A JUST DEFENCE OF THE FORMER DISCOURSE AND ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE ANSWER OF A NAMELESS Popish Priest thereunto:A IVST DEFENCE OF THE FORMER DISCOVRSE AND ARGVMENTS AGAINST THE ANSWER OF A NAMELES Popish Priest thereunto:
pp. 35–233513 passagespart 7 of 13
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But how doth this follow; The Apostle doth so there: therefore our Saviour doth so here? especially considering how divers the scope of either in either place is. The Apostles scope is to show that tthe old Israelites had as good and as sure outward pledges of Gods favour and love as we Christians now have; and yet “were not spared when they provoked him to wrath, for all that. Our Saviours scope is to prove that the spiritual food of his flesh, which uhe there tendered them and advised them to seek after, was much more excellent and of far greater virtue and efficacy, then the Manna that their Fathers did once eat in the Wilderness. For, that xthat (considered as corporal food) was it self corruptible, and could not ypreserve them that eat of it from death, whereas this was zfood incorruptible, and being spiritually fed on would cause them
to live for ever. For the Apostles purpose therefore it was necessary to consider the Manna as a Sacrament and to compare the Eucharist with it, as with our Baptism he had paralleled the Red Sea before. But for our Saviour so to do there was no necessity at all: Nor indeed doth he consider the Manna there as a Sacrament, no more then the Jews did, that there mentioned it to him; nor doth he speak cught of the Sacrament where he speaketh of the Manna, as
Jansenius observeth) so much troubled Augustine, and Caietan, yea and Jansenius himself too. Nor was there any necessity that the bread of the Eucharist should be more mentioned in the one place, then the drink of it in the other.
But how doth this follow; The Apostle doth so there: therefore our Sauiour doth so heere? especially considering how diuers the scope of either in either place is. The Apostles scope is to shew that tthe old Israelites had as good and as sure outward pledges of Gods fauour and loue as wee Christians now haue; and yet “were not spared when they prouoked him to wrath, for all that. Our Sauiours scope is to prooue that the spirituall food of his flesh, which uhe there tendred them and aduised them to seeke after, was much more excellent and of farre greater vertue and efficacie, then the Manna that their Fathers did once eate in the Wildernesse. For, that xthat (considered as corporall food) was it selfe corruptible, and could not ypreserue them that eate of it from death, whereas this was zfood incorruptible, and being spiritually fed on would cause them ato liue for euer. For the Apostles purpose therefore it was necessary to consider the Manna as a Sacrament and to compare the Eucharist with it, as with our Baptisme hee had paralleled the Red Sea before. But for our Sauiour so to do there was no necessity at all: Nor indeed doth he consider the Manna there as a Sacrament, no more then the Iewes did, that there mentioned it to him; nor doth hee speake cught of the Sacrament where hee speaketh of the Manna, as bBellarmine also himselfe acknowledgeth. His speech to them occasioned by the cbread that they had eaten of, and dthe Manna that they spake of, is the very like to that other speech of his to the Samaritane woman, occasioned by ethe water that hee had asked of her; fHe that drinketh of this water shall thirst againe; but he that drinketh of the ⟨p. 123⟩water that I shall giue him, shall neuer thirst more, &c. Which had it been considered, would easily haue assoyled those difficulties, that (as gIansenius obserueth) so much troubled Augustine, and Caietan, yea and Iansenius himselfe too. Nor was there any necessity that the bread of the Eucharist should bee more mentioned in the one place, then the drinke of it in the other.
2. Because hChrists body, as by faith it is received, was not wanting to those of old time, that lived before Christs Incarnation.
2. Because hChrists bodie, as by faith it is receiued, was not wanting to those of old time, that liued before Christs Incarnation.
hQuia corpus Domini ut sumitur sola fide, non defuit veteribus. Bellar. ibid.Quia corpus Domini vt sumitur sola fide, non defuit veteribus. Bellar. ibid.
What he giveth us here we take, that Christs body was by faith received even before he was incarnate. But how proveth this that Christ therefore spake there of a sacramental eating of it? and not rather that he called home those his carnal followers, from the corporal feeding, either on ithe bread that they had eaten of, or the kManna that they mentioned, and lwould fain still have been fed with, that they might live without labour, not to an eating of sacramental bread, which they would not have much misliked, but to that tspiritual feeding, uwhich as well their holy forefathers, as all true and faithful Christians now, were eternally saved by. Yea this may be confirmed by Bellarmines own grants: Who first confesseth this as xa certain truth, that there is no mention at all of the Eucharist in all that our Saviours discourse, before those words, (which were spoken after he had done yspeaking of the Manna) zThe bread that I will give is my flesh, that I will give for the life of the world. 2. He granteth expressly that those words, aI am the brad of life; he that cometh to me shall not hunger, &c. do bnot properly belong to the Sacrament. 3. He observeth ca three fold bread spoken of by our Saviour: the first, that dmaterial bread, ethat Christ had fed them withal: the second fspiritual bread, ghimself incarnate, hwhich he ⟨p. 124⟩wisheth them to get, and must iby faith be apprehended, that it may feed and refresh •s: the third (he might well have said kM•nna, which he omitteth, termed also lbread there, but) mthe sacramental bread (saith he) expressed in those words. nthe bread that I will give, is my fl•sh that I will give for the life of the world: as if this were not the same spiritual bread that he spake of before. 4. Being pressed with this that there is no bread at all in the Eucharist 22(as they say) k & therefore it cannot be the sacramental bread that is there spoken of, neither can it be meant of the bread that Christ was to give in the Supper, as he elsewhere had said: he saith that pbread there signifieth not wheaten bread, qnor Christs body absolutely, but rmeat or food in general: and so the sense of it is this; The bread, that is, the meat, that I will give, is my flesh it self, that is to be crucified and stain for the salvation of mankind.
