Linc. Then after he came to Cyrillus, which (as he said) made against M. Ridley in the Sacrament,1 even by Philippe Melanchthon his own alleging in his common places, and forthwith called for Melanchthon, but in vain, because all such books were burned a little before, wherefore he passed it over.
Cyrillus also in an other place pro•ing to the Jews ⟨p. 1765⟩that Christ was come, useth this reason, *Altars are erected in Christs name in Britain and in far countries: Ergo, Christ is come. But we may use the contrary, of that reason: Altars are plucked down in Britain: Ergo, Christ is not come. A good Argument á contrarijs: I will stand to it in the Schools by and by with any man. Ye see what a good argument this your doctrine maketh for the Jews, to prove that Christ is not come.*
D. Ridley smiling, answered: your Lordship is not ignorant that this word Altar in the Scripture signifieth aswell the Altar whereupon the Jews were wont to make their burnt Sacrifices, as the table of the Lords Supper. Cyrillus meaneth there by this word Altar, not that the Jewish Altar, but the Table of the Lord, and by that saying (Altars are erected in Christs name, Ergo Christ is come) he meaneth that the Communion is ministered in his remembrance, Ergo Christ is come: for the strength of his argument is, because the remembrance of a thing can not be, except the thing it self be past: then could not all Countries celebrate the Communion in the remembrance of Christs passion, except Christ had been come and suffered. As for the taking down of the Alters, it was done upon just considerations, for that they seemed to come to nigh to the Jews usage. Neither was the supper of the Lord at any time more better ministered, more duly received, then in these latter days when all things were brought to the rites and usage of the primitive Church.
Linc. Then after he came to Cyrillus, which (as he said) made agaynst M. Ridley in the Sacrament,1 euen by Philippe Melancthon his owne alledging in his common places, and forthwith called for Melancthon, but in vaine, because all such bookes were burned a litle before, wherefore he passed it ouer.
Cyrillus also in an other place pro•ing to the Iewes ⟨p. 1765⟩that Christe was come, vseth this reason, *Altars are erected in Christes name in Britaine and in farre countreyes: Ergo, Christ is come. But we may vse the contrarye, of that reason: Altars are plucked downe in Britaine: Ergo, Christe is not come. A good Argument á contrarijs: I wyll stande to it in the Scholes by and by with any man. Ye see what a good argument this your docrine maketh for the Iewes, to proue that Christ is not come.*
D. Ridley smilyng, aunsweared: your Lordshyp is not ignoraunt that this worde Altare in the Scripture signifieth aswell the Altar whereupon the Iewes were wont to make their burt Sacrifices, as the table of the Lordes Supper. Cyrillus meaneth there by this worde Altare, not that the Iewysh Altar, but the Table of the Lorde, and by that saying (Altars are erected in Christes name, Ergo Christ is come) he meaneth that the Communion is ministred in his remembraunce, Ergo Christe is come: for the strength of his argument is, because the remembraunce of a thyng can not be, except the thing it selfe be past: then coulde not all Countreys celebrate the Communion in the remembraunce of Christes passion, except Christe had bene come and suffered. As for the taking downe of the Alters, it was done vpon iust considerations, for that they seemed to come to nigh to ye Iewes vsage. Neither was the supper of the Lorde at any tyme more better ministred, more duely receiued, then in these latter dayes when all thynges were brought to the rites and vsage of the primatiue Church.
- 1A place of Cyrillus alleged by Melanchthon. Scripture books burned at Oxford.A place of Cyrillus alledged by Melancthon. Scripture bookes burned at Oxford.
- *Argumentum á contrario sensu ex Cyrillo contra Judaeo.Argumentum á contrario sensu ex Cyrillo contra •udaeo•.
- *Altars be erected in Christs remembrance in Britain. Ergo Christ is come. Altars be now plucked down in Britain: Ergo, Christ i• not come. Answer. This argument is not a sensu contrario. For erecting of altars in the Antecedent▪ and plucking down altars in the consequent, be not contrary. In the Antecedent, Cyril meaneth the table, or else the celebration of the Lords Supper in his remembrance. In the consequent by plucking down of altars▪ is meant the taking away of places and monuments, serving not to the Lords Supper, but to Idolatry, whereby the true table of the Lords Supper in his remembrance may be erected again.Altars be erected in Christes remembrance in Britayne. Ergo Christ is come. Altars be now plucked downe in Britayne: Ergo, Christ i• not come. Aunswere. This argument is not a sensu contrario. For erecting of altars in the Antecedent▪ and plucking downe altars in the consequent, be not contrary. In the Antecedent, Cyril meaneth the table, or els the celebration of the Lordes Supper in his remembrance. In the consequent by plucking downe of altars▪ is ment the taking away of places and monumentes, seruing not to the Lordes Supper, but to Idolatry, whereby the true table of the Lordes Supper in his remēbrance may be erected agayne.