¶ What the Church is.
pp. 249–279168 passagespart 1 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 249–279168 passagespart 1 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This word Church 1hath diverse significations. First it signifieth a place or house, whether Christen people were wont in the old time to resort at times convenient, for to hear the word of doctrine, the law of God & the faith of our Saviour Jesus Christ, & how and what to pray and whence to ask power and strength to live godly. For 2the officers thereto appointed preached the price word of God only and prayed in a t••ng that all men understood. And yt people hearkened unto his prayers, & said thereto Amen & prayed with him in their hearts, & of him learned to pray at home and every where, and to instruct every man his household.
THis worde Churche 1hath diuerse significations. First it signifieth a place or house, whether Christen people were wont in the old tyme to resorte at tymes cōuenient, for to heare the word of doctrine, the law of God & the fayth of our Sauiour Iesus Christ, & how and what to pray and whence to aske power and strength to liue godly. For 2the officers therto appointed preached the price word of God onely and pray•d in a t••ng that all men vnderstode. And yt people hearkned vnto his prayers, & sayd thereto Amē & prayed with him in their hartes, & of him learned to pray at home and euery where, and to instruct euery man his houshold.
Where now we hear but voices with out signification and buzzings, howlings and cryings, as it were the hazings of Foxes or baitings of Bear•s, & wonder at disguisings & t•yes whereof we know no meaning.
Where now we heare but voyces with out signification and buzsinges, howlynges and cryinges, as it were the ha•yng•s of Foxes or baytings of Bear•s, & wonder at disguisings & t•yes wherof we know no meanyng.
By reason whereof we be fallen into such ignorance, that we know of the mercy & promises which are in Christ nothing at all.
By reason wherof we be fallen into such ignorauncie, that we know of the mercy & promises whiche are in Christ nothyng at all.
And of the law of God we think as do the Turks, and as did the old 1heathen people, how that it is a thing which every man may do of his own power, and in doing thereof becometh good and waxeth righteous and deserveth heaven: yea and are yet more mad then that. For we imagine the same of Phantasies and vain ceremonies of our own making, neither needful unto the taming of our own flesh, neither profitable unto our neighbour, neither honour unto God.
And of the law of God we thinke as do the Turkes, and as did the old 1heathen people, how that it is a thyng which euery man may do of his owne power, and in doyng therof becōmeth good and waxeth righteous and deserueth heauen: yea and are yet more mad then that. For we imagine the same of Phantasies and vayne ceremonies of our owne making, neither nedefull vnto the tamyng of our owne flesh, neither profitable vnto our neighbour, neither honour vnto God.
And of prayer we think, that no 1man can pray but at Church, and that it is nothing else but to say Pater noster unto a post. Wherewith yet and with other observances of our own imagining, we believe, we deserve to be sped of all that our blind hearts desire.
And of prayer we thinke, that no 1man can pray but at Church, and that it is nothing els but to say Pater noster vnto a post. Wherewith yet and with other obseruaūces of our owne imaginyng, we beleue, we deserue to be sped of all that our blynd hartes desire.
In an other signification it is abused 1and mistaken for a multitude of shaven shorne, and oiled which we now call the spirituality and Clergy. As when we read in the Chronicles king William was a great tyrant and a wicked 2man unto holy Church and took much lands from them. King John 3was also a per••ous man and a wicked unto holy Church, & would have had them punished for theft, murder and what soever mischief they did, as though they had not been people anointed, but even of the vile rascal and common lay people.
In an other signification it is abused 1and mistakē for a multitude of shauen shorne, and oyled which we now call the spiritualtie and Clergy. As when we read in the Chronicles kyng William was a great tyraūt and a wicked 2man vnto holy Church and tooke much landes from them. Kyng Iohn 3was also a per••ous man and a wicked vnto holy Church, & would haue had them punished for theft, murther and what soeuer mischief they dyd, as though they had not bene people annoynted, but euē of the vile rascall and common lay people.
And Thomas Becket was a blessed & an holy man for he dyed for the liberties 1(to do all mischief unpunished) & privileges of the Church. Is he a lay man or a man of the Church? Such is the living of holy Church. So men say 2of holy church. Ye must believe in holy Church & do as they teach you. Will ye not obey holy Church? Will ye not do the penance enjoined you by holy Church? Will yet not forswear obedience unto holy Church? Beware least ye fall into yt indignation of holy church, lest they curse you & so forth. In which 3all we understand but the Pope, Cardinals, Legates, Patriarchs, Archbishops, Bishops, Abbots, Priors, Chancellors, Archdeacons, Commissaries, Officials, Priests, Monks, Friars, Black, Whit, Pied, Grey, and so forth, by (I trow) a thousand names of blasphemy and of hypocrisies & as many sundry fashions of disguisings.
And Thomas Becket was a blessed & an holy man for he dyed for the liberties 1(to do all mischief vnpunished) & priuileges of the Church. Is he a laye man or a man of the Church? Such is the liuing of holy Church. So men say 2of holy church. Ye must beleue in holy Church & do as they teach you. Will ye not obey holy Church? Will ye not do the penaunce enioyned you by holy Church? Will yet not forsweare obedience vnto holy Church? Beware least ye fal into yt indignatiō of holy church, lest they curse you & so forth. In which 3all we vnderstand but ye Pope, Cardinals, Legates, Patriarckes, Archbyshops, Byshops, Abbotes, Priours, Chauncelers, Archdeacons, Commissaries, Officials, Priestes, Monkes, Friers, Blacke, Whit, Pied, Grey, and so forth, by (I trow) a thousand names of blasphemy and of hypocrisies & as many sundry fashions of disguisinges.