What hee giueth vs heere wee take, that Christs body was by faith receiued euen before hee was incarnate. But how prooueth this that Christ therefore spake there of a sacramentall eating of it? and not rather that he called home those his carnall followers, from the corporall feeding, either on ithe bread that they had eaten of, or the kManna that they mentioned, and lwould faine still haue been fed with, that they might liue without labour, not to an eating of sacramentall bread, which they would not haue much misliked, but to that tspirituall feeding, uwhich as well their holy forefathers, as all true and faithfull Christians now, were eternally saued by. Yea this may be confirmed by Bellarmines owne grants: Who first confesseth this as xa certaine truth, that there is no mention at all of the Eucharist in all that our Sauiours discourse, before those wordes, (which were spoken after hee had done yspeaking of the Manna) zThe bread that I will giue is my flesh, that I will giue for the life of the world. 2. Hee granteth expresly that those wordes, aI am the brad of life; hee that commeth to me shall not hunger, &c. doe bnot properly belong to the Sacrament. 3. He obserueth ca three fold bread spoken of by our Sauiour: the first, that dmateriall bread, ethat Christ had fed them withall: the second f
xConstat in magna parte capitis de Eucharistia non agi. Solū quaestio est de illis verbis, Panis quem ego dabo, &c. & sequentibus Bellarm, de Euchar. l. 1. c. 5.Constat in magna parte capitis de Eucharistia non agi. Solū quaestio est de illis verbis, Panis quem ego dabo, &c. & sequentibus Bellarm, de Euchar. l. 1. c. 5.
And he addeth that speradventure our Saviour called his flesh sometimes bread, to show that under the species of bread it was to be eaten. So that all the force of Bellarmines Argument is but merely conjectural, and dependeth upon a peradventure, which he cannot certainly aver. But 2without all peradventure he affirmed before that the bread of which our Saviour said; uMy Father giveth you the true bread from heaven; and xThe bread of God is he that came from heaven and giveth life to the world: and yI am the bread of life; he that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth in me shall never thirst: and zI am the bread that came down from heaven: and again, aI am the bread of life: and bThis is the bread that came down from heaven, that whosoever eateth thereof should never die: and cI am the living bread that came down from heaven: if any man eat of this bread he shall live for ever: that the bread I say, of which he said all this, was not the Eucharist, or the sacramental bread, and none of all this directly and properly concerneth it. And well may we put it out of peradventure, that the bread of which our Saviour saith dit is his flesh that he will give for the life of the ⟨p. 125⟩world, and ewhosoever eateth of it, hath life everlasting; fwhich no man also can have without it; is no other then that of which he had before said, that git is himself, and that hit giveth life to the world, and ilife everlasting to every one that eateth of it: the rather also for that our Saviour himself so informeth us when he saith, (not kpassing as Bellarmine would have it from a second bread to a third, but more particularly expressing what the second bread was, and repeating more fully what before he had said) mI am the living bread that came down from heaven: 18if any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever: nand the bread that I will give (what bread, think we, but the same that he was even then speaking of? which yet was onone of the sacramental bread, saith Bellarmine) is my flesh that I will give for the life of the world. Those ensuing passages therefore are not meant of the sacramental bread or the Eucharist, no more then the former. But leave we Bellarmine, and return we to this our Defendant, whom we are principally now to deal with.
And he addeth that speraduenture our Sauiour called his flesh sometimes bread, to shew that vnder the species of bread it was to be eaten. So that all the force of Bellarmines Argument is but meerely coniecturall, and dependeth vpon a peraduenture, which hee cannot certainely auerre. But 2without all peraduenture hee affirmed before that the bread of which our Sauiour said; uMy Father giueth you the true bread from heauen; and xThe bread of God is hee that came from heauen and giueth life to the world: and yI am the bread of life; hee that commeth to mee shall neuer hunger; and hee that beleeueth in mee shall neuer thirst: and zI am the bread that came downe from heauen: and againe, aI am the bread of life: and bThis is the bread that came downe from heauen, that whosoeuer eateth thereof should neuer die: and cI am the liuing bread that came downe from heauen: if any man eate of this bread hee shall liue for euer: that the bread I say, of which hee said all this, was not the Encharist, or the sacramentall bread, and none of all this directly and properly concerneth it. And well may wee put it out of peraduenture, that the bread of which our Sauiour saith dit is his flesh that he wil giue for the life of the ⟨p. 125⟩world, and ewhosoeuer eateth of it, hath life euerlasting; fwhich no man also can haue without it; is no other then that of which hee had before said, that
sPan•s, i. cibus, &c. Ibid.
