pp. 1795–18431,445 passagespart 31 of 37
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Phil. I esteem them, in as much as they be of force: as your Lordship doth hear me deny no doctors you bring, but only require the true application of them, according to the writers meaning, & as by his own words may be proved.
Phil. I esteeme them, in as muche as they bee of force: as your Lordship doth heare me deny no doctors you bring, but onely require the true application of them, according to the writers meaning, & as by his owne wordes may be proued.
York. I will read him the place, and so make an end. After he had read the sentence▪ he said, that by four special points here S. Austine proveth the catholic church. The first is, by the consent of all nations, the second, by the Apostolic Sea, the third, by universality, & the fourth, by this word Catholic.
Yorke. I will reade him the place, and so make an end. After he had read the sentence▪ he sayde, that by foure speciall poynts here S. Austine proueth the catholick church. The first is, by the consent of all nations, the secōd, by the Apostolick Sea, the third, by vniuersalitie, & the fourth, by this word Catholicke.
Chich. That is a notable place in deed▪ and it please your Grace.
Chich. That is a notable place in deede▪ and it please your Grace.
Phil. I pray you, my Lord, of what church doth S. Austine write the same, of Rome, or not?
York. Yea, he writeth it of the Church of Rome.
Yorke. Yea, he writeth it of the Church of Rome.
Phil. I will lay with your Lordship as much as I can make, it is not so▪ and let the book be seen.
Phil. I will lay with your Lordshippe as much as I can make, it is not so▪ and let the booke be sene.
Bath. What art thou able to lay, that hast nothing.
York Doth he not make mention here of the Apostolic sea, whereby he meaneth Rome?
Yorke Doth he not make mention here of the Apostolicke sea, whereby he meaneth Rome?
Phil. That is very straitly interpreted my lord, as though the Apostolic Sea had been no where else but at Rome. But let it be Rome, and yet shall you never verify the same, unless all the other conditions do go therewith as S. Augustine doth proceed withal, whereof none except the Apostolic sea can now be verified of the Church of Rome. For the faith which that Sea now maintaineth hath not the consent of all nations neither hath had. Besides that, it cannot have the name of Catholic, because it differeth from the Catholic Churches which the Apostles planted, almost in all things.
Phil. That is very straitly interpreted my lord, as though the Apostolicke Sea had bene no where els but at Rome. But let it be Rome, and yet shall you neuer verify ye same, vnlesse all the other conditions do go therewith as S. Augustine doth proceed withal, wherof none except the Apostolicke sea can now bee verified of the Churche of Rome. For the fayth which that Sea now maynteineth hath not the consent of al nations neither hath had. Besides that, it cannot haue the name of Catholick, because it differeth frō the Catholicke Churches which the Apostles planted, almost in all thinges.
York. Nay, he goeth about here to prove the Catholic Church by universality:1 & how can you show your church to be universal fifty, or an hundred years ago?
Yorke. Nay, he goeth about here to proue the Catholicke Church by vniuersality:1 & how can you shew your church to be vniuersall fifty, or an hundreth yeares ago?
Phil. That is not material, neither any thing against S. Augustine. For my church (whereof I am) were to be counted universal, though it were but in x. persons, because it agreeth with the same that the Apostles universally did plant.
Phil. That is not materiall, neither any thing agaynst S. Augustine. For my church (wherof I am) were to be coū ted vniuersal, though it were but in x. persōs, because it agreeth wt the same that the Apostles vniuersally did plant.
York. I perceive you are an obstinate man in your opinion, & will not be taught: wherefore it is but lost labour to talk with you any longer: you are a member to be cut of.
Yorke. I perceiue you are an obstinate man in your opinion, & will not be taught: wherefore it is but lost labour to talke with you any lenger: you are a member to be cut of.
Chichester. I have heard of you before how you troubled the good Bishop of Winchester, and now I see in you that I have heard.
Chichester. I haue heard of you before how you troubled the good Bishop of Winchester, and now I see in you that I haue heard.
Phil. I trust you see no evil in me by this. I desire of you a sure ground to build my faith on, & if you show ne none, I pray you speak not ill of him that meaneth well.
Phil. I trust you see no euill in me by this. I desire of you a sure ground to build my fayth on, & if you shew ne none, I pray you speake not ill of him that meaneth well.
Phil. That is spoken uncharitably my Lord, to blaspheme him whom you can not justly reprove.
Phil. That is spoken vncharitably my Lord, to blaspheme him whom you can not iustly reproue.
Chich. Why, you are not God. Blasphemy is counted a rebuke to Godward, and not to man.
Phil. Yes, it may be as well verified of an infamy laid to man speaking in Gods cause, as you now do lay unto me for speaking freely the truth afore GOD, to maintain your vain Religion. You are void of all good ground. I perceive you are blind guides and leaders of the blind, & therefore (as I am bound to tell you) very hypocrites, tyrannously persecuting the trueth, which otherwise by just order you are able to convince by no means. Your own doctors and testimonies which you bring, be evidently against you, and yet you will not see the truth.
Phil. Yes, it may be as well verified of an infamy layde to man speaking in Gods cause, as you now do lay vnto me for speaking freely the truth afore GOD, to maynteyne your vayne Religion. You are voyd of all good ground. I perceiue you are blind guides and leaders of the blinde, & therfore (as I am bounde to tell you) very hipocrites, tyrannously persecuting the trueth, which otherwise by iust order you are able to conuince by no meanes. Your owne doctors and testimonies which you bring, be euidently agaynst you, and yet you will not see the truth.
Phil. My Lords, you must bear with me, since I speak in Christs cause:1 and because his glory is defaced, and his people cruelly and wrongfully slain by you, because they will not consent to the dishonour of God, and to hypocrisy with you. If I told you not your fault it should be required at my hands in the day of judgement. Therefore know you (ye hypocrites in deed) that it is the spirit of God that telleth you your sin, & not I. I pass not (I thank God) of all your cruelty. God forgive it you, & give you grace to repent. And so they departed.
Phil. My Lordes, you must beare with me, since I speake in Christes cause:1 and because his glory is defaced, and his people cruelly and wrongfully slayne by you, because they will not consent to the dishonor of God, and to hypocrisie with you. If I told you not your fault it should be required at my hands in the day of iudgement. Therfore know you (ye hypocrites in deed) that it is the spirit of God that telleth you your sinne, & not I. I passe not (I thank God) of al your cruelty. God forgeue it you, & geue you grace to repent. And so they departed.
The same day at night before supper, the bishop sent for me into his chapel in the presence of the archdeacon Harpesfield, Doctor Chadsey, & other his Chaplains,1 and his servants: at what time he said.
THe same day at night before supper, the bishop sent for me into his chappell in the presence of ye archdeacon Harpesfield, Doctor Chadsey, & other his Chapleines,1 and his seruauntes: at what time he sayd.
Lond. Master Philpot, I have by sundry means gone about to do you good, and I marvel you do so little consider it: by my trueth I can not tell what to say to you. Tell me directly, whether you will be a conformable man or no, & whereupon you chiefly stand.
Lond. Maister Philpot, I haue by sundry meanes gone about to do you good, and I maruell you do so litle consider it: by my trueth I can not tell what to say to you. Tell me directly, whether you will be a conformable man or no, & wherupon you chiefly stand.
Phil. I have told your Lordships oftentimes plain enough, whereon I stand chiefly, requiring a sure probation of the Church whereunto you call me.
Phil. I haue tolde your Lordships oftentimes playne enough, wheron I stand chiefly, requiring a sure probation of the Church wherunto you call me.
Harps. S. Austen writing against the Donatists, declareth four special notes to know the Church by:1 the consent of many nations, the faith of the Sacraments confirmed by antiquity, succession of Bishops, and universality.
Harps. S. Austen writing agaynst the Donatistes, declareth foure speciall notes to know the Church by:1 the cōsent of many nations, the fayth of the Sacramentes confirmed by antiquity, succession of Bishops, and vniuersality.
Lond. I pray you Master Archdeacon, feet the book hither: it is a notable place, let him see it. And the book was brought and the bishop read it, demanding how I could answer the same.
Lond. I pray you Mayster Archdeacon, fette the booke hither: it is a notable place, let him see it. And the booke was brought and the bishop read it, demaunding how I could aunswere the same.
Phil. My Lord, I like S. Austens four points for the trial of the catholic church, whereof I am: for it can abide every point thereof together, which yours can not do.
Phil. My Lorde, I like S. Austens foure poyntes for the triall of the catholicke churche, whereof I am: for it can abide euery poynt therof together, which yours can not do.
Harps. Have not we succession of Bishops in the Sea and church of Rome? Wherefore then do you deny our Church to be the catholic church?
Harps. Haue not we succession of Bishops in the Sea and church of Rome? Wherfore then do you deny our Church to be the catholicke church?
Phil. D. Austine doth not put succession of Bishops only to be sufficient, but he addeth the use of the Sacraments according to antiquity and doctrine universally taught & received of most nations from the beginning of the primitive Church, the which your Church is far from. But my church can avouch all these better then yours: therefore by S. Austins judgement which you here bring, mine is the catholic church, and not yours.
Phil. D. Austine doth not put succession of Bishops onely to be sufficient, but he addeth the vse of the Sacramentes according to antiquity and doctrine vniuersally taughte & receiued of most nations from the beginning of the primatiue Church, the whiche your Churche is farre from. But my church can auouch all these better then yours: therfore by S. Austins iudgement which you here bring, mine is the catholicke church, and not yours.
Harps. Chad. It is but folly (my Lord) for you to reason with him, for he is irrecuperable.1
Harps. Chad. It is but folly (my Lord) for you to reason wt him, for he is irrecuperable.1
Phil. That is a good shift for you to run unto, when you be confounded in your own sayings, & have nothing else to say: you are evidently deceived, and yet will not see it when it is laid to your face.
Phil. That is a good shift for you to runne vnto, when you be confounded in your owne sayinges, & haue nothing else to say: you are euidently deceiued, and yet will not see it when it is layd to your face.
Thus have I at large set forth, as many of the said John Philpot his examinations & privy conferences, as are yet come to light, being faithfully written with his own hand. And although he was divers other times, after this examined, both openly in the Consistory at Pauls, & also secretly in the bishops house: yet, what was there said, is not yet sufficiently known, either because M. Philpot was not himself suffered to write, or else for that his writings are by some kept close, and not brought forth otherwise than as the bishops Register hath noted, whose handling of such matters, because it is (either for fear or for favour of his Lord and master) very slender, little light of any true & right meaning can be gathered, especially in the behalf of the answerer. Howbeit such as it is, such thought I good to put forth requiring the reader to judge hereof according to his answers in his former examinations.
THus haue I at large set forth, as many of ye sayd Iohn Philpot his examinations & priuy conferences, as are yet come to light, being faythfully written with his owne hand. And although he was diuers other times, after this examined, both openly in the Consistory at Paules, & also secretly in the bishops house: yet, what was there sayd, is not yet sufficiently knowne, either because M. Philpot was not himselfe suffered to write, or els for that his writings are by some kept close, and not brought forth otherwise thē as the bishops Register hath noted, whose handling of such matters, because it is (either for feare or for fauor of his Lord and maister) very slender, litle light of any true & right meaning can be gathered, especially in the behalfe of the answerer. Howbeit such as it is, such thought I good to put forth requiring the reader to iudge hereof according to his aunsweres in his former examinations.
The Bishop having sufficiently taken his pleasure with M. Philpot in his private talks,1 and seeing his zealous, learned, and immutable Constancy, thought it now high time to rid his hands of him, and therefore on the 13. and 14. days of December, sitting judicially in the Consistory at Pauls, he caused him to be brought thither before him and others, as it seemeth, more for orders sake, than for any good affection to justice and right judgement. The effect aswell of which two sundry their proceedings, as also of one other had the 11. day of the same month in his chapel, appear in a manner to be all one. The Bishop therefore first speaking to Master Philpot, said:
THe Bishop hauing sufficiently taken his pleasure with M. Philpot in his priuate talkes,1 and seeing his zealous, learned, and immutable Constancy, thought it now high time to rid his handes of him, and therefore on the 13. and 14. dayes of December, sitting iudicially in the Consistory at Paules, he caused him to be brought thither before him and others, as it seemeth, more for orders sake, thē for any good affection to iustice and right iudgement. The effect aswell of which two sundry their procedinges, as also of one other had ye 11. day of the same month in his chappell, appeare in a maner to be all one. The Bishop therefore first speaking to Mayster Philpot, sayd:
Lond. M. Philpot,1 amongest other things that were laid and objected unto you, these three things ye were especially charged and burdened withal. The first is, that you being fallen from the unity of Christs Catholic Church, do refuse and will not come and be reconciled thereunto. The second is, that you have blasphemously spoken against the sacrifice of the Mass, calling it idolatry. And the third is, that you have spoken against the sacrament of the altar, denying the real presence of Christs body and blood to be in the same. And according to the will and pleasure of the Synod legative, ye have been oft & many times by me invited and required to go from your said errors and heresies, and to return to the unity of the catholic Church, which if you ⟨p. 1827⟩will now willingly do, ye shall be mercifully▪ & gladly received, charitably used, and have all the favour I can show you. And now to tell you true, it is assigned and appointed to give sentence against you, if you stand herein, & will not return. Wherefore if ye so refuse, I do ask of you whether you have any cause that you can show, why I should not now give sentence against you?
Lond. M. Philpot,1 amongest other thinges that were laid and obiected vnto you, these three thinges ye were especially charged and burdened withall. The first is, that you beyng fallen from the vnitye of Christes Catholicke Church, do refuse and will not come and be reconciled thereunto. The second is, that you haue blasphemously spoken agaynst the sacrifice of the Masse, calling it idolatry. And the third is, that you haue spoken agaynst the sacrament of the aultar, denying the reall presence of Christes body and bloud to be in the same. And according to the will and pleasure of the Synode legatiue, ye haue bene oft & many times by me inuited and required to go from your sayd errors and heresies, and to returne to the vnity of the catholicke Church, which if you ⟨p. 1827⟩wil now willingly do, ye shalbe mercifully▪ & gladly receiued, charitably vsed, and haue al the fauor I can shew you. And now to tell you true, it is assigned and appoynted to geue sentence agaynst you, if you stande herein, & will not return. Wherfore if ye so refuse, I doe aske of you whether you haue any cause that you can shew, why I shoulde not now geue sentence agaynst you?
