REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDERED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Universities.REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDRED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Vniuersities.
pp. 17–326288 passagespart 3 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And is it to be thought possible, that you, who have demeaned your selves so impiously towards these Parents and Pastors, will be more respective towards others? Nay there is not any Council, which you have not long ago trodden under feet, so that every one of you, are enfolded in a thousand excommunications. And dare you, Campian, notwithstanding make mention of Councils, which if they were in any force, surely you should no more be tolerated in the Church, then Publicans and Pagans. There followeth this, say you, for the rooting out of heresy, the four general Councils of the ancient Fathers, which were of such strength and authority, that a thousand years since, they were had in singular account even as Gods word it self. And we likewise do freely confess, that the authority of those four Councils was good and profitable.1 Read what learned Luther hath writ of those four general Councils, and so also you may know our judgement of them. Notwithstanding there is no reason why we should assent unto Gregory, 2who professeth that he doth embrace and reverence these four Councils, as the four books of the holy Gospel. For this were rather to violate the Gospel, then to reverence the Councils. Although as I take it, Gregory's meaning was, that what was decreed and concluded in these four Councils, out of Gods word against Arrive, Eu••onius, Macedonius, Nestorius, Eutyches, and Diosc•ru•, that he firmly embraced, and would not suffer ⟨p. 98⟩these decreet, which are approved by the Evangelical writings, and in which this impious heresy is condemned, to be revoked and repealed no more then the Gospel it self, neither can I imagine that it was Gregory's purpose to affirm this of all these Councils, that the Council of Nice, Constantine ple, Ephesus and Chalced•n, were fully equal unto the holy Gospel in authority and dignity. And so we our selves do not doubt, that those things which these Fathers have determined against those heretics, before named concerning the consubstantial subsistence of the Father and the Son, of the divinity of the holy Ghost, of the one person of Christ in two natures, are as true as the Gospel it self; not because these Councils so judged and concluded, but because in the Gospel, the self same doctrine of faith is delivered.
And is it to be thought possible, that you, who haue demeaned your selues so impiously towards these Parents and Pastors, will be more respectiue towards others? Nay there is not any Councell, which you haue not long ago trodden vnder feete, so that euery one of you, are infoulded in a thousand excōmunications. And dare you, Campian, notwithstanding make mention of Councels, which if they were in any force, surely you should no more be tolerated in the Church, then Publicans and Pagans. There followeth this, say you, for the rooting out of heresie, the foure general Councels of the auncient Fathers, which were of such strength and authority, that a thousand yeares since, they were had in singular account euen as Gods word it selfe. And we likewise doe freely confesse, that the authority of those foure Councels was good and profitable.1 Reade what learned Luther hath writ of those foure generall Councels, and so also you may know our iudgement of them. Notwithstanding there is no reason why we should assent vnto Gregorie, 2who professeth that he doth imbrace and reuerence these foure Councels, as the foure bookes of the holy Gospell. For this were rather to violate the Gospell, then to reuerence the Councels. Although as I take it, Gregories meaning was, that what was decreed and concluded in these foure Councels, out of Gods word against Arriu•, Eu••onius, Macedonius, Nostorius, Eutyches, and Diosc•ru•, that he firmely embraced, and would not suffer ⟨p. 98⟩these decreet, which are approued by the Euangelicall writings, and in which this impious heresie is condemned, to be reuoked and repealed no more then the Gospell it selfe, neither can I imagine that it was Gregories purpose to affirme this of all these Councels, that the Councell of Nice, Constantin• ple, Ephesus and Chalced•n, were fully equall vnto the holy Gospell in authority and dignity. And so we our selues do not doubt, that those things which these Fathers haue determined against those heretikes, before named concerning the consubstantiall subsistence of the Father and the Sonne, of the diuinity of the holy Ghost, of the one person of Christ in two natures, are as true as the Gospel it selfe; not because these Councels so iudged and concluded, but because in the Gospell, the selfe same doctrine of faith is deliuered.
Further you say, That also i•••r own country, by our Parliaments, the same Councils retain their ancient right. It is true indeed, that in these and all other things, which they propound, if they be consonant to the holy Scriptures, they do still retain their ancient right and dignity. But lest you should suppose that we did ever attribute thus much to these Councils, that we judge all that to be necessarily embraced, whatsoever they have decreed; hear you now what our Church hath thought and ordained of these general Councils. Councils, not only may err, but also sometimes have erred, 1and that in these things, which belong to the rule of piety, and therefore whatsoever by them is decreed as necessary to salvation, hath no virtues nor authority, unless it may be showed that it is taken ou• of the holy Scriptures. Cite you now these words, and then contest (as you call it) your sweet country. And in like manner, this your most dear country in which you were borne, brought up and graced, doth contest, entreat, and beseech you, by all those things, which are unto you most swee•e and best esteemed, that you desist any more in this b•dde ⟨p. 99⟩cause to be troublesome unto her; that you will no• corrupt her children with an impious and strange religion; that you will make more precious account of her dignity, then of a foreign enemy: and that you would at length return thither, from whence you have stra•ed. And surely you would not contemn this speech of your country, if you could, even for a little space, lay aside, that prejudicate opinion which you have sucked from Rome, and brought with you hither into England.
Further you say, That also i•••r owne country, by our Parliaments, the same Councels retaine their auncient right. It is true indeed, that in these and all other things, which they propound, if they be consonant to the holy Scriptures, they doe still retaine their auncient right and dignity. But lest you should suppose that we did euer attribute thus much to these Councels, that we iudge all that to be necessarily embraced, whatsoeuer they haue decreed; heare you now what our Church hath thought and ordained of these generall Councels. Councels, not only may erre, but also sometimes haue erred, 1and that in these things, which belong to the rule of piety, and therfore whatsoeuer by them is decreed as necessary to saluation, hath no vertus nor authority, vnlesse it may be shewed that it is taken ou• of the holy Scriptures. Cite you now these words, and then contest (as you call it) your sweet coūtry. And in like māner, this your most deare countrie in which you were borne, brought vp and graced, doth contest, intreat, and beseech you, by all those things, which are vnto you most swee•e and best esteemed, that you desist any more in this b•dde ⟨p. 99⟩cause to be troublesome vnto her; that you will no• corrupt her children with an impious and strange religion; that you will make more preciou• account of her dignity, then of a forraine enemie: and that you would at length returne thither, from whence you haue stra•ed. And surely you would not contemne this speech of your country, if you could, euen for a litle space, lay aside, that preiudicate opinion which you haue sucked from Rome, and brought with you hither into England.
But let us hear, what is this your contestation? If, say you, you will re•erence these four• Councils, you will chiefly honour the Bishop of the chief• S••, that is Peter. And so do we ascribe great honour, unto Peter, and that worthily; neither do we contend with you about him; but this affirm, that those things which were proper unto Peter, cannot in any wise appertain to your Pope, who was never like either Peter or Paul. And in truth what madness is this, so insolently to brag of Peters great virtues, when in the mean time, you cannot prove that your Popes are endued with any such? Do you suppose that any man that is in his right wits, will think that Peters faith, piety, and all the rest of his virtues, have bin derived to your Pope by a lineal descent, from so many other Popes, of whom a great number, were not men, but monsters? This doubtless is a gross dotage, and fit to be taken away,1 with the mad mans purge, and as one saith, for those diseases, reprehension is the best ma•••r of cure. Should I entitle your Gregori• the 13. who now governeth at Rome, with the name of Peter? doth he teach? doth he feed Christs sheep? surely he cannot. Doth he perform the duty of an Apostle, or of a Bishop? nothing less. How therefore doth he demean himself? Sitting in the Vatican, he provoketh to war, moveth seditions, armeth subjects against their Princes, and filleth the whole world with upro••••▪ Did Peter thus behave himself? is ⟨p. 100⟩this to be Peter? can you deny that these things be true, and shall I then yield unto him the like honour, that is due to Peter, being so unlike him in conditions? But let us further examine your words; You will (say you) chiefly honour the Bishop of the chief Sea, that is Peter; but by what Council do you prove that necessary? you allege the Council of Nice Can. 6. In which there is not so much as any mention of the Bishop of the chief Sea, or of Peter; neither in truth could any thing be produced of greater force against your Bishop, then that decree of Nicene Synod: for it matcheth all Metropolitans and Patriarchs in an equal rank of honour with the Bishop of Rome; neither doth it attribute any more to him, then unto the Metropolitans of Antioch, Alexandria, and the rest of the other Provinces. If you please, you shall hear the words of the Council:2
But let vs heare, what is this your contestation? If, say you, you will re•erence these four• Councels, you will chiefely hon•r the Bishop of the chief• S••, that is Peter. And so do we ascribe great honour, vnto Peter, and that worthily; neither doe we contend with you about him; but this affirme, that those things which were proper vnto Peter, cannot in any wise appertaine to your Pope, who was neuer like either Peter or Paul. And in truth what madnes is this, so insolently to bragge of Peters great vertues, when in the meane time, you cannot proue that your Popes are indued with any such? Do you suppose that any man that is in his right wits, will thinke that Peters faith, piety, and all the rest of his vertues, haue bin deriued to your Pope by a lineall descent, from so many other Popes, of whom a great number, were not men, but monsters? This doubtlesse is a grosse dotage, and fit to be taken away,1 with the mad mans purge, and as one saith, for those diseases, reprehension is the best ma•••r of cure. Should I entitle your Gregori• the 13. who now gouerneth at Rome, with the name of Peter? doth he teach? doth he feed Christs sheepe? surely he cannot. Doth he performe the duty of an Apostle, or of a Bishop? nothing lesse. How therfore doth he demeane himselfe? Sitting in the Vatican, he prouoketh to warre, moueth seditions, armeth subiects against their Princes, and filleth the whole world with vpro••••▪ Did Peter thus behaue himselfe? is ⟨p. 100⟩this to be Peter? can you deny that these things be true, and shall I then yeeld vnto him the like honor, that is due to Peter, being so vnlike him in conditions? But let vs further examine your words; You will (say you) chiefely honor the Bishop of the chiefe Sea, that is Peter; but by what Councell doe you proue that necessary? you alleage the Councell of Nice Can. 6. In which there is not so much as any mention of the Bishop of the chiefe Sea, or of Peter; neither in truth could any thing be produced of greater force against your Bishop, then that decree of Nicene Synode: for it matcheth all Metropolitanes and Patriarkes in an equall ranke of honor with the Bishop of Rome; neither doth it attribute any more to him, then vnto ye Metropolitanes of Antioch, Alexandria, and the rest of the other Prouinces. If you please, you shall heare the words of the Councell:
dLet the ancient custom be in force, which was in Egypt, Libya, and Pentapolis, that the Bishop of Alexandria have the chief dignity, over all these things: because also this was the custom of the Bishop of Rome: and in like manner at Antioch, and in the rest of the Provinces, let the Primacy and authority be received unto the Churches.
dLet the ancient custome be in force, which was in Aegypt, Libya, and Pentapolis, that the Bishop of Alexandria haue the chiefe dignity, ouer all these things: because also this was the custome of the Bishop of Rome: and in like manner at Antioch, and in the rest of the Prouinces, let the Primacy and authority be receiued vnto the Churches.
dDVR. This cause by you alleged maketh much for establishing the authority of the Roman Sea over all Churches. For when as the Fathers to prove the authority of the Bishop of Alexandria, allege the custom of the Church of Rome, they show hereby that Alexandria dependeth upon Rome; as the mother Church from which she hath all her authority. And that this was their mind appeareth by the words of Paschasmus the Popes Legate in the Councell of Chalcedon, & is also proved by the 39. Canon translated out of Arabic into Latin. The same Fathers likewise assembled at Sardis approved the Supremacy of the Roman Sea. WHIT. pag. 299. Nothing could be alleged more direct against the Romish Supremacy then this Canon, wherein their own proper limits of jurisdiction are assigned to every Metropolitan. For if the Pope should rule over the whole Church, it had bin absur'd to limit every one their own borders, wherein they should have supreme authority according to the custom of the Church of Rome. Neither doth this prove the supremacy of the Romish Church, because they allege her custom and example, as you ignorantly infer: seeing an example may be taken aswell from an equal or inferior, as from a superiors. It is no marvel if Paschasinus, being the Popes Legate, spake for the supremacy of the Roman Sea, neither is his testimony to be regarded, being a party. Your Arabic Canon is merely Arabic, and not Nicene; for of this Councel there were only 20. Canons written in Greek, and not in the Arabian tongue. The Canon of the Councell of Sardis helpeth you not, seeing the Councell of Africa testifieth that i• was counterfeit.DVR. This cause by you alleadged maketh much for establishing the authority of the Romane Sea ouer all Churches. For vvhen as the Fathers to proue the authority of the Bishop of Alexandria, alleage the custome of the Church of Rome, they shew hereby that Alexandria dependeth vpon Rome; as the mother Church frō which she hath all her authority. And that this was their mind appeareth by the words of Paschasmus the Popes Legat in the Councell of Chalcedon, & is also proued by the 39. Canon translated out of Arabicke into Latin. The same Fathers likevvise assembled at Sardis approued the Supremacy of the Romane Sea. WHIT. pag. 299. Nothing could be alleadged more direct against the Romish Supremacy then this Canon, wherin their own proper limits of iurisdiction are assigned to euery Metropolitane. For if the Pope should rule ouer the whole Church, it had bin absur'd to limit euery one their owne borders, wherein they should haue supreame authority according to the custome of the Church of Rome. Neither doth this proue the supremacy of the Romish Church, because they alleadge her custome and example, as you ignorantly inferre: seeing an example may be taken aswell from an equall or inferiour, as from a superious. It is no maruell if Paschasinus, being the Popes Legate, spake for the supremacy of the Romane Sea, neither is his testimony to be regarded, being a party. Your Arabicke Canon is meerely Arabicke, and not Nicene; for of this Councel there were only 20. Canons written in Greek, and not in the Arabian tongue. The Canon of the Councell of Sardis helpeth you not, seeing the Councell of Africke testifieth that i• was counterfeite.
You see (Campian) I suppose that no extraordinary prerogative hath been given to the Bishop of Rome: and that his Province and Jurisdiction hath been circumscribed within determined bounds and borders.1 And after this same manner doth Ruffinus, (if you do not credit us) interpret this Canon. This Ancient custom is observed at Alexandria, and in the city of Rome, that the Bishop of Alexandria take the charges of Egypt, and the Bishop of Rome of the Churches of the cities near adjoining. And therefore let the Bishop of Rome take care of the bordering Churches of the neighbour cities, with which the Nicene Synod hath enjoined him to rest satisfied; and hereafter let him not trouble himself, with the care of our Churches, which appertain not unto his charge. And so you see, that if you had been well advised, you would never have mentioned this Council.2 But you adjoin also unto this the Council ofe Chalcedon, that thereby you may prove that the ⟨p. 102⟩chief honour is to be ascribed unto the Bishop of the chief sea, that is unto Peter. I grant, Campian, that this sea in time past, was had in the chief place of honour, and I know very well that the chief dignity was attributed to the Bishop of this sea; the reason whereof you may easily perceive out of the self same Council. For this was not done by any commandment of Christ, that the Church of Rome should excel in dignity, all other Churches of the world: but the Fathers testify, that the cause why that City was invested with greater privilege than others, was this, because it was the chief seat of the Empire. You may find the words themselves in the same act which you cite.4 But if (as you say) the Church of Rome ought to have the preeminence above all other Churches in the world, in divine authority, what then meant the Chalcedonian Fathers, to affirm that there were some prerogatives granted unto that Church, for this cause alone; in that Rome was the head of the Empire, and therefore they thought that the Bishop of that City, which was the Empress of the world, was worthy of some more honour than others? And this honour to speak of was only this; that the Bishop of Rome should have the preeminence of place in Councils, the priority of speech in delivering his opinion, and the precedence in rank and place.
You see (Campian) I suppose that no extraordinary prerogatiue hath been giuen to the Bishop of Rome: and that his Prouince and Iurisdiction hath been circumscribed within determined bounds and borders.1 And after this same manner doth Ruffinus, (if you do not credit vs) interpret this Canon. This Auncient custome is obserued at Alexandria, and in the citie of Rome, that the Bishop of Alexandria take the charges of Aegypt, and the Bishop of Rome of the Churches of the cities neire adioyning. And therefore let the Bishop of Rome take care of the bordering Churches of the neighbour cities, with which the Nicene Synode hath enioyned him to rest satisfied; and hereafter let him not trouble himselfe, with the care of our Churches, which appertaine not vnto his charge. And so you see, that if you had been well aduised, you would neuer haue mentioned this Councell.2 But you adioyne also vnto this the Councell ofe Chalcedon, that thereby you may proue that the ⟨p. 102⟩chiefe honour is to be ascribed vnto the Bishop of the chiefe sea, that is vnto Peter. I graunt, Campian, that this sea in time past, was had in the chiefe place of honour, and I know very well that the chiefe dignitie was attributed to the Bishop of this sea; the reason whereof you may easilie perceiue out of the selfe same Councell. For this was not done by any commaundement of Christ, that the Church of Rome should excell in dignitie, all other Churches of the world: but the Fathers testifie, that the cause why that Citie was inuested with greater priuiledge than others, was this, because it was the chiefe seate of the Empire. You may finde the words themselues in the same acte which you cite.4 But if (as you say) the Church of Rome ought to haue the preheminence aboue all other Churches in the world, in diuine authoritie, what then ment the Chalcedonian Fathers, to affirme that there were some prerogatiues graunted vnto that Church, for this cause alone; in that Rome was the head of the Empire, and therefore they thought that the Bishop of that Citie, which was the Empresse of the world, was worthie of some more honour than others? And this honour to speake of was onely this; that the Bishop of Rome should haue the preheminence of place in Councels, the prioritie of speech in deliuering his opinion, and the precedence in rancke and place.
eDVR. The Councell of Chalcedon standeth so directly for the supremacy of the Roman Sea, that you ca with no shifts avoid it. For therein Dioscorus, as for diver, other faults, so especially for excommunstating the Pope, was deprived of Episcopal authority, Act. 3. Besides they writ thus to Pope Leo. He extē death his madness against him, unto whom the custody of the vineyard is committed by our Saviour, and against thee who labourest to unite the body of the Church. Again, they desire that their decrees should be confirmed of the same Pope. And Paschasinus saith that the Pope of Rome, whichus head of all the Churches, deprived him; because as Lucentius addeth, he presumed to call a Councell without the authority of the Apostolic Sea. WHIT. pag. 302. This councell is so far from confirming the Popes supremacy, that it plainly overthroweth it: for though Pope Leo with all earnestness opposed against the honour and dignity of the Bishop of Constantinople, yet he obtein•• of the Councell that degree of honour which he desired, which he could not have done if the Councell had acknowledged the Popes supremacy. Concerning Dioscorus, he was deprived for many notable crimes, as murder, blasphemy against the Trinity burglary, adultery and excommunicating the Pope; and you make this last a special cause of his deprivation, as though it were a more heinous crime then murder, adultery and blasphemy. Therein advancing your Pope, as your manner is, above the blessed Trinity. The committing of the vineyard to Peter, maketh nothing for your Pope, who is not Peter, nor any thing like him. Prove that it was committed to the Pope and you say something. The confirmation of the decrees was not a thing proper to the Pope, but also appertained to the other Patriarchs and Metropolitans; yea to the Emperors. Paschasinus and Lucentius accusing Dioscorus, say not a word of the Popes supremacy, although they were the Popes Legates. And whereas he calleth Rome the head of all the Churches, his meaning was, that it was the first, greatest, and most famous Church.DVR. The Councell of Chalcedon standeth so directly for the supremacy of the Romane Sea, that you ca with no shifts auoid it. For therein Dioscorus, as for diuer, other faults, so especially for excommunstating the Pope, vvas depriued of Episcopall authority, Act. 3. Besides they writ thus to Pope Leo. He extē deth his madnes against him, vnto whom the custody of the vineyard is committed by our Sauiour, and against thee who labourest to vnite the body of the Church. Againe, they desire that their decrees should be confirmed of the same Pope. And Paschasinus saith that the Pope of Rome, vvhichus head of all the Churches, depriued him; because as Lucentius addeth, hee presumed to call a Councell vvithout the authority of the Apostolike Sea. WHIT. pag. 302. This councell is so far from confirming the Popes supremacy, that it plainly ouerthroweth it: for though Pope Leo with all earnestnes opposed against the honor and dignity of the Bishop of Constantinople, yet he obtein of the Councell that degree of honor which he desired, which he could not haue done if the Councell had acknovvledged the Popes supremacy. Concerning Dioscorus, he was depriued for many notable crimes, as murther, blasphemy against the Trinity burglary, adultery and excommunicating the Pope; and you make this last a speciall cause of his depriuation, as though it were a more heinous crime then murther, adultery and blasphemy. Therein aduauncing your Pope, as your manner is, aboue the blessed Trinity. The committing of the vineyard to Peter, maketh nothing for your Pope, who is not Peter, nor any thing like him. Proue that it was committed to the Pope and you say something. The confirmation of the decrees was not a thing proper to the Pope, but also appertained to the other Patriarckes and Metropolitanes; yea to the Emperors. Paschasinus and Lucentius accusing Dioscorus, say not a word of the Popes supremacy, although they were the Popes Legates. And whereas he calleth Rome the head of all the Churches, his meaning was, that it was the first, greatest, and most famous Church.
