Unto this master D. Gager replying and desiring Master Rainoldes to forbear, Master Rainoldes did rejoin as followeth.Vnto this maister D. Gager replying and desiring Maister Rainoldes to forbeare, Maister Rainoldes did reioine as followeth.
pp. 29–163154 passagespart 2 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Or if they thought the Praetors edict to have that meaning, which perhaps they did: then they come too short of his meaning somewhat, and are well corrected therefore by Gothofredus. Now you, to prove the contrary and disprove my proofs, affirm that pNerva and Pegasus add those words 8for gain sake to distinguish players for gain from free players, which, you say, is manifest: and again as manifest, you say, that Ulpian doeth approve their distinction. But if you thought good to confirm this point, whereof I showed only what cause I had to doubt, I denied it not: you should bring strong arguments to convince they do so, not idle affirmations that it is manifest they do. For what if a wealthy and lascivious courtesan should say that qMoses mentioneth the hire of the whore, to distinguish mercenary whores from free and frank dames, as it is manifest: and again, as manifest that the rProphets do approve his distinction? were there any weight in this to persuade us that Moses and the Prophets mention the whores hire to distinguish hired whores from defilers of them selves without hire; unhonest from honest; infamous from praise-worthy: and not to note rather that such as play the whores do it for hire commonly? You add, that Glossa communis, Baldus, Petrus de Castro (would you not say Paulus? for Petrus I can not hear of) and all whom you have seen upon that text of law do so understand it. This is an argument yet: though not strong enough. For all, whom you have seen, understand it so. It may be. But others, who have seen more law-books, perhaps can tell you of many that understand it otherwise. My self, as few as I have seen, can tell you of two; sBudaeus, and an Author of a Greek abridgement of the Civill law, whom Budaeus citeth. For the Greek author doth ⟨p. 63⟩expound it thus, That all, who try masteries in solemn games for gain sake, are infamous: 9and also they who come upon the stage for praise sake. And Budaeus moving a question and doubt how these words of the text, that all who come upon the stage
that all stage-playing was counted infamous at Rome, and all stageplayers were wont to be disfranchised by the Censors.
Or if they thought the Praetors edict to haue that meaning, which perhaps they did: then they come too short of his meaning somewhat, and are well corrected therefore by Gothofredus. Now you, to proove the contrarie and disproove my proofes, affirme that pNerva and Pegasus adde those words 8for gaine sake to distinguish players for gaine from free players, which, you say, is manifest: and againe as manifest, you say, that Ulpian doeth approove their distinction. But if you thought good to confirme this point, whereof I shewed onely what cause I had to dout, I denied it not: you should bring strong arguments to convince they doe so, not idle affirmatiōs that it is manifest they doe. For what if a wealthie and lasciuious courtisan should say that qMoses mentioneth the hire of the whoore, to distinguish mercenarie whoores frō free and franke dames, as it is manifest: and againe, as manifest that the rProphets doe approove his distinction? were there any weight in this to perswade vs that Moses and the Prophets mention the whoores hire to distinguish hired whoores frō defilers of them selues without hire; vnhonest from honest; infamous from prayse-worthie: and not to note rather that such as play the whoores doe it for hire commonlie? You adde, that Glossa communis, Baldus, Petrus de Castro (would you not say Paulus? for Petrus I can not heare of) and all whom you have seene vpon that text of law doe so vnderstand it. This is an argument yet: though not strong enough. For all, whō you have seene, vnderstand it so. It may be. But others, who haue seene more law-bookes, perhaps can tell you of many that vnderstand it otherwise. My selfe, as few as I haue seene, can tell you of two; sBudaeus, and an Autour of a Greeke abridgement of the Civill law, whom Budaeus citeth. For the Greeke authour doth ⟨p. 63⟩expound it thus, That all, who trie masteries in solemne games for gaine sake, are infamous: 9and also they who come vpon the stage for prayse sake. And Budaeus moving a question and doubt how these wordes of the text, that all who come vppon the stage 1for reward, are infamous; should be vnderstoode, whether that they be not also infamous who come vpon the stage 2for vaineglorious ostentation, answereth and resolveth out of St Augustin, and Livie, 3that all stageplaying was counted infamous at Rome, and all stageplayers were wont to be disfranchised by the Censors.
pD. de his qui notantur infam. l. 2. §. Ait Praetor.
8Quaestus causa, & propter praemiū.Quaestus causa, & propter praemiū.
3Attem omnem scenicā probrosam Romae fuisse: atque omnes scenicos censoria nota tribu moveri solitos.Attem omnem scenicā probrosam Romae fuisse: atque omnes scenicos censoria nota tribu moueri solitos.
Whose interpretation in a point of this quality deserveth more credit then a hundred such as Paulus de Castro: so meanly seen in the text he treateth of, that he giveth the word, stage, a different meaning from that in the Praetors edict, which it expoundeth; and saith, it speaketh of other games. An argument much stronger in show, in substance weaker, you fetch out of the text: that in certamen descendere, and in scenam prodire, do (as they say in your law) ambulare aequis passibus, in the same places of the same title, De his qui notantur infamia; but it is most evident, that tqui descendit in certamen depugnaturus cum bestijs dentatis, ac feris, virtutis ostendendae non mercedis causa, non est notatus; Ergo qui prodit in scenam pronuntiandi gratia sine praemio & quaestu, non est notatus. Which syllogism of yours if you allow for good: what say you unto this, that (me seems) is like it? In certamen descendere and in scenam prodire do ambulare aequis passibus in the same places of the same title; but it is most evident, that vqui descendit in certamen luct a aut cur su certaturus cum hominibus non facit artem ludicram; Ergo qui prodit in scenā pronuntiandi gratia non facit artem ludicra. The major is your own. The minor as true as yours: Yet the conclusion false; which xthe same places of the same title show. And seeing by my syllogism you perceive, I trust, that the manly exercises of wrestling and running do far out-run stage-playing, as it is meet they should: you see that the major of your syllogism faileth, and that certamen and scena do not walk with even pass, but are coupled together as a quick greyhound and a lazy cur. Further is it from reason that you adjoin a reason of the favourable part of the distinction out of ⟨p. 64⟩the yCode; or rather adjoin it not, but say that you think it may be gathered thence: because the games of wrestling, running, and such like be permitted to them who desire and offer to bear the charge thereof. When neither doeth it follow that because these games are allowed by Emperors to willing bearers of the charge, znot imposed on the unwilling, therefore free stageplayers are approved by Ulpian: and it is a wandering fancy to imagine why it should be so, when the question is whether it be so or no.
Whose interpretation in a point of this qualitie deserveth more credit then a hundred such as Paulus de Castro: so meanlie seene in the text he treateth of, that he giueth the word, stage, a different meaning from that in the Praetors edict, which it expoundeth; and saith, it speaketh of other games. An argument much stronger in shew, in substance weaker, you fetch out of the text: that in certamen descendere, and in scenam prodire, doe (as they saye in your lawe) ambulare aequis passibus, in the same places of the same title, De his qui notātur infamia; but it is most evident, that tqui descendit in certamen depugnaturus cum bestijs dentatis, ac feris, virtutis ostendendae nō mercedis causa, non est notatus; Ergo qui prodit in scenam pronuntiandi gratia sine praemio & quaestu, non est notatus. Which syllogisme of yours if you allow for good: what say you vnto this, that (me seemes) is like it? In certamen descendere and in scenam prodire doe ambulare aequis passibus in the same places of the same title; but it is most evident, that vqui descendit in certamen luct a aut cur su certaturus cum hominibus non facit artem ludicram; Ergo qui prodit in scenā pronuntiandi gratia non facit artem ludicra. The major is your owne. The minor as true as yours: Yet the conclusiō false; which xthe same places of the same title shew. And seeing by my syllogisme you perceiue, I trust, that the manlie exercises of wrastling and running doe farre out-runne stageplaying, as it is meete they should: you see that the major of your syllogisme fayleth, and that certamen and scena doe not walke with evē passe, but are coupled togither as a quick greyhound and a lazy curre. Farder is it from reason that you adioyne a reason of the favourable parte of the distinction out of ⟨p. 64⟩the yCode; or rather adioyne it not, but say that you thinke it may be gathered thence: because the games of wrastling, rūning, and such like be permitted to them who desire and offer to beare the charge thereof. When neither doeth it follow that because these games are allowed by Emperours to willing bearers of the charge, znot imposed on the vnwilling, therefore free stageplayers are approved by Ulpian: and it is a wandring fansie to imagin why it should be so, when the question is whether it bee so or no.
tD. de postulando. l. 1. §. bestias. & D. de his qui not. infam. l. 4.
vD. de his qui not. infam. l. 4. C de athletis. l. un.
xL. 1. 2. & 3. D. de his qui not. infam.
yC. de spectaculis. l. 1. in fine.
zL. 10. D. ad leg. Jul. de vi publica.L. 10. D. ad leg. Iul. de vi publica.
The reason of the other side which I set down to show that the distinction can not be enforced out of Ulpian's words, because the scripture likewise condemneth them of wickedness who play the whores for hire, yet acquitteth not free whores; you confute as soundly, as you confirm your own. For you say it is simply evil to play the whore, either freely or for reward; but not simply evil to come upon the stage, because the law alloweth it if it be done sine quaestu: which is a plain begging of the point in question. And yet having told me that I must evict that it is simply a sin for any prodire in scenam, as it is for a woman to prostitute her body; (I cut off your superfluous words, as namely, vile, in adding which epitheton to sin you double a fault corrected by your self before when you said, that I assume that the one is as grievous a sin, as the other, or at the least as absolutely a sin:) but having told me this, you plead again the same sophism, avouching that your consequence, Prodire in scenam quaestus causa, infamat; ergo prodire in scenam sine quaestu, non infamat, is a good consequence, because the law so distinguisheth. How much greater reason had you to be persuaded, that sith I had evicted it to be simply evil, because simply infamous by the Praetors sentence, that is, by the law; Ulpian, with his authors, interpreters thereof, did insert those words not for distinction sake, but to note the common cause why it was practised, the love of reward. Chiefly seeing otherwise it must needs follow there is [Greek or Hebrew] between the texts of your law, and one of them doeth cross an other. Which if the lawyers whom you have seen thereon, had as well observed by S. Austin and Livy, as Budaeus had: perhaps they would have thought that all sorts of stage-players, even such ⟨p. 65⟩as show them selves for applause to please men, are therein noted also, as Budaeus did. But I, who think there may be repugnancies in your texts, and had an eye to the point in question between us, to wit, whether the Praetor, whose 4edict expressed the ancient Romans law, pronounced all stage-players infamous; not whether Ulpian thought so, who lived in later age after greater and longer corruption of manners, and consequently of opinions;
The reason of the other side which I sett downe to shew that the distinction can not be enforced out of Ulpians words, because the scripture likewise condemneth them of wickednes who play the hoores for hire, yet acquitteth not free hoores; you confute as soundly, as you confirme your owne. For you say it is simply evill to play the hoore, either freely or for reward; but not simply evill to come vpon the stage, because the law alloweth it if it bee done sine quaestu: which is a plaine begging of the point in question. And yet having tolde mee that I must evict that it is simply a sinne for any prodire in scenam, as it is for a woman to prostitute her body; (I cut off your superfluous words, as namely, vile, in adding which epitheton to sinne you double a fault corrected by your selfe before when you said, that I assume that the one is as greevous a sinne, as the other, or at the least as absolutely a sinne:) but having tolde me this, you pleade againe the same sophisme, avouching that your consequence, Prodire in scenam quaestus causa, infamat; ergo prodire in scenam sine quaestu, non infamat, is a good consequence, because the law so distinguisheth. How much greater reason had you to be perswaded, that sith I had evicted it to be simply evill, because simply infamous by the Praetors sentence, that is, by the law; Vlpian, with his autours, interpreters thereof, did insert those wordes not for distinction sake, but to note the common cause why it was practised, the loue of reward. Chiefly seeing otherwise it must needes folow there is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 betwene the texts of your law, and one of them doeth crosse an other. Which if the lawiers whom you haue seene thereon, had as wel observed by S. Austin and Livie, as Budaeus had: perhaps they would haue thought that all sortes of stage-players, even such ⟨p. 65⟩as shew them selves for applause to please men, are therein noted also, as Budaeus did. But I, who thinke there may be repugnancies in your textes, and had an eye to the point in question betwene vs, to weet, whether the Praetor, whose 4edict expressed the ancient Romans law, pronounced all stage-players infamous; not whether Vlpian thought so, who lived in later age after greaterand longer corruption of maners, and consequentlie of opinions;
4Edictum per petuū. Ascon. Paedian in cic. orat. pro corn D. de orig. jur. l. 2. §. Eodem tempore. C. de vet. jur. enucleand. l. 2. §. Sed quia.Edictum per petuū. Ascon. Paedian in cic. orat. pro corn D. de orig. jur. l. 2. §. Eodem tempore. C. de vet. jur. enucleand. l. 2. §. Sed quia.
in so much that he would exempt a 5sort of fruitless game-servers from infamy, whom neither aancient Romans, though Heathens, did before him, nor bChristian Emperors after: I (as you acknowledge) did admit they thought so, but urged that the Praetor affirmed the same that I do, and they mistook his meaning, as Gothofredus proveth in his note thereon. To the which assertion, after a preferring of them before Gothofrede, if not in learning, yet authority, needless to be stood on; (for though he were not better learned then they were, yet might he see by S. Austin and Livy that they saw not; neither is it authority, but learning, that must teach us what the Praetor meant:) you say that in some sense his short, but quick note, Immò & qui sine quaestu, hurteth not you at all. Well. In some sense then it hurteth you, in some it doeth not. And doth that sense, wherein he meant it, hurt you or no? If no: why say you afterward, Gothofrede doeth gloze against a manifest law without giving any reason of his so doing? If yea: what spirit of wrangling had bewitched you to construe an authors words as not gainsaying you, which in his own meaning you knew made flat against you? For after you had said, If he meaneth thereby to tax Laberius, Lentulus, Nero, and such like, that did exercere histrioniam, though gratuitam, his exception maketh not against your text; and had given a reason thereof, beside the text clean, neither agreeing to Laberius, whom yet by your forenaming him it should have touched: you come in with these words, But Gothofrede in deed foundeth his sharp note upon a saying of S. Austin, Omnes enim scenici probrosi; and of Livie, Et tribu moveri soliti. So you do confess that Gothofrede in deed, although you sensed him as if he taxed only them who played to satisfy their dissolute and ⟨p. 66⟩lewd humours, that so he might not seem to make against your text, your sense thereof at least; yet in deed he counteth all stage-players infamous, according to the sayings of S. Austin and Livy, whereon he foundeth his note.
in so much that hee would exempt a 5sort of fruitlesse game-servers from infamie, whom neither aancient Romans, though Heathens, did before him, nor bChristian Emperours after: I (as you acknowledge) did admit they thought so, but vrged that the Praetor affirmed the same that I doe, and they mistooke his meaning, as Gothofredus prooveth in his note thereon. To the which assertion, after a preferring of them before Gothofrede, if not in learning, yet authoritie, needelesse to bee stoode on; (for though hee were not better learned then they were, yet might he see by S. Austin and Livie that they saw not; neither is it autoritie, but learning, that must teach vs what the Praetor meant:) you say that in some sense his short, but quicke note, Immò & qui sine quaestu, hurteth not you at all. Well. In some sense then it hurteth you, in some it doeth not. And doth that sense, wherin he meant it, hurt you or no? If no: why say you afterward, Gothofrede doeth gloze against a manifest law without giuing any reason of his so doing? If yea: what spirit of wrangling had bewitched you to construe an autours words as not gainesaying you, which in his own meaning you knew made flat against you? For after you had saide, If hee meaneth thereby to taxe Laberius, Lentulus, Nero, and such like, that did exercere histrioniam, though gratuitam, his exception maketh not against your text; and had given a reason thereof, beside the text cleane, neither agreeing to Laberius, whom yet by your forenaming him it should haue touched: you come in with these wordes, But Gothofrede in deede foundeth his sharpe note vpon a saying of S. Austin, Omnes enim scenici probrosi; and of Livie, Et tribu moveri soliti. So you doe confesse that Gothofrede in deede, although you sensed him as if he taxed onely them who played to satisfie their dissolute and ⟨p. 66⟩lewde humours, that so hee might not seeme to make against your text, your sense thereof at least; yet in deede he counteth all stage-players infamous, according to the sayinges of S. Austin and Livie, whereon he foundeth his note.
5Agitatores. D. de his qui notantur infam. l. 4.
aTacit. annal. lib. 14. Curriculo quadri garum insistere, foedum studium. Dio, Xiphil. epit. in Net. Es [Greek or Hebrew].Tacit. annal. lib. 14. Curriculo quadri garum insistere, foedum studium. Dio, Xiphil. epit. in Net. Es 〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
bC. de spectaculis & scenicis. l. 4. See Cuiacius upon it.C. de spectaculis & scenicis. l. 4. See Cuiacius vpon it.
In deed Master Gager, you are much to blame, who, to show that you can obscure a most clear truth with pretence of law, and a distinction of some sense, do hazard the shipwreck of a good conscience, and wastefully employ your wit and time both, in bolstering out by writing that which your self see and know to be untrue. I did say before, that I gathered by your dealing that when you resolved to reply against me, you thought with your self: I know not whether these things be true which he writeth; yet am I disposed to have a crash against them. Now I must in part correct that my saying. For you show that somewhere in your reply you thought; I know that this thing, which he writeth, is true; 6yet have I a lust to contradict it.
In deede Maister Gager, you are much to blame, who, to shew that you can obscure a most cleere truth with pretense of lawe, and a distinction of some sense, doe hazard the shipwracke of a good conscience, and wastfully employ your witt and time both, in bolstering out by writing that which your selfe see and knowe to bee vntrue. I did say before, that I gathered by your dealing that when you resolved to reply against me, you thought with your selfe: I know not whether these things be true which he writeth; yet am I disposed to haue a crash against them. Now I must inpart correct that my saying. For you shew that somewhere in your reply you thought; I know that this thing, which he writeth, is true; 6yet haue I a lust to contradict it.
True it is therefore that by Gothofrede's judgement the Praetor accounted all stage-players infamous; and they, who took the Praetor otherwise, mistook him. Whereof although I did not allege Gothofredus for the chiefest proof, but principally cited him to satisfy you, a lawyer by a lawyer, and proved it by the best interpreter of the law, the practise and consent of the ancient Romans, which he doeth ground on also: yet you having answered him (you say) already as it were by the way, do add that by him the rest of my authorities and all mine examples also may receive their true, though short answer. The authorities then of Tully, of Nepos, of Laberius, of Livy, of Juvenal, of Suetonius, of Tacitus, of Dio, and of S. Austin; the examples of Nero, Lentulus, and the rest, whom not such authors only but the people of Rome too did esteem infamous for their stage-playing, were it freely, or for gain; may be answered by your answer to Gothofredus. And how? For he (you say) glozeth against a manifest law without giving any reason of his so doing. Why? Doeth not he give a reason in these words, Omnes enim scenici probrosi, & tribu moveri soliti, proved by S. cAustin and dLivy? But S. Austin and Livy could never dream of your text, you say; and so their authorities serve not to ⟨p. 67⟩interpret it. As who say Gothofredus brought them to interpret your text, that is, Ulpian: not rather to interpret the Praetors edict, & to correct your text thereby. For thus doth he reason in effect: Ulpian expounding the Praetors edict, saith that, they only, who play upon the stage for gain sake, are infamous: but the Praetor meant that they, who play without gain, are infamous also, even generally all stage-players; as it is apparent by S. Austin and Livy: therefore Ulpian misseth in expounding the Praetors edict. And, I trust, an older writer may be cited to correct a younger, of whom he could not dream: or else your self do evil to cite Ulpian against me, of whom he could not dream you wot well. Though S. Austin also might have dreamed of Ulpian, 7for ought that I know. But you say further that S. Austin and Livy are to be understood against Histriones: and so their authorities serve not to this of your text. Wherein I must confess I understand not what you mean.
