pp. 1795–18431,445 passagespart 24 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Christo. You understand Cyprian well in deed: I think you never red him in your life.
Christo. You vnderstand Cyprian well in deed: I thinke you neuer red hym in your lyfe.
Phil. Yes, M. Doct. that I have, I can show you a book noted with mine own hand: though I have not read so much as you, yet I have read somewhat. It is shame for you to wrest and wreath the Doctors as you do, to maintain a false religion, which be altogether against you, if you take them aright, and in deed your false packing of doctors together,1 hath given me and others occasion to look upon them, whereby we find you shameful liars, and misreporters of the ancient doctors.
Phil. Yes, M. Doct. that I haue, I can shew you a booke noted with myne owne hand: though I haue not read so much as you, yet I haue read somewhat. It is shame for you to wrast and wreath the Doctors as you do, to maintain a fals religion, which be altogether against you, if you take them aright, and in deede your false packing of doctors together,1 hath geuen me and others occasion to looke vpon them, wherby we find you shamefull liers, and misreporters of the ancient doctors.
Morgan. What, will you be in hand to allow doctors now? they of your sect do not so. I marvel thereof you will allow them.
Morgan. What, wil you be in hand to allow doctors now? they of your sect do not so. I meruaile thereof you will allow them.
Phil. I do allow them in as much as they do agree with the scriptures, and so do all they which be of the truth, how so ever you term us: and I praise God for that good understanding I have received by them.
Phil. I do allow them in as much as they doe agree wyth the scriptures, and so do al they which be of the truth, how so euer you terme vs: and I prayse God for that good vnderstandyng I haue receyued by them.
Christo. What, you understand not the Doctors, you may be ashamed to say it.
Christo. What, you vnderstand not the Doctors, you may be ashamed to say it.
Phil. I thank God I understand them better then you: for you have Excaecationem cordis, The blindness of heard, so that you understand not truly what you read, no more then the wall here, as the taking of Cyprian doth well declare. And afore God, you are but deceivers of the people,1 for all your brag you make of learning, neither have ye Scripture or ancient doctor on your side, being truly taken.
Phil. I thanke God I vnderstand them better then you: for you haue Excaecationem cordis, The blindnes of heard, so that you vnderstand not truely what you read, no more then the wall here, as the takyng of Cyprian doth wel declare. And afore God, you are but deceyuers of the people,1 for all your brag you make of learnyng, neyther haue ye Scripture or auncient doctour on your side, being truly taken.
Morgan. Why, all the Doctors be on our side, and against you altogether.
Morgan. Why, all the Doctors be on our side, and agaynst you altogether.
Phil. Yea, so you say when you be in your pulpits alone, & none to answer you. But if you will come to cast accounts with me thereof, I will venture with you a recantation, that I (as little sight as I have in the doctors) will bring more authorities of ancient Doctors on my side, then you shall be able for yours, and he that can bring most, to him let the other side yield. Are ye so content herewith?
Phil. Yea, so you say when you be in your pulpits alone, & none to answer you. But if you wil come to cast accounts with me therof, I will venter with you a recantatiō, that I (as little sight as I haue in the doctors) wil bring more authorities of ancient Doctors on my side, then you shall be able for yours, and he yt can bring most, to him let ye other side yeeld. Are ye so content herewith?
Christo. It is but folly to reason with you: you will believe no man but yourself.
Christo. It is but folly to reason with you: you wil beleue no man but yourselfe.
Phil. I will believe you or any other learned man, if you can bring any thing worthy to be believed. You cannot win me with vain words from my faith. Before God there is no truth in you.
Phil. I will beleue you or any other learned man, if you cā bring any thing worthy to be beleued. You cannot winne me with vaine words from my fayth. Before God there is no truth in you.
Morgan. What, no truth, no truth? ha, ha, he.
Phil. Except the Articles of the Trinity, you are corrupt in all other things, and sound in nothing.
Phil. Except the Articles of the Trinitie, you are corrupt in all other thyngs, and sound in nothyng.
Morgan. What say you? do we not believe well on the sacrament?
Morgan. What say you? do we not beleeue well on the sacrament?
