pp. 1795–18431,445 passagespart 29 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. I am (Master Doctor) of the unfeigned Catholic Church, and will live and dye therein: and if you can prove your church to be the true Catholic church, I will be one of the same.
Phil. I am (Mayster Doctor) of the vnfayned Catholicke Church, and will liue and dye therin: and if you can proue your church to be the true Catholicke church, I wil be one of the same.
Wright. I came not to dispute with you, but to exhort you. Here be better learned then I that can inform you better then I.
Wright. I came not to dispute with you, but to exhorte you. Here be better learned then I that can enforme you better then I.
Chad. What proof would you have? I will prove unto you our church to have his being and foundation by the scriptures,1 by the Apostles, and by the primitive church, confirmed with the blood of martyrs, and the testimony of all Confessors.
Chad. What proofe woulde you haue? I will prooue vnto you our church to haue his being and foūdatiō by the scriptures,1 by the Apostles, and by the primitiue church, confirmed with the bloud of martyrs, and the testimony of al Confessours.
Phil. Give me your hand, M. Doctor, prove that, & have with you.
Phil. Geue me your hand, M. Doctor, proue that, & haue with you.
Chadsey. If I had my Books here, I could soon prove it,1 I will go fet some: and with that he went and fet his book of Annotations, saying: I can not bring my Books well, therefore I have brought my book of Annotations, and turned there to a Common place of the Sacrament, asking me whether the Catholic Church did not allow the presence of Christs body in the Sacrament, or no? I hear say, you do confess a real presence: but I will be hanged, if you will abide by it. You will deny it by and by.
Chadsey. If I hadde my Bookes here, I coulde soone prooue it,1 I will goe fet some: and with that he wente and fet his booke of Annotations, saying: I can not bring my Bookes well, therefore I haue brought my booke of Annotations, and turned there to a Common place of the Sacrament, asking me whether the Catholicke Churche did not allow the presence of Christes body in the Sacrament, or no? I heare say, you doe confesse a reall presence: but I wil be hanged, if you wil abide by it. You will denie it by and by.
Phil. That I have said, I cannot deny, neither intend not, whatsoever ye say.
Phil. That I haue sayd, I cannot deny, neither intend not, whatsoeuer ye say.
Chad. If there be a real presence in the Sacrament, then evil men receive Christ, which thing you will not grant, I am sure.
Chad. If there be a reall presence in the Sacrament, then euill men receiue Christ, which thing you wil not graunt, I am sure.
Phil. I deny the Argument. For I do not grant in the Sacrament,1 by transubstantiation any real presence, as you falsely imagine, but in the due administration to the worthy receivers.
Phil. I denye the Argument. For I doe not graunte in the Sacrament,1 by transubstantiatiō any reall presence, as you falsly imagine, but in the due administration to ye worthy receiuers.
Chad. I will prove that the evil and wicked men eat the body of Christ, as well as the good men, by Saint Austine here.
Chad. I will prooue that the euill and wicked men eate the body of Christ, as well as the good men, by Saynt Austine here.
Phil. And in the beginning of his Text Saint Augustine seemeth to approve his assertion: but I bade him read out to the end, and there saint Austine declareth that it was quodam modo, 1after a certain manner the evil men received the body of Christ, which is sacramentally only, in the utter signs, and not really, or in deed, as the good doth. And thus all the Doctors that you seem to bring in for your purpose, be quite against you, if you did rightly weigh them.
Phil. And in the beginning of his Texte Sayncte Augustine seemeth to approoue his assertion: but I bade hym reade out to the end, and there saynt Austine declareth that it was quodam modo, 1after a certayne maner the euill men receiued the body of Christ, which is sacramentally onely, in the vtter signes, and not really, or in deede, as the good doth. And thus all the Doctours that you seeme to bring in for your purpose, be quite against you, if you did rightly weigh them.
Chad. By God you are a subtle fellow. See how he would writhe S. Austine's words.
Chad. By God you are a subtle felow. See how he would writhe S. Austines wordes.
Phil. See who of us wrieth S. Augustine more, you or I, which take his meaning by his own express words. And seeing you charge me of subtlety, what subtlety is this of you, to say, that you will prove your matter of the church even from the beginning,1 promising to show your Books therein, and when it cometh to the showing, you are able to show none, and for want of proof slip into a bymatter, & yet faint in the proof thereof. Afore God you are bare arst in all your religion.
Phil. See who of vs wrieth S. Augustine more, you or I, which take his meaning by his owne expresse words. And seing you charge me of subtletye, what subtletye is this of you, to say, that you will proue your matter of the churche euen from the beginning,1 promising to shew your Bookes therin, and when it commeth to the shewing, you are able to shew none, and for want of proofe slip into a bymatter, & yet faynt in the proofe thereof. Afore God you are bare arst in all your religion.
