consolation and instruction of the faithfull?
Rainoldes. Nay, the name of beggary is to good for it. For if S. Paul called the ceremonies of the Jews 1weak and beggarly rudiments, when they were matched with the gospel: what name deserve yours, ordained not of God, as theirs, but of men?
Rainoldes. Nay, the name of beggerie is to good for it. For if S. Paule called the ceremonies of the Iewes 1weake and beggerly rudiments, when they were matched with the gospel: what name deserue yours, ordeined not of God, as theirs, but of men?
Hart. You do us great injury to apply S. Pauls words, spoken of the Jewish ceremonies which should cease, to ours which should continue. Much more, in that you say that God ⟨p. 579⟩ordained not ours, as he did theirs. For he ordained theirs by Moses, and ours by S. Paul.
Hart. You doo vs great iniurie to apply S. Paules words, spoken of the Iewish ceremonies which should cease, to ours which should continue. Much more, in that you say that God ⟨p. 579⟩ordeined not ours, as he did theirs. For he ordeined theirs by Moses, and ours by S. Paul.
Hart. S. iAustin saith that all that order of doing which the whole Church observeth through the world in consecrating, offering, and distributing of the Eucharist (which order of doing we do call the Mass) was ordained by S. Paul.
Hart. S. iAustin saith that all that order of doing which the whole Church obserueth through the world in consecrating, offering, and distributing of the Eucharist (which order of dooing we doo call the Masse) was ordeined by S. Paul.
Rainoldes. Your kJesuit in deed maketh that note upon S. Austin. And if his meaning be thereby to prove only so much of that order, as the whole Church observed through the world in S. Austins time: then doth he disprove your ceremonies quite, yea some what more then ceremonies. For behold he mentioneth the distributing of the Eucharist, that is of the bread and cup of thanks-giving: both the which you distribute not in any Mass; in private Masses, neither. But if he meant as lBristow did, and you would have him, that S. Paul ordained all that order of doing which your Church observeth and calleth it the Mass: your Council doth disprove him. For they confess that the Church of Rome hath certain rites, mneither ordained by S. Paul, nnor observed through the whole Church. And S. Austin speaketh of nothing but that which the whole Church observed, as namely the receiving of the Sacrament fasting: which custom being kept alike of all Christians, he gathereth on S. Pauls words to the Corinthians (5 other things will I set in order when I come) that he ordained it.
Rainoldes. Your kIesuit in déede maketh that note vpon S. Austin. And if his meaning be thereby to proue onely so much of that order, as the whole Church obserued through the world in S. Austins time: then doth he disproue your ceremonies quite, yea some what more then ceremonies. For behold he mentioneth the distributing of the Eucharist, that is of the bread and cuppe of thankes-giuing: both the which you distribute not in any Masse; in priuat Masses, neither. But if he meant as lBristow did, and you would haue him, that S. Paul ordeined al that order of dooing which your Church obserueth and calleth it the Masse: your Councell doth disproue him. For they confesse that the Church of Rome hath certaine rites, mneither ordeined by S. Paul, nnor obserued through the whole Church. And S. Austin speaketh of nothing but that which the whole Church obserued, as namely the receyuing of the Sacrament fasting: which custome being kept alike of all Christians, he gathereth on S. Pauls wordes to the Corinthians (5 other thinges will I set in order when I come) that he ordeined it.
kTorrensis in confession. Augustinian, lib. 1. cap. 8. tit. 6.
Hart. It is true, S. Austin doth speak of those rites, which the whole Church observed through the world without any change or diversity of manners. But so much the more doth he prove the doctrine of the Council of Trent. For the rites, which pthey say, the Church hath received from the Apostles by tradition, are namely mystical *blessings, lights, incense, vestments, and many other such things. And for these S. Austins witness is of force that S. Paul ordained all that order of doing which we call the Mass. For the proof whereof you may see a clearer testimony of his in qan epistle to Paulinus, quoted by Torrensis, upon the same place of S. Austins confession.
Hart. It is true, S. Austin doth speake of those rites, which the whole Church obserued through the world without any change or diuersitie of maners. But so much the more doth he proue the doctrine of the Councell of Trent. For the rites, which pthey say, the Church hath receiued from the Apostles by tradition, are namely mysticall *blessinges, lightes, incense, vestiments, and many other such thinges. And for these S. Austins witnesse is of force that S. Paul ordeinedal that order of dooing which we call the Masse. For the proofe whereof you may sée a cléerer testimonie of his in qan epistle to Paulinus, quoted by Torrensis, vpon the same place of S. Austins confession.
Rainoldes. And in that also Torrensis doth […] you. For S. Austin there, writing to a Bishop who had inquired of him ⟨p. 580⟩how those words differ one from an other in S. rPaul, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, doth tell him that he thinketh thereby is understood that, which all the church, or in a manner all practiseth, to wit, that supplications are those which are made in celebrating of the sacraments before that which is upon the Lords table begin to be blessed; prayers, when it is blessed, and sanctified, and prepared to be distributed, and divided; intercessions, when the people is blessed and offered to God by their Pastors as it were by advocates; which things being done, and the sacrament received, the giving of thanks doth knit up all, which S. Paul in those words remembereth also last. Now, what is there here more for your Mass, then for our Communion? Or if our Communion, which differeth from your Mass no less then light from darkness, yet hath all these things which S. Austin toucheth as meant by S. Paul: what face hath Torrensis, who saith that S. Paul is avouched by S. Austin to have ordained all that order of doing which you call the Mass? Is this your Jesuits dealing with the ancient Fathers to make them fetch your Massing rites from the Apostles?
