pp. 141–204274 passagespart 2 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
They say, as touching the Argument of Marcion, 1that it may be, he took the occasion of his error out of the Gospel, where it is written of Christ that he walked dry foot upon the water, that he was lifted up into heaven, 2and that he escaped out of the hands of the Jews, so as they saw him not, and yet that these things ought not to be taken out of the Gospel by reason of the danger ⟨p. 154⟩of the Marcionites. 3Whereunto we answer, that in the Gospels it is described, that Christ once or twice did these miracles, but ye appoint that these things be perpetual. And that which is in the Scriptures, we our selves have not feigned, therefore we ought not to be accused of giving occasion. Howbeit in those things which we have devised, which we do expound and teach as doctrine without the express word of God, we must beware least we set open a window to Heretics.
They say, as touching the Argument of Marcion, 1that it may be, he tooke the occasion of his errour out of the Gospell, where it is written of Christ that he walked drie foote vpon the water, that he was lifted vp into heauen, 2and that hee escaped out of the handes of the Iewes, so as they sawe him not, and yet that these things ought not to bée taken out of the Gospell by reason of the daunger ⟨p. 154⟩of the Marcionits. 3Whereunto we answere, that in ye Gospels it is described, that Christ once or twise did these myracles, but ye appoint that these things be perpetuall. And that which is in the Scriptures, wee our selues haue not feigned, therefore wée ought not to be accused of giuing occasion. Howbeit in those things which we haue deuised, which we doe expound and teach as doctrine without the expresse word of God, we must beware least we set open a windowe to Heretikes.
111 Furthermore, the nature of a sacrament is corrupted, of which Augustine upon John sayeth, The word cometh unto the element, and it is made a sacrament. The nature thereof is, that it should be made of these two things: but as these men appoint the elements, that is, the bread and wine are taken away: And then Augustine ought not to have said: The word cometh unto the element, 2but, It taketh away the element. And while they remove the natures of the elements, the proportion of the signification perisheth. Wherefore the bread signifieth the body of Christ, because it nourisheth, strengtheneth, and sustaineth: which we cannot attribute unto accidents. It is also a signification of many grains gathered in one, which representeth the mystical body, and that cannot be attributed unto accidents. Wherefore Paul said: 3We that are many, are one bread and one body, because we are partakers of one bread. 4In baptism, water is said to be the fountain of regeneration, 5and because the substance thereof is preserved, that doeth very well agree, for the accidents of water would not be convenient. And in taking away of the substance of bread and wine in the proposition, 6This is my body, they abuse the verb substantive Is, for it is transubstantiated, turned or changed from one to another. For while they utter those words of the Lord, the bread is not yet the body of Christ. Wherefore if they would understand Is in his own true signification, they should utter that which is false. Therefore among the schoolmen, some grant that the verb Is should be taken for, To be made, To be changed, or turned. Moreover they attribute this power or efficacy unto those few words of the Lord, that so often as they be repeated, this changing is made, and yet have they not in the holy Scriptures any word thereof. And if a man should speak those words which Paul, Matthew, Mark, or Luke hath, they would think that there is no consecration: for they ascribe all the virtue unto the words of their own Canon. But we know that then the sacrament is, when we do those things which Christ did and commanded to be done: but he not only spake those words, but he also gave thanks, he brake the bread, he did eat, and he reached it unto others to eat.
And where as there be many things here, all do concur with the trueth of the sacrament, neither must any of these things be intermitted. §11I pass over that they be ignorant whether consecration be had in the words of Christ or in prayers. Further they set them selves in great peril. For it may be that an ill sacrificer or false worker doeth not speak the words, doth change or invert them. §12Moreover, seeing an intent (as they speak) of him that consecrateth is required: it might be, that he in doing of these things thinketh nothing at all of consecration, and perhaps that he is minded not to have it done.
And where as there be manie things here, all doe concurre with the trueth of the sacrament, neither must anie of these things be intermitted. §11I passe ouer that they be ignorant whether consecration be had in the wordes of Christ or in prayers. Further they set them selues in great perill. For it may be that an yll sacrificer or false worker doeth not speake the words, doth change or inuert them. §12Moreouer, séeing an intent (as they speake) of him that consecrateth is required: it might bée, that he in doing of these things thinketh nothing at all of consecration, and perhaps that he is minded not to haue it doone.
12 They fall into many absurdities, 1and those inexplicable: for therein they affirm that there may be a body, and that in infinite places together and at one very time. But they say, that this is no hinderance unto them, because though the body of Christ be there, yet is it not by the way of quantity. And this is to be wondered at how they place a body and a quantity, and to be truly present: and yet not by the way of quantity. And seeing they affirm him to be truly present, and corporally, and carnally as they say, but not locally, who perceiveth not that these be arguments invented to deceive? 2They object that this was given to the humane body of Saint Ambrose, 3who being at Milan was present at Turon in the funerals of Saint Martin, and there was seen: Why (say they) shall not this which Ambrose had, be rather granted to the body of Christ? But they take as granted, which we grant not. For it might be, 4that it was revealed unto Ambrose, and that it seemed unto him he was present at those funerals, and by the help of Angels he was perhaps represented in them and unto the sight of the people, but that his body was verily in both places together, we will not grant. Further we might leave it to the author of the miracle recited, to consider whether it be true or no. 5They oppose again as touching souls, that whereas they be creatures, yet each one of them is in the head, and in all the members of our body. 6But they deal very unwisely, which compare a spirit with a body, and that they would have to be given unto bodies which they may lawfully do unto a spirit. Christ said plainly: 7A spirit hath no flesh and bones, whereby he ⟨p. 155⟩put no small difference between them. Further if we should grant, that that is to be given unto the body which our soul hath, it followeth not that the body of Christ can be in divers places, because our soul and the Angels cannot be in divers places at one and the self same time: For they be creatures, and therefore of a power limited and definite.
13 There follow also many other inconveniences: 1because if the mice have gnawen these sacred hosts, they will say, that they eat accidents. And if they be filled and satisfied, this also shall be a work of Accidents. And if it happen that a sacrificing Priest, do utter those words over a great vessel of wine, and over a great chest full of bread, and that thou demand what filleth the vessel, what the chest, or what also filled the bellies of them which did eat and drink thereof: they would answer, Accidents. And because those that eat, are sustained, some of them dare to say, that God createth in the bellies of the eaters and drinkers, either fleame or some other humour, which may be converted into blood whereby they should be nourished. §16But and if that that sacrament be burned, as it was done in the time of Hesychius (which thing he himself testifieth upon Leviticus, and the very same hath Origen upon the same book,) undoubtedly ashes will remain, and by that means shall a substance be procreated out of accidents. In like manner worms may arise of the bread consecrated, & there also they will say that substance is brought forth of accidents. Albeit, (as they be bold fellows,) some of them feign that the former matter is by miracle brought again, by reason whereof these things may happen. But if it be lawful after this manner to breed and feign miracles, every divine may escape as he will. For to every intricate matter he will apply a miracle, and so will he unwind himself out of all Arguments which shall be objected against him. §17These things they affirm not only by miracles, but also by subtle sophistical arguments. As Scotus when he is urged in the uttering of those words: This is my body, that he should tell us what is showed in the subject of the proposition, at length answereth, 2that there is demonstration made of some singular or particular thing of a more general substance, which together with that which is affirmed thereof doeth show the self same thing or (as the schoolmen said) is of the self same supposition: neither do those things differ one from another which are signified by the subject and that which thereof is affirmed, except it be by a divers manner of conceiving. See whereinto they rush and yet for all that they escape not. For it is not yet answered by them what is showed, when it is said, This is my body.
The Bishop of Rochester sayeth in these propositions, that when any thing is changed into an other thing, it is not absurd that that which was before should be showed: And so he admitteth, that in This is my body should be showed the bread which was before, and is changed into the body of Christ while those words be spoken. But then (say I) the proposition is not well framed: For it should have bin said: This is made my body, or, This is turned into my body: otherwise, being said, This is my body, the speech is unproper.
The Bishop of Rochester saieth in these propositions, that when any thing is changed into an other thing, it is not absurde that that which was before shoulde bee shewed: And so he admitteth, that in This is my bodie should be shewed the bread which was before, and is chaunged into the bodie of Christ whyle those wordes be spoken. But then (saie I) the proposition is not well framed: For it should haue bin said: This is made my bodie, or, This is turned into my bodie: otherwise, being said, This is my bodie, the spéech is vnproper.
14 They which say, that the body of Christ is really joined with the signs, the natures I mean of bread and wine being preserved, do thus argue against Transubstantiation: What dignity or privilege have Accidents, that they can be joined with the body of Christ, which ought to be denied to the substance and nature of bread? And if the Accidents can remain, why shall not also the substance of bread be retained? Yea rather, many of the fathers suppose, that this may be done. And thence they take a similitude, that the humane and divine natures in Christ do verily remain, and so remain, as one passeth not into another: whose opinions we will bring in when time shall serve. §19They fall also into an other absurdity: for while they break the Sacrament, 1we demand of them what they break there. Here they stagger and some have said, as testifieth the master of the sentences in the 4. book, that the essence or substance of the body of Christ is broken: but this opinion is by him confuted: because the body of Christ is immortal, and therefore it is not subject to these things, and to new chances. There were others which said that the same is no true breaking, but that it only appeareth to be, and so seemeth unto our senses. And this is also rejected, least we should establish here a perpetual illusion. At length they say, that they be accidents which be broken. And when as they after a sort appoint a Mathematical quantity, that is, a quantity separated from matter, which if it be divided, it is only done by the power of the mind and by the promptness of the understanding. These men also divide in very deed, so as the parts divided may most manifestly be seen. §20In Jeremiah we read, 2Let us cast wood upon his bread: which place is ⟨p. 156⟩cited by Tertullian and Lactantius, and they interpret that this was spoken of putting the wood of the cross into the body of Christ: and they will that mention was made of bread, because through bread Christ was to give himself unto us. And that which the Prophet speaketh, 3they will have to be a figure of the bread of the Sacrament: which seeing these men take away, and only leave a figure unto us, they affirm a figure of a figure, so as no sound thing remaineth.
The very which may be gathered by that which is oftentimes alleged by the fathers as concerning Melchizedek, 1who brought the bread and the wine, the figure whereof is not by these men observed, when they remove away the bread and the wine. And the self same thing followeth as touching the Shewbread.
The very which may be gathered by that which is oftentimes alledged by the fathers as concerning Melchizedeck, 1who brought the bread and the wine, the figure whereof is not by these men obserued, when they remooue away the bread and the wine. And the selfe same thing followeth as touching the Shewbread.