Phil. Under protestation, not to go from my appeal that I have made, and also not to consent to you as my competent judge, I say▪ touching your first objection concerning the Catholic Church, I neither was nor am out of the same. And as touching the sacrifice of the Mass, and the Sacrament of the *altar, I never spake against the same. And as concerning the pleasure of the Synod, I say: that these xx. years I have been brought up in the faith of the true catholic church, which is contrary to your church, whereunto ye would have me to come: and in that time I have been many times sworn (as well in the reign of K. Henry the 8. as in the reign of good King Edward his Son) against the usurped power of the Bishop of Rome, which oath I think that I am bound in my conscience to keep quia teneor reddere Domino juramentum. But if you or any of the Synod can by Gods word persuade me that my said oath was unlawful, and that I am bound by Gods law to come to your church, faith and religion, whereof you be now, I will gladly yield, agree, and be conformable unto you: otherwise not. Boner then not able with all his learned Doctors to accomplish this his offered condition,2 fell to persuading of him, as well by his accustomed vain promises, as also by bloody threatenings to return to their Church: to the which he answered.
Phil. Under protestatiō, not to go from my appeale that I haue made, and also not to consent to you as my cōpetent iudge, I say▪ touching your first obiection concerning the Catholick Church, I neither was nor am out of the same. And as touching the sacrifice of the Masse, and the Sacrament of the *aultar, I neuer spake agaynst the same. And as concerning the pleasure of the Sinode, I say: that these xx. yeares I haue bene brought vp in the fayth of the true catholick church, which is contrary to your church, whervnto ye woulde haue me to come: and in that time I haue bene many times sworne (as wel in the reign of K. Henry the 8. as in the reigne of good King Edward his Sonne) agaynst the vsurped power of the Bishop of Rome, which othe I thinke that I am bounde in my conscience to keepe quia teneor reddere Domino iuramentum. But if you or any of the Synode can by Gods worde perswade me that my sayd othe was vnlawfull, and that I am bound by Gods law to come to your church, faith and religion, wherof you be now, I will gladly yeld, agree, and be conformable vnto you: otherwise not. Boner then not able with all his learned Doctours to accomplish this his offered condition,
Phil. You and all other of your sort are hypocrites, and I would all the world did know your hypocrisy, your tyranny, ignorance and Idolatry. Upon these words, the Bishop did for that time dismiss him, commanding that on Monday the 16. day of the same month,1 between the hours of one & three in the after noon, he should again be brought thither, there to have the definitive sentence of condemnation pronounced against him, if he remained then in his former constancy.
Phil. You and all other of your sorte are hypocrites, and I would al the world did know your hypocrisy, your tyranny, ignoraunce and Idolatry. Upon these wordes, the Bishop did for that tyme dismisse him, cōmaunding that on Monday the 16. day of the same moneth,1 betwene the hours of one & three in the after noone, he shoulde agayne be brought thither, there to haue the definitiue sentence of condēnation pronounced against him, if he remayned then in his former constancy.
AT which day and time, Master Philpot being there presented before the bishops of London,1 Bath, Worcester, and Lichfield, Boner Bishop of London began his talk in this manner.
AT which day and time, Mayster Philpot being there presented before the bishops of London,1 Bath, Worcester, and Liechfield, Boner Bishop of London began hys talke in this maner.
London. My Lord Stokesley, my predecessor, when he went about to give sentence against an heretic, used to make this prayer. Deus qui errantibus ut in viam possint redire justitiae veritatis tuae lumen ostendis, 1da cunctis qui Christiana professione cē sentur, & illa respuere quae huic inimica sint nomini, & ea quae sint apta sectari per Christum dominum nostrum, Amen. Which I will follow. And so he read it with a loud voice in Latin. To the which Master Philpot said:
London. My Lorde Stokesley, my predecessour, when he went about to geue sentence agaynst an hereticke, vsed to make this prayer. Deus qui errantibus vt in viam possint redire iustitiae veritatis tuae lumen ostendis, 1da cunctis qui Christiana professione cē sentur, & illa respuere quae huic inimica sint nomini, & ea quae sint apta sectari per Christum dominum nostrum, Amen. Which I will folow. And so he read it with a loud voice in Latin. To the which Mayster Philpot sayd: