pp. 1795–18431,445 passagespart 26 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. It appeareth by your communication, that you are better acquainted with the spirit of the Buttery, then with the spirit of God. Wherefore I must now tell thee (thou painted wall & hypocrite) in the name of the living Lord, whose truth I have told thee, that God shall rain fire and brimstone upon such scorners of his word, and blasphemers of his people as thou art.
Phil. It appeareth by your communication, that you are better acquainted with the spirit of the Buttry, then with the spirit of God. Wherefore I must now tell thee (thou painted wall & hypocrite) in the name of the liuing Lord, whose truth I haue told thee, that God shal raine fire and brimstone vpon such scorners of his worde, and blasphemers of his people as thou art.
Morgan. What, you rage now.
Phil. Thy foolish blasphemies hath compelled the spirit of God which is in me, to speak that which I have said unto thee, thou enemy of all righteousness.
Phil. Thy foolish blasphemies hath compelled the spirit of God which is in me, to speake that which I haue said vnto thee, thou enemy of all righteousnes.
Morgan. Why do you judge me so?
Morgan. Why do you iudge me so?
Phil. By thine own wicked words I judge of thee, thou blind and blasphemous Doctor: for as it is written: By thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned. I have spoken on Gods behalf, & now have I done with thee.
Phil. By thine owne wicked words I iudge of thee, thou blynd and blasphemous Doctour: for as it is written: By thy words thou shalt be iustified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned. I haue spoken on Gods behalfe, & now haue I done with thee.
Morgan. Why, then I tell thee Philpot, that thou art an heretic, and shalt be burnt for thine heresy, and afterwards go to hell fire.
Morgan. Why, then I tel thee Philpot, that thou art an heretike, and shalt be burnt for thine heresy, and afterwards go to hell fire.
Phil. I tell thee, thou hypocrite,1 that I pass not this for thy fire and fagots, neither (I thank God my Lord) stand in fear of the same: my faith in Christ shall overcome them. But the hell fire which thou threatenest me, is thy portion, and is prepared for thee (unless thou speedily repent) and for such hypocrites as thou art.
Phil. I tel thee, thou hypocrite,1 that I passe not this for thy fire and fagots, neither (I thanke God my Lord) stande in feare of the same: my faith in Christ shall ouercome thē. But the hel fire which thou threatnest me, is thy portion, and is prepared for thee (vnlesse thou spedily repent) and for such hypocrites as thou art.
Morgan. What, thou speakest upon wine, thou hast tippled well to day, by likelihood.
Morgan. What, thou speakest vpon wyne, thou hast tipled well to day, by likelihood.
Phil. So said the cursed generation, of the Apostles being replenished with the holy Ghost, & speaking the wondrous works of God, they said they were drunk, when they had nothing else to say, as thou doest now.
Phil. So said the cursed generation, of the Apostles beyng replenished with the holy Ghost, & speaking the wōdrous works of God, they said they were dronk, when they had nothing els to say, as thou doest now.
Morgan. Why, I am able to answer thee, ywis, I trow.
Phil. So it seemeth with blasphemies and lies.
Phil. So it seemeth with blasphemies and lyes.
Morgan. Nay, even with learning, say what thou canst.
Morgan. Nay, euen with learnyng, say what thou canst.
Phil. That appeared well at my disputation in the Convocation house,1 where thou tookest upon thee to answer those few arguments I was permitted to make, and yet wast not able to answer one, but in thine answers did fumble and stammer, that the whole house was ashamed of thee: and the final conclusion of all thine answers was, that thou couldst answer me, if I were in the schools at Oxford.
Phil. That appeared well at my disputation in the Conuocation house,1 where thou tookest vpon thee to aunswer those few arguments I was permitted to make, and yet wast not able to aunswere one, but in thyne aunsweres did fumble and stammer, that the whole house was ashamed of thee: and the finall conclusion of all thine answers was, that thou couldst answer me, if I were in the scholes at Oxford.
Morgan. What, did I so? thou beliest me.