15 Again we will bring a reason taken from baptism. A little before we argued from thence, that for the trueth of that Sacrament it was not requisite that water should be transubstantiated: now we reason from the men themselves which be baptised, 1of whom the Scripture plainly saith that they lay away the old man, and are again begotten: and yet is there no Transubstantiation imagined in them, nevertheless generation is described to be a motion whereby a new substance is gotten. 2Wherefore it is no marvel that Nicodemus took offence at the words of the Lord, wherein it was showed him that he should be borne again. For while he thought with himself that a new generation was preached unto man already brought forth and well in years, he stood in a doubt. But and if we interpret that generation to be new, and the nativity to be spiritual, why do we not vouchsafe to do the same in the Eucharist? And why do we not transfer all things unto spiritual eating? I gladly join together these two Sacraments, Baptism and the Eucharist, because Paul in the 1. 3Epistle to the Corinthians the 12. Chap. knitteth them together, 4when he saith: All we by one spirit are baptised into one body, and have bin all made to drink with one spirit. Neither is it of any force, if thou shalt say, that we be baptised into one body, to wit, the mystical body, because from the mystical body Christ is not absent, seeing he is the head thereof. And else where Paul most plainly saith, 5that We in baptism put on Christ. §22We see moreover, that the holy writers bring out of the 6. Chapter of John many things as touching the Sacrament of the Eucharist. Yea rather, there is none of the fathers which in the interpreting of that chapter, writeth not plentifully of the Eucharist. Whereupon we conclude a reason after this manner: 6The things which be there spoken, either serve unto this sacrament or they serve not: if they belong not unto this, what need is there to rite them, or by those places to dispute of the Eucharist? But if they have respect unto this, seeing there is only a spiritual eating, that is by faith, whereby is received the true body and blood of Christ, what need is there to bring in an other new receiving, and to imagine a carnal eating, whereby the same thing should be received again?
For if we grant that there cometh some godly and faithful man, then these men shall be constrained to admit, that twice he doth receive the body of Christ: First by a spiritual eating through faith, afterward by their carnal eating which they have never proved. And thus thou seest that these men do stop up their own way, so as they cannot truly cite those testimonies which are upon the 6. Chapter of John. §23And while they affirm Transubstantiation, they are found to be in the same error that the Capernaites were. 1Even they also revolved in their mind I know not what corporal eating of the flesh of Christ, from which cogitation, Christ straight way revoked them, when he said: 2that his words were spirit and life: and that the flesh profiteth nothing. And he objected unto them the memory of his ascension into heaven, saying: 3What if ye see the Son of man ascend into heaven where he was at the first? But these men say, 4that they are not of the same mind that the Capernaites were: for say they: they thought that the flesh of Christ should be cut into pieces, and should be torn with the teeth, and therefore they have utterly misliked thereof: but as touching the special imagination of the Capernaites, 5what soever it was they know not, but very like it is, that they thought carnally, therefore they were troubled with the mention made of ascending into heaven. Why do not these men teach themselves thereby, who are bound to say that they eat Christ both carnally and corporally? What difference is there whether thou receive him by parts, or if thou swallow him all at once?
For if we graunt that there commeth some godly and faithfull man, then these men shall be constrained to admit, that twise he dooth receaue the body of Christ: First by a spirituall eating through faith, afterward by their carnall eating which they haue neuer prooued. And thus thou séest that these men doe stop vp their owne way, so as they cannot truely cite those testimonies which are vppon the 6. Chapter of Iohn.
16 Hereunto it serveth, that Christ said unto his Apostles about the end of his life, 1that he would leave the world and would depart from them: which should not be true, if he were with us by transubstantiation as these men would. They have used to answer that Christ left the world as touching mortal conditions, and as touching familiarity ⟨p. 157⟩and bodily conversation. These indeed are subtle shifts, but they serve not to the purpose. For when Christ spake these words, 2Philip answered: Behold now thou speakest plainly, and without parables. Howbeit if it were so to be understood, the speech had been obscure and like a parable. Further if Christ remain with us so corporally in the Eucharist, he might by the same reason remain both in our hearts, & also in our selves. Therefore he might still after his ascension rule the Church by his own self, and be present with his Apostles. 3But he sayeth, that he would leave a vicar in his stead: namely the holy Ghost, who had not been necessary, if whole Christ as touching divinity & humanity (as these men will) were present. For seeing the flesh and body of him is by participation in each one of us (according to their doctrine) and that his godhead is present, he might deal by his own self without the holy Ghost to be the prompter. §25Mary the mother of the Lord, the most blessed virgin, when she had heard of the Angel, 4that the word of GOD should take flesh upon him, and that she was chosen to conceive & bring forth the Son of God, she judged these to be strange and wonderful things, and demanded how these things should be, & so forth. But this translation of the bread into the body of Christ, seeing it is no less matter than is that mystery of his incarnation and nativity of the Virgin, it is a wonder that in the holy scriptures there is found neither admiration nor question demanded of that matter: and that in none of the writings of the Evangelists or Apostles, 5
For us therefore doeth that question and answer serve, but it nothing at all profiteth these men, who feign another eating differing from that spiritual eating, to wit, this eating which we now have in hand.
For vs therefore doeth that question and answere serue, but it nothing at all profiteth these men, who faine another eating differing from that spirituall eating, to wit, this eating which wee nowe haue in hand.
17 Other inconveniences and absurdities do follow the feigning of these things. For Christ said: 1I will that where I am, there also my minister should be: and he spake the same often times to his Apostles. 2And in the Apocalypse we read of certain Martyrs: They follow him wheresoever he shall go. Whereupon would be concluded, that in the Eucharist, not only should be affirmed Transubstantiation into the body of Christ, but into all the Saints. Which if it displease them, let them leave Christ in heaven with his saints, otherwise they shall follow him together for company. But they say: 3We suffer him also to be in heaven, visible and in his Majesty and glory, but yet herein the sacrament we affirm him to be invisible: and those things which be objected as touching the fellowship of the Saints and Martyrs, they be true as touching Christ, according as he is visible in heaven in his glory and Majesty. This answer leaneth upon a false ground: for it admitteth that one and the same body of Christ is in many places at once: which the fathers deny. It admitteth that Christ is with us as touching his body and flesh; whereas he said, that as touching these things, 4he would send another in his place, namely, the holy Ghost. §27Neither can they avoid it that Christ had two bodies, seeing in the supper when he had taken bread into his hands, 5if it had bin transubstantiated into his body, yet he himself had borne his own body with his body, and it should be necessary to grant both the body bearing and the body borne to be both one, when as nevertheless one and the same agent and patient in respect of one and the self same thing in one very time cannot be. 6And thus we see into what absurdities they cast themselves. 7They are wont to bring Augustine upon the Psalms, who said that Christ bare himself in his own hands.
But we reply, that we have sentences of the scripture, in which our faith may exercise it self far otherwise than in these which men have devised. 1We believe that the Son of God, is incarnate of the virgin, that he was borne, that he died for us, that he was raised up from the dead, and that he was taken up into heaven, and many of these kind of things, wherein our faith doth abundantly enough exercise it self. §28And seeing the sense toucheth not, the reason understandeth not, nor experience teacheth this Transubstantiation, how shall it be known? I know, thou wilt say, by faith: but if we are ⟨p. 158⟩to deal by faith, that without the word of God can not be had, and thereof ye be utterly destitute.
But we replie, that we haue sentences of the scripture, in which our faith may exercise it selfe farre otherwise than in these which men haue deuised. 1We beléeue that the sonne of God, is incarnate of the virgin, that he was borne, that he died for vs, that he was raised vp from the dead, and that he was taken vp into heauen, and many of these kinde of things, wherein our faith doth aboundantly ynough exercise it selfe. §28And séeing the sense toucheth not, the reason vnderstandeth not, nor experience teacheth this Transubstantiation, how shall it be knowē? I know, thou wilt say, by faith: but if we are ⟨p. 158⟩to deale by faith, that without the worde of God can not be had, and thereof ye be vtterly destitute.
18 Furthermore, seeing Christ made this sacrament of two parts, namely, of the body and blood, thereby it sufficiently appeareth, that the thing cannot be received by this transubstantiation, because these things in the real and carnal body of Christ are not divided: 1But they have a shift, and they say that it is contained in one of these parts alone or in two. Indeed we hear them affirm this, 2but the words of the Scripture teach it not: but about the bread only there is mention made of the body and about the cup only is the blood specified. They answer as touching the bread, that by the power of the words transubstantiation is made into the body of Christ or into the flesh of Christ properly and by it self, 3and that the blood and the soul & divinity followeth by concomitancy. And in like manner do they speak of the cup, that by an efficacy of the words, first and properly there is a transubstantiation made into the blood, 4but by a concomitancy or a kind of conjunction there is had both the body & the soul & the divinity. And by this their subtle reason, they make Christ less provident, as he that hath given no more unto the two parts than is severally contained in one of them. And of this their fancy hath grown, that afterward they divided the sacrament, and in giving only one part unto the Laity, they have persuaded them, that they have even as much as if they received both parts. Add that by this their feigned devise, they set open a window unto many counterfeit opinions: because there is no opinion whereunto they by their concomitancy may not tie infinite things. And it would follow as we above said, that all the Saints are present in this sacrament, seeing they always follow Christ. But the only reason whereby we refel them, is this, that they teach, out the scripture doeth not speak.
18 Furthermore, séeing Christ made this sacrament of two parts, namelie, of the bodie and bloud, thereby it sufficientlie appeareth, that the thing cannot be receiued by this transubstantiation, because these things in the reall and carnall bodie of Christ are not diuided: 1
19 There hath an other false & absurd opinion followed this transubstantiation: in that they have thought that after receiving of the sacraments, there remaineth still a sacrament, and that the bread or show of bread doth really and verily contain in it the body of Christ. That this is false we will show by other sacraments, 1where the whole consisteth in action, which being taken away, it is no more a sacrament. It appeareth in baptism that when a man is dipped or sprinkled with water by the words of the Lord, then it ceaseth to be a sacrament, The very which thing was in circumcision: for that sacrament also consisted in action. Neither will I disdain to take those which be called sacraments by them, as is confirmation, extreme unction, penance, and other such like: all which we see have place in action only. But they are wont to say, 2that this sacrament of the Eucharist must be excepted. But how logically our adversaries speak this, it may be easily perceived. 3When as all the parts of the induction are granted, and that there is only an instance put of the thing in controversy, who seeth not that it is lewdly done, and only to dally with the argument, for that is after a sort to grant the premisses, and to deny the conclusion?
19 There hath an other false & absurd opinion followed this transubstantiation: in that they haue thought that after receiuing of the sacramentes, there remaineth still a sacrament, and that the bread or shew of bread doth really and verily containe in it the bodie of Christ. That this is false wee will shewe by other sacraments, 1where the whole consisteth in action, which being taken away, it is no more a sacrament. It appeareth in baptisme that when a man is dipped or sprinkled with water by the words of the Lord, then it ceaseth to be a sacrament, The verie which thing was in circumcision: for that sacrament also consisted in action. Neyther will I disdaine to take those which bee called sacraments by them, as is confirmation, extreme vnction, penance, and other such like: all which wee sée haue place in action onelie. But they are woont to say, 2
And by reason of these strange wonders of this Metamorphosis, we are hindered from the end, which is chiefest, and is commended unto us by Christ in the holy scriptures: 1namely the remembrance of Christ and his death. For here all the mind and meaning of these men is occupied in believing of transubstantiation, yea thou mayest see some sacrificers, who when they are come to the Communion only urge and thrust this upon us, to be believed, passing over other things more necessary. 2And by the means of this feigned devise, the Communion is the less frequented, because men being persuaded in that, began to think with themselves: If Christ be there corporally and carnally covered with accidents, surely we will go unto the Temple: we will see, we will worship, we will call upon, we will light candles, and such other like things, whereby they thought they might gratify Christ. Which if they had not thought, but had judged, as true it is, that it is only a sacrament, they would thereby have understood that they should have no commodity unless they had communicated, and their minds would have been more stirred up unto the Communion, which is, truly to satisfy the institution of Christ.
