REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDERED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Universities.REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDRED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Vniuersities.
pp. 17–326288 passagespart 2 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Hitherto Campian hath busied himself in discoursing unto us, what he could, concerning the holy books, being desirous also to deliver unto us, such things as we have depraved in our false translations: save that, as he saith, he reserves this labour for his old College fellow Gregory Martin, & some others, whom he well knoweth will perform it far more learnedly and copiously then himself. Therefore if you think good, we will expect this Martin of whom you speak, and whom I shall easily conceive to be a man of more learning then your self, unless he be a very dolt indeed. And I doubt not but we shall be able to maintain our translations, both Latin and English, against your Martin and all your Colleagues. And as for those petty Doctors whom you lastly reproach, I neither know them, nor the nature of their offence. But when once your friend Martin shall come abroad, who now perhaps is hammering some special piece of work, we shall learn from him many new and excellent points. This your first reason seemed very just in your conceit to maintain your glorious challenge of disputation, with some of the learned of our Universities. But Campian, you had dealt a great deal wiser for your self, if either you had never conceived thes• reasons, or straightway upon the birth smothered them. For before by your great challenge you begat a marvellous and wonderful conceit of your self in every mans mind: and now when they shall read• those slender reasons of yours, they will easily perceive, there is no cause why you should take so much upon you, and they will tontemptuously deride you, as you well deserve, & hiss you out of their schools. Therefore the counsel which Archidamu• gave to ⟨p. 56⟩his Son headily venturing to right with the Athenians, the same do our University men give to to you: Either add to thy might, or abate of thy mind: for no man, Campian, ever took more upon him, and performed less than you have done. But let us see what other things you bring us.
Hitherto Campian hath busied himself in discoursing vnto vs, what he could, concerning the holy bookes, being desirous also to deliuer vnto vs, such things as we haue depraued in our false translations: saue that, as he saith, he reserues this labour for his old Colledge fellow Gregory Martin, & some others, whom he well knoweth will performe it farre more learnedly and copiously then himselfe. Therefore if you thinke good, we will expect this Martin of whom you speake, and whom I shall easily conceiue to be a man of more learning then your selfe, vnlesse he be a very doult indeed. And I doubt not but we shall be able to maintaine our translations, both Latin and English, against your Martin and all your Colleagnes. And as for those petty Doctors whom you lastly reproach, I neither know them, nor the nature of their offence. But when once your friend Martin shall come abroad, who now perhaps is hammering some speciall peece of worke, we shall learne from him many new and excellent points. This your first reason seemed very iust in your conceit to maintaine your glorious challenge of disputation, with some of the learned of our Vniuersities. But Campian, you had delt a great deale wiser for your self, if either you had neuer conceiued thes reasons, or streightway vpon the birth smothered them. For before by your great challenge you begat a maruelous and wonderfull conceit of your selfe in euery mans mind: and now when they shall read those slender reasons of yours, they will easily perceiue, there is no cause why you should take so much vpon you, and they wil tontemptuously deride you, as you well deserue, & hisse you out of their scholes. Therefore the counsell which Archidamu gaue to
his Sonne headily venturing to right with the Athenians, the same doe our Vniuersitie men giue to to you: Either adde to thy might, or abate of thy mind: for no man, Campian, euer tooke more vpon him, and performed lesse than you haue done. But let vs see what other things you bring vs.
Another matter that provoked me to undertake this enterprise; and that enforced me little to fear these my adversaries slender armies, is the usual inclination of my enemy in expounding the Scriptures, full of deceit, and void of wisdom. These things you Philosophers would quickly find out; and therefore I was desirous of your audience. Let us demand (for example sake) of our adversaries, what caused them to devise this new opinion, whereby Christ is* excluded out of the mystical supper? If they name the Gospel, we join with them, the very words they are for us.a This is my body, this is my blood: which words seemed tob Luther so forcible, that when he earnestly desired to be of Zuinglius mind, because by that means he might have wrought the Pope most displeasure; yet notwithstanding he yielded, being overcome and vanquished by the most plain text of Scripture, and as unwillingly confessed that Christ is truly present in the most holy Sacrament, as thec devils in time past being overcome with miracles, with outcries confessed that Christ is the Son of God. Go to then, the written word doth favour us: the controversy is about ⟨p. 57⟩the true meaning of the written word. Let us try out this by the words thereunto adjoining:d Corpus meum quod pro vobis datur, sanguis meus, qui pro multis e•lundetur: that is, My body which is given for you, my blood which shall be shed for many. Yet the matter goeth hard on Calvins side▪ and maketh very manifestly and plainly for us. What say they else? Confer say they, the Scriptures together. Agreed. Thec Gospels make for us,f S. Paul accordeth also. The words, the sentences, the whole connection of Scriptures do often most reverently repeat the bread and the wine, a not able miracle, heavenly food, his flesh, his body, his blood. Here is nothing figurative, nothing obscured by doubtful speeches: yet notwithstanding the adversaries stand stiffly in their opinion, and never cease wrangling. What shall we then do? I hope antiquity may be heard, and that the reverend hoar head of Fathers of all former ages, to Christs time more nigh, & farther off from the time of these controversies, may be their judgement, determine this debate, which we cannot end amongst our selves, being suspected one of another.* They cannot away with that; they say then they are betrayed. They cry out for the sincere and pure word of God:
ANother matter that prouoked me to vndertake this enterprize; and that enforced mee little to feare these my aduersaries slender armies, is the vsuall inclination of my enemie in expounding the Scriptures, full of deceite, and void of wisdome. These things you Philosophers would quickely finde out; and therefore I was desirous of your audience. Let vs demaund (for example sake) of our aduersaries, what caused them to deuise this new opinion, whereby Christ is* excluded out of the mysticall supper? If they name the Gospell, we ioyne with them, the very words they are for vs.a This is my bodie, this is my blood: which words seemed tob Luther so forcible, that when he earnestly desired to be of Zuinglius mind, because by that meanes he might haue wrought the Pope most displeasure; yet notwithstanding he yeelded, being ouercome and vanquished by the most plaine text of Scripture, and as vnwillingly confessed that Christ is truly present in the most holy Sacrament, as thec diuels in time past being ouercome with miracles, with outcries confessed that Christ is the sonne of God. Goe to then, the written word doth fauour vs: the controuersie is about ⟨p. 57⟩the true meaning of the written word. Let vs trie out this by the words thereunto adioyning:d Corpus meum quod pro vobis datur, sanguis meus, qui pro multis e•lundetur: that is, My bodie which is giuen for you, my blood which shalbe shed for many. Yet the matter goeth hard on Caluins side▪ and maketh very manifestly and plainely for vs. What say they else? Conferre say they, the Scriptures together. Agreed. Thec Gospels make for vs,f S. Paul accordeth also. The words, the sentences, the whole connexion of Scriptures doe often most reuerently repeate the bread and the wine, a not able miracle, heauenly foode, his flesh, his bodie, his blood. Here is nothing figuratiue, nothing obscured by doubtfull speeches: yet notwithstanding the aduersaries stand stiffely in their opinion, and neuer cease wrangling. What shall we then doe? I hope antiquitie may be heard, and that the reuerend hoare head of Fathers of all former ages, to Christs time more nigh, & farther off from the time of these controuersies, may be their iudgement, determine this debate, which we cannot end amongst our selues, being suspected one of another.
*This is false, for we do not exclude Christ from the Supper.This is false, for we doe not exclude Christ from the Supper.
*This is false, for in this controversy we willingly admit Antiquity as witness.This is false, for in this cō trouersie we willingly admit Antiquity as witnesse.
they utterly reject all mens commentaries: treacherously and witlessly done. We will urge them with the word of God; they darken it: we call the Saints in heaven for witnesses; they refuse them. In few words this is their drift, that unless thou wilt stand to their own judgement that are guilty, there is no judgement to be had. And so they behave themselves in every controversy between us. As concerning grace poured into us from heaven, inherent justice, the visible Church, the necessity of Baptism, Sacraments, and sacrifices, meritorious works of good folk; hope and fear, inequality of offences, the authority of S. Peter, the keys, vows, Evangelical counsels, and other like controversies, we Catholics in sundry of our books, in our mutual conference, in churches, in schools ⟨p. 58⟩have brought forth many and weighty places of Scripture, and have both tried and applied the same. They have scorned at this. We have alleged the interpretations of the ancient Greek and Latin Churches; they have refused them. What say they then? marry that M. Doctor Martin Luther, or else M. Philip Melanchthon, or certainly M. Zuinglius, or without doubt M. Calvin, and M. Beza have faithfully entreated upon these matters. Can I imagine any of you to be so stuffed in the nose, that being forewarned, cannot quickly smell out this subtle juggling? wherefore I confess plainly that I am desirous to have audience in the University schools, that after I have called these Ruffian-like knights out of their dark dens into the open and plain field, I may before your eyes discomfit them, not by my own strength, which am not to be compared with the worst of an hundred of our side, but by the puissance of the cause, and certainty of the truth which we maintain.
they vtterlie reiect all mens commentaries: trecherouslie and witlesselie done. We will vrge them with the word of God; they darken it: we call the Saints in heauen for witnesses; they refuse them. In few words this is their drift, that vnlesse thou wilt stand to their owne iudgement that are guiltie, there is no iudgement to be had. And so they behaue themselues in euerie controuersie betweene vs. As concerning grace powred into vs from heauen, inherent iustice, the visible Church, the necessity of Baptisme, Sacraments, and sacrifices, meritorious works of good folke; hope and feare, inequality of offences, the authoritie of S. Peter, the keyes, vowes, Euangelicall counsailes, and other like controuersies, we Catholikes in sundrie of our books, in our mutuall conference, in churches, in schooles ⟨p. 58⟩haue brought forth many and waightie places of Scripture, and haue both tried and applied the same. They haue scorned at this. We haue alledged the interpretations of the auncient Greeke and Latin Churches; they haue refused them. What say they then? marry that M. Doctor Martin Luther, or else M. Philip Melanthon, or certainelie M. Zuinglius, or without doubt M. Caluin, and M. Beza haue faithfullie entreated vpon these matters. Can I imagine any of you to be so stuffed in the nose, that being forewarned, cannot quicklie smell out this subtile iugling? wherfore I confesse plainlie that I am desirous to haue audience in the Ʋniuersitie scholes, that after I haue called these Ruffian-like knights out of their dark dennes into the open and plaine field, I may before your eies discomfite them, not by my owne strength, which am not to bee compared with the worst of an hundred of our side, but by the puissance of the cause, and certaintie of the truth which we maintaine.
What could be said touching the Scriptures we have heard, we must proceed to hear what can be said for the interpretation and exposition of them; for our usual inclination in expounding the Scriptures, (saith Campian) hath encouraged and incited him earnestly to desire this encounter. And we also (Campian) have long ago desired to buckle with you herein. And at length ⟨p. 59⟩the Lord hath brought you out of your lurking holes into the broad light, that we might try it out with you; but what is our disposition you speak of? It is full of deceit, say you, and void of wisdom. Thus you being a man of small reach, and less discretion, do conceit our inclination. Assuredly the matter you have now in hand is a cause of great weight: for the force, the substance, and as it were the soul of the Scripture consisteth in the meaning: very well said Hierome: The Scriptures are not in the letter, but in the understanding: 1and in another place:a The Gospel is not in the words of the Scripture, but in the sense. They then have the best end of the staff, and are the best patrons of Religion and truth, who find out and keep the true and natural meaning of the Scripture. For the letter or word is plain; all controversies depend upon the meaning of the Word. The state of the question is then thus, whether of us twain have attained the true and natural meaning of the Scripture: whether you Jesuits, falsely called Catholics; or we, who oppose your opinion and judgment. First therefore in general, and in few words we will see what is your opinion and judgement: then we will answer to your cavils. Now it is most clear that you make both the Scripture it self, and the interpretation of it to depend upon the authority of theb Church. And the Church you call not the whole multitude of Christians and faithful men, but you ⟨p. 60⟩restrain both the name and nature of the Church unto yourc Bishops. But your Bishops may differ touching the sense of the Scriptures, so shall we be uncertain and shall not resolve which of them to believe. But you can help this, generald Councils must decide and determine all questions and controversies. Shall we then rest in them? no more then in the other: for thee Pope must be judge over the Councils. So in the conclusion, the whole interpretation of holy Scriptures is transferred to the Pope, and must be fetched out of his breast:
WHat could be said touching the Scriptures wee haue heard, wee must proceed to heare what can bee said for the interpretation and exposition of them; for our vsuall inclination in expounding the Scriptures, (saith Campian) hath encouraged and incited him earnestly to desire this encounter. And we also (Campian) haue long ago desired to buckle with you herein. And at length ⟨p. 59⟩the Lord hath brought you out of your lurking holes into the broad light, that we might trie it out with you; but what is our disposition you speake of? It is full of deceit, say you, and void of wisdome. Thus you being a man of small reach, and lesse discretion, do conceite our inclination. Assuredly the matter you haue now in hand is a cause of great waight: for the force, the substance, and as it were the soule of the Scripture consisteth in the meaning: very well said Hierome: The Scriptures are not in the letter, but in the vnderstanding: 1and in another place:a The Gospell is not in the words of the Scripture, but in the sense. They then haue the best end of the staffe, and are the best patrons of Religion and truth, who find out and keepe the true and natural meaning of the Scripture. For the letter or word is plaine; all controuersies depend vpon the meaning of the Word. The state of the question is then thus, whether of vs twaine haue attained the true and naturall meaning of the Scripture: whether you Iesuits, falsely called Catholikes; or we, who oppose your opinion and iudgment. First therefore in generall, and in few words we will see what is your opinion and iudgement: then we will answere to your cauils. Now it is most cleere that you make both the Scripture it selfe, and the interpretation of it to depend vpon the authority of theb Church. And the Church you call not the whole multitude of Christians and faithfull men, but you ⟨p. 60⟩restraine both the name and nature of the Church vnto yourc Bishops. But your Bishops may differ touching the sense of the Scriptures, so shall we be vncerteine and shall not resolue which of them to beleeue. But you can helpe this, generalld Councels must decide and determine all questions and controuersies. Shall we then rest in them? no more then in the other: for the
1Contra Lucifer. in 1. cap. ad Gila.
aDVR. Then Luther and Calvin obtruded a new Gospel upon the Church; when they brought in a new sense of the words, such as the whole Christian world knew not; yea it had a far other sense of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 138. If this last be granted you, yet it followeth not that they brought in a new Gospel, because they differed from that sense: for the sense is not to be sought for among the multitude; but we must look to the Scriptures and to God speaking in them: as the men of Berea did not take the sense of the most, but searched the Scriptures whether Paul taught things agreeing unto it.DVR. Then Luther and Caluin obtruded a new Gospell vpon the Church; when they brought in a new sense of the words, such as the whole Christian •orld knew not; yea it had a far other sense of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 138. If this last be graunted you, yet it followeth not that they brought in a new Gospell, because they differed from that sense: for the sense is not to be sought for among the multitude; but we must looke to the Scriptures and to God speaking in them: as the men of Berea did not take the sense of the most, but searched the Scriptures whether Paul taught things agreeing vnto it.
bDVR. Js it some heinous offence to require the judgement of the Church in interpreting the Scriptures? WHIT. pag. 142. We contemn not the judgement of the Church, but highly esteem it as profitable to the well interpreting of the Scriptures. But we contemn the judgment of your Church, which hath not any thing which a true Church should have. DVR Whither then should we go to find the sense? WHIT. Even whether Christ biddeth us, go search the Scriptures, John 5.39. And this use they have, saith S. Paul. 2. Tim. 3.15.16.DVR. Js it some haynous offence to require the iudgement of the Church in interpreting the Scriptures? WHIT. pag. 142. We contemne not the iudgement of the Church, but highly esteeme it as profitable to the well interpreting of the Scriptures. But we contemne the iudgment of your Church, which hath not any thing which a true Church should haue. DVR Whither then should we goe to finde the sense? WHIT. Euen whether Christ biddeth vs, go search the Scriptures, Iohn 5.39. And this vse they haue, saith S. Paul. 2. Tim. 3.15.16
yea and as a proper right he so challengeth the power of interpreting of the Scripture, that whatsoever he thinketh, that must be accounted the sense and meaning of them. This is your constant and perpetual property and disposition in interpreting the Scriptures, full of dotage, error, and falsehood, void of advise, knowledge and wisdom. For what an absurd and horrible thing is it, that the sense and meaning ⟨p. 61⟩of the holy Scripture should depend upon one mans judgement and voice? specially being such a one, as commonly the Bishops of Rome have been, unlearned, wicked, heretical. And hence have proceeded all those goodly interpretations, Take, Eat, that is, you Priests say private Masses:1 Drink ye all of this, that is, only the Priests must drink. Be ye holy, for I am holy,f therefore it is unlawful for the Minister of the Word to marry a wife. Give ye not holy things to dogs, therefore the people must be forbidden to read the Scriptures. What should I number up innumerable moe of your interpretations, by which you do nothing but pervert and wrest the Scriptures? Is this indeed, Campian, the right interpreting of Scripture? or must all Christians receive this exposition as the oracle of God?
yea and as a proper right he so challengeth the power of interpreting of the Scripture, that whatsoeuer he thinketh, that must be accounted the sense and meaning of them. This is your constant and perpetuall propertie and disposition in interpreting the Scriptures, full of dotage, error, and falshood, void of aduise, knowledge and wisdome. For what an absurd and horrible thing is it, that the sense and meaning ⟨p. 61⟩of the holy Scripture should depend vpon one mans iudgement and voice? specially being such a one, as commonly the Bishops of Rome haue been, vnlearned, wicked, hereticall. And hence haue proceeded all those goodly interpretations, Take, Eate, that is, you Priests say priuate Masses:1 Drinke yee all of this, that is, only the Priests must drinke. Be yee holy, for I am holy,f therfore it is vnlawful for the Minister of the Word to marry a wife. Giue yee not holy things to dogges, therefore the people must be forbidden to reade the Scriptures. What should I number vp innumerable moe of your interpretations, by which you doe nothing but peruert and wrest the Scriptures? Is this indeed, Campian, the right interpreting of Scripture? or must all Christians receiue this exposition as the oracle of God?
1Dist. 31. Tenere.
fDVR. Which o• the Popes or what Catholic •riter ever collected this out of that place? WHIT. pag. 159. Pope Syricius did first of all so collect: and after him Pope Innocent, as you may read in Gratian Dist. 31. cap. Ten•re; Dist. 82. cap. prop• suisti: cap. plurimos.DVR. Which o• the Popes or what Catholike •riter euer collected this out of that place? WHIT. pag. 159. Pope Syricius did first of all so collect: and after him Pope Innocent, as you may reade in Gra••an Dist. 31. cap. Ten•re; Dist. 82. cap. prop• suisti: cap. plurimos.
But what should I speak of the constant tenor you keep in the interpretation of Scripture? for you make the sense of Scriptures so changeable, so diverse, and inconstant, like to a nose of wax and a leaden rule,1 that at all assays it may ever serve your turn. So writethg Nicholas Cusanus, a Cardinal of Rome,3 to the Bohemians. This understand that the Scriptures are fitted to the time, and diversely to be understood; so that at one time they may be expounded according to the common & customable course: but change that, and the sense is changed; so that it is no marvel if the custom of the Church at one time interpret the Scriptures after this manner, & another time after that. Was there ever the like boldness heard of; that men would wrest the eternal and immutable word of God, which ever hath but one and the same sense, to serve the will of the Church, that is, of the Pope of ⟨p. 62⟩Rome?4 besides this you have made so manyh senses of every place, to wit, an allegorical, a tropological, an anagogical sense, that by your Legerdemain, you have abolished the true and native sense. Now, Campian, since you know that this is the manner of your Church in the interpreting of the Scripture, than which what can be more corrupt, how dare you presume to reprehend our manner of interpretation? But we follow no other course then that which the Fathers have prescribed, and which the thing it self argues to be most fit. For that is our course which Augustine advised: we interpret obscure places by those which are plainer, we observe the phrase and stile of the Scripture, we weigh circumstances, we compare scripture with scripture, we go not one jot from the Analogy of faith. They who take this course, adjoining their hearty prayers, that the Lord would open this sealed book unto them; and teach them the true sense of the scripture, shall never need to run to Rome, and enquire of that sacred Oracle of the Pope, who himself neither understandeth the true sense of scripture, neither is able to expound them to others.