True it is therfore that by Gothofredes iudgement the Praetor accounted all stage-players infamous; and they, who tooke the Praetor otherwise, mistooke him. Whereof although I did not alleage Gothofredus for the chiefest proofe, but principally cited him to satisfie you, a lawier by a lawier, and prooved it by the best interpreter of the lawe, the practise and consent of the ancient Romans, which he doeth ground on also: yet you having answered him (you say) already as it were by the way, doe adde that by him the rest of my autorities and all mine examples also may receve their true, though short aunswer. The autorities then of Tullie, of Nepos, of Laberius, of Liuie, of Iuvenal, of Suetonius, of Tacitus, of Dio, and of S. Austin; the examples of Nero, Lentulus, and the rest, whom not such autours onely but the people of Rome too did esteeme infamous for their stage-playing, were it freelie, or for gaine; may bee aunswered by your answere to Gothofredus. And how? For hee (you say) glozeth against a manifest lawe without giuing any reason of his so doeing. Why? Doeth not he giue a reason in these wordes, Omnes enim scenici probrosi, & tribu moveri soliti, prooved by S. cAustin and dLivie? But S. Austin and Livie could never dreame of your text, you say; and so their autorities serve not to ⟨p. 67⟩interpret it. As who say Gothofredus brought them to interpret your text, that is, Ulpian: not rather to interpret the Praetors edict, & to correct your text thereby. For thus doth he reason in effect: Ulpian expounding the Praetors edict, saith that, they onely, who play vpon the stage for gaine sake, are infamous: but the Praetor meant that they, who play without gaine, are infamous also, even generally all stage-players; as it is apparant by S. Austin and Livie: therefore Ulpian misseth in expounding the Praetors edict. And, I trust, an older writer may be cited to correct a younger, of whom he could not dreame: or else your selfe doe evill to cite Ulpian against me, of whom hee could not dreame you wote well. Though S. Austin also might haue dreamed of Vlpian, 7for ought that I know. But you saye farder that S. Austin and Livie are to bee vnderstoode against Histriones: and so their autorities serve not to this of your text. Wherein I must confesse I vnderstand not what you meane.
cDe civit. Dei lib. 2. cap. 11De ciuit. Dei lib. 2. cap. 11
dLib. 7.
7Ulpian lived about two hundred years before S. Aust. Lamprid. Alexandro Sever. Euseb. Chro.Vlpian lived about two hundred yeares before S. Aust. Lamprid. Alexandro Sever. Euseb. Chro.
For I can not imagine you should be so absurd as to say that they speak not against players on stage, because they speak against Histriones. Only as eSocrates; being asked what he thought of a certain book of Heraclitus, answered, Those things which I understood in it are excellent, and so, I think, are those to which I understood not: semblably may I say touching these branches and parts of your reply, that what I understand therein maketh nothing against the point that I did conclude by Gothofredus; no more, I think, doeth that which I understand not. Nay, I say too little when I say I think. For seeing histriones signifieth stage-players; & stage-players are such as come 8upon the stage to play or pronounce, whom the 9Praetor speaketh of: I know, that what soever your meaning be therein, it can have no force to overthrow that with I concluded by Gothofredus. So this with the former distinctionlesse distinction of a sense he meant not, being all the answer that you make to him: the rest of my authorities and examples all are so far from being answered by him, that your answerless answer doth rather leave both him and them as unanswerable. But you go forward, and, to overthrow them both an other way, you deny that the Romans ever judged Omnes scenicos infames. ⟨p. 68⟩And why? Because plays (say you) were sometime instituted, as in a common plague, ad placandos Deos, and were provided by great officers of the common treasure: and so they are referred ad religionem & devotionem. Sometime they were set out at the private cost of them that sued to the people for great offices, or generally for the honour and solace of the city: and so they are referred to magnificence. For magnificentia is a goodly virtue, & versatur circa sumptus amplos, non turpes aut infames, because it is a virtue, but circa quaecunque in Rempublicam honestae laudis studio conferuntur: among the which fAristotle reckoneth Ludos splendidè facere. Neither is it to be thought that Aesopus & Roscius, being both men of that fame, favour, wealth, and entire familiarity with the best and wisest in their times, were reputed as infamous persons. What should I speak of so many Circi, Theatra, Amphitheatra, builded by the greatest and bravest Romans with so huge charge & sumptuousness?
For I can not imagin you should bee so absurd as to say that they speake not against players on stage, because they speake against Histriones. Onely as eSocrates; beeing asked what hee thought of a certaine booke of Heraclitus, aunswered, Those things which I vnderstood in it are excellent, and so, I thinke, are those to which I vnderstood not: semblably may I say touching these branches and partes of your reply, that what I vnderstand therein maketh nothing against the point that I did conclude by Gothofredus; no more, I thinke, doeth that which I vnderstand not. Nay, I say too litle when I say I thinke. For seeing histriones signifieth stage-players; & stage-players are such as come 8vpon the stage to play or pronounce, whom the 9Praetor speaketh of: I know, that what soeuer your meaning be therein, it can haue no force to ouerthrow that wich I concluded by Gothofredus. So this with the former distinctionlesse distinction of a sense he meant not, being all the answer that you make to him: the rest of my authorities and examples all are so farre from beeing answered by him, that your answerlesse answer doth rather leaue both him and them as vnanswerable. But you go forward, and, to ouerthrow them both an other way, you deny that the Romans euer iudged Omnes scenicos infames. ⟨p. 68⟩And why? Because playes (say you) were sometime instituted, as in a common plague, ad placandos Deos, and were prouided by great officers of the common treasure: and so they are referred ad religionem & deuotionem. Sometime they were sett out at the priuat cost of them that sued to the people for great offices, or generally for the honor and solace of the citie: and so they are referred to magnificence. For magnificentia is a goodly vertue, & versatur circa sumptus amplos, non turpes aut infames, because it is a vertue, but circa quaecunque in Rempublicam honestae laudis studio conferuntur: among the which fAristotle reckeneth Ludos splendidè facere. Neither is it to be thought that Aesopus & Roscius, being both men of that fame, favour, wealth, and entire familiarity with the best and wisest in their times, were reputed as infamous persons. What should I speake of so many Circi, Theatra, Amphitheatra, builded by the greatest and bravest Romās with so huge charge & sumptuousnes?
eDiog. La•. in Socr.
8Qui artis ludicrae pronuntiandive causa in scenam prodierit.
9Praetoris verba dicunt. l. 1. Ait Praetor. l. 2 D. de his qui not. infam.
Which though they were once upon foul abuses, or some other occasion, as you write, overthrown by the Romans themselves: yet even those plays for which they were abolished were ex eo genere of whom they might have said (as gTacitus doeth of Astrologers) quod in civitate nostra, & vetabitur semper, & retinebitur. Howsoever; I can not think that either they would have suffered such things to be done at all, if they had judged them evil: or to be performed by infamous persons, being matters of that state and magnificence, and, as they thought, of that devotion and necessity. Thus far your own words. In which, to show that you do not deny without cause that the Romans ever judged all stage-players to be infamous, you make two proofs thereof: one, that Aesopus & Roscius were not reputed as infamous persons; an other, that the Romans would not have suffered such things to be performed by infamous persons, being matters of great state & magnificence, and; as they thought, of great devotion and necessity. Such proposition, such proofs. The proposition savouring of a strange boldness (to use no harder term) that you, who scarce are forty years old, if yet forty, in a question of fact, of a thing done fifteen, sixteen, or seventeen hundred years ago, which a number of witnesses, that lived the same time, men of good ⟨p. 69⟩credit, affirm to have been done, should presume to say, I deny that it was done. For Tully reporteth that the Romans counting all kinds of stage-plays shameful and dishonest, did judge accordingly of the players. Nepos, Laberius, Livy, Juvenal, Tacitus, the rest, whom I cited, both of the learned sort, and of the common people, do testify the same. Neither can you deny but their words alleged by me, do clearly argue that they judged thus of free players also, not only of players for gain. Yet you harden your face to say against them all: I deny that the Romans ever judged all stage-players to be infamous. Yea, for proof hereof you produce two reasons, which imply that they thought no stageplayers infamous, no not players for gain: and so you avouch an evident untruth against your own confession, your own conscience. For Roscius and Aesopus played for gain: as hPliny and iMacrobius show. Their wealth, which you mention, was gotten by that trade.
Which though they were once vpon fowle abuses, or some other occasion, as you write, overthrowne by the Romans themselues: yet even those playes for which they were abolished were ex eo genere of whom they might haue said (as gTacitus doeth of Astrologers) quod in civitate nostra, & vetabitur semper, & retinebitur. Howsoever; I can not thinke that either they would haue suffered such things to bee done at all, if they had iudged them evill: or to be performed by infamous persons, being matters of that state and magnificence, and, as they thought, of that devotion and necessitie. Thus farre your owne wordes. In which, to shew that you doe not deny without cause that the Romans ever iudged all stage-players to be infamous, you make two proofes thereof: one, that Aesopus & Roscius were not reputed as infamous persons; an other, that the Romans would not haue suffered such things to be perfourmed by infamous persons, being matters of great state & magnificence, and; as they thought, of great devotion and necessitie. Such proposition, such proofes. The proposition savouring of a strange boldnes (to vse no harder terme) that you, who scarse are fourtie yeares old, if yet fourtie, in a questiō of fact, of a thing done fifteene, sixteene, or seuenteene hundred yeares ago, which a number of witnesses, that liued the same time, men of good ⟨p. 69⟩credit, affirme to haue bene doon, should presume to saye, I deny that it was done. For Tullie reporteth that the Romans counting all kindes of stage-playes shamefull and dishonest, did iudge accordingly of the players. Nepos, Laberius, Livie, Iuvenall, Tacitus, the rest, whom I cited, both of the learned sort, and of the common people, doe testifie the same. Neither can you denie but their wordes alleadged by me, doe clearlie argue that they iudged thus of free players also, not onely of players for gaine. Yet you harden your face to say against them all: I denie that the Romans ever iudged all stage-players to bee infamous. Yea, for proofe hereof you produce two reasons, which imply that they thought no stageplayers infamous, no not players for gaine: and so you avouch an evident vntrueth against your owne confession, your owne conscience. For Roscius and Aesopus played for gaine: as hPlinie and iMacrobius shew. Their wealth, which you mētion, was gottē by that trade.
Now your text of kUlpian with Pegasus and Nerva, sayeth that all who play for gain, are infamous; as you confessed before; adding that you saw no cause to mislike it, less durst dispute against it. Wherefore in saying that Aesopus and Roscius were not reputed as infamous persons, your own mouth and heart condemn you of gain saying an undoubted trueth. Much more when you infer the same of other stage-players, even of the rascals, the most vile among them, in the reason following. For although the fame, the favour, the wealth of Roscius and Aesopus, should no more have moved you to wash away all stain from their credit, then from lFlora and mPhryne, who were whores of great fame, favour, wealth: yet their familiarity with the best and wisest might probably persuade you, that they were not reputed as infamous persons. Howbeit, had you weighed, how 1the best and wisest so well acquainted with them, had showed in 2one of them, that nother things brought him to such estimation, his ostage-playing was some stain unto him: you should have perceived that in this respect their credit might be tainted, notwithstanding the acquaintance, whereto, by means of other parts approved in them, they grew in process of time with the best and wisest. But your next ⟨p. 70⟩reason saith as much for the vilest and most beastly stageplayers, as for Aesopus and Roscius. For in certain plays, called 3the plays of Flora, the 4players were not men, but women, and those lewd ones, professed whores and strumpets: which, besides all wanton filthiness of words, did show them selves naked also to the people, and used most shameful motions and gestures. These plays were instituted (to use your own words) ad placandos Deos, 5that Flora, as the Goddess of flowers, might be entreated not to hurt the corn, nor any thing that bloweth and blossometh: and so they are referred ad religionem & devotionem. The 6officers that had the charge to set them out, did set them out at their private cost, to get the peoples favour for the obtaining of greater offices: and so they are referred to magnificence. The 7stages and theatres, wherein men behold them, were builded by the greatest and bravest Romans with huge charge and sumptuousness:
Now your text of kUlpian with Pegasus and Nerva, sayeth that all who play for gaine, are infamous; as you confessed before; adding that you sawe no cause to mislike it, lesse durst dispute against it. Wherefore in saying that Aesopus and Roscius were not reputed as infamous persons, your owne mouth and heart cōdemne you of gain saying an vndoubted trueth. Much more when you inferre the same of other stage-players, euen of the rascalls, the most vile among them, in the reason following. For although the fame, the favour, the wealth of Roscius and Aesopus, should no more haue mooved you to washe away all staine from their credit, then from lFlora and mPhryne, who were whoores of great fame, favour, wealth: yet their familiaritie with the best and wisest might probably perswade you, that they were not reputed as infamous persons. Howbeit, had you weighed, how 1the best and wisest so wel acquainted with them, had shewed in 2one of thē, that nother things brought him to such estimation, his ostage-playing was some staine vnto him: you should haue perceyued that in this respect their credit might bee tainted, notwithstanding the acquaintance, whereto, by meanes of other partes approoved in them, they grew in processe of time with the best and wisest. But your next ⟨p. 70⟩reason saith as much for the vilest and most beastlie stageplayers, as for Aesopus and Roscius. For in certaine playes, called 3the playes of Flora, the 4players were not men, but wemen, and those lewde ones, professed whoores and strumpers: which, besides all wanton filthines of words, did shew them selues naked also to the people, and vsed most shamefull motions and gestures. These playes were instituted (to vse your own words) ad placandos Deos, 5
4Mimae, as they are termed by Vale rius Maxim.; turba meretricia, by Ovi. meretrices, quae mimor•m funguntur officio, by Lactantius. lib. 1 cap. 20Mimae, as they are termed by Vale rius Maxim.; turba meretricia, by Oui. meretrices, quae mimor•m funguntur officio, by Lactantius. lib. 1 cap. 20
Wherefore sith the Romans would not have suffered such things to be performed by infamous persons, being matters of great state and magnificence, and, as they thought, of great devotion and necessity: it followeth, by your reason, that they did not judge professed whores and strumpets to be infamous persons. Now, if this consequent touching whores be false, as your plaw showeth it is: then is the consequution of your reason faulty. Which your self may see by the other branch thereof, avouched jointly, to wit, that the Romans would not have suffered such things to be done at all, if they had judged them evil: and by him, whose sentence, that it is a virtue 8to set out plays bravely, you add for the gracing and countenancing of your reason, I mean, even by Aristotle. For he, in reckoning it among magnificent actions 9if any where men think they ought to set out plays bravely (so he qualifieth his sentence with a circumstance of moment omitted by you in alleging it,) respecteth the opinions and customs of the Grecians: who thought it an honourable thing to be at charges with furnishing and decking companies of Musicians, of Dancers, of Players, in their solemn feasts, & usual processions celebrated to their Gods. As among the Athenians, for example sake, qDemosthenes, when no man of ⟨p. 71⟩his tribe was willing to bear the charge thereof, did promise of his own accord that he 1would bear it, and thereupon provided golden crowns and costly garments for a company 2in the feast of Bacchus. This feast rhad as filthy matters represented, though by an other sex, in the shows & plays belonging thereunto, as that of Flora had. Yet, such was the brutish superstition of Heathens, that sAristotle him self, one of the best among them, banishing all unseemly speeches and spectacles out of his common wealth, 3excepteth such as these, done in the honour of their Gods, according to their law, twhich 4allowed that beastliness in many cities then. In like sort the Romans, albeit they judged the things to be evil which the players did in the feast of Flora, so evil that vthe refuse & dregs of the people durst not for shame desire to have the fight there of while Cato was present: yet did they allow;
Wherefore sith the Romans would not haue suffered such things to bee perfourmed by infamous persons, being matters of great state and magnificence, and, as they thought, of great devotion and necessitie: it foloweth, by your reason, that they did not iudge professed whoores and strumpets to be infamous persons. Now, if this consequent touching whoores bee false, as your plaw sheweth it is: then is the consequution of your reason faulty. Which your self may see by the other branch thereof, avouched ioyntlie, to weet, that the Romans would not haue suffered such things to be done at all, if they had iudged them evill: and by him, whose sentence, that it is a vertue 8to sett out playes bravelie, you adde for the gracing and countenancing of your reason, I meane, even by Aristotle. For he, in reckening it among magnificent actions 9if any where men thinke they ought to sett out playes bravelie (so he qualifieth his sentēce with a circūstance of moment omitted by you in alleaging it,) respecteth the opinions and customes of the Grecians: who thought it an honorable thing to be at charges with furnishing and decking companies of Musicians, of Dansers, of Players, in their solemne feastes, & vsuall processions celebrated to their Gods. As among the Athenians, for example sake, qDemosthenes, when no man of ⟨p. 71⟩his tribe was willing to beare the charge thereof, did promise of his owne accorde that he 1would beare it, and therevppon provided golden crownes and costlie garments for a companie 2in the feast of Bacchus. This feast rhad as filthie matters represented, though by an other sexe, in the shewes & playes belonging thervnto, as that of Flora had. Yet, such was the brutish superstition of Heathens, that sAristotle him selfe, one of the best among them, banishing all vnseemely speeches and spectacles out of his commō wealth, 3
pD. de condict. ob turp. vel injust. caus. l. 4. §. Sed quid D. de ritu▪ nupt. l. 41.D. de cōdict. ob turp. vel injust. caus. l. 4. §. Sed quid D. de ritu▪ nupt. l. 41.
8Ludos splendidè facere.
9[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
qOrat. in Midiam.