Philpot. It is the thing which (among all other) you do most abuse.
Philpot. It is the thing which (among all other) you doe most abuse.
Morgan. Wherein I pray you? tell us.
Morgan. Wherein I pray you? tell vs.
Phil. I have told you before (M. Doct.) in the Convocation house.
Phil. I haue told you before (M. Doct.) in the Conuocation house.
Phil. I did weep in deed, and so did Christ upon Jerusalem, and am not to be blamed therefore, if you consider the cause of my weeping.
Phil. I did weepe in deed, and so did Christ vpon Ierusalem, and am not to be blamed therefore, if you consider the cause of my weepyng.
Morgan. What, make you your self Christ? ha, ha.
Morgan. What, make you your selfe Christ? ha, ha.
Phil. No sir, I make not my self Christ: but I am not ashamed to do as my master and saviour did, to bewail & lament your infidelity and idolatry, which I there foresaw thorough tyranny you would bring again to this realm, as this day doth declare.
Phil. No sir, I make not my selfe Christ: but I am not ashamed to do as my maister and sauiour did, to bewaile & lament your infidelitie and idolatrye, which I there foresaw thorough tyranny you would bryng agayne to this realme, as this day doth declare.
Morgan. That is your argument.
Phil. As I may touch but one of the least abuses, you minister it not in both kinds as you ought to do, but keep the one half from the people, contrary to Christs institution.
Phil. As I may touch but one of the least abuses, you minister it not in both kynds as you ought to doe, but keepe the one halfe from the people, contrary to Christes institution.
Christo. Why, is there not as much contained in one kind, as in both? And what need is it then to minister in both kinds?
Christo. Why, is there not as much conteined in one kynd, as in both? And what neede is it then to minister in both kyndes?
Phil. I believe not so, for if it had, Christ would have given but one kind only:1 for he instituted nothing superfluous, and therefore you cannot say that the whole effect of the sacrament is as well in one kind, as in both, since the scripture teacheth otherwise.
Phil. I beleeue not so, for if it had, Christ would haue geuē but one kind only:1 for he instituted nothing superfluous, and therfore you cannot say that the whole effect of the sacrament is as well in one kind, as in both, since the scripture teacheth otherwyse.
Christo. What, if I can prove it by scripture, that we may minister it in one kind? The apostles did so, as it may appear in the Acts of the Apostles, in one or two places, where it is written that the Apostles continued In orationibus & fraction panis: In prayers, and in breaking of bread, which is meant of the Sacrament.
Christo. What, if I can prooue it by scripture, that we may minister it in one kind? The apostles did so, as it may appeare in the Actes of the Apostles, in one or two places, where it is written that the Apostles continued In orationibus & fractione panis: In prayers, and in breakyng of breade, which is ment of the Sacrament.
Philpot. Why, Master Doctor, do you not know that Saint Luke by the making mention of the breaking of bread, meaneth the whole use of the sacrament, according to Christs institution, by a Figure which you have learned in Grammar, *Synecdoche, where part is mentioned, and the whole understanded to be done, as Christ commanded it.
Philpot. Why, Maister Doctour, do you not knowe that Saint Luke by the makyng mention of the breakyng of bread, meaneth the whole vse of the sacrament, accordyng to Christes institution, by a Figure which you haue learned in Grammer, *Synecdoche, where part is mentioned, and the whole vnderstanded to bee done, as Christ commanded it.
Christo Nay, that is not so. For I can show out of Euseb. in Eccles hist. that there was a man of God, (whom he named) that sent the Sacrament in one kind by a boy to one that was sick.
Christo Nay, that is not so. For I can shew out of Euseb. in Eccles hist. that there was a man of God, (whom he named) that sent the Sacrament in one kynd by a boy to one that was sicke.
Phil. I have read in deed that they did use to give that was left of the Communion bread, to children, to mariners, & to women, and so peradventure the boy might carry a piece of that was left to the sick man.
Phil. I haue read in deed that they did vse to geue yt was left of the Communion bread, to children, to mariners, & to women, and so peraduenture the boy might cary a piece of that was left to the sicke man.