But what should I speake of the constant tenour you keepe in the interpretation of Scripture? for you make the sense of Scriptures so changeable, so diuerse, and inconstant, like to a nose of waxe and a leaden rule,1 that at all assaies it may euer serue your turne. So writethg Nicholas Cusanus, a Cardinall of Rome,3 to the Bohemians. This vnderstand that the Scriptures are fitted to the time, and diuersely to be vnderstood; so that at one time they may be expounded according to the common & customable course: but change that, and the sense is changed; so that it is no maruell if the custome of the Church at one time interpret the Scriptures after this manner, & another time after that. Was there euer the like bouldnes heard of; that men would wrest the eternall and immutable word of God, which euer hath but one and the same sense, to serue the will of the Church, that is, of the Pope of ⟨p. 62⟩Rome?4 besides this you haue made so manyh senses of euery place, to wit, an allegoricall, a tropological, an anagogicall sense, that by your Ledgerdemaine, you haue abolished the true and natiue sense. Now, Campian, since you know that this is the manner of your Church in the interpreting of the Scripture, than which what can be more corrupt, how dare you presume to reprehend our manner of interpretation? But we follow no other course then that which the Fathers haue prescribed, and which the thing it selfe argues to be most fit. For that is our course which Augustine aduised: we interpret obscure places by those which are plainer, we obserue the phrase and stile of the Scripture, we weigh circumstances, we compare scripture with scripture, we go not one iot from the Analogie of faith. They who take this course, adioyning their harty prayers, that the Lord would open this sealed booke vnto them; and teach them the true sense of the scripture, shall neuer need to runne to Rome, and enquire of that sacred Oracle of the Pope, who himselfe neither vnderstandeth the true sense of scripture, neither is able to expound them to others.
1Pighius.
gDVR. Cusanus hath written very rightly, for there are divers senses of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 162. What rule then can be more uncertain then the Scriptures? or what can be spoken more vilely of the Scripture? how then is the Scripture one rule? Phil. 3.16. how is i• firm enduring for ever? 1. Pet. 1.25. how no deceitful balance. August. d•▪ Baptis. cont. Don. lib. 2. cap. 6.DVR. Cusanus hath written very rightly, for there are diuers senses of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 162. What rule then can be more vncerteine then the Scriptures? or what can be spoken more vilely of the Scripture? how then is the Scripture one rule? Phil. 3.16. how is i• firme induring for euer? 1. Pet. 1.25. how no deceitfull ballance. Augus•. d•▪ Baptis. cont. Don. lib. 2. cap. 6.
3Nicol. Cusan. Epist. 2. Epist. 7.
4Thom. 1.•. 1. art. 10.
hDV•. The Fathers and Antiquity have ever made these four senses of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 163. To faine such four senses in every sentence differeth not much from a learned kind of madness. Allegories I confess many are in the Scriptures, but such as the holy Ghost himself hath made; but to make other Allegories, when the words may be understood without a Trope, or when the Grammatical sense is not absurd and repugnant to sound doctrine, I think is too great boldness and temerity. A Tropological sense is not a new sense differing from the Grammatical, but one •s it were with it. Finally, if the Fathers as men have erred, must we needs follow their errors? The Fathers rejected the errors and false interpretations of their predecessors, why may not we deal so with them?
But to return now to Campian: what is the usual fault he finds in our dealing with the scripture? and what be the arguments by which he doth confute us? Let us demand, saith he, (for example sake) of our Adversaries what caused them to devise this new opinion, whereby Christ is excluded out of the mystical Supper. ⟨p. 63⟩We, Campian, do noti exclude Christ out of the Supper, neither do we otherwise think of the Sacrament then both Christ hath taught us, and the old Church hath prescribed. We certainly affirm, that the faithful in the supper receive whole Christ, God and Man: we believe and teach that they eat his body and drink his blood. Neither doubt we to affirm, but that he, that comes to the supper, and doth not in the supper partake of Christ, that he is in danger of condemnation. Do we now exclude Christ from the supper? But whosoever includeth Christ in the supper as you do, he feigneth and forgeth a new Christ to himself, he confoundeth heaven and earth together, he offereth violence to nature, and mu•• needs admit innumerable absurdities. Wherefore we following the scripture, as our school-masters, not taking up any new opinion, place the natural and humane body of Christ in heaven; for so the Apostle Peter speaketh, whom the heavens must contain, until the time that all things be restored; 2yet thek virtue, the communion, the benefit of this body we exclude not from the supper: but stiffly maintain, that in the supper whole Christ is present to each mans faith. This is the sum of our opinion, which I no less doubt to be the true sense of the scripture, then that Christ is Christ, or that to be scripture which is scripture. This opinion out of all others which we hold, have you made choice of, as an example to impugn and gain-say: Let us see now how scholar-like you acquit your self. If they name the Gospel, say you, ⟨p. 64⟩we join with them. The very words make for us. This is my body, this is my blood: I acknowledge the words do, but I enquire now for the sense of them: whether they should be so expounded as your Church teacheth: that the bread is Transubstantiated into the body, and the wine into the blood of Christ: or by a Trope and in a mystical sense, that the bread is the Sacrament, the sign and symbol of the body, and so the wine of the blood of Christ, as we interpret them.
But to returne now to Campian: what is the vsuall fault he finds in our dealing with the scripture? and what be the arguments by which he doth confute vs? Let vs demaund, saith he, (for example sake) of our Aduersaries what caused them to deuise this new opinion, whereby Christ is excluded out of the mysticall Supper. ⟨p. 63⟩We, Campian, do noti exclude Christ out of the Supper, neither do we otherwise thinke of the Sacrament then both Christ hath taught vs, and the old Church hath prescribed. We certeinly affirme, that the faithfull in the supper receiue whole Christ, God and Man: we beleeue and teach that they eate his body and drinke his blood. Neither doubt we to affirme, but that he, that comes to the supper, and doth not in the supper partake of Christ, that he is in danger of condemnation. Doe we now exclude Christ from the supper? But whosoeuer includeth Christ in the supper as you doe, he faineth and forgeth a new Christ to himselfe, he confoundeth heauen and eart• together, he offereth violence to nature, and mu•• needs admit innumerable absurdities. Wherfore we following the scripture, as our schole-masters, not taking vp any new opinion, place the naturall and humane body of Christ in heauen; for so the Apostle Peter speaketh, whom the heauens must conteine, vntill the time that all things be restered; 2yet thek vertue, the communion, the benefit of this body we exclude not from the supper: but stifly maintaine, that in the supper whole Christ is present to each mans faith. This is the summe of our opinion, which I no lesse doubt to be the true sense of the scripture, then that Christ is Christ, or that to be scripture which is scripture. This opinion out of all others which we hold, haue you made choice of, as an example to impugne and gain-say: Let vs see now how scholler-like you acquite your selfe. If they name the Gospell, say you, ⟨p. 64⟩we ioyne with them. The very words make for vs. This is my body, this is my blood: I acknowledge the words do, but I enquire now for the sense of them: whether they should be so expounded as your Church teacheth: that the bread is Transubstantiated into the bodie, and the wine into the blood of Christ: or by a Trope and in a mysticall sense, that the bread is the Sacrament, the signe and symboll of the body, and so the wine of the blood of Christ, as we interpret them.
iDVR. If you place Christs body and your supper so far asunder, how do you not exclude h m from i•? WHIT. pag. 168. It is true, if things that are severed could no way be joined but by a corporal ouching; but without it, it may fitly be, as all believers are joined together, though they be far distant and distracted one from another; as Jews, Grecians, and all other godly, make but one body with Christ: what is that bond of this union, but the power of the spirit? Such an union is this in the Sacrament, and it hath the some bond.DVR. If you place Christs body and your supper so farre asunder, how do you not exclude h m from i•? WHIT. pag. 168. It is true, if things that are seuered could no way be ioyned but by a corporall ouching; but without it, it may fitly be, as all beleeuers are ioyned together, though they be farre distant and distracted one from another; as Iewes, Grecians, and all other godly, make but one body with Christ: what is that bond of this vnion, but the power of the spirit? Such an vnion is this in the Sacramēt, and it hath the some bond.
kDVR. The• is Christ as present in Baptism, and in the word, and wheresoever your faith seeks for him, as in the supper; yea as present to the Father• in the old Testament as now to us. WHIT. pag. 169. So questionless he is, unless all men be without hope of life and salvation, who are deprived of the Supper. For John 6.53. yea all Christians communicate of Christ alike, as well such as come to the supper, as they who cannot partake in it: And that he was present to the Fathers it is proved. 1. Cor. 10.3.4.DVR. The• is Christ as present in Baptisme, and in the word, and wheresoeuer your faith seekes for him, as in the supper; yea as present to the Father• in the old Testament as now to vs. WHIT. pag. 169. So quest•onlesse he is, vnl•sse all men be without hope of life and saluation, who are depriued of the Supper. For
Whether opinion hath more truth in it, we will now discuss. As for that which you tell us of Luther, I suppose you will not expect any answer from me: and undoubtedly in this thing Luther was far more opposite to your opinion, then ours. For he ever condemned your Transubstantiation, as it is, for an accursed invention and fiction of Satan. Luther we acknowledge was a man, who though he saw the truth in many things, yet he might err in some things: his good things we embrace, but we are bound by no law to defend his errors.
Whether opinion hath more truth in it, we will now discusse. As for that which you tell vs of Luther, I suppose you will not expect any answere from me: and vndoubtedly in this thing Luther was farre more opposite to your opinion, then ours. For he euer condemned your Transubstantiation, as it is, for an accursed inuention and fiction of Satan. Luther we acknowledge was a man, who though he saw the truth in many things, yet he might erre in some things: his good things wee embrace, but wee are bound by no law to defend his errors.
But how shall we find out the meaning of this saying? Let us try out this, say you, by the words thereto adjoining. Nothing can be spoken more truly, nothing more fitly, nor more ingenuously. And verily I could wish you would always do, as you pretend in this place to do, sift out the meaning of the scripture by the circumstances of the words. But what are the words adjoining? My body which is given for you, my blood which is shed for you. Campian, you are too sparing and scant in the point: repeat, and say, that which goeth before. As they did eat, Christ took bread, he blessed it, he brake it, and gave it to his disciples, and said, Take, eat, this is my body, and he took the cup, and gave thanks, and gau• it to them saying, Drink ye all of this, for this is my blood &c. So now, Campian, I will deal with you from the words which are now adjoining. What was it Christ took? you will say ⟨p. 65⟩bread: what brake he? bread: what gave he to his disciples? bread: wh•• did he bid them take and eat? bread: what said he was his body? was it any other thing, •hen the very same bread which he took into his hands, brake andl gave to his disciples. Therefore that when Christ saith. This is my body: this is my blood; is as much as if he said: This bread is my body, and this cup is my blood. But the bread and the body of Christ, the cup and the blood of Christ, are they not differing, and well-nigh contrary? Then tell us, how they can affirm, or be spoken one of another, unless you will admit a Tropical speech. Yet, Campian, to use your own words, the matter goeth hard on your side, and maketh very plainly and manifestly for us. For Christ saith plainly that the bread is his body, which cannot be true without a figure, that bread made to eat, should be properly Christs body. And this is that figure which we find so often in the Scriptures, specially when any Sacrament is spoken of. So in Genesis cap. 17. the Lord saith of Circumcisionm This is the covenant betwixt me and ⟨p. 66⟩3you. Yet Circumcision was not the covenant, but the sign of the covenant. Now tell us I pray you, what difference betwixt these two: This is my covenant & this is my body? The former you cannot deny, but must be understood by a Metonymy: and can any man make doubt, but that the latter likewise is to be so expounded. The like we read of the Lamb.4n[…] is the Lords Passover.
But how shal we find out the meaning of this saying? Let vs trie out this, say you, by the words thereto adioyning. Nothing can be spoken more truly, nothing more fitly, nor more ingenuously. And verely I could wish you would alwaies doe, as you pretend in this place to doe, sist out the meaning of the scripture by the circumstances of the words. But what are the words adioyning? My body which is giuen for you, my blood which is shed for you. Campian, you are too sparing and scant in the point: repeate, and say, that which goeth before. As they did eate, Christ tooke bread, he blessed it, he brake it, and gaue it to his disciples, and said, Take, eate, this is my body, and he tooke the cup, and gaue thankes, and gau• it to them saying, Drinke yee all of this, for this is my blood &c. So now, Campian, I will deale with you from the words which are now adioyning. What was it Christ tooke? you will say ⟨p. 65⟩bread: what brake he? bread: what gaue he to his disciples? bread: wh•• did he bid them take and eate? bread: what said he was his bodie? was it any other thing, •hen the very same bread which he tooke into his hands, brake andl gaue to his disciples. Therfore that when Christ saith. This is my body: this is my blood; is as much as if he said: This bread is my body, and this cup is my blood. But the bread and the body of Christ, the cup and the blood of Christ, are they not differing, and wel-nigh contrary? Then tell vs, how they can affirme, or be spoken one of another, vnlesse you will admit a Tropicall speech. Yet, Campian, to vse your owne words, the matter gocth hard on your side, and maketh very plainly and manifestly for vs. For Christ saith plainly that the bread is his body, which cannot be true without a figure, that bread made to eate, should be properly Christs body. And this is that figure which we find so often in the Scriptures, specially when any Sacram•nt is spoken of. So in Genesis cap. 17. the Lord saith of Circumcisionm This is the couenant betwixt me and ⟨p. 66⟩3you. Yet Circumcision was not the couenant, but the signe of the couenant. Now tell vs I pray you, what difference betwixt these two: This is my couenant & this is my body? The former you cannot deny, but must be vnderstood by a Metonymy: and can any man make doubt, but that the latter likewise is to be so expounded. The like we reade of the Lambe.
lDVR. He took bread, but he gave not bread to his disciples, but his body. WHIT. pag. 183. Then one body of Christ is made two, one sitting among them, another delivered unto them; yea as many bodies as there were Communicants. And the disciples did receive, chaw, and eat him, whom they saw s•ting with them: but when was the change made? for before he had spoken these operative words, This is my body, he brake it & gave it •o his disciples: either these words make not the change, or he ga•e to his disciples, bread unchanged. DVR. •f there was no change, then the blessing wa• without profit. WHIT. pag. 185. As if all blessings were without profit if they change not the nature of things: God blessed our first parents, Gen. 1.28. Noah and his Sons, Gen. 9.1 Christ his disciples at his departure, Luk. 24.51. was their blessing without profit, because they changed not their natures and substance? Besides to bless is nothing else but to give thanks, as Luke hath it, which was done by words before, not by those, This is my body.DVR. He tooke bread, but he gaue not bread to his disciples, but his bodie. WHIT. pag. 183. Then one body of Christ is made two, one sitting among them, another deliuered vnto them; yea as many bodies as there were Communicants. And the disciples did receiue, chaw, and eate him, whom they saw s•ting with them: but whē was the chāge made? for before he had spoken these operatiue words, This is my bodie, he brake it & gaue it •o his disciples: either these words make not the change, or he ga•e to his disciples, bread vnchanged. DVR. •f there was no change, then the blessing wa• without profit. WHIT. pag. 185. As if all blessings were without profit if they change not the nature of things: God blessed our first parents, Gen. 1.28. Noah and his Sonnes, Gen. 9.1 Christ his disciples at his departure,
And yet the Lamb was not the Passover, but a memorial of it: like to this is that of S. Paul. oThe rock was Christ. 2Now as the rock was Christ, so is this mystical bread the body of Christ. Thus as yet you see the matter is never the better on your side; have you any thing else? The Gospel, say you, makes for us, S. Paul accordeth also. Nay S. Paul utterly overthroweth your opinion:3 for when he speaketh of this Sacrament in one continued speech, he useth the wordp bread, four several times, and that after Consecration; so that it appeareth▪•earely to have the proper nature of bread, though it be said to be the body of Christ. But yet you add: The words, the sentences, the whole convection of Scripture, do often most reverently repeat the bread, the wine, a notable miracle, heavenly food, his flesh▪ his body, his blood. In good earnest you discourse of these things with great reverence and shamefastness. For you would prove that in this Sacrament, there remaineth neither bread nor wine, but certain qualities of these things, hanging in the air, and void• of the things themselves. And for any notable miracle, I acknowledge none, but answer you with Austen. They may be honoured as religious things, 5but they ⟨p. 67⟩cannot be wondered at as qmiracles. No man ever denied, but that in the Sacrament heavenly food is both prepared, and offered to all the godly. But those heavenly and holy banquets, whereby our souls are nourished up to eternal life, you make profane and common, when you imagine, that Christ may be received and eaten like other meats, aswell of ther wicked, as of the most devout men in the world; which is an horrible opinion, senseless and unsound. For that you add of flesh, body, and blood, I confess: for being the Sacraments of these things, they have their names given unto them: for signs of things (saith Augustine) are said to be the things of which they are signs. But, say you, here is nothing figurative, nothing obscure by doubtful speeches. True it is there is never a riddle in the words, no obscurity. For the obscurity that is, is not in the words, but in your interpretation of them, which ten Apollos cannot so unfold and open, that things might agree and answer fitly one to another.
And yet the Lamb was not the Passeouer, but a memoriall of it: like to this is that of S. Paul. oThe rocke was Christ. 2Now as the rocke was Christ, so is this mysticall bread the body of Christ. Thus as yet you see the matter is neuer the better on your side; haue you any thing else? The Gospell, say you, makes for vs, S. Paul accordeth also. Nay S. Paul vtterly ouerthroweth your opinion:3 for when he speaketh of this Sacrament in one continued speech, he vseth the wordp bread, foure seuerall times, and that after Consecration; so that it appeareth▪•earely to haue the proper nature of bread, though it be said to be the body of Christ. But yet you adde: The words, the sentences, the whole conuection of Scripture, doe often most reuerently repeate the bread, the wine, a notable miracle, heauenly food, his flesh▪ his bodie, his blood. In good earnest you discourse of these things with great reuerence and shamefastnes. For you would proue that in this Sacrament, there remaineth neither bread nor wine, but certeine qualities of these things, hanging in the ayre, and void• of the things themselues. And for any notable miracle, I acknowledge none, but answere you with Austen. They may be honoured as religious things, 5but they ⟨p. 67⟩cannot be wondred at as qminacles. No man euer denied, but that in the Sacrament heauenly food is both prepared, and offered to all the godly. But those heauenly and holy banquets, whereby our soules are nourished vp to eternall life, you make prophane and common, when you imagine, that Christ may be receiued and eaten like other meates, aswell of ther wicked, as of the most deuout men in the world; which is an horrible opinion, senselesse and vnsound. For that you adde of flesh, body, and blood, I confesse: for being the Sacraments of these things, they haue their names giuen vnto them: for signes of things (saith Augustine) are said to be the things of which they are signes. But, say you, heere is nothing figuratiue, nothing obscure by doubtfull speeches. True it is there is neuer a riddle in the words, no obscuritie. For the obscurity that is, is not in the words, but in your interpretation of them, which ten Apolloes cannot so vnfold and open, that things might agree and answere fitly one to another.
oDVR. There is no figure in the word Christ, but in rock; for the rock was the sign of Christ. WHIT. pag. 175. Then you acknowledge a Metonymy in the word•, because the rock was the Sacrament of Christ. And if here there be a Trope, then why not in these words of this Sacrament?DVR. There is no figure in the word Christ, but in rocke; for the rocke was the signe of Christ. WHIT. pag. 175. Then you acknowledge a Metonymy in the word•, because the rock was the Sac•amen• of Christ. And if heere there be a Trope, then why not in these words of this Sacramēt?
pDVR. S. Paul calleth it so because it was now Christ, who wa• the living bread. WHIT. pag. 188. many of your fellows interpret it far otherwise, yea your sh••t S. Paul overthroweth, 1. Cor. 10.16. The bread which we break, is it not the Communion of the body of Christ? Now not Christ was broken but the bread.DVR. S. Paul call•th it so because it vvas novv Christ, vvho vva• the liuing bread. WHIT. pag. 188. many of your fellowes interpret it far otherwise, yea your sh••t S. Paul ouerthroweth, 1. Cor. 10.16. The bread vvhich vve breake, is it not the Comunion of the body of Christ? Now not Christ was brokē but the bread.
5De Trinit. lib. 3. c. 10.
qDVR. Augustine speaketh of thes• miracles which are made of a bodily substance, and so are sensible: now no such thing is seen in the Eucharist. WHIT. pag. 191. But if there were a true miracle, it would be sensible, and have the witness of the senses, as all other miracles of the Scriptures have. For thing that are hid (saith Augustine) are not miracles. He writ three books of the miracles of the Scriptures, in which he hath not spoken one word of this miracle. Therefore he knew not the Popish Transubstantiation.