Chad. You shall be constrained to come to us at length, whether you will, or no.
Chad. You shalbe cōstrained to come to vs at length, whether you will, or no.
Phil. Hold that argument fast: for it is the best you have, for you have nothing but violence.
Phil. Holde that argument fast: for it is the best you haue, for you haue nothing but violence.
1The Thursday after, I was called in the morning before the Archbishop of York, the Bishop of Chichester, the Bishop of Bath, and the Bishop of London. The Bishop of Chichester being first come, began to talk with me.
1THe Thursday after, I was called in the morning before the Archbishop of Yorke, the Byshop of Chichester, the Bishop of Bath, and the Bishop of London. The Byshop of Chichester being first come, beganne to talke with me.
Chich. I am come of good will to talk with you, to instruct you what I can, to come to the Catholic church, & to will you mistrust your own judgement, & to learn first to have humility, & by the same to learn of others that be better learned then you, as they did learn of such as were their betters before them.
Chich. I am come of good will to talke with you, to instruct you what I can, to come to the Catholicke church, & to will you mistrust your owne iudgement, & to learn first to haue humility, & by the same to learne of others that be better learned then you, as they did learne of such as were their betters before them.
Phil. We must all be taught of God, and I will with all humility learn of them that will inform me by Gods word, what I have to do. I confess I have but little learning in respect of you,1 that both of your years and great exercise to excel therein: but faith consisteth not only in learning, but in simplicity of believing that which Gods word teacheth. Therefore I will be glad to hear both of your Lordship, and of any other (that God hath revealed unto by his word) the true doctrine thereof, and to thank you, that it doth please you to take pains herein.
Phil. We must all be taughte of God, and I will with all humilitye learne of them that will infourme me by Gods worde, what I haue to doe. I confesse I haue but little learning in respect of you,1 that both of your yeares and great exercise to excell therin: but fayth consisteth not onelye in learning, but in simplicitye of beleuing that whiche Gods woorde teacheth. Therefore I will bee gladde to heare both of your Lordshippe, and of any other (that God hath reuealed vnto by hys word) the true doctrine therof, and to thank you, that it doth please you to take paynes herein.
Chich. You take the first alleged, amiss, as though all men should be taught by inspiration, and not by learning. How do we believe the gospel, but by the authority of the church and because the same hath allowed it?
Chich. You take the first alleged, amisse, as though all men should be taught by inspiratiō, and not by learning. How do we beleue the gospel, but by the authority of the church and because the same hath allowed it?
Phil. S. Paul saith: He learned not the Gospel by men, 1neither of men, but by the revelation of Jesus Christ: which is a sufficient proof that the Gospel taketh not his authority of man, but of God only.
Phil. S. Paule sayth: He learned not the Gospell by men, 1neyther of men, but by the reuelatiō of Iesus Christ: which is a sufficient proofe that the Gospell taketh not his authoritye of man, but of God onely.
Chich. S. Paul speaketh but of his own knowledge how he came thereto.
Chich. S. Paule speaketh but of his own knowledge how he came thereto.
Phil. Nay, he speaketh of the Gospel generally, Which cometh not from man, but from God, 1and that the Church must only teach that which cometh from God, and not mans precepts.
Phil. Nay, hee speaketh of the Gospell generally, Whyche commeth not from man, but from God, 1and that the Churche must onely teach that which commeth from God, and not mans preceptes.
Chich. Doth not Saint Augustine say: I would not believe the Gospel, if the authority of the Church did not move me thereto?
Chich. Doth not Saynt Augustine say: I would not beleue the Gospell, if the authority of the Churche did not mooue me thereto?
Phil. I grant that the authority of the Church doeth move the unbelievers to believe, but yet the Church giveth not the word his authority:1 for the word hath his authority only from God, and not of man: men be but disposers thereof. For first the word hath his being before the Church, and the word is the foundation of the church: and first is the foundation sure, before the building thereon can be steadfast.
Phil. I graunte that the authoritye of the Churche doeth moue the vnbeleeuers to beleeue, but yet the Church geueth not the woorde his authority:1 for the woorde hath his authority onely from God, and not of man: mē be but disposers thereof. For firste the worde hath his beyng before the Churche, and the woorde is the foundation of the church: and first is the foundation sure, before the building theron can be stedfast.
Chich. I perceive you mistake me. I speak of the knowledge of the Gospel, and not of the authority: for by the church we have all knowledge of the Gospel.
Chich. I perceiue you mistake me. I speake of the knowledge of the Gospell, and not of the authority: for by the church we haue all knowledge of the Gospell.