2t Fortasse ideò carnem suam aliquoties panem appellavit, &c. Ibid.t Fortasse ideò carnem suam aliquoties panem appellauit, &c. Ibid.
His last Argument out of Tolet is not so much for the Eucharist, as against the spiritual eating Christs flesh and drinking his blood by faith. If our Saviour had meant nothing but that they should believe in him, it had been a strange course by such an obscure manner of speaking pto drive away so many that had formerly followed him and believed in him, without any word added that might open this dark doctrine.
His last Argument out of Tolet is not so much for the Eucharist, as against the spirituall eating Christs flesh and drinking his blood by faith. If our Sauiour had meant nothing but that they should beleeue in him, it had been a strange course by such an obscure manner of speaking pto driue away so many that had formerly followed him and beleeued in him, without any word added that might open this darke doctrine.
To omit that here again he departeth from Augustine, who qsaith thus expressly; Our Lord being about to give the holy Ghost called himself bread exhorting us to believe in him. rFor to believe in him is to eat that living bread. He that believeth in him feedeth on him, she is fatted invisibly, because he is invisibly bred again: he is there filled, where he is renewed. And again, tThey that shed Christs blood, drank his blood when they believed in him; and uthey drank it by believing in him.
To omit that here againe he departeth from Augustine, who qsaith thus expresly; Our Lord being about to giue the holy Ghost called himself bread exhorting vs tobeleeue in him. rFor to beleeue in him is to eate that liuing bread. He that beleeueth in him feedeth on him, she is fatted inuisibly, because he is inuisibly bred againe: he is there filled, where he is renewed. And again, tThey that shed Christs blood, drank his blood whē they beleeued in him; and uthey drank it by beleeuing in him.
qAug. in Joa. tract. 26.Aug. in Ioa. tract. 26.
rCredere in eum, hoc est manducare panem vivum.Credere in eum, hoc est manducare panem viuum.
sQui credit in eum, manducat. In•sibiliter far, quin invisibiliter renascitur: juf us novus in•us est: ubi novell•r, ibi satiatur.Qui credit in eum, manducat. In•sibiliter sa•r, quin invisibiliter renascitur: iuf us nouus in•us est: vbi novell•r, ibi satiatur.
tSang• em fuderunt cum saevire•t, biberunt cum crederent. Aug […] Joan. tr. 1. Saevieutes •ude•u•t, credentes biberunt. de temp. 74. & de verb. Dom. 59.Sang• em fuderunt cum saeuire•t, biberunt cum crederent. Aug 〈…〉 Ioan. tr. 1. Saeuieutes •ude•u•t, credentes biberunt. de temp. 74. & de verb. Dom. 59.
uC•edendo biberunt, quem saeviendo fuderunt. Idem. in Joan. tr. 8.C•edendo biberunt, quem saeuiendo fuderunt. Idem. in Ioan. tr. 8.
1. It pleased our Saviour sometime, as to xNicodemus, and to ythe people oft-times, to speak things in obscure Parables, which yet to them he did not explicate. “Nor may any tax the wisdom of Christ without impiety for so doing. Yea *so (saith Augustine) he spake that here which he would not have all to understand.
1. It pleased our Sauiour sometime, as to xNicodemus, and to ythe people oft-times, to speake things in obscure Parables, which yet to them he did not explicate. “Nor may any taxe the wisedome of Christ without impiety for so doing. Yea *so (saith Augustine) he spake that here which he would not haue all to vnderstand.
“See Chrys. on Joan. hom. 46.See Chrys. on Ioan. hom. 46.
*Sic oportebat ut diceretur, quod non ab omnibus intelligeretur. Aug. in Joan. tr. 27.Sic oportebat vt diceretur, quod non ab omnibus intelligeretur. Aug. in Ioan. tr. 27.
3. If his meaning had been that they were to eat of his very flesh it self miraculously made of bread, as these men would make us believe, had it not been as obscure and as difficult for them to have conceived it?
3. If his meaning had beene that they were to eate of his very flesh it selfe miraculously made of bread, as these men would make vs beleeue, had it not beene as obscure and as difficult for them to haue conceiued it?