What resteth yet, is it not that at length we find out some certain and true sense of these words? I hope, say you, Antiquity may be heard. I verily in this controversy will reject no Antiquity, no Council, no ancient Father, neither will I refuse any monument of true Antiquity. For that same reverend hoary head of Fathers which you speak of, could never come to the knowledge of this new doctrine of Transubstantiation lately hatched. If those holy Fathers and reverend Elders did now live, they would never acknowledge this monster, nor endure the sight of it, but judge it worthy to be abandoned into the utmost parts of the world. Whereas then you say, They cannot away with that, They say then they are betrayed. ⟨p. 68⟩You trifle and say nothing to the purpose: for we can away well with this trial, and fear no treachery in it. But will call you very willingly to this reverend Antiquity, as to a bar of trial. Therefore if you please we will demand of those reverend Fathers, what they judge to be the meaning of those words, which you have produced for example sake. And seeing there is no necessity to collect all their sayings, some few of them shall speak, to give us a taste of the rest.s Tertullian saith,2 Christ professed his desire to eat the Passover, as his own, and having taken bread, and distributed it to his disciples, he made it his body, by saying▪ this is my body, that is, the figure or sign of my body. You acknowledge both Tertullians words and his meaning.t Augustine saith,4 Christ admitted Judas to that banquet, in which he commended to his disciples the figure of his body and blood. In another place also.u The Lord verily doubted not to speak thus. 6This is my body, when he gave the sign of his ⟨p. 69⟩body. And that you may understand, that this was Augustine's perpetual tenor in interpreting of these words, and that he determined far diverse to you touching the eating of Christs flesh: hear what he saith in his books of Christian Instruction, where he giveth divers precepts for the understanding of the phrase of the Scriptures. If, saith he, any sentence there seem to command any impious act, 7or to forbid any duty tending to the profit or good of others, it is a figurative speech; unless, saith Christ, you eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, you have no life in you: It seemeth to enjoin an *heinous act.
What resteth yet, is it not that at length wee find out some certeine and true sense of these words? I hope, say you, Antiquitie may be heard. I verily in this controuersie will reiect no Antiquitie, no Councell, no auncient Father, neither will I refuse any monument of true Antiquitie. For that same reuerend hoarie head of Fathers which you speake of, could neuer come to the knowledge of this new doctrine of Transubstantiation lately hatched. If those holy Fathers and reuerend Elders did now liue, they would neuer acknowledge this mōster, nor indure the sight of it, but iudge it worthy to be abandoned into the vtmost parts of the world. Whereas then you say, They cannot away with that, They say then they are betrayed. ⟨p. 68⟩You trifle and say nothing to the purpose: for we can away well with this triall, and feare no treachery in it. But will call you very willingly to this reuerend Antiquitie, as to a barre of triall. Therefore if you please we will demaund of those reuerend Fathers, what they iudge to be the meaning of those words, which you haue produced for example sake. And seeing there is no necessity to collect all their sayings, some few of them shall speake, to giue vs a tast of the rest.s Tertullian saith,2 Christ professed his desire to eate the Pass•ouer, as his owne, and hauing taken bread, and distributed it to his disciples, hee made it his bodie, by saying▪ this is my body, that is, the figure or signe of my body. You acknowledge both Tertullians words and his meaning.t Augustine saith,4 Christ admitted Iudas to that banquet, in which he commended to his disciples the figure of his body and blood. In another place also.u The Lord verily doubted not to speake thus. 6This is my body, when he gaue the signe of his ⟨p. 69⟩body. And that you may vnderstand, that this was Augustines perpetuall tenor in interpreting of these words, and that he determined farre diuerse to you touching the eating of Christs flesh: heare what he saith in his bookes of Christian Instruction, where he giueth diuers precepts for the vnderstanding of the phrase of the Scriptures. If, saith he, any sentence there seeme to cōmaund any impious act,
sDVR. Tertullian speaketh not of that bread, which Christ in his last supper made his body, but of another bread, which was the figure of his body under the law. WHIT. pag. 2•0. The pla•e showeth very plainly that he speaketh of no other bread, then of tha• which Christ had said, this is my body: and which, in the night he was betrayed, he took, brake, and gave to his disciples. Tell us where under the law Christ ever said thus, or did thus with any bread? DVR. Bread & wine in the old Testament were Figures of Christs body & blood: therefore in the new Testament of the bread must the true body of Christ be made, & of the v•ine his blood. WHIT. pag. 202. It will well follow from this, that Christ must have in the new Testament a true body & true blood: but it cannot be enforced hereupon, that it must be made of bread & wine. As if because their Sacraments were figures, therefore ours must be transubstantiated into the things themselves. Then will it follow, that because the flood, the •edsea, & the cloud were types of our Baptism, therefore it should not be a figure or a sign, but be turned into th• very blood of Christ.DVR. Tertullian speaketh not of that bread, vvhich Christ in his last supper made his body, but of another bread, vvhich vvas the figure of his body vnd•r the lavv. WHIT. pag. 2•0. The pla•e sheweth very plainly that he speaketh of no other bread, then of tha• which Christ had said, this is my body: and which, in the night he vvas betrayed, he tooke, brake, and gaue to his disciples. Tell vs where vnder the law Christ euer said thus, or did thus with any bread? DVR. Bread & wine in the old Testament vvere Figures of Christs body & blood: therfore in the nevv Testament of the bread must the true body of Christ be made, & of the v•ine his blood. WHIT. pag. 202. It will well follow frō this, that Christ must haue in the new Testament a true body & true blood: but it cannot be inforced hereupō, that it must be made of bread & wine. As if because their Sacramen•s were figures, the•fore ours must be trāsubstantiated into the things themselues. Then will it follow, that because the flood, the •edsea, & the cloud were types of our Bapisme, therefore it should not be a figure or a signe, but be turned into th very blood of Christ.
It is therefore a figurative speech, commanding us to communicate in the Passion of the Lord. Do you think this reverend old man dotes, or hath he not given a judicious interpretation, well agreeing unto the judgement of the ancient? I think matters yet go worse on your side, then they did before: but perhaps you will say, these are too ancient to serve your turn, hear then some of latter times.1 Theodoret a Grecian and a learned man writeth thus in his Dialogue•xMystical signs do not lose their proper nature. This very speech quite overthroweth your Transubstantiation, for if their proper nature remain, without doubt nothing can be Transubstantiated or changed. Now the bread keepeth his proper and old nature, therefore there can be no Transubstantiation: but I will ⟨p. 70⟩join to Theodoret Marcarius; whose homilies Morelius had out of the Kings Library, and hath published them in Greek: and I suppose that you being a Friar, will not reject the testimony of so ancient a Monk: he writeth thus. In the Church, saith he,3 is offered bread and wine, yantitypes or resemblances of his body and blood. What, saith he, bread and wine? but bread is already turned into flesh, and wine into blood. Ought a Monk to speak after this manner? give you them so slender a name, as similitudes? Pardon me, Campian, this Monk was never used to speak after your manner, neither was your Transubstantiation as yet come abroad? what say you now? are you pleased with this reverend hoar head of the Fathers? If you rest not here, it shall be free for you to appeal to any one of the whole reverend company of the holy Fathers; not one of them, no not any one of them, do I except against. For I make no doubt, but if they may be judges, you shall ever have the worst. From henceforth therefore do not cast any such calumni••ions upon us, and boast your self of the bare names of the Fathers; for the Fathers both in this controversy and in many others are firm on our side. As for the Fathers of whom you name many, but I believe have read but a few, I thus answer you. We are not the servants of the Fathers, but the sons. When they prescribe us any thing out of the Law and divine authority, we obey them, as our parents. If they enjoin any thing against the voice of the heavenly truth, we have learned not to hearken to them, but to God.
It is therefore a figuratiue speech, commanding vs to communicate in the Passion of the Lord. Doe you thinke this reuerend old man dotes, or hath he not giuen a iudicious interpretation, wel agreeing vnto the iudgement of the auncient? I thinke matters yet goe worse on your side, then they did before: but perhaps you will say, these are too aunciēt to serue your turne, heare then some of latter times.1 Theodoret a Gretian and a learned man writeth thus in his Dialogue•xMysticall signes doe not lose their proper nature. This very speech quite ouerthroweth your Transubstantiation, for if their proper nature remaine, without doubt nothing can be Transubstantiated or changed. Now the bread keepeth his proper and old nature, therefore there can be no Transubstantiation: but I will ⟨p. 70⟩ioyne to Theodoret Marcarius; whose homilies Morelius had out of the Kings Librarie, and hath published them in Greeke: and I suppose that you being a Frier, will not reiect the testimony of so auncient a Monke: he writeth thus. In the Church, saith he,3 is offered bread and wine, yantitypes or resemblances of his body and blood. What, saith he, bread and wine? but bread is already turned into flesh, and wine into blood. Ought a Monke to speake after this manner? giue you them so slender a name, as similitudes? Pardon mee, Campian, this Monke was neuer vsed to speake after your manner, neither was your Transubstantiation as yet come abroad? what say you now? are you pleased with this reuerend hoare head of the Fathers? If you rest not heere, it shall be free for you to appeale to any one of the whole reuerend company of the holy Fathers; not one of them, no not any one of them, do I except against. For I make no doubt, but if they may be iudges, you shall euer haue the worst. From henceforth therefore do not cast any such calumni••ions vpon vs, and boast your selfe of the bare names of the Fathers; for the Fathers both in this controuersie and in many others are firme on our side. As for the Fathers of whom you name many, but I beleeue haue read but a few, I thus answere you. We are not the seruants of the Fathers, but the sonnes. When they prescribe vs any thing out of the Law and diuine authoritie, we obey them, as our parents. If they inioyne any thing against the voyce of the heauenly truth, we haue learned not to harken to them, but to God.
1Theod.
xDVR Theodorets meaning is, that the signs have not lost their natural properties, though their nature be changed. WHIT. pag. 214. If the natural properties remain, then certainly their natures must, for essential properties can never be separated from •heir natures: yea in the words follow ng in this very place, Theodoret affirmeth, that the nature remaineth. The mystical bread, saith he, remaineth in the nature it first had, in the figure, and in the form.DVR Theodorets meaning is, that the signes haue not lost their naturall properties, though their nature be changed. WHIT. pag. 214. If the naturall properties remaine, then certeinly their natures must, for esse•t•all properties can neuer be separated from •heir natures: yea in the words follow ng in this very place, Theodoret affirmeth, that the nature remaineth. The mysticall bread, saith he, remaineth in the nature it first had, in the figure, and in the forme.
3Marcar. homil.
yDVR. An antitype or resemblance of the type is not the type or figure, but the substance signified by that type or figure. WHIT. pag. 217. An antitype is never properly the substance of the type, though sometime it be another type answering to it, and both of them are but similitudes & figures of the substance. And sometimes a type and an antitype are both one and the same: as Heb. 9.24. The Tabernacle is called an antitype of heaven, being the substance signified by the Tabernacle and no answering type to the Tabernacle. And in this sense do divers of the Fathers use the word Antitype: as Basil, Nazianzen, Theodoret, Chrysost.DVR. An antitype or resemblance of the type is not the type or figure, but the substance signified by that type or figure. WHIT. pag. 217. An antitype is neuer properly the substance of the type, though sometime it be another type answering to it, and both of them are but similitudes & figures of the substance. And sometimes a type and an antitype are both one and the same: as Heb. 9.24. The Tabernacle is called an antitype of heauē, being the substance signified by the Tabernacle and no answering type to the Tabernacle. And in this sense doe diuers of the Fathers vse the word Antitype: as Basil, Nazianzen, Theodoret, Chrysost.
You as Vassals and base servants receive whatsoever the Fathers say, without judgement or reason, being afraid, as I think, either of the whip, or the halter, if every thing they speak be not Gospel with you.
You as Vassals and base seruants receiue whatsoeuer the Fathers saie, without iudgement or reason, being affraid, as I think, either of the whippe, or the halter, if euery thing they speake be not Gospell with you.
In few words, say you, this is their drift, unless thou wilt stand to their own judgement, that are guilty, there is no judgement to be had. Verily this fits you a great deal better then us, for you will receive no judgement but the judgement of the Pope, and Church of Rome; which Church and Pope we have proved long ago to be guilty of most heinous crimes, and there hath been a perpetual variance betwixt him and us. Is there any equity then in your demands that we should stand to his judgement, who […] both a person guilty, and an adversary to us? And well should we deserve to lose the cause, if we would be so witless contenders. Much truer speaketh Augustine, Let one matter encounter with another, 1one cause with another, one reason with another, by the authority of the holy Scriptures, which are not proper to either side, but common zwitnesses for both. And to their judgements would we have you to stand, not ours. As for other things you speak of, I pass them over, for you will reserve them for us till another place; and whereas you say, you have cited many and worthy places of Scripture, we have weighed those places in their balances, and have found them to light to prove what you proposed. And it is your use indeed, rather to take them by number, then by weight. But you charged us with scorning at this and shifting them off, we did nothing less; all we did was to free them from your cavils. We have, say you, alleged the interpretations ⟨p. 72⟩of the Greek and Latin Churches. I confess it, but we have wrung all those weapons from you, and have by them battered all your holds. But say you, what say they then? marry that M. Doctor Martin Luther, or M. Philip Melanchthon, or certainly M. Zuinglius, or without doubt M. Calvin, and M. Beza, have faithfully entreated upon those matters. Tell us, Friar, what should hinder, why every one of these you have nominated, may not as faithfully entreat of th•se things, as those who have lived before them in ages past? what wanted they, which the other had? what skill of art, what knowledge of the tongues, what other helps? there is not any one of these, but hath far surpassed in learning, and all deserved commendation, the whole society of Jesuits.
In few words, say you, this is their drift, vnlesse thou wilt stand to their owne iudgement, that are guilty, there is no iudgement to be had. Verily this fits you a great deale better then vs, for you will receiue no iudgement but the iudgement of the Pope, and Church of Rome; which Church and Pope wee haue proued long agoe to be guilty of most heynous crimes, and there hath been a perpetuall variance betwixt him and vs. Is there any equity then in your demaunds that we should stand to his iudgement, who 〈…〉 both a person guilty, and an aduersarie to vs? And well should we deserue to lose the cause, if we would be so witlesse contenders. Much truer speaketh Augustine, Let one matter encounter with another, 1one cause with another, one reason with another, by the authoritie of the holy Scriptures, which are not proper to either side, but common zwitnesses for both. And to their iudgements would we haue you to stand, not ours. As for other things you speake of, I passe them ouer, for you will reserue them for vs till another place; and wheras you say, you haue cited many and worthy places of Scripture, we haue weighed those places in their ballances, and haue found them to light to proue what you proposed. And it is your vse indeed, rather to take them by number, then by weight. But you charged vs with scorning at this and shifting them off, we did nothing lesse; all we did was to free them from your cauils. We haue, say you, alledged the interpretations ⟨p. 72⟩of the Greeke and Latin Churches. I confesse it, but we haue wrung all those weapons from you, and haue by them battered all your holds. But say you, what say they then? marry that M. Doctor Martin Luther, or M. Philip Melangthon, or certeinly M. Zuinglius, or without doubt M. Caluin, and M. Beza, haue faithfully intreated vpon those matters. Tell vs, Frier, what should hinder, why euery one of these you haue nominated, may not as faithfully intreate of th•se things, as those who haue liued before them in ages past? what wanted they, which the other had? what skill of art, what knowledge of the tōgues, what other helpes? there is not any one of these, but hath far surpassed in learning, and all deserued commendation, the whole society of Iesuits.
1Contra Maxim. lib. 3. c. 14.
zDVR. How foolishly do you allege Augustine, who maketh the Scripture a witness of the truth, not a judge, as you would have it. WHIT. pag. 243. If the Scripture be the witness, where shall we find a judge answerable to this witness? Is it the Church? Then must it be of more authority then the Scripture, which here you affirm not, neither may it be gram ted; for the Scripture is the word of God, therefore he that is the judge of it, must be the judge of God himself. To deny the Scriptures then the preeminence in judging, is to thrust God out of his throne Therefore as God, so the Scripture the word of God, hath the authority both of a witness and a judge. DVR. Augustine ever thought, that the Popes judgement was the highest tribunal upon earth, where all controversies must be decided. WHIT. pag. 244. Augustine never thought so, but writ the contrary De civitat Dei lib. 15. •ap. 3. The Lord, saith he, hath penned the Scripture, which is called Canonical, because it is of highest authority, yea he never once pressed the Arians, either with the authority of the Pope, or of the Councell, which undoubtedly he would have done, neither could he have done better, if the highest judgement had been in the Church.DVR. How foolishly do you alledge Augustine, who maketh the Scripture a witnes of the truth, not a iudge, as you would haue it. WHIT. pag. 243. If the Scripture be the witnes, where shall we find a iudge answerable to this witnes? Is it the Church? Then must it be of more authority then the Scripture, which heere you affirme not, neither may it be grā ted; for the Scripture is the word of God, therefore he that is the iudge of it, must be the iudge of God himselfe. To deny the Scriptures then the preheminence in iudging, is to thrust God out of his throne Therefore as God, so the Scripture the word of God, hath the authoritie both of a witnesse and a iudge. DVR. Augustine euer thought, that the Popes iudgement was the highest tribunall •pon earth, where all controuersies must be decided. WHIT. pag. 244. Augustine neuer thought so, but writ the contrary De ciuitat Dei lib. 15. •ap. 3. The Lord, saith he, hath penned the Scripture, which is call•d Canonicall, because it is of highest authoritie, yea hee neuer once pressed the Arrians, either with the authoritie of the Pope, or of the Councell, which vndoubtedly he would haue done, neither could he haue done better, if the highest iudgement had been in the Church.
But why do I compare these burning lights, bright stars of piety and religion, with the base scum of your Doctors? and this now is another of your reasons, why you were so desirous to have audience in the University Schools. If you be, Campian, so desirous, as you would make the world believe, I marvel why you are so long a coming: for our schools were ever open for you, but you could never find the way into them. If you hereafter come, you shall find many in our schools, that will encounter with you in all kind of learning. And here you end your discourse of the right sense of the Scriptures.
But why doe I compare these burning lights, bright starres of piety and religion, with the base scumme of your Doctors? and this now is another of your reasons, why you were so desirous to haue audience in the Vniuersity Schooles. If you be, Campian, sodesirous, as you would make the world beleeue, I maruell why you are so long a comming: for our schooles were euer open for you, but you could neuer find the way into them. If you hereafter come, you shall find many in our schooles, that will encounter with you in all kind of learning. And heere you end your discourse of the right sense of the Scriptures.
