Rainoldes. But you have not proved that they were used through the whole world, either by S. Austin, or by S. Denis. oNay, that Denis (who so ever he were,) doth prove the contrary. For in his description of the Mass (as you call it) there are neither lights, nor vestments, nor crossings, nor all the other ceremonies: whereby it is manifest that they were not used through the whole world when that Denis wrote. As for incense, howsoever it crept into that Church in the which he lived: it appeareth by the writings of pTertullian, and qArnobius, that the Church used it not in their days. Neither is the censing, which Denis speaketh of, liker to yours: then (I ⟨p. 590⟩showed) your blessings are like to S. Austins. For rhe hath it only once about the Church. But in syour solemn Mass it is used often, and to sundry things: to the cross, to relics, to images, to candlesticks, to the altar, the lower part of it, and the higher, to the Priests, to the book, to the bread and wine, thrice above the chalice, and the host, and thrice about them, to the altar, and the Priest again and again, to the quire, to the deacon, to the subdeacon, to the people; and, in Masses for the dead, to the sacrament also at the time of the elevation. So that, if the words of the tTrent-council be weighed with your practise: you will leese the countenance of that which Denis showeth to. For with him it is incense in the singular number. Your Masses and the Council hau• *incenses in the plural. By the which word if the Council meant to note all the censinges that are used in Massing, as they did of likelihood: then neither Denis maketh for your Massing-incense. Though, whatsoever he make, he maketh nought for your reason: because he proveth not that it was used through the whole world. Now the lights, which your Jesuit hath found in S. uAustin, make less a great deal for it. For S. xAustin calleth the lights which they used, 1 lights of the night: because they did use them in the night time when they met at prayers, yas Christians were wont. But your Massing-lights are used in the day time, when the sun shineth: a thing perhaps observed through the whole world, but zof idolatrous Heathens, not of the Church of Christ.
Rainoldes. But you haue not proued that they were vsed through the whole world, either by S. Austin, or by S. Denys. oNay, that Denys (who so euer he were,) doth proue the contrarie. For in his description of the Masse (as you call it) there are neither lightes, nor vestiments, nor crossinges, nor all the other ceremonies: whereby it is manifest that they were not vsed through the whole world when that Denys wrote. As for incense, howsoeuer it crept into that Church in the which he liued: it appeereth by the writinges of pTertullian, and qArnobius, that the Church vsed it not in their dayes. Neither is the censing, which Denys speaketh of, liker to yours: then (I ⟨p. 590⟩shewed) your blessinges are like to S. Austins. For rhe hath it onely once aboute the Church. But in syour solemne Masse it is vsed often, and to sundrie thinges: to the crosse, to relikes, to images, to candlestickes, to the altar, the lower part of it, and the higher, to the Priestes, to the booke, to the bread and wine, thrise aboue the chalice, and the host, and thrise about them, to the altar, and the Priest againe and againe, to the quire, to the deacon, to the subdeacon, to the people; and, in Masses for the dead, to the sacrament also at the time of the eleuation. So that, if the wordes of the tTrent-councell be weighed with your practise: you will léese the countenance of that which Denys sheweth to. For with him it is incense in the singular number. Your Masses and the Councell hau• *incenses in the plurall. By the which word if the Councell meant to note all the censinges that are vsed in Massing, as they did of likelyhood: then neither Denys maketh for your Massing-incense. Though, whatsoeuer he make, he maketh nought for your reason: because he proueth not that it was vsed through the whole world. Now the lights, which your Iesuite hath founde in S. uAustin, make lesse a greate deale for it. For S. xAustin calleth the lights which they vsed, 1 lightes of the night: because they did vse them in the night time when they met at prayers, yas Christians were wont. But your Massing-lights are vsed in the day time, when the sunne shineth: a thing perhaps obserued through the whole world, but zof idolatrous Heathens, not of the Church of Christ.
- oIn Concil. Carthag. 4. c•n▪ 6.
- pIn apology ▪ cap. 42.In apolog• ▪ cap. 42.
- qAduers. ge• tes lib. 7▪
- rDionys. Areopag. hierar. eccles. cap. 3.
- sVit. celebrandi Missam.
- tSess. 22. cap. 5.
- *Thymiamata.
- uConfession. Augustin. lib. 3. cap. 11. tit. 2.
- xDe tempore. In Natali •om. Serm. 3. • Luminaria noctis.
- yAct. 20.8.
- zTertullian. de idololatri•.