Phil. I confess that. For faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word.1 And I acknowledge that God appointeth an ordinary means for men to come unto the knowledge now, and not miraculously, as he hath done in times past: yet we that be taught by men must take heed that we learn nothing else but that which was taught in the Primitive church by revelation. Here came in the Bishop of York, and the Bishop of Bath, and after they had saluted one another, and commoned a while together, the Archbishop of York called me unto them, saying,
Phil. I confesse that. For fayth commeth by hearing, and hearing by the worde.1 And I acknowledge that God appoynteth an ordinarye meanes for men to come vnto the knowledge now, and not myraculously, as he hath done in times past: yet we that be taught by men must take heede that we learne nothing els but that which was taught in the Primitiue church by reuelation. Here came in the Byshop of Yorke, and the Bishop of Bath, and after they had saluted one another, and commoned a while together, the Archbishop of Yorke called me vnto them, saying,
York. Sir, we hearing that you are out of the way, are come of charity to inform you, & to bring you into the true faith, and to the catholic church again,1 willing you first to have humility, and to be humble & willing to learn of your betters: for else we can do no good with you. And god saith by his Prophet: On whom shall I rest, but on the humble & meek, and such as tremble at my word. Now if you will so be, we will be glad to travel with you.
Yorke. Syr, wee hearing that you are out of the way, are come of charity to enforme you, & to bring you into ye true fayth, and to the catholicke church againe,1 willing you first to haue humility, and to be humble & willing to learne of your betters: for els we can do no good with you. And god sayth by his Prophet: On whom shall I rest, but on the humble & meeke, and such as tremble at my word. Now if you will so be, we will be glad to trauell with you.
Phil. I know that humility is the door whereby we enter unto Christ, and I thank his goodness I have entered in at the same unto him, & with all humility hear whatsoever truth you shall speak unto me.
Phil. I know that humility is the doore wherby we enter vnto Christ, and I thanke his goodnes I haue entred in at the same vnto him, & with all humility heare whatsoeuer truth you shall speake vnto me.
York. What be the matters you stand on, and require to be satisfied in?
Yorke. What be the matters you stande on, and require to be satisfied in?
Phil. My Lord, & it please your grace, we were entered into a good matter before you came, of the church and how we should know the truth but by the church.
Phil. My Lord, & it please your grace, we were entred into a good matter before you came, of the church and howe we should know the truth but by the church.
York. In deed that is the head, we need to begin at. For the church being truly known, we shall sooner agree in the particular things.
Yorke. In deede that is the head, we neede to begynne at. For the church being truely knowne, we shal sooner agree in the particular thinges.
Phil. If your Lordships can prove the church of Rome to be the true catholic church it shall do much to persuade me toward that you would have me incline unto.
Phil. If your Lordships can proue the church of Rome to be ye true catholicke church it shall do much to persuade me toward that you would haue me encline vnto.
York. Why, let us go to the definition of the church. What is it?
Yorke. Why, let vs go to the definition of the church. What is it?
Phil. It is a Congregation of people, dispersed through the world, agreeing together in the word of GOD,1 using the Sacraments and all other things according to the same.
Phil. It is a Congregation of people, dispersed throughe the worlde, agreeing together in the woorde of GOD,1 vsing the Sacramentes and al other thinges according to the same.
York. Your definition is of many words to no purpose.
Yorke. Your definition is of many wordes to no purpose.
Phil. I do not precisely define the church, but declare unto you what I think the church is.
Phil. I do not precisely define the church, but declare vnto you what I thinke the church is.
York. Is the church visible or invisible?
Yorke. Is the church visible or inuisible?
Phil. It is both visible and invisible.1 The invisible church is of all the elects of God only: the visible consisteth of both good and bad, using all things in faith, according to Gods word.
Phil. It is both visible and inuisible.1 The inuisible church is of all the electes of God onely: the visible consisteth of both good and bad, vsing all thinges in fayth, according to Gods word.
York. The church is an universal congregation of faith full people in Christ through the world: which this word Catholic doth well express: for what is Catholic else?1 doth it not signify universal?
Yorke. The church is an vniuersall congregation of fayth full people in Christ through the world: which this worde Catholick doth well expresse: for what is Catholicke els?1 doth it not signify vniuersall?
Phil. The church is defined by S. Austine to be called Catholic ⟨p. 1825⟩in this wise: Ecclesia ideo dicitur Catholica, quia universaliter perfecta est & in nullo claudicat: The Church is called therefore Catholic, because it is throughly perfect, and halteth in nothing.
Phil. The church is defined by S. Austine to be called Catholike ⟨p. 1825⟩in this wyse: Ecclesia ideo dicitur Catholica, quia vniuersaliter perfecta est & in nullo claudicat: The Church is called therefore Catholike, because it is throughly perfect, and halteth in nothyng.