SO soon as the Adversary heard the Church named, he waxed wan: yet notwithstanding he hath devised one thing, which I would wish you to note well; that thereby you may perceive, the ruin and hard shifts of falsehood. The enemy perceived that both in thea old and newb Testament, there is every where* honourable mention made of the Church, and that it is called a holy city, a fruitful vineyard, an high hill, a direct path, the only dove, the kingdom of heaven, the spouse and body of Christ, the pillar of truth, the multitude unto which the holy Ghost being promised, poureth all things needful to salvation. The congregation, against all which the gates of hell shall never so prevail, that they shall utterly extinguish the same. The congregation, which who so repugneth, though he confess Christ with his mouth, yet hath he no more to do with Christ, then hath a Publican and heathen man. He durst not say any thing against this openly, neither would he seem to gain-say that Church, whereof the Scriptures so often make mention. He kept craftily still, the name of the Church, but the thing it self by describing it, he* took quite away. For he hath portrayed the Church with such properties as do altogether hide it and make it, as if it were Plato his Idea;c unapt to be seen with the senses, but subject to the privy insight and speculation of a very few men, such only as by special inspiration, might in their imagination comprehend this airy body, and could likewise with a sharp eye discern ⟨p. 74⟩such as are members of this chosen society, what is become of truth? where is plain dealing? what Scriptures? what just judgments, what Fathers describe the Church in this sort?* There are Epistles in the Apocalypse of S. John written byd Christ himself to the seven Churches which were in Asia. There are also diverse Epistles written by S. Peter, S. Paul, S. John. and by others unto sundry Churches. In the Acts of the Apostles, we find mention made of many Churches begun and enlarged: what were those? were they known to God only, and to his Saints, or also to all sorts of Christians? But truly necessity is a deadly dart; pardon them:
SO soone as the Aduersarie heard the Church named, hee waxed wanne: yet notwithstanding hee hath deuised one thing, which I would wish you to note well; that thereby you may perceiue, the ruine and hard shifts of falsehood. The enemie perceiued that both in thea old and newb Testament, there is euery where* honorable mention made of the Church, and that it is called a holy citie, a fruitfull vineyard, an high hill, a direct path, the only doue, the kingdome of heauen, the spouse and bodie of Christ, the pillar of truth, the multitude vnto which the holy Ghost being promised, powreth all things needfull to saluatiō. The congregation, against all which the gates of hell shall neuer so preuaile, that they shall vtterlie extinguish the same. The congregation, which who so repugneth, though he confesse Christ with his mouth, yet hath he no more to doe with Christ, then hath a Publican and heathen man. He durst not say any thing against this openly, neither would hee seeme to gain-say that Church, whereof the Scriptures so often make mention. He kept craftily still, the name of the Church, but the thing it self by describing it, he* took quite away. For he hath portraied the Church with such properties as doe altogether hide it and make it, as if it were Plato his Idea;c vnapt to be seene with the senses, but subiect to the priuy insight and speculation of a very few men, such onely as by speciall inspiration, might in their imagination comprehend this arrie bodie, and could likewise with a sharpe eye discerne ⟨p. 74⟩such as are members of this chosen societie, what is become of truth? where is plaine dealing? what Scriptures? what iust iudgmentes, what Fathers describe the Church in this sorte?* There are Epistles in the Apocalyppes of S. Iohn written byd Christ himselfe to the seauen Churches which were in Asia. There are also diuerse Epistles written by S. Peter, S. Paul, S. Iohn. and by others vnto sundry Churches. In the Actes of the Apostles, we finde mention made of many Churches begun and enlarged: what were those? were they knowne to God onelie, and to his Saintes, or also to all sortes of Christians? But truly necessitie is a deadly dart; pardon them:
*The scripture maketh honourable mention of the Church, therefore the Roman Church is that true Church of Christ, of which the Scripture speaketh so •• ten.The scripture maketh honorable mention of the Church, therefore the Romane Church is that true Church of Christ, of which the Scripture speaketh so •• ten.
*This is false, for your definition maketh a true Church
for they that all these* 1500 years cannot spy out so much, as one time, one village, one house embrued with their doctrine, until that unhappye Monk by his incestuous marriage had deflowered a Nun, dedicated to God by former solemn vow: or until that quarrelling Switzerf had conspired against his country: or until that infamous runagateg had undertaken an usurped authority in Geneva. If they will have any Church at all, they must needs fetch the same out of blind corners, and challenge those for their ancestors, whom they neither knew themselves, neither any mortal man hath seen, except they brag of such forefathers, who were manifest heretics, as Aerius, Jovinianus, 5Heluidius, Vigillantius, the Image breakers, Berengarius, Waldensis, Lothardus, Wycliffe, Huss, of all which they have begged some pieces of their devilish doctrine. Marvel not though I have not feared these smothers, which if I shall once come to the clear light, I shall easily expel. For this is our speech together. Tell me, dost thou believe as the Church doth, which flourished these many hundred years past? Yea verily: let us therefore discourse of our countries and times; what Church dost thou believe? The congregation of the faithful, whose names are unknown, but it is apparent that many such have been: Is it apparent that ⟨p. 75⟩many such have been. To whom it is apparent? To God; who saith so? we that have received our doctrine from God himself. This is a loud lie, how may I believe it? If thou were fervent in faith, thou should know this as assuredly, as thou dost that thou art alive: Can you refrain laughing when you hear such foolish answers? All Christian people are commanded to cleave fast unto the Church, they are warned to take heed, lest they be slain with the spiritual sword: they are bid keep peace in the house of God: to commit their souls in trust unto this pillar of truth, there to make all their complaints to take for heathen all such as are cast out of this Church: and yet all that, have so many men, so many hundred years, been ignorant, where that Church is, or who belong unto it; will they in darkness still stand upon that point? that where or in what place soever the Church is, there are contained therein, only saints, and such as are predestinate to go to heaven:
for they that all these* 1500 yeeres cannot spie out so much, as one time, one village, one house embrued with their doctrine, vntill that vnhappiee Moncke by his incestuous marriage had destoured a Nunne, dedicated to God by former solemne vowe: or vntill that quarrelling Swizerf had conspired against his countrie: or vntill that infamous runagateg had vndertaken an vsurped authoritie in Geneua. If they will haue any Church at all, they must needes fetch the same out of blind corners, and challenge those for their ancestors, whom they neither knew themselues, neither any mortall man hath seene, except they brage of such forefathers, who were manifest heretiques, as Aerius, Iouinianus, 5Heluidius, Vigillantius, the Image breakers, Berengarius, Waldensis, Lothardus, Wyclife, Husse, of all which they haue begged some peices of their diuelish doctrine. Maruaile not though I haue not feared these smoders, which if I shall once come to the cleare light, I shall easily expell. For this is our speech together. Tell me, dost thou beleeue as the Church doth, which flourished these many hundred yeeres past? Yea verilie: let vs therefore discourse of our countries and times; what Church dost thou beleeue? The congregation of the faithfull, whosenames are vnknowne, but it is apparant that many such haue been: Is it apparant that ⟨p. 75⟩manie such haue been. To whom it is apparant? To God; who saith so? we that haue receiued our doctrine from God himselfe. This is a loude lie, how may I beleeue it? If thou were feruent in faith, thou should know this as assuredlie, as thou dost that thou art aliue: Can you refraine laughing when you heare such foolish answers? All Christian people are commannded to cleaue fast vnto the Church, they are warned to take heed, lest they be slaine with the spirituall sword: they are bid keepe peace in the house of God: to commit their soules in trust vnto this pillar of truth, there to make all their complaints to take for heathen all such as are cast out of this Church: and yet all that, haue so many men, so manie hundred yeeres, been ignorant, where that Church is, or who belong vnto it; will they in darkenesse still stand vpon that point? that where or in what place soeuer the Church is, there are contained therein, onely saints, and such as are predestinate to goe to heauen:
*This is false, our doctrine hath been derived from Christ himself unto us, by the faithful of all ages.This is false, our doctrine hath been deriued from Christ himselfe vnto vs, by the faithfull of all ages.
whereby it falleth out that if any man will refuse to obey his prelate, he may think himself to be blameless in so doing: if he persuade himself that his said prelate hath committed any great offence, & by that means is excommunicated out of the Church. When I perceived that my adversaries invented such devises, and that they would not associate themselves to any Church, that heretofore hath been: and that when they were quite deprived of the thing it self, they would needs (though with much ado) keep still the bare name in possession, I solaced my self, with the hope I conceived of your ripe judgements, yea and I nothing doubted, but that as soon as you should find out even by their own confessions, these their juggling tricks, you would straightways, like plain honest and wise men cut off such foolish snares, framed of set purpose to work your overthrow.
whereby it falleth out that if any man will refuse to obey his prelate, he may thinke himselfe to be blamelesse in so doing: if hee perswade himselfe that his said prelate hath committed any great offence, & by that meanes is excommunicated out of the Church. When I perceiued that my aduersaries inuented such deuises, and that they would not associate themselues to any Church, that heretofore hath been: and that when they were quite depriued of the thing it selfe, they would needes (though with much adoe) keepe still the bare name in possession, I solaced my selfe, with the hope I conceiued of your ripe iudgements, yea and I nothing doubted, but that assoone as you should find out euen by their owne confessions, these their iugling trickes, you would straightwaies, like plaine honest and wise men cut off such foolish snares, framed of set purpose to worke your ouerthrow.
What is it, Campian, you further bring unto us? you propound unto us the nature of the Church, wherein you bring nothing besides your accustomed manner of vain and childish oratory, neither worthy the hearing of our University men, or answerable to the opinion that is held of you. As touching the Church there are many questions and great controversies, and at this day almost all disputations about religion are reduced to this head. For youra Catholics being tossed with the boisterous storms of other disputations, have been willing to takeb harbour in this haven of the Church. Here they dwell, here they place all their hopes of safety and victory, here they hide themselves, whensoever they are beaten out of the field. Therefore they fortify this sconce with all the skill they can, and strengthen it with munition on all sides; for which cause I marvel so much the more to find you, from whom so great things are expected, in this controversy to be so sleight and shallow; for you neither teach, nor conclude, nor yet propound any thing for your Church against ours, which hath in it either forcible reason or proof. But it may be ⟨p. 77⟩this is but your first skirmish, you will haply afterwards deal with us hand to hand; yet I will trace you out in your own steps, that I may lay hold of you, if haply I may find you any where certain.
WHat is it, Campian, you further bring vnto vs? you propound vnto vs the nature of the Church, wherein you bring nothing besides your accustomed manner of vaine and childish oratorie, neither worthy the hearing of our Vniuersitie men, or answerable to the opinion that is held of you. As touching the Church there are many questions and great controuersies, and at this day almost all disputations about religion are reduced to this head. For youra Catholikes being tossed with the boysterous stormes of other disputations, haue been willing to takeb harbor in this hauen of the Church. Here they dwell, here they place all their hopes of safety and victorie, heere they hide themselues, whensoeuer they are beaten out of the field. Therefore they fortifie this sconce with all the skill they can, and strengthen it with munition on all sides; for which cause I maruell so much the more to find you, from whom so great things are expected, in this controuersie to be so sleight and shallow; for you neither teach, nor conclude, nor yet propound any thing for your Church against ours, which hath in it either forceable reason or proofe. But it may be ⟨p. 77⟩this is but your first skirmish, you will happely afterwards deale with vs hand to hand; yet I wil trace you out in your owne steps, that I may lay hold of you, if happely I may find you any where certeine.
aDVR. Jt is well, that once you will acknowledge us to be Catholics. WHIT. pag. 247. Triumph not much for the name, my meaning is to give it you no otherwise, thē usually the name of man is given to a dead and dry corps, where nothing is but skin and bone. He is a Catholic, not who followeth the popish Apostasy, but that professeth the doctrine of Christ.DVR. Jt is well, that once you will acknowledge vs to be Catholiks. WHIT. pag. 247. Triumph not much for the name, my meaning is to giue it you no otherwise, thē vsually the name of man is giuen to a dead and dry corpes, where nothing is but skinne and bone. He is a Catholike, not who followeth the popish Apostasie, but that professeth the doctrine of Christ.
bDVR. Is it so great a fault to fly into the haven of the Church? WHIT. pag. That is not the fault we tax you for, but that you cover all your errors by pretending the name of the Church. And if we by manifest arguments out of the Scripture, reprove and refel your heresies, you cry out you are the Church, and by that thinks to defend all things, though they be never so absurd.DVR. Is it so great a fault to flie into the hauen of the Church? WHIT. pag. That is not the fault we taxe you for, but that you couer all your errors by pretending the name of the Church. And if we by manifest arguments out of the Scripture, reproue and refell your heresies, you cry out you are the Church, and by that thinks to defend all things, though they be neuer so absurde.
So soon, say you, as the adversary heard the Church but named, he waxed wan: yea Campian, it made him blush, when he perceived so chaste & holy a matron, so impiously & insolently to be abused by you. The Church doth ever expel you, and deny all commerce with you. Yet you as very audacious & importunate wooers give not over your suite to compass her. Sure there was no cause why your adversary should wax so wan, unless he feared some evil measure from such cutthroats as you are. Yet notwithstanding, say you, he hath devised one thing, which I would wish you to note well. You will sure acquaint us with some great and unheard of matter; verily I much desire to know what is this one thing: yet I fear it will prove stark nothing; and for all your throes, you will bring forth but a mouse. As for the honourable praises of the Church, you mention, we both acknowledge those, and speak far greater things of it: but verily they agree not to your Church at all; for it is the Babylonish whore, a branch cut off from the true Vine, a den of thieves, a broad way leading to destruction, the kingdom of hell, the body of Antichrist, a sink of errors, a great mother of fornications, the Church of the wicked, out of which every Christian ought to depart, which Christ shall one day fearfully destroy, and give her the just recompense of all her sins. In vain then do you reckon up the praises of the Church, unless you can demonstrate that they are proper to your Church, which you shall never be able to do, so long as Rome standeth. He would not, say you, seem to gain-say the Church, he kept craftily still the name of the Church, but the thing it self by his definition he took quite away. We verily, Campian, creverence and honour the Church, as our ⟨p. 78⟩mother, and in our definition we both retain the name, and clearly set out the nature of the thing it self. But you having lost the Church long since, do yet challenge the name and the vain title of the church. Our definition of the Church doth nothing like you; why I pray you? because we describe the Church by those properties which do altogether darken and hide it. We ascribe those properties to the Church which comprise the true nature of the Church, whose presence make a Church, and their absence mar or destroy a Church. But what are those properties which you affirm to darken and hide the Church?
So soone, say you, as the aduersarie heard the Church but named, he waxed wanne: yea Campian, it made him blush, when he perceiued so chast & holy a matron, so impiously & insolently to be abused by you. The Church doth euer expell you, and deny al commerce with you. Yet you as very audacious & importunate wooers giue not ouer your suite to compasse her. Sure there was no cause why your aduersary should wax so wanne, vnlesse he feared some euill measure from such cutthroats as you are. Yet notwithstanding, say you, he hath deuised one thing, which I would wish you to note well. You will sure acquaint vs with some great and vnheard of matter; verily I much desire to know what is this one thing: yet I feare it will proue starke nothing; and for all your throes, you wil bring forth but a mouse. As for the honorable praises of the Church, you mention, we both acknowledge those, and speake far greater things of it: but verily they agree not to your Church at all; for it is the Babylonish whoore, a branch cut off from the true Vine, a denne of theeues, a broad way leading to destruction, the kingdome of hell, the body of Antichrist, a sinke of errors, a great mother of fornications, the Church of the wicked, out of which euery Christian ought to depart, which Christ shal one day fearefully destroy, and giue her the iust recompence of all her sinnes. In vaine then do you reckon vp the praises of the Church, vnlesse you can demonstrate that they are proper to your Church, which you shall neuer be able to doe, so long as Rome standeth. He would not, say you, seeme to gain-say the Church, hee kept craftily still the name of the Church, but the thing it selfe by his definition he tooke quite away. We verily, Campian, creuerence and honor the Church, as our ⟨p. 78⟩mother, and in our definition wee both retaine the name, and cleerely set out the nature of the thing it selfe. But you hauing lost the Church long since, do yet challenge the name and the vaine title of the church. Our definition of the Church doth nothing like you; why I pray you? because we describe the Church by those properties which doe altogether darken and hide it. Wee ascribe those properties to the Church which comprise the true nature of the Church, whose presence make a Church, and their absence marre or destroy a Church. But what are those properties which you affirme to darken and hide the Church?
cDVR. Why do you not then defend her authority, but diminish and lessen it, yea and horribly blaspheme, affirming that the spouse of Christ may err and be deceived? WHIT. pag. 248. It is you that blaspheme, making the Church equal to God, to whom it is only peculiar not to err, not be deceived. For the Church may err though she be his Spouse, but not persist in any deadly error: as the Church of the Apostles did, when she thought her husbands kingdom was of this world, yea and after showed her ignorance of the calling of the Gentiles.DVR. Why do you not then defend her authoritie, but diminish and lessen it, yea and horriblie blaspheme, affirming that the spouse of Christ may erre and be deceiued? WHIT. pag. 248. It is you that blaspheme, making the Church equall to God, to whom it is only peculiar not to erre, not be deceiued. For the Church may erre though she be his Spouse, but not persist in any deadly error: as the Church of the Apostles did, when shee thought her husbands kingdome was of this world, yea and after shewed her ignorance of the calling of the Gentiles.
we verily judge this to be proper to the true Church, tod hear the word of Christ, and keep it, to use wholly and purely those Sacraments, which Christ, when he departed from his Church, left her, as a pledge of his love to her, and as a proof of her loyalty to him. These we maintain as the most true and substantial properties of the ⟨p. 79⟩Church, and this definition, made of the natural and inbred principles and grounds of the thing, which we define, you shall never be able to overthrow. I pray you what is there here that hideth the Church? doth the word of God; do the Sacraments hide the Church? yea these are they that make thec Church appear as clear as any thing at noon day, these give unto the Church strength, health and beauty: abolish these, there will remain nothing but the carcass of the Church. What drowsy dream then is this, you tell us of an airy body? as if we denied that the Church could be found on the earth; we never doubted but the Church ever hath been, and ever shall be upon the earth: though we also grant that the sight of it being sometime so clear that it may be seen of all: at another time is so obscured & ever shadowed, that one can hardly know it. But no Church pleaseth you, save that which is continually flourishing, and which is visible to all mens eyes, which hath a continual succession of Bishops to be fetched from the beginning, and which is subject to the Pope. Now Campian, as for you, you come to late to tell us of these frantic popish dreams; we have heard, discussed, and dissolved them, above a thousand times. Do you think you are able to make us believe, that the state of the Church is such, that it cannot be hid, that treachery should prevail nothing against it, an open enemy nothing, Antichrist himself nothing? These can never quite overthrow the Church, they may drive it to straits and thrust it into corners.3 Augustine compareth the Church to the Moon, which sometime while it is enlightened by the Sun-beams, shineth out, a• another time it is deprived of the greatest part of the light, and sometime shineth not at all. So the Church sometime shineth most brightly, sometime is more obscured, sometime hardly appeareth, and her whole course is ⟨p. 80⟩continually gaining and losing of light.
we verily iudge this to be proper to the true Church, tod heare the word of Christ, and keepe it, to vse wholly and purely those Sacraments, which Christ, when hee departed from his Church, left her, as a pledge of his loue to her, and as a proofe of her loyalty to him. These we maintaine as the most true and substantiall properties of the ⟨p. 79⟩Church, and this definition, made of the naturall and inbred principles and grounds of the thing, which we define, you shall neuer bee able to ouerthrow. I pray you what is there heere that hideth the Church? doth the word of God; do the Sacraments hide the Church? yea these are they that make thec Church appeare as cleere as any thing at noone day, these giue vnto the Church strength, health and beauty: abolish these, there will remaine nothing but the carkase of the Church. What drowsie dreame then is this, you tell vs of an airy body? as if we denied that the Church could be found on the earth; wee neuer doubted but the Church euer hath been, and euer shal be vpon the earth: though we also grant that the sight of it being sometime so cleere that it may be seen of all: at another time is so obscured & euer shadowed, that one can hardly know it. But no Church pleaseth you, saue that which is continually flourishing, and which is visible to all mens eies, which hath a continuall succession of Bishops to be fetched from the beginning, and which is subiect to the Pope. Now Campian, as for you, you come to late to tell vs of these frantike popish dreames; wee haue heard, discussed, and distolued them, aboue a thousand times. Doe you thinke you are able to make vs beleeue, that the state of the Church is such, that it cannot be hid, that treachery should preuaile nothing against it, an open enemy nothing, Antichrist himselfe nothing? These can neuer quite ouerthrow the Church, they may driue it to straits and thrust it into corners.3 Augustine compareth the Church to the Moone, which sometime while it is inlightned by the Sunne-beames, shineth out, a• another time it is depriued of the greatest part of the light, and sometime shineth not at all. So the Church sometime shineth most brightly, sometime is more obscured, sometime hardly appeareth, and her whole course is ⟨p. 80⟩continually gayning and losing of light.
dDVR. The Church is not to be sought for by these, as by notes, but they are to be learned from the Church. WHIT. pag. 252. Will it therefore follow because the word is no where else truly preached, but in the Church, nor the Sacraments purely administered, that the Church is not to be known and found out by then? Yea the contrary followeth, because they are not elsewhere but in the Church: therefore by these notes the true Church is to be known and demonstrated. For if only Peripatetians profess the Philosophy of Aristotle, then that kind of learning pointeth out the Peripatetians, and distinguisheth them from all other sects of Philosophers. DVR. Thus to search out the Church, is but to seek out one unknown thing by another, which is more unknown. WHIT. pag. 254. As if the Scripture were more hidden and unknown then the Church, and the Scripture could better be known by the Church, then it by the Scripture: undoubtedly no. 1. Because the Scripture begeteth and maketh a Church; and then is a ting hknowne, when the cause is known. 2. I here are many and divers Churches, but there is but one constant Scripture always like it self. 3. If at any time there was ever doubt made of the Scripture; yet there have been many moe questions and doubts concerning the Church. Lastly the Scripture is called a Canon, a rule; now the rule as it is straighter, so is it more certain then the thing that is squared by it. DVR. The notes of the Church ought to be such, as are agreed upon among all, as are proper to it, neither can be challenged probably by any other Church. WHIT. pag. 356. I conf•sse as much, and such are our notes in all things; whereas yours, are nothing lest. DVR. But every sect layeth claim to your notes. WHIT. pag. 256. What then, what if you lay claim to the things I possess, are they therefore not mine own? Be it that heretics do lay claim to the Scriptures, yet they do it without all show of reason, and out of the Scriptures only can they be confuted.DVR. The Church is not to be sought for by these, as by notes, but they are to be learned from the Church. WHIT. pag. 252. Will it therefore follow because the word is no where else truly preached, but in the Church, nor the Sacramēts purely administred, that the Church is not to be knowne and found out by then? Yea the contrary followeth, because they are not elsewhere but in the Church: therefore by these notes the true Church is to be knovvne and demonstrated. For if only Peripatetians professe the Philosophy of Aristotle, then that kind of learning pointeth out the Peripatetians, and distinguisheth them frō all other sects of Philosophers. DVR. Thus to search out the Church, is but to secke out one vnknowne thing by another, which is more vnknowne. WHIT. pag. 254. As if the Scripture vvere more hidden and vnknovvne then the Church, and the Scripture could better bee knovvne by the Church, then it by the Scripture: vndoubtedly no. 1. Because the Scripture begeteth and maketh a Church; and then is a ting hknovvne, vvhen the cause is knovvne. 2. I here are many and diuers Churches, but there is but one constant Scripture alvvaies like it selfe. 3. If at any time there vvas euer doubt made of the Scripture; yet there haue been many moe questions and doubts concerning the Church. Lastly the Scripture is called a Canon, a rule; novv the rule as it is straighter, so is it more certeine then the thing that is squared by it. DVR. The notes of the Church ought to be such, as are agreed vpon among all, as are proper to it, neither can be challengd probablie by any other Church. WHIT. pag. 356. I confsse as much, and such are our notes in all things; vvhereas yours, are nothing leste. DVR. But euery sect layeth claime to your notes. WHIT. pag. 256. What then, vvhat if you lay claime to the things I possesse, are they therfore not mine ovvne? Be it that heretikes do lay claime to the Scriptures, yet they doe it vvithout all shevv of reason, and out of the Scriptures only can they be confuted.