Rainoldes. And in that also Torrensis doth 〈…〉 you. For S. Austin there, writing to a Bishop who had inquired of him ⟨p. 580⟩how those wordes differ one from an other in S. rPaul, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giuing of thankes, doth tell him that he thinketh thereby is vnderstood that, which all the church, or in a maner all practiseth, to weete, that supplications are those which are made in celebrating of the sacramēts before that which is vpon the Lordes table beginne to bee blessed; prayers, when it is blessed, and sanctified, and prepared to be distributed, and diuided; intercessions, when the people is blessed and offered to God by their Pastours as it were by aduocates; which thinges being doon, and the sacrament receyued, the giuing of thankes doth knit vp all, which S. Paul in those wordes remmbreth also last. Now, what is there here more for your Masse, then for our Communion? Or if our Communion, which differeth from your Masse no lesse then light from darkenesse, yet hath all these thinges which S. Austin toucheth as meant by S. Paul: what face hath Torrensis, who saith that S. Paul is auouched by S. Austin to haue ordeined all that order of dooing which you call the Masse? Is this your Iesuites dealing with the auncient Fathers to make them fetch your Massing rites from the Apostles?
Hart Yet even there S. Austin doth mention blessing twice▪ and that out of S. Paul. Whereby the first point, which the Council of Trent nameth, is approved, to wit, of mystical blessings.
Hart Yet euen there S. Austin doth mention blessing twise▪ and that out of S. Paul. Whereby the first point, which the Councell of Trent nameth, is approued, to wéete, of mysticall blessinges.
Rainoldes. True, if the Council had meant by 1that word, as the scripture doth, either sthe giving of thanks unto God, or tthe sanctifying of creatures unto holy uses, or upraying for the people, that the Lord will bless them. But if they meant the making of the sign of the cross, as it is plain they did, both by the matter which that▪ chapter handleth touching visible signs, and by their intent to confirm the ceremonies which Protestants condemn, and by the Canon of the Mass which is as full of crosses as xa conjurers circle, and the word [* he blessed] is taken so there with a cross in the middest of it: then your mystical blessings of the Trent-fathers were neither meant by S. Paul, nor mentioned by S. Austin.
Rainoldes. True, if the Councell had meant by 1that worde, as the scripture doth, either sthe giuing of thankes vnto God, or tthe sanctifying of creatures vnto holy vses, or upraying for the people, that the Lord will blesse them. But if they meant the making of the signe of the crosse, as it is plaine they did, both by the matter which that▪ chapter handleth touching visible signes, and by their intent to confirme the ceremonies which Protestants condemne, and by the Canon of the Masse which is as ful of crosses as xa coniurers circle, and the worde [* he blessed] is taken so there with a crosse in the middest of it: then your mysticall blessinges of the Trent-fathers were neither meant by S. Paul, nor mentioned by S. Austin.
1Ble••ing, and to bless. Gr. [Greek or Hebrew], & [Greek or Hebrew]. Lat. benedictio, & benedicere.Ble••ing, and to blesse. Gr. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, & 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Lat. benedictio, & benedicere.
Hart. Yes: S. Austin seemeth to mean• there by [blessing] •he […] of the sign of the cross on the sacrament. For in a ••rmon of his touching the same matter, he saith that the body ⟨p. 581⟩of Christ is consecrated with the sign of the cross.
Hart. Yes: S. Austin séemeth to mean• there by [blessing] •he 〈…〉 of the signe of the crosse on the sacrament. For in a ••rmon of his touching the same matter, he saith that the body ⟨p. 581⟩of Christ is consecrated with the signe of the crosse.
euery faithfull body a temple to serue God in. The Christian worship then doth differ euen in prayers from that of the Iewes, both in respect of the temple,
the ministery of the new testament, that is, of them who taught the gospell, came after the ministerie of Priestes in the old, and yet both old and new are the Lords testament: so might and did the worship of God amongst Christians in spirit and truth come after the worship of God amongst the Iewes, though yet they both did worship God spiritually. For the Iewes before did worship in the temple with the ceremonies of the law:
vaile betweene the quire and the altar in lent, resembleth
tOr monstraus, as D. Allen callenth it, De Eucharist. Sacram. cap. 30. It is a vessel, like a cage, having ••des of glass or crystal, that through them the consecrated cake set up therein, may be showed to men.Or monstraus, as D. Allen callēth it, De Eucharist. Sacram. cap. 30. It is a vessel, like a cage, hauing ••des of glasse or crystall, that through them the consecrated cake set vp therein, may be shewed to men.
mDurand. l. 2. c. 7 & l. 4. c. 6. & l. 6. c. 72.73.80.89. &c. […] eccles. l. 1. tit. 2.Durand. l. 2. c. 7 & l. 4. c. 6. & l. 6. c. 72.73.80.89. &c. 〈…〉 eccles. l. 1. tit. 2.
nChiefly on Candlemas-day, and •enebre-wednesday. Durand. l. 6. c. 72. & l. 7. c. 7.Chiefely on Candlemas-day, and •enebre-wensday. Durand. l. 6. c. 72. & l. 7. c. 7.
reconciling of a churchyard, or other sacred place, if it be polluted. In conclusion, to passe ouer your
so doo you require it, and what should you haue fyer vpon your altar as they had, vnlesse you burne as they did? but your dayly sacrifice of the Masse is celebrated in such Leuitical sort, as if you contended to set forth a Iewish worship more liuely then the Leuiticall Priests could. In attire like them, in mysteries aboue them, in
their trumpets: in washing often, in blessing and crossing, in censing often, in soft spéech and whispering, in kissing of the amice, kissing of the fanel, kissing of the stole, kissing of the altar, kissing of the booke, kissing of the Priests hand, and kissing of the pax: in smiting and knocking, in gesturing by rule and measure, in bowing and ducking, in spacing forward, backward, and turning round about, and trauersing of the ground: beside the swéete musicke of