1[Greek or Hebrew]〈non-Latin alphabet〉
2Ev [Greek or Hebrew]Ev 〈non-Latin alphabet〉
rHerodot. Euterpe. [Greek or Hebrew]. Athenaeus dipnos. lib. 14 [Greek or Hebrew] & [Greek or Hebrew], Cle▪ Alexandr. ad hort. ad gent. Arnob. advers. gent. lib. 5.Herodot. Euterpe. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Athenaeus dipnos. lib. 14 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 & 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Cle▪ Alexandr. ad hort. ad gent. Arnob. advers. gent. lib. 5.
and by public order provide for the doing of them, 5because they thought them pleasant to their devilish Goddess, whose wrathful plagues they feared, if they should omit them. And thus, for the rest of their plays also, whether made to pacify 6the mother of their Gods, or 7any of her children, they thought it a necessary devotion to set them out, a stately magnificence to set them out bravely; yet did they repute the players thereof infamous, as Tully, Livy, the Praetor, Ulpian, all consent; though withal discrediting thereby both Gods and plays, as xAustin and yTertullian note. How much the more strange doeth your boldness seem, not only to pronounce that the Romans would not have suffered such things to be performed by infamous persons; but to say, as bringing a proof thereof too, that you can not think it, I can not think that they would have suffered it. And can you think that this is a seemly thing, or tolerable, in a matter of fact, proved by the uniform consent of so many and so worthy witnesses, for you to contradict it with these kinds of speeches: I deny that the Romans ever judged all stage players to be infamous; It is not to be thought that they deemed Aesopus and Roscius infamous; I can not think ⟨p. 72⟩that they would have suffered their plays to be performed by men infamous? Can you think without blushing, how the ancient Fathers conclude by the confession of the Romans themselves, 8one, that plays are evil, because the Praetor noted the players with infamy; an 9other, that such Gods should not be worshipped, because such men were counted infamous who performed the plays that they required: and you, of the contrary, deny that such men were counted infamous by the Romans, or noted by the Praetor; a thing, that no Heathen, amongest all their adversaries (whom I have ever read of) durst? Can you think your students of Christ-church, and others, with whom you have communicated this reply of yours, to be so weak eyesighted, that they perceive not, that your self, in citing & applying Tacitus his words touching Astrologers to the point in question, do confute your self, as if God had bereft you almost of common sense, when you went about it? For if you think that the Romans would retain Astrologers always in their city, yet forbid them always:
and by publike order provide for the dooing of them, 5because they thought them pleasant to their divelish Goddesse, whose wrathfull plagues they feared, if they should omitt them. And thus, for the rest of their playes also, whether made to pacifie 6the mother of their Gods, or 7any of her childrē, they thought it a necessarie devotion to sett them out, a statelie magnificence to sett them out bravelie; yet did they repute the players thereof infamous, as Tullie, Livie, the Praetor, Vlpian, all consent; though withall discrediting thereby both Gods and playes, as xAustin and yTertullian note. How much the more strange doeth your boldnes seeme, not onelie to pronounce that the Romans would not have suffered such things to be performed by infamous persons; but to say, as bringing a proofe thereof too, that you can not thinke it, I can not thinke that they would haue suffered it. And can you thinke that this is a seemely thing, or tolerable, in a matter of fact, prooved by the vniforme consent of so many and so worthy witnesses, for you to contradict it with these kindes of speeches: I deny that the Romans ever iudged all stage players to be infamous; It is not to be thought that they deemed Aesopus and Roscius infamous; I can not think ⟨p. 72⟩that they would haue suffered their playes to be performed by men infamous? Can you thinke without blushing, how the ancient Fathers conclude by the confession of the Romans themselues, 8one, that playes are evill, because the Praetor noted the players with infamie; an 9other, that such Gods should not bee worshipped, because such men were counted infamous who perfourmed the playes that they required: and you, of the cōtrarie, denie that such men were coūted infamous by the Romans, or noted by the Praetor; a thing, that no Heathen, amongest all their adversaries (whom I haue ever read of) durst? Can you thinke your students of Christ-church, and others, with whom you haue communicated this reply of yours, to be so weak eyesighted, that they perceiue not, that your selfe, in citing & applying Tacitus his wordes touching Astrologers to the point in question, doe confute your selfe, as if God had bereft you almost of common sense, when you went about it? For if you thinke that the Romans would retaine Astrologers alwayes in their citie, yet forbid them alwayes:
5Quo ve malo mentem concussa? timore Deorū. Horat. satyr. lib. 2. sat 3.Quo ve malo mentem concussa? timore Deorū. Horat. satyr. lib. 2. sat 3.
6Ludi Megalenses. Livi. lib. 29. & 34. Aug de ciu. Dei lib. 2. cap. 4.Ludi Megalenses. Liui. lib. 29. & 34. Aug de ciu. Dei lib. 2. cap. 4.
7Ludi Romani, in honorem Jovis, Junonis, & Minervae: ludi Apollinares, &c. Cic. in Verr. li. 5. Livi. li. 27. •1. &c.Ludi Romani, in honorem Iovis, Iunonis, & Minervae: ludi Apollinares, &c. Cic. in Verr. li. 5. Livi. li. 27. •1. &c.
xDe civ. Dei. lib. 2. cap. 13.
yDe spectaculis, cap. 22.
8Tertullian Quanta confessio est malae rei, quarū actors cùm acceptissimi sint, sine nota non sunt.Tertullian Quanta confessio est malae rei, quarū actores cùm acceptissimi sint, sine nota non sunt.
9S. Augustin. Theatricae illius turpitudinis qua fronte notatur actor, si adoratur exactor? Proponunt Grae ci; Si D• tales colendi sunt, profectò etiā tales homines honorandi sunt. Assumunt Ro mani: Sed nullo modo tales homines honorandi sunt. Concludunt Christiani; Nullo igitur modo Dii tales colendi sunt.S. Augustin. Theatricae illius turpitudinis qua frōte notatur actor, si adoratur exactor? Proponūt Grae ci; Si D• tales colendi sunt, profectò etiā tales homines honorandi sunt. Assumunt Ro mani: Sed nullo modo tales homines honorādi sunt. Concludunt Christiani; Nullo igitur modo Dii tales colendi sunt.
can you not think that they would have suffered such things to be done at all, if they had judged them evil? And if you think plays to be of that kind, of which they might have said as Tacitus doth of Astrologers: can you think that they who zjudged Astrologers worthy of greater punishment, would have judged players worthy a note of infamy? I would to God you could think, & think upon your bed (as the aProphet exhorteth) of your offence herein, your bloving of vanity, your seeking of lies. Then would you be still, and quietly acknowledge that by Tully, Nepos, Laberius, Livy, Juvenal, and other ancient Romans, stage-players were taken to be infamous persons, even all, whether they played freely, or for gain: and therefore not only the hirelings, but the free too, are comprised and noted in the Praetors words. Then would you rather observe in the reading of your cGlossa communis, that though certain lawyers took the Praetor otherwise, yet certain took him so as well as Gothofredus. Then would you devise more and better reasons for the general doctrine out of dJustinian's Code, and eTheodosius both, then now for the favourable part of your distinction you did out ⟨p. 73⟩of Justinianus; omitting and neglecting that, in fthe same title, whence that silly single reason was enforced, stage-players are termed 1vile, 2unhonest persons, without all distinction.
can you not think that they would haue suffered such things to bee done at all, if they had iudged thē evill? And if you thinke playes to be of that kinde, of which they might haue saide as Tacitus doth of Astrologers: can you thinke that they who ziudged Astrologers worthie of greater punishment, would haue iudged players worthie a note of infamie? I would to God you could thinke, & think vpō your bedde (as the aProphet exhorteth) of your offense herein, your bloving of vanitie, your seeking of lyes. Then would you bee still, and quietlie acknowledge that by Tullie, Nepos, Laberius, Livie, Iuvenal, and other auncient Romans, stage-players were taken to bee infamous persons, euen all, whether they played freelie, or for gaine: and therefore not onely the hirelinges, but the free too, are comprised and noted in the Praetors wordes. Then would you rather observe in the reading of your cGlossa communis, that though certaine lawiers tooke the Praetor otherwise, yet certaine tooke him so as well as Gothofredus. Then would you devise more and better reasons for the generall doctrine out of dIustinians Code, and eTheodosius both, then now for the favourable part of your distinctō you did out ⟨p. 73⟩of Iustinianus; omitting and neglecting that, in fthe same title, whence that seelie single reason was inforced, stage-players are termed 1vile, 2vnhonest persons, without all distinction.
zTacit. annal. li. 2 Ulpian. li. 7. de offic. Procon. coll. leg. Mos. & Roman. C de malef. & mathem. li. 5.Tacit. annal. li. 2 Vlpian. li. 7. de offic. Procon. coll. leg. Mos. & Roman. C de malef. & mathem. li. 5.
It may be that your conscience felt some prick hereof; or at least your knowledge informed you that this would not hold water. Else, why adjoin you a new point of defence, that the actors of your plays are no stage-players? Whereas gbefore your only answer to this point was, that you played freely: nor needed there more in your desire to be short (which you pretend often) if you thought it certain the law comprised not free players. But what soever you thought, when you resolved of having two strings unto your bow: this new string is worse a great deal then the old was; the hemp is naught whereof you made it. For whereas you deny; that you, who come on the stage once in a year, or two, in seven, or in ten, or sometime twenty years, are to be termed 3stage-players; as he is not a wrestler that sometime to prove his strength, trieth for a fall or two; nor he a fencer, that sometime taketh up the cudgels to play a venny: First make these similitudes perfect with adding 4that which answereth to 5the stage, that they be not similia dissimilia, (as hTully calleth them,) and then he is a 6wrestler who to prove his strength on that stage, as it were, doeth try for a fall or two; and a 7Fencer likewise, who cometh once thither, though he never come again; and so are they stage-players, who play upon the stage once in a year or two. Next, the law doeth cut off all strife about the name, by noting him with infamy, 8who cometh on the stage to play, or pronounce. So that when you acknowledge that yours come on the stage to this intent and end, you show that both you wrangle and trifle in denying they are to be termed stage-players. As for that you add, that you do differ from them, whom I mentioned, in the manner of your playing, in the end, effects, & other circumstances, as in the examination of mine examples shall appear; the which as I have alleged to illustrate mine authorities, as being the men whom they properly speak against; so if you show that you are not to be likened to them, neither mine authorities, nor mine examples shall touch you: the drift ⟨p. 74⟩of your speech is to prove, even for the thing too, that you are clear from that which the law disgraceth; but with what sinews of arguments you do it, I will (by a more perfect similitude than yours were) endeavour to make plain unto you:
It may bee that your cōscience felt some pricke hereof; or at least your knowledge informed you that this would not holde water. Else, why adioyne you a new point of defense, that the actors of your playes are no stage-players? Whereas gbefore your onely answere to this point was, that you played freely: nor needed there more in your desire to bee short (which you pretend often) if you thought it certaine the lawe comprised not free players. But what soeuer you thought, when you resolved of having two stringes vnto your bowe: this newe string is worse a great deale then the old was; the hempe is naught whereof you made it. For whereas you denie; that you, who come on the stage once in a yeare, or two, in seauen, or in tenne, or sometime twentie yeares, are to be termed 3stage-players; as he is not a wrastler that sometime to proove his strength, trieth for a fall or two; nor he a fenser, that sometime taketh vp the cudgells to play a venny: First make these similitudes perfitt with adding 4that which answereth to 5the stage, that they bee not similia dissimilia, (as hTullie calleth them,) and then hee is a 6wrastler who to proove his strength on that stage, as it were, doeth trie for a fall or two; and a 7Fenser likewise, who commeth once thither, though he neuer come againe; and so are they stage-players, who play vpon the stage once in a yeare or two. Next, the law doeth cutt off all strife about the name, by noting him with infamie, 8who commeth on the stage to play, or pronounce. So that when you acknowledge that yours come on the stage to this intent and ende, you shewe that both you wrangle and trifle in denying they are to be termed stage-players. As for that you adde, that you doe differ from them, whom I mentioned, in the maner of your playing, in the ende, effectes, & other circumstances, as in the examination of mine exaples shall appeare; the which as I haue alleaged to illustrate mine authorities, as being the men whom they properly speak against; so if you shew that you are not to be likened to them, neyther mine authorities, nor mine examples shall touch you: the drift
gEpilo. Ulys. red respon. ad Mom.Epilo. Vlys. red respon. ad Mom.
3Scenici, o• histriones.
4In arenam. D. de postulando li. 1. §. removet. D. de accusationib. li. 4.
5In scenam.
hDe finib. l. 4
6Athleta C. deathle. l. […].Athleta C. deathle. l. 〈…〉.
iMaximinus, a savage Emperor, a man of a huge, tall, and strong body, took a most sottish and proud conceit thereof that he could not be killed. Whereupon a certain man said in his presence; He that can not be killed by one, is killed by many: The Elephant is great; yet is he killed: The Lion is strong; yet is he killed: The Tiger is swift; yet is he killed: Beware of many joined, if single ones you fear not.
iMaximinus, a savage Emperour, a man of a huge, tall, and strong body, tooke a most sottish and proude conceit thereof that he could not be killed. Wherevpon a certaine man said in his presence; He that can not be killed by one, is killed by many: The Elephant is great; yet is he killed: The Lion is strong; yet is hee killed: The Tyger is swift; yet is he killed: Beware of many ioyned, if single ones you feare not.
The author of this speech meant to reason thus, by way of a syllogism: Every living creature may be killed: Maximinus the Emperor is a living creature: Therefore he may be killed. And least Maximinus through his proud conceit should object against it, that every living creature, who could be overmatched by one, might be killed; but it was impossible for any one to match him: the author said, that such as could not be killed by one, might by many; adding for proof thereof that Elephants, Lions, Tigers, be they never so great, strong, and swift, are killed. Here suppose that he had withal, in hope of better persuading Maximinus, told him that kTully saith all living creatures may be killed: which to be true in all absolutely and simply, yea even such as no one can lightly overmatch, lTully showeth further; and mXenophon, nPolybius, oLivy, pPliny, qPlutarch, do witness by sundry stories of those beasts. Now, if Maximinus had given ea•e thereto, and answered that him self did differ from those beasts in the manner of his strength, in the end, effects, and other circumstances, as it should appear in examination of the examples; which as the man had cited to illustrate his authorities, as being the creatures whom they properly speak of, so if Maximinus had showed that he was not to be likened to them neither the authorities, nor the examples should touch him; what should the fellow have done, who did make that argument? Should he have denied that Maximinus differed from Elephants, Lions, Tigers, in the manner of his strength, and the rest of your circumstances? ⟨p. 75⟩How could he? when he might have been controlled straight by Maximinus saying: They have no man to their subjects: I rule the whole world; they want helps to shield them from wounds; I wear armour: they can hold no swords, or other weapons; I can: they are of low stature; I am eleven foot high. Should he have granted that because it appeareth by those and the like differences, that Maximinus was not such a living creature as those beasts were, therefore he was no living creature: nether could he be touched either by the examples or by the authorities? That had been to bewray either fear, or ignorance, and to betray the truth: sith the authorities reached to the thing in general; and so the examples brought to illustrate them did touch Maximinus also by consequent.
The autour of this speech meant to reason thus, by way of a syllogisme: Every living creature may be killed: Maximinus the Emperour is a living creature: Therefore hee may bee killed. And least Maximinus through his proud conceit should obiect against it, that every living creature, who could be overmatched by one, might be killed; but it was impossible for any one to match him: the autour saide, that such as could not be killed by one, might by many; adding for proof thereof that Elephants, Lions, Tigers, bee they never so great, strong, and swift, are killed. Here suppose that he had withall, in hope of better perswading Maximinus, tolde him that kTullie saith all living creatures may bee killed: which to bee true in all absolutely and simply, yea even such as no one can lightly overmatch, lTullie sheweth farder; and mXenophon, nPolybius, oLivie, pPlinie, qPlutarch, doe witnesse by sundry stories of those beasts. Now, if Maximinus had given ea•e thereto, and answered that him selfe did differ from those beasts in the maner of his strength, in the end, effectes, and other circumstances, as it should appeare in examination of the examples; which as the man had cited to illustrate his autorities, as being the creatures whom they properly speake of, so if Maximinus had shewed that he was not to be likened to thē neither the autorities, nor the examples should touch him; what should the felow haue done, who did make that argument? Should hee haue denyed that Maximinus differed from Elephants, Lions, Tigers, in the maner of his strength, and the rest of your circumstances? ⟨p. 75⟩How could he? when he might haue bene controlled straight by Maximinus saying: They haue no man to their subiects: I rule the whole world; they want helpes to shield them from wounds; I weare armour: they can holde no swordes, or other weapons; I can: they are of low stature; I am eleven foote high. Should he haue graunted that because it appeareth by those and the like differences, that Maximinus was not such a living creature as those beasts were, therefore he was no living creature: nether could hee be touched either by the examples or by the autorities? That had bene to bewray either feare, or ignorance, and to betray the truth: sith the autorities reached to the thing in generall; and so the examples brought to illustrate them did touch Maximinus also by consequent.
Then belike, albeit the differences, that he might allege against the authors reason had been true all, yet had they all bin idle; as neither disproving the major, nor the minor, whereof the conclusion doeth necessarily follow. This is the condition and state of your differences, Mr. D. Gager; they are not all true, and they are all idle. They are not all true. Nay, is there any of them not untrue in part? Doubtless not the first: wherein you affirm that you differ from them altogether in furniture, & manner of setting out plays: they did it with excessive charge: you thriftily, warily, and almost beggarly. For, I hope, as Irus came beggarly in with you; so 9they would have clothed him in rags too, and could: and such cloaks as they used to borrow for brave wooers, cost 1them no more the fetching, then yours out of the revels: and excess in charges is measured by ability, as rAristotle showeth; the swidow giving two mites, gave more then all the rest: and you in spending pence might be more excessive then they in spending pounds. Not the second difference, touching the manner of action; whereof you say that they acted their plays in an other sort then you do, or can or well know how: but so exquisitely and carefully, that you may seem compared with them either for skill, or diligence, rather Recitare, which I do not dislike, then Agere. For other sort of playing you fancy without ground, saying you know not what of things performed you know not how: I ween you know not, neither ⟨p. 76⟩why they who played unwilling and had small list to learn it; should be more skilful and diligent then yours: sure if yours should seem rather recitare, which I mislike not, then agere; none of yours played tdrunken, nor vdanced, nor 2hurled footstools, nor xput on women's raiment. Not the third difference, which you set in this, that they came on the stage of a lewd, vast, dissolute, wicked, impudent, prodigal, monstrous humour; you contrariwise do it to sundry good intents, as namely (for example) to conform your youth to convenient action. For neither came they all with such a disposition; witness is Laberius, witnesses are others alleged out of Dio; so that you speak herein as if Maximinus had said that those beasts, which the fellow mentioned, are of low stature, a thing untrue in yElephants:
Then belike, albeit the differences, that he might alleage against the autours reason had bene true all, yet had they all bin idle; as neither disprooving the major, nor the minor, whereof the conclusion doeth necessarily follow. This is the condition and state of your differences, Mr. D. Gager; they are not all true, and they are all idle. They are not all true. Nay, is there any of them not vntrue in part? Doutlesse not the first: wherein you affirme that you differ from them altogether in furniture, & maner of setting out playes: they did it with excessiue charge: you thriftily, warily, and almost beggerly. For, I hope, as Irus came beggerly in with you; so 9they would haue clothed him in ragges too, and could: and such clokes as they vsed to borow for brave wooers, cost 1them no more the fetching, then yours out of the revils: and excesse in charges is measured by abilitie, as rAristotle sheweth; the swidow giving two mites, gaue more then all the rest: and you in spending pence might be more excessiue then they in spending poundes. Not the second difference, touching the maner of action; whereof you say that they acted their playes in an other sort then you doe, or can or well know how: but so exquisitly and carefully, that you may seeme compared with them either for skill, or diligence, rather Recitare, which I doe not dislike, then Agere. For other sort of playing you fansie without ground, saying you know not what of thinges perfourmed you know not how: I weene you know not, neither ⟨p. 76⟩why they who played vnwilling and had small list to learne it; should bee more skilfull and diligent then yours: sure if yours should seeme rather recitare, which I mislike not, then agere; none of yours played tdrunken, nor vdaunsed, nor 2hurled footestooles, nor xput on wemens raiment. Not the third difference, which you set in this, that they came on the stage of a lewde, vast, dssolute, wicked, impudent, prodigall, monstrous humour; you contrarywise doe it to sundry good intents, as namely (for example) to conforme your youth to convenient action. For neither came they all with such a disposition; witnesse is Laberius, witnesses are others alleaged out of Dio; so that you speake herein as if Maximinus had said that those beasts, which the felow mentioned, are of low stature, a thing vntrue in
9Horace show eth that they ought; de ar▪ te poetica: & that they had wherewith to do it; Epist. 7. lib. 1 Vilia vendē tem tunicato scruta popello.Horace shew eth that they ought; de ar▪ te poetica: & that they had wherewt to doe it; Epist. 7. lib. 1 Vilia vendē tem tunicato scruta popello.
1Chlamydes Lucullus, ut aiunt, Si posset centum scenae praebere rogatus, Qui possum tot? ait; tamē & quaeram, & quot habebo Mittam. post paulo scribit scribit sibi millia quinque esse domi chlamydum: partem, vel tolleret omnes. Horat. epistolar. li. 1 ep. 6.Chlamydes Lucullus, vt aiunt, Si posset centum scenae praebere rogatus, Qui possum tot? ait; tamē & quaeram, & quot habebo Mittam. post paulo scribit scribit sibi millia quinque esse domi chlamydum: partem, vel tolleret omnes. Horat. epistolar. li. 1 ep. 6.
yOppian. de venat. lib 2 Aeliā. de hist. anim. l. 12. c. 8 Lud. Verto man navigat lib. 4 cap. 10. Petr. Gillius elephanti descript cap 6.Oppian. de venat. lib 2 Aeliā. de hist. anim. l. 12. c. 8 Lud. Verto man navigat lib. 4 cap. 10. Petr. Gillius elephanti descript cap 6.
Nor is it more true that you frame your youth to convenient action, framing some of them to the action of wooers, some of knaves, some of parasites, some of clowns, some of drunkards, some of bragging soldiers, or of the like to these, then that zMaximinus was eleven foot high. Not the fourth difference, wherein (to make a further profit of the circumstance that before you urged against the name of stage-players) you say that they frequented the stage; you do it seldom, sometime not in seven, ten or twenty years. For how do you prove that they whom Juvenal, Tacitus, Dio note, frequented it more then some of yours have? and Laberius did it but once in 3three score years, who yet both called himself a stage-player for that doing, and counted it a stain unto him. The fifth offendeth less, affirming that they did it on the public theatre not of the city only, but of the whole world: you in a private house, and to a few, men of understanding. Yet look by what reason you name the Roman theatre, the theatre of the whole world, your should be the theatre of England, France, and Ireland, if not of whole Europe: and why say you that you did it to men of understanding? as if in Rome women also had been present who might behold the lusty motions of the players, and understand not what they spake; 4none such on your stage. In the sixth you lavish more then in the fourth, saying that they were men grown, one of them three score years old, ⟨p. 77⟩Knights, of noble houses, Patricii, & one of them Emperor of the world: in you being young men, boys, poor Scholars, all these things are quite contrary. For, touching age, among 5them who were compelled by Nero to become stage-players, the stories, which I cited, do record (quite contrary to your quite contrary) that there were not only 6men grown, and 7old, but young too; and some of your players came on the stage as old as aNero, your great Emperor: touching wealth, the beggary of those needy squires, whom out of Juvenal and Tacitus I specified, hath small contrariety unto poor scholars state: touching birth, and gentry, you forgot your self, when, in saying elsewhere, The gentleman that played Ulysses, and setting 8bhis verses before your book, you showed that your players are not quite contrary to Patricii;
noris it more true that you frame your youth to convenient action, framing some of them to the action of wooers, some of knaves, some of parasites, some of clownes, some of drunkards, some of bragging souldiers, or of the like to these, then that zMaximinus was eleven foote high. Not the fourth difference, wherein (to make a farder profit of the circumstance that before you vrged against the name of stage-players) you say that they frequented the stage; you doe it seldom, sometime not in seven, ten or twenty yeares. For how doe you proove that they whom Iuvenal, Tacitus, Dio note, frequented it more then some of yours haue? and Laberius did it but once in 3three score years, who yet both called himself a stage-player for that doeing, and counted it a staine vnto him. The fifth offendeth lesse, affirming that they did it on the publike theater not of the citie onely, but of the whole world: you in a privat house, and to a few, men of vnderstanding. Yet looke by what reason you name the Roman theater, the theater of the whole worlde, your should be the theater of England, France, and Ireland, if not of whole Europe: and why say you that you did it to men of vnderstanding? as if in Rome wemen also had bene present who might behold the lusty motions of the players, and vnderstand not what they spake; 4none such on your stage. In the sixth you lavish more then in the fourth, saying that they were men growne, one of them three score yeares olde, ⟨p. 77⟩Knights, of noble houses, Patricii, & one of them Emperour of the world: in you being young men, boyes, poore Scholers, all these things are quite contrary. For, touching age, among 5them who were compelled by Nero to become stage-players, the stories, which I cited, doe record (quite contrary to your quite contrary) that there were not onely 6men growne, and 7olde, but young too; and some of your players came on the stage as olde as aNero, your great Emperour: touching wealth, the beggerie of those needy squiers, whom out of Iuvenal and Tacitus I specified, hath small contrarietie vnto poore scholers state: touching birth, and gentrie, you forgott your self, when, in saying elswhere, The gentleman that played Ulysses, and setting
zJul. Capitol. in Maximin. duob. Erat magnitudine tanta, ut octo pedes digito videretur egressus.Iul. Capitol. in Maximin. duob. Erat magnitudine tanta, ut octo pedes digito videretur egressus.
3Ego bis tricenis annis actis sine nota, Eques Ro manus è lare e gressus meo Domum revertar mimus. Macro. Saturn. lib. 2 cap. 7.
4At siqua forsan ivveni vellicet togā, Quidque hic agatur scire discupiat nimis, &c. And Rogare veniam à foemi nis non est opus. Prolog. & epilog. in HippolytumAt siqua forsan iuueni vellicet togā, Quidque hic agatur scire discupiat nimis, &c. And Rogare veniam à foemi nis non est opus. Prolog. & epilog. in Hippolytum
5Non nobilitas cuiquam, non aetas, aut acti honores impedimento, quo minus Graeci Latinive histrionis artem exercerent. Tacit. annal. lib. 14.Non nobilitas cuiquam, non aetas, aut acti honores impedimento, quo minus Graeci Latiniue histrionis artem exercerent. Tacit. annal. lib. 14.
unless you think so meanly of his name, and stock, that a 9smoky Lentulus, or Fabius, or Mamercus, doeth pass it in nobility; yea, though it have learning and Scholarship joined with it; neither only pass it, but pass it so far, that not content to make it differ in degree, you make it quite contrary, as if it were of the basest of the rascality. And seeing these things, specially this last point, wherein you must bear with me, if farthermore being taught by cTully, that Lentulitas, what shall I term it? the Lentulusnes of noble parentage is 1nothing in comparison of virtue; nay, being taught by him, whom Tullies dlight came from, even by the eFather of lights, that fthey are most noble who most excel in godliness and graces of the spirit, I account all Christian Scholars and Students, as good and noble gentlemen, as the Heathen Lentuli; but seeing these differences do square so from the trueth: the rest, which are the same, enlarged and applied to particular comparisons of certain of your players with certain of theirs, must needs be enrolled in the same predicament. Howbeit you do utter them in such a gsort, as if you did not only mean to have it though, that there is less resemblance, and therefore greater difference between their players & yours, whom I notwithstanding had compared as like: but also that I should be forced to acknowledge it by mine own confession, and grant that I was wonderfully overseen therein. For you ⟨p. 78⟩ask of me (to set down your own words:) Who ever would resemble our Melantho with your Laureolus? the one represented by an ingenuous boy, and for her lewdness imagined to be hanged within: the other acted by Lentulus, a man nobly descended, expressing perhaps openly on the stage the same punishment. What likeness is there between our young men, putting on the persons of Antinous, and the rest of Penelope's wooers: and between gentlemen of the noble race of Fabius, in their own persons, not so much counterfeiting others, as expressing their own scurrilities? Such as our Antinous and the rest of the wooers can not be justly charged with: no not our Irus, or Ulysses. Again, what resemblance is there between our Hippodamia only singing, Eurimachus only saying, Phemius both singing and saying, all three represented by such as they were:
vnlesse you thinke so meanlie of his name, and stocke, that a 9smokie Lentulus, or Fabius, or Mamercus, doeth passe it in nobilitie; yea, though it haue learning and Scholership ioyned with it; neither onely passe it, but passe it so farre, that not content to make it differ in degree, you make it quite contrarie, as if it were of the basest of the rascalitie. And seeing these things, specially this last point, wherein you must beare with me, if farthermore being taught by cTullie, that Lentulitas, what shall I terme it? the Lentulusnes of noble parentage is 1nothing in comparison of vertue; nay, being taught by him, whom Tullies dlight came from, even by the eFather of lightes, that fthey are most noble who most excell in godlines and graces of the spirit, I account all Christian Scholers and Studentes, as good and noble gentlemen, as the Heathen Lentuli; but seeing these differences doe square so frō the trueth: the rest, which are the same, enlarged and applyed to particular comparisons of certaine of your players with certaine of theirs, must needs be enroled in the same predicament. Howbeit you doe vtter them in such a gsort, as if you did not onely meane to haue it though, that there is lesse resemblance, and therfore greater difference betwene their players & yours, whom I notwithstanding had compared as like: but also that I should be forced to acknowledge it by mine own confession, and graunt that I was wonderfully overseene therein. For you ⟨p. 78⟩aske of me (to sett downe your owne wordes:) Who ever would resemble our Melantho with your Laureolus? the one represented by an ingenuous boy, and for her lewdnes imagined to bee hanged within: the other acted by Lentulus, a man nobly descended, expressing perhaps openly on the stage the same punishment. What likenes is there betwene our young men, putting on the persons of Antinous, and the rest of Penelopes wooers: and betwene gentlemen of the noble race of Fabius, in their owne persons, not so much counterfeiting others, as expressing their own scurrilities? Such as our Antinous and the rest of the wooers can not be iustly charged with: no not our Irus, or Vlysses. Againe, what resemblance is there betweene our Hippodamia onely singing, Eurimachus onely saying, Phemius both singing and saying, all three represented by such as they were:
9Fumosos equitum cum dictatore magistros-Juvenal. satyr. 8.Fumosos equitum cum dictatore magistros-Iuvenal. satyr. 8.
cEpistolar. ad familiar. lib. 3. epi. 7.
1Etiam ne tu has in eptias, ullam App•etatem, aut Lentulitatem valere apud me plus, quā ornamenta virtutis existimas?Etiam ne tu has in eptias, vllam App•etatem, aut Lentulitatem valere apud me plus, quā ornamenta virtutis existimas?
and between Nero, playing mens, women's, and minstrels parts upon the stage in Rome? Behold A marvellous case, that I should compare and resemble players together so absurdly, as no man would ever have done besides me: and that I should affirm them to be like one an other, between whom there is no likeness, no resemblance, as your sharp urging doeth imply. But perhaps your stomach is the more eager against my comparisons, because of our dissension about the stage and plays. The party, that spake in the presence of Maximinus, spake 2upon the stage, and was a 3player himself: it may be you would have used him more gently. For else, had you been there, and loved Maximinus you might (which I marvel if you think not absurd) have answered thus in his behalf. Who ever would resemble Maximinus to an Elephant? the one, a man well featured, and feeding very daintily within doors in his palace: the other a beast, a hthick skin, having a 4nose an 5ell long, and ieating grass perhaps without doors on the mountains. What likeness is there between him, our Emperor, a most gracious personage, and of sweet conditions: and between a Tiger, a kcruel savage beast, wearing lhear of sundry colours, speckled, spotty? Such as our Emperor hath none upon his body: no, nor the like paws, or 6tail. Again what resemblance is there between him, excelling in all three things, greatness, strength, and swiftness: & between an Elephant, ⟨p. 79⟩great and strong only; a Tiger, strong and swift; a Lion having little to trust to, beside strength? Think you that you had spoken with any grain of salt, Mr. D. Gager, if you had spoken thus? Though I have disadvantaged my self in this similitude: because both your Melantho was a great deal liker to Juvenal's Laureolus, your wooers and the rest to those degenerate gentlemen, then Maximinus was to beasts: and I have scarce put one false difference in mine, of Maximinus sweet conditions; you have put many in yours. For, to pass over the ingenuousness of the boy that represented Melantho, opposed to the nobleness of Lentulus who did act Laureolus, the unlikeness whereof in nobleness, and acting, is disproved already; chiefly sith 7things that are not the same, may be like:
and betwene Nero, playing mens, wemens, and minstrels parts vpon the stage in Rome? Beholde A marvelous case, that I should compare and resemble players together so absurdly, as no man would ever haue done besides me: and that I should affirme them to bee like one an other, betwene whom there is no likenes, no resemblance, as your sharpe vrging doeth emply. But perhaps your stomake is the more egre against my comparisons, because of our dissension about the stage and playes. The partie, that spake in the presence of Maximinus, spake 2vpon the stage, and was a 3player himselfe: it may be you would haue vsed him more gentlie. For else, had you bene there, and loved Maximinus you might (which I marvell if you thinke not absurd) haue aunswered thus in his behalfe. Who ever would resemble Maximinus to an Elephant? the one, a man well featured, and feeding very daintily within doores in his palace: the other a beast, a hthicke skinne, having a 4nose an 5ell long, and ieating grasse perhaps without doores on the mountaines. What likenes is there betwene him, our Emperour, a most gratious personage, and of sweete conditions: and betweene a Tigre, a kcruell savage beast, wearing lheare of sundry coolours, speckled, spotty? Such as our Emperour hath none vpon his body: no, nor the like pawes, or 6taile. Againe what resemblance is there betweene him, excelling in all three things, greatnes, strength, and swiftnes: & betwene an Elephant, ⟨p. 79⟩great and strong onely; a Tigre, strong and swift; a Lion having litle to trust to, beside strength? Thinke you that you had spoken with any graine of salt, Mr. D. Gager, if you had spoken thus? Though I haue disadvantaged my self in this similitude: because both your Melantho was a great deale liker to Iuvenals Laureolus, your wooers and the rest to those degenerat gentlemen, then Maximinus was to beastes: and I haue scarse put one false difference in mine, of Maximinus sweete conditions; you haue put many in yours. For, to passe over the ingenuousnes of the boy that represented Melantho, opposed to the noblenes of Lentulus who did act Laureolus, the vnlikenes whereof in noblenes, and acting, is disprooved already; chiefly sith
2In theatro.
3Scurra mimus. Jul. Capitolin. In whom it is printed, minus: by error, for mimus, as I take it.Scurra mimus. Iul. Capitolin. In whom it is printed, minus: by error, for mimus, as I take it.
4So is his proboscis termed by Aristotle. de hist. ani lib. 2. cap. 1. and by Oppian, de venat. lib. 2.
5Or two yards, some of them, with the advantage. Petr. Gillius eleph. descript. cap. 5. & 6.Or two yardes, some of them, with the advantage. Petr. Gillius eleph. descript. cap. 5. & 6.
first, what proof have you, that 8they, whom Juvenal noted under the name of Fabii, did not so much counterfeit others, which your wooers did, as express their own scurrilities? When contrariwise some of them would have hid their faces with 9visors, for shame, that they might not be known, as counting the infamy thereof worse then death: a very great presumption, that they did abhor from expressing their own scurrilities on the stage, whom it grieved so much to come on the stage at all.
first, what proofe haue you, that 8they, whom Iuvenal noted vnder the name of Fabii, did not so much counterfeit others, which your wooers did, as expresse their owne scurrilities? When contrariwise some of them would haue hid their faces with 9visours, for shame, that they might not be knowne, as counting the infamie thereof worse then death: a very great presumption, that they did abhorre from expressing their own scurrilities on the stage, whom it greeved so much to come on the stage at all.
8The gentlemen of noble houses which Dio specifieth: and [Greek or Hebrew] among them namely.The gentlemen of noble houses which Dio specifieth: and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 among them namely.
9[Greek or Hebrew]. Dio Neron.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Dio Neron.
Next, what wrong is it to charge your Antinous, and other of the whores, with such scurrilities, as theirs? were not the mplays that they played made of like arguments, in like sort, to yours? Is not Antinous set forth by nHomer, as a malapert lknave? to speak in oHorace's phrase, of him and his complices. Do pyou not follow Homer, and express Antinous with the rest accordingly, both in their misbehaviour of words & of deeds? Thirdly, do you know what is meant in Juvenal by planipedes Fabios, when I having said that the race of Fabius resembled & counterfeited such base ridiculous things as are expressed in Irus, you deny that he may be justly charged with such? And if you know that they, who were termed qplanipedes, counterfeited such things as rLaberius did when he put on the person of a bondslave whipped: are you not ashamed to deny that such are expressed in Irus, a beggar buffeted, thrown down, and 2haled out by the feet, the wooers laughing ⟨p. 80⟩thereat? Finally, why are not the blows, in your tragedy, given to Ulysses, like the 3Mamercians whirrets that Juvenal speaketh of? you think them not so bad. I think them worse rather. For whirrets, that he speaketh of, were given with the hand. Your Ulysses is 4stricken with Melanthius heel, and 5with Antinous foot-stool: unless Antinous hurling it did miss the mark, and played not his part as you appointed him out of 6Homer. Thus are your differences all untrue, in part: in whole, a number of them. But suppose they were true. Yet are they all idle: because, as in the fellows speech to Maximinus, the major being proved that all living creatures may be killed, whether one or many be able to surprise them; the minor apparent, that he was a living creature; the conclusion followed, notwithstanding whatsoever differences between him, and them, whose examples were brought to prove the major: likewise in my reason, the major being proved, that all stage-players are infamous by the civill law, whether they play for gain, or freely; the minor apparent, that they who play your plays on the stage, are stage-players; the conclusion followeth, notwithstanding whatsoever differences between yours, and them whose examples for proof of the major I produced. Nay, I say further, that as some true differences between Maximinus, and the beasts, do sharpen the edge of the conclusion against him;
Next, what wrong is it to charge your Antinous, and other of the whoores, with such scurrilities, as theirs? were not the mplayes that they played made of like arguments, in like sort, to yours? Is not Antinous sett foorth by nHomer, as a malapert lknave? to speake in oHoraces phrase, of him and his complices. Doe pyou not followe Homer, and expresse Antinous with the rest accordinglie, both in their misbehaviour of wordes & of deedes? Thirdlie, doe you know what is meant in Iuvenal by planipedes Fabios, when I having said that the race of Fabius resembled & counterfaited such base ridiculous things as are expressed in Irus, you denie that hee may bee iustlie charged with such? And if you know that they, who were termed qplanipedes, counterfaited such things as rLaberius did when he put on the person of a bondslaue whipped: are you not ashamed to deny that such are expressed in Irus, a begger buffeted, throwne down, and 2haled out by the feete, the wooers laughing ⟨p. 80⟩thereat? Finally, why are not the blowes, in your tragedie, given to Vlysses, like the 3Mamercians whirrets that Iuvenal speaketh of? you thinke them not so badde. I thinke them worse rather. For whirrets, that hee speaketh of, were given with the hande. Your Ulysses is 4strooken with Melanthius heele, and 5with Antinous foote-stoole: vnlesse Antinous hurling it did misse the marke, and played not his part as you appointed him out of 6
mJuvenal. sat. 8. Sueton Ner cap. 2•. Dio Ner.Iuvenal. sat. 8. Sueton Ner cap. 2•. Dio Ner.
for if sgreater, stronger, and swifter creatures are killed, how much more might he be? so for you to be stage-players it is more shameful then for the old Romans, sith they were tignorant, vinfidels, xwithout God in the world; you are Scholars, Christians, chosen to be trained up unto the Ministry; and yunto whom much is committed, the more shall be required of him; zthey who have many sins forgiven them, should love much; it is a great offence ato give the Nazarites wine to drink, though to bdrink wine be not unlawful. Wherefore that of Terence wherewith you conclude, saying that you think it was a foul shame for noble men and Nero to play, but to play noble men or Nero it is no shame for you; as che saith in the Comedy, Duo quum idem faciunt, saepe, ut possis dicere, Hoc liceti mpunè facere huic, illi non licet; Non quòd dissimilis ⟨p. 81⟩res sit, sed quòd is qui facit: although you straiten the point (whether for shame, or for the figure?) when you speak of playing noble men and Nero, your purpose being to justify the playing of the dbasest, drunkards, & ewhores too; but if Terence's saying would fit the point in question, the use thereof must be to prove that they might lawfully come on the stage, you may not. The truth is that it cannot be applied hereto, because fthe law speaketh generally of stage-players, as it doeth of bawds, of thieves, with the like; and common sense doeth teach us, that 7we may not distinguish where the law distinguisheth not. Else, if I should say that by the same law our English thieves, who rob on Gads hill, are infamous; one of their abetters might answer, No not so: for the Law speaketh of such as gLucius Tubulus, men of wealth and state, who robbed the whole world repairing unto Rome; not of poor good fellows that rob a few Kentish men travailing to Graves-end: and I think it was a foul shame for rich men and Tubulus to rob; but to rob rich men and Tubulus, it is no shame for us: as he saith in the Comedy, that oftentimes, you may say, when two men do the same thing, the one is not blameworthy for it, the other is, not as if there were difference in the thing it self, but in the man that doeth it. Which Comical sentence, though it might be as well applied by Justice Graybeard to the excuse of theft in poor men, as by Terence's 8Mitio it is to the excuse of whoredom in a young man;
for if sgreater, stronger, and swifter creatures are killed, how much more might he be? so for you to be stage-players it is more shamefull then for the olde Romans, sith they were tignorant, vinfidels, xwithout God in the world; you are Scholers, Christians, chosen to be trained vp vnto the Ministerie; and yvnto whom much is committed, the more shall be required of him; zthey who haue many sinnes forgiven them, should loue much; it is a great offence ato giue the Nazarites wine to drinke, though to bdrinke wine be not vnlawfull. Wherefore that of Terence wherewith you conclude, saying that you thinke it was a fowle shame for noble men and Nero to play, but to play noble men or Nero it is no shame for you; as chee saith in the Comedie, Duo quum idem faciunt, saepe, vt possis dicere, Hoc liceti mpunè facere huic, illi non licet; Non quòd dissimilis ⟨p. 81⟩res sit, sed quòd is qui facit: although you straiten the point (whether for shame, or for the figure?) when you speake of playing noble men and Nero, your purpose being to iustifie the playing of the dbasest, drunkards, & ewhooers too; but if Terences saying would fitt the point in question, the vse thereof must bee to proove that they might lawfully come on the stage, you may not. The truth is that it cannot bee applyed hereto, because fthe law speaketh generally of stage-players, as it doeth of bawdes, of theeves, with the like; and common sense doeth teach vs, that
7Ubi lex non distinguit, nec nos distinguere debemus. Gloss ad li. […]. D de Public. in rem act. li. 1. §. quod autem. D. de aleatoribus.Vbi lex non distinguit, nec nos distinguere debemus. Gloss ad li. 〈…〉. D de Public. in rem act. li. 1. §. quod autem. D. de aleatoribus.
yet were it unjustly applied thereunto: because the law condemning theft in whomsoever without respect of persons, be they rich or poor, doeth count it none of those things which fall within the compass of Terence's 9oftentimes. So considering, stage-players are spoken of in like sort, as thieves, by the law: you see how Terence's saying may be applied unto them. But if we might apply it unto them justly, we must infer thereof that it was no shame for Nero & his mates to come on the stage, for you it is: as S. Paul commandeth us hnot to eat with any that is called a brother, if he be a fornicator; which, iwith an infidel committing the same filthiness, he doeth not forbid. And thus while you endeavour to unwind your self out of the nett of ignominy and infamy ⟨p. 82⟩cast upon you by the civill law, you are bound faster in it: to the fulfilling of that proverb, which I wish you had marked in the kComedy rather, if not in the lScripture, It is hard to kick against pricks.
yet were it vniustly applied therevnto: because the law condemning theft in whomsoever without respect of persons, bee they rich or poore, doeth count it none of those things which fall within the compasse of Terences 9oftentimes. So considering, stage-players are spoken of in like sort, as theeves, by the law: you see how Terences saying may be applied vnto them. But if we might apply it vnto them iustly, wee must inferre thereof that it was no shame for Nero & his mates to come on the stage, for you it is: as S. Paul commandeth vs hnot to eate with any that is called a brother, if he be a fornicatour; which, iwith an infidell committing the same filthines, he doeth not forbid. And thus while you endevour to vnwind your selfe out of the nett of ignominie and infamie ⟨p. 82⟩cast vpon you by the civill lawe, you are bound faster in it: to the fulfilling of that proverbe, which I wish you had marked in the kComedie rather, if not in the lScripture, It is hard to kicke against prickes.
In the second head, to a reason drawn out of the law of God for the reproof of stage-plays as now you handle it, denying that you made it to prove that men may lawfully put on women's raiment therein, as I took it; though how just cause I had to take it so, I have declared; but unto this reason grounded on the mlaw of God in Deuteronomy, Whatsoever man doeth put on woman's raiment, he is abominable to the Lord; But men did put on women's raiment in your plays; you must acknowledge therefore that you were justly blamed: you reply in like sort as unto the former of the civill law; first, that the prohibition of men to wear women's raiment is not general, but toucheth certain cases only; next, that your players did not wear women's raiment. And because in treating of the prohibition I showed out of the Scriptures, that it doeth belong not to the ceremonial law, but to the moral; and no part of the moral law may be transgressed, no, not for the saving of honour, wealth, or life: my proofs hereof being so clear, strong, and pregnant, that you durst not deny the thing to be proved, you move a doubt, as your term is, out of words of mine; in deed you reason thus against it. I pray you give me leave to propose my contrary doubt. The moral law, as you truly say, is the law of love and charity; to the which wheresoever the ceremonial law is repugnant, there it giveth place to the moral. The moral law therefore is never contrary to love and charity, in commanding or forbidding any thing. But the place of Deuteronomy, being taken strictly, absolutely, and in the rigour of the letter, may sometimes hinder the actions of love and charity, both towards our selves and others; as in those cases, which both you and I propose. Ergo in that strictness it belongeth rather to the law ceremonial, though the equity thereof pertaineth to the law moral, and so it is perpetually and simply to be observed. Now, I have given you leave to propose your contrary doubt. I pray you give me leave to propose my contrary question. In the ⟨p. 83⟩same book of Deuteronomy it is written, nThou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adultery. These precepts being taken strictly, absolutely, and in the rigour of the letter, may sometimes hinder the actions of love and charity, both towards our selves and others; as appeareth by the example of Joseph, and of David:
In the second head, to a reason drawn out of the law of God for the reproofe of stage-playes as now you handle it, denying that you made it to proove that men may lawfully put on wemens raiment therein, as I tooke it; though howe iust cause I had to take it so, I haue declared; but vnto this reason grounded on the mlaw of God in Deuteronomie, Whatsoever man doeth put on womans raiment, he is abominable to the Lord; But men did put on wemens raiment in your playes; you must acknowledge therefore that you were iustly blamed: you reply in like sort as vnto the former of the civill law; first, that the prohibition of men to weare wemens rayment is not generall, but toucheth certaine cases onely; next, that your players did not weare wemens raiment. And because in treating of the prohibition I shewed out of the Scriptures, that it doeth belong not to the ceremoniall law, but to the morall; and no parte of the morall law may bee transgressed, no, not for the saving of honour, wealth, or life: my proofes hereof beeing so cleere, strong, and pregnant, that you durst not deny the thing to bee prooved, you moue a dout, as your terme is, out of wordes of mine; in deede you reason thus against it. I pray you giue mee leaue to propose my contrary dout. The morall law, as you truely say, is the law of loue and charitie; to the which wheresoever the ceremonial law is repugnant, there it giveth place to the morall. The morall law therefore is never contrarie to loue and charitie, in commanding or forbidding any thing. But the place of Deutero nomie, being taken strictly, absolutely, and in the rigor of the letter, may sometimes hinder the actions of loue and charitie, both towards our selves and others; as in those cases, which both you and I propose. Ergo in that strictnes it belongeth rather to the law ceremoniall, though the equitie thereof pertaineth to the law morall, and so it is perpetually and simply to bee observed. Nowe, I haue given you leaue to propose your contrary dout. I pray you giue me leaue to propose my contrary question. In the ⟨p. 83⟩same booke of Deuteronomie it is written, nThou shalt not kill, Thou shalt not commit adulterie. These precepts beeing taken strictly, absolutely, and in the rigor of the letter, may sometimes hinder the actions of loue and charitie, both towardes our selves and others; as appeereth by the example of Ioseph, and of David:
Joseph, who olost his liberty and put his life in hazard, because phe refused to commit adultery with his Masters wife; David, who qcast his followers and him self into sundry dangers and distresses, because rhe would not kill Saul. Hereupon I ask you, whether you think, that seeing the moral law bound Joseph & David to slove their neighbours, & themselves, therefore they should have made no scruple of adultery and murder, in these cases, in which the forbearing thereof did hinder the actions of love toward them selves and others: but ought to have judged those precepts in that strictness to belong rather to the law ceremonial, though the equity thereof pertaineth to the law moral, and so it is perpetually and simply to be observed. Which if you think not, as God forbid you should, and you will profess (as I am persuaded) that you detest such thoughts: then do you acknowledge that it came rather of a lust to cross and contradict my speech, then of any doubt you had within your self, that you say, a precept, which being strictly kept might breed some disadvantage to our selves or others, must in this respect be counted ceremonial, and not be kept strictly, because the moral law is never contrary to love and charity in commanding or forbidding any thing. And sure you might have reason to take it not well, if I should suppose you to be so ill catechized, as that you knew not that the moral law commandeth us to tlove God above all things, and man after him; that vour love to Godward is proved by the observing and keeping of his commandments; that if by keeping of them we should seem to hate man, we must xhate him rather, then not perform our love to God: that it followeth not hereof the law is contrary unto love neither, because to hate man so is to ylove him less then God, in comparison, and not in deed to hate him; nay, it is to love him, sith it is to wish him and work him zgreater good by loss of less good which ⟨p. 84⟩he can not retain therewith. Howbeit, had you doubted, yet might you have found enough to resolve you, if you had read my writing rather with a mind to learn, then to gainsay, in as much as I showed by Scripture touching Peter, that he should not have lied to avoid the danger of whatsoever trouble: because to lye is evil;
Ioseph, who olost his libertie and put his life in hazard, because phe refused to commit adulterie with his Maisters wife; David, who qcast his folowers and him selfe into sundry dangers and distresses, because rhe would not kill Saul. Herevpon I aske you, whether you thinke, that seeing the morall lawe bound Ioseph & David to sloue their neighbours, & themselves, therefore they should haue made no scruple of adulterie and murder, in these cases, in which the forbearing thereof did hinder the actions of loue toward them selves and others: but ought to haue iudged those precepts in that strictnes to belong rather to the law ceremonial, though the equitie thereof pertaineth to the law moral, and so it is perpetually and simply to be observed. Which if you thinke not, as God forbid you should, and you will professe (as I am perswaded) that you detest such thoughts: then doe you acknowledge that it came rather of a lust to crosse and contradict my speech, then of any dout you had within your selfe, that you say, a precept, which beeing strictly kept might breede some disadvantage to our selves or others, must in this respect bee counted ceremoniall, and not be kept strictly, because the morall law is never contrarie to love and charitie in commanding or forbidding any thing. And sure you might haue reason to take it not well, if I should suppose you to be so ill catechized, as that you knew not that the moral law commandeth vs to tloue God aboue all things, and man after him; that vour loue to Godward is prooued by the obseruing and keeping of his commandements; that if by keeping of them we should seeme to hate man, we must xhate him rather, then not performe our loue to God: that it foloweth not hereof the law is contrary vnto loue neither, because to hate man so is to yloue him lesse then God, in comparison, and not in deede to hate him; nay, it is to loue him, sith it is to wish him and worke him
not allowed in any case by our law-giver, no not for the defence of the glory of God, much less for the safety of man, a worm. Or, if, notwithstanding all that this could teach you, there might some occasion of doubting still remain: should you not have rather sought to be resolved by me in private conference, then publicly in writing (made common with many, even in the country also, not only in our University) to affirm a point implying flat atheism, that we are no further to keep Gods commandments, then stands with our commodity? and so conclusively to vouch it with an Ergo, as if it did follow necessarily, that all the laws of God (for your reason holdeth by consequent in all) must be set aside, like ceremonial matters, when our own, or other mens, honour, wealth, or life, cometh in question with them? and to add that the equity thereof yet pertaineth to the law moral, and so they are perpetually and simply to be observed? which seemeth by distinguishing their equity from strictness to strengthen them in sound meaning; in deed destroyeth them by teaching their transgressors how to defend most gross iniquity: as idolaters, for example, when, if aNebuchadnezzar do threaten he will burn all who worship not his golden image, they may say, that albeit in Deuteronomy God saith, bThou shalt not bow down to them, nor worship them, yet sith the moral law is never contrary to love in forbidding any thing, and the place of Deuteronomy, being taken strictly, would hinder now mens actions of love toward them selves; Ergo in that strictness it belongeth rather to the law ceremonial, though the equity thereof pertaineth to the law moral, and so it is perpetually and simply to be observed. A sentence so ungodly, that when Peter only touched it a far off, or rather less then touched it, speaking of a particular case, no general law; nor Ergoing against it, nor terming the keeping of it strictness, nor plastering the breach of it with equity: but ⟨p. 85⟩when he tended towards it by saying to our Saviour, cMaster, pity thy self, this shall not be unto thee, our Saviour answered him, Get thee behind me, Satan, thou art an offence unto me, because thou savourest not the things that are of God, but the things that are of men.
not allowed in any case by our law-giver, no not for the defense of the glorie of God, much lesse for the safetie of man, a worme. Or, if, notwithstanding all that this could teach you, there might some occasion of doubting still remaine: should you not haue rather sought to be resolved by me in private conference, then publikelie in writing (made common with many, even in the country also, not onely in our Vniversitie) to affirme a point implying flat atheisme, that wee are no farder to keepe Gods commaundements, then standes with our commoditie? and so conclusivelie to vouch it with an Ergo, as if it did folow necessarilie, that all the lawes of God (for your reason holdeth by consequent in all) must be sett aside, like ceremoniall matters, when our owne, or other mens, honour, wealth, or life, cometh in question with them? and to adde that the equitie thereof yet pertayneth to the law moral, and so they are perpetuallie and simplie to be observed? which semeth by distinguishing their equitie from strictnes to strēgthen them in sound meaning; in deede destroyeth them by teaching their transgressors how to defend most grosse iniquitie: as idolaters, for example, when, if aNabuchodonosor doe threaten he will burne al who worship not his golden image, they may say, that albeit in Deuteronomie God saith, bThou shalt not bowe downe to them, nor worship them, yet sith the morall law is never contrary to loue in forbidding any thing, and the place of Deuteronomie, being taken strictlie, would hinder now mens actions of love toward them selues; Ergo in that strictnes it belongeth rather to the law ceremoniall, though the equitie thereof pertaineth to the law morall, and so it is perpetuallie and simplie to be observed. A sentence so vngodlie, that when Peter onely touched it a farre off, or rather lesse then touched it, speaking of a particular case, no generall law; nor Ergoing against it, nor terming the keeping of it strictnes, nor plaistering the breach of it with equitie: but ⟨p. 85⟩when he tended towards it by saying to our Saviour, cMaister, pitie thy selfe, this shall not bee vnto thee, our Sauiour answered him, Gett thee behind me, Satan, thou art an offense vnto me, because thou savourest not the things that are of God, but the things that are of men.
Suitable to this new argument of yours is the defence of your old (the only one you pressed before) from two examples. For whereas you had reasoned thus, Some men of Macedonia, moved by Prince Alexander, did putt on Women's raiment to save the honour of Ladies; the like did Achilles, the son of Thetis, to save his life; Ergo it is lawful to do it in such cases; and I made answer thereto, that the reason is naught, because we are to live by laws, not by examples; neither may we lye or forswear our selves to save our lives, or benefit others, though David & Peter did so, men worthier to be followed then Macedonians, or Achilles: you reply, that the reason is good (this must you mean by saying that the examples are alleged to good purpose in the circumstances that you apply them for, or else you delude us with an other sophism;) and why? For Alexander's fact is commended (say you) as proceeding from a most noble, and true heroical mind; and because it was better that the Persian Ambassadors were slain, then that the chastities of so many great Ladies should so dishonourably be either overthrown, or so much as assailed: and Thetis might well hide her son Achilles in a maidens apparel in respect of motherly love & pity which she was to bear her son, knowing, as she did, that he should be slain in that journey to Troy, whether he was requested to accompany the other Grecian Lords. Touching the former whereof, to admit, that Alexander's fact proceeded from a noble true heroical mind, and that it was better the Persian Ambassadors were slain then the chastities of so many great Ladies should so dishonourably be overthrown, or assailed: yet doeth it not follow that men might therefore lawfully put women's raiment on to kill them; the thing might be convenient and good to be done, the means of doing it not good. As 1it is better that a person guilty should be left unpunished, then a person guiltless should be condemned: and 2he, whose saying this was, spake it ⟨p. 86⟩of a noble true heroical mind. Yet were the means naught to procure by bribes or by false witnesses the escape or acquittal of a guilty person: and if any man, who had used such dealing, should be commended for it, he should be commended amiss in that respect, as Alexander is by you.
Sutable to this new argument of yours is the defense of your olde (the onely one you pressed before) from two examples. For whereas you had reasoned thus, Some men of Macedonie, mooved by Prince Alexander, did putt on Wemens raiment to save the honor of Ladies; the like did Achilles, the sonne of Thetis, to save his life; Ergo it is lawfull to doe it in such cases; and I made answer thereto, that the reason is naught, because we are to live by lawes, not by exāples; neyther may we lye or forsweare our selves to save our lives, or benefitt others, though David & Peter did so, men worthier to be folowed then Macedonians, or Achilles: you reply, that the reason is good (this must you meane by saying that the examples are alleadged to good purpose in the circumstances that you apply them for, or else you delude vs with an other sophisme;) and why? For Alexanders fact is commended (say you) as proceeding from a most noble, and true heroicall minde; and because it was better that the Persian Embassadors were slaine, then that the chastities of so many great Ladies should so dishonorably be either overthrowne, or so much as assailed: and Thetis might well hide her sonne Achilles in a maidens apparell in respect of motherlie love & pitie which shee was to beare her sonne, knowing, as shee did, that hee should be slaine in that iourney to Troy, whether he was requested to accompanie the other Grecian Lords. Touching the former wherof, to admitt, that Alexanders fact proceeded from a noble true heroicall minde, and that it was better the Persian Embassadours were slaine then the chastities of so many great Ladies should so dishonorably be overthrowne, or assailed: yet doeth it not folow that men might therefore lawfullie put womens raiment on to kill them; the thing might be cōvenient and good to be done, the meanes of doeing it not good. As 1it is better that a person guiltie should bee left vnpunished, then a person guiltlesse should be condemned: and 2he, whose saying this was, spake it ⟨p. 86⟩of a noble true heroicall minde. Yet were the meanes naught to procure by bribes or by false witnesses the escape or acquittall of a guiltie person: and if any man, who had vsed such dealing, should be commended for it, he should bee commended amisse in that respect, as Alexander is by you.
1Satius est impunitum relinqui facinus nocentis, quàm innocentem damnari.
2Trajan the Emperor lib. 19. D. de poenis.Trajan the Emperour lib. 19. D. de poenis.
Now, for the later, how prove you that Thetis might well hide her son Achilles, as she did? You say, that you think not but she might do it well. So. Your reason then is: I think she might do it well; Ergo she might. A common kind of argument with you; but thin, and lean: nor likely to prove better at the length in trial, of whatsoever plight it seem in your writing. For let it fare as it may in Topics, in Analytics it must fast: it can not away with mood and figure. And what if you think not that she might neither? as I think you do not; unless you think contraries, or speak otherwise then you think. For your self affirm, that the putting on of women's raiment which is termed an abomination to the Lord in the place of Deuteronomy, is the wearing of it ordinarily, so to converse among men and women, against the course of all natural and civill regard. But Thetis, intending thereby to hide Achilles, did clothe him to converse so ordinarily among men and women: even longer, then he would endure to converse so; though dhe endured for certain years. Therefore that, which she did, you think to be abominable: yea, pronounced in Scripture an abomination to the Lord. The less material is it whether that be true which by the way I noted, that Statius the Poet making Chiron, Calchas, and Achilles himself to reprove the putting of that raiment on him, meant that men of wise, virtuous, religious, ingenuous, valiant minds, did judge the thing simply in any case unlawful by the light of nature. Though I wish our judges, unto whose arbitrement I refer the matter, whether you control me therein well, or no, to mark that for Chiron, in whom are represented wise and virtuous persons, albeit you affirm he had a further reach then his words outwardly import: yet in setting down that reach you add, perhaps, as staggering at your own conceit; and withal acknowledge that his words outwardly, whereof you can not prove an ⟨p. 87⟩other inward meaning, import as much as I said. Beside that they may justly suspect your partial censure, because, where I had likewise noted by the way that the fact of Achilles, deflowering Deidamia by means and occasion of his conversing so with her, doeth show what inconvenience and danger of uncleanness cleaveth to the cladding of men in women's raiment:
Now, for the later, how proove you that Thetis might well hide her sonne Achilles, as shee did? You say, that you thinke not but she might doe it well. So. Your reason then is: I thinke shee might doe it well; Ergo she might. A common kinde of argument with you; but thinne, and leane: nor likely to proove better at the length in triall, of whatsoever plight it seeme in your writing. For let it fare as it may in Topickes, in Analytickes it must fast: it can not away with moode and figure. And what if you thinke not that shee might neither? as I thinke you doe not; vnlesse you thinke contraries, or speake otherwise then you thinke. For your selfe affirme, that the putting on of wemens rayment which is termed an abomination to the Lord in the place of Deuteronomie, is the wearing of it ordinarily, so to converse among men and wemen, against the course of all naturall and civill regard. But Thetis, intending thereby to hide Achilles, did clothe him to converse so ordinarily among men and wemen: even longer, then he would endure to converse so; though dhe endured for certaine yeares. Therefore that, which shee did, you thinke to bee abominable: yea, pronounced in Scripture an abomination to the Lorde. The lesse materiall is it whether that be true which by the way I noted, that Statius the Poet making Chiron, Calchas, and Achilles himselfe to reproove the putting of that raiment on him, meant that men of wise, vertuous, religious, ingenuous, valiant mindes, did iudge the thing simply in any case vnlawfull by the light of nature. Though I wish our iudges, vnto whose arbitrement I referre the matter, whether you controll me therein well, or no, to marke that for Chiron, in whom are represented wise and vertuous persons, albeit you affirme hee had a furder reache then his words outwardly import: yet in setting down that reache you adde, perhaps, as staggering at your owne conceit; and withall acknowledge that his words outwardly, whereof you can not proove an ⟨p. 87⟩other inward meaning, import as much as I said. Beside that they may iustly suspect your partiall censure, because, where I had likewise noted by the way that the fact of Achilles, deflowring Deidamia by meanes and occasion of his conversing so with her, doeth shewe what inconvenience and danger of vncleannes cleaveth to the cladding of men in wemens raiment:
dStatius Achilleid. li. 2. Natum ante pedes projecit. Neoptolemum. De quo Verg. Aeneid. lib. 2 Apollod. de orig. Deor. lib. 3.
you do overthwartly & wrongfully cross my note by saying that he was likely to do as much in his own likeness any where else. For let malefactors be never so ready to practise any wickedness of their own corrupt and lewd inclination: the circumstances of manner, season, place, and so forth, commodious to perform it do more entice them thereunto. Weapons them selves (saith eHomer) do draw men to fight: and 3opportunity maketh the eves. The force whereof in this thing I said enough to open by that, as fChaerea could not have defiled Pamphila, no not in Thais house, without his Eunuchs raiment: so, if woman's raiment had not come on gClodius, Caesar should not have put away his wife Pompeia so soon as he did; perhaps never. Or are you of opinion that with us it skilleth not whether scholars lodge in Colleges & Halls, or in townsmen's houses? Yea, although they be neither so much conversant, nor go in like attire, as Achilles used with Lycomedes daughter? Our Saviour said to his Disciples, hIf thy foot cause thee to offend, cut it of; if thine eye cause thee to offend, pluck it out: meaning that we must sever our selves from things and persons that are most dear unto us, if they be an occasion unto us of sin, and hinder us in the way of life. Yet a man that had heard him with your disposition, might have said, What needs it? seeing though we cut off one foot, or pluck out one eye, the other is likely to cause us to offend. Upon Moses words in Genesis, touching Dinah, that ishe went out to see the daughters of that country, and Shechem ravished her, kgodly learned interpreters observe that her wandering and idle curiosity is noted and reproved as an occasion of the villainy that was done unto her. Yet a gadding humour and wanton eye of maidens loth to follow S. lPauls rule and keep at home, might say that such teachers are puritans, who can not abide whitsun-ladies: for ⟨p. 88⟩Shechem was likely to do as much to Dinah, though she had kept at home in her fathers house, and never come in Shechem's sight. The very fact in question, whereon you mislike that I made this note of such occasions and enticements, hath the same observed therein by the mPoet, the wise reporter of it: namely, that Achilles lust was first kindled by seeing Deidamia; afterward increased by conversing with her;
you doe overthwartly & wrongfully crosse my note by saying that hee was likely to doe as much in his owne likenes any where else. For let malefactours bee never so ready to practise any wickednes of their owne corrupt and lewde inclination: the circumstances of maner, season, place, and so foorth, commodious to performe it doe more entise them therevnto. Weapons them selves (saith eHomer) doe draw men to fight: and 3opportunitie maketh the eves. The force whereof in this thing I said enough to open by that, as fChaerea could not haue defiled Pamphila, no not in Thais house, without his Eunuches raiment: so, if womans rayment had not come on gClodius, Caesar should not haue put away his wife Pompeia so soone as he did; perhaps never. Or are you of opinion that with vs it skilleth not whether scholers lodge in Colleges & Halls, or in townesmens houses? Yea, although they bee neither so much conversant, nor go in like attire, as Achilles vsed with Lycomedes daughter? Our Saviour said to his Disciples, hIf thy foote cause thee to offend, cutt it of; if thine eye cause thee to offend, plucke it out: meaning that wee must sever our selves from thinges and persons that are most deare vnto vs, if they be an occasion vnto vs of sinne, and hinder vs in the way of life. Yet a man that had heard him with your disposition, might haue said, What needes it? seeing though we cutt off one foote, or plucke out one eye, the other is likely to cause vs to offend. Vpon Moses wordes in Genesis, touching Dina, that ishee went out to see the daughters of that country, and Sichem ravished her, kgodly learned interpreters observe that her wandering and idle curiositie is noted and reprooved as an occasion of the vilanie that was done vnto her. Yet a gadding humour and wanton eye of maidens loth to folow S. lPaules rule and keepe at home, might say that such teachers are puritans, who can not abide whitson-ladies: for ⟨p. 88⟩Sichem was likely to doe as much to Dina, though shee had kept at home in her fathers house, and never come in Sichems sight. The very fact in question, whereon you mislike that I made this note of such occasions and entisements, hath the same observed therein by the
eOdyss. li. 2• [Greek or Hebrew].Odyss. li. 2•〈non-Latin alphabet〉.
and finally accomplished by coming through the fallacy of his attire, like a woman, 4whither else in likeness of a man he could not. But whatsoever Statius judged of the matter, or others shall judge of that I noted by the way; you grant it was abominable by the law of God, for Thetis to put woman's raiment on her son Achilles, as she did. And so you have rather confirmed, then confuted, mine answer to your argument from the two examples of Macedonians and Achilles. You come in now anew with half a dozen more: three of men, attiring them selves in women's raiment; three of women, in mens. And quoting 5their names only in your margin, you say that if you had thought that these two examples should not have been taken in your meaning, that is, only in the circumstance for the which you alleged them, you could have used many true stories of both sexes, to the which no such exceptions could have been taken. Wherein, to pass over, that by giving the name of true to those stories, you make it very probable that you meant nbefore under the name of stories, the fable of Achilles, as I supposed you did by the drift of your words, (speaking first in general of 6stories proving 7two points; then bringing 8one in special to prove the one of them, 9Achilles to prove the other) which yet you deny to have been your meaning, and charge me with untruth in effect for saying it: you do further charge me that I have not taken those two examples in your meaning. No have? Why? Meant you not by them to conclude, that a man may lawfully put on woman's raiment, to save his life, or benefit many, because in such cases Achilles and the Macedonians did put on such raiment? And have not I expressly set this reason down, affirming it to be your reason, and making mine answer accordingly thereto? yes: but I ⟨p. 89⟩have also in mine answer to it noted other circumstances of the same examples, thereby to make plainer the badness of your reason: and so I have not taken them in your meaning, that is (as you expound it) only in the circumstance for the which you alleged them. You are a merry man, and not much unlike in this respect to one, who when he had taken up a waster and buckler in Cheapside at London to play with an apprentice, & the apprentice rapped him, sometime upon the head, sometime upon the elbow, or shoulder, or side, he cast them down again;
and finally accomplished by coming through the falacie of his attire, like a woman, 4whither else in likenes of a man hee could not. But whatsoever Statius iudged of the matter, or others shall iudge of that I noted by the way; you graunt it was abominable by the lawe of God, for Thetis to put womans raiment on her sonne Achilles, as shee did. And so you haue rather confirmed, then confuted, mine aunswere to your argument from the two examples of Macedonians and Achilles. You come in now anew with halfe a dozen more: three of men, attiring them selves in wemens raiment; three of wemen, in mens. And quoting 5their names onely in your margent, you say that if you had thought that these two examples should not haue bene taken in your meaning, that is, onely in the circumstance for the which you alleaged them, you could haue vsed many true stories of both sexes, to the which no such exceptions could haue bene taken. Wherein, to passe over, that by giving the name of true to those stories, you make it very probable that you meant nbefore vnder the name of stories, the fable of Achilles, as I supposed you did by the drift of your wordes, (speaking first in generall of 6stories prooving 7two points; then bringing 8one in speciall to proove the one of them, 9Achilles to proove the other) which yet you deny to haue bene your meaning, and charge mee with vntruth in effect for saying it: you doe farder charge me that I haue not taken those two examples in your meaning. No haue? Why? Meant you not by them to conclude, that a man may lawfully put on womans raiment, to saue his life, or benefite many, because in such cases Achilles and the Macedonians did put on such raiment? And haue not I expressely set this reason downe, affirming it to be your reason, and making mine aunswere accordingly thereto? yes: but I ⟨p. 89⟩haue also in mine aunswer to it noted other circumstances of the same examples, therby to make plainer the badnes of your reason: and so I haue not taken them in your meaning, that is (as you expound it) onely in the circumstance for the which you alleaged them. You are a mery man, and not much vnlike in this respect to one, who when hee had taken vp a waster and buckler in Cheapeside at London to play with an apprentice, & the apprentice rapped him, sometime vpon the head, sometime vpon the elbow, or shoulder, or side, hee cast them downe againe;
4Lex procal ire mares: iterat praecepta verendus Ductor, inaccessumque viris edicitur antrum. Nec satis est: stat fine dato metuenda sacerdos, exploratque aditus; nequis temerator ob erret Agmine faemineo: Tacitus sub•isit Apollo.
nUlyss. red. resp. ad Momum.Vlyss. red. resp. ad Momum.
6Id quod crebra testari potest Histor.
7Quid si cogeret lethi metus Mutare vestem? publicum quid si bonum Suaderet?
8Veste filius Amyntae indui Juvenes muliebri dumb •bet, tot faeminis Claris pudorē servatVeste filius Amyntae indui Iuvenes muliebri dum •bet, tot faeminis Claris pudorē servat
saying, that if he had thought that the apprentice would not have stricken upon his buckler still, he would not have played with him. Yet in this you vary from the vain of his speech, that you say you could have used many true stories of both sexes, to the which no such exceptions could have been taken. Though you help your self no more by this varying, then if his skill had served him to have warded all the blows with his buckler; his weakness being nevertheless unable to resist, but that he might have had his buckler beaten about his ears. For what if no such exceptions could be taken against your six examples? Doeth not the same answer that I made to your reason from the Macedonians example, and Achilles, beat down these also to the ground: sith none of them is equal to David, or to Peter, whose actions notwithstanding are no sufficient warrants for us? Moreover, as in beheading of noble personages, that are traitors, the executioner, having cut of their heads, doeth hold them up in his hands, & show them to the people: so I, having thus beheaded, as it were, these your six examples, I mean, the reason drawn from them, perhaps (notwithstanding your confident assertion that no such exceptions can be taken against them) might hold them up in my hands, and show that they are dead, by the like or more absurd consecutions from other circumstances thereof. For example, in one or two, the chiefest of them, the first of each sex, Euclides, and Euphrosyna; the story of Euclides is, that when the oAthenians, having their neighbours of Megara in great hatred, had decreed that if any of the men of that city were found within Athens, he should suffer death: Euclides being of it, and loth ⟨p. 90⟩to lose the benefit of the school of Socrates, with whom he used to be at Athens and to hear him, before that law was made, did cloth himself in woman's attire towards evening; went from his house in Megara to Athens, unto Socrates; enjoyed his speech and conference some part of the night time; and when day approached, returned home again a little more then twenty miles in the same attire.
saying, that if he had thought that the apprentice would not haue stroken vpon his buckler still, he would not haue played with him. Yet in this you vary from the vaine of his speech, that you say you could haue vsed many true stories of both sexes, to the which no such exceptions could haue bene taken. Though you helpe your selfe no more by this varying, then if his skill had served him to haue warded all the blowes with his buckler; his weaknes being neverthelesse vnable to resist, but that he might haue had his buckler beaten about his eares. For what if no such exceptions could be taken against your six examples? Doeth not the same aunswer that I made to your reason from the Macedonians example, and Achilles, beate downe these also to the ground: sith none of them is equall to David, or to Peter, whose actions notwithstanding are no sufficient warrants for vs? Moreover, as in beheading of noble personages, that are traitours, the executioner, having cutt of their heads, doeth hold them vp in his handes, & shew them to the people: so I, having thus beheaded, as it were, these your six examples, I meane, the reason drawne from them, perhaps (notwithstanding your confident assertion that no such exceptions can bee taken against them) might hold them vp in my handes, and shew that they are dead, by the like or more absurd consequutions from other circumstances thereof. For example, in one or two, the chiefest of them, the first of eche sexe, Euclides, and Euphrosyna; the storie of Euclides is, that when the oAthenians, hauing their neighbours of Megara in great hatred, had decreed that if any of the men of that citie were found within Athenes, he should suffer death: Euclides being of it, and loth ⟨p. 90⟩to lose the benefit of the schoole of Socrates, with whom hee vsed to be at Athenes and to heare him, before that law was made, did cloth himselfe in womans attire towardes evening; went from his house in Megara to Athenes, vnto Socrates; enioyed his speech and conference some parte of the night time; and when day approched, returned home againe a litle more then twentie miles in the same attire.
Now, if this were lawfully done, because he did it: then pWilliam Bishop of Ely, who, to save his honour and wealth, became a 1green-sleeves, going in woman's raiment less way then twenty miles, from Dover castle to the Sea side, did therein like a man; although the women of Dover, when they had found it out by plucking down his muffler & seeing his new-shaven beard, 2called him a monster for it: then with us a scholar, who thinketh of some man, as Euclid did of Socrates, and can not well frequent his house in the day time for suspicion of lewdness with his Xanthippe, or of Popery, may come like a maiden thither in the night: then our University Statute of night-walkers would be taken away, or qualified at least; and if our Proctors meet one like a woman at midnight, they must not be suspicious; some studious youth, it may be, come from Wickam or Beaconsfield, and daring not to travail by day for thieves through Shotover, is going to some learned man. In like sort, touching Euphrosyna, a maid of Alexandria, (of Antioch 3you name her, by slip of pen or memory) the story is, that qshe, desiring much to live in an Abbey like a monk, 4forsook not only her father, who had brought her up to be a staff in his old age, a comfort in his weakness to him; but also a 5worthy, noble, virtuous gentleman, to whom she was betrothed; clad in mans apparel she came unto the Abbot; and being asked of him who she was, from what place, & for what cause she came, she answered, that 6her name in deed was Smaragdus, and she was of the Emperors Court, and came to that Abbey to lead a holy life, if she might be admitted; and so finding favour to be admitted as a man, she lived there 7eight and thirty years in mans apparel. Whereof if you infer again, as you do, Euphrosyna did it, Ergo lawful; ⟨p. 91⟩a better proof, I grant, then, Achilles did it, or Macedonians did it, because they were profane men, rEuphrosyna is a Saint; but as you reason thus: likewise may an other in the same mood and figure; Euphrosyna, through a desire of monkish perfection, refused to honour her father; Ergo sChrist did wrongfully check the Scribes and Pharisees for breaking Gods commandments to keep traditions of men: Euphrosyna chose rather to be with others then with him to whom she was betrothed;
Now, if this were lawfully done, because he did it: then pWilliam Bishop of Ely, who, to saue his honour and wealth, became a 1greene-sleeues, going in womans raiment lesse way then twenty miles, from Douer castle to the Sea side, did therein like a man; although the wemen of Douer, when they had found it out by plucking downe his muffler & seeing his newshauen beard, 2called him a monster for it: then with vs a scholer, who thinketh of some man, as Euclide did of Socrates, and can not well frequent his house in the day time for suspitiō of lewdnes with his Xanthippe, or of Poperie, may come like a maiden thither in the night: then our Vniuersitie Statute of night-walkers would be taken away, or qualified at least; and if our Proctors meete one like a womā at midnight, they must not be suspicious; some studious youth, it may be, come from Wickam or Beaconsfield, and daring not to trauaile by day for theeues through Shotouer, is going to some learned man. In like sort, touching Euphrosyna, a maide of Alexandria, (of Antioche 3you name her, by slippe of penne or memorie) the storie is, that qshe, desiring much to liue in an Abbay like a monke, 4forsooke not onely her father, who had brought her vp to be a staffe in his olde age, a comfort in his weaknes to him; but also a 5worthy, noble, vertuous gentleman, to whom she was betrothed; clad in mans apparell she came vnto the Abbat; and being asked of him who she was, from what place, & for what cause she came, she answered, that 6her name in deede was Smaragdus, and she was of the Emperours Court, and came to that Abbay to leade a holy life, if she might be admitted; and so finding fauour to be admitted as a man, she liued there 7eight and thirty yeares in mans apparell. Whereof if you inferre againe, as you doe, Euphrosyna did it, Ergo lawfull; ⟨p. 91⟩
pMatt. Paris. hist. Ang. in Ricardo pry.Matt. Paris. hist. Ang. in Ricardo pri.
1Tunica viridi faeminea indutus; capam habens ejusdem coloris, peplum in capite muliebre portans.Tunica viridi faeminea indutus; capam habens ejusdem coloris, peplum in capite muliebre portās.
2Mulierculae clamorem ad sidera tollentes, Venite, inquiunt, & lapidemus hoc monstrū, quod sexum utrumque deformavit.Mulierculae clamorem ad sidera tollentes, Venite, inquiunt, & lapidemus hoc monstrū, quod sexum vtrumque deformavit.
3Euphrosyna virgo Antioch
qSim Metaphrast. vit. S. Euphrosynes Alexandr. apud Surium, de probat. Sanct. histor. Tom. 1.
4Cur metuum parentem lugentē & tristē reliquisti? Non te ad hanc spem alebam, sed ut haberē baculum senectutis, solatium imbecillitatis meae.Cur metuum parentem lugentē & tristē reliquisti? Non te ad hanc spem alebam, sed vt haberē baculum senectutis, solatium imbecillitatis meae.
Ergo Moses erred in teaching that a tmaid betrothed is a vwife, & that xthe wife should cleave inseparably to her husband: Euphrosyna lied for a vantage; Ergo St. yJohn was a precisian, who condemneth all lies: Euphrosyna conversed in mens apparel, amongst men, eight and thirty years; Ergo D. Gager mistook the place of Deuteronomy, when he gave it this meaning, that to go attired so ordinarily is abomination to the Lord. See you now what manner if true stories, of true all, you could have used of both sexes? and how bold you were in saying that no such exceptions could be taken to them, as to the former? The which notwithstanding, were it as you say, you do no more help your argument thereby, then if a traitor being beheaded, whom you favoured, you stayed the executioner from holding up his head, and sowed it on again your self to his body with close and hansom stitches. For although no such exceptions could be taken to any of your examples, yet had I beheaded with the zthe sword of Gods word the reason drawn from them: and with Justinian's sword too, in that I adjoined for your sake out of your law, that we are to live by laws, not by examples: and to 8look, not so much what is done any where, as what ought to be done.
Ergo Moses erred in teaching that a tmaide bethrothed is a vwife, & that xthe wife should cleaue inseparably to her husband: Euphrosyna lyed for a vantage; Ergo St. yIohn was a precisian, who condemneth all lyes: Euphrosyna conuersed in mens apparell, amongst men, eight and thirty yeares; Ergo D. Gager mistooke the place of Deuteronomie, when he gaue it this meaning, that to goe attired so ordinarily is abomination to the Lord. See you now what maner if true stories, of true all, you could haue vsed of both sexes? and how bold you were in saying that no such exceptions could be taken to them, as to the former? The which notwithstanding, were it as you say, you doe no more helpe your argument thereby, then if a traitour being beheaded, whom you favoured, you staied the executioner from holding vp his head, and sowed it on againe your selfe to his body with close and hansom stitches. For although no such exceptions could be taken to any of your examples, yet had I beheaded with the zthe swoord of Gods woord the reason drawne from them: and with Iustinians swoord too, in that I adioyned for your sake out of your law, that we are to liue by lawes, not by examples: and to 8looke, not so much what is done any where, as what ought to be done.
8Non tam spectandum est quid Romae factū sit, quàm quid fieri debeat. lib. 12. D. de Officio Praesid.Non tam spectandum est quid Romae factū sit, quàm quid fieri debeat. lib. 12. D. de Officio Praesid.
Hereunto you add an other new argument to show that the place of Deuteronomy toucheth certain cases only, not generally forbiddeth a man to put on woman's raiment: and that is, the opinion and judgement of Divines. For after you had delivered these expositions of it, as liked by your self, that to wear such raiment of a lewd intent, the rather thereby, & the more safely to be in the company of women to bring some bad purpose about; or of an effeminate mind to suffer his hear to grow ⟨p. 92⟩long, or to frizzle it; or in speech, colour, gate, gesture, and behaviour to become womanish; or ordinarily so to converse among men and women, against the course of all natural, and civill regard, is abomination to the Lord: and noted it moreover to be expounded by other thus, that women are forbidden to put on the armour of men, and men the raiment of women, because at that time it was superstitious, in as much as among the Gentiles women wore mens armour in the sacrifices of Mars, and men wore women's ornaments and instruments, as distaff, spindle, and such like, in the sacrifices of Venus; and therefore is it added that he who doth so is abominable to God because abomination is taken in the Scriptures commonly for idolatry, or some thing belonging to idolatry: but after you had set down these expositions, you say that all the Divines whom ever you talked with of this matter, do affirm the true meaning of that place to be contained in these senses rehearsed. Wherein by alleging the consent of all Divines that ever you talked with hereof, as making for you, first, you grant your self never to have talked here of with S. Cyprian, Chrysostom, Procopius, Thomas Aquinas, Liranus, Calvin, Hyperius, Beza, Bishop Babingtō; who making it a point annexed (as I showed) to the seventh commandment, do imply the meaning thereof to be larger then your rehearsed senses: never with aClemens Alexandrinus, bGulielmus Parisiensis, cDionysius Carthusianus, dFerus, eFagius, fDanaeus; who by handling it in like sort as the former, do testify their agreement with them in the conclusion: never with Tertullian, gLactantius, hAustin, the Bishops assembled in the sixth general council to the number of above two hundred and twenty:
Hereunto you adde an other new argument to shew that the place of Deuteronomie toucheth certaine cases onely, not generally forbiddeth a man to put on womans raiment: and that is, the opinion and iudgement of Diuines. For after you had deliuered these expositions of it, as liked by your selfe, that to weare such raiment of a lewde intent, the rather thereby, & the more safely to be in the company of wemen to bring some bad purpose about; or of an effeminate minde to suffer his heare to grow ⟨p. 92⟩long, or to frizell it; or in speech, colour, gate, gesture, and behaviour to become womanish; or ordinarily so to conuerse among men and wemen, against the course of all naturall, and civill regard, is abomination to the Lord: and noted it moreover to be expounded by other thus, that wemen are forbidden to put on the armour of men, and men the raiment of wemen, because at that time it was superstitious, in as much as among the Gentiles wemen woare mens armour in the sacrifices of Mars, and men woare wemens ornaments and instruments, as distaffe, spindell, and such like, in the sacrifices of Venus; and therefore is it added that he who doth so is abominable to God because abomination is taken in the Scriptures commonly for idolatrie, or some thing belonging to idolatrie: but after you had sett downe these expositions, you say that all the Divines whom ever you talked with of this matter, doe affirme the true meaning of that place to be conteined in these senses rehearsed. Wherein by alleaging the consent of all Diuines that euer you talked with hereof, as making for you, first, you grant your self never to haue talked here of with S. Cyprian, Chrysostome, Procopius, Thomas Aquinas, Liranus, Calvin, Hyperius, Beza, Bishop Babingtō; who making it a point annexed (as I shewed) to the seventh commandemēt, doe imply the meaning therof to be larger then your rehearsed senses: neuer with aClemens Alexandrinus, bGulielmus Parisiensis, cDionysius Carthusianus, dFerus, eFagius, fDanaeus; who by handling it in like sort as the former, doe testifie their agreement with them in the conclusion: neuer with Tertullian, g
who partly by urging that place against stage-players partly by condemning the thing it speaketh of, as lewd, do evidently argue that they are of a different mind from you concerning it. Or sith you having had the most of these quoted in my letters to you, do grant, for Cyprian namely & the general council, that they make against you, & therefore seem, in citing all that ever you talked with; to mean not such as you have read and perused, but whom you have asked thereof by word of mouth: then, why should you more enforce against ⟨p. 93⟩me the sayings and judgment of all that ever you talked with, then I against you the sayings and judgements of all that ever I talked with? For as you report of them whom you talked with that they are very godly and excellently learned: in like sort may I of them whom I talked with. And of mine you can not but the rather believe me, because I named you one, of whom your self answer, that you esteem him to be a good man, a good scholar, and a good Preacher: you name me none of yours. Again, there hath not any of yours in public place, where men do speak with greater advise to Christian auditories, avouched that which you hold: he, whom you commend, and commend justly, hath preached the same that I teach. But, you say, he could not justify his speech, uttered so publicly, if it should come to due trial. But, I say, this speech of yours so publicly uttered is come to due trial, and you can not justify it. For he, having opened the words of his text, iLet me not wander from thy commandments, & begun to show what a contrary course unto the Prophets practise we take now a days, did prosecute it thus. To let pass other things, let stage-plays in the University, and Maygames in the town, speak whether these things be so. In kDeuteronomy the precept is, The woman shall not put on mans raiment, nether shall a man putt on woman's raiment; for all that do so are abomination to the Lord: And it is the lApostles precept to abstain from all appearance of evil. Whether the former precept be broken in all plays, I know not. Sure very few or none there are, wherein either the one, or both, is not broken: either through the vile scurrility of the matter oftentimes unbeseeming chaste ears; or thorough the time for the preparing for them; or through the unnecessary charges about them;
who partly by vrging that place against stage-players partly by condemning the thing it speaketh of, as lewde, doe evidently argue that they are of a different minde from you concerning it. Or sith you hauing had the most of these quoted in my letters to you, doe grant, for Cyprian namely & the generall concel, that they make against you, & therfore seeme, in citing all that euer you talked with; to meane not such as you haue read and perused, but whom you haue asked thereof by woord of mouth: then, why should you more enforce against ⟨p. 93⟩mee the sayings and iudgment of all that euer you talked with, then I against you the sayings and iudgements of all that euer I talked with? For as you report of them whom you talked with that they are very godly and excellently learned: in like sorte may I of them whom I talked with. And of mine you can not but the rather beleeue me, because I named you one, of whom your selfe answer, that you esteeme him to be a good man, a good scholer, and a good Preacher: you name me none of yours. Againe, there hath not any of yours in publike place, where men doe speake with greater advise to Christian auditories, avouched that which you hold: he, whom you commend, and commend iustly, hath preached the same that I teach. But, you say, he could not iustifie his speech, vttered so publikely, if it should come to due triall. But, I say, this speech of yours so publikely vttered is come to due triall, and you can not iustifie it. For he, hauing opened the woords of his text, iLet me not wander from thy commandements, & begonne to shew what a cōtrary course vnto the Prophets practise we take now a daies, did prosequute it thus. To lett passe other things, let stage-playes in the Vniuersitie, and Maygames in the towne, speake whether these things be so. In kDeuteronomie the precept is, The woman shall not put on mans raiment, nether shall a man putt on womans raiment; for all that doe so are abomination to the Lord: And it is the lApostles precept to abstaine from all appearance of evill. Whether the former precept be broken in all playes, I know not. Sure very few or none there are, wherein either the one, or both, is not broken: either through the vile scurrilitie of the matter oftentimes vnbeseeming chast eares; or thorough the time for the preparing for them; or through the vnnecessarie charges about them;
or through the manifold dangers coming both to actors, and spectators, by them. Hereupon, having added somewhat touching maygames, he made this exhortation. The Prophet prayeth unto the Lord, that he may not wander from his commandments. His action ought to be thine instruction: and art thou so far from following him that thou treadest his law under thy feet, and castest his words behind thee? Take heed, fear, and tremble; thou hast not to deal with ⟨p. 94⟩man, but with God: who hath left thee his law, not to dally withal, or cunningly to deceive thy self with thine own glosses upon the same, but to be the witness of his will, and rule of thy life. This is the same speech, and all, that he did utter so publicly hereof; set down in writing by him self before he uttered it: a speech, that in this present trial between us is already justified, and shall be declared further to be mgold, silver, precious stones, in the day of great trial. So shall the same doctrine delivered by S. Cyprian, the sixth general council, and other worthy men: when of the contrary side your wood, hay, stubble, shall be consumed by fire. In the mean season your self do lay open your own corrupt affections, & blaze your own shame sundry ways. One, in that you say, that you trust you shall not seem to any man to wrong S. Cyprian & the rest, if you follow the opinion of others both very godly & excellently learned, who do interpret that text of Deuter. otherwise then he, or they do: specially in a case that toucheth you so near, wherein you are to defend your self and many your good friends from the reproach of open infamy. For you speak therein, as if the question being of an other text, nThou shalt not give to usury unto thy brother, owhich some newer writers expound against unmerciful and cutting usury, as they term it; not against all usury, as Austin with a number of ancient Fathers doeth; an usurer should say: I trust I shall not seem to any man to wrong S. Austin and the rest, if I follow the opinion of others, both very godly and excellently learned, who do expound that text otherwise then he, or they do; specially in a case that toucheth me so near, wherein I am to defend my self, and many my good friends, from great discredit and discommodity. An other, in that you add, that you well wot it little becometh you to say, Da veniam Cyprian.
or through the manifold daungers comming both to actors, and spectators, by them. Herevpon, having added somewhat touching maygames, he made this exhortation. The Prophet prayeth vnto the Lorde, that hee may not wander from his commandementes. His action ought to be thine instruction: and art thou so farre from folowing him that thou treadest his law vnder thy feete, and castest his wordes behinde thee? Take heede, feare, and tremble; thou hast not to deale with ⟨p. 94⟩man, but with God: who hath left thee his law, not to dally withall, or cunningly to deceve thy selfe with thine owne glosses vpon the same, but to bee the witnesse of his will, and rule of thy life. This is the same speech, and all, that hee did vtter so publikely hereof; set downe in writing by him selfe before hee vttered it: a speech, that in this present triall betweene vs is already iustified, and shall bee declared farder to be mgold, silver, pretious stones, in the day of great triall. So shall the same doctrine delivered by S. Cyprian, the sixth generall councel, and other worthy men: when of the contrary side your wood, hay, stubble, shal be consumed by fire. In the meane season your self doe lay open your own corrupt affections, & blaze your own shame sundry wayes. One, in that you say, that you trust you shall not seeme to any man to wrong S. Cyprian & the rest, if you folow the opiniō of others both very godly & excellentlie learned, who do interpret that text of Deuter. otherwise then hee, or they doe: specially in a case that toucheth you so neere, wherin you are to defende your selfe and many your good frends from the reproch of open infamie. For you speake therein, as if the question beeing of an other text, nThou shalt not giue to vsurie vnto thy brother, owhich some newer writers expound against vnmercifull and cutting vsurie, as they terme it; not against all vsurie, as Austin with a number of ancient Fathers doeth; an vsurer should saye: I trust I shall not seeme to any man to wrong S. Austin and the rest, if I folow the opinion of others, both very godly and excellenly learned, who doe expound that text otherwise then hee, or they doe; specially in a case that toucheth mee so neere, wherin I am to defend my selfe, and many my good frendes, from great discredit and discommoditie. An other, in that you adde, that you well wote it litle becommeth you to say, Da veniam Cypriane.
In deed, for my self, whom in this you glance at, I must confess I thought that it did become pme to say, Da veniam Cyprian, upon the circumstances that I said it: which, if it were a fault, though D. qFulke thought otherwise, but if it were, it was of error; and I will recant it, if you confute the 9reasons that moved me to think it did become me so to say. But you, who wot well (by your own confession) ⟨p. 95⟩it little becometh you to say, Da veniam Cyprian, do thereby acknowledge, that although you are persuaded, as you pretend, the proper natural sense of the word of God to be on your side, not on Cyprian's; in trueth you are not so. For else you would think that it should become you very well to say, Pardon me, O Cyprian: sith you know, I hope, that it became the Apostles very well to say, rWe ought rather to obey God then men. And if it do little become you to say, Pardon me, O Cyprian, when yet you dissent from him and contradict him: then you glozed in saying that with all humbleness you reverence his authority; seeing, to crave 1leave and pardon, in dissenting, is a sign of reverence. And if to use so mild words, Pardon me, O Cyprian, it become you little: how much less, to say, as in effect you do, 2It is a cursed gloss, O Cyprian, which thou makest? And if unto Cyprian alone it little becometh you to say so much: how greatly unbeseeming is it for you to say it unto such a number, both of old, & new interpreters, besides him? Finally, for an upshot, where you say that he, as a godly man, was carried with a vehement & a perfect hatred against the detestable abuses of the heathen spectacles in his time: you grant that the spectacles of plays set forth by you have detestable abuses in them; sith the 3tragedies, the playing whereof he detesteth, are such as your Ulysses; the 4Comedies, as your Rivals: and so, how little care you have of being godly, who are not only not carried with an hatred, I say not, with a vehement & perfect hatred, against them, but also dote upon them, & write defences of them, I judge you not, your own mouth judgeth you. As for those godly and learned Divines, who being talked withal by you touching the true sense of the place of Deuteronomy, did make that answer which you mention: what if they, misliking your resolute intent, did follow the example of Michaeas the Prophet?