Will you that I manifest it to you by examples? while David and Solomon reigned, the Church flourished in Israel; but when Ahab reigned, the face of the Church was so far obscured, that the most divine Prophetf Elijah complained that there was not one remaining save himself. If there could be such a havoc made of the Church,2 that of all that great number of the godly, there was scarce one to be seen, (though there was a good sum remaining of them.) it need be no wonder that in the kingdom of Antichrist, who surpasseth all Ahabs and Jezebels in all barbarous cruelty, that the Church should be so wasted, that there should appear a marvellous scarcity of faithful men. And yet could Antichrist in that great havoc of religion and the Church, never so far prevail, but there was a remnant of many thousand thousands of Saints, who never bowed their knees to the beast, neither ever received the mark of the beast. Let us pass along to those times when Christ lived upon the earth, and consider the state of the Church of Jerusalem. For no Church can be more like to the Church of Rome, then that, as the state of it was, when Christ did perform the work of our salvation. They had the Scripture, they were a people zealous of the law, they had the Temple, they had Levites, Priests, yea a high Priest; what was wanting here to make a perfect Church? Christ at length showeth himself openly, and bringeth that happy message of salvation; this very Church hated, persecuted, cursed, and in the end killed this Christ, the Son of God, the legate of his Father, the teacher of celestial doctrine; the author of our salvation. This Church then, Campian, was it a true Church or no, what think you? If it was, then the true Church hated Christ, and judged him worthy of death. If it was not, then where and what is the true Church? for ⟨p. 81⟩Christ at the first had a very small number, that if you answerg Christ and his company was the Church, then you fall into that crime, which you reprove us for. If then this might befall theh Church of Jerusalem, that though it had, and by continued succession enjoyed the name of the Church, yet in very truth it was nothing else but a cave and den of thieves:
Will you that I manifest it to you by examples? while Dauid and Salomon raigned, the Church flourished in Israell; but when Ahab raigned, the face of the Church was so far obscured, that the most diuine Prophetf Eliah complained that there was not one remaining saue himselfe. If there could be such a hauocke made of the Church,2 that of all that great number of the godly, there was scarce one to be seene, (though there was a good summe remaining of them.) it need be no wonder that in the kingdome of Antichrist, who surpasseth all Ahabs and Iezabels in all brabarous cruelty, that the Church should be so wasted, that there should appeare a maruellous scarcity of faithfull men. And yet could Antichrist in that great hauocke of religion and the Church, neuer so far preuaile, but there was a remanant of many thousand thousands of Saints, who neuer bowed their knees to the beast, neither euer receiued the marke of the beast. Let vs passe along to those times when Christ liued vpon the earth, and consider the state of the Church of Ierusalem. For no Church can be more like to the Church of Rome, then that, as the state of it was, when Christ did performe the worke of our saluation. They had the Scripture, they were a people zealous of the law, they had the Temple, they had Leuits, Priests, yea a high Priest; what was wanting here to make a perfect Church? Christ at length sheweth himselfe openly, and bringeth that happie message of saluation; this very Church hated, persecuted, cursed, and in the end killed this Christ, the Son of God, the lagat of his Father, the teacher of celestiall doctrine; the author of our saluation. This Church then, Campian, was it a true Church or no, what think you? If it was, then the true Church hated Christ, and iudged him worthy of death. If it was not, then where and what is the true Church? for ⟨p. 81⟩Christ at the first had a very smale number, that if you answereg Christ and his company was the Church, then you fall into that crime, which you reproue vs for. If then this might befall theh Church of Hierusalem, that though it had, and by continued succession inioyed the name of the Church, yet in very truth it was nothing else but a caue and denne of theeues:
fDVR. Elijah spake not of the whole Church, but of the kingdom of Israel, wherein he lived. WHIT. pag. 261. He lived at that time, not in the kingdom of Israel, but in the mountain of God, Mount Horeb. 1. King. 19.8. But grant he spake of Israel only: it is no less for our purpose. For that which happened there, that no good men appeared, though many lay hid, so it may fall out in other churches, and at other times, that none or few of the faithful appear; yet God may have a multitude of unknown believers.DVR. Elias spake not of the whole Church, but of the kingdome of Israell, wherein he liued. WHIT. pag. 261. He liued at that time, not in the kingdome of Israell, but in the moūtaine of God, Moūt Horeb. 1. King. 19.8. But grāt he spake of Israell only: it is no lesse for our purpose. For that which hapned there, that no good men appeared, though many lay hid, so it may fall out in other churches, and at other times, that none or few of the faithfull appeare; yet God may haue a multitude of vnknowne beleeuers.
gDVR. The Church undoubtenly was in Christ and his Apostles. WHIT. pag. 262. See then what followeth for our advantage; it it so fell out that the true Church was not amongst them who had a lawful succession ordained of the Lord; who also had the place, the name, the dignity, and magnificent ornaments of the Church; but it was in a few, who after a sort were cut off from the Church, it is a thing without question, that the Church is not always to be sought for in a visible multitude, and an outward succession of men: but often times in obscure places, and amongst a very few.DVR. The Church vndoubtenly was in Christ and his Apostes. WHIT. pag. 262. See then what followeth for our aduantage; it it so fell out that the true Church was not amongst them who had a lawfull succession ordeined of the Lord; who also had the place, the name, the dignity, and magnificent ornaments of the Church; but it was in a few, who after a sort were cut off from the Church, it is a thing without question, that the Church is not alwaies to bee sought for in a visible multitude, and an outward succession of men: but often times in obscure places, and amongst a very few.
hDVR. That which befell the Synagogue of Hierusal•••, cannot befall to the Church of Christ, whieth the Prophets have plainly foretold should never perish.
I see not what the Church of Rome can challenge to it self, why it may not be said long ago to have lost the body of the Church, though it keep still the visard, the name, and the vestments of the Church. What if the Romish Church condemned Luther? shall we say therefore Luther is an heretic, and that it is the Catholic Church? The Church of Jerusalem condemned Christ, and him and his they would have denied to be the true Church, if by any colour they could, that they might free themselves out of those straights, they were brought into. But happily they will say, there is no such thing to be found in Christs new Church.1 But S. Paul prophesieth of an Apostasy, that should be before Christs coming ⟨p. 82⟩to judgement,i which Apostasy is from religion and the Church, as the most ancient Fathers do understand it: and Christ prophesied evidently of the small number of his.3 When the Son of man shall come shall he find kfaith on the earth? If hardly any faith shall remain on the earth, and the Church cannot be said to be a Church, but improperly without faith, it followeth necessarily that when Christ cometh, their number shall be very small, who may truly be called the Church. You have now those Scriptures which do thus paint out the Church unto us, unless you think your self better able to portray it, then the holy Ghost himself could do, who hath set out the Church in far better colours and manner, then I find yours to be, in which there is nothing left but painted walls. But, say you, there are Epistles of Christ written to the seven Churches which were in Asia; there are also divers Epistles which were written by S. Peter, S. Paul, S. John, and by others unto sundry Churches; in the Acts of the Apostles we find mention made of many Churches begun and enlarged. What then, Campian, what think you may be inferred hereupon? These were not known to God only, but also to all Christians: who ever denied that? These same Churches of Asia to whom Christ sent Epistles and the Churches of the Corinthians, Philippians, Thessalonians, Colossians, to which Paul writ, were particular visible Churches. Did we ever seem to make question whether a Church might be visible or no? we verily call all those visible and apparent Churches, which profess the pure word of God and hold those rights ⟨p. 83⟩and Sacraments which are commanded by Christ.
I see not what the Church of Rome can challenge to it selfe, why it may not be said long agot to haue lost the body of the Church, though it keepe still the visard, the name, and the vestments of the Church. What if the Romish Church condemned Luther? shall we say therefore Luther is an heretike, and that it is the Catholike Church? The Church of Ierusalem condemned Christ, and him and his they would haue denied to be the true Church, if by any colour they could, that they might free themselues out of those straights, they were brought into. But happily they will say, there is no such thing to be found in Christs new Church.1 But S. Paul prophesieth of an Apostasie, that should be before Christs comming ⟨p. 82⟩to iudgement,i which Apostafie is from religion and the Church, as the most auncien• Fathers do vnderstand it: and Christ prophesied euidently of the small number of his.3 When the Soune of man shall come shall he find kfaith on the earth? If hardly any faith shal remaine on the earth, and the Church cannot be said to be a Church, but improperly without faith, it followeth necessarily that when Christ commeth, their number shall be very small, who may truly be called the Church. You haue now those Scriptures which do thus paint out the Church vnto vs, vnlesse you thinke your selfe better able to puttray it, then the holy Ghost himselfe could do, who hath set out the Church in farre better colours and manner, then I find yours to be, in which there is nothing left but painted walles. But, say you, there are Epistles of Christ written to the seauen Churches which were in Asia; there are also diuers Epistles which were written by S. Peter, S. Paul, S. Iohn, and by others vnto sundrie Churches; in the Acts of the Apostles wee find mention made of manie Churches begun and enlarged. What then, Campian, what think you may be inferred hereupon? These were not knowne to God only, but also to all Christians: who euer denied that? These same Churches of Asia to whom Christ sent Epistles and the Churches of the Corinthians, Philippians, Thessalonians, Colossians, to which Paul writ, were particular visible Churches. Did we euer seeme to make question whether a Church might be visible or no? we verily call all those visible and apparant Churches, which professe the pure word of God and hold those rights ⟨p. 83⟩
iDVR. The Fathers have understood the place of Antichrist, or of a defection from the Roman Empire. WHIT. pag. 268. Nay Cyril of Jerusalem (a man you much esteem) Catech. 11. doth interpret it of an Apostasy from the true faith, so doth Chrysostom, Oecumenius, so many others. Yea your Divines of Rhemes have so expounded it.DVR. The Fathers haue vnderstood the place of Antichrist, or of a defection from the Romane Empire. WHIT. pag. 268. Nay Cyrill of Hierusalem (a man you much esteeme) Catech. 11. doth interpret it of an Apostasie from the true faith, so doth Chrysostome, Oecumenius, so many others. Yea your Diuines of Rhemes haue so expounded it.
kDVR. Augustine de vultat. Ecclesiae cap. 13. saith, WE understand this speech, either for the perfection of faith, or for the multitude of the wicked, or for the small number of the good. So doth Hierome contr. Luciferano•. WHIT. pag. 270. What if these Fathers mistook the place, must we rest in their exposition? we have Nazianzene cont. Arran. Theophyla. in 28. Luc. Caietan upon this place against them: nay further when Augustine writeth that there is signified the multitude of the wicked, and the small number of the good, doth he not defend our opinion, that the number of the wicked shall be great, but of the godly small?DVR. Augustine de vultat. Ecclesiae cap. 13. saith, VVE vnderstand this speech, either for the perfection of faith, or for the multitude of the wicked, or for the small number of the good. So doth Hierome contr. Luciferano•. WHIT. pag. 270. What if these Fathers mistooke the place, must we rest in their exposition? we haue Nazianzene cont. Arran. Theophyla. in 28. Luc. Caietan vpon this place against them: nay further when Augustine writeth that there is signified the multitude of the wicked, and the small number of the good, doth he not defend our opinion, that the number of the wicked shall be great, but of the godly small?
And so at this day by the blessing of God there are many visible Churches in England, Scotland, Germany, France, and other parts of Christendom, though it grieve you Jesuits they should be so visible and apparent. But what kind of reasoning is this?l Those Churches to whom Christ and his Apostles writ were visible: therefore the Catholic Church is ever visible. Have you learned such Logic as this at Rome in your famous schools of Jesuits? or do you, Campian, think that these manner of Allegations should go for proofs in the ears of our University men? but where are those Churches now, which were then so flourishing? Show me the Church of Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamus, Corinthians, and the rest. Now they are no where to be seen, and are no longer Churches. And that which we have seen already befall those Churches, teach us, I pray you, how it may not also betide the Church of Rome? And though Rome become a heap, yet the Church shall be safe: neither shall the downfall of any city or Empire ever be able to abolish it. And at this day there are many flourishing Churches, which are equal to your falsely called Catholic Church, for the number, & undoubtedly are far better for the truth they hold.
And so at this day by the blessing of God there are many visible Churches in England, Scotland, Germanie, Fraunce, and other parts of Christendome, though it greeue you Iesuits they should be so visible and apparant. But what kind of reasoning is this?l Those Churches to whom Christ and his Apostles writ were visible: therefore the Catholike Church is euer visible. Haue you learned such Logicke as this at Rome in your famous schoolts of Iesuits? or doe you, Campian, thinke that these manner of Allegations should goe for proofes in the eares of our Vniuersity men? but where are those Churches now, which were then so flourishing? Shew me the Church of Ephesus, Smyrna, Pergamus, Corinthes, and the rest. Now they are no where to be seene, and are no lōger Churches. And that which we haue seen already befal those Churches, teach vs, I pray you, how it may not also betide the Church of Rome? And though Rome become a heap, yet the Church shall be safe: neither shal the downfall of any citie or Empire euer be able to abolish it. And at this day there are many flourishing Churches, which are equall to your falsly called Catholike Church, for the number, & vndoubtedly are far better for the truth they hold.
lDVR. All particular Churches on which the Catholic Church consisteth, as on parts, are visible: therefore the Catholic Church it self is visible. WHIT. pag. 272. All particular Churches which make the Catholic, are not visible: because it consisteth not of the Churches of this time only, but of Churches of the times past, and of those which shall be in the time to come. But say it were compact and made of the Churches of this time only, yet it followeth not that it must be visible: nay so long […] particulars are visible, it cannot, for when all the parts are grown into o••, then is the whole visible, but not each several part; so when the several parts may be seen, the whole cannot be seen, because the parts are no••ow become one. So the contrary to your collection will follow that because the parts are visible, the whole cannot be seen.DVR. All particular Churches on which the Catholike Church consisteth, as on parts, are visible: therefore the Catholike Church it selfe is visible. WHIT. pag. 272. All particular Churches which make the Catholike, are not visible: because it consisteth not of the Churches of this time only, but of Churches of the times past, and of those which shall be in the time to come. But say it were compact and made of the Churches of this time only, yet it followeth not that it must be visible: nay so long 〈…〉 particulars are visible, it cannot, for when all the parts are growen into o••, then is the whole visible, but not each seuerall part; so when the seuerall parts may be seene, the whole cānot be seen, because the parts are no••ow become one. So the cōtrary to your collection will follow that because the parts are visible, the whole cannot be seene.
But you say, That for 1500. years we could not spy out one town, one village, one house seasoned with our doctrine. Nay, Campian, that is very false,m for in the ⟨p. 84⟩Apostles time, all Churches, all cities, all towns, every family embraced the same faith and religion which we now profess. After that by little and little, the purity of doctrinen began to be corrupted, and divers superstitions spread far and near; though the holy Fathers did as much as they could, resist,3 until that mystery of iniquity, which took rooting in the very Apostles time, spread it selfo by all the parts of the Church, and at length possessed it wholly. Yet Antichrist that man of sin, could never prevail so far, but a great multitude of the Saints remained; and those, whose names were written in the book of life, did utterly abhor all those filthy and wicked ⟨p. 85⟩superstitions of Antichrist. For in the Church of Rome it self even in the worth times of it, yet many were ever found, who worshipped the God of their Fathers, and kept themselves unpolluted with that horrible Idolatry. And this can histories of all times witness, which I could now recite if it were needful, and reckon up to you, many houses, villages, towns, cities, and countries, where Christ had many and populous Churches. Thep Greek Church could never yet be brought to join it self to your Church, and it is […] opposite to you, as ever our Church was. And yet you so forge these things, as if the Pope of Rome long ago had had the whole world under his subjection. Until that unhappy Monk, as you say, by his incest•••• marriage had deflowered a Nun, dedicated to God by […] sole•••• […] or until that quarrelling Sw••• had conspired against his country, or that infamous ••••gate had undertaken an usurped authority in Ge••••. So, Campian, go on to rail and revile every good man, pour out the gall of your bitterness, seeing you have undertaken to spend all your venomous darts upon them. Luther's name is written in the book of life; and his memory shall ever be sacred among all good men, and your reproaches shall not be able to pierce or wound him. It is a true saying, that a false reproach pierceth not the skin: you call him Monk, & your self is but a Friar; now Monks were ever accounted more honest then Friars. But he ⟨p. 86⟩by incestuous marriage de••oured […] Nom•••, dedicated to God by solemn vow.q
But you say, That for 1500. yeares we could not spie out one towne, one village, one house seasoned with our doctrine. Nay, Campian, that is very false,m for in the ⟨p. 84⟩Apostles time, all Churches, all cities, all townes, euery family embraced the same faith and religion which we now professe. After that by little and little, the purity of doctrinen began to be corrupted, and diuers superstitions spread far and neare; though the holy Fathers did as much as they could, resist,3 vntill that mystery of iniquitie, which tooke rooting in the very Apostles time, spread it selfeo by all the parts of the Church, and at length possessed it wholy. Yet Antichrist that man of sinne, could neuer preuaile so farre, but a great multitude of the Saints remained; and those, whose names were written in the booke of life, did vtterly abhorre all those filthie and wicked ⟨p. 85⟩superstitions of Antichrist. For in the Church of Rome it selfe euen in the worth times of it, yet many were euer found, who worshipped the God of their Fathers, and kept themselues vnpolluted with that horrible Idolatrie. And this can histories of all times witnesse, which I could now recite if it were needful, and reckon vp to you, many houses, villages, townes, cities, and countries, where Christ had many and populous Churches. Thep Greeke Church could neuer yet be brought to ioyne it self to your Church, and it is 〈…〉 opposite to you, as euer our Church was. And yet you so forge these things, as if the Pope of Rome long agoe had had the whole world vnder his subiection. Vntill that vnhappy Monke, as you say, by his incest•••• marriage had defloured a Nunne, dedicated to God by 〈…〉 sole••••〈…〉 or vntill that quarrelling Sw••• had c••spired against his country, or that infamous gate had vndertaken an vsurped authority in Ge. So, Campian, go on to raile and reuile euery good man, powre out the gall of your bitternes, seeing you haue vndertaken to spend all your venemous darts vpon them. Luthers name is written in the book of life; and his memory shal euer be sacred among all good men, and your reproaches shall not be able to pearce or wound him. It is a true saying, that a false repreach pierceth not the skinne: you call him Monke, & your selfe is but a Frier; now Monkes were euer accounted more honest then Friers. But he
mDVR. The Arians, M••cedonians, and all other ancient heretics may by the same probability say as much. WHIT. pag 272. It the Arians or any other heretic can prove the doctrine of their Churches out of the holy Scriptures, they may answer the same which we do, for every Church which holdeth the Apostles doctrine, may profess that all cities, village•, […] which were religious, were seasoned with their doctrine.DVR. The Arrians, M••cedonians, and all other auncient heretikes may by the same probability say as much. WHIT. pag 272. It the Arrians or any other heretike can proue the doctrine of their Churches out of the holy Scriptures, they may answere the same which we doe, for euery Church which holdeth the Apostles doctrine, may professe that all cities, village•, 〈…〉 which were religous, were seasoned with their doctrine.
nDVR. Tell me then from whom, and in what age any doctrine of our profession was brought into the Church. WHIT. pag. 277. The motion of the Sun is so very swift, that we may see it hath moved, though we cannot discern the moving of it: so such is the mystery of your iniquity that I well perceive by the Scriptures your doctrines are not Apostolical; but the time when, and the manner how they were brought in, is not much to our purpose. And it were too long to tell all, yet hear some, Your Romish Bishop a long time together was but equal to other Bishops th•ugh much was given to him for the excellency of that Church. After the Christian world was divided into four Provinces, when he became the chief of the Patriarchs, after this he began to challenge authority over other Churches, and for that purpose counterfeited the Councell of Nice: but he was repressed by the African Councell. Then Gregory the great, greatly inveighed against John of Constantinople, because he sought the name of universal Bishop, and for that ambition called him the forerunner of Antichrist. Lastly, Boniface the eight with a great sum obtained that honour of Phocas the Parricide. And since that he grew to that height, that he made not only Churches and Kings, but the Christian Emperor himself to kiss his feet. But see another example. Time was when there were no images in Churches: As that of Epiphanius proveth, who rent a veil in pieces, because there was in it an image of Christ or of some Saint. But in time they were received into the Church, but no honour given them: yet after that, good Bishops brake them and cast them out again; as Gregory writeth that Serenus the Bishop of Massilia did, whom he thus checketh for it. In that you forbade them to be worshipped, we commend you, but that you brake them, we reprehend you. Gregor. regist. lib. 7. Epist. 9. Lastly the second Nicene Councell decreed, that they were not to be broken, yea that they were religiously to be worshipped. And thus hath it succeeded in other things, as S. Paul did foretell saying; The mystery of iniquity doth already work.