And thus neither do we our selves, now much envy this honour to the Roman Bishop, but that if so it please him, he may enjoy it; so that he do not (because he hath the chief place) imperiously tyrannize over his brethren, as he hath done for many ages, and persuadeth himself that he may do it lawfully. But seeing it pleaseth you to object unto us, the Council of Chalcedon, that you may challenge the chief honour, as due to your Bishop of the chief Sea, before I proceed further, I would gladly you ⟨p. 103⟩should resolve me in this question, why thef Fathers of this Council, made the Sea of Constantinople, equal to the Sea of Rome? for so they decree, and definitively determine: that seeing great privileges were granted to the Church of Rome, in respect of the Empire of the city, they thought it a matter of great equity, that the new Rome that was now graced with the Empire and Senate, should enjoy the same privileges which old Rome had done. And although the Bishop of Rome did most earnestly contend and labour, that the Bishop of Constantinople might not be made his equal, yet he could not by his best means effect his desire, but that the decree of the Council prevailed, which had equalised the Bishop of Constantinople, with the Bishop of Rome. And therefore me thinks you have but ill defended the honour and dignity of your Bishop, when you allege the decree of that Council. Moreover, the Council ofg Constantinople which you also cite,3 decreed no other thing for the Roman Sea, then that the Bishop of Constantinople should have the prerogative of honour next to the Bishop of Rome. And this we also confess, that in times past the Provinces were so distributed, that Rome had the chief, Constantinople ⟨p. 104⟩the next, and so every one in their own order. But what maketh that to this cause, which we have now in hand? For this is not the honour which the Bishop of Rome challengeth unto himself: this not the height of power and majesty which he so often arrogateth.4 The Council also ofh Ephesus is alleged by you with as little reason, seeing it ascribeth nothing to the Bishop of Rome, which did not also agree to other Bishops: for if you take hold on this, that Celestinus the Bishop of Rome, was called the holy president, & most reverend Father, because he threatened to excommunicate Nestorius, unless he abjured his heresy;
And thus neither doe we our selues, now much enuie this honour to the Romane Bishop, but that if so it please him, he may enioy it; so that he doe not (because he hath the chiefe place) imperiouslie tyranize ouer his brethren, as he hath done for many ages, and perswadeth himselfe that he may doe it lawfully. But seeing it pleaseth you to obiect vnto vs, the Coūcel of Chalcedon, that you may challenge the chiefe honor, as due to your Bishop of the chiefe Sea, before I proceed further, I would gladly you ⟨p. 103⟩should resolue me in this question, why thef Fathers of this Councell, made the Sea of Constantinople, equall to the Sea of Rome? for so they decree, and diffinitiuely determine: that seeing great priuiledges were graunted to the Church of Rome, in respect of the Empire of the citie, they thought it a matter of great equity, that the new Rome that was now graced with the Empire and Senate, should enioy the same priuiledges which old Rome had done. And although the Bishop of Rome did most earnestly contend and labour, that the Bishop of Constantinople might not be made his equall, yet he could not by his best meanes effect his desire, but that the decree of the Councell preuailed, which had equalised the Bishop of Constantinople, with the Bishop of Rome. And therefore me thinkes you haue but ill defended the honor and dignity of your Bishop, when you alleadge the decree of that Councell. Moreouer, the Councell ofg Constantinople which you also cite,3 decreed no other thing for the Romane Sea, then that the Bishop of Constantinople should haue the prerogatiue of honor next to the Bishop of Rome. And this we also confesse, that in times past the Prouinces were so distributed, that Rome had the chiefe, Constantinople ⟨p. 104⟩the next, and so euery one in their owne order. But what maketh that to this cause, which we haue now in hand? For this is not the honor which the Bishop of Rome challengeth vnto himselfe: this not the height of power and maiestie which he so often arrogateth.4 The Councell also ofh Ephesus is alleadged by you with as litle reason, seeing it ascribeth nothing to the Bishop of Rome, which did not also agree to other Bishops: for if you take hold on this, that Celestinus the Bishop of Rome, was called the holy president, & most reuerend Father, because he threatned to excommunicate Nestorius, vnlesse he abiuted his heresie;
fDVR. This was not the judgement of the whole Coū cell, but of certain men. Neither did the Constantinopolitanes require that their Sea should be of equal authority with the Sea of Rome, but that it should have the like sovereignty in Ecclesiastical matters, and obtain• the next place to it. WHIT. pag. 306. This was the judgment of the whole Councell, except the Popes own Legates Paschasinus, Bonefacius, and Lucentius, who in vain opposed: for the decree runneth thus. These things we all say, these things please us all. And contrary to your assertion, these Fathers decreed that the Bishop of Constantinople should be matched in equal privilege, with the Bishop of Rome; which equality of privileges, cannot stand with the unequality of authority. Neither did priority of place prove, that the Bishop of Rome had any priority of authority, s••ing this was only for orders sake: otherwise by the same reason the Bishop of Constantinople should have had the like authority over the Bishop of Alexandria, because he sate above him.DVR. This was not the iudgement of the whole Coū cell, but of certeine men. Neither did the Constantinopolitanes require that their Sea should be of equall authority with the Sea of Rome, but that it should haue the like soueraignty in Ecclesiasticall matters, and obtain• the next place to it. WHIT. pag. 306. This was the iudgment of the whole Councell, except the Popes owne Legates Paschasinus, Bonefacius, and Lucentius, who in vaine opposed: for the decree runneth thus. These things we all say, these things please vs all. And contrary to your assertion, these Fathers decreed that the Bishop of Constantinople should be matched in equall priuiledge, with the Bishop of Rome; which equality of priuiledges, cannot stand with the vnequality of authority. Neither did prioritie of place proue, that the Bishop of Rome had any priority of authoritie, s••ing this was only for orders sake: otherwise by the same reason the Bishop of Constātinople should haue had the like authority ouer the Bishop of Alexandri•, because he sate aboue him.
gDVR. The filth Canon of the Councell of Constantinople, ascribed greater honour to the Roman Sea, then to any other. WHIT. pag. 311. This honour was only of precedence and place, and not of authority; as plainly appeareth in the words of the Councell it self•. Chap. •8. and in that the like prerogative was granted in the next place to the Bishop of Constantinople, and therefore by the like reason he might rrog authority over the whole Church.
these things are common unto the Bishop of Rome with others: neither was he only entitled reverend, neither could he alone pronounce judgment against heretics. But if these would rather please you; This is the faith of the Catholic and Orthodoxall Church, unto which all the Orthodoxall Bishops give their assent; you interpret these words amiss. For in these words all the Orthodoxall Bishops are said not to assent to the Church, but to the faith: and that faith, which the Fathers in those their letters embraced, all Orthodoxall Bishops in every place have approved, and we also do defend.
these things are cōmon vnto the Bishop of Rome with others: neither was he only intitled reuerend, neither could hee alone pronounce iudgment against heretikes. But if these would rather please you; This is the faith of the Catholike and Orthodoxall Church, vnto which all the Orthodoxall Bishops giue their assent; you interpret these words amisse. For in these words all the Orthodoxall Bishops are said not to assent to the Church, but to the faith: and that faith, which the Fathers in those their letters embraced, all Orthodoxall Bishops in euery place haue approued, and we also do defend.
But what now followeth in your contestation? Thou wilt (say you) acknowledge the unbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ on the Altar. And for this you cite the 14. Canon of the Nicene Coū cell, in which there is not so much as any mention made neither of unbloody, nor ofi sacrifice, nor of ⟨p. 105⟩Altar. But Deacons are there prohibited to arrogate so much unto themselves, that Bishops or Priests being present, they should take upon them to administer the Sacrament of the Lords supper, because it was not lawful for Deacons to deliver the Lords body unto Priests. Now it is an usual thing to call bread the Lords body, because it is a Sacrament of the Lords body; neither in the mean time do I deny that the supper of the Lord is called by many of thek ancient Fathers, an unbloody sacrifice: both because we retain the mysteries of Christs death without any blood, & also offer up praises & thanksgiving as it were for sacrifices unto God; and therefore Cyril joineth in the supper, these together, unbloody sacrifices and praises. 3And Eusebius writeth, that we build an Altar to the Lord, of unbloody and reasonable sacrifices, according to the new mysteries. Now if you ask what manner of unbloody sacrifice this is, let Eusebius himself answer you in his own words. He hath delivered unto us, a lmemorial of his death, which we offer unto him in place of a Sacrifice. Again, you propound the eleventh act of the Council of Chalcedon, which containeth nothing at all, which appertaineth to this matter in hand, neither that place of Socrates which you quote.5 You might have dealt better and more simply, if you would have cited the ⟨p. 106⟩words themselves, and not only quoted uncertain and confused notes in the margin: but you feared lest you might have bin too easily discovered, unless you had masked your self under the visor of deceit.
But what now followeth in your contestation? Thou wilt (say you) acknowledge the vnbloody sacrifice of the body and blood of Christ on the Altar. And for this you cite the 14. Canon of the Nicence Coū cell, in which there is not so much as any mention made neither of vnbloody, nor ofi sacrifice, nor of ⟨p. 105⟩Altar. But Deacons are there prohibited to arrogate so much vnto themselues, that Bishops or Priests being present, they should take vpon them to administer the Sacrament of the Lords supper, because it was not lawfull for Deacons to deliuer the Lords body vnto Priests. Now it is an vsuall thing to call bread the Lords body, because it is a Sacrament of the Lords body; neither in the meane time do I deny that the supper of the Lord is called by many of thek auncient Fathers, an vnbloody sacrifice: both because wee retaine the mysteries of Christs death without any blood, & also offer vp praises & thanksgiuing as it were for sacrifices vnto God; and therefore Cyrill ioyneth in the supper, these together, vnbloody sacrifices and praises. 3And Eusebius writeth, that we build an Altar to the Lord, of vnbloody and reasonable sacrifices, according to the new mysteries. Now if you aske what manner of vnbloody sacrifice this is, let Eusebius himself answer you in his own words. He hath deliuered vnto vs, a lmemoriall of his death, which we offer vnto him in place of a Sacrifice. Again, you propound the eleuenth act of the Councell of Chalcedon, which conteineth nothing at all, which appertaineth to this matter in hand, neither that place of Socrates which you quote.5 You might haue dealt better and more simply, if you would haue cited the ⟨p. 106⟩words themselues, and not only quoted vncertaine and confused notes in ye margent: but you feared lest you might haue bin too easily discouered, vnles you had masked your selfe vnder the vizard of deceite.
iDVR. The word Sacrifice is in the 14. Canon of the Nicene Councell. And in the institutions of this Councell, it is said that the Lamb of God is on the holy table, which is offered of the Priests without blood, &c. WHIT pag. 316. It is not to be found in the words of the Councell in the Greek, but they are your words of the Translator. And concerning the institutions, their authority was always doubtful in the Church, neither do they make for you, seeing we grant that in the right use of the Sacrament we receive the Lamb of God, Sacramentally.DVR. The word Sacrifice is in the 14. Canon of the Nicene Councell. And in the institutions of this Councell, it is said that the Lambe of God is on the holy table, which is offered of the Priests without blood, &c. WHIT pag. 316. It is not to be found in the words of the Councell in the Greeke, but they are your words of the Trāslator. And cōcerning the institutiōs, their authority was alwaies doubtfull in the Church, neither do they make for you, seeing we grant that in the right vse of the Sacrament we receiue the Lambe of God, Sacramentally.
kDVR. The testimonies of the Fathers which you allege, wherein the Sacrament is called an unbloody sacrifice, make nothing for you: seeing that with them is called unbloody, not that is without blood but without effusion of blood. WHIT pag. 318. The word [Greek or Hebrew], unbloody, used by them, signifieth such a thing as hath no blood in it. If therefore this be [Greek or Hebrew], an unbloody sacrifice, as the Fathers call it, then it is a Sacrifice without blood, and not only without shedding of blood. Again if it be a sacrifice wherein no blood is spilt, then is it not the sacrifice of Christ; for in this blood was shed: nor any true sacrifice, for there is no sacrifice that hath blood without the shedding thereof. Heb. 9.22.DVR. The testimonies of the Fathers which you alleadge, vvherein the Sacrament is called an vnbloody sacrifice, make nothing for you: seeing that vvith them is called vnbloody, not that is vvithout blood but vvithout effusion of blood. WHIT pag. 318. The word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, vnbloody, vsed by them, signifieth such a thing as hath no blood in it. If therefore this be 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an vnbloody sacrifice, as the Fathers call it, then it is a Sacrifice without blood, and not only without shedding of blood. Againe if it be a sacrifice wherin no blood is spilt, then is it not the sacrifice of Christ; for in this blood was shed: nor any true sacrifice, for there is no sacrifice that hath blood without the shedding therof.
But let us examine the remainder of your contestation: Thou wilt pray (say you) unto the Martyrs and all the Saints, that they would mediate for thee unto Christ. Thou wilt restrain effeminate Apostates from wicked copulation. Whether the Martyrs and heavenly Saints pray unto Christ for us or no,m we know not: but certain it is, that they aren ignorant of those things we do. And therefore we rather go untoo Christ, and pray unto him alone, who ⟨p. 107⟩both knoweth our wants, and also will and can grant unto us such things as we desire. You if you please may seek after the purling streams, but we will draw out of the fountain it self, neither do we regard the inveterate custom of praying unto saints (for though this custom is ancient; nevertheless, it hath flowed from the well-head of humane superstition, and not from divine authority:) and whereas you adjoin your conceit concerning the restraining effeminate Apostates from wicked copulation; and for this purpose allege some Canons of the Council of Chalcedon:4 in this you follow your old wont: for there is only one Canon to be found against ministering widows, which after they had taken upon them the office of ministration, married again: but how unjust this law is, it may easily appear.5 For when as Saint Paul would have these widows to bep sixty years old at least; this Canon doth admit of those who are but forty: and yet notwithstanding permitteth them not to marry. But you will say they have vowed single life: First, prove that they ought to make any such vow, and then, that if they shall perceive, they can by no means ⟨p. 108⟩perform their vow, that they have done otherwise then they should when they married.q To make a vow in things indifferent, which you cannot possibly perform, is to mock God, and to commit the crime of impious temerity: but to persist in this wicked vow is a double sin. And therefore that which the law prescribeth is to be embraced: The best course in evil promises made, is not to observe them; and we are so to behave our selves, as Bernard counselleth his sister. In evil promises keep not touch. 8rIn a dishonest vow change thy purpose. Do not perform that which thou hast vowed unadvisedly; for that promise is impious which is wickedly performed.
But let vs examine the remainder of your contestation: Thou wilt pray (say you) vnto the Martyrs and all the Saints, that they would mediate for thee vnto Christ. Thou wilt restraine effeminate Apostataes from wicked copulation. Whether the Martyrs and heauenly Saints pray vnto Christ for vs or no,m we know not: but certaine it is, that they aren ignorant of those things we doe. And therefore we rather goe vntoo Christ, and pray vnto him alone, who ⟨p. 107⟩both knoweth our wants, and also will and can grant vnto vs such things as we desire. You if you please may seeke after the pirling streames, but wee will draw out of the fountaine it selfe, neither doe we regard the inueterate custome of praying vnto saints (for though this custome is auncient; neuerthelesse, it hath flowed from the well-head of humane superstition, and not from diuine authoritie:) and whereas you adioyne your conceit concerning the restraining offeminate Apostataes from wicked copulation; and for this purpose alleadge some Canons of the Councell of Chalcedon:4 in this you follow your olde wont: for there is only one Canon to be found against ministring widowes, which after they had taken vpon them the office of ministration, married againe: but how vniust this law is, it may easilie appeare.5 For when as Saint Paul would haue these widowes to bep sixtie yeares old at least; this Canon doth admit of those who are but fortie: and yet notwithstanding permitteth them not to marrie. But you will say they haue vowed single life: First, proue that they ought to make any such vowe, and then, that if they shall perceiue, they can by no meanes ⟨p. 108⟩performe their vowe, that they haue done otherwise then they should when they married.q To make a vow in things indifferent, which you cannot possibly performe, is to mocke God, and to commit the crime of impious temeritie: but to persist in this wicked vowe is a double sinne. And therefore that which the law prescribeth is to be embraced: The best course in euill promises made, is not to obserue them; and we are so to behaue our selues, as Bernard counselleth his sister. In euill promises keepe not touch.
mDVR. You can not be ignorant of this, that the Saints pray for us, if in the doctrine of faith you insist in the steps of the Fathers. WHIT. p. 328. We are ignorant thereof because there is no such thing contained in the Canonical Scriptures, which should not have bin omitted if the spirit of God had thought this knowledge necessary. Neither is it con••oversed what the Fathers thought of it; not doth it follow because they have care of us, they pray for us; neither if they do pray, therefore we should pray unto them.DVR. You cā not be ignorant of this, that the Saints pray for vs, if in the doctrine of faith you insist in the steps of the Fathers. WHIT. p. 328. We are ignorāt therof because there is no such thing cōteined in the Canonical Scriptures, which should not haue bin omitted if the spirit of God had thought this knowledge necessary. Neither is it con••ouersed what the Fathers thought of it; not doth it follow because they haue care of vs, they pray for vs; neither if they do pray, therefore we should pray vnto them.
nDVR. We know the blessedness of the Saints in heaven, and therefore they are not ignorant of our misery in earth. Again, Christ hath revealed unto the Saints living on the earth, divine and heavenly things, and therefore he revealeth to the Saints in heaven, what is done in earth. WHIT. pag 330. Although we generally know that the Saints in heaven are blessed, yet we know not their particular state, their actions, the manner & degree of their happiness: and therefore if your argument be good, it confuteth your self; seeing therefore it followeth, that they likewise are ignorant of our particular state & actions. Moreover Christ revealed to the Saints on earth, heavenly things, but not what was done in heaven, only he made those divine mysteries know unto them, which were necessary to salvation; whereof it followeth not that he revealeth to the Saints in heaven, what is particularly done on earth, unless you can prove that there is the like necessity of this knowledge.DVR. We knovv the blessednes of the Saints in heauen, and therefore they are not ignorant of our misery in earth. Againe, Christ hath reueiled vnto the Saints liuing on the earth, diuine and heauenly things, and therefore he reueileth to the Saints in heauen, vvhat is done in earth. WHIT. pag 330. Although we generally know that the Saints in heauen are blessed, yet we know not their particular state, their actions, the manner & degree of their happines: and therefore if your argument be good, it confuteth your self; seeing therfore it followeth, that they likwise are ignorant of our particular state & actions. Moreouer Christ reueiled to the Saints on earth, heauenly things, but not what was done in heauen, only he made those diuine mysteries knowe vnto them, which were necessary to saluation; whereof it followeth not that he reuealeth to the Saints in heauen, what is particularly done on earth, vnles you can proue that there is the like necessity of this knowledge.
Now what can be more wicked and odious in the sight of God, then to be inwardly inflamed with the fire of lust, and to refuse that lawful mean•• whereby it might be quenched? But you are always harping upon this string; that they are bound by the laws ⟨p. 109⟩of a vow:1 therefore let Cyprian make you answer.s If they have by their vow, consecrated themselves to Christ,3 let them persevere honestly and chastely without any feigned devises. But if they will not or cannot persevere, their best course is to marry. And would Cyprian, think you Campian, have given this counsel to Virgins, if he had judged such marriages wicked, or no better than public incest, as you in your intemperate stile term it? And indeed how much more honest course were it for you Monks and Friars, to avoid your too too public and notoriously wicked fornication, by embracing chaste marriage? for so it might come to pass,4 as your old Pope Pius was wont to say: That many of you might be saved in marriage, which are now damned in single life: But he that is filthy, let him go forward in his filthiness unto his old age; and let him that is holy, •lie uncleanness, and prefer sanctimony of life, before vice and wickedness. And these are the main matters which you have delivered unto us, in that your grave contestation, and have laboured to persuade by interposing the authority of Councils. But you might have considered (Campian) that the counterfeit names of Councils, ought to be of far less authority with us, then the most undoubted truth of Gods word. And whereas you further affirm, that The Synods of other times, and namely that of Trent, are of equal authority and credit with those first Councils: I must tell you, I believe you not, although you promise and take upon you to prove it, when need requires. You promise indeed much, but perform nothing. But here I entreat the godly Reader, and beseech all Christians, that they would attentively mark, what Campian here avoucheth, to wit, that all Synods, and namely that of Trent, are equal to the four ⟨p. 110⟩general Councils: which four Councils, are byt Gregory, whom Campian citeth, marched in equal authority with the four Gospels: from whence it necessarily followeth, that all Councils of other times are of the same authority and credit with the four Evangelists.