In deede, for my selfe, whom in this you glance at, I must confesse I thought that it did become pme to saye, Da veniam Cypriane, vpon the circumstances that I said it: which, if it were a fault, though D. qFulke thought otherwise, but if it were, it was of errour; and I will recant it, if you confute the 9reasons that mooved me to thinke it did become mee so to say. But you, who wote well (by your owne confession) ⟨p. 95⟩it litle becommeth you to say, Da veniam Cypriane, doe thereby acknowledge, that although you are perswaded, as you pretend, the proper naturall sense of the worde of God to bee on your side, not on Cyprians; in trueth you are not so. For else you would thinke that it should become you very well to say, Pardon mee, O Cyprian: sith you know, I hope, that it became the Apostles very well to say, rWee ought rather to obey God then men. And if it doe litle become you to saye, Pardon mee, O Cyprian, when yet you dissent from him and contradict him: then you glozed in saying that with all humblenesse you reverence his autoritie; seeing, to craue 1leaue and pardon, in dissenting, is a signe of reverence. And if to vse so milde words, Pardon mee, O Cyprian, it become you litle: how much lesse, to say, as in effect you doe, 2It is a cursed glosse, O Cyprian, which thou makest? And if vnto Cyprian alone it litle becommeth you to say so much: how greatly vnbeseeming is it for you to say it vnto such a number, both of olde, & new interpreters, besides him? Finally, for an vpshoote, where you say that he, as a godly man, was caried with a vehement & a perfit hatred against the detestable abuses of the heathen spectacles in his time: you graunt that the spectacles of playes sett foorth by you haue detestable abuses in them; sith the 3tragedies, the playing whereof he detesteth, are such as your Ulysses; the 4Comedies, as your Rivales: and so, how litle care you haue of being godly, who are not only not caried with an hatred, I say not, with a vehemēt & perfit hatred, against them, but also dote vpon them, & write defenses of thē, I iudge you not, your own mouth iudgeth you. As for those godly and learned Divines, who being talked withall by you touching the true sense of the place of Deuteronomie, did make that answer which you mention: what if they, misliking your resolute intent, did folow the example of Michaeas the Prophet?
pPraefat. thes. de sacr. scrip. and eccles.
qHis answer to the preface of Gre. Mar. discovery, sect. 15.His answere to the preface of Gre. Mar. discovery, sect. 15.
9Set down in the end of my conference with Hart: in the Defence of such things as Tho. Stapleton, & Gregory Martin have carped at in my Theses.Set down in the end of my conference wt Hart: in the Defence of such things as Tho. Stapleton, & Gregorie Martin haue carped at in my Theses.
1Quod divinarum Scripturarum autoritati congruit in literis Cypriani, cū laude eius accipio: quod autem non congruit, cum pace eius respuo. August. cont. Cresco. gramma. lib. 2 cap. 32.Quod divinarum Scripturarum autoritati congruit in literis Cypriani, cū laude eius accipio: quod autem non cōgruit, cum pace eius respuo. August. cont. Cresco. gramma. lib. 2 cap. 32.
2Maledicta textum glossa quae vitiat bonū. Ulyss. red. resp. ad Mom.Maledicta textum glossa quae vitiat bonū. Vlyss. red. resp. ad Mom.
3Cothurnus est tragicus prisca facinora carmine recensere: de parricidis & incestis horror antiquus, expressa ad imaginē veritatis actione, replicatur Cypr. epist. 2 ad Donat.Cothurnus est tragicus prisca facinora carmine recensere: de parricidis & incestis horror antiquus, expressa ad imaginē veritatis actione, replicatur Cypr. epist. 2 ad Donat.
4Ut ad scenae sales inverecundos transitum faciam, pudet referre quae dicuntur pudet etiam accusare quae fiunt: agentium strophas, adulterorum fallacias, mulierum impudicitias, scurriles jocos, parasitos sordidos; ipsos quoque patres familiâs togatos, modo stupidos, modò obscoenos, in omnibus stolidos, certis nominibus inverecundos. Cyprian. de spectac. cap. 5.Vt ad scenae sales inverecundos transitum faciam, pudet referre quae dicuntur pudet etiam accusare quae fiunt: agentium strophas, adulterorum fallacias, mulierum impudicitias, scurriles iocos, parasitos sordidos; ipsos quoque patres familiâs togatos, modo stupidos, modò obscoenos, in omnibus stolidos, certis nominibus inverecundos. Cyprian. de spectac. cap. 5.
swho being asked by king Ahab whether he should go against Ramoth Gilead to battle, or leave off; did answer him, Go up, & prosper; & the Lord shall deliver it into the hand of the king. What if in a merriment, knowing why you asked it, they spake unto you, as Cassellius a lawyer unto a certain Roman? ⟨p. 96⟩tOf whom, when Uatinius having had stones thrown at him by the people, to whom he was odious, did purpose to set forth a spectacle of fencers, and had gotten the magistrates to make proclamation that no man should cast ought into the place of spectacles saving an apple only; Cascellius being asked, whether a pine apple were an apple, If thou mean to hurl it at Vatianus, it is, quoth he. What if you mistook the sum of their answer, or a word therein? they telling you perhaps that the true meaning of the place of Deuteronomy doeth contain those senses which are rehearsed by you; and you misconstruing them as if they had said that the true meaning thereof is contained in those senses rehearsed, and so may in no case be extended further. Of which three conjectures (you force me to divine of them, and between them, because you would not name the parties whom you cite, that by them selves I might learn what they said, and why,) the last in my opinion seemeth most probable: considering it is likely that godly learned men would look what had been written upon the place by interpreters; and the interpreters, whose words, even translated by you in a manner, are an evident token what your Divines told you, do specify those things as meant, in such sort, that they deny not but more might be meant; yea most of them affirm the general to be meant also. For, of five particulars (so many you set down) Strabus, the author of the ordinary Gloss, hath two: namely that a man 5must not become womanish in colour, gate, and so forth; nor 6suffer his hear to grow long, or frizzle it. The other three, that he may not put on woman's raiment, 7thereby the more safely to be in women's company, to bring about some bad purpose; nor 8ordinarily so to converse among men and women, against the course of natural & civill regard; nor 9to be womanlike in the sacrifices of Venus: these hath Gulielmus Alvernus, Bishop of Paris, and Carthusianus after him; Aquinas, and Liranus too, the last of them. Now Strabus saith not that those two things alone are meant:
swho being asked by king Achab wheher he should go against Ramoth Gilead to battell, or leaue off; did answer him, Go vp, & prosper; & the Lord shall deliver it into the hand of the king. What if in a meriment, knowing why you asked it, they spake vnto you, as Cassellius a lawier vnto a certaine Roman? ⟨p. 96⟩tOf whom, when Uatinius having had stones throwne at him by the people, to whom he was odious, did purpose to set forth a spectacle of fensers, and had gotten the magistrates to make proclamation that no man should cast ought into the place of spectacles saving an apple onely; Cascellius beeing asked, whether a pine apple were an apple, If thou meane to hurle it at Vatianus, it is, quoth he. What if you mistooke the summe of their answer, or a worde therein? they telling you perhaps that the true meaning of the place of Deuteronomie doeth containe those senses which are rehearsed by you; and you misconstruing them as if they had said that the true meaning thereof is contained in those senses rehearsed, and so may in no case bee extended farder. Of which three coniectures (you force me to divine of them, and betweene them, because you would not name the parties whom you cite, that by them selves I might learne what they said, and why,) the last in my opinion seemeth most probable: considering it is likely that godly learned men would looke what had bene written vpon the place by interpreters; and the interpreters, whose wordes, even translated by you in a maner, are an evident token what your Divines tolde you, doe specifie those thinges as meant, in such sort, that they deny not but more might bee meant; yea most of them affirme the generall to be meant also. For, of five particulars (so many you set down) Strabus, the autour of the ordinarie Glosse, hath two: namely that a man 5must not become womanish in colour, gate, and so foorth; nor 6suffer his heare to grow long, or frizill it. The other three, that hee may not put on womans raiment, 7thereby the more safely to be in wemens company, to bring about some bad purpose; nor 8ordinarily so to converse among men and wemen, against the course of naturall & ciuill regard; nor 9
5Mulieris naturaliter diversus est color, motus, incessus, vires
6Comam crispare, torquere capillos: undeApostolus, vir si comam nutrierit, ignominia est. illi.Comam crispare, torquere capillos: vndeApostolus, vir si comam nutrierit, ignominia est. illi.
7Posset intrare vir ad mulierē sub habitu muliebriPosset intrare vir ad mulierē sub habitu muliebri
8Quas natura sexu discreverat, discernat & vestitus.
9In sacris Veneris viri effaeminabantur. Or, as Liranus speaketh, whose words you express, portabant ornamenta & instrumenta mulierū, utpote column, fusum & similia.In sacris Veneris viri effaeminabantur. Or, as Liranus speaketh, whose wordes you expresse, portabant ornamenta & instrumēta mulierū, vtpote colum, fusum & similia.
the rest do say that so much more is meant then the other three, as proveth my assertion. For the vBishop of Paris, cited and abridged by Dionysius Carthusianus, among sundry causes why the law of ⟨p. 97⟩God should forbid a man to put on woman's raiment, giveth this for one, 1that a great occasion of provoking men to lust might be taken away. For 2the apparel of women (saith he) is a great provocation of men to lust and lechery: because a 3woman's garment being put on a man doeth vehemently touch and move him with the remembrance & imagination of a woman; and 4the imagination of a thing desirable doth stir up the desire. The same in 5fewer words Aquinas doeth affirm. And Liranus further, having declared what moved him to prefer the last exposition (rehearsed by your self, though somewhat confusedly, which I was bold to mend in the recital of it, the better here to be understood) saith, that if the text be meant of common apparel, 6then is such an use or rather abuse forbidden, because it is an occasion of wantonness and lust. Wherein he hath relation to that, whereas the 7word, used in the former branch of the sentence touching mens furniture not to be worn by women, doeth sometime signify common apparel, sometime armour; he had said, that this place, he thought, the signification of armour fitted best: induced thereunto because he had read that women in the sacrifices of Mars did bear armour; and the reason added, for all that do so are abomination to the Lord, might well enough agree, sith matters of idolatry are commonly in the Scriptures termed abomination. But seeing it appeareth not by sufficient proof that women wore mens armour in the sacrifices of Mars, or men wore women's distaffs, spindles, and such like, in the sacrifices of Venus; and the later branch of the law forbidding a man to put on woman's 8raiment, doeth show that common apparel is meant in the former, as S. Hierome also in the vulgar 9Latin translation hath noted: it followeth that Liranus resteth and resolveth upon the general sense and exposition as truest. By consequence whereof the word, abomination, must not be restrained to matters of idolatry, but taken in his natural meaning: according to the like use thereof in like places, where the xlaw condemneth those execrable villainies, to which this change of raiment provoketh and enticeth.
the rest doe say that so much more is meant then the other three, as prooveth my assertion. For the vBishop of Parise, cited and abbridged by Dionysius Carthusianus, among sundry causes why the lawe of ⟨p. 97⟩God should forbid a man to put on womans raiment, giveth this for one, 1that a great occasion of provoking men to lust might be taken away. For 2the apparell of wemen (saith he) is a great provocation of men to lust and leacherie: because a 3womans garment beeing put on a man doeth vehemently touch and moue him with the remembrance & imagination of a woman; and 4the imagination of a thing desirable doth stirr vp the desire. The same in 5fewer words Aquinas doeth affirme. And Liranus farder, having declared what mooved him to preferre the last exposition (rehearsed by your self, though somewhat confusely, which I was bolde to mend in the recitall of it, the better here to be vnderstoode) saith, that if the text be meant of common apparell, 6then is such an vse or rather abuse forbidden, because it is an occasion of wantonnes and lust. Wherein he hath relation to that, whereas the 7word, vsed in the former branch of the sentence touching mens furniture not to be worne by wemen, doeth sometime signifie common apparell, sometime armour; he had said, that this place, he thought, the signification of armour fitted best: induced therevnto because he had read that wemen in the sacrifices of Mars did beare armour; and the reason added, for all that doe so are abomination to the Lord, might wel enough agree, sith matters of idolatrie are commonly in the Scriptures termed abomination. But seeing it appeareth not by sufficient proofe that wemen woare mens armour in the sacrifices of Mars, or men woare wemens distaffes, spindles, and such like, in the sacrifices of Uenus; and the later branch of the law forbidding a man to put on womans 8
vGuliel. Pari. de fide & legib. cap. 13.
1Ut occasio magna provocationi libidinis auferretur.Vt occasio magna provocationi libidinis auferretur.
2Magna provocatio libidinis viris est vestitus muliebris.
Thus seeing that no one of all those interpreters, by whom the expositions, which you rehearse, are set down, denieth that the law ⟨p. 98⟩extendeth further then your specialties, & most of them affirm it: I fear it were a fault in me to believe you, that godly learned Divines, with whom you talked thereof, should all avouch unto you the thing you father on them. Howbeit, if they did, and you will needs enforce their testimony against me; mine answer made to Cyprian, to them I must apply: The law forbidding men to put on women's raiment, saith that all who do so are abomination to the Lord. What? And have godly learned Divines said otherwise? Pardon me, ye godly & learned Divines; I would believe you gladly, but that believing you I should not believe the word of God. And I assure my self so much of their modesty, that though you, with yGregory Martin, do taunt me for my presumptuous saying, Pardon me O Cyprian: yet, sith zAustin thought he might, without any disgrace unto Cyprian, allow of Tychonius the Donatists exposition as better sitting a place of scripture, then his did; they will not take it hardly that I prefer the judgement of Cyprian, with Austin, and such, so many other both old and new interpreters, before theirs in this point.
Thus seeing that no one of all those interpreters, by whom the expositions, which you rehearse, are sett down, denieth that the law ⟨p. 98⟩extendeth farder then your specialties, & most of them affirme it: I feare it were a fault in me to beleeve you, that godly learned Divines, with whom you talked thereof, should all avouch vnto you the thing you father on them. Howbeit, if they did, and you will needes enforce their testimonie against me; mine aunswer made to Cyprian, to them I must apply: The law forbidding men to put on wemens raiment, saith that all who doe so are abomination to the Lorde. What? And haue godly learned Divines said otherwise? Pardon me, ye godly & learned Divines; I would beleeve you gladly, but that beleeving you I should not beleeve the word of God. And I assure my selfe so much of their modestie, that though you, with yGregorie Martin, doe taunt me for my presumptuous saying, Pardon mee O Cyprian: yet, sith zAustin thought hee might, without any disgrace vnto Cyprian, allow of Tychonius the Donatists exposition as better sitting a place of scripture, then his did; they will not take it hardly that I preferre the iudgement of Cyprian, with Austin, and such, so many other both olde and new interpreters, before theirs in this point.
yThe preface of his discovery.The preface of his discoverie.
zRetractat. lib. 2. cap. 18
that Flora, as the Goddesse of flowers, might bee entreated not to hurt the corne, nor any thing that bloweth and blossemeth: and so they are referred ad religionem & devotionem. The
officers that had the charge to set them out, did sett them out at their private cost, to gett the peoples favour for the obtaining of greater offices: and so they are referred to magnificence. The
allowed that beastlinesse in many cities then. In like sort the Romans, albeit they iudged the things to be evil which the players did in the feast of Flora, so euill that
the refuse & dregges of the people durst not for shame desire to haue the fight there of while Cato was present: yet did they allow;
vValer. Max. lib. 2. cap 10 Seneca epist. 98.
⟨p. 74⟩
of your speech is to proove, even for the thing too, that you are cleare from that which the lawe disgraceth; but with what sinewes of arguments you doe it, I will (by a more perfitt similitude thē yours were) endevour to make plaine vnto you:
Homer. Thus are your differences all vntrue, in part: in whole, a number of them. But suppose they were true. Yet are they all idle: because, as in the felowes speech to Maximinus, the maior being prooved that all living creatures may bee killed, whether one or many bee able to surprise them; the minor apparant, that hee was a living creature; the conclusion folowed, notwithstanding whatsoever differences betweene him, and them, whose examples were brought to proove the maior: likewise in my reason, the maior being prooved, that all stage-players are infamous by the civill law, whether they play for gaine, or freely; the minor apparant, that they who play your playes on the stage, are stage-players; the conclusion foloweth, notwithstanding whatsoever differences betweene yours, and them whose examples for proof of the maior I produced. Nay, I say farder, that as some true differences betwene Maximinus, and the beastes, doe sharpen the edge of the conclusion against him;
wee may not distinguish where the lawe distinguisheth not. Else, if I should say that by the same law our English theeves, who robbe on Gaddes hill, are infamous; one of their abbetters might aunswer, No not so: for the Law speaketh of such as
Lucius Tubulus, men of wealth and state, who robbed the whole worlde repairing vnto Rome; not of poore good felowes that robbe a few Kentish men travailing to Graves-end: and I thinke it was a fowle shame for rich men and Tubulus to robbe; but to robbe riche men and Tubulus, it is no shame for vs: as he saith in the Comedie, that oftentimes, you may say, when two men doe the same thing, the one is not blameworthy for it, the other is, not as if there were difference in the thing it selfe, but in the man that doeth it. Which Comicall sentēce, though it might be as well applied by Iustice Graybeard to the excuse of theft in poore men, as by Terences
he can not retaine therewith. Howbeit, had you doubted, yet might you haue found enough to resolue you, if you had read my writing rather with a minde to learne, then to gainesay, in as much as I shewed by Scripture touchinge Peter, that hee should not haue lyed to avoid the daunger of whatsoeuer trouble: because to lye is evill;
Euphrosyna is a Saint; but as you reason thus: likewise may an other in the same moode and figure; Euphrosyna, through a desire of moonkish perfection, refused to honour her father; Ergo
Christ did wrongfully checke the Scribes and Pharises for breaking Gods commandements to keepe traditions of men: Euphrosyna chose rather to be with others then with him to whom she was betrothed;
Austin, the Bishops assembled in the sixth generall councell to the number of aboue two hundred and twenty:
to be womanlike in the sacrifices of Uenus: these hath Gulielmus Alvernus, Bishop of Parise, and Carthusianus after him; Aquinas, and Liranus too, the last of them. Now Strabus saith not that those two thinges alone are meant:
raiment, doeth shew that common apparell is meant in the former, as S. Hierome also in the vulgar
Latin translation hath noted: it foloweth that Liranus resteth and resolveth vpon the generall sense and exposition as truest. By consequence whereof the worde, abomination, must not be restrained to matters of idolatrie, but taken in his naturall meaning: according to the like vse therof in like places, where the