And by reason of these straunge wonders of this Metamorphosis, we are hindered from the end, which is chiefest, and is commended vnto vs by Christ in the holy scriptures: 1namely the remembrance of Christ and his death. For here all the minde and meaning of these men is occupied in beléeuing of transubstantiation, yea thou maist sée some sacrificers, who when they are come to the Cō munion onlie vrge and thrust this vpon vs, to bee beleéeued, passing ouer other thinges more necessarie. 2And by the meanes of this fained deuise, the Communion is the lesse frequented, because men being perswaded in that, began to thinke with themselues: If Christ bee there corporallie and carnallie couered with accidents, surelie we will goe vnto the Temple: we will sée, we will worship, we wil call vpon, we wil light candels, and such other like things, whereby they thought they might gratifie Christ. Which if they had not thought, but had iudged, as true it is, that it is onlie a sacrament, they would thereby haue vnderstoode that they should haue no cōmoditie vnlesse they had communicated, and their mindes would haue béene more stirred vp vnto the Communion, which is, truelie to satisfie the institution of Christ.
20 Over this we ought to call to mind, that the time of humility and submission of Christ is passed away, & that he now reigneth in heaven, and that he hath a name which is above every name. Wherefore then should it be requisite by transubstantiation to send him down again communicated as touching the body into our jaws and bellies? I know that they say he is not hurt, 1he draweth no uncleanness. I will grant it, 2but yet it is not very decent, that, as they say, he should be detained under those accidents so long as they remain sound: 3which things when they shall be dissolved, they say that the body of Christ flieth away. Whereby it ⟨p. 159⟩cometh to pass that they daily and especially until noontide constrain him perpetually to depart and fly away. 4But they say, that we must let these cogitations pass, and yet they themselves by their carnal Transubstantiation do suggest the same. §325If they might be brought that we should do all things there spiritually, there would be no such cogitation. And while they appoint this his natural and carnal body to be present, do they it to the intent that he should penetrate our soul? Or else that he may convey himself into our body? Into the soul they cannot say; because nothing is there taken carnally or corporally. But and if they would that the body should be penetrated by him, we demand why he will do this unto it? They will answer, to the intent that man may be sanctified. 6But it is meet that sanctification should begin at the soul, not at the body. They say that a certain power and efficacy is imprinted by the water, and that the soul is made the better, and the body also confirmed. But if we speak of the power, it is not of necessity that this should be by transubstantiation, seeing it may have it without the same. §36
Wherefore it appeareth that the fathers so spake, because they would only have a memory here of the true sacrifice, and a spiritual receiving thereof, 1which is done by faith. Moreover they are wont to say that the body and blood of Christ is shadowed and covered with the accidents of bread and wine, least we should seem to eat raw flesh and to drink blood. 2But I do not think that these men will say, howsoever they paint and colour the matter, if their Transubstantiation be true, but that we do eat raw flesh: insomuch as no reason is brought either by them or by the scriptures that it should be sodden. And yet it is written of the Paschal lamb, which was a figure of this sacrament, that nothing thereof should be eaten raw.
Wherefore it appeareth that the fathers so spake, because they woulde onely haue a memorie here of the true sacrifice, and a spirituall receiuing therof, 1which is doone by faith. Moreouer they are woont to say that the bodie and bloud of Christ is shadowed and couered with the accidents of bread and wine, least we should séeme to eate rawe flesh and to drinke bloud. 2But I doe not thinke that these men wil say, howsoeuer they paint and colour ye matter, if their Transubstantiation be true, but yt we doe eate rawe flesh: insomuch as no reason is brought either by them or by the scriptures that it should be sodden. And yet it is written of the Paschall lambe, which was a figure of this sacrament, that nothing thereof should be eaten rawe.
21 Besides forth we see, that Christ in the Eucharist instituted a sacrament, 1whereby it cometh to pass that all things be done there sacramentally. Neither is it required, that in Sacraments more should be given or desired than the reason of a Sacrament shall require. Further, if we weigh what Christ did in that last supper, we may easily perceive the thing, it is proved, that he gave his own body. If we demand further, what manner of one he gave, they cannot determine with themselves. §38Some seem to say, that he gave such as he had, namely a passible and mortal body. 2Howbeit such a body with those conditions which it then had, might not carnally, as these men dream, be contained in small pieces of bread. §39But others which think themselves wiser, say that Christ in himself had a body mortal and passible: but that in bread he gave a glorified and spiritual body. Then doth that make against them, which we read in the words of the Lord: 3This is my body which is given for you, and my blood which shall be shed for you: Where he plainly extendeth his speech both unto the body which he then had, and unto the blood which he at the same hour possessed. For these glorified and impassible things he received not until the resurrection was past. But admit it as they say: §40We argue, the conditions of the body passible and glorified are contrary one to an other, so as they cannot both together at one time be in one subject. Whereupon it followeth that if ye will have them put into the body of Christ at one very time, ye make Christs body to be twain. §41Experience and the histories teach us, that we must not allow of Transubstantiation, because they write that Victor the Pope of Rome dyed by drinking of poison out of the chalice. 4And Henry the Emperor was poisoned by taking of bread in the Eucharist. If all things be there transubstantiated, 5
Therefore it is concluded that the substances of bread and wine do remain. And before they be aware, the body of Christ is by them deprived of quantity, place, and distance of parts, so as his whole body is constrained to be in the least piece thereof.
Therefore it is concluded that the substances of bread and wine doe remaine. And before they be aware, the bodie of Christ is by them depriued of quantitie, place, and distance of partes, so as his whole body is constrained to be in the least péece thereof.
22 This Sacrament is not only called the Sacrament of the body of Christ our saviour, ⟨p. 160⟩but also of the mystical body: wherefore Paul in the first Epistle to the Corinthians said: 1Ye be the body of Christ: and again, We that are many, be one bread and one body, which be partakers of one bread. And Augustine in his 22. book De Civitate Dei, the 10. Chapter, saith that Christians do not offer sacrifice unto Martyrs. The sacrifice undoubtedly is the body of Christ, which is not offered unto Martyrs, because they them selves be the same, to wit, the body of Christ. Wherefore seeing this Sacrament is of both the bodies, 2even as they appoint not that the bread should be transubstantiated into the body mystical: so it may not be required that it should be truly and properly converted into the body of the Lord, seeing it is declared to be the Sacrament aswell of the one as of the other. §44And of this opinion it would follow, that aswell the faithful as the unfaithful do receive the body of the Lord, 3which I have elsewhere disproved by two reasons. First, that seeing the body of Christ is not plucked away from the spirit of Christ, it would follow that the wicked should receive the spirit of Christ. Secondly, seeing infidels be dead as touching the inward man, they altogether want the instrument whereby they should receive spiritual things. And Augustine plainly said: that none do eat the body of Christ, but they which be of his body. And Jerome in the 4. book upon Jeremiah the 22. Chapter: And whereas he inferreth: They shall not eat and drink, he understandeth the body and blood of our Saviour. And he spake of the Heretics. And the same Father upon Isaiah the 66. Chapter: While they be not holy in body & in spirit, neither do they eat the flesh of Jesus nor do drink his blood. And many such like places are had out of the Fathers. §45And whereas here they so very often pretend unto us many miracles, we must not so easily give credit, because miracles are not wont to be brought in, unless it be in respect that they be strange and wonderful things, by whose unaccustomed happening, a weight may be added unto the word of God. For then men be stricken with admiration, and may be easily led to embrace the doctrine of Christ.
But here is no visible thing changed, and there is nothing that can stir up men to admiration, 1wherefore they seem in vain to crave help of miracles. The virgin in deed conceived of the holy Ghost, but this she sensibly perceived to be done. And if any at any time have bin converted unto Christ, they perceived that their mind and their life was changed from the former conversation. But here is nothing perceived of these miracles which they imagine. Only they be talked of, but can be proved by no reason, or experience, or scripture. §46Unto these things that have been already said, add, that the breaking of bread is after the same manner unto the death and passion of Christ, as bread is unto the body. But breaking, as they themselves also affirm, is a Sacrament and sign of the passion of Christ, and yet for all that it is not so to be transubstantiated, as it maketh the same to be truly and really present: therefore neither shall the bread be so changed into the body, as it may make the same to be present really. And then forasmuch as this opinion hath naught else but contention of words and inexplicable difficulties, it furthereth not unto godliness.
But here is no visible thing changed, and there is nothing that can stirre vp men to admiration, 1wherefore they séeme in vaine to craue helpe of miracles. The virgin in déede conceaued of the holy Ghost, but this she sensiblie perceaued to be doone. And if any at any time haue bin conuerted vnto Christ, they perceaued that their minde and their lyfe was changed from the former conuersation. But here is nothing perceiued of these miracles which they imagin. Onely they be talked of, but can be prooued by no reason, or experience, or scripture. §46Vnto these thinges that haue béene alreadie said, adde, that the breaking of bread is after the same manner vnto the death and passion of Christ, as bread is vnto the bodie. But breaking, as they themselues also affirme, is a Sacrament and signe of the passion of Christ, and yet for all that it is not so to be transubstantiated, as it maketh the same to be truely and reallie present: therefore neither shall the bread be so changed into the body, as it may make the same to be present reallie. And then forasmuch as this opinion hath naught else but contention of wordes and inexplicable difficulties, it furthereth not vnto godlynesse.
23 But now let us consider of the Fathers whether they so judge or no. Irenaeus against the Valentinian heretics: 1The earthly bread (saith he) when it hath received that faculty from the word of God, it is no more common bread, but is made the Eucharist, which consisteth of two things, to wit, earthly and heavenly. First of all he denieth not the Eucharist to be bread, except thou make it common bread. Afterward he saith that it consisteth of two things, whereof the one is terrestrial as bread, the other celestial, as the body of Christ. And as on the one part is retained the trueth, to wit, as touching the body of the Lord: so in the other part it is to be preserved, namely as touching bread. And he addeth by a similitude: even so our bodies receiving the same be no more corruptible. 2Tertullian in his first book against Marcion saith, that God cast not away bread being his creature, seeing in it he represented his body. And in the 4. book against the same Marcion, He receiving bread & distributing to his disciples made the same to be his body, saying, This is my body, that is, a figure of my body. But a figure it should not be, unless it were a body of the trueth. Origen upon the book of Numbers, 3Homily 16. We are said to drink the blood of Christ, not only by the rite of the Sacraments, but also when we receive his word. The very which thing Jerome also wrote sometimes upon Ecclesiast. the 3. Chapter. The same Origen upon Matthew the 26. Chapter: This bread which God, being the word, confesseth to be his body, is a nourishing word of souls. Upon Leviticus the 7. Homily: For there is in the Gospel also a letter that killeth, & not in the old Testament only. For if according to the letter, thou follow that which is said: Unless ye shall eat my flesh, & so forth. And in the same book, homily the 9. Do ⟨p. 161⟩not thou stand in a doubt in the blood of the flesh, but learn rather the blood of the word, and hear him speaking unto thee. For this is my blood which is shed for you. Origen upon Matthew the 15. Chapter: The bread sanctified as touching that which it hath material passeth into the belly and is cast out into the draught. And straightway after: Not the matter of the bread but the word spoken over the same is it that profiteth, yet not him that unworthily eateth it unto the Lord. The same father against Celsus the 8. book:
When as we have given thanks for the benefits bestowed upon us, we eat the loaves that be offered.
When as we haue giuen thankes for the benefites bestowed vppon vs, we eate the loaues that be offered.