Christo. Nay, as a Sacrament it was purposely sent unto him.
Christo. Nay, as a Sacrament it was purposely sent vnto hym.
Phil. If it were so, yet can you not precisely say, that he had not the cup ministered unto him also by some other sent unto him: but though one man did use it thus, doth it follow that all men may do the like? S. Cyprian noteth many abuses of the sacrament in his time, which rose upon singular mens examples, as using of water in stead of wine: therefore he sayth: Non respiciendum quid aliquis ante nos fecerit, sed quid Christus qui omnium primus, ante nos fecerit & mandavit: that is, We must not look what any man hath done before us, but what Christ first of all men did & commanded.
Phil. If it were so, yet can you not precisely say, that he had not the cup ministred vnto him also by some other sent vnto him: but though one man did vse it thus, doth it folow that all men may do the like? S. Cyprian noteth many abuses of the sacrament in his tyme, which rose vppon singular mēs examples, as vsing of water in stead of wyne: therfore he sayth: Non respiciendum quid aliquis ante nos fecerit, sed quid Christus qui omnium primus, ante nos fecerit & mandauit: that is, Wee must not looke what any man hath done before vs, but what Christ first of all men did & commanded.
Christo. Hath not the church taught us so to use the sacrament? and how do we know that Christ is Homousios, that is, of one substance with the father, but by the determination of the church? How can you prove that otherwise by express words of scripture, and where find you Homousios in all the scripture?
Christo. Hath not the church taught vs so to vse the sacrament? and how do we know that Christ is Homousios, that is, of one substance with the father, but by the determination of the church? How can you prooue that otherwise by expresse words of scripture, and where find you Homousios in all the scripture?
Phil. Yes, that I do, in the 1. to the Hebrews, where it is written, that Christ is the express Image of Gods own substance, eiusdem substantiae.
Phil. Yes, that I doe, in the 1. to the Hebrues, where it is written, that Christ is the expresse Image of Gods owne substance, eiusdem substantiae.
Christo. Nay, that is not so. It is. There is no more but expressa imago substantiae: The express image of gods substance, and Image is accident.
Christo. Nay, that is not so. It is. There is no more but expressa imago substantiae: The expresse image of gods substance, and Image is accident.
Phil. It is in the text, Of his substance, Substantiae illius ▪ or of his own substance, as it may be right well interpreted. Besides this, that which Christ spake of himself in s. Joh. manifesteth the same, saying: I & the father be one thing: Ego & pater unum sumus. And where as you say, Imago here is accidence, the ancient fathers use this for a strong argument, to prove Christ to be God, because he is the very Image of God.
Phil. It is in the text, Of his substance, Substantiae illius ▪ or of his owne substance, as it may be right wel interpreted. Besides this, that which Christ spake of himself in s. Ioh. manifesteth the same, saying: I & the father be one thing: Ego & pater vnum sumus. And where as you say, Imago here is accidence, the ancient fathers vse this for a strong argument, to prooue Christ to be God, because he is the very Image of God.
Christo. Yea do? is this a good argument, because we are the Image of God, Ergo, we are God.
Christo. Yea do? is this a good argument, because wee are the Image of God, Ergo, we are God.
Phil. We are not called the express Image of God,1 as it is written of Christ, and we are but the Image of God by participation, & as it is written in Genesis, we are made to the likeness and similitude of God. But you ought to know (M. Christoph,) that there is no accidence in God, & therefore Christ cannot be the image of God, but he must be of the same substance with God.
Phil. We are not called the expresse Image of God,1 as it is written of Christ, and wee are but the Image of God by participation, & as it is written in Genesis, wee are made to the likenesse and similitude of God. But you ought to know (M. Christoph,) that there is no accidence in God, & therfore Christ cannot be the image of God, but he must be of the same substance with God.
Christo. Tush.
Phil. I know you go but about to catch me in words. If you can prove that book to be of my setting forth, lay it to my charge when I come to judgement.
Phil. I know you go but about to catch me in wordes. If you can prooue that booke to be of my setting forth, lay it to my charge when I come to iudgement.