Luther indeed took to wife in holy wedlock, a Virgin that once was entangled by a rash & superstitious vow, after she had bin more rightly instructed in the truth of religion. Exclaim bitterly as you list. Call Zuinglius also a swash buckler, seeing your self is a player of a Price. But tell us wherein he did ever show himself such a cutter? forsooth he boldly ventured his life with his fellow citizens.1 If Zuinglius at the command of the Senate went to war against the enemies of his coū try & religion, where he perished by cruel thieves, who lay in wait for him, what did he unbefitting a valiant man, a good citizen, and a faithful Pastor to do. For whereas you challenge him with conspiracy against his country, besides that it is a shameless lie, I wonder why you should object such a crime to him, seeing with you it is a thing very commendable for men to conspire against their Prince and country. As for Calvin whom you call a seareback: runagate, the whole Church of Christ knoweth to be an excellent man, and a most constant servant of the Lord: who was as far from lewdness and dishonesty, as you are from shamefastness and honesty. If he was seared, S. Paul was so too,2 yea & divers others: but indeed he was not. And whereas you call him a runagate, I pray you tell us, where you have lived for ⟨p. 87⟩these divers years, and remember what your self were. Calvin never forsook the Church, he once took upon him to govern, but there he lived with the special love of all, and there he ended his days: but why do I answer you anything in defence of those excellent and worthy men, whom you shall never justly defame, though you burst your hart with lying.
Luther indeed tooke to wife in holy wedlocke, a Virgin that once was intangled by a rash & superstitious vow, after she had bin more rightly instructed in the truth of religion. Exclaime bitterly as you list. Call Zuinglius also a swash buckler, seeing your self is a player of a Price. But tell vs wherein he did euer shew himselfe such a cutter? forsooth he boldly ventered his life with his fellow citizens.1 If Zuinglius at the commaund of the Senate went to warre against the enemies of his coū trie & religion, where he perished by cruell theeues, who lay in waite for him, what did he vnbefitting a valiant man, a good citizen, and a faithfull Pastor to do. For whereas you challenge him with conspiracie against his country, besides that it is a shamelesse lie, I wonder why you should obiect such a crime to him, seeing with you it is a thing very commendable for men to conspire against their Prince and country. As for Caluin whom you call a seareback: runagate, the whole Church of Christ knoweth to be an excellent man, and a most constant seruant of the Lord: who was as farre from lewdnes and dishonastie, as you are from shamefastnes and honesty. If he was seared, S. Paul was so too,2 yea & diuers others: but indeed he was not. And whereas you call him a runagate, I pray you tell vs, where you haue liued for ⟨p. 87⟩these diuers yeares, and remember what your selfe were. Caluin neuer forsooke the Church, hee once tooke vpon him to gouerne, but there he liued with the speciall loue of all, and there he ended his daies: but why doe I answere you anything in defence of those excellent and worthy men, whom you shal neuer iustly defame, though you burst your hart with lying.
But let us now hear your communication as you call it. And here you demand, Whether we will subscribe to the Church which flourished these many hundred yours? we answer, we will subscribe: but say you, to which Church? I answerr to the Church which is built upon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles: that is, to the Churches of Jerusalem, Antioch, Ephesus, and all those famous and excellent Churches of which we read in the Epistles written by the Apostles, yea even to the ancient Church of Rome, to which yours is no more like then an apple to an oyster. Finally we subscribe to those Churches, of whom we read in histories that they kept the seed of that doctrine, which the Apostles taught among them, sound & uncorrupt. These Churches as long as they did continue in the Apostles doctrine, were true Churches; & to those Churches we have and ever will subscribe. And by this I think we have cut off the progress of your conference, for we have not given you such an answer as you feigned to your self. Wherefore that which followeth in you hangeth together like a rope of sand. but no answer will please you, unless we offer to subscribe to your Romish Church: but that we justly disclaim, because it hath foully corrupted the ••• stles ⟨p. 88⟩writing. You must find you out other subscribers, Campian, for we will subscribe to none but the Apostolical Churches. But one thing, say you, they will still stand upon in darkness, that where and in what place soever the Church is, there are conceived therein only Saints, and such as are predestinate to go to heaven. We speak not so of the Church as you write: for we are taught by the Scriptures thus to distinguish the Church, that it is sometimess visible and sometimes invisible. In a particular visible Church, of which they are members, who will hear the Word, and receive the Sacraments: we confess there are many feigned Christians, who had rather have the visard of faith, then true faith indeed. An invisible Church we affirm to contain only the godly, who with a true faith lay hold on the Gospel. These though they may be seen as long as they live amongst men, seeing they are men as others be, yet because neither their faith nor Gods love, which maketh them members of the Church, is visible, we affirm that this Church, consisting of holy and faithful men, is altogether invisible.
But let vs now heare your communication as you call it. And heere you demaund, Whether we will subscribe to the Church which flourished these many hundred youres? we answere, we will subscribe: but say you, to which Church? I answerer to the Church which is built vpon the foundation of the Prophets and Apostles: that is, to the Churches of Hierusalem, Antioch, Ephesus, and all those famous and excellent Churches of which wee reade in the Epistles written by the Apostles, yea euen to the auncient Church of Rome, to which yours is no more like then an apple to an oyste•. Finally we subscribe to those Churches, of whom we reade in histories that they kept the seed of that doctrine, which the Apostles taught among them, sound & vncorrupt. These Churches as long as they did continue in the Apostles doctrine, were true Churches; & to those Churches we haue and euer will subscribe. And by this I thinke we haue cut off the progresse of your conference, for we haue not giuen you such an answere as you fained to your selfe. Wherefore that which followeth in you hangeth together like a rope of sand. but no answere will please you, vnlesse we offer to subscribe to your Romish Church: but that we iustly disclaime, because it hath fouly corrupted the ••• stles ⟨p. 88⟩writing. You must find you out other subscribers, Campian, for wee will subscribe to none but the Apostolicall Churches. But one thing, say you, they will still stand vpon in darkenes, that where and in what place soeuer the Church is, there are con•eiued therein only Saints, and such as are predestinate to go to heauen. We speake not so of the Church as you write: for we are taught by the Scriptures thus to distinguish the Church, that it is sometimess visible and sometimes inuisible. In a particular visible Church, of which they are members, who will heare the Word, and receiue the Sacraments: we confesse there are many fained Christians, who had rather haue the visard of faith, then true faith indeed. An inuisible Church we affirme to containe only the godly, who with a true faith lay hold on the Gospell. These though they may bee seene as long as they liue amongst men, seeing they are men as others bee, yet because neither their faith nor Gods loue, which maketh them members of the Church, is visible, we affirme that this Church, consisting of holy and faithfull men, is altogether inuisible.
rDVR. He did not demand whether you would subscribe to that Church, which had continued in the precept of the Apostles, but whether to that Church, which hath flourished these many hundred years; which if you would, you must needs yield as overcome, when none but ours have flourished thus long. WHIT. pag. 285. As if no Church but the Romish Church had flourished these many hundred years: or for many ages together in the opinion of men, it only h•• the name of ••e church: […] will subscribe to all Churches whether they flourished now […] they hold the Apostles doctrine: but you shall never prove […] we must necessarily subscribe to place, Sea, & succession, no more then Christ & his disciples were bound when there was no true Church flourishing upon the earth.DVR. He did not demaund whether you would subscribe to that Church, which had continued in the precept of the Apostles, but vvhether to that Church, vvhich hath flourished these many hundred yeares; vvhich if you vvould, you must needs yeeld as ouercome, vvhen none but ours haue flourished thus long. WHIT. pag. 285. As if no Church but the Romish Church had flourished these many hundred yeares: or for many ages together in the opinion of men, it only h•• the name of ••e church: 〈…〉 will subscribe to all Churches whether they flourished now 〈…〉 they hold the Apostles doctrine: but you shall neuer proue 〈…〉 we must necessarily subscribe to place, Sea, & succession, no more then Christ & his disciples were bound when there was no true Church flourishing vpon the earth.
sDVR. I believe only one Catholic Church, as the Apostles and Nicene Creed hath taught me, which containeth both the elect, and as many as profess true religion. Now you teach me to believe two Churches. WHIT. pag. 286. This distinction taketh not away the unity of the Church, no more then when the Church is said to be m•••an and u••• phant, universal and particular. For the visible and ••uisible Church make but one: called visible, for the outward policy or order of it, which is seen and discerned; invisible because Gods election and the elects faith is not to be seen with eyes. And this distinction we have, Isaiah. 1.9.
Christ is the head of this Church, to this only the elect ca• join themselves, ⟨p. 89⟩we then acknowledge another Church besides that, which containeth only Saints (for so should there be no visible Church at all) but what company of men soever upon the earth doth profess the doctrine of the Apostles and Prophets, we profess that to be the true Church of Christ, though many wicked men be found in it. Neither are we the first who did invent and devise these things, as you say of us, but are ready to prove them both by the holy scripture and by authority of Antiquity. Comfort then your self, Campian, as much as you can, with the wits of our University men, and promise to your self great things from us, but see you bring more dexterity of wit, or else without doubt you can never deceive us with this shallow conceit. If you should propound these foolish and childish things in the populous assemblies of our University men, I persuade my self, they would not only tear to pieces these your childish shifts, but do as much by you too, for abusing so shamefully their learned conceits.
Christ is the head of this Church, to this only the elect ca• ioyne themselues, ⟨p. 89⟩wee then acknowledge another Church besides that, which cōteineth only Saints (for so should there be no visible Church at all) but what company of men soeuer vpon the earth doth professe the doctrine of the Apostles and Prophets, we professe that to be the true Church of Christ, though many wicked men be found in it. Neither are we the first who did inuent and deuise these things, as you say of vs, but are ready to proue thē both by the holy scripture and by authority of Antiquity. Comfort then your selfe, Campian, as much as you can, with the wits of our Vniuersity men, and promise to your selfe great things from vs, but see you bring more dexterity of wit, or else without doubt you can neuer deceiue vs with this shallow conceit. If you should propound these foolish and childish things in the populous assemblies of our Vniuersity men, I perswade my selfe, they would not only teare to pieces these your childish shifts, but do as much by you too, for abusing so shamefully their learned conceites.
A Great controversy for the keeping of the ceremonies of the old law, which in the Primitive Church much moved the minds of faithful people, was by a Council gathered together, of the Apostles and some elders decided. Children then believed their Parents, and sheep their Shepherds, charging them in this sort:a It hath pleased the holy Ghost, and us; after this there were holden four general ⟨p. 90⟩Councils of ancient Fathers, for the rooting out of heresy, which budded up abundantly in every age, which were of such authority aboveb 1000. years ago, that* great honour was attributed unto them, as though it had been unto the four Gospels. I will seek no further; even here in our own Country by anc act of Parliament, the self same Councils do retain still their former force, and pure authority: which said act I will here allege: And call thee, thy self O England, my most loving Country, to witness. If thou reverence, as thou pretendest, those Councils,5 then wilt thou yield up the supremacy to the Bishop of the chief sea, that is, to Saint Peter. Then wilt thou acknowledge upon the altar, the unbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ. Then wilt thou pray the blessed Martyrs and all the Saints in Heaven to make intercession to Christ for thee. Then wilt thou restrain these lecherous Apostates from their filthy carnal copulation, and open incest. Then wilt thou build up many things, which now thou pullest down, and wish many things undone, which now thou doest. Moreover, I promise and undertake, as occasion and time shall serve, to prove, that the* Councils holden at other times, and namely the Council of Trent, have been of equal authority and credit with the four first Councils. Wherefore then should I not come to this place of trial, securely and courageously, to mark into what corner my enemy will creep, seeing I am* aided with the valiant and piked garrison of all the Councils? For I will allege both most manifest matter which he shall not be able to wrest aside, and also most substantially proved, which he dare not contemptuously reject. He will perhaps go about to trifle out the time, with multiplying of many words: but if you be the men that I have always taken you for, you will take so good heed unto him, that he shall neither rob you of your ears nor eyes.
AGreat controuersie for the keeping of the ceremonies of the old law, which in the Primitiue Church much moued the minds of faithfull people, was by a Councell gathered together, of the Apostles and some elders decided. Children then beleeued their Parents, and sheepe their Sheepheards, charging them in this sort:a It hath pleased the holy Ghost, and vs; after this there were holden foure generall ⟨p. 90⟩Councels of auncient Fathers, for the rooting out of heresie, which budded vp aboundantly in euery age, which were of such authoritie aboueb 1000. yeeres agoe, that* great honour was attributed vnto them, as though it had been vnto the foure Gospels. I will seeke no further; euen here in our owne Countrey by anc acte of Parliament, the selfe same Councels doe retaine still their former force, and pure authoritie: which said acte I will heere alleadge: And call thee, thy selfe O England, my most louing Countrey, to witnesse. If thou reuerence, as thou pretendest, those Councels,5 then wilt thou yeeld vp the supremacie to the Bishop of the chiefe sea, that is, to Saint Peter. Then wilt thou acknowledge vpon the altar, the vnbloodie sacrifice of the bodie and blood of Christ. Then wilt thou pray the blessed Martyrs and all the Saints in Heauen to make intercession to Christ for thee. Then wilt thou restraine these leacherous Apostataes from their filthie carnall copulation, and open incest. Then wilt thou build vp many things, which now thou pullest downe, and wish many things vndone, which now thou doest. Moreouer, I promise and vndertake, as occasion and time shall serue, to proue, that the* Councels holden at other times, and namely the Councell of Trent, haue been of equall authoritie and credit with the foure first Councels. Wherefore then should I not come to this place of triall, securely and couragiously, to marke into what corner my enemie will creepe, seeing I am* ayded with the valiant and piked garrison of all the Councels? For I will alleadge both most manifest matter which he shall not be able to wrest aside, and also most substantially prooued, which he dare not contemptuously reiect. He will perhaps goe about to trifle out the time, with multiplying of many words: but if you be the men that I haue alwaies taken you for, you will take so good heed vnto him, that he shall neither rob you of your eares nor eyes.
If there shall be any at all so mad, as to oppose himself against the sages of all Christendom, ⟨p. 91⟩and those, such men as for holiness of life learning and antiquity, are too great to be challenged; I would willingly behold that brazen face, the which when I shall show you, I will leave the rest to your imaginations. In the mean while, I will give you this caveat, that whosoever affirmeth, that a general Council,* duly and orderly kept, and finished, is of no force or authority, the same man seemeth to me, to be one of no judgement, nor of any wit; and not only an ass in divinity, but also void of discretion in worldly policy. If ever the spirit of God illuminated the Church, surely then that time is most fit to send down the holy Ghost, when the religion, perfection, knowledge, wisdom and honour of all Churches dispersed throughout all Christendom, are assembled together into one City: and using all means both divine and humane, whereby the truth may be searched out,2 they call upon the holy Ghost, promisede by God unto them, that by his assistance, they may establish godly laws, for the safe and wise government of the Church. Now let there some petty peart heretical Doctor leap out, let him look up stately, let him scorn and mock, let him lay all shame aside, let him saucily give judgement of his own judges, what game, what pastime shall he make; we have spied out such a one, even Martin fLuther, who saith, that he more esteemeth of the voices of two honest and learned men (ye may well imagine his own, and Philip Melanchthon's) if they come together in Christs name, then he did of all general Councils. O worthy company! We have found out also, another of the same crew, to witg Kemnitius, who hath undertaken to examine the Council of Trent, by his own unreasonable giddy brain: what hath he gained? an evil name: so that he, except he prevent it by recanting, shall be buried for an heretic with Arrius: whereas the Council of Trent, the elder it waxeth, by so much more it shall flourish daily and continually.*
If there shall be any at all so mad, as to oppose himselfe against the sages of all Christendome, ⟨p. 91⟩and those, such men as for holines of life learning and antiquitie, are too great to be challenged; I would willingly behold that brazen face, the which when I shall sh•w you, I will leaue the rest to your imaginations. In the meane while, I will giue you this caueat, that whosoeuer affirmeth, that a generall Councell,* duly and orderly kept, and finished, is of no force or authoritie, the same man seemeth to me, to be one of no iudgement, nor of any wit; and not onely an asse in diuinitie, but also voide of discretion in worldly policie. If euer the spirit of God illuminated the Church, surely then that time is most fit to send downe the holy Ghost, when the religion, perfection, knowledge, wisdome and honour of all Churches dispersed throughout all Christendome, are assembled together into one Citie: and vsing all meanes both diuine and humane, whereby the truth may be searched out,2 they call vpon the holy Ghost, promisede by God vnto them, that by his assistance, they may establish godly lawes, for the safe and wise gouernement of the Church. Now let there some pettie peart hereticall Doctor leape out, let him looke vp stately, let him scorne and mocke, let him lay all shame aside, let him saucily giue iudgement of his owne iudges, what game, what pastime shall he make; we haue spied out such a one, euen Martin fLuther, who saith, that he more esteemeth of the voices of two honest and learned men (ye may well imagine his owne, and Philip Melancthons) if they come together in Christs name, then he did of all generall Councels. O worthy companie! We haue found out also, another of the same crue, to witg Kemnitius, who hath vndertaken to examine the Councell of Trent, by his owne vnreasonable giddie braine: what hath he gained? an euill name: so that he, except he preuent it by recanting, shall be buried for an heriticke with Arrius: whereas the Councell of Trent, the elder it waxeth, by so much more it shall flourish daily and continually.*
*The Councell of Trent was neither a full Councell, nor lawfully held. And so both the Emperor and the French King have judged. Sleidan. anno 1551. lib. 33. The assembly of certain men.The Councell of Trent was neither a full Councell, nor lawfully held. And so both the Emperor and the French King haue iudged. Sleidan. anno 1551. lib. 33. The assemblie of certaine men.