Now what can be more wicked and odious in the sight of God, then to be inwardly inflamed with the fire of lust, and to refuse that lawfull mean•• whereby it might be quenched? But you are alwaies harping vpon this string; that they are bound by the lawes ⟨p. 109⟩of a vowe:1 therefore let Cyprian make you answere.s If they haue by their vowe, consecrated themselues to Christ,3 let them perseuere honestly and chastely without any feined deuises. But if they will not or cannot perse•ere, their best course is to marrie. And would Cyprian, thinke you Campian, haue giuen this counsell to Virgins, if he had iudged such marriages wicked, or no better than publike incest, as you in your intemperate stile tearme it? And indeed how much more honest course were it for you Monkes and Friers, to auoid your too too publike and notoriously wicked fornication, by imbracing chaste marriage? for so it might come to passe,4 as your olde Pope Pius was wont to say: That many of you might be saued in marriage, which are now damned in single life: But he that is filthie, let him goe forward in his filthines vnto his olde age; and let him that is holy, •lie vncleanenesse, and prefer sanctimonie of life, before vice and wickednes. And these are the maine matters which you haue deliuered vnto vs, in that your graue contestation, and haue laboured to perswade by interposing the authoritie of Councels. But you might haue considered (Campian) that the counterfeit names of Councels, ought to be of farre lesse authoritie with vs, then the most vndoubted truth of Gods word. And whereas you further affirme, that The Synods of other times, and namely that of Trent, are of equall authoritie and credit with those first Councels: I must tell you, I beleeue you not, although you promise and take vpon you to proue it, when need requires. You promise indeed much, but performe nothing. But here I intreate the godly Reader, and beseech all Christians, that they would attentiuely marke, what Campian here auoucheth, to wit, that all Synodes, and namely that of Trent, are equall to the foure ⟨p. 110⟩generall Councels: which foure Councels, are by
sDVR. The words of Cyprian are not to be understood of Virgins already consecrated unto God, but he willeth those who will not persevere in virginity, that they do not consecrate themselves to Christ, but rather marry, WHIT. pag. 343. Cyprian speaketh plainly of such Virgins as were already consecrated, for he reprehendeth such as having consecrated themselves to Christ, did live incontinently, and willeth them, if they vvill not persevere in chastity, to marry. lib. 1. Epistol. 11. And Erasmus thought thus as appeareth by a marginal note of his. Here marriages are permitted to holy Virgins.DVR. The words of Cyprian are not to be vnderstood of Virgins already consecrated vnto God, but he willeth those who will not perseuere in virginitie, that they doe not consecrate themselues to Christ, but rather marry, WHIT. pag. 343. Cyprian speaketh plainly of such Virgins as vvere alreadie consecrated, for hee reprehendeth such as hauing consecrated themselues to Christ, did liue incontinently, and vvilleth them, if they vvill not perseuere in chastitie, to marrie. lib. 1. Epistol. 11. And Erasmus thought thus as appeareth by a marginall note of his. Here marriages are permitted to holy Virgins.
tDVR. Gregory doth not match the four Councels in equal authority with the four Gospels; but only saith, that as he doth undoubtedly and certainly believe the scriptures, so also the four Councels. WHIT. pag. 348. Gregory saith, that he doth embrace and reverence the four Councels as the four books of the Gospel, Epist. libr. 1. Epist. 24. And what is this, but to make them equal? For if there be any inequality, wo cannot embrace and reverence them both alike.DVR. Gregorie doth not match the foure Councels in equall authoritie vvith the foure Gospels; but onely saith, that as hee doth vndoubtedly and certainely beleeue the scriptures, so also the foure Councels. WHIT. pag. 348. Gregorie saith, that he doth imbrace and reuerence the foure Councels as the foure bookes of the Gospell, Epist. libr. 1. Epist. 24. And what is this, but to make them equall? For if there bee any inequalitie, wo cannot imbrace and reuerence them both alike.
I will not urge this point further, neither will I now shake you up, as you usually do Master Luther, but rather leave you to be beaten with the rod of mens silent judgements. After this you being shadowed with this impenetrable shield of Councils, enter the lists, and observe whether your adversary conveyeth himself; for so great a warrior you are, such a skilful Champion, and so fierce in fight, that as soon as you but show your self, forthwith all your enemies betake them to their heels; and eftsoons you declare how you mean to behave your self in this fight, and what a great slaughter you intend to make. But take heed, Campian, least that may worthily be applied to you, which is spoken in the Proverbs: He that is rashly confident, before the conflict, is commonly a coward in the combat.
I will not vrge this poynt further, neither will I now shake you vp, as you vsually doe Master Luther, but rather leaue you to bee beaten with the rod of mens silent iudgements. After this you being shadowed with this impenitrable shield of Councels, enter the lists, and obserue whether your aduersarie conuaieth himselfe; for so great a warrier you are, such a skilfull Champion, and so fierce in fight, that assoone as you but shew your selfe, forthwith all your enemies betake them to their heeles; and eftsoones you declare how you meane to behaue your selfe in this fight, and what a great slaughter you intend to make. But take heede, Campian, least that may worthilie be applied to you, which is spoken in the Prouerbes: He that is rashly confident, before the conflict, is commonly a coward in the combate.
You speak much of the dignity of Councils, which we also acknowledge to be very great, but nevertheless, the holy Ghost is not bound to multitudes of men, to stately preparations, nor to sumptuous pomp. And we may often observe that in Councils there is much contending amongst contrary factions, and sometimes the greater part prevaileth against the better. You say that Luther durst presume to affirm, that he preferred the judgement and suffrages of two good and learned men, before the Councils. And in truth why might he not prefer them; and who could justly find fault with that speech? Seeing Gerson the Moderator of the Council of Constance, doubted not to prefer the judgement of one man, before the whole Council. ⟨p. 111⟩uWe are, saith he, to give more credit unto a man learned in the holy Scriptures alleging catholic authority, then to a general Council: 2which also Pa•ormitan hath confirmed, writing in this manner: We ought (saith he) rather to believe a simple lay man, alleging the Scripture, than the whole Council together. You say further, That Kemnisius dared to peise the Council of Trent in the balance of his own giddy brain. But Kemnisius did not examine that Council by his own square, but by the rule of Gods holy word: And what gained he? (say you) and answering your self in your own question, you say, nothing but infamy: If Kemnisius have not your good word, it is no great wonder; for he hath achieved that by his learning, virtue and industry, that he may seem worthy of envy and hatred from such as you are. But if true and deserved praise be due to good deeds, he hath obtained an honourable reward; even the everlasting glory of a good name. Yea (say you) if he take not heed, he shall be buried with Arrius. But it behooved you, Campian, to trouble your head, rather about your own, then Kemnisius his funerals: and take you heed, least for your evil deeds, there be a sepulchre provided for you amongst the damned.
You speake much of the dignitie of Councels, which we also acknowledge to be very great, but neuerthelesse, the holy Ghost is not bound to multitudes of men, to stately preparations, nor to sumptuous pompe. And we may often obserue that in Councels there is much contending amongst contrarie factions, and sometimes the greater part preuaileth against the better. You say that Luther durst presume to affirme, that hee preferred the iudgement and suffrages of two good and learned men, before the Councels. And in truth why might he not preferre them; and who could iustly finde fault with that speech? Seeing Gerson the Moderator of the Councell of Constance, doubted not to preferre the iudgement of one man, before the whole Councell. ⟨p. 111⟩uWe are, saith he, to giue more credit vnto a man learned in the holy Scriptures alleaging catholike authority, then to a generall Councell: 2which also Pa•ormitan hath confirmed, writing in this manner: We ought (saith he) rather to beleeue a simple lay man, alleaging the Scripture, than the whole Councell together. You say further, That Kemnisius dared to peise the Councell of Trent in the ballance of his owne giddie braine. But Kemnisius did not examine that Councell by his owne square, but by the rule of Gods holy word: And what gained he? (say you) and answering your selfe in your owne question, you say, nothing but infamie: If Kemnisius haue not your good word, it is no great wonder; for he hath atchieued that by his learning, vertue and industrie, that he may seeme worthie of enuie and hatred from such as you are. But if true and deserued praise be due to good deeds, he hath obtained an honourable reward; euen the euerlasting glorie of a good name. Yea (say you) if he take not heede, he shall be buried with Arrius. But it behooued you, Campian, to trouble your head, rather about your owne, then Kemnisius his funerals: and take you heede, least for your euill deedes, there be a sepulchre prouided for you amongst the damned.
uDVR. Gerson did never prefer the judgement of one man before a whole Councell. WHIT. pag. 349. It is untrue, for he thus writeth. We ought rather to b• leeve in a point of doctrine a simple man not authorised, but yet excellently learned in the scriptures, thē the Pope. Again a man thus learned, ought to oppose himself against a general Councell, if he perceive that the greater part incline to that which is contrary to the Gospel, either through malice or ignorance, Gers. de exam. doctr. 1. par. Considerat. 5.DVR. Gerson did neuer preferre the iudgement of one man before a vvhole Councell. WHIT. pag. 349. It is vntrue, for he thus writeth. We ought rather to b• leeue in a point of •octrine a simple man not authorised, but yet excellently learned in the scriptures, thē the Pope. Againe a man thus learned, ought to oppose himselfe against a generall Councell, if he perceiue that the greater part incline to that which is contrary to the Gospel, either through malice or ignorance, Gers. de exam. doctr. 1. par. Considerat. 5.
Now here again you begin more highly to extol the Council of Trent; as though we knew not the notable carriage and behaviour of that famous and goodly Synod. But for my part I easily allow you to be so far in love with it, neither in truth will I become your rival.1 Others have spoken of it those things that are most true: both how it was called, how handled, and how it was dismissed; and therefore I will not go about to refute your affections. Let it enjoy, for me, that credit and estimation which it can. Although every one knoweth thus much, that it was not to be esteemed a Council of the whole Christian state,2 but rather a Conventicle of a ⟨p. 112⟩few men running together into the same place. There was there present a sort of sill•e Friars which did sustain the greatest part of the burden, by disputing, writing and playing the Orators. For as for the Bishops and chief Cardinals, they busied their heads about other matters, for which they were specially assembled. But as I said, let it be such as it was, for I am not offended at your commendations. And let the Bishops make their glorious brags, that they long abode in that school; out of which as yet, as far as I know, not many, either learned divines or good Pastors have come. You also usher in Antony of Prague greatly congratulating with himself; for you would needs show him some kindness, because he made you a Priest. Well; Campian was created Priest by Antony Archbishop of Prague; surely I fear lest you travelled too far to buy such base wares. But now you may celebrate your Masses, seeing you are shaven and anointed, and made a Priest.
Now here againe you begin more highly to extoll the Councell of Trent; as though we knew not the notable carriage and behauiour of that famous and goodly Synode. But for my part I easilie allow you to be so farre in loue with it, neither in truth will I become your riuall.1 Others haue spoken of it those things that are most true: both how it was called, how handled, and how it was dismissed; and therefore I will not goe about to refute your affections. Let it enioy, for me, that credit and estimation which it can. Although euery one knoweth thus much, that it was not to bee esteemed a Councell of the whole Christian state,2 but rather a Conuenticle of a ⟨p. 112⟩few men running together into the same place. There was there present a sort of sill•e Friers which did susteine the greatest part of the burthen, by disputing, writing and playing the Orators. For as for the Bishops and chiefe Cardinals, they busied their heads about other matters, for which they were speciallie assembled. But as I said, let it be such as it was, for I am not offended at your commendations. And let the Bishops make their glorious bragges, that they long abode in that schoole; out of which as yet, as farre as I know, not many, either learned diuines or good Pastors haue come. You also vsher in Antonie of Prage greatly congratulating with himselfe; for you would needs shew him some kindnes, because he made you a Priest. Well; Campian was created Priest by Antony Archbishop of Prage; surely I feare lest you trauelled too far to buy such base wares. But now you may celebrate your Masses, seeing you are shauen and annointed, and made a Priest.
Moreover you demand & exceedingly triumph, why your Adversaries called hither, and secured by the caution of public promise, did not make all hast to come unto it? In which you are sufficiently answered in the Apology of our Church. For what should we do there? or to what end should we undertake so long a journey, either that being mocked and abused, we might return home again, or being burned in the Council, we should pay for our rashness? For what place of disputation was left amongst those, who had every man plighted their faith to the Bishop of Rome, & had religiously bound themselves by oath, that they would never either do or say any thing against his dignity and pleasure? what therefore might be hoped for from these, which might draw any to the disputation? besides the* calamity of John Huss ⟨p. 113⟩of Bohemia, and Hierome of Prague, whom the Fathers burned in the Council of Constance, brought just cause of fear. And yet Huss came to the Council, trusting in the protection of a public promise. Yea but (say you) the Constantine Fathers made no promise, and therefore did not break any. But Sigismund the Emperor gave his public warrant, unto whom it was fit that he should give credit. Notwithstanding, coming to the Council, he was presently apprehended and cast into prison, and pleading his cause before the Council he was condemned and burned, although Sigismond stormed at it. Neither did he fly, as you falsely report, neither in truth could he escape: but thus this holy and innocent man was devoured like a sheep by furious wolves. And what I pray you, did the Emperors authority, commandment, or public warrantize profit him? The Emperor (say you) signed it, but the state of Christendom, greater than the Emperors, did repeal it. And who then can be safe, if the Emperors bear no sway in the Council? Neither doth the horrible murder of John Huss, contrary to a public warrant of protection, so much discourage us from coming to your Councils, as that decree published by the Council it self, That promise is not to be kept with Heretics. Should I then believe you, who I know will keep no promise? If I do, surely I am worthy to perish after the same manner. Hierome of Prague likewise came to the Council of his own accord, and making public profession of his faith, was burned.
Moreouer you demaund & exceedingly triumph, why your Aduersaries called hither, and secured by the caution of publike promise, did not make all hast to come vnto it? In which you are sufficiently answered in the Apoligie of our Church. For what should wee doe there? or to what end should we vndertake so long a iourney, either that being mocked and abused, we might returne home againe, or being burned in the Councell, we should pay for our rashnes? For what place of disputation was left amongst those, who had euery man plighted their faith to the Bishop of Rome, & had religiously bound themselues by oath, that they would neuer either doe or say any thing againg his dignity and pleasure? what therfore might be hoped for from these, which might draw any to the disputation? besides the* calamity of Iohn Husse ⟨p. 113⟩of Bohemia, and Hierome of Prage, whom the Fathers burned in the Councell of Constance, brought iust cause of feare. And yet Husse came to the Councell, trusting in the protection of a publike promise. Yea but (say you) the Constantine Fathers made no promise, and therefore did not breake any. But Sigismonde the Emperor gaue his publike warrant, vnto whom it was fit that he should giue credit. Notwithstanding, comming to the Councell, he was presently apprehended and cast into prison, and pleading his cause before the Councell he was condemned and burned, although Sigismond stormed at it. Neither did hee flie, as you falsely report, neither in truth could hee escape: but thus this holy and innocent man was deuoured like a sheepe by furious wolues. And what I pray you, did the Emperors authoritie, commandement, or publike warrantize profit him? The Emperor (say you) signed it, but the state of Christendome, greater than the Emperors, did repeale it. And who then can be safe, if the Emperors beare no sway in the Councell? Neither doth the horrible murther of Iohn Husse, contrarie to a publike warrant of protection, so much discourage vs from comming to your Councels, as that decree published by the Councell it selfe, That promise is not to be kept with Heretikes. Should I then beleeue you, who I know will keepe no promise? If I doe, surely I am worthy to perish after the same manner. Hierome of Prage likewise came to the Councell of his owne accord, and making publike profession of his faith, was burned.
*DVR. John Huss was not called by the Councell of Constance, neither received from it any public promise. And whereas you say that it was decreed in this Councell, that faith is not to be kept with heretics, it is false. WHIT. pag. 352. The Emperor Sigismund gave him his public warrant, which the Councel most dishonourably infringed. And after they had put Huss to death contrary to public promise, they enacted a law that a promise made unto heretics by the Emperor or by any King or secular Prince, should not hinder any Ecclesiastical Judges from proceeding against them according to law. Concil. Constant. Sess. 19.DVR. Iohn Husse was not called by the Councell of Constance, neither receiued from it any publike promise. And whereas you say that it was decreed in this Councell, that faith is not to be kept with heretikes, it is false. WHIT. pag. 352. The Emperour Sigismund gaue him his publike warrant, which the Councel most dishonorably infringed. And after they had put Husse to death contrary to publike promise, they enacted a law that a promise made vnto heretikes by the Emperour or by any King or secular Prince, should not hinder any Ecclesiasticall Iudges from proceeding against them according to law. Concil. Constant. Sess. 19.
So that the case of these two, (than the which all Christendom at that time had not any more holy or learned) shall remain as a perpetual monument of your treachery and most horrible cruelty; and as a notable caveat unto all the godly, to beware of you for the time to come. Concerning Luther, whom you, cursed Friar, call the hatred of ⟨p. 114⟩God and men, the hand and power of God himself so defended him, that you could never hurt him. For will was not wanting to you for the destruction of Luther, but opportunity. But he was safe (say you) upon the Emperors word: neither in truth durst the Pope attempt Luther's death, after the Emperor had promised him safety. For would Charles the fifth, think you, have endured it? It was not behoofefull for the Pope to have attempted any thing, whereby the Emperors faith might appear falsified: for Charles would never so easily have put up such an indignity as Sigismond had done in time past.
So that the case of these two, (than the which all Christendome at that time had not any more holy or learned) shall remaine as a perpetuall monument of your treacherie and most horrible crueltie; and as a notable caueat vnto all the godly, to beware of you for the time to come. Concerning Luther, whom you, cursed Frier, call the hatred of ⟨p. 114⟩God and men, the hand and power of God himselfe so defended him, that you could neuer hurt him. For will was not wanting to you for the destruction of Luther, but opportunitie. But he was safe (say you) vpon the Emperors word: neither in truth durst the Pope attempt Luthers death, after the Emperor had promised him safetie. For would Charles the fifth, thinke you, haue endured it? It was not behoofefull for the Pope to haue attempted any thing, whereby the Emperors faith might appeare falsified: for Charles would neuer so easilie haue put vp such an indignitie as Sigismond had done in time past.
But (say you) they do too much brag in corners, in which when they have but sounded three Greek words, they would seem to be very wise. They might perhaps seem wise to you, who scarcely (as I suppose) can sound three Greek words. They cannot (as you say) endure the light, which would bring a Scholar into account, and would recall him into some place of reckoning: and is this it, Campian, which you hunt after, a name, same, places of account, to be pointed at with the finger, and to be thus spoken of, This is the man advanced to greatest grace, excelling in worth, and worthy place? Doth this grieve you that you are not highly esteemed of, and do not sit in high place? Well man, proceed in your virtuous courses, and go forward in the way, into the which you are entered to your great praise, and there is good hope you may ascend unto such an high place as you are worthy of.
But (say you) they doe too much brag in corners, in which when they haue but sounded three Greeke words, they would seeme to be very wise. They might perhaps seeme wise to you, who scarcely (as I suppose) can sound three Greeke words. They cannot (as you say) indure the light, which would bring a Scholler into account, and would recall him into some place of reckening: and is this it, Campian, which you hunt after, a name, same, places of account, to be poynted at with the finger, and to be thus spoken of, This is the man aduanced to greatest grace, excelling in worth, and worthy place? Doth this grieue you that you are not highly esteemed of, and doe not sit in high place? Well man, proceede in your vertuous courses, and goe forward in the way, into the which you are entred to your great praise, and there is good hope you may ascend vnto such an high place as you are worthie of.
But whereas you desire, That the English Catholics may obtain a Patent of impunity, if they love the salvation of their souls, surely you require a thing unjust & unequal. For what likeness is there in this, that learned men should assemble from all parts, unto a public Council, and that Runagates should be permitted to return unto their country? We will (say you) with ⟨p. 115⟩winged speed hast unto the Court, relying our selves upon the Princes word. And so indeed you safely may: for if she give her word, you may promise unto your selves assured security. And I the more easily believe you speak the truth, seeing some of you already, have hasted into the Gourt, having no promise from the Prince to rest upon. But Campian, fly you rather to the Indians, that you may take a survey of your Popes new Province: for our most wise Prince desires no such guests, but banisheth you as far as she can from her.
But wheras you desire, That the English Catholikes may obtaine a Patent of impunity, if they loue the saluation of their soules, surely you require a thing vniust & vnequal. For what liknes is there in this, that learned men should assemble from all parts, vnto a publike Councell, and that Runnagates should be permitted to returne vnto their countrie? We will (say you) with ⟨p. 115⟩winged speed hast vnto the Court, relying our selues vpon the Princes word. And so indeed you safely may: for if shee giue her word, you may promise vnto your selues assured securitie. And I the more easilie beleeue you speake the truth, seeing some of you already, haue hasted into the Gourt, hauing no promise from the Prince to rest vpon. But Campian, flie you rather to the Indians, that you may take a suruey of your Popes new Prouince: for our most wise Prince desires no such guests, but banisheth you as farre as she can from her.