124 Cyprian in the sixth Epistle of the first book unto Magnus saith: The Lord calleth his body, bread, which is kneaded together by the uniting of many grains, and he calleth his blood wine that is pressed out of clusters and many grapes. And when he interpreteth the Lords prayer, he calleth the body of the Lord, bread. And in his sermon de coena Domini, he saith, that we do not sharpen the teeth, but only we break and eat that bread with a sincere faith. And in his sermon de Chrismate, he saith manifestly, that Sacraments have names of those things which they signify. Which two sayings it seemeth that Augustine borrowed of him. The later in his epistle to Bonifacius. But when he saith the other, Why preparest thou thy teeth or belly? believe and thou hast eaten: that he hath in the 25. treatise upon John. But the same Cyprian in the third epistle and second book unto Coecilius: In wine he saith is showed the blood of the Lord. And against the Aquarii he saith, that the blood of Christ cannot seem to be present in the cup, if the wine cease to be therein, which by these mens transubstantiation doth come to pass. And in his sermon de coena Domini, he writeth, that the signs are changed into the body of Christ, but so as he taketh a similitude of Christ himself in whom the humane nature appeared, and the divine nature lay hidden. By which similitude thou seest that he would that as in Christ remained the two natures, so they are preserved in this sacrament. And Cyprian in his third Epistle and second book: By this reason, neither can the body of the Lord be in meal alone or in water alone, unless both of them shall be united and coupled together, and made firm into a lump of one loaf, whereby also in the sacrament it self our people is said to be united. And Athanasius expounding those words, 2If any man shall speak a word against the Son of man, it is forgiven him: but he that shall speak against the holy Ghost, it shall not be forgiven him neither in this world nor yet in the world to come: he writeth: And how great a body should be needful unto this, that the world should eat of it? But he inferreth that the thing must be understood spiritually, and that therefore the Lord in that place against the Capernaites made mention of his ascension.
124 Cyprian in the sixt Epistle of the first booke vnto Magnus saith: The Lord calleth his body, breade, which is kneaded together by the vniting of many graines, and he calleth his bloud wine that is pressed out of clusters and many grapes. And when he interpreteth the Lordes prayer, he calleth the bodie of the Lorde, breade. And in his sermon de coena Domini, he saith, that we do not sharpen the téeth, but onely we breake and eate that breade with a syncere faith. And in his sermon de Chrismate, he saith manifestly, that Sacraments haue names of those thinges which they signifie. Which two sayings it séemeth that Augustine borowed of him. The later in his epistle to Bonifacius. But when he saith the other, Why preparest thou thy téeth or belly? beléeue and thou hast eaten: that he hath in the 25. treatise vpon Iohn. But the same Cyprian in the thirde epistle and second booke vnto Coecilius: In wine he saith is shewed the bloud of the Lord. And against the Aquarii he saith, that the bloud of Christ cannot séeme to be present in the cup, if the wine cease to be therin, which by these mens transubstantiation doth come to passe. And in his sermon de coena Domini, he writeth, that the signes are changed into the body of Christ, but so as he taketh a similitude of Christ himselfe in whom the humane nature appéered, and the diuine nature lay hidden. By which similitude thou séest that he would that as in Christ remained the two natures, so they are preserued in this sacrament. And Cyprian in his third Epistle and second booke: By this reason, neither can the body of the Lord be in meale alone or in water alone, vnlesse both of them shalbe vnited and coupled together, and made firme into a lumpe of one loafe, wherby also in the sacrament it selfe our people is saide to be vnited. And Athanasius expounding those wordes,
1Basil in his Liturgy calleth bread [Greek or Hebrew], that is, an example of the like form of the body of Christ, and that after the words of consecration. 2Dionysius de Hierarchia Ecclesiastica the third chapter: The Bishop openeth the bread hidden and undivided, and cutteth it into morsels.
1Basil in his Liturgie calleth bread 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is, an example of ye like forme of the body of Christ, and that after the wordes of consecration. 2Dionysius de Hierarchia Ecclesiastica the thirde chapter: The Bishop openeth the bread hidden and vndiuided, and cutteth it into morsels.
25 Ambrose in his exposition of the first Epistle to the Corinthians, 1when he speaketh of doing this in remembrance of Christ and his death, saith that we in eating and drinking of the flesh and blood of Christ, do signify the things that be offered. And again, about the self same place he saith: that we take it into the mystical cup for a figure of Christ his blood. And in the fourth book the fourth chapter, where he putteth a changing of the signs, he entreateth also of our changing into Christ: and yet it is not affirmed that they which receive the Sacrament be transubstantiated. And the same Father in the same fourth book de Sacramentis ye fourth chapter: This we add moreover: How can it be that which is bread should by consecration be the body of Christ? And straight way: If there be so great a strength in the word of the Lord, as things should begin to be which were not, how much rather is the word so effectuous, that the things which were may remain, and yet be changed into an other thing? Jerome upon Matthew saith plainly, 2that in bread and wine are represented the body and blood of the Lord. Chrysostom upon the later Epistle unto the Corinthians saith, that not alonely that which is set before us upon the table is the body of Christ, but also the poor people unto whom we are bound to do good: because even he that saith, This is my body, said also by his word, that he receiveth alms and is needy in the poor. In his eleventh homily upon Matthew in his work which is called unperfect: he saith that in the holy vessels there is not the body of Christ and the blood of Christ, but a mystery of the body and blood of Christ. Also upon the twelfth chapter of the second Epistle to the Corinthians the 27. homily: Even as Christ, both in the bread and in the cup said, Do this in the remembrance of me. The same father upon the 22. psalm, upon these words, Thou hast prepared a table in my ⟨p. 162⟩sight. As it is showed unto us that there is every day in the sacrament bread and wine according to the order of Melchizedek, unto them similitude of the body and blood of Christ. Emisenus whom they cite de Consecratione distinct. 32. And he seemeth to put a change of the signs: even the selfsame man maketh mention of our changing into Christ.
126 Augustine hath many testimonies of this matter upon the 82. psalm: This that ye see, ye shall not eat, neither shall ye drink this blood which they will pour out: it is a mystery that I speak unto you, which if it be spiritually understood, it will quicken you. De Trinitate the third book and tenth chapter: The bread for this purpose made, is eaten up in receiving of the sacrament. Neither is there any cause why the Bishop of Rochester should go about to draw this saying unto the Shewbread: for we have showed elsewhere by divers arguments that his interpretation is not right. First because, if thou follow the plain sense, and that sense, which at the first view offereth it self unto thee, and which the words make show of, thou shalt manifestly perceive that the speech is of the Eucharist. And Erasmus in the books of Augustine which he mended, wrote in the margin Eucharist. Further a little after in the same chapter, & while he treateth of the same thing, he maketh so evident mention of the Eucharist, as even the adversary cannot deny it. And of the same Eucharist, he had written before in the fourth chapter of that book, when he began the same treatise. Add herewithall: that expressly in these words which we have in hand, it is plainly called a sacrament, which if he had meant, that it should be understood in common, it had been no less agreeable unto those things that he had reckoned before, namely unto the brazen serpent, and to the stone erected by Jacob, than unto the Shewbread. But in those words he expressed not this word Sacrament, which afterward (that we may understand he speaketh of the Eucharist,) he would not suppress. Lastly he saith: The bread made for this purpose is eaten up in the sacrament, which agreeth not with the Shewbread: for that was not made to this end, that it should be eaten, but that they being set upon the table, should remain before the Lord: wherefore they be called in the Hebrew Panim. Afterward it came to pass, that without regard or by hap, they were eaten, least happily it should putrefy before the Lord. For therefore it was changed every week. And when it had been once dedicated unto God, he would have this honour to be given unto it, that it should be eaten of the Priests.
126 Augustine hath many testimonies of this matter vpon the 82. psalme: This that ye sée, ye shal not eate, neither shall ye drinke this bloud which they wil powre out: it is a mysterie that I speake vnto you, which if it be spiritually vnderstood, it wil quicken you. De Trinitate the thirde booke and tenth chapter: The breade for this purpose made, is eaten vp in receiuing of the sacrament. Neither is there any cause why the Bishop of Rochester should go about to draw this saying vnto the Shewbreade: for we haue shewed elsewhere by diuers arguments that his interpretation is not right. First bicause, if thou follow the plaine sense, and that sense, which at the first view offereth it selfe vnto thée, and which the wordes make shew of, thou shalt manifestly perceiue that the spéech is of the Eucharist. And Erasmus in the books of Augustine which he mended, wrote in the margēt Eucharist. Further a litle after in the same chapter, & while he treateth of the same thing, he maketh so euident mention of the Eucharist, as euen ye aduersarie cannot deny it. And of the same Eucharist, he had written before in the fourth chapter of that booke, when he began the same treatise. Adde herewithall: that expresly in these wordes which we haue in hande, it is plainly called a sacrament, which if he had meant, that it should be vnderstoode in common, it had béene no lesse agréeable vnto those things that he had reckened before, namelie vnto the brasen serpent, and to the stone erected by Iacob, than vnto the Shewbreade. But in those wordes he expressed not this worde Sacrament, which afterward (that we may vnderstande hee speaketh of the Eucharist,) hee would not suppresse. Lastly he saith: The breade made for this purpose is eaten vp in the sacrament, which agréeth not with the Shewbreade: for that was not made to this ende, that it should be eaten, but that they béeing set vpon the table, should remaine before the Lord: wherfore they be called in the Hebrew Panim. Afterward it came to passe, yt without regarde or by hap, they were eaten, least happily it shold putrifie before the Lord. For therefore it was changed euery wéeke. And when it had béen once dedicated vnto God, he would haue this honor to be giuen vnto it, that it should be eaten of the Priests.
But the bread of our Eucharist was verily made to this purpose, that in receiving of the sacrament it should be eaten. And unto the arguments already said, I ad one more strong than the rest. For Augustine saith in the present tense: It is eaten, and not, It was eaten: which it behooved to have been, if he had spoken of a figure and ceremony of the olde testament. De Fide ad Petrum the 19. chapter, he calleth it a sacrament of bread and wine. As touching the memory and death of Christ he abundantly instructed the same Peter in the faith: but of this transubstantiation which these men so greatly urge at this day, he speaketh not one word. Against Faustus in the 20. book & the 21. chapter he saith, that the flesh and blood of Christ was promised to us in the old testament, under the similitude of sacrificed beasts: upon the cross it was given in very deed: but he saith, that in the sacrament it was celebrated by a memorial. And in the 21. book De Civitate dei the 25. chapter he plainly affirmeth, that the wicked do not eat the matter of the sacrament, that is, the body of Christ. For he is not to be accounted (saith he) to eat the body of Christ, which is not in the body of Christ. And he, in whom Christ abideth not, neither doeth he abide in Christ. And the like words he hath, in the 20. treatise upon John: but in the 30. treatise he saith: that the body of Christ is in some certain place in heaven, but that his truth is every where spread, which he therefore speaketh, because truth is spiritual, and is always present with the faithful. And communicants wheresoever they be, do confess Christ, and believe that he had a true body, & no feigned body as the heretics thought.