O good Lord, with what diversity of people out of all countries, with what ⟨p. 92⟩choice of Bishops throughout all Christendom, with what excellency of Kings and Common-weals, with what profound divines, with what* devotion, with what lamentations, with what abstinence and fasting, with what flowers of Universities, with what knowledge of strange tongues, with what sharp wits, with what study, with what endless reading, with what store of virtues and exercises was that sacred place replenished? I heard with my own ears Bishops rejoice, being men of great birth and very well learned, of which, one was Anthony Archbishop of Prague (who created me Priest) for that they had been brought up certain years in that famous School; so that they acknowledged no benefit that ever the Emperor Ferdinando bestowed on them (to whom otherwise also they thought themselves no little beholding) to be more princely and bountiful, then this was, that by him being sent in Embassage from Pannonia, they sate in the Council of Trent, together with the rest of the Fathers there present. This thing the Emperor full well perceived, who greeted them in this sort at their return: We have maintained you in an exceeding good School, why made the adversaries no hast hither, being promised to go and come safe; that they might openly have confuted them, against whom they croak like Toads out of their holes. They have broken promise (say they) with Huss and Hierome, who? the heads of the Council of Constance. That is a lye:2 for they made them no promise. And yet Huss had not been put to death; if that he, false and treacherous villain as he was, not only by an escape, which the Emperor Sigismundus had forbidden him upon pain of death; and being taken, was brought back again: but also by* breaking certain covenants which he had made in writing with the Emperor had not lost the benefit of that safe conduct: Huss was hedged in for his hasty knavery; for whereas at his country in Bohem, he had stirred up barbarous tumults, and was therefore commanded to appear before the general ⟨p. 93⟩Council at Constance, he contemned the prerogative of the Council, and made suite for a safe conduct to the Emperor. The* Emperor sealed him one; all Christendom, which is greater then the Emperor, unsealed it again: the arch heretic would not recant, and therefore he was burnt:5
O good Lord, with what diuersitie of people out of all countries, with what ⟨p. 92⟩choice of Bishops throughout all Christendome, with what excellencie of Kings and Common-weales, with what profound diuines, with what* deuotion, with what lamentations, with what abstinence and fasting, with what flowers of Ʋniuersities, with what knowledge of strange tongues, with what sharpe wits, with what studie, with what endlesse reading, with what store of vertues and exercises was that sacred place replenished? I heard with my owne eares Bishops reioyce, being men of great birth and very well learned, of which, one was Anthony Archbishop of Prage (who created me Priest) for that they had been brought vp certaine yeeres in that famous Schoole; so that they acknowledged no benefite that euer the Emperour Ferdinando bestowed on them (to whom otherwise also they thought themselues no little beholding) to be more princely and bountifull, then this was, that by him being sent in Embassage from Pannonia, they sate in the Councell of Trent, together with the rest of the Fathers there present. This thing the Emperour full well perceiued, who greeted them in this sort at their returne: We haue maintained you in an exceeding good Schoole, why made the aduersaries no hast hither, being promised to goe and come safe; that they might openly haue confuted them, against whom they croke like Toads out of their hoales. They haue broken promise (say they) with Husse and Hierome, who? the heads of the Councell of Constance. That is a lye:2 for they made them no promise. And yet Husse had not been put to death; if that he, false and treacherous villaine as he was, not only by an escape, which the Emperour Sigismundus had forbidden him vpon paine of death; and being taken, was brought backe againe: but also by* breaking certaine couenants which he had made in writing with the Emperor had not lost the benefit of that safe conduct: Husse was hedged in for his hastie knauerie; for whereas at his countrie in Bohem, he had stirred vp barbarous tumults, and was therfore commanded to appeare before the generall ⟨p. 93⟩Councel at Constance, he contemned the prerogatiue of the Councell, and made suite for a safe conduct to the Emperor. The* Emperour sealed him one; all Christendome, which is greater then the Emperour, vnsealed it again: the arch heretike would not recant, and therfore he was burnt:
*Two Bishops were taken in adultery and put to death. Illyric.Two Bishops were taken in adulterie and put to death. Illyric.
As for Hierome of Prague, he came privately without any safe conduct at all to the Council of Constance, and being apprehended did appear, and had liberty to say what he could, and was very courteously entreated, and suffered to go abroad at his pleasure. He was cured of his disease, and abjured his heresy, he fell again, and therefore was burnt. But wherefore do they so often inculcate and call to memory, this one example amongst six hundred?1 Let them peruse their chronicles: Martin Luther, one hated both of God and man, personally appeared at Augusta before the Cardinal Caietane, and did he not belch forth of his venomous gorge, what poisoned speeches he could, and at length being protected with the Emperor Maximilian's safe conduct, went he not safe away?2 The same Martin Luther being sent for, to come to Worms, though he had both the Emperor, and almost all the Princes of the Empire his Enemies, did he not upon the Emperors word come and go safe? Finally, did not the ring-leaders of the Lutherans and Zwinglians in the presence of Charles the fifth, the open enemy to all heretics, Conqueror, and sovereign, upon a truce granted them, exhibit at an assembly at Augusta,3 the confession of their faith, which before they had so often altered, and went they not without hurt away? Likewise the council of Trent provided for the adversary most large warrants to come and go safe, but he would not use the same. He beasteth forsooth of himself in corners, where when he can utter three greek words, he may seem to be a great learned man: He flies from the light, which would make a slender scholar to be accounted learned, and so advance him to seats of great dignity. Let them purchase for ⟨p. 94⟩us English Catholics, if they love their souls health,* such a safe conduct in writing: we will not allege Huss for our excuse, but make our speedy repair to the court, putting our whole trust in the Queens Majesties word. But that I may return thither from whence I digressed: All general Councils are on my side, the first, the last, the rest; these shall be my weapons. Let the adversary expect, a well headed dart, which he shall never be able to shake off. God grant that Satan in him may be quite overthrown, and Christ revined.
As for Hierome of Prage, he came priuately without any safe conduct at all to the Councell of Constance, and being apprehended did appeare, and had libertie to say what he could, and was verie curteously intreated, and suffered to goe abroad at his pleasure. Hee was cured of his disease, and abiured his heresie, hee fell againe, and therefore was burnt. But wherefore do they so often inculcate and call to memorie, this one example amongst sixe hundred?1 Let them peruse their chronicles: Martin Luther, one hated both of God and man, personallie appeared at Augusta before the Cardinall Caietane, and did he not belche forth of his venemouse gorge, what poysoned speeches he could, and at length being protected with the Emperour Maximilians safe conduct, went he not safe away?2 The same Martin Luther being sent for, to come to Wormes, though hee had both the Emperour, and almost all the Princes of the Empire his Enemies, did hee not vpon the Emperours word come and goe safe? Finally, did not the ring-leaders of the Lutherans and Zuinglians in the presence of Charles the fifth, the open enemie to all heretikes, Conqueror, and soueraigne, vpon a truce graunted them, exhibit at an assemblie at Augusta,3 the confession of their faith, which before they had so often altered, and went they not without hurt away? Likewise the councell of Trent prouided for the aduersarie most large warrants to come and goe safe, but he would not vse the same. He beasteth forsooth of himselfe in corners, where when he can vtter three greeke words, he may seeme to bee a great learned man: He flies from the light, which would make a slender scholler to bee accounted learned, and so aduance him to seates of great dignitie. Let them purchase for ⟨p. 94⟩vs English Catholikes, if they loue their soules health,* such a safe conduct in writing: wee will not alleadge Husse for our excuse, but make our speedie repaire to the court, putting our whole trust in the Queenes Maiesties word. But that I may returne thither from whence I digressed: All generall Councels are on my side, the first, the last, the rest; these shalbe my weapons. Let the aduersarie expect, a well headed dart, which he shall neuer be able to shake off. God graunt that Satan in him may be quite ouerthrowne, and Christ reuined.
THE next place is concerning Councils, not much differing from the former; for what is a Council but the flower, and as it were a little model of the whole Church? And therefore whatsoever may be said of Coū cels, it appertaineth to the nature of the Church; but when as these for more plainness sake, are sometimes distinguished, I do easily permit you to propound them distinctly.a Now the name of Councils is honourable, their credit singular, and their authority of ⟨p. 95⟩great esteem, and you do never more insolently brag, then in this place: for when you do but name Councils, you think that you have sufficiently confuted your adversaries, and promise unto your self assured victory. Neither will I go about to extenuate the dignity of Councils, wondering thatb Nazianzene, 3should so unjustly judge, and so injuriously write of them. For he saith, that he had deliberated with himself and fully resolved to avoid Episcopal Convocations, because he had never seen a good issue of any Synod. Which howsoever it hath bin true of many, which by reason of the ambition, and busy meddling of some, have not taken away ancient controversies, but rather have sowed the seed of new contentions: yet many Councils have been approved and commended by their most wished event. Whereas therefore you appeal to Councils, we will follow you in many, & in their most weighty censures and decrees: for in all neither do you your selves judge it necessary. But let us now hear you discoursing concerning Councils.
THE next place is concerning Councels, not much differing from the former; for what is a Councell but the flower, and as it were a little modell of the whole Church? And therefore whatsoeuer may be said of Coū cels, it appertaineth to the nature of the Church; but when as these for more plainnes sake, are sometimes distinguished, I doe easily permit you to propound them distinctly.a Now the name of Councels is honorable, their credit singular, and their authority of ⟨p. 95⟩great esteeme, and you doe neuer more insolently bragge, then in this place: for when you doe but name Councels, you thinke that you haue sufficiently confuted your aduersaries, and promise vnto your selfe assured victory. Neither will I go about to extenuate the dignity of Councels, wōdering thatb Nazianzene, 3should so vniustly iudge, and so iniuriously write of them. For he saith, that he had deliberated with himselfe and fully resolued to auoid Episcopall Conuocations, because he had neuer seene a good issue of any Synode. Which howsoeuer it hath bin true of many, which by reason of the ambition, and busie medling of some, haue not taken away auncient controuersies, but rather haue sowed the seed of new contentions: yet many Councels haue been approued and commended by their most wished euent. Whereas therefore you appeale to Councels, we will follow you in many, & in their most weighty censures and decrees: for in all neither do you your selues iudge it necessary. But let vs now heare you discoursing concerning Councels.
aDVR. But you coutemne the authority of the holy Ghost, speaking by Councels, which all the ancient Fathers have had in singular respect. WHIT. pag. 290. You accuse us falsely, for howsoever we assent not with you, who make them shoulder the Scriptures with equal authority; because we know that both they might, and also have grossly erred in many things, as the Fathers have confessed, and ye your selves cannot deny; yet wherein they are consonant with the Scriptures, we embrace their authority▪ and have them in singular respect, and estination. And in preferring the Scripture before them, we follow but the example of the Fathers. August. de Baptis. contra Donat. lib. 2. cap. 3. idem contra Maxim. lib. 3▪ cap. 14. & de unitat. Eccle. cap. 16. Hieron. in Galatas. Ambros. Epist. 32.DVR. But you coutemne the authority of the holy Ghost, speaking by Councels, which al the auncient Fathers haue had in singular respect. WHIT. pag. 290. You accuse vs falsely, for howsoeuer we assent not with you, who make them shoulder the Scriptures with equall authority; because we know that both they might, and also haue grossely erred in many things, as the Fathers haue confessed, and yee your selues cannot deny; yet wherein they are consonant with the Scriptures, we embrace their authority▪ and haue them in singular respect, and estination. And in preferring the Scripture before them, we follow but the example of the Fathers. August. de Baptis. contra Donat. lib. 2. cap. 3. idem contra Maxim. lib. 3▪ cap. 14. & de vnitat. Eccle. cap. 16. Hieron. in Galatas. Ambros. Epist. 32.
bDVR. Nazianzene d•d not judge inturiously nor writeth bitterly of Councels, as you suppose; but only affirmed that the fraud and malice of the heretics of those times, hindered the assembling of lawful Councels. WHIT. pag. 264. It seemeth you have not read his Epistle, or but very sle•gtly, •eeing he therein plainly set•eth down two reasons why he absented himself from the Councell, when he was called: f••st the weakness of his body, and secondly, his judgment concerning Councels: which was, that he thought such assemblies were to be avoided, because he had seen no good of any Synod, and that hereby occasions of evils were rather increased then taken away. DVR. Yea but he hath shened his contrary judgment writing his Cledonius. WHIT. Nothing less: but only he affirmeth that he would subscribe to the Apollinarian heretics, if they could prove that they were received of the west Councell; which he knew they could not.
A weighty question, (say you) concerning lawful cere•••ies, was cleared in a Council of the Apostles and Fld•rs assembled together. The children believed their Parents, and the Sheep their Shepherd, commanding in this form of speech; It bath pleased the holy Ghost and us. Where you make mention of a Council most excellent, and above all exceptions: in which nothing was done rashly, perversely, and factiously (as sometimes in other Councils ⟨p. 96⟩it hath been accustomed) but all things divinely, and by the authority of the holy Ghost himself. and therefore if we did not believe this Council, we were unworthy of the name, either of children or of sheep. This Council resolved that important question concerning ceremonies, and freed the necks of Christians from that most grievous yoke of Mosaical rites: whereby the greater cause of grief is offered us by you, who have imposed upon the Church, contrary to the express commandment of this Council, another yoke much more intolerable, then that of Moses. For this is clear and manifest, that the ceremonies brought into the Church by you, and imposed upon the consciences of men, are twice as many, as those which in time past Moses by Gods express commandment enjoined unto the people of Israel.1 And this is that of whichc Augustine long agone complained, namely that by the multitudes of ceremonies, the state of Christians, was become worse then the state of the Jews themselves, which if Augustine spake of the ceremonies of his time, how much more would he have thus complained, had he seen the great multitudes, which were afterwards added to them. But if the Apostles and Elders according to the meaning & judgment of the holy Ghost, did determine that those ceremonies which the Lord himself had ordained, were to be abolished, how intolerable is your boldness, who contrary to the decree ⟨p. 97⟩of this spirit, and Council have obtruded, upon Christians your innumerable traditions and needles ceremonies. Did the Lord therefore abolish his own ceremonies, that he might establish yours? did he abroga•• a few, that he might bring in a multitude? did he ease us of lighter, that he might impose heavier. Whereby it appeareth that the divine institution of this Council, which, as it was before all other in time, so above all other in excellency, is most wickedly by you violated.
A waighty question, (say you) concerning lawfull cere•••ies, was cleared in a Councell of the Apostles and Fld•rs assembled together. The children beleeued their Parents, and the Sheepe their Sheph•ard, commaunding in this forme of speech; It bath pleased the holy Ghost and vs. Where you make mention of a Councell most excellent, and aboue all exceptions: in which nothing was done rashly, peruersely, and factiously (as sometimes in other Councels ⟨p. 96⟩it hath been accustomed) but al things diuinely, and by the authority of the holy Ghost himself. and therfore if we did not beleeue this Councell, we were vnworthy of the name, either of children or of sheep. This Councel resolued that important question concerning ceremonies, and freed the neckes of Christians from that most grieuous yoke of Mosaicall rites: whereby the greater cause of griefe is offered vs by you, who haue imposed vpon the Church, contrarie to the expresse commandement of this Councell, another yoke much more intolerable, then that of Moses. For this is cleare and manifest, that the ceremonies brought into the Church by you, and imposed vpon the consciences of men, are twice as many, as those which in time past Moses by Gods expresse commaundement inioyned vnto the people of Israell.1 And this is that of whichc Augustine long agone complained, namely that by the multitudes of ceremonies, the state of Christians, was become worse then the state of the Iewes themselues, which if Augustine spake of the ceremonies of his time, how much more would he haue thus complained, had he seene the great multitudes, which were afterwards added to them. But if the Apostles and Elders according to the meaning & iudgment of the holy Ghost, did determine that those ceremonies which the Lord himselfe had ordeined, were to be abolished, how intolerable is your boldnes, who contrary to the decree ⟨p. 97⟩of this spirit, and Councell haue obtruded, vpon Christians your innumerable traditions and needles ceremonies. Did the Lord therfore abolish his owne ceremonies, that he might establish yours? did he abroga•• a few, that he might bring in a multitude? did he ease vs of lighter, that he might impose heauier. Whereby it appeareth that the diuine institution of this Councel, which, as it was before all other in time, so aboue all other in excellency, is most wickedly by you violated.
1August. ad Januar.August. ad Ianuar.
cDVR. Angustine when he writ this, did not after your manner carp at Ecclesiastical ceremonies, but showeth that be would not have them instituted at every mans pleasure. For in his first Epistle to Januariu• he thus writeth. If the whole Church use any of these, it i• insolent madness to dispute, whether such a thing is to be done or no? WHIT. pag. 296. Augustine condemneth the multitude of ceremonies in his time, and would have us rest contented with those few ceremonies, which are commended unto us in the Scriptures. Ad Januar. Epist. 118. cap. 1. & Epist. 119.19. His words which you allege, I willingly embrace; for we use and esteem those ceremonies, which all Churches have received as necessary for order and comeliness. But of this kind yours are not, neither can you wrest those speeches concerning the ceremonies of the Church to approve your Traditions: seeing the Church of Rome long since ceased to be the Church of Christ.DVR. Angustine vvhen he vvrit this, did not after your manner carpe at Ecclesiasticall ceremonies, but shevveth that be vvould not haue them instituted at euery mans pleasure. For in his first Epistle to Ianuariu• he thus vvriteth. If the vvhole Church vse any of these, it i• insolent madnes to dispute, vvhether such a thing is to be done or no? WHIT. pag. 296. Augustine condemneth the multitude of ceremonies in his time, and vvould haue vs rest contented vvith those few ceremonies, vvhich are commended vnto vs in the Scriptures. Ad Ianuar. Epist. 118. cap. 1. & Epist. 119.19. His vvords vvhich you alleage, I vvillinglie embrace; for vve vse and esteeme those ceremonies, vvhich all Churches haue receiued as necessary for order and comelinesse. But of this kind yours are not, neither can you vvrest those speeches concerning the ceremonies of the Church to approue your Traditions: seeing the Church of Rome long since ceased to be the Church of Christ.
Pope must be iudge ouer the Councels. So in the conclusion, the whole interpretation of holy Scriptures is transferred to the Pope, and must be fetched out of his brest:
.
cDVR. You reprove us, that we give the interpretation of the Scriptures to Bishops: they verily ought to deliver the true sense they have received from their predecessors to the people. WHIT. pag. 144. S. Paul alloweth all Ministers of the Gospel this power to interpret the Scriptures, 1. Cor. 14.29.30. who ought aswell to deliver the true sense, as Bishops. Besides, you must know that the knowledge of t•• Scriptures and the gifts of the spirit are not hereditary, or to be delivered from hand to hand.DVR. You reprooue vs, that vvee giue the interpretation of the Scriptures to Bishops: they verily ought to deliver the true sense they haue receiued from their predecessors to the people. WHIT. pag. 144. S. Paul alloweth all Ministers of the Gospell this power to interpret the Scriptures, 1. Cor. 14.29.30. who ought aswell to deliuer the true sense, as Bishops. Besides, you must know that the knowledge of t•• Scriptures and the gifts of the spirit are not hereditarie, or to be deliuered from hand to hand.
dDVR. Great and many controversies have been decided by Councels. WHIT. pag. 145. It followeth not hereupon, that the interpreting of the Scriptures is to be sought for of them; or if good Councels by the true interpretation of the Scriptures have taken away some errors and heresies; that therefore all interpretation is theirs, or that we must look for the same from impious and unlearned Councels.DVR. Great and many controuersies haue been decided by Councels. WHIT. pag. 145. It followeth not hereupon, that the interpreting of the Scriptures is to be sought for of thē; or if good Councels by the true interpretation of the Scriptures haue taken away some errors and heresies; that there•ore all interpretation is theirs, or that we must looke for the same from imp•ous and vnlearned Councels.
eDVR. And why not? seeing no Councell is of any authority, which was not confirmed by the Pope? WHIT. pag. 146. This is false: for the sixth African Councell, and the Calcedon Councell have their authority without him. And Emperors, Patriarchs, and Bishops have confinued Councels. And the Councell of Constantinople by letters desired the confirmation of the decrees from Theodosius the Emperor. DVR.. God set over the Jews one High Priest. Deut. 17.11. Then would Christ never neglect his Spouse, but leave her a chief judge upon the earth. WHIT. pag. 151. Yet that judge was to determine according to the Law; Deut. 17.11. But the Pope maketh interpretations, not out of the word written, but out of his own brain. Again it followeth not, if over one little nation God set one chief judge, Christ must set but one over the whole world. Besides the Jewish judge was a type of Christ. Lastly, it followeth not that Chri•• hath left his Church no judge; i• he have not le•t it one only; for every Church ha•h her Pastor to teach her, and to determine questions in her.DVR. And why not? seeing no Councell is of any authoritie, which was not confirmed by the Pope? WHIT. pag. 146. This is false: for the sixt African Councell, and the Calcedon Councell haue their authority without him. And Emperors, Patria•kes, and Bishops haue confinued Councels. And the Councell of Constantinople by letters desired the confirmation of the decrees from Theodosius the Emperor. DVR.. God set ouer the Iewes one High Priest. Deut. 17.11. Then would Christ neuer neglect his Spouse, but leaue her a chiefe iudge vpon the earth. WHIT. pag. 151. Yet that iudge was to determine according to the Law; Deut. 17.11. But the Pope maketh interpretations, not out of the word written, but out of his owne braine. Againe it followeth not, if ouer one little nation God set one chiefe iudge, Christ must set but one ouer the whole world. Besides the Iewish iudge was a type of Christ. Lastly, it followeth not that Chri•• hath left his Church no iudge; i• he haue not le•t it one only; for euery Church ha•h her Pastor to teach her, and to d••ermine questions in her.