But now at length you return thither whence you have digressed, and gloriously conclude this point, concerning Councils: saying, The general Councils make all for me, the first, last, and middle. You have gotten an easy and speedy victory: I am almost persuaded that you are become another Caesar: V•ni, vidi, vici, I came, I saw, I overcame; but this is not to dart your Javelin, which you say is looped for the purpose. I see words as it were tied together with strings, or rather frantic speeches; but as yet I discern no spear: either a Javelin, or a tongue, or strength, or (which I rather believe) all these are wanting unto you. Surely we of the Universities, Campian, do greatly desire to try how skilfully you have learned to toss your spear, and we hope it will come to pass, that you being pierced with our darts, will at length know and acknowledge your audacious temerity and slothful ignorance of this fight.
But now at length you returne thither whence you haue digressed, and gloriouslie conclude this poynt, concerning Councels: saying, The generall Councels make all for me, the first, last, and middle. You haue gotten an easie and speedie victorie: I am almost perswaded that you are become another Caesar: V•ni, vidi, vici, I came, I sawe, I ouercame; but this is not to dart your Iaueling, which you say is looped for the purpose. I see words as it were tied together with strings, or rather franticke speeches; but as yet I discerne no speare: either a Iauelin, or a thongue, or strength, or (which I rather beleeue) all these are wanting vnto you. Surely we of the Vniuersities, Campian, doe greatly desire to trie how skilfully you haue learned to tosse your speare, and we hope it will come to passe, that you being pierced with our darts, will at length know and acknowledge your audacious temeritie and slothfull ignorance of this fight.
AS that famous Surname of Christians increased first ina Antioch, sob Doctors, that is, very deep Divines, and Prophets, that is, most famous Preachers, first flourished there. Our Lord himself provided for his flock in time to come, such a sort ofc Scribes and wise men, as were experienced in the kingdom of God, bringing forth both old & new things, that is, having God still both in Christ and Moses, in the new and old Testament. How mischievous an act is it to expel with rebuke these men, which were given us by God for a special benefit? The Adversary hath* expelled them. For what cause? for that if they had stood upright, he of necessity had fallen down. So soon, as I throughly perceived that, without any more ado, I desired to make, not that flourishing fight which the common sort of people use, when they contend one with another in the open streets, but that severe and sharp combat, by which we buckle▪ one with another in your Philosophy schools, foot by foot, & man by man, close joined together. If we may once come to the Fathers, the field is fought, & the wager won, on our side. For they are all ours, assure as Gregory the 13. is a most loving Father to all the Churches children. For tod omit divers places, which here and there dispersed, being gathered together out of the ancient writings of the Fathers, do very fitly and plainly fortify our faith: we have their whole books, which of set purpose do expressly and copiously paint out lively that self same Evangelical religion which we maintain. ⟨p. 117⟩What orders of heavenly powers, what sacrifices, what solemn rites, doth that two-fold Hierarchy of the Martyr S. Denis, make known unto us? That matter touchedc Luther so nigh the quick, that he affirmed this blessed mans writings to be most like to dreams and most pernicious.f Caussaeus an obscure upstart in France, following the steppes of his Father Luther, blushed not to term this Apostle S.* Denis borne in a noble country, an old dotard.g The Magdeburgeans which lately set forth the Ecclesiastical history in Centuries, were greatly grieved at S. *Ignatius, so was Calvin also. Insomuch that these bench whistlers pried out certain foul blemishes and unsavoury speeches in his Epistles. In these mens conceits also S. Ireneus writ one foolish toy; and S.
AS that famous Sirname of Christians increased first ina Antioch, sob Doctors, that is, very deepe Diuines, and Prophets, that is, most famous Preachers, first flourished there. Our Lord himselfe prouided for his flocke in time to come, such a sort ofc Scribes and wise men, as were experienced in the kingdome of God, bringing forth both old & new things, that is, hauing God still both in Christ and Moses, in the new and old Testament. How mischieuous an act is it to expel with rebuke these men, which were giuen vs by God for a speciall benefit? The Aduersarie hath* expelled them. For what cause? for that if they had stood vpright, he of necessity had fallen downe. So soone, as I throughlie perceiued that, without any more adoo, I desired to make, not that flourishing fight which the common sort of people vse, when they contend one with another in the open streetes, but that seuere and sharpe combate, by which we buckle▪ one with another in your Philosophy schooles, foot by foot, & man by man, close ioyned together. If we may once come to the Fathers, the field is fought, & the wager wonne, on our side. For they are all ours, assure as Gregory the 13. is a most louing Father to all the Churches children. For tod omit diuers places, which here and there dispersed, being gathered together out of the auncient writings of the Fathers, do very fitly and plainelie fortifie our faith: we haue their whole bookes, which of set purpose do expresly and copiously paint out liuely that selfe same Euangelicall religion which wee maintaine. ⟨p. 117⟩What orders of heauenly powers, what sacrifices, what solomne rites, doth that two-fold Hierarchy of the Martyr S. Denys, make knowne vnto vs? That matter touchedc Luther so nigh the quicke, that he affirmed this blessed mans writings to be most like to dreames and most pernicious.f Caussaeus an obscure vpstart in Fraunce, following the steppes of his Father Luther, blushed not to tearme this Apostle S.*
*This is false, for we never hissed out any learned scribe.This is false, for we neuer hissed out any learned scribe.
dS. Dion. Areo pag. de quo vide Adon Treu. in Martyrel. Adon. Turon. Sing. Suid. Metap.S. Dion. Areo pag. de quo vide Adon Treu. in Martyrel. Adon. Turon. Syng. Suid. Metap.
cComment. in 1.13 17. Deut. Item in cap. •ab.Coment. in 1.13 17. Deut. Item in cap. •ab.
fDial. 5. & 11.
*This Denis is counterfeice and forged.This Denys is counterfeice and forged.
Clement, who was author of the book called Stromatum, yielded out of his works cockle and dregs. And the residueh of the Fathers of this age, which were in very deed* Apostolic men, left unto their posterity blasphemous and monstrous doctrine. Ini Tertullian they greedily catch at that fault, which being told thereof by us, they with us also detest. But let them call to mind, the book which he writ de Praescriptionibus, wherewith the heretics of our time had so sound a blow, was never hither to reprehended by the Church. How sufficiently and evidently hath* Hippolytus kBishop of Portua foreshowed the reign of Luther's heresies, which was a strong pillar▪ in Antichrists building? And for that cause they call him a most childish scribble, & a masker. Thatl critical French man Caussaeus, and them Magdeburgeans do call S. Cyprian (who was the flower and honour of Africa) a block head, a man cast out of Gods sight a depraver of the true doctrine of Penance: why, what hath he done? he hath writ for sooth one book of Virginity, and another of those that are Relapsed, and certain treatises of the unity of the Church, yea & such Epistles also unto Cornelius Bishop of Rome, that except this blessed Martyr be disgraced, Peter Martyr ⟨p. 118⟩the Vermillian, and all his confeder a•s, must be taken for worse then adulterous & Church-robbers. And lest I should stand too long upon particularities, aft the Fathers of that age aren generally* condemned, as men that have corrupted wonderfully, the sincere doctrine of Penance. Ho• I pray you? the Austerity for sooth of theo Canons which at that time was used, doth highly displease this plausible sect, which are fitter for Chambers then for Churches, and is accustomed to tickle sensual ears, and to so cushions to every elbow: wherein, I say, wherein hath the next age offended? forsooth S. Chrysostom and other Fathers of that time have foully darkened justification by faith only S. Gregory Nazianzen, whom ancient writers for honour sake, have Surnamed Theologus. 1. the Divine, by Caussaeus judgement, was but aq brabbler and knew not what to say: S. Ambrose was bewitched of an evil spirit. S. rHierome is as* deeply damned in hell, as the devil himself, because he was injurious to the Apostle, a blasphemer, a naughty man, a wicked fellow.
Clement, who was author of the booke called Stromatum, yeelded out of his works cockle and dregges. And the residueh of the Fathers of this age, which were in very deed* Apostolike men, left vnto their posteritie blasphemous and monstrous doctrine. Ini Tertullian they greedily catch at that fault, which being told therof by vs, they with vs also detest. But let them call to mind, the booke which he writ de Praescriptionibus, wherwith the heretikes of our time had so sound a blow, was neuer hither to reprehended by the Church. How sufficientlie and euidently hath* Hyppolitus kBishop of Portua foreshewed the raigne of Luthers heresies, which was a strong pillar▪ in Antichrists building? And for that cause they call him amost childish scrible, & a masker. Thatl criticall French man Caussaeus, and them Magdeburgeans do call S. Cyprian (who was the flower and honor of Africke) a blocke head, a man cast out of Gods sight a deprauer of the true doctrine of Penance: why, what hath he done? he hath writ for sooth one booke of Virginity, and another of those that are Relapsed, and certaine treatises of the vnity of the Church, yea & such Epistles also vnto Cornelius Bishop of Rome, that except this blessed Martyr be disgraced, Peter Martyr ⟨p. 118⟩the Vermillian, and all his confeder a•s, must bee taken for worse then adulternous & Church-robbers. And lest I should stand too long vpon particularties, aft the Fathers of that age aren generally* condemned, as men that haue corrupted wonderfully, the sincere doctrine of Penance. Ho• I pray you? the Austerity for sooth of the
*They were Apostolic men, yet they did not commit to writing all the things the Apostles did.They were Apostolike men, yet they did not commit to writing all the things the Apostles did.
iLib. de Prascript. contra Ha•.
*This Hippolytus is counterfeit.This Hyppolitus is counterfeite.
Gregory Massonius esteemeth more of one Calvin, then of an hundred Augustines, a hundred is but a few.s Martin Luther careth not a button, if there were against him a thousand Augustines, a thousand Cyprians, a thousand Churches. I think it will be to no purpose to wade any further in this matter, for who may marvel, if they that thus rail against these worthy men, have also been saucy against Optatus, Athanasius, Hilarius, both Cyrils, Epiphanius, Basil, Vincentius, Fulgentius, Leo, and Gregory the Roman? And yet if there may be any just defence of an unjust cause, I do not deny but the Fathers have, wheresoever you read in their works, such matter, as may cause the Adversary to take pepper in the nose, so long as they follow their own humours. For they that cannot away with prescript days of abstinence, how is it likely that they can abide S, Basil, S. Gregory Nazianzene, S. Leo, and S. Chrysostom, who have set forth in printg⟨p. 119⟩very godly sermons, concerning Lent, and Ember days, as things usually at that time observed among Christian people. Can those men choose, which have sold their souls for riches, bodily pleasure, dainty fare, and fine apparel, but bear deadly hatred to S. Basil, S. Chrysostom, S. Hierome, and S. Augustine, whose excellent books of the order, rule, and virtuous life of* Monks, are usually in every mans band? May they that have intruded servile will into man, that have cut off all Christian funerals, that have set on fire the relics of Saints, continue friendship with S. Augustine? who hath penned three whole books of mans* freewill,t one book of care to be taken for the dead, one long chapter of that his noble work De civitat. Dei, concerning miracles wrought at the Churches, Chapels, and sepulchres of holy Martyrs, and certain Sermons of the same matter. Can such as measure faith by their own captiousness, refrain from anger towards S. Augustine, of whose penning there is extant a notableo Epistle against Manichee, wherein he confesseth, that for his faith he will cleave unto* Antiquity, unity, continual succession, and to the Church, which by prescription alone challengeth among so many heresies, the title of Catholic?u Optatus *Bishop of Miletan confuteth such as took part with Donatus, by the Catholic community. Their wickedness he accuseth by the decree of the Pope Melchiades;
Gregorie Massonius esteemeth more of one Caluin, then of an hundred Augustines, a hundred is but a few.s Martin Luther careth not a button, if there were against him a thousād Augustines, a thousand Cyprians, a thousand Churches. I thinke it will be to no purpose to wade any further in this matter, for who may maruell, if they that thus raile against these worthy men, haue also been saucy against Optatus, Athanasius, Hilarius, both Cyrils, Epiphanius, Basill, Vincentius, Fulgentius, Leo, and Gregorie the Romane? And yet if there may be any iust defence of an vniust cause, I do not deny but the Fathers haue, wheresoeuer you reade in their workes, such matter, as may cause the Aduersarie to take pepper in the nose, so long as they follow their owne humours. For they that cannot away with prescript daies of abstinence, how is it likely that they can abide S, Basill, S. Gregorie Nazianzene, S. Leo, and S. Chrysostome, who haue set forth in printg⟨p. 119⟩very godly sermons, concerning Lent, and Ember daies, as things vsually at that time obserued among Christian people. Can those men chuse, which haue sold their soules for riches, bodily pleasure, daintie fare, and fine apparrell, but beare deadly hatred to S. Basill, S. Chrysostome, S. Hierome, and S. Augustine, whose excellent bookes of the order, rule, and vertuous life of* Monkes, are vsually in euery mans band? May they that haue intruded seruill will into man, that haue cut off all Christian funerals, that haue set on fire the reliques of Saints, continue friendship with S. Augustine? who hath penned three whole bookes of mans* freewill,t one booke of care to be taken for the dead, one long chapter of that his noble worke De ciuitat. Dei, concerning miracles wrought at the Churches, Chappels, and sepulchers of holy Martyrs, and certaine Sermons of the same matter. Can such as measure faith by their own captiousnes, refraine from anger towards S. Augustine, of whose penning there is extant a notableo Epistle against Manachie, wherein he confesseth, that for his faith he will cleaue vnto*
he reprovethx their heresy by the succession of the Bishops of Rome. He displayeth theiry madness, by their defiling both of the blessed Eucharist, and also of the holy oil. He abhorreth theirz sacrilege, in breaking down of holy Altars, whereupon Christs body is laid, and also in polluting of the Chalices, which contained Christs blood: I would gladly know what they think of Optatus, who is commended by S. aAugustine as a worthy and Catholic Bishop not inferior to S. Ambrose, and S. Cyprian, and whom S. bFulgentius also recordeth to have been an holy man and faithful Interpreter ⟨p. 120⟩of S. Paul, not unlike unto S. Augustine, and S. Ambrose. They read S. Athanasius Creed in their Churches: Do they for all that bear him any good will, who hath highly commended as an ancient writer in an exact book, S. Antony that hermit of Egypt, and also hath humbly appealed, with the Council of* Alexandria unto the Sea Apostolic of S. Peter? How often doth S. Prudentius in his Hymns pray unto the blessed Martyrs? what Hymns doth he indict in their praise? how often doth he worship the King of Martyrs at their ashes and bones? will they allow of this man? S. Hierome in the defence of Relics, and honour of Saints writeth against Vigillantius, and for the preeminence of virginity against Jovinian: will they tolerate this? An high solemn feast was kept byc S. Ambrose in the honour of his Patrons Geruasius and Protasius, to the great reproach of the Arians; which act the holyd Fathers have highly commended, and God himself adorned with many miracles: will they be friends with S. Ambrose? cS. Gregory the great, that Apostle of* ours, is flat on our side and for that title is hated of our Adversaries, whom Calvin in his fury doth deny to be brought up in thef school of the holy Ghost, because he called holy Images the books of unlearned people. A whole day would not be enough for me to reckon all the Epistles, Sermons, Homilies, Orations, Treatises, and disputations of the old Fathers, wherein of set purpose both gravely and eloquently, they have confirmed our Catholic doctrine. So long as these books of these Fathers shall be sold at the Stationers shop, in vain are the havens and sea coasts watched so narrowly; to no purpose, are houses, coffers, and chests straightly searched; to no end, are penal proclamations set upon so many gates.
he reprouethx their heresie by the succession of the Bishops of Rome. He displaieth theiry madnes, by their dafiling both of the blessed Eucharist, and also of the holy oyle. He abhorreth theirz sacriledge, in breaking downe of holy Altars, whereupon Christs body is laid, and also in polluting of the Chalices, which contained Christs blood: I would gladly know what they thinke of Optatus, who is commended by S. aAugustine as a worthy and Catholike Bishop not inferiour to S. Ambrose, and S. Cyprian, and whom S. bFulgentius also recordeth to haue been an holy man and faithfull Interpretor ⟨p. 120⟩of S. Paul, not vnlike vnto S. Augustine, and S. Ambrose. They reade S. Athanasius Creed in their Churches: Do they for all that beare him any good will, who hath highly commended as an auncient writer in an exact booke, S. Antony that hermite of Aegypt, and also hath humbly appealed, with the Councell of* Alexandria vnto the Sea Apostolike of S. Peter? How often doth S. Prudentius in his Hymnes pray vnto the blessed Martyrs? what Hymnes doth he endite in their praise? how often doth he worship the King of Martyrs at their ashes and bones? will they allow of this man? S. Hierome in the defence of Reliques, and honor of Saints writeth against Vigillantius, and for the preheminence of virginitie against Iouinian: will they tolerate this? An high solemne feast was kept byc S. Ambrose in the honor of his Patrones Geruasius and Protasius, to the great reproach of the Arrians; which act the holyd Fathers haue highly commended, and God himselfe adorned with many miracles: will they be friends with S. Ambrose? cS. Gregorie the great, that Apostle of* ours, is flat on our side and for that title is hated of our Aduersaries, whom Caluin in his fury doth deny to be brought vp in the
xLib. 2.
yLib. 3.
zLib. 6.
aAug. lib. 1 cont. Parmen. De Unit. ca. 16. & lib. 3 de Doct. Christ. c. 40.Aug. lib. 1 cont. Parmen. De Vnit. ca. 16. & lib. 3 de Doct. Christ. c. 40.
bFulgent. li. 2. ad Monim. Vide epist. Synod. Alex. ad Feli. 2.
*A counterfeit Epistle.
cVide Epist. de Ambros. ad Epist. It all. From. 3. Sil•• & tiusdem Amb. Epist. 85. Item Serm. 91.Vide Epist. de Ambros. ad Epist. It al. Fom. 3. Sil•• & tiusdem Amb. Epist. 85. Item Serm. 91.
dAugust. lib. 22. de civie. Dei. cap. 1.August. lib. 22. de ciuie. Dei. cap. 1.
cGreg•r. Tur. lib. de gloria Mar. cap. 46. Metaphrast.
*Gregory the great was neither our Apostle, nor an Apostle at all.Gregorie the great was neither our Apostle, nor an Apostle at all.
fJust. lib. 1. cap. 11. n. 5.Iust. lib. 1. cap. 11. n. 5.
For none of our late writers, neither Harding, nor Sanders, nor Allen, nor Stapleton, nor Bristol, do more vehemently inveigh against these their new found dreams, then those Fathers do, whom I have named: which things when I well considered, ⟨p. 121⟩my courage began to rise, & I had a desire to fight, in which conflict, on which side soever the adversary shall start, except he yield due honour unto God, he shall have the foil: if he allow of the Fathers, he is caught; if he disallow of them, he is no body. Thus it fell out when I was: a young student at Oxford.* John Jewel the captain of English Calvinists, challenged in most bragging sort all Catholics at Pauls Cross in London, urging and alleging like an hypocrite, all the Fathers that ever flourished within six hundred years after Christ. Certain worthy men, which then for religion lived as banished men, in the University of Lonan, though through the iniquity of the time, they lived in great distress, yet answered his challenge. That subtlety, folly, impudency, and sauciness of Jewel, which the fore said writers have luckily discovered, hath done so much good to the common sort of people in England, that within my remembrance I dare boldly say, there scarcely happened any one thing more profitable, to the afflicted English Church then this. Proclamations forth▪ with were set on every gate, that no such* books might lawfully be read or kept in their houses, whereas Jewels exclamations at Pauls Cross, did almost extort the same out of the writers hands. But they that came to the scanning of this matter found that the Fathers were all Catholic, that is, on our side. Neither didg Laurence Humphrey conceal this blow given him and his fellows, who when he had highly extolled Jewel otherwise, noted yet want of* discretion in him for this one thing, that he for his part had allowed the judgements of the Fathers in matters of controversy, which when the said Laurence Humphrey without any circumstances plainly protesteth that he neither hath, nor will have any thing to do. I did once also familiarly request Toby Matthew, who new for preaching beareth the bell, whom for good learning sake and likely seeds of other good virtues, I dearly loved, that he would plainly tell me, whether he that so diligently read the Fathers, ⟨p. 122⟩could be of that side, whereunto he laboured to allure his audience.