4. It is not true that our Saviour added nothing to explicate himself. Augustine in the place before cited *showeth that he did. And both in the beginning, when ahe first told them of this bread: and d they desired him ever to give them of it; he maketh them answer in these words; cI am the bread of life: He that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth in me shall never thirst: and in the process of his speech again, dVerily, verily, I say unto you, He that believeth in me, hath life everlasting: Whereby esaith Jansenius, they might well have understood, in what manner he would give them his flesh to eat. Who also thence gathereth (agreeably to Augustine and other of the Ancients) that *it is all one to feed on Christ, and to believe in him: As also in the Conclusion and shutting up of all, when he saw how they mistook him: “It is the spirit that quickeneth, the flesh availeth nothing: the words that I speak are spirit and life. In which words saith fthe same Jansenius (out of Chrysostom, Theophylact, and 9Augustine) he showeth how they should understand what before he had said.
4. It is not true that our Sauiour added nothing to explicate himselfe. Augustine in the place before cited *sheweth that he did. And both in the beginning, when ahee first told them of this bread: and d they desired him euer to giue them of it; he maketh them answer in these words; cI am the bread of life: Hee that commeth to me shall neuer hunger; and he that beleeueth in me shall neuer thirst: and in the processe of his speech againe, dUerely, verely, I say vnto you, Hee that beleeueth in mee, hath life euerlasting: Whereby esaith Iansenius, they might well haue vnderstood, in what manner hee would giue them his flesh to eate. Who also thence gathereth (agreeably to Augustine and other of the Ancients) that *it is all one to feed on Christ, and to beleeue in him: As also in the Conclusion and shutting vp of all, when hee saw how they mistooke him: “It is the spirit that quickneth, the flesh availeth nothing: the wordes that I speake are spirit and life. In which wordes saith fthe same Iansenius (out of Chrysostome, Theophylact, and 9Augustine) hee sheweth how they should vnderstand what before he had said.
*Exponit quomodo id fiat quod loquitut; & quid sit manducare corpus cius & sanguinem bibere. Aug. in Joan. tr. 26. Citante etiam Biele in Can. Ject. 36. Bede in 1 Cor. 11. & Fulbert. in excerpt. Exposuit modū attributionis & deny sui. Aug. ibid. 27.Exponit quomodo id fiat quod loquitut; & quid sit manducare corpus cius & sanguinem bibere. Aug. in Ioan. tr. 26. Citante etiam Biele in Can. Iect. 36. Beda in 1 Cor. 11. & Fulbert. in excerpt. Exposuit modū attributionis & doni sui. Aug. ibid. 27.
*Idem esse manducare se, & credere in se. Et Biel. Idem est in Christum credere, & in Christum ite: & qui credit in Christum, incorporatur Christo; & per hoc manducat Christum.
MY Adversaries Arguments to the contrary are merely 1topical, and prove nothing. For first it is false, that the faithful Jews before Christ did sacramentally receive our Saviour as well as we: which he barely affirmeth and proveth not, page 7.
MY Aduersaries Arguments to the contrary are meerely 1topicall, and prooue nothing. For first it is false, that the faithfull Iewes before Christ did sacramentally receiue our Sauiour as well as we: which hee barely affirmeth and prooueth not, page 7.
Secondly, those words of Christ, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you shall not have life in you; was a precept respectively given and only obliging such persons to an actual receiving of the Sacrament as they were to whom it was uttered; such persons (to wit) as are by age capable of Sacramental manducation. And surely if Christs words be only understood, as my Adversary would have them, of spiritual eating Christ by faith, they must necessarily import a precept more impossible to be fulfilled by children then sacramentally to receive him. For sooner may children receive the Sacrament, especially drink of the consecrated Chalice (as anciently in the Greek and Latin Churches they were went to do) then actually believe in him.
Secondly, those words of Christ, Except yee eate the flesh of the Sonne of Man and drinke his blood, you shall not haue life in you; was a precept respectiuely giuen and onely obliging such persons to an actuall receiuing of the Sacrament as they were to whom it was vttred; such persons (to wit) as are by age capable of Sacramentall manducation. And surely if Christs words be onely vnderstood, as my Aduersarie would haue them, of spirituall eating Christ by faith, they must necessarily import a precept more impossible to be fulfilled by children then sacramentally to receiue him. For sooner may children receiue the Sacrament, especially drinke of the consecrated Chalice (as anciently in the Greeke and Latine Churches they were went to doe) then actually beleeue in him.
His next Argument pag. 8. maketh more (if this Minister had wit to discern the force thereof) against his own exposition of Christs words, then it doth against our understanding of them. For as all that receive Sacramentally Christs flesh and blood, are not saved; no more are all that spiritually and by faith eat him. This being sufficient for the verity of our Saviours speeches that the Sacrament is ordained to produce those excellent and heavenly effects which Christs promises there import in the souls of such as worthily receive it; and such contrarily as come unworthily thereunto receive death and judgement to themselves by it.
His next Argument pag. 8. maketh more (if this Minister had wit to discerne the force thereof) against his owne exposition of Christs words, then it doth against our vnderstanding of them. For as all that receiue Sacramentally Christs flesh and blood, are not saued; no more are all that spiritually and by faith eate him. This being sufficient for the veritie of our Sauiours speeches that the Sacrament is ordained to produce those excellent and heauenly effects which Christs promises there import in the soules of such as worthily receiue it; and such centrarily as come vnworthily thereunto receiue death and iudgement to themselues by it.