DV•. The Fathers and Antiquity haue euer made these foure senses of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 163. To faine such foure senses in euery sentence differeth not much from a learned kind of madnes. Allegories I confesse many are in the Scriptures, but such as the holy Ghost himselfe hath made; but to make other Allegories, when the words may be vnderstood without a Trope, or when the Grammaticall sense is not absurd and repugnant to sound doctrine, I thinke is too great bouldnesse and temerity. A Tropologicall sense is not a new sense differing from the Grammaticall, but one •s it were with it. Finally, if the Fathers as men haue erred, must we needs follow their errors? The Fathers reiected the errors and false interpretations of their predecessors, why may not we deale so with them?
John 6.53
. yea all Christians communicate of Christ alike, as well such as come to the supper, as they who cannot partake in it: And that he was present to the Fathers it is proued.
. was their blessing without profit, because they changed not their natures and substance? Besides to blesse is nothing else but to giue thankes, as Luke hath it, which was done by words before, not by those, This is my body.
mDV•. This is neither here, nor any where else to be found in the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 173. Ma•ke well. This is my covenant which you shall keep, that every manchild be circumcised: what I pray you is, This, but that every manchild be circumcised, and •o you have it in this place directly: but see, Gen. 17.13. My covenant shall be in your flesh, what is this but circumcision? read Act. 7.8. DVR. This, signifieth not circumcision, but agreement or covenant betwixt God a•d Abraham touching circumcision. WHIT. That agreement, was it the covenant or not? •f it was, then see what a goodly sentence you have made, This my covenant is my covenant. But if it was not: thē you must needs acknowledge a Metonymy; that is, that the name of th• thing is given to the sign, howsoever then it must be understood by a figure.DV•. This is neither heere, nor any where else to be found in the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 173. Ma•ke well. This is my couenant which you shall keepe, that euery manchild be circumcised: what I pray you is, This, but that euery manchild be circumcised, and •o you haue it in this place directly: but see, Gen. 17.13. My couenant shall be in your flesh, what is this but circumcision? reade Act. 7.8. DVR. This, signifieth not circumcision, but agreement or couenant betwixt God a•d Abraham touching circumcision. WHIT. That agreemen•, was it the couenant or not? •f it was, then see what a goodly sentence you haue made, This my couenant is my couenant. But if it was not: thē you must needs acknowledge a Me••nymy; that is, that the name of th• thing is giuen to the signe, howsoeuer then it must be vnderstood by a figure.
nDVR. These words are not to be found there. WHIT. pag. 174. Observe the words. Thus shall you eat it, for it is the Lords Passover. That which was to be eaten is called the Lords Passover. Now they we•e commanded to eat the Lamb, read Exod 12. verse 27.DVR. These words are not to be found there. WHIT. pag. 174. Obserue the words. Thus shall you eate it, for it is the Lords Passouer. That which was to be eaten is called the Lords Passeouer. Now they we•e cōmanded to eate the Lambe, reade Exod 12. ve•se 27.
•
DVR. Augustine speaketh of thes• miracles which are made of a bodily substanc•, and so are sensible: novv no such thing is seene in the Eucharist. WHIT. pag. 191. But if there were a true miracle, it would be sensible, and haue the witnesse of the senses, as all oth•r miracles of the Scriptures haue. For thing• that are hid (saith Augustine) are not miracles. He writ three bookes of the miracles of the Scriptures, in which he hath not spoken one word of this miracle. Therefore he knew not the Popish Transubstantiation.
rDVR. Not we, but the Scripture, the Fathers, and reason it self doth affirm it, but specially S. Paul. 1. Cor. 11.27. Whosoever eateth this bread. WHIT. pag▪ 195. None of these affirm it, and least of all S. Paul; for he saith not, whosoever eateth the body of Christ, but whosoever eateth this bread.DVR. Not vve, but the Scripture, the Fathers, and reason it selfe doth affirme it, but speciallie S. Paul. 1. Cor. 11.27. Whosoeuer eateth this bread. WHIT. pag▪ 195. None of these affirme it, and least of all S. Paul; for he saith not, vvhosoeuer eateth the body of Christ, but vvhosoeuer eateth this bread.
or to forbid any duty tending to the profit or good of others, it is a figuratiue speech; vnlesse, saith Christ, you eate the flesh of the Son of man, and drinke his blood, you haue no life in you: It seemeth to inioyne an
tDVR Augustine signifieth the Sacrament by the name of figure. WHIT pag 204. It is true, Christ gave the Sacrament to his disciples▪ but Augustine useth not the word Sacrament, but figure: to show that as no figure or sign is the thing whereof it is a fi u•e: so the bread is not properly the body, nor the w•ne the blood of Christ.DVR Augustine signifieth the Sacramēt by the name of figure. WHIT pag 204. It is true, Christ gaue the Sacramēt to his di•ci•les▪ but Augustine vseth not the word Sacrament, but figure: to shew that as no figu•e or signe is the thing wherof it is a fi u•e: so the bread is not properly the body, nor the w•ne the blood of Christ.
uDVR Augustine disputeth in this p•ace against the Manichees, carping at Moses words. The blood is the soul of the beast. And saith, it is so spoke, as the Sacrament of the body of Christ is called his body, the blood is called the soul, because it is as the sign of the soul, which lieth hid in the blood, as the Sacramet is the sign of the body of Christ, which is contained in it WH T pag. 206. Nay I infer the contrary as the soul is not the blood, when it is o•• of the veins, & may be eaten; so Christ is not in the Sacrament. And as the blood is the sign of the soul, which is not in it: so is the Sacrament of the body which is not contained in it.DVR Augustine disputeth in this p•ace against the Ma••chees, carp•ng at Moses vvords. The blood is the soule of the beast. And saith, it is so spoke, as the Sacramēt of the body of Christ is called his body, the blood is called the soule, because it is as the signe of the soule, which lieth hid in the blood, as the Sacramet is the signe of the body of Christ, vvhich is conteined in it WH T pag. 206. Nay I infer the cōtrary as the soule is not the blood, whē it is o•• of the vaines, & may be eaten; so Christ is not in the Sacrament. And as the blood is the signe of the soule, which is not in it: so is the Sacrament of the bodie which is not conteined in it.
6Contra. Adimant. cap. 12.
7De doctr. Christ. lib. 3. cap. 16.
*DVR Augustine did not think that it was an heinous thing, to eat the flesh of Christ, but to cate […] (as the Capernites thought) that is, torn and rent in pieces. WHIT. pag. 209. You answer somewhat as touching the fact, but nothing for the figure. But Augustine saith there is a figure, which cannot be, if the flesh of Christ be either eaten, as you say, whole, or chopped in pieces, as the Capernites affirm. And if it be an horrible fact to eat the small parts of Christs bo•ie, is it not a more beastly & bloody thing to devour the whole body of Christ at one mor•el•? DVR. It is no more heinous for a Christian to eat the flesh of Christ whole, then it was for the blessed Virgin to conceive & to nourish it in her womb. WHIT. pag. 211. What is this, but as if you had said, It is no heinous thing to conceive and bring forth an Infant: Therefore it is none to devour it after it is borne.DVR Augustine did not thinke that it vvas an heynous thing, to eate the flesh of Christ, but to cate 〈…〉 (as the Capernites thought) that is, torne and rent in peeces. WHIT. pag. 209. You answere somewhat as touching the fact, but nothing for the figure. But Augustine saith there is a figure, which cannot be, if the flesh of Christ be either eaten, as you say, whole, or chopt in peeces, as the Capernites affirme. And if it be an horrible fact to eate the smale parts of Christs bo•ie, is it not a more beastly & bloody thing to deuoure the whole body of Christ at one mor•el•? DVR. It is no more heynous for a Christian to eate the flesh of Christ whole, then it was for the blessed Virgin to conceiue & to nourish it in her wombe. WHIT. pag. 211. What is this, but as if you had said, It is no heynous thing to conceiue and bring forth an Infant: Therfore it is none to deuoure it after it is borne.
*
Particular Churches are visible: therefore the Catholic Church is visible.Particular Churches are visible: therefore the Catholik Church is visible.
cDVR. Why say you then that your Church lay hid for so many years together? WHIT. pag. 260. Our Church did never lie so hid, but it was discerned by your Pope, unless for so many years he persecuted shadows.DVR. Why say you then that your Church lay hid for so many yeares together? WHIT. pag. 260. Our Church did neuer lie so hid, but it vvas discerned by your Pope, vnlesse for so many yeares he persecuted shadovves.
. Icrem. 31.31. Eze•. 37.26. WHIT. pag. 264. As if the Church of Jerusalem was not the Church of Christ? what then happened unto it, which may not befall my others? And for the Prophesies you recier, they belong to the company of the elect, and not to your popish Church to which the Lord never promised any such thing. Christ verily will never endure that his Church should be abolished or perish: but it is one thing for it to perish, and another to lye hid for a time, and not to be seen; he hath promised it shall ever be preserved, not that it shall ever be visible and glorious. DVR Christ hath promised to be with his Church to the end of the world. WHIT. pag. 265. Will it therefore follow that his Church shall never be hid, nor shut up in a few? nothing less: for he hath promised that wheresoever two or three are gathered together in his name, he will be in the middest of them.
DVR. That which befell the Synagogue of Hierusal•••, cannot befall to the Church of Christ, whieth the Prophets haue plainly foretold should neuer perish. Isay. 19.21. Icrem. 31.31. Eze•. 37.26. WHIT. pag. 264. As if the Church of Hierusalem was not the Church of Christ? what then happened vnto it, which may not befall my others? And for the Prophesies you recier, they belong to the company of the elect, and not to your popish Church to which the Lord neuer promised any such thing. Christ verily will neuer endure that his Church should be abolished or perish: but it is one thing for it to perish, and another to lye hid for a time, and not to bee seene; he hath promised it shall euer be preserued, not that it shall euer be visible and glorious. DVR Christ hath promised to be with his Church to the end of the world. WHIT. pag. 265. Will it therefore follow that his Church shall neuer be hid, nor shut vp in a few? nothing lesse: for hee hath promised that wheresoeuer two or three are gathered together in his name, he will be in the middest of them.
and Sacraments which are commaunded by Christ.
••••
••••
⟨p. 86⟩
by incestuous marriage de••oured 〈…〉 Nom•••, dedicated to God by solemne vow.
DVR. Tell me then from whom, and in what age any doctrine of our profession was brought into the Church. WHIT. pag. 277. The motion of the Sunne is so very swift, that we may see it hath moued, though we cannot discerne the mouing of it: so such is the mystery of your iniquity that I well perceiue by the Scriptures your doctrines are not Apostolicall; but the time when, and the manner how they were brought in, is not much to our purpose. And it were too long to tell all, yet heare some, Your Romish Bishop a long time together was but equall to other Bishops th•ugh much was giuen to him for the excellency of that Church. After the Christian world was diuided into foure Prouinces, when he became the chiefe of the Patriarkes, after this he began to challenge authority ouer other Churches, and for that purpose counterfeited the Councell of Nice: but he was repressed by the African Councell. Then Gregory the great, greatly inueyed against Iohn of Constantinople, because he sought the name of vniuersall Bishop, and for that ambition called him the forerunner of Antichrist. Lastly, Boniface the eight with a great summe obtained that honor of Phocas the Parricide. And since that hee grew to that height, that hee made not only Churches and Kings, but the Christian Emperour himselfe to kisse his feete. But see another example. Time was when there were no images in Churches: As that of Epiphanius proueth, who rent a vaile in peeces, because there was in it an image of Christ or of some Saint. But in time they were receiued into the Church, but no honor giuen them: yet after that, good Bishops brake them and cast them out againe; as Gregory writeth that Serenus the Bishop of Massilia did, whom he thus checketh for it. In that you forbad them to be worshipped, wee commend you, but that you brake them, we reprehend you. Gregor. regist. lib. 7. Epist. 9. Lastly the second Nicene Councell decreed, that they were not to be broken, yea that they were religiously to be worshipped. And thus hath it succeeded in other things, as S. Paul did foretell•e saying; The mysterie of iniquitie doth alreadie worke. 2. Thess. 2.7.
oDVR. What can be spoken or imagined more wicked and impious. WHIT. pag. 278. Then prophesied S. Paul impiously, when he did so •••ell of a departing, and that Antichrist should sit in the Temple of God. Is this any other then that the mystery of iniquity should spread it self over the Church?DVR. VVhat can be spoken or imagined more wicked and impious. WHIT. pag. 278. Then prophesied S. Paul impiously, when he did so •••ell of a departing, and that Antichrist should sit in the Temple of God. Is this any other then that the mysterie of iniquitie should spread it selfe ouer the Church?
pDVR. This is very false, for in the Florentine Councell the Emperor Paleolus, together with the Grecians and Armenians freely acknowledged the Pope to be the Vicar of Christ, and embraced the Roman faith, yea and at this day they dissent from us in few things, as Icremy the Patriarch of Constantinople hath plainly written. WHIT pag. 279. Why are they then of you accounted Schismatics, or why obey they not the Pope? why came they not to the Councell of Trent? the Pope by all means hath sought to have them subject to him, but they still contemn him to his no small grief. It is true, the Emperor, the Patriarch, and a multitude of Bishops came to the Florentine Councel. They agreed with thē in many things, •••hers they dissented; your Transubstantiation they utterly renounced. At that time Jesaphus their Patriarch suddenly died. Eugenius the Pope instantly urged a new election. They denied to make any till they came to Constantinople. See you not how well they agree? I have a book of yours, not of Jeremies, neither vvill a small thing make me believe it is his: for both the Grecian•, and particularly he, hath giver great approbation of our Churches, as we find it in his works published both in Greek and Latin.DVR. This is very false, for in the Florētine Councell the Emperour Paleolus, together with the Grecians and Armenians freely acknowledged the Pope to be the Vicar of Christ, and imbraced the Romane faith, yea and at this day they dissent from vs in few things, as Icremy the Patriarke of Constantinople hath plainly written. WHIT pag. 279. Why are they then of you accounted Schismatickes, or vvhy obey they not the Pope? why came they not to the Councell of Trent? the Pope by al meanes hath sought to haue thē subiect to him, but they stil cō temne him to his no small griefe. It is true, the Emperour, the Patriarke, and a multitude of Bishops came to the Florētine Coūcel. They agreed vvith thē in many things, •••hers they dissented; your Trāsubstantiation they vtterly renoūced. At that time Iesaphus their Patriarke suddenly died. Eugenius the Pope instantly vrged a nevv election. They denied to make any till they came to Constantinople. See you not hovv vvell they agree? I haue a booke of yours, not of Ieremies, neither vvill a small thing make me beleeue it is his: for both the Grecian•, and particularly he, hath giuer great approbation of our Churches, as vve find it in his vvorkes published both in Greeke and Latin.
qDVR. But you go against S. Paul, who directly denounced damnation to those who will marry, having broken their first saith; which is understood by all the Fathers of violating the vow of single life by incestuous marriages. WHIT. pag. 281. But how prove you that the Apostle understandeth by that faith, the vow of virginity? Nay the scope of the place showeth us the contrary, for he forbiddeth that younger widows, whom he persuadeth to marry, should be taken into that office; only such as were threescore years old, who may well abstain from marriages & follow this calling. Now if they be not of this age, he showeth what may be feared of them namely lest that rather then they should not many, they would wa• wa••on against Christ, and break their first faith, which is not their vow, but the profession of Christian religion, which such light buswives would easily co•••••, that they might enjoy their pleasures. And that this is his meaning the 1•. verse showeth: For certain are already turned back after Satan; showing what some had done, he admonisheth them to be wary lest others should do the like. And as for the Fathers, if they did also expound these words, (as indeed they do not) yet the argument is very weak in divinity: The Fathers have thus expounded it, therefore the exposition is true.DVR. But you goe against S. Paul, who directly denounced damnation to those who will marry, hauing broken their first saith; which is vnderstood by all the Fathers of violating the vow of single life by incestuous marriages. WHIT. pag. 281. But how proue you that the Apostle vnderstādeth by that faith, the vow of virginity? Nay the scope of the place sheweth vs the contrary, for he forbiddeth that younger widdowes, whom he perswadeth to marry, should be taken into that office; only such as were threescore yeares old, who may well abstaine from marriages & follow this calling. Now if they be not of this age, he sheweth what may be feared of them namely lest that rather then they should not many, they would wa• wa••on against Christ, and breake their first faith, which is not their vow, but the profession of Christian religion, which such light buswiues would easily co•••••, that they might inioy their pleasures. And that this is his meaning the 1•. verse sheweth: For certeine are already turned backe after Satan; shewing what some had done, he admonisheth them to be wary lest others should do the like. And as for the Fathers, if they did also expound these words, (as indeed they doe not) yet the argument is very weake in diuinity: The Fathers haue thus expounded it, therefore the exposition is true.
. As for the Creeds you mention, we believe them in this point aswell as you. But tell us; this one Catholic Church what is it? If you restrain the name to the visible Church; first, you exclude both that in heaven of the Saints, and that which shall be of these which a•e unborn, and yet do belong to the Catholic Church: secondly you place faith in the sense, which the Apostle saith is of things which are not seen,
. As for that Catholic Church which we believe, it is the company of all the elect, even as many as have been from the beginning of the world, and shall be to the end; therefore it is called the Apostolic and holy Church, the communion of Saints. And to this communion belong no profane and wicked men, no hypocrites; because they have no fellowship with Christ. For the holy Church is the mystical body of Christ, of which body no member can at any time perish.
DVR. I beleeue only one Catholike Church, as the Apostles and Nicene Creed hath taught me, which conteineth both the elect, and as many as professe true religion. Now you teach me to beleeue two Churches. WHIT. pag. 286. This distinction taketh not away the vnity of the Church, no more then when the Church is said to be m•••an and u••• phant, vniuersall and particular. For the visible and ••uisible Church make but one: called visible, for the outward policy or order of it, which is seene and discerned; inuis•ble because Gods election and the electes faith is not to be seene with eies. And this distinction we haue, Esay. 1.9. Matth. 22.14. As for the Creedes you mention, we beleeue them in this point aswell as you. But tell vs; this one Catholike Church what is it? If you restraine the name to the visible Church; first, you exclude both that in heauen of the Saints, and that which shall be of these which a•e vnborne, and yet do belong to the Catholike Church: secondly you place faith in the sense, which the Apostle saith is of things which are not seene, Heb. 11.1. As for that Catholike Church which we beleeue, it is the company of all the elect, euen as many as haue been from the beginning of the world, and shall be to the end; therefore it is called the Apostolike and holy Church, the communion of Saints. And to this communion belong no prophane and wicked men, no hypocrites; because they haue no fellowship with Christ. For the holy Church is the mysticall body of Christ, of which body no member can at any time perish.
DVR. Nazianzene d•d not iudge inturiously nor writet• bitterly of Councels, as you suppose; but only a•fi•med that the fraud and malice of the heretikes of those times, hindred the assembling of lawfull Councels. WHIT. pag. 264. It seemeth you haue not read his Epistle, or but very sle•gtly, •eeing he therein plainly set•eth downe two reasons why he absented himselfe from the Councell, when he was called: f••st the weaknes of his body, and secondly, his iudgment concerning Councels: which was, that he thought such assemblies were to be auoided, because he had seene no good of any Synode, and that hereby occasions of euils were rather increased then taken away. DVR. Yea but he hath shened his contrary iudgment vvriting his Cledonius. WHIT. Nothing lesse: but only hee affirmeth that he vvould subscribe to the Apollinarian heretikes, if they could proue that they vvere receiued of the vvest Councell; vvhich hee knevv they could not.
3Nazianz. Epist. 4•. ad Procop. [Greek or Hebrew].Nazianz. Epist. 4•. ad Procop. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.