But the breade of our Eucharist was verily made to this purpose, that in receauing of the sacrament it should be eaten. And vnto the arguments already said, I ad one more strong than the rest. For Augustine saith in the present tence: It is eaten, and not, It was eaten: which it behooued to haue béen, if he had spoken of a figure and ceremonie of the olde testament. De Fide ad Petrum the 19. chapter, he calleth it a sacrament of breade and wine. As touching the memory and death of Christ he aboundantly instructed the same Peter in the faith: but of this transubstantiatiō which these men so greatly vrge at this day, he speaketh not one worde. Against Faustus in the 20. booke & the 21. chapter he saith, that the flesh and bloud of Christ was promised to vs in the olde testament, vnder the similitude of sacrificed beasts: vpon the crosse it was giuē in very déede: but he saith, that in the sacrament it was celebrated by a memoriall. And in the 21. booke De Ciuitate dei the 25. chapter he plainely affirmeth, that the wicked doe not eate the matter of the sacrament, that is, the bodie of Christ. For he is not to be accompted (saith he) to eate ye bodie of Christ, which is not in the bodie of Christ. And he, in whom Christ abideth not, neither doeth he abide in Christ. And the like wordes he hath, in the 20. treatise vpō Iohn: but in the 30. treatise he saith: yt the body of Christ is in some certaine place in heauen, but that his truth is euery where spread, which he therfore speaketh, bicause truth is spirituall, and is alwaies present with the faithfull. And communicants wheresoeuer they be, do confesse Christ, and beléeue that he had a true body, & no feined body as the heretikes thought.
27 Against Adamantus the Manichee the 12. Chapter he writeth: The Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when as yet he gave a sign of his body. Neither maketh it any matter if thou say: he gave both the sign and the thing signified: for Augustine had not respect unto this, but he would show that the saying is figurative, and like unto another which he allegeth out of Deuteronomy, The blood is the life. 1Therefore he said: the Lord doubted not, because in tropes or figures we dare do something. In his 3. Book of Christian doctrine the 16. Chapter, he showed that it was a figurative kind of speech which we have in the 6. of John, 2to wit: Unless ye shall eat the flesh of the Son of man, &c. because a wicked thing seemeth to be commanded. For it is more heinous to eat the flesh of man, than to kill him: and to drink blood, than to shed it. Therefore ⟨p. 163⟩(faith he) it is a commanding figure, namely, that we should sweetly & profitably lay up in memory the flesh of Christ, that was crucified and wounded for us. In an Epistle unto Boniface he said most plainly, that sacraments take their name of those things whereof they should be sacraments: and he expressed by name the sacrament of the body of Christ. And he addeth that the sacrament of the blood of Christ, is the blood of Christ. And all this he wrote to show that baptism is the Sacrament of faith, and that therefore it may be said that it is faith, and that young children being baptized have faith, because they receive this sacrament. And least that any should say, that these be signs substantially (as these men speak) of the thing present, let them consider of the similitudes which these men have alleged: to wit, that we say, when we be near unto Easter, that to morrow or the next day after shall be the Passion of the Lord, and upon Sunday the Lord rose again, when as yet these things are not now present but were done long before. Further, he here affirmeth, that the baptism of young children is faith; which nevertheless young children presently have not. Yea and the same father, as we have it De Consecratione distinct. 2. in the Chapter Interrogo vos, sayeth, that it is as sinful a negligence, to suffer the word which is preached, to slip out of our minds, as it is for a part of the sacrament to fall upon the earth.
Which if it were granted, this Transubstantiation would take but small place. For it would seem to be far more absurd, that the body it self of Christ should fall or be trodden under foot, than if any part of the holy words should be heard with small regard. Moreover upon the 8. Psalm he sayeth, that Christ admitted Judas in the supper, when he commē dead unto us the figure of his body. They are accustomed to say, that the figure or sign in this sacrament, which is the body of Christ, being hidden with accidents, is his own dead and unbloody body as he hung upon the Cross, and that the blood hidden under the accidents of wine is the figure of the blood shed upon the Altar of the Cross. But who perceiveth not that the devises of these men be vain? For there ought to be put a sign and figure, which is sensible & more known than the thing signified. Therefore the Master of the Sentences out of Augustine defined a sacrament to be a visible sign of an invisible grace. 1But the body of Christ being hidden under accidents, as themselves affirm is no less obscure than is that which hung upon the Cross: yea and if I may say the truth, more unknown and obscure than the thing signified. Which is against the nature of a sign and figure. For more easily is the body known and considered of us how it hung upon the Cross, than as they make it in the Eucharist.
Which if it were graunted, this Transubstantiation would take but small place. For it woulde séeme to be farre more absurd, that the bodie it selfe of Christ should fall or be troden vnder foote, than if any part of the holy wordes should be heard with small regard. Moreouer vpon the 8. Psalme he saieth, that Christ admitted Iudas in the supper, when he commē ded vnto vs the figure of his bodie. They are accustomed to say, that the figure or signe in this sacrament, which is the bodie of Christ, being hidden with accidents, is his owne dead and vnbloudie bodie as he hung vpon the Crosse, and that the bloud hidden vnder the accidents of wine is the figure of ye bloud shed vpon the Aultar of the Crosse. But who perceiueth not that the deuises of these men be vaine? For there ought to be put a signe and figure, which is sensible & more knowen than the thing signified. Therefore the Maister of the Sentences out of Augustine defined a sacrament to be a visible signe of an invisible grace. 1But the bodie of Christ being hidden vnder accidents, as themselues affirme is no lesse obscure than is that which hung vpon the Crosse: yea and if I may say the truth, more vnknowen and obscure than the thing signified. Which is against the nature of a signe and figure. For more easily is the bodie knowen and considered of vs how it hung vpon the Crosse, than as they make it in the Eucharist.
28 Leo the Pope in an Epistle unto the Clergy & people of Constantinople, wrote, 1that this is a mystical distribution, a spiritual food, and a heavenly virtue: That here we receive it, to the intent we may be made the flesh of Christ, who for our sakes took our flesh upon him. Cyrillus in the 4. 2Book and 14. Chapter upon John: On this wise he gave unto the believing Disciples pieces of bread, saying: Take ye. The same Father in an Epistle to Calosyrius: Wherefore it became him after a sort to be united unto our bodies, by his holy flesh, and by his precious blood, which we receive in the lively blessing in bread and wine. Now will we allege Theodoritus, Bishop of Cyrus: 3he lived in the time of Cyrillus, and was in the Synod of Ephesus, and Chalcedone: and he was accounted most learned and eloquent. And when in the Synod of Ephesus, there had happened a dissension between John the Patriarch of Antioch, and Cyrillus the Patriarch of Alexandria, it seemed good to Theodoritus to cleave unto the Patriarch of Antioch: howbeit the matter came to an agreement, and in the Synod of Chalcedone Theodoritus was known for a very learned man, and holy member of the Church of Christ, yea and in the books which he wrote, he purposely withstandeth Nestor, and by express words dealeth against him. The Book was printed at Rome. And the Papists perceived that he is most manifestly against Transubstantiation, and they have excused him for two causes. First for that the Church had not as yet pronounced as concerning that matter: as though we should seek what the Pope with his Cardinals decreed either at Constance, or in the Synod where Berengarius was condemned, and not rather what hath bin preached and believed in the old Church. Further they said, that this man in writing against Heretics, when he entreated of those mysteries, did overmuch lean unto the other part, and so was against Transubstantiation, to the intent the adversaries might be the easilier confuted. But how vain an excuse this is, it may appear by the discourse of the writer, where thou mayest perceive that not one word hath escaped him, but that the whole Argument and strength thereof is drawn from the nature of a sacrament; so as if thou mingle therewithal ⟨p. 164⟩Transubstantiation, there can be nothing concluded. Yea rather the Heretics will carry away the victory.
They add, that he in the self same book speaketh sometime more reverently of the Eucharist: but all things being considered, he speaketh no where so reverently that he is against our opinion, which we have now affirmed. He disputeth against them which denied that Christ had a true body, and said that his body at the time of his Ascension was wholly turned into the divine nature. First he allegeth the prophecy of the Patriarch Jacob that he may prepare himself a way to derive an argument from the sacraments. The words be these.
They adde, that he in the selfe same booke speaketh sometime more reuerently of the Eucharist: but all things being considered, he speaketh no where so reuerently that he is against our opinion, which we haue now affirmed. He disputeth against them which denied that Christ had a true bodie, and said that his bodie at the time of his Ascension was wholy turned into the diuine nature. First he alleageth the prophesie of the Patriarch Iacob that he may prepare himselfe a waie to deriue an argument from the sacraments. The wordes be these.
29 ORTH. Doest thou know that God called bread his own body? SOD. I know it. ORTH. And again that at another time his flesh was called Corn? SOD. This also I know: for I have heard him say that The hour cometh wherein the Son of man shall be glorified: 1and unless the grain of Corn be cast into the earth and die, it remaineth alone, but if it be dead, it will bring forth much fruit. ORTH. He undoubtedly in the delivery of the mysteries, called bread, his body, & the Cup mixed, his blood. SOD. So in deed he named it. ORTH. But it might also according to nature be called a body, yea even his own body and blood. SOD. It is granted. ORTH. Yea verily our Saviour himself changed the names; and to the body, he gave the name of the sign, and to the sign the name of the body. 2After the same manner also, when he said that he himself is the vine, he called his blood, the sign. SOD. This in deed is true: but I would also learn the cause of the changing of the names. ORTH. The end why it is so called is manifest unto them which be instructed in Religion. For he would that they which be partakers of those divine mysteries, should not have regard unto the nature of those things which be seen, but that by the changing of names they should believe that transmutation which is done by grace. For he that called his own natural body Corn, and bread, and also called himself a vine; even he himself also honoured those things, which seem to be signs, with the name of his body and blood: not forsooth changing nature it self, but unto nature adding grace. SOD. Truly the mystical things are spoken mystically, & those things which are not known unto all men are made clear and manifest. ORTH. Wherefore seeing he confesseth that the robe and garment is by the Patriarch called the Lords body, and that we be entered into the talk of divine mysteries, tell me in very deed, whose singe and figure thou thinkest that most holy meat to be? Was it the sign of the very divinity of Christ, or else of his own body and blood? SOD. Doubtless even of those things whereof also they received their names. ORTH. Doest thou mean, of the body & blood? SOD. So I mean. ORTH. Thou hast truly spoken: For the Lord taking the sign sayeth not: This is my divinity: but, This is my body: And again, This is my blood. And in another place:
29 ORTH. Doest thou know that God called bread his owne bodie? SOD. I knowe it. ORTH. And againe that at another time his flesh was called Corne? SOD. This also I know: for I haue heard him say that The houre commeth wherein the sonne of man shall be glorified:
But the bread which I will give for the life of the world. SOD. 1In very deed all these things be true, for they be the words of GOD. ORTH. Certainly if these things be true, the Lord had a body in deed. SOD. But I say that he is without body. ORTH. But thou confessest that he had a body, &c.
But the bread which I will giue for the life of the world. SOD. 1In verie déede al these things be true, for they bee the wordes of GOD. ORTH. Certainely if these things be true, the Lord had a bodie in déede. SOD. But I say that he is without bodie. ORTH. But thou confessest that he had a bodie, &c.