For none of our late writers, neither Harding, nor Sanders, nor Allen, nor Stapleton, nor Bristol, do more vehemently inueigh against these their new found dreames, then those Fathers do, whom I haue named: which things when I well considered, ⟨p. 121⟩my courage began to rise, & I had a desire to fight, in which conflict, on which side soeuer the aduer sarie shall start, except he yeeld due honor vnto God, he shall haue the foyle: if he allow of the Fathers, he is caught; if he disallow of them, he is no body. Thus it fell out when I was: a yong student at Oxford.* Iohn Iewel the captaine of English Caluinists, challenged in most bragging sort all Catholikes at Paules Crosse in London, vrging and alledging like an hypocrite, all the Fathers that euer flourished within sixe hundred yeares after Christ. Certeine worthy men, which then for religion liued as banished men, in the Ʋniuersity of Lonan, thoug through the iniquity of the time, they liued in great distresse, yet answered his challenge. That subtiltie, follie, impudency, and saucines of Iewel, which the fore said writers haue luckily discouered, hath done so much good to the cōmon sort of people in England, that within my remembrance I dare boldly say, there scarcely hapned any one thing more profitable, to the afflicted English Church then this. Proclamatiōs forth▪ with were set on euery gate, that no such* bookes might lawfullie be read or kept in their houses, whereas Iewels exclamations at Paules Crosse, did almost extort the same out of the writers hands. But they that came to the scanning of this matter found that the Fathers were all Catholike, that is, on our side. Neither didg Laurence Humphrey conceale this blow giuen him and his fellowes, who when he had highly extolled Iewel otherwise, noted yet want of* discretion in him for this one thing, that hee for his part had allowed the iudgements of the Fathers in matters of controuersie, which when the said Laurence Humphrey without any circumstances plainly protesteth that he neither hath, nor will haue any thing to doe. I did once also familiarly request Toby Mathew, who new for preaching beareth the bell, whom for good learning sake and likely seedes of other good vertues, I dearely loued, that he would plainly tell me, whether he that so diligently read the Fathers, ⟨p. 122⟩
*This word Bishop Jewel did never eat, neither will we ever renounce.This word Bishop Iewel did neuer eat, neither wil we euer renoūce.
*But Bishop Jewel published the whole book of the Adversaries that all might read them.But Bishop Iewel published the whole booke of the Aduersaries that all might reade them.
gLib. de vita Juclii.Lib. de vita Iuclii.
*This is false, he never upbraided him with any impudency.This is false, he neuer vpbraided him with any impudencie.
He replied no, if he both read them, and withal believed them.* This his answer is very true, and I persuade my self, that neither he now, nor Matthew Hutton, who as I hear is a famous man, and bent much to study the Fathers, nor any other of the Adversaries, which do the like, do otherwise think. Wherefore, yet I might come surely to this combat, to encounter with such, who as though they had a Wolfe by the ears, are enforced to discredit their cause for ever, whether they reject the Fathers or stand to their judgement. For by doing the one, they truss up their trinkets to fly away, and by doing the other, they are straightways strangled.
He replied no, if he both read them, and withall beleeued them.* This his answere is very true, and I perswade my selfe, that neither hee now, nor Mathew Hutton, who as I heare is a famous man, and bent much to study the Fathers, nor any other of the Aduersaries, which do the like, do otherwise thinke. Wherefore, yet I might come surely to this combate, to encounter with such, who as though they had a Wolfe by the eares, are inforced to discredit their cause for euer, whether they reiect the Fathers or stand to their iudgement. For by doing the one, they trusse vp their trinckets to flie away, and by doing the other, they are streightwaies strangled.
*This is most false, they who give most to the Fathers are most dissenting from you.This is most false, they who giue most to the Fathers are most dissenting from you.
Now Campian calleth upon the Fathers, from whom, because he presumes of a firm defence, he earnestly desireth a conflict, not like those light skirmishes of men in the streets, but a serious and constant disputation, such as Philosophers use: Campian (you see) hath a better mind to converse with Philosophers, than with Divines: for being furnished with Rhetoric and Logic, and having spent most of his time in often declaiming and in inventing and answering sophistical captions, he doubteth not of a famous victory, if Philosophers were Judges. But (Campian) these matters are not to be disputed among Philosophers, which are otherwhiles ⟨p. 123⟩deceived with probability and appearance of truth, following that opinion which themselves judge most agreeable to reason. This question in hand, must be discussed in the assembly of most grave and learned Divines, whom no juggling of words, no subtlety in disputation, no wit, no cunning, no youthful insolent boldness, in quarrelling lying, or foolish vaunting, can once move, much less remove them from the truth they are persuaded of. Here can you not have liberty to brag of your counterfeit devises, Philosophy may not sit as judge in these controversies, neither will those things, wherein you chiefly trust, be here of any authority: you must leave your own erroneous and endless walks, and be drawn perforce into the compass and limits of Scripture and true divinity. For Christ and his Apostles (as that discreet man said in the Nicene Council) commended not Logic and vain subtlety unto us,1 but a naked opinion, consisting in faith and good works: And this simple and sincere word of truth, will easily dissolve all your cavils, will dispel your artificial mists, and will hold you fast as in a net, so that the more you struggle to get out, the faster and straiter are you tied. But you haste to the Fathers, and say, If we may once come unto them, the war is ended. Now I must tell you, you make too much hast, and overslip many things. Is the battle ended, say you? Why, who had the victory? This is verily childish and too ridiculous, but yet usual in your combats, to triumph before the victory. But I would hear how you have finished the war, with such admirable expedition: For (say you) the Fathers are as surely ours, as Gregory the thirteenth himself;
NOw Campian calleth vpon the Fathers, from whom, because hee presumes of a firme defence, he earnestly desireth a conflict, not like those light skirmishes of men in the streets, but a serious and constant disputation, such as Philosophers vse: Campian (you see) hath a better minde to conuerse with Philosophers, than with Diuines: for being furnished with Rhetoricke and Logicke, and hauing spent most of his time in often declaiming and in inuenting and answering sophisticall captions, he doubteth not of a famous victorie, if Philosophers were Iudges. But (Campian) these matters are not to be disputed among Philosophers, which are otherwhiles ⟨p. 123⟩deceiued with probabilitie and apparance of truth, following that opinion which themselues iudge most agreeable to reason. This question in hand, must be discusted in the assemblie of most graue and learned Diuines, whom no iugling of words, no subtiltie in disputation, no wit, no cunning, no youthfull insolent boldnes, in quarrelling lying, or soolish vaunting, can once moue, much lesse remoue them from the truth they are perswaded of. Here can you not haue libertie to bragge of your counterfeit deuises, Philosophie may not sit as iudge in these controuersies, neither will those things, wherein you chiefely trust, be heere of any authority: you must leaue your owne erroneous and endlesse walkes, and be drawne perforce into the compasse and limits of Scripture and true diuinitie. For Christ and his Apostles (as that discreete man said in the Nicene Councell) commended not Logicke and vaine subtiltie vnto vs,1 but a naked opinion, consisting in faith and good works: And this simple and sincere word of truth, will easilie dissolue all your cauils, will dispell your artificiall mists, and will hold you fast as in a net, so that the more you struggle to get out, the faster and straiter are you tied. But you haste to the Fathers, and say, If we may once come vnto them, the warre is ended. Now I must tell you, you make too much hast, and ouerslippe many things. Is the battaile ended, say you? Why, who had the victorie? This is verily childish and too ridiculous, but yet vsuall in your combats, to triumphe before the victorie. But I would heare how you haue finished the warre, with such admirable expedition: For (say you) the Fathers are as surely ours, as Gregorie the thirteenth himselfe;
the most loving Father of the Children of the Church. Give me leave to answer you in your own words: My friends who are present, can you forbear laughing? What could be affirmed, ⟨p. 124⟩more weakly, fondly, or absurdly? Call you him, the most loving Father of the Churches Children, whom we knew to be their furious and mortal adversaries? And conclude you that other to be as true as this? I grant aswell the one as the other, for both are most false. What think you? have you not got a famous victory? And thus (Campian) you use to make an end of battles, and put to flight great armies of adversaries. What remaineth, but that as Conqueror, you be crowned with a Laurel garland, and carried with triumph into the Vatican, and solace your self many years with your dear Father Gregory, that good old man? But now (Campian) proceed and prosecute the victory, which you have gotten. We have (say you) whole volumes of the Fathers, which do fully, distinctly, and purposely declare that Evangelical religion, which we now defend. Now you muster and reckon up your armies; whereby you procured this victory, look well to them, you were best, and lay sure hold of them, lest they revolt, and forsaking you, come to our Tents: for you force them to be with you against their wills. So that in the most dangerous and important fight, they fly unto us with speed, and do most sharply assault and batter you. But let us consider your volumes: The two fold Hierarchy of Denis the Martyr, what orders doth it teach us, what sacrifices, what rites? Assuredly it teacheth us novelties, unheard of in the Scriptures; we therefore leave both them and their author wholly unto you. For, though this Denis, whosoever he were, was both for time ancient, and in his stile of writing, not unlearned; yet, that he should be the Ar••pagit•, whom Paul at Athens converted to the Faith, is altogether incredible. If you ask me a reason of this my opinion, I pray you read diligently and considerately that which Laurentius Valla, and Erasmus of Rotterdam ⟨p. 125⟩have written of him. Both of them persuade, by no feigned surmises, but by very weighty reasons, and such as (I ween) you will hardly gainsay, that this Denis cannot be the party you report him to be. You then have no reason to be angry with Luther or Caussaeus if they handled thisa counterfeit somewhat roughly, and censured him freely.
the most louing Father of the Children of the Church. Giue me leaue to answere you in your owne words: My friends who are present, can you forbeare langhing? What could be affirmed, ⟨p. 124⟩more weakely, fondly, or absurdly? Call you him, the most louing Father of the Churches Children, whom wee knew to bee their furious and mortall aduersaries? And conclude you that other to bee as true as this? I graunt aswell the one as the other, for both are most false. What thinke you? haue you not got a famous victorie? And thus (Campian) you vse to make an end of battailes, and put to flight great armies of aduersaries. What remaineth, but that as Conqueror, you bee crowned with a Laurell garland, and carried with triumph into the Vatican, and solace your self many yeeres with your deare Father Gregorie, that good old man? But now (Campian) proceed and prosecute the victorie, which you haue gotten. We haue (say you) whole volumes of the Fathers, which doe fully, distincty, and purposely declare that Euangelicall religion, which we now defend. Now you muster and reckon vp your armies; whereby you procured this victorie, looke well to them, you were best, and lay sure hold of them, lest they reuolt, and forsaking you, come to our Tents: for you force them to bee with you against their wils. So that in the most dangerous and important fight, they flie vnto vs with speede, and doe most sharply assault and batter you. But let vs consider your volumes: The two fold Hierarchie of Denys the Martyr, what orders doth it teach vs, what sacrifices, what rites? Assuredly it teacheth vs nouelties, vnheard of in the Scriptures; we therefore leaue both them and their author wholy vnto you. For, though this Denys, whosoeuer he were, was both for time ancient, and in his stile of writing, not vnlearned; yet, that he should be the Ar••pagit•, whom Paul at Athens conuerted to the Faith, is altogether incredible. If you aske me a reason of this my opinion, I pray you reade diligently and consideratly that which Laurentius Valla, and Eras•us of Roteradam ⟨p. 125⟩haue written of him. Both of them perswade, by no fained surmises, but by very weightie reasons, and such as (I weene) you will hardly gainsay, that this Denys cannot be the partie you report him to be. You then haue no reason to be angrie with Luther or Caussaeus if they handled thisa counterfeit somewhat roughly, and censured him freely.
aDVR. You say that Deny• is counterfeit, but prove it by no reason. But Origen, Nazianzene, Zoph•ine Archbishop of Jerusalem, Damascene, Nicephorus, Euthemius, Dionysius Archbishop of Alexandria, acknowledge his books & him to have been a disciple of S. Paul. WHIT. pag. 357. But I say that Antiquity was altogether ignorant of his books; which could not be if they bad been written of Denis Arc•pagita: for Eus•biu: diligently searching out, and setting down all ancient writers, and all th••r books and Epistles which they writ, mentioneth not •im, nor his works, neither do any […] the Greek and Latin Fathers speak of him. But who can think that the books of a disciple of Saint Paul should be unknown, and not highly esteemed of all in those days? Besides he citeth the Epistles of Ignatius, as also the Gospel and Revelation of S. John, which must needs be written divers years after the death of Denis Ar••pagita: he writeth▪ an Epistle to Polycarpus and calleth him a ruler of the Church, when at his detah Polycarpus must needs be very young▪ for Denis was slain Anno Dom 96. Polycarp died 1•6. being but 86. years of age; he calleth Timothy his sonne, who was converted before ever that Ar••pagita was: he acknowledgeth that his masters had their learning from the Apostles, doth he not thereby deny himself S. Pauls scholar? finally the Church Hierarchy and all the names of the officers reckoned up by him, were never known in the Apostles time▪ For your authors they are all new and late writers, but two. The first Origen, whom Erasmus denieth Annot. in Act. 17. once to have made motion of him in all his writings: neither ever doth Nazianzene.DVR. You say that Deny• is counterfeite, but proue it by no reason. But Origen, Nazianzene, Zoph•ine Archbishop of Hierusalem, Damascene, Nicephorus, Euthemius, Dionysius Archbishop of Alexa•dria, acknowledge his bookes & him to haue been a disciple of S. Paul. WHIT. pag. 357. But I say that Antiquitie was altogether ignorant of his bookes; which could not be if they bad been written of Denys Arcpagita: for Eusbiu: diligently searching out, and setting downe all auncient writers, and all thr bookes and Epistles which they writ, mentioneth not im, nor his workes, neither doe any the Greeke and Latin Fathers speake of him. But who can thinke that the bookes of a disciple of Saint Paul should be vnknowne, and not highly esteemed of all in those daies? Besides he citeth the Epistles of Igtius, as also the Gospell and Reuelation of S. Iohn, which must needs be written diuers yeares after the death of Denys Arpagita: hee writeth an Epistle to Polycarpus and calleth him a ruler of the Church, when at his detah Polycarpus must needs be very yong for Denys was slaine Anno Dom 96. Polycarpe died 16. being but 86. yeares of age; he calleth Timothy his sonne, who was conuerted before euer that Arpagita vvas: he acknowledgeth that his maisters had their learning from the Apostles, doth he not thereby deny himselfe S. Paules scholer? finally the Church Hierarchie and all the names of the officers reckoned vp by him, were neuer knowne in the Apostles time For your authors they are all new and late writers, but two. The first Origen, whom Erasmus denieth Annot. in
Where you say Calvin and the writers of the Centuries were offended with Ignatius, 1I confess they had just cause of offence. If heretics alleged him, to be a patron of a wicked and detestable opinion, Calvin might with reason and discretion reject him: how aptly and truly he was by them alleged, I cannot tell, let them look to it. Howsoever it be, the truth ought not by his authority to be borne down, whose credit is little, if any at all: you are not ignorant what the judgement of all the learned is those Epistles of Ignatius. Eusebius indeed makes mention of some of his Epistles, and Hierome of others: but now many more go under his name, which they have not ⟨p. 126⟩mentioned. Hierome balso reports a saying of his;3 and Theodoret another, which are not found in those Epistles which are carried about: what would you have more? Gratian himself favours not overmuch this your Ignatius. You see then, of how obscure, suspected and uncertain reputation are these two, which you place in the forefront of your army.
Where you say Caluin and the writers of the Centuries were offended with Ignatius, 1I confesse they had iust cause of offence. If heretikes alleaged him, to bee a patron of a wicked and detestable opinion, Caluin might with reason and discretion reiect him: how aptly and truly he was by them alleaged, I cannot tell, let them look to it. Howsoeuer it be, the truth ought not by his authoritie to be borne downe, whose credit is little, if any at all: you are not ignorant what the iudgement of all the learned is those Epistles of Ignatius. Eusebius indeed makes mention of some of his Epistles, and Hierome of others: but now many more goe vnder his name, which they haue not ⟨p. 126⟩mentioned. Hierome balso reports a saying of his;3 and Theodoret another, which are not found in those Epistles which are caried about: what would you haue more? Gratian himselfe fauours not ouermuch this your Ignatius. You see then, of how obscure, suspected and vncertaine reputation are these two, which you place in the forefront of your armie.
1Ignatius.
bDVR. If divers of those things there cited out of him be not to be found, how. followeth it that those works of his which are extant, be forged and none of his? WHIT. pag. 360. From thence verily it will follow that his works are not perfect, yea many things are found in his Epistles, which are incredible to have been taught in those days: as the strict keeping of Lent, and fasting upon the Sabbath days; yea it was but lately that these Epistles were printed and published, and so of the less credit and authority.DVR. If diuers of those things there cited out of him bee not to bee found, hovv. follovveth it that those works of his vvhich are extant, bee forged and noue of his? WHIT. pag. 360. From thence verely it will follow that his works are not perfect, yea many things are found in his Epistles, which are incredible to haue been taught in those daies: as the strict keeping of Lent, and fasting vpon the Sabbath daies; yea it was but latelie that these Epistles were printed and published, and so of the lesse credit and authority.
You are offended, that the Censors, as you call them, upbraid Irenaeus, as in some thing fantastical. We use not to speak reproachfully of Irenaus, whom we confess to have been both holy and learned: but what is this to the purpose? If Iraneus have written something foolishly, must be therefore by and by, be wholly yours? And if some where we have noted his opinion, as not true and sound, do we therefore reject all his works? Is this your manner of disputing (Campian) is this your skirmishing? are you of opinion, that never any word passed from Irenaeus unadvisedly, or which might justly be termed unreasonable? Then tellc me, Campian, 2how Christ preached only one year, yet was baptized the thirtieth year of his age, and died the fiftieth? what, shall we believe, that Christ taught only one year, and that the fortieth year? will you deny this to be a very new, strange, and almost frantic novelty? Besides that, many write Irenaeus to have been one of them, whom the Fathers call Millenaries; think you that was not a frantic opinion? And can you doubt of Clemens, whether he hath ⟨p. 127⟩sometimes sown Tares? what call you that, where he denieth, that Christ indeed did either hunger or thirst? Again, that Christ taught but one year, which he had of Irenaus? Again,3 that the Philosophers in hell expected the coming of Christ, & being taught by own mouth believed? Will you deny those to be Tares? and many of this kind are his to be found in the worthiest writers of that age. If you deny it, bring me one whom I will not convince to have erred by your own judgement. You dare not say,4 we have wronged Tertullian: But you will us to remember, that the book of Prescriptions was never taxed; which, for ought I remember, never was: though I confess that writing, which you name, is notable, in which many things are written, very divinely, against your Church.d I wonder you are not ashamed of Hippolytus; of whom Harding himself was almost ashamed.6 Think not that we are ought moved withe authors of so small credit, so lately drawn but of darkness, as they scarce yet have learned to look upon the light. For what was this Hippolytus? He writ, you say, of Antichrist. But how worthily? that foolish book of Hippolytus, which a ⟨p. 128⟩certain man, I know not who, of late days published, guesseth, that the Devil is Antichrist, and feigneth many other things:
You are offended, that the Censors, as you call them, vpbraide Irenaeus, as in some thing fantasticall. We vse not to speake reprochfully of Irenaus, whom we confesse to haue been both holy and learned: but what is this to the purpose? If Iraneus haue written something foolishly, must be therefore by and by, be wholy yours? And if some where we haue noted his opinion, as not true and sound, doe we therefore reiect all his works? Is this your manner of disputing (Campian) is this your skirmishing? are you of opinion, that neuer any word passed from Irenaeus vnaduisedly, or which might iustly be tearmed vnreasonable? Then tellc me, Campian, 2how Christ preached onely one yeare, yet was baptized the thirtieth yeare of his age, and died the fiftieth? what, shall we beleeue, that Christ taught onely one yeare, and that the fortieth yeare? will you denie this to be a very new, strange, and almost franticke noueltie? Besides that, many write Irenaeus to haue been one of them, whom the Fathers call Millenaries; thinke you that was not a franticke opinion? And can you doubt of Clemens, whether hee hath ⟨p. 127⟩sometimes sowne Tares? what call you that, where he denieth, that Christ indeed did either hunger or thirst? Againe, that Christ taught but one yeere, which he had of Irenaus? Againe,3 that the Philosophers in hel expected the comming of Christ, & being taught by owne mouth beleeued? Wil you deny those to be Tares? and many of this kind are his to be found in the worthiest writers of that age. If you denie it, bring me one whom I will not conuince to haue erred by your owne iudgement. You dare not say,4 we haue wronged Tertullian: But you will vs to remember, that the book of Prescriptions was neuer taxed; which, for ought I remember, neuer was: though I confesse that writing, which you name, is notable, in which many things are written, very diuinely, against your Church.d I wonder you are not ashamed of Hippolytus; of whom Harding himselfe was almost ashamed.6 Thinke not that we are ought moued withe authors of so small credit, so lately drawne but of darknes, as they scarse yet haue learned to looke vpon the light. For what was this Hippolytus? He writ, you say, of Antichrist. But how worthily? that foolish booke of Hippolytus, which a
cDVR. You that acknowledge, and admit nothing but the Scriptures, can by no argument confute this err•r. WHIT. p. 362. What may worse beseem a livine, then thus to speak? What think you of these places: Christ when he began to preach the Gospel was about thirty years of age? Luke 3.23. After his Baptism John maketh mention of three Pasleovers, and that in the third he was put to death? Is not the time then very plainly set down? and indeed what can be more plain and casie? Hence we may observe that the Fathers have plainly erred, where you would hardly believe any man could err.DVR. You that acknovveledge, and admit nothing but the Scriptures, can by no argument confute this err•r. WHIT. p. 362. What may worse beseeme a liuine, then thus to speake? What thinke you of these places: Christ when he began to preach the Gospell was about thirtie yeares of age? Luke 3.23. After his Baptisme Iohn maketh mention of three Pasleouers, and that in the third he was put to death? Is not the time then very plainely set downe? and indeede what can be more plaine and casie? Hence we may obserue that the Fathers haue plainely erred, where you would hardly beleeue any man could erre.