Phil. I do not belie thee: the book of the report of the disputation beareth record thereto, and all that were present then, can tell (if they list) thou saidst so. And I tell thee plain, thou art not able to answer that spirit of truth, which speaketh in me for the defence of Christs true Religion. I am able by the might thereof, to drive thee round about this gallery before me: and if it would please the queens majesty and her Council to hear thee and me, I would make thee for shame shrink behind the door.
Phil. I do not belye thee: the booke of the report of ye disputation beareth record therto, and al that were present then, can tell (if they list) thou saydst so. And I tell thee playne, thou art not able to answer that spirit of truth, which speaketh in me for the defence of Christes true Religion. I am able by the might therof, to driue thee roūd about this gallery before me: and if it would please the queenes maiesty and her Councell to heare thee and me, I woulde make thee for shame shrinke behinde the doore.
Morgan. Yea would you so?
Phil. Thou hast the spirit of Illusion and Sophistry, which is not able to countervail the spirit of truth.1 Thou art but an Ass in the true understanding of things pertaining unto God. I call thee Ass not in respect of malice, but in that thou kickest against the trueth, and art void of all godly understanding, not able to answer to that thou braggest in.
Phil. Thou hast the spirite of Illusion and Sophistrye, which is not able to counteruaile the spirit of truth.1 Thou art but an Asse in the true vnderstanding of thinges pertayning vnto God. I cal thee Asse not in respect of malice, but in that thou kickest agaynst the trueth, and art voyde of all godly vnderstāding, not able to answere to that thou braggest in.
Morgan. Why, have I not answered thee in all things thou hast said unto me? I take them to record.
Morgan. Why, haue I not answered thee in all things thou hast sayd vnto me? I take them to record.
Phil. Ask of my fellow whether I be a thief.
Phil. Aske of my felow whether I be a theefe.
Cousins. Hark, he maketh us all thieves.
Cosins. Harke, he maketh vs all theeues.
Phil. You know that phrase of the Proverb, that like will hold with like. And I am sure, you will not judge with me, against him, speak I never so true: and in this sense I speak it. The strongest answer that he hath made against me is, that you will burn me.
Phil. You know that phrase of the Prouerbe, that like will holde with like. And I am sure, you will not iudge with me, against him, speake I neuer so true: and in this sense I speake it. The strongest answere that he hath made against me is, that you will burne me.
Morgan. Why, we do not burn you: it is the Temporal men that burn you, and not we.
Morgan. Why, we doe not burne you: it is the Temporall men that burne you, and not we.
Phil. Thus you would (as Pilate did) wash your hands of all your wicked doings. But I pray you Invocate secular brachium: call upon the secular power to be executioners of your unrighteous judgements. And have you not a title in your law, De haereticis comburendis for, to burn heretics?
Phil. Thus you woulde (as Pilate dyd) washe your handes of all your wicked doinges. But I pray you Inuocate seculare brachium: call vpon the secular power to be executioners of your vnrighteous iudgementes. And haue you not a title in your law, De haereticis comburendis for, to burne heretickes?
Harps. I have heard you both a good while reason together, and I never heard so stout an heretic as you are M. Philpot.
Harps. I haue hearde you both a good while reason together, and I neuer hearde so stout an hereticke as you are M. Philpot.
Cousins. Neither I in all my life.
Cosins. Neither I in all my life.
Phil. You are not able to prove me an heretic, by one jot of Gods word.
Phil. You are not able to proue me an heretick, by one iote of Gods word.
Harps. You have the Spirit of arrogancy, I will reason with you no more.1 And so he was departing, and M. Cousins also. And with that the bishop and Christoforsō came in again, and said.
Harps. You haue the Spirite of arrogancy, I will reason with you no more.1 And so he was departing, and M. Cosins also. And with that the bishop and Christoforsō came in agayne, and sayd.
Boner. Master Doctor, how doeth this man and you agree?
Boner. Mayster Doctour, howe doeth this man and you agree?
Morgan. My Lord, I do ask him where his church was fifty years ago?
Morgan. My Lord, I doe aske him where his church was fifty yeares agoe?
Boner. Are you not half agreed, as one man said once to tway parties, of whom the one was equally disagreeing from the other?