30 Out of the second Dialogue we have these words. SOD. We must doubtless (according to the proverb) remove every stone that we may attain unto the trueth, especially in setting forth the doctrine of God. ORTH Show me then: whereof the signs (which be offered unto God by the ministers of holy things) be mystical signs. SOD. Of the body and blood of the Lord. ORTH. OF the true body or not? SOD. Of the true body. ORTH. Very well said: for they must be a principal pattern of the Image. For the painters do follow nature, and they paint the Images of those things that be seen. SOD. Thou sayest true. ORTH. If then those divine mysteries be examples of a body being, then is the Lords body now also a body, and is not changed into the nature of divinity, but is replenished with divine glory. SOD. In good time hast thou moved this speech of divine mysteries: for thereby will I show thee a changing of the Lords body into an other nature: answer therefore unto my questions. ORTH. I will answer. SOD. What callest thou that gift which is offered before the priests invocation? ORTH. We must not speak openly: For it is very likely that some here present be not yet throughly instructed. SOD. This is a diffuse answer. ORTH. Look what seed it was, such meat it is. SOD. But how do we name the other sign? ORTH. This name also is common betokening a figure of the cup. SOD. How dost thou call those things after sanctification? ORTH. The body of Christ, and the blood of Christ. SOD. And doest thou believe, that thou receivest the body ⟨p. 165⟩and blood of Christ? ORTH. Yea verily I believe it. SOD. Therefore even as the signs of the body and blood of the Lord, be one thing undoubtedly before the invocation of the priest, but after the very invocation be changed from one to an other, and become other things: so likewise the body of the Lord, after it is received, is changed into divine substance. ORTH. Thou art caught in the same nets which thou hast laid. For those mystical signs, after sanctification do not change their own proper nature: 1for they in very deed remain in their former substance, both in figure and form, and are even so seen and handled as before: and the things that are done, are understood and believed & honoured, as though they were such as they are believed to be.
30 Out of the second Dialogue we haue these wordes. SOD. We must doubtlesse (according to the prouerbe) remooue euery stone that we may attaine vnto the trueth, especiallie in setting foorth the doctrine of God. ORTH Shew me then: whereof the signes (which be offered vnto God by the ministers of holy thinges) be mysticall signes. SOD. Of the bodie and bloud of the Lord. ORTH. OF the true bodie or not? SOD. Of the true bodie. ORTH. Very wel said: for they must be a principall patterne of the Image. For the painters doe followe nature, and they paint the Images of those thinges that be séene. SOD. Thou sayst true. ORTH. If then those diuine mysteries be examples of a bodie being, then is the Lordes bodie now also a bodie, and is not changed into the nature of diuinitie, but is replenished with diuine glory. SOD. In good time hast thou mooued this speach of diuine mysteries: for thereby will I shew thée a changing of the Lordes bodie into an other nature: aunswere therefore vnto my questions. ORTH. I will aunswere. SOD. What callest thou that gift which is offered before the priestes inuocation? ORTH. We must not speake openly: For it is very lykelie that some here present be not yet throughlie instructed. SOD. This is a diffuse aunswere. ORTH. Looke what séede it was, such meate it is. SOD. But how doe we name the other signe? ORTH. This name also is common betokening a figure of the cup. SOD. How doost thou call those thinges after sanctification? ORTH. The bodie of Christ, and the bloud of Christ. SOD. And doest thou beléeue, that thou receauest the bodie
Compare therefore the Image with the principal figure, and thou shalt see the similitude. For a figure must agree with the trueth. For that very body it self hath his first figure, and form, and circumscription, and (to speak plainly) the very substance also of a body. But after the resurrection it became immortal, and it is accounted worthy of the seat which is at the right hand of God, and is worshipped of all creatures, as a body being of the Lords own nature. SOD. Howbeit that mystical sign changeth his first name, and is not afterward named by that name which it was first called, but is called a body. Wherefore the trueth it self, must now be called God, and not any more a body. ORTH. Thou appearest ignorant unto me: it is not only called a body, but also the bread of life: for so the Lord called it. Yea and we also call this a divine body and a quickening body, and the masters body, and the Lords body, teaching, that it is no common body of every man, but the body of our Lord Jesus Christ, who is God and man: even Jesus Christ, yesterday and to day, and the same for ever.
Compare therfore the Image with the principall figure, and thou shalt sée the similitude. For a figure must agrée with the trueth. For that very bodie it selfe hath his first figure, and forme, and circumscription, and (to speake plainlie) the very substance also of a bodie. But after the resurrection it became immortall, and it is accounted woorthie of the seate which is at the right hand of God, and is woorshipped of all creatures, as a bodie being of the Lordes owne nature. SOD. Howbeit that mysticall signe changeth his first name, and is not afterward named by that name which it was first called, but is called a bodie. Wherefore the trueth it selfe, must now be called God, and not any more a bodie. ORTH. Thou appearest ignorant vnto me: it is not onely called a bodie, but also the bread of life: for so the Lord called it. Yea and we also call this a diuine bodie and a quickening bodie, and the maisters bodie, and the Lordes bodie, teaching, that it is no common bodie of euerie man, but the bodie of our Lord Iesus Christ, who is God and man: euen Iesu Christ, yesterday and to day, and the same for euer.
31 There is extant an Epistle in the Library of Florence (albeit not imprinted) of Chrysostom to Caesarius the Monk in the time of his second banishment, 12written against Apollinaris and others which confoū dead the divinity and humanity of Christ. Christ is both God and man: God because he cannot suffer; Man, because of his passion and suffering: One Son, one Lord, one and the self same doubtless possessing one dominion, and one power of the natures united (although they be not together of one substance) and each one of them being unmingled keepeth an acknowledgement of his own property: for this cause that they be two things not confounded. For like as before the bread be sanctified, we name it bread, and the same being sanctified, by the divine grace by means of the priest is undoubtedly delivered from the name of bread, and is accounted worthy to be called the Lords body, although the nature of bread have remained in it, and is declared not to be two bodies but one body of the Son: even so this divine [Greek or Hebrew], that is to say, the nature of an overflowing body, hath made both these one Son and one person. Hesychius in the 20. 3book upon Leviticus the 8. Chapter: Therefore he commandeth that the flesh should be eaten with bread, to the intent we might understand the same to be called a mystery of him, because it is flesh and bread together. 4Gelasius against Eutiches wrote that in the Sacrament of the Eucharist the substance and nature of bread and wine do not cease to be: and he maketh a comparison of this Sacrament with Christ, in whom both the natures aswell divine as humane remain whole, even as in this Sacrament doth the nature of bread and of the body of Christ. Gregory in the register: 5while we take aswell the sweet bread as the leavened bread, we are made one body of the Lord our Saviour. 6Bertram in his little book De Corpore & Sanguine Domini, saith as touching the natures of the signs, that according to the substance of the creatures look what they were before consecration, the same they remain afterward.
as it cometh to pass in the consecration of Bishops, where the King, or the Crosiers staff, or the labels of the Mitre, be signs of things given and granted, and yet no vain signs. For the things which they signify are most certainly given. The very which I have showed to be done in Sacraments.
as it commeth to passe in the consecration of Byshops, where the King, or the Crosiers staffe, or the labels of the Miter, be signes of thinges giuen and graunted, and yet no vaine signes. For the thinges which they signifie are most certainelie giuen. The very which I haue shewed to be doone in Sacramentes.
111 Furthermore, the nature of a sacrament is corrupted, of which Augustine vpon Iohn saieth, The woorde commeth vnto the element, and it is made a sacrament. The nature thereof is, that it should be made of these two things: but as these men appoint the elements, that is, the bread and wine are taken awaie: And then Augustine ought not to haue said: The worde commeth vnto the element, 2but, It taketh awaie the element. And while they remooue the natures of the elements, ye proportion of the significatiō perisheth. Wherefore the bread signifieth the bodie of Christ, because it nourisheth, strēgtheneth, and sustaineth: which we cannot attribute vnto accidents. It is also a signification of many graines gathered in one, which representeth the mysticall bodie, and that cannot be attributed vnto accidents. Wherfore Paul said: 3We that are manie, are one bread and one bodie, because we are partakers of one bread. 4In baptisme, water is said to be the fountaine of regeneration, 5and because the substaunce thereof is preserued, that doeth verie well agrée, for the accidents of water would not be conuenient. And in taking awaie of the substance of bread and wine in the proposition, 6This is my bodie, they abuse the verbe substantine Is, for it is transubstantiated, turned or changed from one to another. For while they vtter those wordes of the Lorde, the bread is not yet the bodie of Christ. Wherfore if they would vnderstand Is in his own true significatiō, they should vtter that which is false. Therefore among the schoolemen, some graunt that the verb Is should be taken for, To be made, To be changed, or turned. Moreouer they attribute this power or efficacie vnto those fewe wordes of the Lord, that so often as they be repeated, this changing is made, and yet haue they not in the holie Scriptures any worde thereof. And if a man should speake those wordes which Paul, Matthew, Marke, or Luke hath, they would thinke that there is no consecration: for they ascribe all the vertue vnto the wordes of their owne Canon. But we knowe that then the sacrament is, when we doe those things which Christ did and commanded to be doone: but he not onely spake those wordes, but he also gaue thankes, he brake the breade, he did eate, and he reached it vnto others to eate.
12 They fall into many absurdities, 1and those inexplicable: for therein they affirme that there maie be a bodie, and that in infinite places together and at one verie time. But they saie, that this is no hinderaunce vnto them, because though the body of Christ be there, yet is it not by the waie of quantitie. And this is to be woondred at how they place a body and a quantitie, and to be trulie present: and yet not by the way of quantitie. And séeing they affirme him to be trulie present, and corporallie, and carnallie as they say, but not locallie, who perceiueth not that these bee argumentes inuented to deceiue? 2They obiect that this was giuen to the humane bodie of Saint Ambrose, 3who being at Millaine was present at Turon in the funerals of Saint Martin, and there was séene: Why (say they) shall not this which Ambrose had, be rather granted to the bodie of Christ? But they take as graunted, which we graunt not. For it might be, 4that it was reuealed vnto Ambrose, and that it séemed vnto him he was present at those funerals, and by the help of Angels he was perhappes represented in them and vnto the sight of the people, but that his bodie was verily in both places together, we will not graunt. Further we might leaue it to the author of the myracle recited, to consider whether it bée true or no. 5They oppose againe as touching soules, that whereas they be creatures, yet eache one of them is in the head, and in al the members of our bodie. 6But they deale verie vnwiselie, which compare a spirite with a bodie, and that they would haue to bee giuen vnto bodies which they may lawfullie doe vnto a spirit. Christ saide plainelie: 7A spirit hath no flesh and boanes, whereby hee ⟨p. 155⟩put no small difference betwéene them. Further if we should graunt, that that is to be giuen vnto the bodie which our soule hath, it followeth not that the bodie of Christ can bee in diuers places, because our soule and the Angels cannot be in diuers places at one and the selfe same time: For they be creatures, and therefore of a power limited and definite.
13 There followe also many other inconueniences: 1because if the myce haue gnawen these sacred hosts, they wil say, that they eate accidents. And if they be filled and satisfied, this also shall be a worke of Accidents. And if it happen that a sacrificing Priest, doe vtter those wordes ouer a great vessell of wine, and ouer a great chest full of bread, and that thou demand what filleth the vessell, what the chest, or what also filled the bellies of them which did eate and drinke thereof: they would answere, Accidents. And because those that eate, are sustained, some of them dare to saie, that God createth in the bellies of the eaters and drinkers, either fleame or some other humor, which may be conuerted into bloud whereby they should be nourished. §16But and if that that sacrament be burned, as it was doone in the time of Hesychius (which thing he himself testifieth vpon Leuiticus, and the very same hath Origen vpon the same booke,) vndoubtedly ashes will remaine, and by that meanes shall a substance be procreated out of accidents. In like maner wormes may arise of the bread consecrated, & there also they will say that substance is brought forth of accidents. Albeit, (as they be bold felowes,) some of them faine that ye former matter is by myracle brought againe, by reason whereof these things may happen. But if it be lawfull after this manner to bréede and feine myracles, euerie diuine may escape as he will. For to euery intricate matter he will apply a myracle, and so will he vnwinde himselfe out of all Arguments which shall be obiected against him. §17These things they affirme not onely by myracles, but also by subtill sophisticall arguments. As Scotus when he is vrged in the vttering of those wordes: This is my bodie, that he should tell vs what is shewed in the subiect of the proposition, at length answereth, 2that there is demonstration made of some singular or particular thing of a more generall substance, which together with that which is affirmed thereof doeth shewe the selfe same thing or (as the schoolemen said) is of the selfe same supposition: neither do those things differ one from another which are signified by the subiect and that which thereof is affirmed, except it be by a diuers manner of conceiuing. Sée whereinto they rush and yet for all that they escape not. For it is not yet answered by them what is shewed, when it is said, This is my bodie.