2Lib. 2. cap. 39.40.
3Clement. Stromat. lib. 3. idem lib. 1. idem. lib. 5.
4Tertul.
dDVR. But you tell us not any one particular whereby this may appear. WHIT. pag. 365. I suppose you never read this book, or else you would not make doubt of it. Is any thing more against your traditions, then that he pronounceth a curie to them that shall bring any doctrine, but the self same which the nations received from the Apostles, and they from Christ himself? And that men cannot be otherwise persuaded of the things of faith, then from the writings of faith? when he gathereth from Christ sending of his Apostles, that no Ministers are else to be receive, but such as Christ hath ordained? when whatsoever is later brought is foreign and false? when he w•••eth, that faith must be built and borne up, upon the writings of the Law and of the Prophets, the Evangelists and Apostles?DVR. But you tell vs not any one particular whereby this may appeare. WHIT. pag. 365. I suppose you neuer read this booke, or else you would not make doubt of it. Is any thing more against your traditions, then that hee pronounceth a curie to them that shall bring any doctrine, but the selfe same which the nations receiued from the Apostles, and they from Christ himselfe? And that men cannot be otherwise perswaded of the things of faith, then from the writings of faith? when he gathereth from Christ sending of his Apostles, that no Ministers are else to be receiue, but such as Christ hath ordeined? when whatsoeuer is later brought is forraine and false? when he weth, that faith must be built and borne vp, vpon the writings of the Law and of the Prophets, the Euangelists and Apostles?
which neither can be true, nor were ever esteemed for true. And yet you marvel we set him so light, whom no man regards or reads, or almost knows. I can give you good leave to reckon him for your own, and if you will, let him have a better note in your army.
which neither can be true, nor were euer esteemed for true. And yet you marueile we set him so light, whom no man regards or reads, or almost knowes. I can giue you good leaue to recken him for your owne, and if you will, let him haue a better note in your armie.
The accusation concerning Cyprian, 1is more heinous, whom all men reverence for his singular faith and excellent learning. But Caussaeus termeth him senseless and without God. They of Magdeburg, call him a corrupter of penance. Shall I be tied to take upon me, and defend every speech, which any man hath at any time uttered? This Caussaeus I never saw, nor before this ever heard of him. But in as much, as you so odiously accuse him, I suppose him to be some learned and godly man. Unto that he saith of Cyprian, I answer that which I remember I have read inf Nazianzene, viz. that he was in his youth dissolute and given to much vice, and worshipped Devils, and used the help of Devils: He was (saith Nazianzene) a worshipper of Devils, and after a disciple of Christ. 3Your unreasonableness forceth me to mention those things, which I had rather have concealed. For in the Fathers imperfections, you stick fast like a burr, and cease not to rub up the remembrance of those things, which you should do better, not once to touch, If these things which Nazianzene reporteth of Cyprian be true, then Caussaeus might say, that Cyprian at that time was foolish and godless. For I cannot think that Caussaeus would write so of him, but in regard of those times, or that any man would conceive so injuriously, of that godly Martyr: whereas they of Magdeburg complain ⟨p. 129⟩that he corrupted the doctrine of repentance, therein they forge against him no new accusation, but rather disclose that which all men know to have been too true. Cyprian wrote some thing of Repentance very unseasonably and undiscreetly, and not heg alone, but all the holy Fathers of that time, were tainted with that error. For being desirous by severe laws, to limit and restrain the evil manners of men, they made the greatest part of Repentance to consist, in certain outward disciplines, which they appointed: which severe censuring of sin & sharp punishing of wickedness, might haply be borne withal: but when they thought the punishment of sin to be discharged, Gods justice satisfied, freedom from sin, and certain forgiveness with righteousness hereby to be procured; herein they diminished the power of Christs death, they attributed too much to their own inventions, and in a word depraved the doctrine of repentance:
The accusation concerning Cyprian, 1is more haynous, whom all men reuerence for his singular faith and excellent learning. But Caussaeus tearmeth him senselesse and without God. They of Magdenburge, call him a corrupter of penance. Shall I be tied to take vpon me, and defend euery speech, which any man hath at any time vttered? This Caussaeus I neuer saw, nor before this euer heard of him. But in as much, as you so odiously accuse him, I suppose him to bee some learned and godly man. Vnto that he saith of Cyprian, I answere that which I remember I haue read inf Nazianzene, viz. that he was in his youth dissolute and giuen to much vice, and worshipped Diuels, and vsed the helpe of Diuels: He was (saith Nazianzene) a worshipper of Diuels, and after a disciple of Christ. 3Your vnreasonablenes forceth me to mention those things, which I had rather haue concealed. For in the Fathers imperfections, you sticke fast like a burre, and cease not to rub vp the remembrance of those things, which you should doe better, not once to touch, If these things which Nazianzene reporteth of Cyprian be true, then Caussaeus might say, that Cyprian at that time was foolish and godlesse. For I cannot thinke that Caussaeus would write so of him, but in regard of those times, or that any man would conceiue so iniuriously, of that godly Martyr: whereas they of Magdenburge complaine ⟨p. 129⟩that hee corrupted the doctrine of repentance, therein they forge against him no new accusation, but rather disclose that which all men know to haue been too true. Cyprian wrote some thing of Repentance very vnseasonably and vndiscreetly, and not heg alone, but all the holy Fathers of that time, were tainted with that error. For being desirous by seuere lawes, to limit and restraine the euill manners of men, they made the greatest part of Repentance to consist, in certaine outward disciplines, which they appointed: which seuere censuring of sinne & sharpe punishing of wickednes, might happely be borne withall: but when they thought the punishment of sinne to be discharged, Gods iustice satisfied, freedome from sinne, and certeine forgiuenes with righteousnes hereby to be procured; herein they diminished the power of Christs death, they attributed too much to their owne inuentions, and in a word depraued the doctrine of repentance:
1Cyprian.
fDVR. That Cyprian which Nazianzene speaketh of, was not our Cyprian the Father of the Church. WHIT. pag. 367. Nazianzene certainly speaketh of the same Cyprian. for see how he describes him; He did not only govern the Church of Carthage, and all Africa, but the whole West, and almost the East, the Southern and Northern parts: how think you, is it not the same Cyprian?DVR. That Cyprian which Nazianzene speaketh of, was not our Cyprian the Father of the Church. WHIT. pag. 367. Nazianzene certainely speaketh of the same Cyprian. for see how hee describes him; He did not only gouerne the Church of Carthage, and all Affricke, but the vvhole VVest, and almost the East, the Southerne and Northerne parts: how thinke you, is it not the same Cyprian?
3Nazian. de Cypri.
gDVR. O singular impudency! O intolerable arrogance! what, have all the Fathers in that age erred so sousely in so great a matter? As if they were ignorant that the works of repentance had any virtue any where else. but from the merits and blood of Christ. WHIT. pag. 369. What need all this heat? It had been your part to have showed that the Fathers who then lived, have spoken nothing unfitly of repentance, so had you confuted that I charge them with, which your hear will not cure. And what if the Fathers have thought that mens works have all their virtue and power from the merit of Christ; will it thence follow they have spoken nothing unfitly of repentance and works? As if Christ by his death had only merited that we might by our works and merits deserve eternal life; or that they who hold the foundation may not build timber or hay upon it.DVR. O singular impudencie! O intollerable arrogancie! what, haue all the Fathers in that age erred so sousely in so great a matter? As if they were ignorant that the works of repentance had any vertue any where else. but from the merits and blood of Christ. WHIT. pag. 369. What neede all this heate? It had been your part to haue shewed that the Fathers who then liued, haue spoken nothing vnfitly of repentance, so had you confuted that I charge them with, which your heare will not cure. And what if the Fathers haue thought that mens works haue all their vertue and power from the merit of Christ; will it thence follow they haue spoken nothing vnfitly of repentance and works? As if Christ by his death had onely merited that we might by our works and merits deserue eternall life; or that they who hold the foundation may not build timber or haie vpon it.
because our sins are cleansed and removed, by no offices or works of ours, but only by the blood and passion of Christ. And so your objection of Repentance is answered. We do not for all this deny the works of Cyprian, nor reject the books of any Father of that age, as you falsely affirm, seeing both he and they agree with us in the greatest questions: but this is the privilege of you and your fellows, that you even greedily hunt after, and pursue, whatsoever is faulty in any author, as if all the Fathers errors, served to make up the body and faith of your religion. Something, you say, Cyprian wrote to Cornelius, ⟨p. 130⟩which if we give credit unto: then Peter Martyr and his confederates, must be held for worse than adulterous & sacrilegious; but what that is, I cannot so much as conjecture. I know that Cyprian sent many letters to Cornelius, but none of them accuse us, either of adultery or sacrilege; neither can you out of those letters allege any thing to our prejudice or your advantage: but this is ever your manner, to prove nothing clearly and distinctly, but only to name the Fathers, and from their names, to raise certain roving & uncertain suspicions. That which you write of Chambers and pillows, I pass over as nothing else, but scoffing and reproachful taunts, such as is common in every varlets mouth. Now you come to the next age, and here you mention Chrysostom, Nazianzene, Ambrose, and Hierome. But to what purpose I pray you?1 for what if Luther do censure Chrysostom sharply, because by too much advancing our works and merits, he obscureth the righteousness of faith? what though Caussaeus find some thing fabulous in Nazianzene? 2htherefore are these Fathers wholly on your side? what is this else but dotage, and to speak without wit or fear? Some body said that Ambrose was bewitched by the devil;4 whether any ⟨p. 131⟩ever said it or no, I never knew, neither is it greatly material; the best & most righteous men, may sometimes be so far bewitched, as they do not in some things perceive the truth: and you do too openly bewray your malice, by labouring to raise an evil opinion of him, and to make us infamous for such speeches as may have a good construction, though at the first they seem odious. Certainly I have read many Papists, and heard of some, all passing shameless, and malapert;
because our sinnes are clensed and remoued, by no offices or workes of ours, but only by the blood and passion of Christ. And so your obiection of Repentance is answered. We doe not for all this deny the workes of Cyprian, nor reiect the bookes of any Father of that age, as you falsely affirme, seeing both he and they agree with vs in the greatest questions: but this is the priuiledge of you and your fellowes, that you euen greedily hunt after, and pursue, whatsoeuer is faulty in any author, as if all the Fathers errors, serued to make vp the body and faith of your religion. Something, you say, Cyprian wrote to Cornelius, ⟨p. 130⟩which if we giue credit vnto: then Peter Martyr and his cōfederats, must be held for worse thē adulterous & sacrilegious; but what that is, I cannot so much as couiecture. I know that Cyprian sent many letters to Cornelius, but none of them accuse vs, either of adultery or sacriledge; neither can you out of those letters alleadge any thing to our preiudice or your aduantage: but this is euer your manner, to proue nothing clearely and distinctly, but only to name the Fathers, and from their names, to raise certaine rouing & vncertaine suspitions. That which you write of Chambers and pillowes, I passe ouer as nothing else, but scoffing and reproachfull taunts, such as is common in euery varlets mouth. Now you come to the next age, and heere you mention Chrysostome, Nazianzene, Ambrose, and Hierome. But to what purpose I pray you?1 for what if Luther do censure Chrysostome sharply, because by too much aduauncing our works and merits, he obscureth the righteousnes of faith? what though Caussaeus find some thing fabulous in Nazianzene? 2htherefore are these Fathers wholie on your side? what is this else but dotage, and to speake without witte or feare? Some body said that Ambrose was bewitched by the diuell;4 whether any ⟨p. 131⟩euer said it or no, I neuer knew, neither is it greatly materiall; the best & most righteous men, may sometimes be so farre bewitched, as they doe not in some things perceiue the truth: and you doe too openly bewray your malice, by labouring to raise an euill opinion of him, and to make vs infamous for such speeches as may haue a good construction, though at the first they seeme odious. Certeinly I haue read many Papists, and heard of some, all passing shamelesse, and malepere;
1Chrysostom.
2Nazian.
hDVR. You freely grant that Chrysostom, Nazianzene, Ambrose, and Hierome are on Campians side: and yet you pleasantly demand are these Fathers wholly yours? we, who are then true sons, do not challenge them as half Fathers, but wholly our Fathers. WHIT. pag. 370. When did I ever grant Campian so much? I should certainly do the Fathers great injury, if I should adjudge them for Campian, who are so far different from him. And for your kindred with them; it is but as the Jews were Abrahams children: for if you were the children of the Fathers, you would hold the faith of the Fathers. For the Scribes and Pharisees were not the children of Moses, because they sate in Moses chair. Neither are they the children of the Saints, who hold the places of the Saints; as Hierome. Neither have they the inheritance of Peter, which have not the faith of Peter; as Ambrose: neither ought faith to be tried by persons, but persons by saith, as Tertullian hath written. We verily love and duly reverence the Fathers, yet we acknowledge but one Father in heaven, and one teacher, which is Christ. And if you acknowledge them wholly your Fathers, why do you forsake many of their opinions?DVR. You freely graunt that Chrysostome, Nazianzene, Ambrose, and Hierome are on Campians side: and yet you pleasantly demaund are these Fathers wholy yours? we, who are then true sonnes, doe not challenge them as halfe Fathers, but wholy our Fathers. WHIT. pag. 370. When did I euer grant Campian so much? I should certeinly doe the Fathers great iniury, if I should adiudge them for Campian, who are so farre different from him. And for your kindred with them; it is but as the Iewes were Abrahams children: for if you were the children of the Fathers, you would hold the faith of the Fathers. For the Scribes and Pharisies were not the children of Moses, because they sate in Moses chaire. Neither are they the children of the Saints, who hold the places of the Saints; as Hierome. Neither haue they the inheritance of Peter, which haue not the faith of Peter; as Ambrose: neither ought faith to be tried by persons, but persons by saith, as Tertullian hath written. We verily loue and duly reuerence the Fathers, yet wee acknowledge but one Father in heauen, and one teacher, which is Christ. And if you acknowledge them wholy your Fathers, why doe you forsake many of their opinions?
but more impudent then your self, in all my life, did I never know any. There is no end of your lying, you fear no mens censure, there is neither faith nor truth in any thing you speak. Even now you set upon Beza with a fresh lye. He (you say) hath written that Hierome is as surely damned, as the devil, because he was injurious to the Apostles, a blasphemous, a wicked, and an ungodly man. That Beza affirmeth not these things, I protest and a•ow: let any man that will, see the place; if it be otherwise, let me be accounted very infamous. For as for those first words, that Hierome was damned aswell a• the devil, either they are by malicious cavilling fetched out of some other place, as all the rest are, or altogether forged, as the most. In the place alleged, there is no such thing: Concerning that he saith of Injury and Blasphemy, I will set down Beza his own words, that all men may know your impudency. Even Hierome, 1saith Beza, if it be true that Erasmus upon this place saith of him, is not only injurious to the Apostle, in that he findeth want of moderation, in this speech, wherein rather appeareth his Divine courage but also is openly blasphemous, in that even in Christ himself he hath found some sign of imperfection. Thus far Beza: the matter of his complaint, is about S. Pauls sharp answer unto the high Priest, in which Hierome, (as Erasmus testifieth) in his Dialogues against Pelagius, findeth some want of moderation, & not only ⟨p. 132⟩so, but even in Christ himself, he looketh for some imperfection of piety; which reports of Hierome, if it be true as Erasmus affirmeth, why might not Beza justly esteem him, in the one injurious to the Apostle, in the other so blasphemous against Christ? For what can be devised more unworthy the Apostle then that in his answer to the high Priest, he should show too much spleen, or what could be spoken more blasphemous against Christ, than that the grace, wherewith he was endued, was imperfect. But Beza further reprehendeth Hieromes exceeding boldness, in wresting the Scriptures, wherein he hath most just cause of complaint: for either Hierome wrested the Scriptures, or they are so weak and easy of themselves, as they may be any way turned. And truly he must be very desperate, that should defend Hieromes interpretations. Gregorius Massonius esteemeth more of Calvin, then of a thousand Augustines:
but more impudent then your selfe, in all my life, did I neuer know any. There is no end of your lying, you feare no mens censure, there is neither faith nor truth in any thing you speake. Euen now you set vpon Beza with a fresh lye. He (you say) hath written that Hierome is as surely damned, as the diuell, because he was iniurious to the Apostles, a blasphemous, a wicked, and an vngodly man. That Beza affirmeth not these things, I protest and a•ow: let any man that will, see the place; if it be otherwise, let me be accounted very infamous. For as for those first words, that Hierome was damned aswell a• the diuell, either they are by malicious cauelling fetched out of some other place, as all the rest are, or altogether forged, as the most. In the place alledged, there is no such thing: Concerning that he saith of Iniury and Blasphemy, I will set downe Beza his owne words, that all men may know your impudency. Euen Hierome, 1saith Beza, if it be true that Erasmus vpon this place saith of him, is not only iniurious to the Apostle, in that hee findeth want of moderation, in this speech, wherin rather appeareth his Diuine courage but also is openly blasphemous, in that euen in Christ himselfe he hath found some signe of imperfection. Thus far Beza: the matter of his complaint, is about S. Paules sharpe answere vnto the high Priest, in which Hierome, (as Erasmus testifieth) in his Dialogues against Pelagius, findeth some want of moderatiō, & not only ⟨p. 132⟩so, but euen in Christ himself, he looketh for some imperfection of piety; which reports of Hierome, if it be true as Erasmus affirmeth, why might not Beza iustly esteeme him, in the one iniurious to the Apostle, in the other so blasphemous against Christ? For what can bee deuised more vnworthy the Apostle then that in his answere to the high Priest, he should shew too much spleene, or what could be spoken more blasphemous against Christ, thē that the grace, wherewith he was indued, was imperfect. But Beza further reprehendeth Hieromes exceeding boldnes, in wresting the Scriptures, wherein he hath most iust cause of complaint: for either Hierome wrested the Scriptures, or they are so weake and easie of themselues, as they may be any way turned. And truly he must be very desperate, that should defend Hieromes interpretations. Gregorius Massonius esteemeth more of Caluin, then of a thousand Augustines:
1Beza in annot. novi Testam. in Act. Apost. cap. 23.Beza in annot. noui Testam. in Act. Apost. cap. 23.
Luther is not moved though a thousand Austens, Cyprians, Churches▪ be against him. The answer is ready: whosoever speaketh truth, in that respect, is more to be esteemed, then a great multitude that could not discern the truth. They therefore that have observed the errors of the Fathers, either those you have named, or the rest, which here also you reckon up, Optatus, Athanasius, Hilary, Cyril, Epiphanius Basil, Vincentius, Fulgentius, Lee, and Gregory of Rome, and have admonished the Readers of them; are so far from malapertness herein; as that contrary, they have performed a work, for the Church needful, profitable, and acceptable to all good and godly men. For as the true expositions of Scriptures, are to be expounded to the Churches, so are the contrary to be rejected.1 Hierome saith well, it is the worst kind of teaching, to deprave sentences of Scripture, and to draw them perforce to serve our turns. Wherefore we profess with Augustine; All writers and their sayings must be ⟨p. 133⟩ijudged, according to the holy Scriptures, the authority whereof is more excellent, then the whole nature of man is able to conceive: not that I disallow the opinions of the most worthy Fathers, but I follow those that come nearest unto the Scriptures, and when the Scripture it self is manifest, I embrace it before them all. Whereas then we consider the sayings of the Fathers, and examine them by the light of Scriptures, we do here nothing unwonted, nothing boldly or arrogantly; but you have always been fliers of the light of Scriptures, as Tertullian speaketh:3 and therefore do so diligently provide for lurking holes in the Fathers, that you may always have some place of refuge. For seeing Scriptures fail you, what remaineth, but that you seek aide from any, even the meanest?
Luther is not moued though a thousand Austens, Cyprians, Churches▪ be against him. The answere is ready: whosoeuer speaketh truth, in that respect, is more to be esteemed, then a great multitude that could not discerne the truth. They therfore that haue obserued the errors of the Fathers, either those you haue named, or the rest, which heere also you recken vp, Optatus, Athanasius, Hilarie, Cyrill, Epiphanius Basil, Vincentius, Fulgentius, Lee, and Gregory of Rome, and haue admonished the Readers of them; are so farre from malepertnes herein; as that cōtrary, they haue performed a work, for the Church needfull, profitable, and acceptable to all good and godly men. For as the true expositions of Scriptures, are to bee expounded to the Churches, so are the contrary to bee reiected.1 Hierome saith well, it is the worst kind of teaching, to depraue sentences of Scripture, and to draw them perforce to serue our turnes. Wherefore we professe with Augustine; All writers and their sayings must bee ⟨p. 133⟩iiudged, according to the holy Scriptures, the authority wherof is more excellent, then the whole nature of man is able to conceiue: not that I disallow the opinions of the most worthy Fathers, but I follow those that come nearest vnto the Scriptures, and when the Scripture it selfe is manifest, I embrace it before them all. Whereas then we consider the sayings of the Fathers, and examine them by the light of Scriptures, we do here nothing vnwonted, nothing boldly or arrogantly; but you haue alwaies been fliers of the light of Scriptures, as Tertullian speaketh:3 and therefore do so diligently prouide for lurking holes in the Fathers, that you may alwaies haue some place of refuge. For seeing Scriptures faile you, what remaineth, but that you seeke aide from any, euen the meanest?
1Hierom. Paul. August.
iDVR. That trial must not be made by Apostate Monks, but by lawful Pastors and doctors. WHIT. pag. 372. And why not I pray you? is it because they are Monks? I think not: or because they have departed from you? That is the matter; as it none might touch, read, & examine the scriptures, but those who have plight their troth to you, never to assent to the Scriptures, though they directly contradict popish doctrine we would willingly hearken to lawful Pastors, examining & interpreting the Scriptures, such as you have none. Because with you examinations must not be made by the rule of the scriptures, but after the will of the Pope, and all your Pastors have tied themselves to the judgement of the Romish Antichrist: that, yt which they see, they will not see, if it displease ye Pope, by whose spirit they are guided.DVR. That trial must not be made by Apostate Monks, but by lawfull Pastors and doctors. WHIT. pag. 372. And why not I pray you? is it because they are Monkes? I thinke not: or because they haue departed frō you? That is the matter; as it none might touch, reade, & examine the scriptures, but those who haue plight their troth to you, neuer to assent to the Scriptures, though they directly cōtradict popish doctrin we would willingly harkē to lawfull Pastors, examining & interpreting the Scriptures, such as you haue none. Because with you examinatiōs must not be made by the rule of ye scriptures, but after the wil of the Pope, and all your Pastors haue tyed thēselues to the iudgemēt of the Romish Antichrist: that, yt which they see, they wil not see, if it displease ye Pope, by whose spirit they are guided.
But you tell us, why we do so much avoid the Fathers. I had rather you would tell us why you do so carefully avoid the Scriptures. For (say you) they that cannot away with set times of Fasting, must needs be offended with Basil, Naziancene, Leo, and Chrysostom, which have published excellent Sermons of Lent. Christ ordained no set and ordinary fasts in the Gospel,k Lent was appointed long after, and the manner of ⟨p. 134⟩observing it in those times, was not one & the same in all Churches. We both allow and use public and Christian fasts which are fitted to the time and the Churches occasions: as for your appointed, and yearly solemn fasts, we do with good reason reject them, because they are full of superstition, and injurious unto Christian liberty. Our judgement of fasting is the same which Augustine hath taught:2 I find it not set down in any Commandment of the Lord, or his Apostles, what days we ought to fast, what not. Augustine then knew not these your set yearly ceremonies of fasting, not your Lenten fast, which hath a certain time and number of days prescribed. Further (you say) they that have set their souls to sale for gold, lust, excess, and worldly ostentation how can they be but most opposite to Basil, Chrysostom, Hierome, and Augustine, whose books of the profession of Monks are in every mans hands? what will you censure all to be covetous, lustful, gluttonous, or ambitious that are not Monks? back with that foot you were best, for fear of your head: for neither the Pope, nor his Cardinals and Bishops, hold it either necessary, or convenient for them to lay aside, their abundant wealth, continual pleasures, their dainty fare, their kingly honour, and thrust themselves into a Monastery; whosoever liveth after their fashion, cannot be well affected to Basil, nor any man that is holy.l For they are altogether so drowned in sensuality and excess, making themselves drudges unto their ambitions, banquets, and delights. And to conclude: in the ⟨p. 135⟩whole course of their lives, so behaving themselves, as becometh better sensual and voluptuous persons, proceeding out of the gardens of Epicures, then grave teachers out of Christs School. Who knoweth not that the whole world crieth shame upon you, and hath done continually and most deservedly?
But you tell vs, why we do so much anoid the Fathers. I had rather you would tell vs why you doe so carefully auoide the Scriptures. For (say you) they that cannot away with set times of Fasting, must needs be offended with Basil, Naziancene, Leo, and Chrysostome, which haue published excellent Sermons of Lent. Christ ordeined no set and ordinary fasts in the Gospell,k Lent was appointed long after, and the manner of ⟨p. 134⟩obseruing it in those times, was not one & the same in all Churches. We both allow and vse publike and Christian fasts which are fitted to the time and the Churches occasions: as for your appointed, and yearely solemne fasts, we do with good reason reiect them, because they are full of superstition, and iniurious vnto Christian liberty. Our iudgement of fasting is the same which Augustine hath taught:2 I find it not set downe in any Commandement of the Lord, or his Apostles, what daies we ought to fast, what not. Augustine then knew not these your set yearely ceremonies of fasting, not your Lenten fast, which hath a certeine time and number of daies prescribed. Further (you say) they that haue set their soules to sale for gold, lust, excesse, and worldly ostentation how can they be but most opposite to Basil, Chrysostome, Hierome, and Augustine, whose bookes of the profession of Monkes are in euery mans hands? what will you censure all to be couetous, lustfull, gluttonous, or ambitious that are not Monkes? backe with that foot you were best, for feare of your head: for neither the Pope, nor his Cardinals and Bishops, hold it either necessary, or conuenient for them to lay aside, their abundant wealth, continuall pleasures, their dainty fare, their kingly honor, and thrust themselues into a Monasterie; whosoeuer liueth after their fashion, cannot be well affected to Basil, nor any man that is holy.l For they are altogether so drowned in sensuality and excesse, making themselues drudges vnto their ambitions, banquets, and delights. And to conclude: in the ⟨p. 135⟩whole course of their liues, so behauing themselues, as becommeth better sensuall and voluptuous persons, proceeding out of the gardens of Epicures, then graue teachers out of Christs Schoole. Who knoweth not that the whole world crieth shame vpon you, and hath done continually and most deseruedly?
kDVR. Who hath but so much as saluted the Fathers, and knoweth not this to be safe? for the observation of Lent is most ancient and ordained by the Apostles. WHIT. pag. 371. I deny it not to be most ancient, but not instituted by the Apostles; for Apollonius writeth that Montanus first made laws for let and certain fasts; and Tertullian when he was become a Montanist, writeth as much in his book wherein he defendeth the fasts of Montanus. Again, the Apostles never put any religion in choice and change of meats, Rom. 14.17. Coll. 2 16. Tit. 1.1•. and so ordained not Lean. Lastly the Churches of the Apostles differed much in this fast, both in their times, & in their kinds of meat; as Eusebius & Socrates record; which would never have bin if it had bin Apostolical, at least as Papists do affirm, who take in for a truth, that those Churches would faithfully persist in the Apostles decrees.DVR. Who hath but so much as saluted the Fathers, and knoweth not this to be salfe? for the obseruation of Lent is most auncient and ordained by the Apostles. WHIT. pag. 371. I deny it not to be most auncient, but not instituted by the Apostles; for Apollonius writeth that Montanus first made lawes for let and certaine fasts; and Tertullian when hee was become a Montanist, writeth as much in his booke wherein he defendeth the fasts of Montanus. Againe, the Apostles neuer put any religion in choise and change of meats, Rom. 14.17. Coll. 2 16. Tit. 1.1•. and so ordeined not Lene. Lastly the Churches of the Apostles differed much in this fast, both in their times, & in their kinds of meat; as Eusebius & •ocrates record; which would neuer haue bin if it had bin Apostolical, at least as Papists do affirme, who take in for a truth, that those Churches would faithfully persist in the Apostles decrees.
2August. Epist. 86.
lDVR. When you are overcome by the truth, you slander our lives, and speak evil of our persons. WHIT. pag. 377. I do not slander you, nor detract from you, the world hath understood long ago what manner of men you were. If you be grown better I should be glad of it. But I know men have judged otherwise of this order, and such as did not hate your Monastical life. For the Romish Cardinals and Priors did write thus to the Pope himself. There is another abuse amongst the orders of religious men, for many are so deformed and out of order, that they are a great scandal to the people, and hurt much by their example. We think that all orders ought to be abolished.
you for all that blush not to lay those things to our charge, which are well enough known to be your own fault; your Prelates and Monks, whose goodly order and strait rule of severe discipline, (you report) differ as much from other men, as the Tarrentines were wont to affirm that they excelled all others, who giving themselves wholly over to pleasures, (while the most took great pains and always did something whereby to live) thought their life the only true life. Such is and hath bin your life, that others must seem not to live, if that be to live which you have esteemed. But what need I answer you any more of fasting and Monkish orders, which have not one Monk in your whole Church any thing resembling those of ancient time, neither do you observe the old manner of fasting? but you go on, and upbraid us with fouler matters. They that have brought a bondage upon mans will, which have taken away Christian funerals, which have burned Saints relics can they (say you) be well pleased with Augustine? we (Campion) have wronged no Saints, we have neither burned their relics, nor taken away their funerals:m only we could not suffer any profane superstition, injurious to the Majesty and glory of God; and for this we have the direction of God himself, being our pattern whom we follow, and Augustine also herein consenteth with us: But we have ⟨p. 136⟩captivated the will of man, and then (you say) how can we be well affected unto Augustine? well enough, why not? for (say you) he writ three books of free will. A most witless and ridiculous collection: Augustine writ three books of freewill, ergo Augustine affirmeth that men have freewill. If that reason be currant, then this also: Augustine writ a book of two souls against the Manichees; also a book of lying; another of the quantity of the soul; ergo Augustine defendeth two souls in a man; ergo he praised lying; ergo he attributeth greatness & quantity to the soul. I pray you what difference is there? I grant Augustine writ those books you mention, but they overthrow not our opinion, who affirm that the will of man is in bondage: & if ever you had perused those books, you would never have affirmed it, nor once named the books in this matter.
you for all that blush not to lay those things to our charge, which are well inough knowne to bee your owne fault; your Prelates and Monkes, whose goodly order and straite rule of seuere discipline, (you report) differ as much from other men, as the Tarrentines were wont to affirme that they excelled all others, who giuing themselues wholy ouer to pleasures, (while the most tooke great paines and alwaies did something whereby to liue) thought their life the only true life. Such is and hath bin your life, that others must seeme not to liue, if that be to liue which you haue esteemed. But what need I answere you any more of fasting and Monkish orders, which haue not one Monke in your whole Church any thing resembling those of auncient time, neither do you obserue the old manner of fasting? but you goe on, and vpbraide vs with fouler matters. They that haue brought a bondage vpon mans will, which haue taken away Christian funerals, which haue burned Saints reliques can they (say you) be well pleased with Augustine? we (Campion) haue wronged no Saints, we haue neither burned their reliques, nor taken away their funerals:m only we could not suffer any prophane superstition, iniurious to the Maiestie and glorie of God; and for this we haue the direction of God himselfe, being our patterne whom we follow, and Augustine also herein consenteth with vs: But we haue ⟨p. 136⟩captiuated the will of man, and then (you say) how can we be well affected vnto Augustine? well inough, why not? for (say you) he writ three bookes of free will. A most witles and ridiculous collection: Augustine writ three bookes of freewill, ergo Augustine affirmeth that men haue freewill. If that reason be currant, then this also: Augustine writ a booke of two soules against the Manichees; also a booke of lying; another of the quantity of the soule; ergo Augustine defendeth two soules in a man; ergo he praised lying; ergo he attributeth greatnes & quantity to the soule. I pray you what difference is there? I graunt Augustine writ those bookes you mention, but they ouerthrow not our opinion, who affirme that the will of man is in bondage: & if euer you had perused those bookes, you would neuer haue affirmed it, nor once named the bookes in this matter.
mDVR. Therefore you have taken away the relics of the Saints, and the funerals of Christians, as superstitions and injurious to the majesty of God. WHIT. pag. 370. Are you so without judgement, that you cannot distinguish betwixt things and the superstitious use of them? It is not these not any comely burial we dislike, but Popish pompcions funerals and impious worshipping of relics.DVR. Therefore you haue taken away the reliques of the Saints, and the funerals of Christians, as superstitions and iniurious to the maiestie of God. WHIT. pag. 370. Are you so vvithout iudgement, that you cannot distinguish betvvixt things and the superstitious vse of them? It is not these not any comely buriall vve dislike, but Popish pompcions funerals and impious vvorshipping of reliques.
Augustine writ these books against the Manichees, wherein he disputeth not of mans freewill, which is the point in controversy, but of the cause of sin which proceeded from freewill, and he entitled those books of freewill, because in them he intendeth to show, that the original and beginning of sin is to be found in mans freewill, not in God. This you might easily have learned out of his retractations; for thus he writeth.1 The discourse was undertaken for them that deny sin to have his original from the free action of our will, affirming, that from this would follow, that God himself the author of nature is culpable. And so proceedeth, utterly denying, that he had any purpose in those books, to speak of that will, which is made free by Gods grace. And whatsoever in these books passed his pen, which seemed to favour the Pelagians, then Patrons of freewill, as you are now, all that he carefully collecteth out of the whole work, and cleareth it from their cavils. Have we any cause to be offended with Augustine, which in this question is ⟨p. 137⟩not against us? And that you may plainly perceive, how indiscreetly you alleged these books of freewill, mark what he writeth of the will of man in those same books:n Hold thou fast (saith Augustine) this principal of piety, 3that no good thing happens unto thee, either when thou thinkest or understandest, or any way imaginest, which is not from God. And this was Augustine's constant opinion of freewill: after that being stirred by the Pelagians, he throughly understood the question, viz. that he judged it, to be utterly lost and gone.o Man (saith he) by abusing his freewill lost both it and himself.5
Augustine writ these bookes against the Manichees, wherein he disputeth not of mans freewill, which is the point in controuersie, but of the cause of sinne which proceeded from freewill, and he entituled those bookes of freewill, because in them he intendeth to shew, that the originall and beginning of sinne is to be found in mans freewill, not in God. This you might easily haue learned out of his retractations; for thus he writeth.1 The discourse was vndertaken for them that deny sin to haue his originall from the free action of our will, affirming, that from this would follow, that God himselfe the author of nature is culpable. And so proceedeth, vtterly denying, that he had any purpose in those bookes, to speake of that will, which is made free by Gods grace. And whatsoeuer in these books passed his pen, which seemed to fauour the Pellegians, then Patrons of freewill, as you are now, all that he carefully collecteth out of the whole worke, and cleareth it from their cauils. Haue we any cause to be offended with Augustine, which in this question is ⟨p. 137⟩not against vs? And that you may plainly perceiue, how indiscreetly you alledged these bookes of freewill, marke what hee writeth of the will of man in those same bookes:n Hold thou fast (saith Augustine) this principall of piety, 3that no good thing happens vnto thee, either when thou thinkest or vnderstandest, or any way imaginest, which is not from God. And this was Augustines constant opinion of freewill: after that being stirred by the Pellagians, he throughly vnderstood the question, viz. that he iudged it, to be vtterly lost and gone.o Man (saith he) by abusing his freewill lost both it and himselfe.5
1Retract. lib. 1.1. q.
nDVR. Whereto tendeth this but to bewray your ignorance? all Catholics believe that the will of man, though free, is able to do nothing to merit heaven by, but by the grace of God. And you are ignorant that the freedom of will consisteth in this, that by no necessity it is carried to either part. WHIT. pag. 382. Pelagians in former time believed as much. But as Pelagius affirmed that the will was only helped with grace, and not made good by grace: so you teach that no new will is infused, but the natural is helped, and as it were unloosed by grace; which is not much from Pelagianism: for both of you defend that the liberty of will remaineth in mans corrupt nature, that it need not be given him from above, but only by the help of grace, to be drawn out of certain difficulties, in which the corruption of sin had left it. And as for my ignorance I confess it, and think it more learned then your knowledge; for if those who do things necessarily, do them not freely, then neither God nor the devil worketh not freely; for God worketh well, and the devil evil, necessarily. So you see necessity is not opposed to freewill: for not necessity, but force and compulsion taketh away the freedom of the will.DVR. Wherto tendeth this but to bewray your ignorāce? all Catholikes beleeue that the will of man, though free, is able to do nothing to merit heauen by, but by the grace of God. And you are ignorant that the freedome of will consisteth in this, that by no necessitie it is carried to either part. WHIT. pag. 382. Pelagians in former time beleeued as much. But as Pelagius affirmed that the will was only helped with grace, and not made good by grace: so you teach that no new will is infused, but the natural is helped, and as it were vnloosed by grace; which is not much from Pelagianisme: for both of you defend that the liberty of wil remaineth in mans corrupt nature, that it need not be giuen him from aboue, but only by the helpe of grace, to be drawne out of certeine difficulties, in which the corruption of sinne had left it. And as for my ignorance I confesse it, and thinke it more learned then your knowledge; for if those who do things necessarily, do them not freely, then neither God nor the diuel worketh not freely; for God worketh well, and the diuell euill, necessarily. So you see necessity is not opposed to freewill: for not necessity, but force and compulsion taketh away the freedome of the will.
3Delibere Arbit. 61.2. cap. 20.
oDVR. The meaning of the place is this, that man so lost his freewill, that be lost himself; yet so as no man in his right wits will deny, but he is a man still. WHIT. pag. 384. You grant as much as we desire: for as man lost himself, and yet remained a man, but not such as he was, good, just, holy, endued with perfection, but clean changed: so the free will of man was lost, not that no will remained, but that it was changed from good to evil; for we say not there is remaining no freewill at all; but no good will: as we affirm not, there is no man at all remaining, but no good man.
But yet further you urge Augustine against us, for (say you) they that make their captious devises, the rule of their faith, must not they be offended with Augustine, which hath an excellent Epistle against Manicheus? An Epistle (Campian) do you call it? it was ever accounted a book: but what is there in that Epistle (as you call it) against us? in which he professeth himself to agree with Antiquity, unity, perpetual succession, and with that Church, which alone amongst so ⟨p. 138⟩many heresies, hath attained unto the name Catholic by prescription. We also agree with that Church, which hath all these. And yet to these must be added (as Augustine saith in the same place) sincere wisdom and truth; else all the other bind us not; for they are of no value without that wisdom; but this wisdom and truth, though without these, is of it self to be preferred before all things: so saith Augustine, 1if the truth appear manifestly, so as it cannot be doubted of, it alone is more to be esteemed then pall those reasons, that keep me in the Catholic Church. Thus then Augustine setteth more by the truth it self alone, and sincere wisdom, then all those things you mention, Antiquity Unity, Succession, and we perceiving this truth and wisdom so manifestly in our Churches, that none, that will see the truth, can doubt whether we hold the truth or no; do willingly give you free liberty to brag, whilst you list, of antiquity, unity, & succession, without the truth. There is then, as you see, no cause, why we should be angry with Augustine, either now or before.
But yet further you vrge Augustine against vs, for (say you) they that make their captious deuises, the rule of their faith, must not they bee offended with Augustine, which hath an excellent Epistle against Manicheus? An Epistle (Campian) do you call it? it was euer accounted a booke: but what is there in that Epistle (as you call it) against vs? in which he professeth himselfe to agree with Antiquity, vnity, perpetuall succession, and with that Church, which alone amongst so ⟨p. 138⟩many heresies, hath attained vnto the name Catholike by prescription. We also agree with that Church, which hath all these. And yet to these must be added (as Augustine saith in the same place) sincere wisdome and truth; else all the other bind vs not; for they are of no value without that wisdome; but this wisdome and truth, though without these, is of it selfe to bee preserred before all things: so saith Augustine, 1if the truth appeare manifestly, so as it cannot be doubted of, it alone is more to be esteemed then pall those reasons, that keepe me in the Catholike Church. Thus then Augustine setteth more by the truth it selfe alone, and sincere wisdome, then all those things you mention, Antiquity Vnity, Succession, and we perceiuing this truth and wisdome so manifestly in our Churches, that none, that will see the truth, can doubt whether we hold the truth or no; do willingly giue you free liberty to bragge, whilest you list, of antiquity, vnity, & succession, without the truth. There is then, as you see, no cause, why we should be angry with Augustine, either now or before.
1Cont. Fundam. cap. 4.
pDVR Augustine affirmeth, that these cannot be without the truth. WHIT. pag. 387. Nay Augustine showeth the contrary: for if truth cannot be separated from these, he had spoken very unfitly, when he said, he preferred the truth before all these. If you can take or rightly challenge the possession of truth, in the next place you may inquire of Antiquity, Unity, & Succession.DVR Augustine affirmeth, that these cannot be without the truth. WHIT. pag. 387. Nay Augustine sheweth the contrarie: for if truth cannot be separated from these, he had spoken very vnfitly, when he said, he preferred the truth before all these. If you can take or rightly challenge the possessiō of truth, in the next place you may inquire of Antiquity, Vnity, & Succession.