As for those few Catholic writers who have denied Christs words in that 6. Chap. of Saint John to have been understood at all of Sacramental manducation; I answer, that their number is not great, and their authority of no weight at all against a numberless multitude of ancient Fathers and modern Doctors of better note contrarily understanding them; yielding better reasons for that their literal ⟨p. 128⟩true explication, and easily solving all heretical Objections gathered from the literal sense of our Saviours words in that Chapter against our communion under one kind and other points of Catholic doctrine. And sithence my Adversary will not stick to contemn these very Authors in their other known Catholic doctrines, why doth he so highly value and mainly urge them in this opinion, wherein without any heretical intention or obstinacy of Judgement they differ from us?
As for those few Catholike writers who haue denied Christs words in that 6. Chap. of Saint Iohn to haue beene vnderstood at all of Sacramentall manducation; I answer, that their number is not great, and their authoritie of no weight at all against a numberlesse multitude of ancient Fathers and moderne Doctors of better note contrarily vnderstanding them; yeelding better reasons for that their literall ⟨p. 128⟩true explication, and easily soluing all hereticall Obiections gathered from the literall sense of our Sauiours words in that Chapter against our communion vnder one kinde and other points of Catholike doctrine. And sithence my Aduersaerie will not sticke to contemne these very Authors in their other knowne Catholike doctrines, why doth he so highly value and mainely vrge them in this opinion, wherein without any hereticall intention or obstinacie of Iudgement they differ from vs?
None are saved but such as so feed on Christ, as is there spoken of. But many are saved that never fed on Christ in the Eucharist; as the Fathers before Christ; the children of the faithful that die infants, &c. Ergò it is not spoken of the Eucharist.
None are saued but such as so feede on Christ, as is there spoken of. But many are saued that neuer fed on Christ in the Eucharist; as the Fathers before Christ; the children of the faithfull that die infants, &c. Ergò it is not spoken of the Eucharist.
1. That I barely affirm that the Jews before Christ did sacramentally receive Christ as well as we, but I prove it not. It is true; I say obiter that they fed on Christs flesh spiritually as well as we now do: though that be no part of mine Argument. And I add a place or two of Augustine for the proof of it grounded on the Apostles words, 1. Cor. 10. 3, 4. Which seeing that this shifter overslippeth, let him hear Bishop Jansenius himself (not to go any further) relate a little more at large, to wit, that gthe good Jews in the old Testament were quickened by eating of Manna, because under that visible food they also spiritually did eat the true Bread of Life by Manna signified. Or if Jansenius will not serve, let him hear their great Albert; hThere is (saith he) a three-fold eating of Christ; ⟨p. 129⟩sacramentally only, spiritually only, or sacramentally and spiritually both. In the first sort *all that ever were saved did eat: in the second sort evil Christians eat him in the Sacrament: in the third sort, good communicants only. And again, alleging those words of the Apostle; iAll those good Ancients in the Manna understood believed and tasted Christ himself, and were thereby saved. And this no Papist (I suppose) will be so absurd as to deny. But this is but a by-matter, no part of the main Argument; and therefore I forbear here to insist further on it.
1. That I barely affirme that the Iewes before Christ did sacramentally receiue Christ as well as we, but I prooue it not. It is true; I say obiter that they fed on Christs flesh spiritually as well as we now doe: though that be no part of mine Argument. And I adde a place or two of Augustine for the proofe of it grounded on the Apostles words, 1. Cor. 10. 3, 4. Which seeing that this shifter ouerslippeth, let him heare Bishop Iansenius himselfe (not to goe any further) relate a little more at large, to wit, that gthe good Iewes in the old Testament were quickned by eating of Manna, because vnder that visible foode they also spiritually did eate the true Bread of Life by Manna signified. Or if Iansenius will not serue, let him heare their great Albert; hThere is (saith he) a three-fold eating of Christ; ⟨p. 129⟩sacramentally onely, spiritually onely, or sacramentally and spiritually both. In the first sort *all that euer were saued did eate: in the second sort euill Christians eate him in the Sacrament: in the third sort, good communicants onely. And againe, alleadging those words of the Apostle; iAll those good Auncients in the Manna vnderstood beleeued and tasted Christ himselfe, and were thereby saued. And this no Papist (I suppose) will be so absurd as to deny. But this is but a by-matter, no part of the maine Argument; and therefore I forbeare here to insist further on it.
gJansen. ibid. Boni manna manducando vivificati sunt: eo quod sub visibi•• illo cibo etiam spiritualiter manducaverunt velum panem vitae per manna significa•um quem & nos ede•do vivificamur.Iansen. ibid. Boni manna manducando viuificati sunt: eo quod sub visibi•• illo cibo etiam spiritualiter manducauerunt ve•um panem vitae per manna significa•um quem & nos ede•do viuificamur.
hAlbert. Magn. de Sacram. Euchar. serm, 17 Modus manducationis triplex, Sacramentalis tantûm, spiritualis tantùm, sacramentalis & spiritualis simul.