14 They which say, that the body of Christ is really ioyned with the signes, the natures I meane of bread and wine being preserued, doe thus argue against Transubstantiation: What dignitie or priuiledge haue Accidentes, that they can be ioyned with the body of Christ, which ought to be denyed to the substance and nature of bread? And if the Accidentes can remaine, why shall not also the substance of bread be retained? Yea rather, many of the fathers suppose, that this may be doone. And thence they take a similitude, that the humane and diuine natures in Christ doe verily remaine, and so remaine, as one passeth not into another: whose opinions we will bring in when time shall serue. §19They fall also into an other absurditie: for while they breake the Sacrament, 1we demaund of them what they break there. Here they stagger and some haue said, as testifyeth the maister of the sentences in the 4. booke, that the essence or substance of the body of Christ is broken: but this opinion is by him confuted: because the body of Christ is immortall, and therefore it is not subiect to these things, and to new chaunces. There were others which said that the same is no true breaking, but that it onely appeareth to be, and so séemeth vnto our senses. And this is also reiected, least we should establish here a perpetuall illusion. At length they say, that they be accidents which be broken. And when as they after a sort appoint a Mathematicall quantitie, that is, a quantitie separated from matter, which if it be diuided, it is onely doone by the power of the minde and by the promptnesse of the vnderstanding. These men also diuide in very déede, so as the partes diuided may most manifestly be séene. §20In Ieremy we reade, 2Let vs cast wood vppon his bread: which place is ⟨p. 156⟩cited by Tertullian and Lactantius, and they interpret that this was spoken of putting the wood of the crosse into the body of Christ: and they will that mention was made of bread, because through bread Christ was to giue himselfe vnto vs. And that which the Prophet speaketh, 3they will haue to be a figure of the bread of the Sacrament: which séeing these men take away, and onely leaue a figure vnto vs, they affirme a figure of a figure, so as no sound thing remaineth.
15 Againe we will bring a reason taken frō baptisme. A little before we argued from thence, that for the trueth of that Sacrament it was not requisite that water should be transubstantiated: now we reason from ye men themselues which be baptised, 1of whom the Scripture plainely saith that they lay away the olde man, and are againe begotten: and yet is there no Transubstantiation imagined in them, neuerthelesse generation is described to be a motion whereby a new substance is gotten. 2Wherefore it is no maruell that Nichodemus tooke offence at the wordes of the Lord, wherein it was shewed him that he should be borne againe. For while he thought with himselfe that a new generation was preached vnto man already brought foorth and well in yeares, he stood in a doubt. But and if we interpret that generation to be new, and the natiuitie to be spiritual, why doe we not vouchsafe to doe the same in the Eucharist? And why doe we not transferre all thinges vnto spirituall eating? I gladly ioyne together these two Sacramentes, Baptisme and the Eucharist, because Paul in the 1. 3Epistle to the Corinthians the 12. Chap. knitteth them together, 4when he saith: All wee by one spirit are baptised into one body, and haue bin all made to drinke with one spirit. Neither is it of any force, if thou shalt say, that we be baptised into one body, to wit, the mysticall body, because from the mysticall body Christ is not absent, séeing he is the head thereof. And else where Paul most plainely saith, 5that We in baptisme put on Christ. §22We see moreouer, that the holy writers bring out of the 6. Chapter of Iohn many thinges as touching the Sacrament of the Eucharist. Yea rather, there is none of the fathers which in the interpreting of that chapter, writeth not plētifully of the Eucharist. Whereupon we conclude a reason after this manner: 6The thinges which be there spoken, either serue vnto this sacrament or they serue not: if they belong not vnto this, what néede is there to rite them, or by those places to dispute of the Eucharist? But if they haue respect vnto this, séeing there is onely a spirituall eating, that is by faith, whereby is receaued the true body and bloud of Christ, what néede is there to bring in an other new receauing, and to imagin a carnal eating, whereby the same thing should be receaued againe?
16 Hereunto it serueth, that Christ said vnto his Apostles about the ende of his life, 1that he would leaue the world and would depart from them: which should not bée true, if he were with vs by transubstantiation as these men would. They haue vsed to aunswere that Christ left the world as touching mortall conditions, and as touching familiaritie ⟨p. 157⟩and bodilie conuersation. These indéede are subtile shifts, but they serue not to the purpose. For when Christ spake these wordes, 2Philip aunswered: Beholde nowe thou speakest plainelie, and without parables. Howbeit if it were so to be vnderstood, the spéech had béene obscure and like a parable. Further if Christ remaine with vs so corporallie in the Eucharist, he might by the same reason remaine both in our heartes, & also in our selues. Therefore hee might still after his ascension rule the Church by his owne selfe, and bee present with his Apostles. 3But he saieth, that hee would leaue a vicar in his stead: namelie the holie Ghost, who had not béene necessarie, if whole Christ as touching diuinitie & humanitie (as these men will) were present. For séeing the flesh and bodie of him is by participation in eache one of vs (according to their doctrine) and that his godhead is present, hee might deale by his owne selfe without the holie Ghost to be ye prompter. §25Marie the mother of the Lord, the most blessed virgin, when shee had heard of the Angel, 4that the word of GOD should take flesh vpon him, and that she was chosen to conceiue & bring foorth the sonne of God, she iudged these to be strange and woonderful things, and demaunded howe these things should be, & so forth. But this translation of the bread into the bodie of Christ, séeing it is no lesse matter than is that mysterie of his incarnation and natiuitie of the Virgin, it is a woonder that in the holy scriptures there is founde neither admiration nor question demaunded of that matter: and that in none of the writings of the Euangelists or Apostles, 5this beliefe of Transubstantiation is commēded vnto vs, being a thing of so great importance. Neither doe we hearken vnto some that say, in the 6. Chapter of Iohn there went a question before: because the answere that was there giuen of spirituall eating, they wil now transferre vnto this sacramentall eating, which neuerthelesse they assigne to be another than that was.
17 Other inconueniences and absurdities doe follow the faining of these things. For Christ said: 1I will that where I am, there also my minister should be: and he spake the same often times to his Apostles. 2And in the Apocalips wee reade of certaine Martyrs: They follow him wheresoeuer he shall goe. Whereupon woulde be concluded, that in the Eucharist, not onely shoulde be affirmed Transubstantiation into the bodie of Christ, but into all the Saints. Which if it displease them, let them leaue Christ in heauen with his saints, otherwise they shal follow him together for companie. But they say: 3We suffer him also to be in heauen, visible and in his Maiestie and glorie, but yet herein the sacrament wee affirme him to be inuisible: and those things which be obiected as touching the fellowship of the Saints and Martyrs, they be true as touching Christ, according as he is visible in heauen in his glorie and Maiestie. This answere leaneth vppon a false grounde: for it admitteth that one and the same bodie of Christ is in many places at once: which the fathers denie. It admitteth that Christ is with vs as touching his bodie and flesh; whereas he said, that as touching these things, 4he woulde send another in his place, namely, the holy Ghost. §27Neither can they auoide it that Christ had two bodies, séeing in the supper when he had taken bread into his hands, 5if it had bin trāsubstantiated into his bodie, yet he himselfe had borne his owne bodie with his bodie, and it should bée necessarie to graunt both the bodie bearing and the bodie borne to be both one, when as neuerthelesse one and the same agent and pacient in respect of one and the selfe same thing in one verie time cannot be. 6And thus we sée into what absurdities they cast themselues. 7They are woont to bring Augustine vpon the Psalmes, who said that Christ bare himselfe in his owne handes. 8But if the place which is written vppon the 73. Psalme be considered, that he, After a sort, bare himselfe in his owne handes: that also doe we graunt, because he bare in his owne handes the sacrament of his owne body, and not properly and really his owne body. Adde that because Christ communicated with his Apostles, it followeth that he did eate his owne selfe. But they haue béene accustomed to answere, that these things be exercises of our faith.
20 Ouer this we ought to call to minde, that the time of humilitie and submission of Christ is passed away, & that he nowe raigneth in heauen, and yt he hath a name which is aboue euerie name. Wherfore then should it be requisite by transubstantiation to send him downe againe communicated as touching the bodie into our iawes and bellies? I knowe that they say hee is not hurt, 1hee draweth no vncleanesse. I will grant it, 2but yet it is not very decent, that, as they say, he should be detained vnder those accidentes so long as they remaine sound: 3which thinges when they shalbe dissolued, they say that the bodie of Christ flieth away. Whereby it ⟨p. 159⟩commeth to passe that they dailie and especiallie vntil noonetide constraine him perpetuallie to depart and flie away. 4But they say, that we must let these cogitations passe, and yet they themselues by their carnall Transubstantiation doe suggest the same. §325If they might be brought that wee shoulde doe all things there spiritually, there would bee no such cogitation. And while they appoint this his naturall and carnall bodie to be present, doe they it to the intent that he should penetrate our soule? Or else that he may conueigh himselfe into our bodie? Into the soule they cannot say; because nothing is there taken carnally or corporally. But and if they would that the bodie should be penetrated by him, we demaund why he will doe this vnto it? They will answer, to the intent that man may be sanctified. 6But it is méete that sanctification should begin at the soule, not at the bodie. They say that a certaine power and efficacie is imprinted by the water, and that the soule is made the better, and the bodie also confirmed. But if we speake of ye power, it is not of necessitie yt this should be by transubstantiation, séeing it maie haue it without the same. §36And the auncient Fathers, when they taught the nature of this Sacrament, said, that an vnbloudie sacrifice is here sacrificed, which will not well agrée, if wee should determine that there is true and corporall bloud. 7Neither doeth it suffice that they say: 8it is an vnbloudie sacrifice, bebecause Christ is not here slaine, nor yet his bloud violently drawne forth. 9For although that these things be not doone, yet without bloud (according to the grosse imagination of these men) the thing is not doone.