Boner. Are you not halfe agreed, as one man sayd once to tway parties, of whō the one was equally disagreeing frō the other?
Christo. My Lorde, it is but folly to reason with him any further: your Lordship shall but loose time, for he is incurable.
Christo. My Lorde, it is but folly to reason with hym any further: your Lordshippe shall but loose time, for he is incurable.
Boner. Well then, let his keeper have him away· And with that Doct. Chadsey led me a way by the which we could not pass, and therefore came back again through the bishops chamber, where all these doctors were clustered together: and as I was passing, the Bishop took me by the gown and said: Wot you what M. Christoferson telleth me? I pray you M. Christoforson, rehearse the sentence in Latin, and so he did. The contents thereof was, that an heretic would not be won.
Boner. Well then, let his keeper haue him away· And with that Doct. Chadsey led me a way by the which we coulde not passe, and therfore came backe agayne through the byshops chamber, where al these doctors were clustred together: and as I was passing, the Bishoppe tooke me by the gowne and sayd: Wote you what M. Christoferson telleth me? I pray you M. Christoforson, rehearse the sentence in Latine, and so he did. The contentes thereof was, that an hereticke would not be won.
Christo. S. Paule saith: Haereticum hominem post unam atque alteram admonitionem devita: Flee an heretic after once or twice warning.
Christo. S. Paule sayth: Haereticum hominem post vnam atque alteram admonitionem deuita: Flee an heretick after once or twise warning.
All the Doctors. Yea, my Lord, it is best you so do, & trouble your Lordship no more with him.
Phil. 1You must first prove me justly to be an heretic, before you use the judgement of S. Paul against me: for he speaketh of such as hold opinion against the manifest word, the which you cannot prove by me. And because you want in your proof, & be able to prove nothing against me, therefore you go about falsely to suppose me to be an heretic, for the safeguard of your own counterfeit honesties: but afore God you are the heretics, which so stoutly & stubbornly maintain so many things directly against Gods word, as God in his time shall reveal. As I went out of his chamber, the Bishop called me aside and said:
Phil. 1You must first proue me iustly to be an hereticke, before you vse the iudgement of S. Paule agaynst me: for he speaketh of such as hold opiniō against the manifest word, the which you cannot proue by me. And because you want in your proofe, & be able to proue nothing agaynst me, therfore you go about falsly to suppose me to be an heretick, for the safegard of your owne counterfeit honesties: but afore God you are the heretickes, which so stoutly & stubburnly mainteine so many thinges directly agaynst Gods word, as God in his time shall reueale. As I wēt out of his chā ber, the Bishop called me aside and sayd:
Boner. I pray thee in good sadness, what meanest thou by writing in the beginning of the Bible: Spiritus est Vicarius Christi in terris: 1The spirit is the vicar of Christ on the earth? Iwis you have some special meaning thereof.
Boner. I pray thee in good sadnes, what meanest thou by writing in the beginning of the Bible: Spiritus est Vicarius Christi in terris: 1The spirit is the vicar of Christ on the earth? Iwis you haue some speciall meaning therof.
Phil. My Lord, I have none other meaning then (as I have told you already) that Christ since his ascension worketh all thinks in us by his spirit, and by his spirit doth dwell in us. I pray you my Lord, let me have my bible, with other lawful books and writings which you have of mine, whereof many of them be none of mine, but lent to me by my friends.
Phil. My Lorde, I haue none other meaning then (as I haue tolde you alreadye) that Christe since hys ascension worketh all thinkes in vs by his spirite, and by his spirite doth dwell in vs. I pray you my Lord, let me haue my bible, with other lawfull bookes and writinges whiche you haue of mine, whereof many of them be none of myne, but lent to me by my frendes.
Boner. Your Bible you shall not have, but I will perhaps let you have an other: & after I have perused the rest, you shall have such as I think good.
Boner. Your Bible you shall not haue, but I will perhaps let you haue an other: & after I haue perused the rest, you shall haue such as I thinke good.
Phil. I pray your Lordship then, that you would let me have candle light.
Phil. I pray your Lordshippe then, that you would let me haue candle light.
Boner. To what purpose, I pray you?