It hath yet or should have an other signification, little known among the common people now a days. That is ⟨p. 250⟩to wit, it signifieth a congregation, a multitude or a company gathered together 1in one, of all degrees of people. As a man would say, the church of Lon don, meaning not the spirituality only (as they will be called for their diligent serving of God in the spirit, and so sore eschewing to meddle with temporal matters) but the whole body of the city, of all kinds, conditions & degrees: and the church of Bristow, all that pertain unto the town generally. And what congregation is meant, thou shalt alway understand by the matter that is entreated of, and by the circumstances thereof.
It hath yet or should haue an other signification, little knowen among the common people now a dayes. That is ⟨p. 250⟩to wit, it signifieth a congregation, a multitude or a company gathered together 1in one, of all degrees of people. As a mā would say, the church of Lō don, meaning not the spiritualtie onely (as they will be called for their diligent seruing of God in the spirite, and so sore eschuing to meddle wyth temporall matters) but the whole bodye of the citie, of all kindes, conditions & degrees: and the church of Bristow, all that pertaine vnto the towne generally. And what congregation is mēt, thou shalt alway vnderstand by the matter that is entreated of, and by the circumstaunces thereof.
And in this third signification is the 1church of God or Christ taken in the scripture, even for the whole multitude of all them that receive the name of Christ to believe in him, and not for the clergy only. For Paul saith Gal. i. 2I persecuted the church of God above measure, which was not the preachers only, but all that believed generally, as it is to see Act. xxij. where he saith, 3I persecuted this way even unto the death, binding and putting in prison both men and women. And Gal. i. I 4was unknown concerning my person unto the congregations of the Jews which were in Christ. And Rom. 5xvi. I commend unto you Phoebe the Deaconi••e of the church of Cenchris. And the churches of Asia salute you. i. 6Corin. the last.
And in this third signification is the 1church of God or Christ taken in the scripture, euē for the whole multitude of all them that receaue the name of Christ to beleue in him, and not for the clergy onely. For Paule sayth Gal. i. 2I persecuted the church of God aboue measure, which was not the preachers onely, but all that beleued generally, as it is to see Act. xxij. where he saith, 3
And if a man can not rule his own house, how shall he take the care of the church of God. i. Tim. iij? if any faithful 1man or woman have widows, let them find them, that the church be not charged. i. Tim. v. And Mat. 18. 2if thy brother hear thee not, tell the church or congregation and so forth. 3In which places and throughout all the scripture, the church is taken for the whole multitude of them that believe in Christ in that place, in that parish, town, city, province, land, or throughout all the world, and not for the spirituality only.
And if a man can not rule his owne house, how shall he take the care of the church of God. i. Tim. iij? if any faithfull 1man or woman haue widdowes, let them finde them, that the church be not charged. i. Tim. v. And Mat. 18. 2if thy brother heare thee not, tell the church or congregation and so forth. 3In which places and thoroughout all the scripture, the church is taken for ye whole multitude of them that beleue in Christ in that place, in that parishe, towne, citie, prouince, land, or thoroughout all the worlde, and not for the spiritualtie onely.
Notwithstanding yet it is sometimes taken generally for all them that embrace 1the name of Christ, though their faiths be naught, or though they have no faith at all. And sometimes it is taken specially for the elect only, in whose hearts God hath written his law with his holy spirit, and given them a feeling faith of the mercy that is in Christ Jesus our Lord.
Notwithstāding yet it is somtimes taken generally for all them that embrace 1the name of Christ, though their faithes be naught, or though they haue no fayth at all. And sometimes it is taken specially for the electe onely, in whose hartes God hath written hys lawe with his holy spirite, and geuen them a feeling faith of the mercy that is in Christ Iesu our Lord.
Wherefore in as much (as the clergy, as the nature of those hard & indurat Adamant stones is, to draw all to them) had appropriate unto themselves the term that of right is common 1unto all the whole congregation of them that believe in Christ, & with their false and subtle wiles had beguiled and mocked the people, & brought them into the ignorance of the word, making them understand by this word church, nothing but the shaven flock, of them that shore the whole world: therefore in the translation of the new Testament where I found this word Ecclesia, I interpreted it, by this word congregation. Even therefore did I it, and not of any mischievous mind or purpose to stablish heresy, as master More untruly reporteth of me in his Dialogue, where he raileth on yt translation of the new Testament.
WHerefore in as much (as the clergy, as the nature of those hard & indurat Adamātstones is, to draw all to them) had appropriat vnto themselues the terme that of right is common 1vnto all the whole congregation of them that beleue in Christ, & wyth their false and subtil wyles had beguiled and mocked the people, & brought them into the ignoraunce of the word, making thē vnderstand by this worde church, nothing but the shauen flocke, of them that shore the whole worlde: therefore in the translation of the new Testament where I found this word Ecclesia, I enterpreted it, by thys word congregation. Euen therfore did I it, and not of any mischeuous mynde or purpose to stabl•she heresie, as master More vntruely reporteth of me in hys Dialoge, where he rayleth on yt translation of the new Testament.
And when M. More saith, that this word Church is known well enough. I report me unto the consciences of all the land, whether he say truth or other wise, or whether the lay people understand by Church the whole multitude of all that profess Christ, or the juggling spirits only. And when he saith that congregation is a more general 1term, if it were, it hurteth not. For the circumstance doth ever tell what congregation is meant. Nevertheless yet saith he not the truth. For wheresoever I may say a congregation, there may I say a Church also, as the Church of the devil, the Church of Satan, the Church of wretches, yt Church of wicked men, the Church of liars and a Church of Turks thereto.
And when M. More sayth, that this word Church is knowen wel inough. I report me vnto the consciēces of all the land, whether he say truth or other wise, or whether the lay people vnderstand by Church the whole multitude of all that professe Christ, or the iugglyng spirites onely. And whē he saith that congregation is a more generall 1terme, if it were, it hurteth not. For the circumstance doth euer tell what cō gregation is ment. Neuerthelesse yet sayth he not the truth. For whersoeuer I may say a congregation, there may I say a Church also, as the Church of the deuill, the Church of Sathan, the Church of wretches, yt Church of wickedmen, the Churche of lyers and a Church of Turkes therto.
For M. More must grant (if he will have Ecclesia translated throughout all the new Testament by this word Church) that Church is as common as Ecclesia. Now is Ecclesia a Greek 1word and was in use before the time of the Apostles and taken for a congregation among the heathen, where was no congregation of God or of Christ. And also Lucas him self useth Ecclesia for a Church or congregation of heathen people thrice in one Chapter, even in the xix. of the Acts, where Demetrius the goldsmith or silversmith had gathered 2a company against Paul for preaching against Images.
For M. More must graunt (if he will haue Ecclesia translated throughout all the new Testament by this woorde Church) that Church is as commō as Ecclesia. Now is Ecclesia a Greeke 1word and was in vse before the tyme of the Apostles and taken for a cōgregation among the heathē, where was no congregation of God or of Christ. And also Lucas him selfe vseth Ecclesia for a Church or congregation of heathen people thrise in one Chapter, euē in the xix. of the Actes, where Demetrius the goldsmith or siluersmith had gathered 2a company agaynst Paule for preachyng agaynst Images.
Howbeit M. More hath so long used▪ ⟨p. 251⟩his figures of Poetry, that (I suppose) 1when he erreth most, he now by the reason o• a long custom, believeth himself, that he saith most true. Or else (as the wise people which when they dance naked in nets believe that no man seeth them) even so M. More thinketh that his errors be so subtly couched that no man can espy them. So blind he counteth all other men in comparison of his great understanding. But charitably I exhort him in Christ to take heed, for though Judas were wilier then his fellows to get lucre, yet 2he proved not most wise at yt last end. Neither though Balaam the false Prophet 3had a clear sight to bring y• curse of God upon the children of Israel for honours sake, yet his covetousness did so blind his prophecy, that he could not see his own end. Let therefore M. 4More and his company awake be times ere ever their sin be ripe, lest the voice of their wickedness asceno• up and awake God out of his sleep, to look upon them and to how his ears unto their cursed blasphemies against the open truth, and to send his harvest men and mowers of vengeance to reap it.
Howbeit M. More hath so long vsed▪ ⟨p. 251⟩his figures of Poetry, that (I suppose) 1whē he erreth most, he now by the reason o• a long custome, beleueth himself, that he sayth most true. Or els (as the wise people which when they daunce naked in nettes beleue that no man seeth them) euen so M. More thinketh that his errours be so subtilly couched that no man can espy them. So blinde he counteth all other men in comparison of his great vnderstandyng. But charitably I exhorte him in Christ to take hede, for though Iudas were wilier then his felowes to get lucre, yet
But how happeth it that M. More hath not contended in likewise against his darling Erasmus all this long 1while? Doth not he change this word Ecclesia into congregation and that not seldom in the new Testament? peradventure he oweth him favour because he made Moria in his house. Which book if it were in English, then should every man see, how that he then was far otherwise minded then he now writeth. But verily I think that as Judas betrayed not Christ for any love that he had unto the high Priests, Scribes and Pharisees, but only to come by that wherefore he thirsted: even so M. More (as there are tokens evident) 2wrote not these books for any affection that he bare unto the spiritualty or unto the opinions which he so barely defendeth, but to obtain only that which he was an hungered for: I pray God that he eat not to hastily lest he be choked at the latter end, but that he repent and resist not the spirit of God which openeth light unto the world.
But how happeth it that M. More hath not contended in likewise against hys derelyng Erasmus all this longe 1while? Doth not he chaūge this word Ecclesia into congregatiō and that not seldome in the new Testamēt? peraduenture he oweth him fauour because he made Moria in hys house. Whiche booke if it were in English, thē should euery man see, how that he then was farre otherwise mynded then he now writeth. But verely I thinke that as Iudas betrayd not Christ for any loue that he had vnto the hyghe Priestes, Scribes and Phariseis, but onely to come by that wherfore he thirsted: euē so M. More (as there are tokens euidēt) 2wrote not these bookes for any affectiō that he bare vnto the spiritualty or vnto the opinions which he so barely defēdeth, but to obtaine onely that which he was an hungred for: I pray God that he eate not to hastly lest he be chokeo at the latter end, but that he repēt and resist not the spirite of God which openeth light vnto the worlde.
AN other thing which he rebuketh, is, that I interpret this Greek word Presbiteros by this word Senior. 1Of a truth Senior is no very good English, though Senior and Junior be used in the universities: but there came no better in my mind at that time. Howbeit I spied my fault since, long ere M. More told it me, and have • dead it in all the works which I since made, and call it an Elder. And in that he maketh here•ie of it, to call 2Presbiteros an Elder, he condemneth their own old Latin text of heresy also, which they use yet daily my• •ch and have used, I suppose, this, I suppose, this run hum dread years. For that text doth[…]an elder likewise. In the. 1. Pet. 5. •s 3standeth it in the Latin text. Se•ores qui in vobis sunt, obsecro ego con• pascite qui in vobis est gregem Chri• […]elders that are among you I[…]which am an elder also, that ye seed flock of Christ, which is among[…]There is Presbyteros calle• […]And in that he saith feed Chris• he meaneth even the Minister chosen to teach the people & to[…]them in Gods word & no •ay[…]And in the 2. Epistle of Joh• […] 4text, Senior electae Dominae & […] The elder unto the elect Lady[…]her children. And in the[…]John. Senior Ga•o dilecto. […] 5unto the beloved Gai•s. In these[…]pistles Presbyteros is calle an[…]And in the xx. of the Acts, y text s
And when he layeth Timothy unto my charge, how he was young, then he ⟨p. 252⟩we•eth that he hath wo••e his golden spu•s: But I would pray him to show me where he readeth that Paul calleth him Presbyteros, Priest or Elder. I […] not then call him Episcopus properly. For those over•ears which 1we now call Bishops after the Greek word, we• alway biding in one place to[…]the congregation there. N•w was T•the an Apostle. And Paul also writeth that he came shortly again. well, will he say, it cometh yet all to one. For if it be cometh the lower Minister to be of a sad and dis• much more it becometh the higher. It is •h. But ij. things are without law, God and necessity. If 2God to show his power shall shed out his grace more upon youth then upon age at a […], who shall let him? we•ē be no […] v• to rule or to preach 3(for both are forbidden them) yet hath God endowed them with his spirit at sundry times and showed his power and goodness upon them and wrought wonderful things by them, because 4he would not have them •d. We ••ad that women have judged all Israel and have been great propheti•ies and have done mighty deeds. Yea and if stones be true, women have preached sense the opening of yt new Testament.
And when he layth Tmothe vnto my charge, how he was young, thē he
Do not our women now Christen and minister the Sacrament of Baptism in time of need? Might they not by as good reason preach also, if necessity required? […] a woman were driven into some Island, where Christ was never preached, might she there not preach him, it she had the g•t thereto? Might she not also Baptise? And why might she not, by the same reason minister the Sacrament of the body and blood of Christ, and teach them how to chose •rs & ministers? O poor women, how despite ye them? The vi• the better welcome unto you. An whore had ye lever than an honest wife. If only shaven and anointed may do these things, then Christ did them not nor any of his Apostles, nor any man in long time after. For they used no such ceremonies.
Do not our w•men now Christen and minister the Sacrament of Baptisme in tyme of nede? Might they not by as good reason preach also, if necessitie required? 〈…〉 a woman were driuē into some Iland, where Christ was neuer preached, might she there not preach him, it she had the g•t thereto? Might she not also Baptise? And why might she not, by the same reason minister the Sacrament of the body and bloud of Christ, and teach them how to chose •rs & ministers? O poore wemen, how despite ye them? The vi• the better welcome vnto you. An whore had ye leuer thē an honest wife. If onely shauen and annoynted may do these thinges, then Christ dyd them not nor any of his Apostles, nor any man in long tyme after. For they vsed no such ceremonies.
Notwithstanding, though God be under no law, and necessity lawless: 1yet be we under a law, and ought to prefer the men before the women, & age before youth, as •he as we can. For it is against the law of nature that young men should rule the elder, and as uncomely as that women should rule the men, but when need requireth. And therefore if Paul had had other shift, and a man of age as mete for 2the room, he would not have put Timothy in the office, he should no doubt have been kept back until a fuller age, and have learned in the mean time in silence. And whatsoever thou be that readest this, I exhort thee in our lord, that thou read both yt epis•s of Paul to Timothy, that thou mayst see how diligently (as a mother careth for her child if it be in peril) Paul writeth unto Timothy to instruct him, to teach him, to exhort, to courage him, to sh••e him up, to be wise, sober, diligent, circumspect, sad, humble and meek, saying▪ these I write that thou mayest 3know how to behave thy self in the house of God, which is the church or congregation. A•oy•• •ustes of yo•h, beware of ungodly fables & old wives tales, & avoid the company of men of corrupt minds, which wast their brains about wrangling questions. Let no man despise thy•e youth. As who should say, youth is a despised thing of it self, whereunto men give none obedience or reverence naturally. See therefore that thy ve••ue exceed, 4to recompense thy lack of age, and that thou so behave thy self that no fault be found with thee. And again, rebuke not an Elder sharply, but exhort him as thy father, and young men as thy brethren, and the elder women as thy mothers, and yt young women as thy sisters, and such like in every chapter. Adm none accusation against an Elder under less then two witnesses. And Paul chargeth him in the sight of God, and of the Lord Jesus Christ, and of his elect Angels, to do nothing rashly or of affection. And shortly whereunto youth is most prove and ready to fall, thereof warneth he him with all diligence, even almost or altogether half a osen times of some one thing. And finally as a man would
And when he affirmeth that I say, how that the oiling and shaving is no 1part of the Priesthood. That improne•h he not, nor can do. And therefore I say i• yet. And when he hath insearched the most that he can, this is all that he can say against me, that of an hundred there be not x. that have the properties ⟨p. 253⟩which Paul requireth to be in them. Wherefore if oiling and shaving be no part of their Priesthood, then evermore of a thousand ix. hundred at the lest should be no Priests at all. And quoth your friend would confirm it with an oath and swear deeply, that it would follow and that it must needs so be. Which argument yet, if there were no other shift I would solve after an Oxford fashion, with concedo consequentiam & consequens. And I say moreover that their anointing is but a ceremony borrowed of the Jews, though they have somewhat altered the manner, and their shaving borrowed of the heathen Priests, and that they be no 2more of their priesthood, then the oil, salt, spittle, •aper and chrisom cloth of the substance of baptism. Which things no doubt, because they be of their con•uring, they would have preached of necessity unto the salvation of the child, except necessity had driven them unto the contrary.
And when he affirmeth that I say, how that the oyling and shauing is no 1part of the Priesthode. That improne•h he not, nor can do. And therfore I say i• yet. And when he hath insearched the •most that he cā, this is all that he can say agaynst me, that of an hundred there be not x. that haue the properties ⟨p. 253⟩which Paule requireth to be in them. Wherfore if oyling and shauyng be no part of their Priesthode, then euermore of a thousand ix. hundred at the lest should be no Priests at all. And quoth your frend would confirme it with an oth and sweare depely, that it would folow and yt it must nedes so be. Which argument yet, if there were no other shift I would solue after an Oxford fashion, with concedo consequentiam & consequens. And I say moreouer that their annoynting is but a ceremonie borowed of ye Iewes, though they haue somewhat altered the maner, and their shauing borowed of the heathen Priestes, and that they be no
And seeing that the oil is not of necessity, let M. More tell me what more virtue is in the oil of confirmation, in as much as the bishop sacreth the one as well as the other: yea and let him tell the reason why there should be 1more virtue in the oil wherewith yt Bishop anointeth his Priests. Let him tell you from whence the oil cometh, how it is made, and why he selleth it to the curates wherewith they anoint the sick, or whether this be of less virtue then the other.
And seing that the oyle is not of necessitie, let M. More tell me what more vertue is in the oyle of confirmatiō, in as much as the bishop sacreth the one as well as the other: yea and let hym tell the reason why there shoulde be 1more •ertue in the oyle wherewith yt Byshop annointeth his Priestes. Let him tell you from whence the oyle cō meth, how it is made, and why he selleth it to the curates wherewyth they annointe the sicke, or whether this be of lesse vertue then the other.
And finally, why used not the Apostles 1this greek word [Greek or Hebrew], or the interpreter this Latin word Sacerdos, but alway this word Presbyteros and Senior, by which was at that time nothing signified but an Elder? And it 2was no doubt taken of the custom of the Hebrews, where the officers were ever elderly men as nature requireth. As it appeareth in the old testament and also in the new. The Scribes, Pharisees, and the elders of the people saith the text, which were the officers and rulers, so called by the reason of their age.
And finally, why vsed not the Apostles 1this greke worde 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or the interpreter this Latin woorde Sacerdos, but alway this worde Presbyteros and Senior, by which was at that time nothing signified but an Elder? And it 2was no doubt taken of the custome of the Hebrues, where the officers were euer elderly men as nature requireth. As it appeareth in the olde testament and also in the new. The Scribes, Pharises, and the elders of the people sayth the text, which were the officers and rulers, so called by the reason of their age.
HE rebuketh me also that I translate 1this greek word [Greek or Hebrew] into love, and not rather into charity, so holy & so known a term. Verily charity is no known English, in that sense which agape requireth. For when we say, give your alms in the worship of God and sweet saint charity, and when the father teacheth his son to say blessing father for saint charity, what mean they? In good faith they wot not. Moreover when we say, God help you, I have done my charity for this day, do we not take it for a•s? And the man is ever childing and out 2of charity, and I beshrew him saving my charity, there we take it for patience. And when I say a charitable man, it is taken for merciful. And though mercifulness be a good love, or rather spring of a good love, yet is not every good love mercifulness. As when a woman loveth her husband godly, or a man his wife or his friend that is in none adversity, it is not alway mercifulness. Also we say not this man 3hath a great charity to god, but a great love. Wherefore I must have used this general term love, in spite of mine hart oftentimes. And agape & charitas were words used among the Hethe• ere Christ came, and signified therefore more then a godly love. And we may say well enough and have heard it spoken that the Turks be charitable one to an other among themselves, & some of them unto the christen to. Besides all this agape is common unto all loves.
HE rebuketh me also that I trāslate 1thys greke worde 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 into loue, and not rather into charitie, so holy & so knowen a terme. Ʋerely charitie is no knowen Englishe, in that sence which agape requireth. For when we say, geue your almes in the worship of God and sweete saint charitie, and when the father teacheth his sonne to say blessing father for saint charitie, what meane they? In good fayth they wot not. Moreouer whē we say, God helpe you, I haue done my charitie for this day, do we not take it for a•s? And the man is euer childing and out
And when M. More saith every love 1is not charity, no more is every Apostle Christs Apostle, nor every Angel Gods Angel, nor every hope christen hope, nor every saith or belief Christs belief, and so by an hundred thousand words. So that if I should alway use but a word that were no more general then the word I interpret, I should interpret nothing at all. But the matter it self and the circumstances do declare what love, what hope, and what faith is spoken of. And finally I say not charity God, or charity your neighbour, but jove God and love your neighbour, yea & though we say a man ought to love his neighbours wife & his daughter, a Christen man doth understand that he is commanded to defile his neighbours wife or his daughter.
And when M. More saith euery loue 1is not charitie, no more is euery Apostle Christes Apostle, nor euery Angell Gods Angell, nor euery hope christen hope, nor euery sayth or beliefe Christes beleife, and so by an hūdred thousand wordes. So that if I should alway vse but a worde yt were no more generall then the worde I enterprete, I should enterprete nothing at all. But the matter it selfe and the circumstaunces do declare what loue, what hope, and what fayth is spokē of. And finally I say not charitie God, or charitie your neighbour, but ioue God and loue your neighbour, ye & though we say a man ought to loue his neighbours wife & his daughter, a Christen man doth vnderstand that he is commaūded to defile his neighbours wife or his daughter.
And with like reasons rageth he 1because I turn [Greek or Hebrew] into favour and not into grace, saying that every favour is not grace, and that in some favour there is but little grace. I can say also in some grace there is little ⟨p. 254⟩goodness. And when we say, he standeth well in my Ladies grace, we understand no great godly savour. And in Universities many ungracious graces are gotten.
ANd with lyke reasons rageth he 1because I turne 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 into fauour and not into grace, saying that euery fauour is not grace, and that in some fauour there is but little grace. I can say also in some grace there is little ⟨p. 254⟩goodnesse. And when we say, he standeth well in my Ladyes grace, we vnderstand no great godly sauour. And in Ʋniuersities many vngracious graces are gotten.
And that I use this word knowledge 1and not confession, and this word repentance and not penance. In which all he can not prove, that I give not the right English unto the Greek word. But it is a far other thing that pay•eth them and byteth them by the breasts. There he secret pangs that pinch the very hearts of them, whereof they dare not complain. The sickness that maketh them so impatient is, that they have lost their juggling terms. For the doctors and preachers were wont to make many divisions, distinctions & sorts of grace, gratis data, gratum faciens, preveniens & subsequens. And with confession they 2juggled, & so made the people, as oft as they spake of it: understand shrift in the care. Whereof the Scripture maketh no mention: no it is clean against the Scripture as they use it and preach it, and unto God an abomination and a soul stinking sacrifice unto the filthy Idol Priapus. The loss of those juggling terms is the matter where of all these bots breed, that gnaw them by the belies and make them so unquiet.
ANd that I vse this worde knowledge 1and not confession, and this word repentaunce and not penaunce. In which all he can not proue, that I geue not the right Englishe vnto the Greeke word. But it is a farre other thyng that pay•eth them and byteth them by the brestes. There he secret panges that pinch the very hartes of them, wherof they dare not cōplayne. The sekenesse that maketh them so impaciēt is, that they haue lost their iugglyng termes. For the doctours and preachers were wont to make many dimisiōs, distinctions & sortes of grace, gratis data, gratum faciens, preueniens & subsequens. And with confession they 2iuggled, & so made the people, as oft as they spake of it: vnderstand shrift in the care. Wherof the Scripture maketh no mentiō: no it is cle•ne agaynst the Scripture as they vse it and preach it, and vnto God an abhominatiō and a soule stinkyng sacrifice vnto the filthy Idole Priapus. The losse of those iugglyng termes is the matter where of all these bottes brede, that gnaw them by the belyes and make them so vnquiet.
And in like manner, by this word penance, 1they make the people understand holy deeds of their enjoining, with which they must make satisfaction 2unto Godward for their sins. When all the Scripture preacheth that Christ hath made full satisfaction for our sins to Godward, & we must now be thankful to God again and kill the lusts of our flesh with holy works of gods enjoining & to take patiently all that God layeth on my back. And if I have 3hurt my neighbour, I am bound to shr•e my self unto him and to make him amends, if I have wherewith, or if not then to ask him forgiveness, and he is bound to forgive me. And as for their penance the Scripture knoweth not of. The Greek hath Metanoia and Metanoite, repentance and repent▪ or forthinkyng and forthinke. As we say in English it forthinketh me or I forthinke, and I repent or it repenteth me and I am sorry that I did it. So now the Scripture •ayth repent or let it forthinke you and come & believe the Gospel or glad tidings that is brought you in Christ, and so shall all be forgiven you, and henceforth live a new life: And it will follow if I repent in 4the hart, that I shall do no more so willingly and of purpose. And if I believed the Gospel, what God hath done for me in Christ, I should surely love him again & of love prepare my self unto his commandments.
And in like maner, by this word penaunce, 1they make the people vnderstand holy deedes of their enioynyng, with which they must make satisfactiō 2vnto Godward for their sinnes. When all the Scripture preacheth that Christ hath made full satisfactiō for our sinnes to Godward, & we must now be thākfull to God agayne and kill the lustes of our flesh with holy workes of gods enioynyng & to take paciently all that God layeth on my back. And if I haue
These things to be even so M. More knoweth well enough. For he understandeth the Greek, and he knew them long ere I. But so blind is covetousness & drunken desire of honour. Gifts blind the eyes of the seeing and pervert the words of the righteous Deut. xvij 1When covetousness findeth vantage in serving falsehood, it riseth up into an o•mate malice against the truth & seeketh all means to resist it, and to quench it. As Balaam the false Prophet, though he wist that God loved Israel 2and had blessed them and promised them great things, and that he would fulfil his promises, yet for covetousness and desire of honour, he fell into such malice against the truth of God, that he sought •ow to resist it and to curse the people. Which when God would not let him do, he turned him self an other way and gave pestilent counsel, to make the people sin against God, whereby the wrath of God •el upon them, and many thousand perished. Notwithstanding Gods truth abode fast and was fulfilled in the rest. And Balaam as he was the cause that many perished, so escaped he not him self. No more did any that maliciously resisted the open truth against his own conscience, sense the world began, that ever I read. For it is sin against y• holy ghost, which Christ saith 3shall neither be forgiven here nor in the world to come, which text may this wise be understand that as that sin 4shall be punished with everlasting dā nation in the life to come: even so shall it not escape vengeance here. As thou •eest in Judas, in Pharaoh, in Balaam and in all other tyrants which against their consciences resisted the open truth of God.
These thinges to be euen so M. More knoweth well inough. For he vnderstandeth the Greke, and he knew them long yer I. But so blynd is couetousnesse & dronkē desire of honour. Giftes blind the eyes of the seyng and peruert the wordes of the righteous Deut. xvij
So now the cause why our Prelates thus rage, & that moveth them to call M. More to help, is not that they find just causes in the translation, but because they have lost their juggling and feigned terms, wherewith Peter prophesied ⟨p. 255⟩1they should make merchandise of the people.
So now the cause why our Prelates thus rage, & that moueth them to call M. More to helpe, is not that they finde iust causes in the translation, but because they haue lost their iugglyng and fayned termes, wherewith Peter prophesied ⟨p. 255⟩1they should make marchaundise of the people.
AN other doubt there is, whether the Church or congregation be before 1the Gospel or the Gospel before the Church. Which question is as hard to solve, as whether the father be elder then the son or the son elder then his father. For the whole Scripture and all believing hearts testify that we are begotten through the word. Wherefore if the word beget the congregation, & he that begetteth is before him that is begotten, then is the Gospel before the Church. Paul also Rom. ix. saith, how shall they call on him whom they 2believe not? And how shall they believe without a preacher? That is, Christ must first be preached ere men can believe in him. And then it followeth, that the word of the preacher must be before the faith of the believer. And therefore 3in as much as the word is before the faith, and faith maketh the congregation, therefore is the word or Gospel before the congregation. And again as the air is dark of it self & receiveth all her light of the sun: even so are all mens hearts of themselves dark with lies and receive all their truth of Gods word, in that they consent thereto. And moreover as the dark air giveth the sun no light, but contrariwise the light of the sun in respect of the air is of it self and lighteneth the air & purgeth it from darkness: even so the lying hart of man can give the word of God no truth, but contrary wise the truth of Gods word is of her self, and lighteneth the harts of the believers and maketh them true, and cleanseth them from lies, as thou readest John. xv. ye be clean by reason of the 4word. Which is to be understand, in that the word had purged their hearts from lies, from false opinions & from thinking evil good, and therefore from consenting to sin. And John. xvij. 5sanctify them O father thorough thy truth. And thy word is truth. And thus thou seest that Gods truth dependeth not of man. It is not true because man so saith or admitteth it for true: But man is true because he believeth it, testifieth and giveth witness in his hart that it is true. And Christ also saith him self
But did not y• Apostles teach ought 1by mouth that they wrote not? I answer, because that many taught one thing, and every man the same in divers places and unto divers people. and confirmed every sermon with a sundry miracle: therefore Christ & his Apostles preached an •red thousand sermons, and did as many miracles, which had been superfluous to have been all written. But the pith and substance in general of every thing necessary unto our souls health, both of what we ought to believe, and what we ought to do was written, and of the miracles done to confirm it, as many as were needful. So that whatsoever 2we ought to believe or do, that same is written expressly, or drawn out of that which is written.
BUt did not y• Apostles teach ought 1by mouth that they wrot not? I aunswere, because that many taught one thyng, and euery man the same in diuers places and vnto diuers people. and confirmed euery sermō wyth a sundry miracle: therfore Christ & his Apostles preached an •red thousād sermons, and did as many miracles, which had bene superfluous to haue bene all written. But the pith and substaunce in generall of euery thing necessary vnto our soules health, both of what we ought to beleue, and what we ought to do was written, and of the miracles done to confirme it, as many as were nedeful. So that whatsoeuer 2we ought to beleue or do, that same is written expresely, or drawen out of that which is written.
AN other thyng which he rebuketh, is, that I interprete this Greeke worde Presbiteros by this worde Senior. 1Of a truth Senior is no very good Englishe, though Senior and Iuniot be vsed in the vniuersities: but there came no better in my mynde at that tyme. Howbeit I spied my fault since, long yer M. More tolde it me, and haue • ded it in all the woorkes which I sens made, and call it an Elder. And in that he maketh here•ie of it, to call 2Presbiteros an Elder, he condemneth their owne old Latin text of heresie also, which they vse yet dayly my• •ch and haue vsed, I suppose, this, I suppose, this run hū dred yeares. For that text doth〈…〉an elder likewise. In the. 1. Pet. 5. •s 3standeth it in ye Latin text. Se•ores qui in vobis sunt, obsecro ego con• pascite qui in vobis est gregem Chri• 〈…〉elders that are among you I〈…〉which am an elder also, that ye sed• flocke of Christ, which is among〈…〉There is Presbyteros calle• 〈…〉And in yt he sayth fede Chris• he meaneth euen the Ministe• chosen to teach the people & to〈…〉them in Gods word & no •ay〈…〉And in the 2. Ep•st•e of Ioh• 〈…〉 4text, Senior electae Dominae & 〈…〉 The elder vnto the ele•t Lady〈…〉her children. And in the〈…〉Iohn. Senior Ga•o dilecto. 〈…〉 5vnto the beloued Gai•s. In these〈…〉pistles Presbyteros is calle• an〈…〉And in the xx. of the Actes, y• text s• 6Paule sent for maiores natu Eccle• 〈…〉elders in byrth of the congregation or Church, and sayd vnto them, take〈…〉vnto your selues & vnto y• who•e 〈…〉, ouer which the holy ghos• hath〈…〉 7you Episcopos ad regendum Eccle• Dei, Byshops ouer•ca•s to〈…〉the Church of God. There is • teros called an Elder in byrth〈…〉same immediately called a〈…〉ouersear, to declare what p• ment. Hereof ye see that I haue〈…〉more erred then their owne text〈…〉they haue vsed sence the scripture wa• first in the Latin •oung, and that their owne text vnderstandeth by Presby•eros 8nothyng saue an Elder. And they were called Elders, because of their age, grauitie & sadnesse, as thou may•t see by the text: and Byshops or ouersears by the reasō of their offices. And all that were called Elders (or Priests if they so wil) were called Bishops also, though they haue diuided yt names now, which thing thou mayst euidently see by the first Chapter of Titus. And Actes xx. and other places mo.
Notwithstanding, though God be vnder no lawe, and necessitie lawlesse: 1yet be we vnder a lawe, and ought to preferre the men before the women, & age before youth, as •he as we cā. For it is agaynst the lawe of nature that young men should rule the elder, and as vncomely as that women shoul•e rule the men, but when neede requireth. And therfore if Paule had had other shift, and a man of age as mete for 2the roome, he would not haue put Timothy in the office, he should no doubt haue bene kept backe vntil a fulier age, and haue learned in the meane time in silence. And whatsoeuer thou be that reade•t this, I exhort thee in our lord, that thou read both yt epis•s of Paule to Timothy, that thou mayst see how diligently (as a mother careth for her childe if it be in perill) Paule writeth vnto Timothy to instruct him, to teach hym, to exhort, to corage hym, to sh••e him vp, to be wise, sober, diligent, circumspect, sad, humble and me•ke, saying▪ these I write that thou mayest 3know how to behaue thy selfe in the house of God, which is the church or congregation. A•oy•• •ustes of yo•h, beware of vngodly fables & old wiues tales, & auoyde the company of men of corrupt myndes, which wast theyr braynes about wrangling questions. Let no man dispise thy•e youth. As who shoulde say, youth is a dispised thyng of it selfe, whereunto men geue none obedience or reuerence naturally. See therefore that thy ve••ue exceede, 4to recompence thy lacke of age, and that thou so behaue thy self that no fault be founde with thee. And againe, rebuke not an Elder sharpely, but exhort him as thy father, and yongmen as thy brethren, and the elder women as thy mothers, and yt yoūg womē as thy sisters, and such like in euery chapter. Adm• none accusation agaynst an Elder vnder lesse then two witnesses. And Paule chargeth hym in the sight of God, and of the Lord Iesus Christ, and of his elect Angels, to do nothing rashely or of affection. And shortely whereunto youth is most proue and ready to fall, therof warneth he hym with all diligence, euen almost or altogether halfe a •osen times of some one thyng. And finally as a man woulde 5teach a childe that had •euer be•ore gone to schole, so tēderly & so carefully doth Paul teach him. It is an other thyng to teach the people, and to teach the preacher. Here Paule teacheth the preacher, young Timothy.
AN other doubt there is, whether the Church or congregatiō be before 1the Gospell or the Gospell before the Church. Which question is as hard to solue, as whether the father be elder then the sonne or the sonne elder then his father. For the whole Scripture and all beleuing hartes testifie that we are begotten through the word. Wherfore if the word beget the congregatiō, & he that begetteth is before hym that is begotten, then is the Gospell before the Church. Paul also Rom. ix. sayth, how shall they call on him whom they 2beleue not? And how shall they beleue without a preacher? That is, Christ must first be preached yer men can beleue in him. And then it foloweth, that the word of the preacher must be before the fayth of the beleuer. And therfore 3in as much as the word is before the faith, and faith maketh the congregation, therfore is the word or Gospell before the congregation. And agayne as the ayre is darke of it selfe & receaueth all her light of the sonne: euen so are all mens hartes of thēselues darke with lyes and receaue all their truth of Gods word, in that they consent therto. And moreouer as the darke ayre geueth the sonne no light, but contrarywise the light of the sonne in respect of the ayre is of it selfe and lighteneth the ayre & purgeth it from darkenesse: euē so the lying hart of man can geue the word of God no truth, but contrary wise the truth of Gods word is of her self, and lighteneth the harts of the beleuers and maketh them true, and clenseth them from lyes, as thou readest Iohn. xv. ye be cleane by reason of the 4word. Which is to be vnderstand, in that the word had purged their harces from lyes, from false opinions & from thinking euill good, and therfore from consentyng to sinne. And Iohn. xvij. 5sanctifie them O father thorough thy truth. And thy woorde is truth. And thus thou seest that Gods truth dependeth not of man. It is not true because man so sayth or admitteth it for true: But man is true because he beleueth it, testifieth and geueth witnesse in hys hart that it is true. And Christ also sayth him selfe Iohn. v. I receaue no witnesse of mā. For if the multitude of 6mās witnesse might make ought true, then were the doctrine of Mahomete truer then Christes.