But at length you leave Augustine, and call out Optatus, Bishop of Miletum; of whom you say, you desire to know, what our opinion is. I verily think he was a good Father, and very like unto Augustine, and I take the things to be true, which many worthy men have said in his commendation. But he disproved the Donatists by the communion of the Catholic Church. Why should he not? or what doth that concern us? Augustine also observed the same course, and it was a good motive, that the communion of the Church should be objected to the schismatical Donatists, which seditiously without cause, separated themselves from the Church. But we deny your Church to be Catholic, and therefore you cannot thus convince us, though Optatus might thereby confute the Donatists. It must first appear, that it is the ⟨p. 139⟩Church, before we can be convicted of schism. Theq Church of Rome was then the preserver of Religion, the maintainer of the true faith, and shined like a star in the sight of all other Churches: no marvel then though the most holy Fathers, esteemed much the reverence of this Church, & urged the heretics with the example of it,2 as a great prejudice unto them. Hence it is, that sometimes they allege the decrees and succession of the Bishops of Rome, thereby proving that the heresies, by them refuted, were not heard of, in the most famous and honourable Church. But since that time the course of the Church is turned, and the Sea of Rome hath declined and degenerated from her sincere faith, to detestable falsehood. Restore us (Campian) the old Church of Rome, and we will never separate our selves from her: but of that Church you have nothing left, but the walls and old rubbish, yet still you brag of the name of the Catholic Church. And whereas you mention Altars, on which the members of Christ are carried, and Chalices containing his blood, I know well many things concerning Altars, are to be found in the ancient Fathers, which Altars in Africa, were not of stone, butr wooden, as you may see in Augustine's ⟨p. 140⟩Epistle to Boniface: and I grant the members of Christ, and hiss blood are received in the holy mysteries, but after a heavenly and spiritual manner,5 appropriate unto our most holy faith. As for your devouring of flesh, Optatus was not acquainted with it, and the ancient Church of Christ, not so much as ever dreamed of so great a monster.
But at length you leaue Augustine, and call out Optatus, Bishop of Miletum; of whom you say, you desire to know, what our opinion is. I verily thinke he was a good Father, and very like vnto Augustine, and I take the things to be true, which many worthy men haue said in his commendation. But he disproued the Donatists by the communion of the Catholike Church. Why should he not? or what doth that cōcerne vs? Augustine also obserued the same course, and it was a good motiue, that the communion of the Church should be obiected to the schismaticall Donatists, which seditiously without cause, separated themselues from the Church. But wee deny your Church to be Catholike, and therefore you cannot thus conuince vs, though Optatus might therby confute the Donatists. It must first appeare, that it is the ⟨p. 139⟩Church, before we can be conuicted of schisme. Theq Church of Rome was then the preseruer of Religion, the maintainer of the true faith, and shined like a starre in the sight of all other Churches: no maruell then though the most holy Fathers, esteemed much the reuerence of this Church, & vrged the heretikes with the example of it,2 as a great preiudice vnto them. Hence it is, that sometimes they alledge the decrees and succession of the Bishops of Rome, therby prouing that the heresies, by them refuted, were not heard of, in the most famous and honorable Church. But since that time the course of the Church is turned, and the Sea of Rome hath declined and degenerated from her sincere faith, to detestable falshood. Restore vs (Campian) the old Church of Rome, and we will neuer separate our selues from her: but of that Church you haue nothing left, but the walles and old rubbish, yet still you bragge of the name of the Catholike Church. And whereas you mention Altars, on which the members of Christ are carried, and Chalices containing his blood, I know well many things concerning Altars, are to be found in the auncient Fathers, which Altars in Africa, were not of stone, butr woodden, as you may see in Augustines ⟨p. 140⟩Epistle to Boniface: and I graunt the members of Christ, and hiss blood are receiued in the holy mysteries, but after a heauenly and spiritual manner,5
qDVR. So indeed Calvin answereth, but it will not serve your turn: for Opratus proveth himself to be in the Catholic Church, because he joined himself to Saint Peters chair. WHIT pag. 388. And what call you Peters chair? the external seat, or the succession of Bishops? you shall never prove it, and the contrary I cen easily object out of Optatus himself. Optatus calleth Syritius Bishop of Rome his fellow, and the companion of other Bishops who held a sound and Catholic judgement. With all those Syricius agreed in one society and fellowship, by their letters sent one to another as witnesses of their consenting in doctrine and lawful ordination: Optatus then proveth that he was a Catholic, because he kept the Catholic confession and conjunction with Syrrcius and other Bishops. Finally his argument was good against the Donatists, who did separate themselves from the communion of the Catholic Church, while they consented not with these Churches, where the doctrine of the Apostles and a lawful ordination of Bishops did ever flourish. But it is nothing to us and you.DVR. So indeed Caluin answereth, but it will not serue your turne: for Opratus proueth himself to be in the Catholike Church, because he ioyned himselfe to Saint Peters chaire. WHIT pag. 388. And what call you Peters chaire? the externall seate, or the succession of Bishops? you shall neuer proue it, and the contrary I cen easily obiect out of Optatus himselfe. Optatus calleth Syritius Bishop of Rome his fellow, and the companion of other Bishops who held a sound and Catholike iudgement. With all those Syricius agreed in one society and fellowship, by their letters sent one to another as witnesses of their consenting in doctrine and lawfull ordination: Optatus then proueth that he was a Catholike, because he kept the Catholike confession and coniunction with Syrrcius and other Bishops. Finally his argument was good against the Donatists, who did separate themselues from the communion of the Catholike Church, while they consented not with these Churches, where the doctrine of the Apostles and a lawfull ordination of Bishops did euer flourish. But it is nothing to vs and you.
2Irenaeus. August.
rDVR. What difference is there? the Donatists overthrew wooden Altany, and you Altars of stone. WHIT pag. 389. They troubled sacred tables by their sacrilege: not reproving the administration of the Sacrament, but the ordination of Bishops, which yet was lawful: we have cast down Altars wickedly erected for the wicked Mass and profane Idolatry. Is there no difference, think you?DVR. VVhat difference is there? the Donatists ouerthrew vvoodden Altany, and you Altars of stone. WHIT pag. 389. They troubled sacred tables by their sacriledge: not reprouing the administration of the Sacrament, but the ordination of Bishops, which yet was lawfull: we haue cast downe Altars wickedly erected for the wicked Masse and prophane Idolatry. Is there no difference, thinke you?
DVR. The filth Canon of the Councell of Constantinople, ascribed greater honor to the Romane Sea, then to any other. WHIT. pag. 311. This honor was only of precedence and place, and not of authority; as plainly appeareth in the words of the Councell it self•. Chap. •8. and in that the like prerogatiue was graunted in the next place to the Bishop of Constantinople, and therefore by the like reason he might •rrog••• authority ouer the whole Church.
3Canon. 5.
4Ephes. Conc. in Epist. ad Nestor.
hDVR. In the Councell of Ephesus divers things are contained, which approve the supremacy of the Sea of Rome, &c. WHIT. pag. 313. Campian cited the Epistle of the Councell to Nestorius, wherein there is nothing which any way favoureth the Popes supremacy; the which you perceiving, do rake together other fragments concerning things which are not in controversy, and leave out those points which make against you.DVR. In the Councell of Ephesus diuers things are conteined, vvhich approue the supremacy of the Sea of Rome, &c. WHIT. pag. 313. Campian cited the Epistle of the Councell to Nestorius, wherein there is nothing which any way fauoureth the Popes supremacy; the which you perceiuing, do rake together other fragments concerning things which are not in controuersie, and leaue out those points which make against you.
lDVR. Eusebius doth not call it a sacrifice, because it is a sole & bare memorial of the new Testament, as you suppose: but because we offer an unbloody socrifice, for a memorial of a bloody sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 323. Neither do I affirm it, for this is not a bare memorial, seeing the thing it self, thereby signified, is therein contained in the right use of it. But withal I deny that this memorial is the same sacrifice which Christ offered, as you would have it; for how can a sacrifice be ye self same with it of which it is a memorial? If therefore this be an unbloody sacrifice, thē it is not the Sacrifice which Christ offered, which was bloody, & the memorial of no other sacrifice. See Eus. de Demon. l. 1.DVR. Eusebius doth not call it a sacrifice, because it is a sole & bare memoriall of the new Testament, as you suppose: but because vvee offer an vnbloody socrifice, for a memoriall of a bloody sacrifice. WHIT. pag. 323. Neither doe I affirme it, for this is not a bare memoriall, seeing the thing it selfe, thereby signified, is therin cōteined in the right vse of it. But withall I deny that this memoriall is the same sacrifice which Christ offered, as you would haue it; for how can a sacrifice be ye self same with it of which it is a memorial? If therfore this be an vnbloody sacrifice, thē it is not the Sacrifice which Christ offered, which was bloody, & the memorial of no other sacrifice. See Eus. de Demon. l. 1.
In a dishonest vowe change thy purpose. Doe not performe that which thou hast vowed vnaduisedly; for that promise is impious which is wickedly performed.
oDVR. S. Paul desireth the Romans and Corinthians to pray for him, and therefore we may desire the same of the Saints in heaven. We know that we obtain all in the name of Christ, but seeing all are not in like grace with God, the Fathers and we have made choice of those who are most gracious. WHIT. pag. 336. The first part of your answer confuteth the latter, unless you will say that Paul was less gracious with God, then the Romans and Corinthians; and both are weak & of no value: for first Paul prayeth not to them as you do to Saints, but only desireth them to perform a mutual Christian duty, which the Saints living, who are acquainted with one anothers estate and wants, ought not to neglect: if he had made the likesuite to a Prophet departed, John Baptist, or James slain by Herod, you had somewhat to say. Lastly if those are to be made choice of for mediators, who are in greatest grace with God, to whom should we go but unto Christ his dearly beloved Sonne, in whom God is well pleased and we reconciled? Eph. 16. Matth. 3.17. Joh. 14.6. 1. Tim. 2.5.DVR. S. Paul desireth the Romans and Corinthians to pray for him, and therfore vve may desire the same of the Saints in heauen. We knovv that vve obtaine all in the name of Christ, but seeing all are not in like grace vvith God, the Fathers and vve haue made choise of those vvho are most gratious. WHIT. pag. 336. The first part of your answere confuteth the latter, vnles you will say that Paul was lesse gratious with God, then the Romans and Corinthians; and both are weake & of no value: for first Paul praieth not to them as you do to Saints, but only desireth them to performe a mutual Christian duty, which the Saints liuing, who are acquainted with one anothers estate and wants, ought not to neglect: if he had made the likesuite to a Prophet departed, Iohn Baptist, or Iames slaine by Herode, you had somewhat to say. Lastly if those are to be made choise of for mediators, who are in greatest grace with God, to whom should we goe but vnto Christ his dearely beloued Sonne, in whom God is well pleased and we reconciled? Eph. 16. Matth. 3.17. Ioh. 14.6. 1. Tim. 2.5.
pDVR. There is nothing determined in the Scriptures concerning the age of widows. That which S. Paul writeth, was profitable for the insancie of the Church; but when the Gospel had taken deeper •oot in mens harts, they began to prefer contivency before marriage. WHIT. pag. 337. Your impudency is to be admired, seeing S. Paul hath plainly determined that they should be fixtie years of age at the least, 1. Tim. 5.9. neither were such Apostolical constitutions to endure only for a time, but until the coming of Christ, as appeareth. 1. Tim. 6.14. And whereas you say the Gospel after the Apostles times, took deeper root in mens minds, it is merely false; it was indeed further propagated, but the Church was never in after ages endued with the like measure of grace, and extraordinary gifts, as it was in the Apostles times, when they received the first fruits of the spirit. And I would pray the Reader to consider that Duraeus doth confess, that in the first age of the Church single life was not so much desired of most, and in later times they only beg•n to prefer continency before matriage. But how much better it had been to have kept the Apostolic institutions, and to have changed compelled continency for lawful and holy marriage, the lamentable event hath sufficiently proved.DVR. There is nothing determined in the Scriptures concerning the age of vviddovves. That vvhich S. Paul vvriteth, vvas profitable for the insancie of the Church; but vvhen the Gospell had taken deeper •oot in mens harts, they began to preferre cōtiuency before marriage. WHIT. pag. 337. Your impudency is to be admired, seeing S. Paul hath plainly determined that they should bee fixtie yeares of age at the least, 1. Tim. 5.9. neither were such Apostolicall constitutions to indure only for a time, but vntill the comming of Christ, as appeareth. 1. Tim. 6.14. And whereas you say the Gospell after the Apostles times, tooke deeper roote in mens minds, it is meerely false; it was indeed further propagated, but the Church was neuer in after ages indued with the like measure of grace, and extraordinarie giftes, as it was in the Apostles times, when they receiued the first fruits of the spirit. And I would pray the Reader to consider that Duraeus doth confesse, that in the first age of the Church single life was not so much desired of most, and in later times they onely beg•n to preferre continency before matriage. But how much better it had been to haue kept the Apostolike institutions, and to haue chaunged compelled continency for lawfull and holy marriage, the lamentable euent hath sufficiently proued.
qDVR. You say, to vow that which we cannot perform, is to mock God; but this we may perform, seeing God bestoweth the virtue of continency upon those, who seek it by fasting and prayer: and seeing the vestal Nuns and Egyptian Priests attained unto it, and wines also, when their husbands are long absent upon necessary occasion. WHIT. pag. 340. God granteth not all things we pray for, but those things which he hath promised, as appeareth in the example of S. Paul 2. Cor. 12.8. But we have no promise of the gift of continency; yea contrariwise Christ hath taught us, that all are not capable of it, but those only to whom it is given Matth. 19.11. & the Apostle saith that it is a gift proper to some only. 1. Cor. 7.7. and therefore we have no ground absolutely to pray for it with assurance of being heard. The vestal Nuns & Egyptian Priests are fit examples for your imitation, who lived single, but not chaste: and yet the Vestals might marry when they were past thirty years old; and some Egyptian Priests, as appeareth, Gen. 41.45. Concerning the chastity of wives in their husbands necessary absence, the reason is not alike; for it is one thing to impose upon our selves a voluntary necessity, and another to undergo it when it is imposed by God. God will keep us in our ways, Psal. 90.14. but not when we rashly thrust our selves into needless difficulties.DVR. You say, to vovv that vvhich vve cannot performe, is to mocke God; but this vve may performe, seeing God bestovveth the vertue of continencie vpon those, vvho seeke it by fasting and prayer: and seeing the vestall Nuns and Aegyptian Priests atteined vnto it, and vvines also, vvhen their husbands are longe absent vpon necessary occasion. WHIT. pag. 340. God granteth not all things wee pray for, but those things which hee hath promised, as appeareth in the example of S. Paul 2. Cor. 12.8. But we haue no promise of the gift of continency; yea cōtrariwise Christ hath taught vs, that all are not capable of it, but those only to whō it is giuen Matth. 19.11. & the Apostle saith that it is a gift proper to some onely. 1. Cor. 7.7. and therefore wee haue no ground absolutely to pray for it with assurance of being heard. The vestall Nuns & Aegyptian Priests are fit examples for your imitation, who liued single, but not chast: and yet the Vestals might marrie when they were past thirtie yeares old; and some Aegyptian Priests, as appeareth, Gen. 41.45. Concerning the chastitie of wiues in their husbands necessary absence, the reason is not alike; for it is one thing to impose vpon our selues a voluntary necessitie, and another to vndergoe it when it is imposed by God. God will keepe vs in our waies, Psal. 90.14. but not when wee rashly thrust our selues into needlesse difficulties.
8Bernard. ad Soror. de modo bene vivendi Serm. 62.Bernard. ad Soror. de modo bene viuendi Serm. 62.
rDVR. Bernard writeth not against the vow of virginity, but only willeth us to break a dishonest vow, neither is this book, you know, thought to be his. WHIT. pag. 342. It is not much material who was the author, but his judgement is to be embraced: seeing then that is a dishonest vow, the performance whereof is joined with dishonesty, it followeth that the vow of single life is such, when as it causeth men to burn in the flame of lust, and therefore is rather to be broken then observed.DVR. Bernard vvriteth not against the vovv of virginity, but only vvilleth vs to breake a dishonest vovv, neither is this booke, you knovv, thought to be his. WHIT. pag. 342. It is not much materiall who was the author, but his iudgement is to be embraced: seeing then that is a dishonest vow, the performance whereof is ioyned vvith dishonestie, it follovveth that the vovv of single life is such, vvhen as it causeth men to burne in the flame of lust, and therefore is rather to be broken then obserued.
Gregory, whom Campian citeth, marched in equall authoritie with the foure Gospels: from whence it necessarily followeth, that all Councels of other times are of the same authoritie and credit with the foure Euangelists.
Ignatius, so was Caluin also. Insomuch that these bench whistlers pried out certaine foule blemeshes and vnsauorie speeches in his Epistles. In these mens conceits also S. Ireneus writ one foolish toy; and S.
Canons which at that time was vsed, doth highly displease this plausible sect, which are fitter for Chambers then for Churches, and is accustomed to tickle sensuall eares, and to so •cushions to euery elbow: wherein, I say, wherein hath the next age offended? forsooth S. Chrysostome and other Fathers of that time haue fouly darkened iustification by faith only S. Gregory Nazianzen, whom auncient writers for honor sake, haue Sirnamed Theologus. 1. the Diuine, by Caussaeus iudgement, was but a
Bishop of Miletan confuteth such as tooke part with Donatus, by the Catholike cōmunity. Their wickednes he accuseth by the decree of the Pope Melchiades;
schoole of the holy Ghost, because hee called holi• Images the books of vnlearned people. A whole day would not be enough for me to reckon all the Epistles, Sermons, Homilies, Orations, Treatises, and disputations of the old Fathers, wherein of set purpose both grauely and eloquently, they haue confirmed our Catholike doctrine. So long as these bookes of these Fathers shall be sold at the Stationers shop, in vaine are the hauens and sea coasts watched so narrowly; to no purpose, are houses, coffers, and chests straightly searched; to no end, are penall proclamations set vpon so many gates.
could be of that side, whereunto he laboured to allure his audience.
. once to haue made m•otion of him in all his writings: neither euer doth Nazianzene.
⟨p. 128⟩
certaine man, I know not who, of late daies published, gesseth, that the Diuell is Antichrist, and faineth many other things:
•••
6Hippolyt.
eDVR. Why do you reject this book of Hippolyte as counterfeit? Hierome affirmeth, that he was a Bishop, and hath written many Commentaries upon the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 367. Will it therefore follow that this book is not counterfeit? nay it is the rather forged, because Hierom doth not number it amongst his books. Hippolytus was a very worthy man, of whom Eusebius. Hierom, Theodoret, Nicephorus have made very honourable mention. But this book is childish in the beginning, and in the whole altogether unanswerable to his eloquence and judgement.DVR. VVhy do you reiect this booke of Hippolyte as counterfeite? Hierome affirmeth, that he was a Bishop, and hath written many Commentaries vpon the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 367. Will it therefore follow that this booke is not counterfeit? nay it is the rather forged, because Hierom doth not number it amongst his bookes. Hyppolitus was a very worthy man, of whom Eusebius. Hierom, Theodoret, Nicephorus haue made verie honorable mention. But this booke is childish in the beginning, and in the whole altogether vnanswerable to his eloquence and iudgement.
DVR. VVhen you are ouercome by the truth, you slander our liues, and speake euill of our persons. WHIT. pag. 377. I do not slander you, nor detract from you, the world hath vnderstood long agoe what manner of men you vvere. If you be grovvne better I should be glad of it. But I knovv men haue iudged othervvise of this order, and such as did not hate your Monasticall life. For the Romish Cardinals and Priors did vvrite thus to the Pope himself. There is another abuse amongst the orders of religious men, for many are so deformed and out of order, that they are a great scandale to the people, and hurt much by their example. VVe thinke that all orders ought to be abolished.
DVR. The meaning of the place is this, that man so lost his freewill, that be lost himselfe; yet so as no man in his right wits will deny, but he is a man still. WHIT. pag. 384. You graunt as much as we desire: for as man lost himselfe, and yet remained a man, but not such as he was, good, iust, holy, indued with perfection, but cleane changed: so the free will of man was lost, not that no wil remained, but that it was changed from good to euill; for we say not there is remaining no freewill at all; but no good wil: as we affirme not, there is no man at all remaining, but no good man.
5Enchir. 3.
appropriate vnto our most holy faith. As for your deuouring of flesh, Optatus was not acquainted with it, and the auncient Church of Christ, not so much as euer dreamed of so great a monster.
sDVR. Optatus writeth that the body of Christ dwelleth upon the Altar. WHIT. pag. 390. I answer that the sacrament of the body of Christ is after a sort Christs body, and the name of the thing is given to the sign,, as is usual in all Sacraments. For the body of Christ is no where properly but in heaven at the right hand of his Father, where it shall remain to the end of the world.DVR. Optatus writeth that the body of Christ dwelleth vpon the Altar. WHIT. pag. 390. I answere that the sacrament of the body of Christ is after a sort Christs body, and the name of the thing is giuen to the signe,, as is vsuall in all Sacraments. For the body of Christ is no where properly but in heauen at the right hand of his Father, where it shall remaine to the end of the world.