Hart. I grant, it neither can, nor ought to be denied, that ⟨p. 83⟩every one of those things, and specially, if they be joined all together, do help very much to understand the scriptures rightly. But *yet they are not so sure and certain means as some other are, which we prefer before them. Neither do they help always; nay, sometimes they do hurt rather, and deceive greatly such as expound the Scripture after them. This is not only said, but also proved at large out of the Doctors and Fathers, by that worthy man of great wit and judgement, our countryman M. Stapleton Doctor of Divinity, the Kings Professor of controversies in the university of Douai. Of whose most wholesome work, entitled, A methodical demonstration of doctrinal principles of the faith: one book is wholly spent to show the means, way and order, how to make authentical interpretation of the Scriptures. In the which he layeth this for a ground, that rthe Scripture cannot be rightly understood but by the rule of faith. Whereupon she condemneth the Protestants opinion, that the sense of Scriptures must be fetched out of the Scriptures. Which error of yours to overthrow the more fully: he delivereth four means of expounding the Scriptures; tthe first, very certain and sure, the rule of faith; uthe next, no less certain, the practise of the church; xthe third, at least probable, the consent of the Fathers; ythe last, most infallible, the councels interpretation. And zthese means, he saith, are the only certain sure infallible means, of understanding and expounding the Scripture aright. As for other means, which learned men do use, such as you observed out of S. Austin: he granteth they are profitable, but deceitful many ways, if each of them be severally taken by it self. Which he proveth in particular by the chiefest of them: first, the weighing of circumstances, what goeth before, what cometh after; next, the words and kind of speeches used in the Scriptures; thirdly, athe conference of places together, one to be lightened by an other; fourthly, brecourse to the fountains of the Greek and the Hebrew text. Wherefore, though I acknowledge your way to be a good way, and such as I am well content to walk in, when these our ways shall lead me to it: notwithstanding, sith it is ccommon to us with all Heretics, yea with Jews and Paynims;
Hart. I graunt, it neither can, nor ought to be denyed, that ⟨p. 83⟩euery one of those things, and specially, if they be ioined all togither, doo helpe very much to vnderstand the scriptures rightly. But *yet they are not so sure and certaine meanes as some other are, which we preferre before them. Neither do they helpe alwaies; nay, sometimes they do hurt rather, and deceiue greatlie such as expound the Scripture after them. This is not onelye said, but also proued at large out of the Doctors and Fathers, by that worthie man of great wit and iudgement, our countriman M. Stapleton Doctor of Diuinitie, the Kinges Professor of controuersies in the vniuersitie of Doway. Of whose most wholesome worke, entitled, A methodicall demonstration of doctrinall principles of the faith: one booke is wholly spent to shew the meanes, way and order, how to make authenticall interpretation of the Scriptures. In the which hee layeth this for a ground, that rthe Scripture cannot be rightly vnderstood but by the rule of faith. Whereupon she condemneth the Protestantes opinion, that the sense of Scriptures must be fetched out of the Scriptures. Which errour of yours to ouerthrow the more fully: he deliuereth foure meanes of expounding the Scriptures; tthe first, very certaine and sure, the rule of faith; uthe next, no lesse certaine, the practise of the church; xthe third, at least probable, the consent of the Fathers; ythe last, most infallible, the councels interpretation. And zthese meanes, he saith, are the onely certaine sure infallible meanes, of vnderstanding and expounding the Scripture aright. As for other meanes, which learned men do vse, such as you obserued out of S. Austin: he graunteth they are profitable, but deceitfull many waies, if ech of them be seuerally taken by it selfe. Which he proueth in particular by the chiefest of them: first, the weighing of circumstances, what goeth before, what commeth after; next, the wordes and kinde of speeches vsed in the Scriptures; thirdly, athe conferēce of places togither, one to be lightned by an other; fourthly, brecourse to the fountaines of the Greeke and the Hebrue text. Wherefore, though I acknowledge your way to be a good way, and such as I am well content to walke in, when these our waies shall lead me to it: notwithstanding, sith it is ccommon to vs with all Heretikes, yea with Iewes and Painims;
- *Staplet. princ. doctr. l. 11. ca. •.
- rStaplet. princ. doctr. lib. 11. c. 1.
- scap. 2.
- tcap. 3.
- ucap. 4.
- xcap. 5.
- ycap. 6.
- zcap. •.
- acap. 10.
- bcap. 12.
- ccap. 9.