21 Besides foorth we sée, that Christ in the Eucharist instituted a sacrament, 1wherby it commeth to passe that all thinges be doone there sacramentally. Neither is it required, that in Sacramentes more should be giuen or desired than the reason of a Sacrament shall require. Further, if we weigh what Christ did in that last supper, we may easily perceiue the thing, it is prooued, that he gaue his owne body. If we demaund further, what manner of one he gaue, they cannot determine with themselues. §38Some séeme to say, that he gaue such as he had, namely a passible and mortall body. 2Howbeit such a body with those conditions which it then had, might not carnally, as these men dreame, be contained in small péeces of bread. §39But others which thinke themselues wiser, say that Christ in himselfe had a body mortall and passible: but that in bread he gaue a glorified and spirituall body. Then dooth that make against them, which we read in the wordes of the Lord: 3This is my body which is giuen for you, and my bloud which shall be shed for you: Where he plainely extendeth his speach both vnto the body which he then had, and vnto the bloud which he at the same houre possessed. For these glorified and impassible thinges he receaued not vntill the resurrection was past. But admit it as they say: §40We argue, the conditions of the body passible and glorified are contrary one to an other, so as they cannot both together at one time be in one subiect. Whereuppon it followeth that if ye will haue them put into the body of Christ at one very time, ye make Christes body to be twaine. §41Experience and the histories teach vs, that we must not allow of Transubstantiation, because they write that Victor the Pope of Rome dyed by drinking of poyson out of the challice. 4And Henry the Emperor was poysoned by taking of bread in the Eucharist. If all things be there transubstantiated, 5and that only accidentes are remaining, how may these thinges be? We know that euery of the Sacramentes (as the aduersaries themselues speake) consist of matter and forme. The matter, they say, is the signes or elements, but the forme they say is that which is added by the word. §42But that which is compounded of the two, must not cast away the one, so as nothing thereof should remaine but accidentes: otherwise the nature of composition and coniunction would not be kept.
22 This Sacrament is not onely called the Sacrament of the body of Christ our sauiour, ⟨p. 160⟩but also of the mysticall bodie: wherefore Paul in the first Epistle to the Corinthians sayd: 1Ye be the body of Christ: and again, We that are many, be one bread and one body, which be partakers of one bread. And Augustine in his 22. booke De Ciuitate Dei, the 10. Chapter, saith that Christians doe not offer sacrifice vnto Martyrs. The sacrifice vndoubtedlie is the body of Christ, which is not offered vnto Martyrs, because they thē selues be the same, to wit, the body of Christ. Wherefore séeing this Sacrament is of both the bodies, 2euen as they appoint not that the bread should be transubstantiated into the bodie mysticall: so it may not be required that it should be truely and properlie cōuerted into the bodie of the Lord, séeing it is declared to be the Sacrament aswell of the one as of the other. §44And of this opinion it would followe, that aswell the faithfull as the vnfaithfull doe receaue the bodie of the Lord, 3which I haue elsewhere disprooued by two reasons. First, that seeing the bodie of Christ is not plucked away from the spirit of Christ, it would followe that the wicked should receaue the spirit of Christ. Secondly, séeing infidels be dead as touching ye inward man, they altogether want the instrument whereby they should receaue spirituall thinges. And Augustine plainelie said: that none doe eate the bodie of Christ, but they which be of his bodie. And Ierom in the 4. booke vppon Ieremy the 22. Chapter: And whereas he inferreth: They shall not eate and drinke, he vnderstandeth the bodie and bloud of our Sauiour. And he spake of the Heretickes. And the same Father vppon Esay the 66. Chapter: While they be not holy in bodie & in spirit, neither doe they eate the flesh of Iesus nor doe drinke his bloud. And manie such like places are had out of the Fathers. §45And whereas here they so very often pretend vnto vs manie miracles, we must not so easilie giue credit, because miracles are not woont to be brought in, vnlesse it be in respect that they be strange and woonderfull thinges, by whose vnaccustomed happening, a weight may be added vnto the word of God. For then men be stricken with admiration, and may be easily led to imbrace the doctrine of Christ.
23 But now let vs consider of the Fathers whether they so iudge or no. Irenaeus against the Valentiniā hereticks: 1The earthly bread (saith he) when it hath receaued that facultie from the word of God, it is no more common bread, but is made the Eucharist, which consisteth of two thinges, to wit, earthlie and heauenlie. First of all he denieth not the Eucharist to be bread, except thou make it cōmon bread. Afterward he saith yt it consisteth of two thinges, whereof the one is terrestriall as bread, the other celestiall, as the bodie of Christ. And as on the one part is retained the trueth, to wit, as touching the bodie of the Lorde: so in the other part it is to be preserued, namely as touching bread. And he addeth by a similitude: euen so our bodies receauing the same be no more corruptible. 2Tertullian in his first booke against Marcion saith, that God cast not away bread being his creature, séeing in it he represented his bodie. And in the 4. booke against ye same Marcion, He receiuing bread & distributing to his disciples made ye same to be his bodie, saying, This is my body, that is, a figure of my body. But a figure it should not be, vnlesse it were a bodie of the trueth. Origen vpon the booke of Numbers, 3Homilie 16. We are said to drinke the bloud of Christ, not onely by the rite of the Sacramentes, but also when we receaue his word. The very which thing Ierom also wrote sometimes vppon Ecclesiast. the 3. Chapter. The same Origen vpon Matthew the 26. Chapter: This bread which God, being ye word, confesseth to be his body, is a nourishing word of soules. Vppon Leuiticus the 7. Homilie: For there is in the Gospell also a letter yt killeth, & not in the olde Testament onelie. For if according to ye letter, thou followe yt which is said: Vnlesse ye shall eate my flesh, & so foorth. And in the same booke, homilie the 9. Doe ⟨p. 161⟩not thou stand in a doubt in the bloud of the flesh, but learne rather the bloud of the word, and heare him speaking vnto thée. For this is my bloud which is shed for you. Origen vpon Matthew the 15. Chapter: The bread sanctified as touching that which it hath materiall passeth into the bellie and is cast out into the draught. And straightway after: Not the matter of the bread but the word spoken ouer the same is it that profiteth, yet not him that vnwoorthilie eateth it vnto the Lord. The same father against Celsus the 8. booke:
25 Ambrose in his exposition of the first Epistle to the Corinthians, 1when he speaketh of doing this in remembrance of Christ and his death, saith that we in eating and drinking of the flesh and bloud of Christ, doe signifie the things that be offred. And again, about the selfe same place he saith: that we take it into the mysticall cup for a figure of Christ his bloud. And in the fourth booke the fourth chapter, where he putteth a changing of the signes, he intreateth also of our changing into Christ: and yet it is not affirmed that they which receiue the Sacrament be transubstantiated. And the same Father in the same fourth booke de Sacramentis ye fourth chapter: This we adde moreouer: How can it be that which is bread should by consecration be the body of Christ? And straight way: If there be so great a strength in the worde of the Lorde, as things should begin to be which were not, how much rather is the worde so effectuous, that the things which were may remaine, and yet be changed into an other thing? Ierome vpon Matthew saith plainly, 2that in breade and wine are represented the body and bloud of the Lord. Chrysostome vpon the later Epistle vnto the Corinthians saith, that not alonely that which is set before vs vpon the table is the body of Christ, but also the poore people vnto whom we are bound to do good: bicause euen he that saith, This is my body, said also by his word, that he receiueth almes and is néedie in the poore. In his eleuenth homily vpon Matthew in his worke which is called vnperfect: he saith that in the holy vessels there is not the body of Christ and the bloud of Christ, but a mysterie of the body and bloud of Christ. Also vpon the twelfth chapter of the seconde Epistle to the Corinthians the 27. homilie: Euen as Christ, both in the breade and in the cup said, Do this in the remembrance of me. The same father vpon the 22. psalme, vpon these wordes, Thou hast prepared a table in my ⟨p. 162⟩sight. As it is shewed vnto vs that there is euery day in the sacrament breade and wine according to the order of Melchisedech, vnto thē similitude of the body and blood of Christ. Emisenus whom they cite de Consecratione distinct. 32. And he séemeth to put a change of the signes: euen the selfesame man maketh mention of our changing into Christ.
28 Leo the Pope in an Epistle vnto the Clergie & people of Constantinople, wrote, 1that this is a mysticall distribution, a spirituall foode, and a heauenly vertue: That here we receiue it, to the intent we may bée made the flesh of Christ, who for our sakes tooke our flesh vppon him. Cyrillus in the 4. 2Booke and 14. Chapter vpon Iohn: On this wise he gaue vnto the beléeuing Disciples péeces of bread, saying: Take ye. The same Father in an Epistle to Calosyrius: Wherefore it became him after a sort to be vnited vnto our bodies, by his holy flesh, and by his precious bloud, which we receiue in the liuely blessing in bread and wine. Now will we alleage Theodoritus, Bishop of Cyrus: 3he liued in the time of Cyrillus, and was in the Synode of Ephesus, and Chalcedone: and he was accounted most learned and eloquent. And when in the Synode of Ephesus, there had happened a discension betwéene Iohn the Patriarche of Antioch, and Cyrillus the Patriache of Alexandria, it séemed good to Theodoritus to cleaue vnto the Patriarche of Antioch: howbeit the matter came to an agréement, and in the Synode of Chalcedone Theodoritus was knowen for a verie learned man, and holy member of the Church of Christ, yea and in the bookes which he wrote, he purposely withstandeth Nestor, and by expresse wordes dealeth against him. The Booke was printed at Rome. And the Papistes perceiued that he is most manifestly against Transubstantiation, and they haue excused him for two causes. First for that the Church had not as yet pronounced as concerning that matter: as though wée shoulde séeke what the Pope with his Cardinals decreed either at Constance, or in the Synode where Berengarius was condemned, and not rather what hath bin preached and beléeued in the olde Church. Further they saide, that this man in writing against Hereticks, whē he intreated of those mysteries, did ouermuch leane vnto the other part, and so was against Transubstantiation, to the intent the aduersaries might be the easilier confuted. But how vaine an excuse this is, it may appeare by the discourse of the writer, where thou maiest perceiue that not one word hath escaped him, but that the whole Argument and strength thereof is drawen from the nature of a sacrament; so as if thou mingle therewithall ⟨p. 164⟩Transubstantiation, there can bée nothing concluded. Yea rather ye Heretickes will carrie away the victorie.
31 There is extant an Epistle in the Lybrarie of Florence (albeit not imprinted) of Chrysostome to Caesarius the Moonke in the time of his second banishment, 12written against Appolinaris and others which confoū ded the diuinitie and humanitie of Christ. Christ is both God and man: God because he cannot suffer; Man, because of his passion and suffering: One sonne, one Lord, one and the selfe same doubtlesse possessing one dominion, and one power of the natures vnited (although they be not together of one substance) and each one of them being vnmingled kéepeth an acknowledgement of his owne propertie: for this cause that they be two thinges not confounded. For like as before the bread be sanctified, we name it bread, and the same being sanctifyed, by the diuine grace by meanes of the priest is vndoubtedlie deliuered from the name of bread, and is accounted woorthie to be called the Lords bodie, although the nature of bread haue remained in it, and is declared not to be two bodies but one bodie of the sonne: euen so this diuine 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that is to say, the nature of an ouerflowing bodie, hath made both these one sonne and one person. Hesychius in the 20. 3booke vppon Leuiticus the 8. Chapter: Therefore he commaundeth that the flesh should be eaten with bread, to the intent we might vnderstand the same to be called a mysterie of him, because it is flesh and bread together. 4Gelasius against Eutiches wrote that in the Sacrament of the Eucharist the substance and nature of bread and wine doe not cease to be: and he maketh a comparison of this Sacrament with Christ, in whom both the natures aswell diuine as humane remaine whole, euen as in this Sacrament dooth the nature of bread and of the bodie of Christ. Gregorie in the register: 5while we take aswell the swéete bread as the leauened bread, we are made one bodie of the Lord our Sauiour. 6Bertram in his little booke De Corpore & Sanguine Domini, saith as touching the natures of the signes, that according to the substāce of the creatures looke what they were before consecration, the same they remaine afterward. 7Bernard in his Sermon De Coena Domini, manifestlie setteth foorth a similitude of a King, whereby any man receaueth either the faith of wedlock or the possession of some dignitie: