II. The second question.
pp. 160–16533 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 160–16533 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This question is in controversy between us both with the Papists & the Ubiquitaries, because both of them are of opinion that the things being present in their signs, or under the shows of the signs are covertly and miraculously carried up and down in the hands of the ministers, handled by them, and put into the mouths of the Communicants. We contrariwise teach, that the things with their signs are both together exhibited and received with their signs in the lawful use of the Supper, but in a divers manner. For the ⟨p. 161⟩signs are handled by the Ministers, and taken by the mouth of the Communicants: But the things themselves are given by Christ our high Priest, & received by faith. This point may in like sort with the former be expressed in three propositions; two negative, and one affirmative.
This question is in controuersie betweene vs both with the Papists & the Vbiquitaries, because both of them are of opinion that the things being present in their signes, or vnder the shewes of the signes are covertly and miraculously caried vp and downe in the hands of the ministers, hādled by them, and put into the mouthes of the Communicants. We contrariwise teach, that the thinges with their signes are both togither exhibited and receiued with their signes in the lawful vse of the Supper, but in a diuers manner. For the ⟨p. 161⟩signes are handled by the Ministers, and takē by the mouth of the Communicants: But the things themselues are given by Christ our high Priest, & received by faith. This point may in like sort with the former be expressed in three propositiōs; two negatiue, and one affirmatiue.
The things signified, that is, the body and blood of Christ, are neither handled, nor reached out by the hand of the Ministers to be received corporally in the signs.
The things signified, that is, the bodie and bloude of Christ, are neither handled, nor reached out by the hand of the Ministers to be receaved corporallie in the signes.
1 The first reason is collected negatively from the whole kind of Sacraments, thus, In no Sacrament the Ministers handle or bestow things spiritually signified. Therefore neither in the Lords Supper do they handle the thing spiritually signified.
1 The first reason is collected negatiuelie from the whole kinde of Sacraments, thus, In no Sacrament the Ministers handle or bestowe things spirituallie signified. Therefore neither in the Lords Supper doe they handle the thing spiritually signified.
The Antecedent is proved both by an induction or instance in every Sacrament, which is evident by the adversaries own confession; and also the proportion between the Sacrament, and the word. Marc. 1. I am the voice crying &c. Joh. 1. I baptise with water; he which cometh after me shall baptise with the holy Ghost, and with fire. 1. Cor. 3. 7. Neither he that watereth, nor he that planteth is any thing, but God which giveth the increase. Therefore it holdeth alike also in the Sacraments, which are the visible word.
The Antecedent is proved both by an induction or instance in every Sacrament, which is evident by the adversaries owne confession; and also the proportion betweene the Sacrament, and the worde. Marc. 1. I am the voice crying &c. Ioh. 1. I baptise with water; he which cōmeth after me shall baptise with the holie Ghost, and with fire. 1. Cor. 3. 7. Neither he that watereth, nor hee that planteth is anie thing, but God which giveth the encrease. Therefore it holdeth alike also in the Sacraments, which are the visible word.
2 The second reason is this.
The things signified are not corporally, IN, WITH, or UNDER the signs, as hath been showed. Therefore they are not handled, or distributed by the hand of the Minister.
The things signified are not corporally, IN, WITH, or VNDER the signes, as hath beene shewed. Therefore they are not handled, or distributed by the hand of the Minister.
3 The third reason proceedeth thus, The things signified in the Supper are spiritual, which coupled with their signs are offered in the promise of grace. But the promise of grace is not handled with hands &c.
3 The third reason proceedeth thus, The things signified in the Supper are spirituall, which coupled with their signes are offered in the promise of grace. But the promise of grace is not handled with hands &c.
4 The fourth reason is the testimonies of Fathers; as Chrysost. Sermone de Euch. […]. Think not when ye come to these mysteries, that ye receive the Lords body at the hands of a man, that is to say the Minister; with many other such like places.
4 The fourth reason is the testimonies of Fathers; as Chrysost. Sermone de Euch. 〈…〉. Thinke not whē yee come to these mysteries, that yee receiue the Lordes body at the hands of a mā, that is to say the Minister; with many other such like places.
The things signified I mean, the body and blood of the Lord are not received WITH, IN, and UNDER the bread and wine by the mouth of the body.
The things signified I meane, the body and bloude of the Lord are not received WITH, IN, and VNDER the bread and wine by the mouth of the body.
1 The first is, because they are not bodily present with, in, and under the signs as hath been showed quest. • propos 2.
1 The first is, because they are not bodily present with, in, and vnder the signes as hath beene shewed quest. • propos 2.
2 The second i• because they pass into the belly which is the receptacle appointed for bodily meats 1. Cor. 6. 13. For all which entereth in at the mouth, goeth down into the belly Mat. 13.
2 The secōd i• because they passe into the belly which is the receptacle appointed for bodily meates 1. Cor. 6. 13. For all which entereth in at the mouth, goeth downe into the belly Mat. 13.
3. The third is because the promise, wherein the things are offered, is not received by the mouth.
3. The third is because the promise, wherin the things are offered, is not receiued by the mouth.
The things signified, suppose, The lords body and blood are received spiritually by faith.
The thinges signified, suppose, The lordes bodie and bloud are receiued spritually by faith.
1 The first reason is derived from the condition of the whole kind; because in Sacraments the things signified are received by faith: by which alone as we are justified; so we receive all the benefits of the new Testament.
1 The first reason is deriued from the conditiō of the whole kinde; because in Sacramēts the things signified are receiued by faith: by which alone as we are iustified; so we receiue all the benefites of the new Testament.
2 The second is, because the promise of grace is not apprehended but by faith. Now the communion of the body and blood of Christ is the promise of grace. See Ursin. Volum. 1. Pag. 103.
2 The second is, because the promise of grace is not apprehended but by faith. Nowe the communion of the body and bloud of Christ is the promise of grace. See Vrsin. Volum. 1. Pag. 103.
Ob. To whatsoever instrument the eating of one thing in the Lords Supper appertaineth, to the same the eating of the other ought to appertain. But the eating of one body, that is the bread, in the Lords Supper appertaineth to the mouth. Therefore the eating of the other, which is Christs body, appertaineth to the same.
Ob. To whatsoeuer instrument the eating of one thing in the Lords Supper appertaineth, to the same the eating of the other ought to appertaine. But the eating of one body, that is the bread, in the Lordes Supper appertaineth to the mouth. Therefore the eating of the other, which is Christs body, appertaineth to the same.
Ans. 1 The Major is true in such meats as are naturally conjoined, of contain one the other, of the which sort is a a Pie. Now the bread and the body of Christ are not so joined together. In these then it is false.
Ans. 1 The Maior is true in such meates as are naturally conioined, of containe one the other, of the which sort is a a Pye. Now the bread and the body of Christ are not so ioined togither. In these then it is false.
The Major thus he proves; ⟨p. 164⟩Whosoever includeth in the same word of eating both bread and wine, & the body & blood of Christ affirmeth also that they are both received with the same instrument. But Christ includeth both bread & wine, & his body & blood in one & the same word of eating. Therefore CHRIST affirmeth that they are both received with the same instrument of eating.
The Maior thus he proues; ⟨p. 164⟩Whosoeuer includeth in the same worde of eating both bread and wine, & the body & blood of Christ affirmeth also that they are both receiued vvith the same instrument. But Christ includeth both bread & wine, & his body & bloud in one & the same worde of eating. Therefore CHRIST affirmeth that they are both received with the same instrumēt of eating.
Ans. 1. The proof of the Major faileth, because an universal affirmative should be concluded in Barbara.
Ans. 1. The proofe of the Maior faileth, because an vniuersal affirmatiue should be concluded in Barbara.
2 The Major beggeth that which is in controversy and is denied. The falseness thereof appeareth John the third, where CHRIST includeth in the same word of birth the spirit and the flesh: and yet it followeth not that they both are borne after the same manner, or by the same instrument.
2 The Maior beggeth that which is in controversie and is denyed. The falsenesse thereof appeareth Iohn the third, where CHRIST includeth in the same worde of birth the spirit and the flesh: and yet it followeth not that they both are borne after the same manner, or by the same instrument.
3 The Minor also is false. For this word of eating is referred to the hallowed bread, not to the body, but by way of consequence. For it properly pertaineth unto that, which the Lord took in his hands and brake, which was bread, and not his body. This reason is worthy the marking for that according to the Papists and such as simply maintain Consubstantiation the body of CHRIST is not there before the words of consecration (as they call them) are ⟨p. 165⟩pronounced, but beginneth to be there in the very last instant of the pronouncing of these words, This is my body. But according to the Ubiquitaries, which are as it were chemical consubstantiators, it is there indeed, as in any other bread, but it is not yet edible until after consecration. CHRIST then commanded not to eat that with our mouth in the bread, which as yet was not in the bread, or as yet was not edible.
3 The Minor also is false. For this worde of eating is referred to the hollyed breade, not to the bodie, but by way of consequence. For it properly pertaineth vnto that, which the Lord tooke in his handes and brake, which was bread, and not his body. This reason is vvorthy the marking for that according to the Papistes and such as simplie mainetaine Consubstantiation the bodie of CHRIST is not there before the wordes of consecration (as they call them) are ⟨p. 165⟩pronounced, but beginneth to bee there in the very last instante of the pronouncing of these wordes, This is my bodie. But according to the Vbiquitaries, which are as it were chymicall consubstantiators, it is there indeede, as in any other breade, but it is not yet edible vntill after consecration. CHRIST then commaunded not to eate that with our mouth in the breade, which as yet was not in the breade, or as yet was not edible.
Then again he proves the Major of his former syllogism.
Then againe he proues the Maior of his former syllogisme.
A word having but one signification is to be taken but in one. But eating both of the bread and of the body of Christ hath but one signification, viz. with the mouth. It is then to be taken in one signification of both.
A word having but one signification is to be taken but in one. But eating both of the breade and of the body of Christ hath but one signification, viz. with the mouth. It is then to bee taken in one signification of both.
Ans. 1. Here again faileth the proof of the Major, being an universal affirmative, which should have bin concluded in Barbara.
Ans. 1. Heere againe faileth the proofe of the Maior, being an vniversall affirmatiue, which should haue bin concluded in Barbara.
2 The Minor is a begging of that which is in controversy.
2 The Minor is a begging of that which is in cō troversie.