*Omnes saluandi ab origine mundi.
iIdem ibid. se•m. 18 omnes •oni veteres in Manna cibum inuisibile. n. s•. Christum spiritu•ter in•exerunt, crediderunt, gustaverunt, &c.Idem ibid. se•m. 18 omnes •oni veteres in Manna cibum inuisibile. n. s•. Christum spiritu•ter in•exerunt, crediderunt, gustauerunt, &c.
1. Many young ones die, though at years of discretion, when in ordinary course they may well have faith, and believe actually, yet ere they be admitted to the Eucharist: and yet is not their salvation at all thereby prejudiced.
1. Many yong ones die, though at yeeres of discretion, when in ordinary course they may well haue faith, and beleeue actually, yet ere they be admitted to the Eucharist: and yet is not their saluation at all thereby preindiced.
2. By the doctrine of their Church even kInfants have an habit of faith infused into them in Baptism.
2. By the doctrine of their Church euen kInfants haue an habite of faith infused into them in Baptisme.
kB•llarm. de Bapt. l. 1. c. 11. ex Concil. Tr•dent. sess. 7. can. 13. Et Biel. in Can Miss lect 36. De pueris eti•m quod spiritualiter manducant corpus Christi in susceptione baptismatis, patet de consecr. dist. 2. Quia passus
3. Neither is it a thing impossible for the Spirit of God by an extraordinary manner to work faith in such infants as are to be saved dying before years of discretion; no more then it was to regenerate John Baptist lin his mothers womb: of whom Gregory therefore saith that he was mnew bred yet unborn.
3. Neither is it a thing impossible for the Spirit of God by an extraordinary manner to worke faith in such infants as are to be saued dying before yeeres of discretion; no more then it was to regenerate Iohn Baptist lin his mothers wombe: of whom Gregorie therefore saith that he was mnew bred yet vnborne.
4. The speech is of the same latitude and extent at least with those other; nwhosoever believeth in me, hath life eternal: And, oWhosoever believeth not in the Son of God. shall never plive, but qshall be damned: and the like; which comprehend those only, to whom it appertaineth actually ⟨p. 130⟩to come unto Christ, and to believe in him, rsaith Jansenius. And that is enough for my purpose.
4. The speech is of the same latitude and extent at least with those other; nwhosoeuer beleeueth in me, hath life eternall: And, oWhosoeuer beleeueth not in the Sonne of God. shall neuer pliue, but qshall be damned: and the like; which comprehend those onely, to whom it appertaineth actually ⟨p. 130⟩to come vnto Christ, and to beleeue in him, rsaith Iansenius. And that is enough for my purpose.
Now this Argument (saith he) if I had wit to discern the force of it, maketh more against us then against them. And why so? Forsooth, because all are not saved that spiritually and by faith feed on Christ. This is like B•llarmines bold assertion, that tsome that believe in Christ perish eternally, because they die before they can have a Priest to assoil them. And what is this but to say that all that do truly believe in Christ are not saved? Yea what is this (not to repeat all the allegations both of Scripture and Fathers produced for the proof of the Proposition, which he purposely passeth over, not being able to answer) but to give our Saviour himself and the holy Ghost the lye, who so oft say; uWhosoever believeth in him shall be saved.
Now this Argument (saith he) if I had wit to discerne the force of it, maketh more against vs then against them. And why so? Forsooth, because all are not saued that spiritually and by faith feede on Christ. This is like B•llarmines bold assertion, that tsome that beleeue in Christ perish eternally, because they die before they can haue a Priest to assoile them. And what is this but to say that all that doe truly beleeue in Christ are not saued? Yea what is this (not to repeate all the allegations both of Scripture and Fathers produced for the proofe of the Proposition, which he purposely passeth ouer, not being able to answere) but to giue our Sauiour himselfe and the holy Ghost the lye, who so oft say; uWhosoeuer beleeueth in him shall be saued.
tAliquos credentes in Christum in aeternum perire, quod ante moriantur, quam à Sacerdote absolui potuerint. Bellarm. de poenit. l 3. c. 2.
Nor is it sufficient (as he addeth) for to verify our Saviours speeches that the Sacrament is ordained to produce such effects in the Souls of such as worthily receive it, though the contrary befall those that do unworthily receive it. For (to answer them again in the words of one of their own Authors) our Saviours words imply manifestly xa certain effect (as he speaketh) not a matter that may be: (as Augustine and Cyril also in the places cited by me there show,) whereupon also he concludeth that yit is apparent thence that all are not there said to eat the flesh of Christ and drink his blood, that receive the Sacraments of Christs body and blood.
Nor is it sufficient (as he addeth) for to verifie our Sauiours speeches that the Sacrament is ordained to produce such effects in the Soules of such as worthily receiue it, though the contrary befall those that doe vnworthily rēceiue it. For (to answer them againe in the words of one of their owne Authors) our Sauiours words imply manifestly xa certaine effect (as he speaketh) not a matter that may be: (as Augustine and Cyril also in the places cited by me there shew,) whereupon also he concludeth that yit is apparent thence that all are not there said to eate the flesh of Christ and drinke his blood, that receiue the Sacraments of Christs body and blood.
xManducationis & potus certum effectum. Jansen. concord. c. 59.Manducationis & potus certum effectum. Iansen. concord. c. 59.
yHinc manife stum evadit, non omnes. &c. Idem ibid.Hinc manife stum euadit, non omnes. &c. Idem ibid.
§ 8. To their own Authors, Cardinals, Schoolmen, Canonists, public Professors, or Readers of Divinity in their Universities, (a Friars I might have said too,) and in steed ⟨p. 131⟩of Jesuits (being better informed by him) I now say, Bishops, which will not much mend the matter.
§ 8. To their owne Authors, Cardinals, Schoelemen, Canonists, publike Professors, or Readers of Diuinity in their Vniuersities, (a Friers I might haue said too,) and in steed ⟨p. 131⟩of Iesuites (being better informed by him) I now say, Bishops, which will not much mend the matter.
aFeius in Joan. 6. & Mathias Doring in replic. super. Lyr. in Psal. 110.Feius in Ioan. 6. & Mathias Doring in replic. super. Lyr. in Psal. 110.
1. He answereth that they be but few in number, and their authority of no great weight, in regard of those that hold the contrary. Yet one of their own Bishops (though of an other mind himself) confesseth, that there are bvery many of them that are of this judgement. But had there been but one or two of them (especially of note, as some of them were) of some one sort, it might well have weighed much on our side. For cthe witness of an adversary is of no small weight. How much more, when so many of all sorts, of so special repute, shall so uniformly speak for us, and herein accord with us?
1. Hee answereth that they bee but few in number, and their authoritie of no great weight, in regard of those that hold the contrarie. Yet one of their owne Bishops (though of an other mind himselfe) confesseth, that there are bvery many of them that are of this iudgement. But had there beene but one or two of them (especially of note, as some of them were) of some one sort, it might well haue weighed much on our side. For cthe witnesse of an aduersarie is of no small weight. How much more, when so many of all sorts, of so speciall repute, shall so vniformely speake for vs, and herein accord with vs?
bEx ipsis Catholicis perm•lti •unt, qui totum is•um sermonem ad spiritualem manducationem referunt: Sebastian Oxoniens. Epi•c. ad part. 3. Thom. q. 76. nu. 28.
c[Greek or Hebrew]. Isidor. Pesus. ep. 228. l. 2.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Isidor. Pesus. ep. 228. l. 2.
2. He demandeth of his Adversary, why he doth so highly value them and mainly urge them herein, when in other points he will not stick to contemn them. Had he any wit in his addle brain, he would never have asked this idle Question It is as if in a Law-suite, because a man taketh hold (as he may well do) of somewhat that falleth from his Adversaries, or is granted him and confessed by them, because it furthereth his own cause, he were therefore bound to believe or admit all that ever they say to the prejudice of his right. The greater differences are between them and us, yea in the present controversy concerning the manner of Christs presence in the Sacrament, the less cause there is to suspect that they should speak partially for us; and the greater cause to suppose they were by evidence of truth enforced to confess that, that should take away some of those grounds, whereby the cause that themselves stiffly maintained, is ordinarily upheld.
2. He demandeth of his Aduersarie, why he doth so highly value them and mainely vrge them herein, when in other points he will not sticke to contemne them. Had he any wit in his adle braine, he would neuer haue asked this idle Question It is as if in a Law-suite, because a man taketh hold (as he may well doe) of somewhat that falleth from his Aduersaries, or is granted him and confessed by them, because it furthereth his owne cause, he were therefore bound to beleeue or admit all that euer they say to the preiudice of his right. The greater differences are betweene them and vs, yea in the present controuersie concerning the manner of Christs presence in the Sacrament, the lesse cause there is to suspect that they should speake partially for vs; and the greater cause to suppose they were by euidence of truth enforced to confesse that, that should take away some of those grounds, whereby the cause that themselues stiffely maintained, is ordinarily vpheld.
3. He addeth in the end: These men herein without heretical intention, or obstinacy of judgement differed from us. Whom he meaneth by that, Us, I leave to himself to explain: And the less heretical their intention was (as he understandeth heretical) the less suspicion there is of collusion or any purpose therein to gratify us; and ⟨p. 132⟩so much the stronger therefore is their testimony for us. *The testimony of a mere stranger, or no well-willer to the cause maketh it to be of more moment. But when he speaketh of obstinacy of judgement, he glanceth at a secret in their Church, which I shall in a word or two take occasion hereby to discover. It is no matter what a man hold or maintain among them, so long as he acknowledgeth the Popes Supremacy, the main pillar of their faith, and submit himself and his works wholly to his censure, and so be ready to unsay what he saith, when he will have him so to do. For his censure indeed alone is that which they call commonly the censure of the Church. And to this purpose they confess that many of their writers have held the very same points, for which they condemn us now as Heretics, of whom yet they say that they were not Heretics, because they submitted themselves to this Censure. I will add an instance or two hereof out of Bellarmine.
3. He addeth in the end: These men herein without hereticall intention, or obstin•cie of iudgement differed from vs. Whom he meaneth by that, Vs, I leaue to himselfe to explaine: And the lesse hereticall their intention was (as he vnderstandeth hereticall) the lesse suspition there is of collusion or any purpose therein to gratifie vs; and ⟨p. 132⟩so much the stronger therefore is their testimonie for vs. *The testimonie of a meere stranger, or no well-willer to the cause maketh it to be of more moment. But when he speaketh of obstinacie of iudgement, he glaunceth at a secret in their Church, which I shall in a word or two take occasion hereby to discouer. It is no matter what a man hold or maintaine among them, so long as he acknowledgeth the Popes Supremacie, the maine pillar of their faith, and submit himselfe and his workes wholly to his censure, and so be ready to vnsay what he saith, when he will haue him so to doe. For his censure indeede alone is that which they call commonly the censure of the Church. And to this purpose they confesse that many of their writers haue held the very same points, for which they condemne vs now as Heretikes, of whom yet they say that they were not Heretikes, because they submitted themselues to this Censure. I will adde an instance or two hereof out of Bellarmine.
*Confessio propria testimonies quibusnis; •estesque non familiares domesticis praeferuntur. Menoch. lib. 2. a•b. cas. •26. & Althus. dicaeolog. l. 3. c. 45.Confessio propria testimo•is quibusnis; •estesque non familiares domesticis praeferuntur. Menoch. lib. 2. a•b. cas. •26. & Althus. dicaeolog. l. 3. c. 45.
1. In this very particular; he confesseth that dmany of the Authors before mentioned expound that 6. Chap. of John as the Heretics do: but they submit themselves (saith he) and their writings to the Censure of the Councils and Popes; which the Heretics do not.
1. In this very particular; he confesseth that dmany of the Authors before mentioned expound that 6. Chap. of Iohn as the Heretikes doe: but they submit themselues (saith he) and their writings to the Censure of the Councels and Popes; which the Heretikes doe not.
2. In the present controversy, Durandus held not a Transubstantiation, but a transformation in the Sacrament: ewhich opinion (saith he) is heretical; and yet was he no Heretic; because he was ready to yield to the judgement of the Church.
2. In the present controuersie, Durandus held not a Transubstantiation, but a transformation in the Sacrament: ewhich opinion (saith he) is hereticall; and yet was hee no Heretike; because he was ready to yeeld to the iudgement of the Church.
3. Ambrose Catharine's opinion of the Ministers intention in the Sacrament, differeth not (f saith he) for ought I see, from the opinion of Chemnicius and other Heretics, save that he in the end of his book submitteth himself to the Apostolic Sea and Council.
3. Ambrose Catharines opinion of the Ministers intention in the Sacrament, differeth not (f saith he) for ought I see, from the opinion of Chemnicius and other Heretikes, saue that he in the end of his booke submitteth himselfe to the Apostolike Sea and Councel.
4. Durandus in the point concerning merit of works gheld as we now do, that no reward was due to them but out of Gods mere liberality, and that it were temerarious and blasphemous to say, that God were unjust, if he should not ⟨p. 133⟩so reward them: And yet was he also no Heretic for the cause before-mentioned.
4. Durandus in the point concerning merite of workes gheld as we now doe, that no reward was due to them but out of Gods meere liberalitie, and that it were temerarious and blasphemous to say, that God were vniust, if he should not ⟨p. 133⟩so reward them: And yet was he also no Heretike for the cause before-mentioned.
gIdem de justific. lib. 3. cap. 16.Idem de iustific. lib. 3. cap. 16.
the bread that I will giue, is my fl•sh that I will giue for the life of the world: as if this were not the same spirituall bread that hee spake of before. 4. Being pressed with this that there is no bread at all in the Eucharist
(as they say) k & therfore it cannot be the sacramentall bread that is there spoken of, neither can it bee meant of the bread that Christ was to giue in the Supper, as hee elsewhere had said: he saith that
meate or food in generall: and so the sence of it is this; The bread, that is, the meate, that I will giue, is my flesh it selfe, that is to be crucified and staine for the saluation of mankind.
nVers. 51.
22o De pane quē da•u•us erat in coena. Ibid. c. 6.o De pane quē da•u•us erat in coena. Ibid. c. 6.
passing as Bellarmine would haue it from a second bread to a third, but more particularly expressing what the second bread was, and repeating more fully what before hee had said)
none of the sacramentall bread, saith Bellarmine) is my flesh that I will giue for the life of the world. Those ensuing passages therefore are not meant of the sacramentall bread or the Eucharist, no more then the former. But leaue wee Bellarmine, and returne we to this our Defendant, whom we are principally now to deale with.