Rainoldes. That count is evil cast. For, as in the writings of Fathers which we have, some one expoundeth places of Scripture oftentimes otherwise then all the rest, t(a thing notorious and confessed:) so, it is likely that in those which we have not some places were otherwise expounded than they be in those which we have. Yet I will not deny but you had reason so to count. For else your lawyer had been dumb, and could not have spoken a word for his client. But if this be your rule of the churches exposition: then I could have made mine exposition, the churches, with a wet finger, if I would have stuffed it with the names of Fathers. For my words of Peter, that he alone made answer for all the Apostles, & received the keys together with them all, are the words of uS. Austin, though I did not name him. And xS. Ambrose saith of that promise of Christ (I will give thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and the rest which followeth) that what is said to Peter, is said to the Apostles. And yJerome saith, that the foundation and firmness of the church lay on all the Apostles equally, and they did all receive the keys. And zOrigen saith, that Christs promise of building his church, of giving the keys, of binding and loosing, made as to Peter only, was common unto all. And aHilary saith in like sort, that through the worthiness of their faith they obtained ⟨p. 72⟩the keys of the kingdom of heaven, and the power of binding and loosing in heaven and earth. Neither do I doubt but other of the Fathers have said as much as these in the expounding of these words. But have they or not: this is no path for us to walk in, if we seek the right way. For neither might we hope for an end of our travels because of sundry expositions, one contrary to an other: and we should faint for thirst in time of heat and drought, looking for water in the wilderness, as *the travellers of Tema: and (that is worst of all) sometimes we should leave the pure water of truth, and swill up puddle in steed of it. For, although the Fathers were men endued of God with excellent gifts, and brought no small light to understanding of the scriptures: yet learned men in our days may give a right sense of sundry places thereof which the Fathers saw not, yea against the which perhaps they consent.
Rainoldes. That count is euill cast. For, as in the writings of Fathers which we haue, some one expoundeth places of Scripture oftentimes otherwise then all the rest, t(a thing notorious and confessed:) so, it is likely that in those which we haue not some places were otherwise expounded thē they be in those which we haue. Yet I will not deny but you had reason so to count. For else your lawier had béene dumbe, and could not haue spoken a word for his client. But if this be your rule of the churches exposition: then I could haue made mine exposition, the churches, with a wet finger, if I would haue stuffed it with the names of Fathers. For my words of Peter, that he alone made answere for all the Apostles, & receiued the keyes togither with them all, are the wordes of uS. Austin, though I did not name him. And xS. Ambrose saith of that promise of Christ (I will giue thee the keyes of the kingdome of heauen, and the rest which followeth) that what is said to Peter, is said to the Apostles. And yIerom saith, that the foundation and firmenesse of the church lay on all the Apostles equally, and they did all receiue the keyes. And zOrigen saith, that Christes promise of building his church, of giuing the keyes, of binding and loosing, made as to Peter onely, was common vnto all. And aHilarie saith in like sort, that through the worthinesse of their faith they obtained ⟨p. 72⟩the keyes of the kingdome of heauen, and the power of binding and loosing in heauen and earth. Neither doo I doubt but other of the Fathers haue said as much as these in the expounding of these words. But haue they or not: this is no path for vs to walke in, if we séeke the right way. For neither might we hope for an ende of our trauels because of sundrie expositions, one contrarie to an other: and we should faint for thirst in time of heate and drouth, looking for water in the wildernesse, as *the trauellers of Tema: and (that is woorst of all) sometimes wee should leaue the pure water of truth, and swill vp puddle in stéed of it. For, although the Fathers were men indued of God with excellent gifts, and brought no small light to vnderstanding of the scriptures: yet learned men in our dayes may giue a right sense of sundrie places thereof which the Fathers saw not, yea against the which perhaps they consent.
- tSixth. Senen. biblioth. sanct. li. 5. & 6. Alloys. Lipom. caten. in Genes. & Exod.Sixt. Senen. biblioth. sanct. li. 5. & 6. Aloys. Lipom. caten. in Genes. & Exod.
- uIn Johan. tractat. 118.In Iohan. tractat. 118.
- xIn Psal. 38.
- yAduers. Jovinian. lib. 1.Aduers. Iouinian. lib. 1.
- zIn Matth. tractat. 1.
- aDe Trinitat. lib. 6.
- *Job. 6.19.Iob. 6.19.