REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDERED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Universities.REASONS OF CAMPIANS CHALLENGE RENDRED AND GIVEN TO THE Students of the English Vniuersities.
pp. 17–326288 passagespart 4 of 8
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
They sing (say you) in their Churches, the Creed of Athanasius, but they favour him not; and why? because he praiseth Antony the Hermit. You speak wisely; ast though we were so envious, that we could not with patience endure any man to be praised: nay there is somewhat else.2 He with his Synod of Alexandria, humbly appealed unto the sentence of the Apostolic Sea: this Epistle is all counterfeit, compacted of many lies, and monstrous flattery. Prudentius I grant as au Poet, sometimes called upon the Martyrs, whose acts he describes in verse, and the superstitious ⟨p. 141⟩custom of praying to Saints had now taken deep root in the Church: which as a Tyrant haled sometimes the holy Fathers into the same error. As for Vigillantius and Jovinian, against whom Hirr•••• writeth most bitterly; if they taught those things that are laid to their charge, we maintain them not. That* Ambrose should be careful, to commend and set forth the praises of his friends Geruasius and Protasius, we willingly permit. Neither do we wholly mislike Gregory, with whom surely you have more cause to be offended, then we. But whereas he said that Images were lay-mens books, he neither learned inx the school of the holy Ghost, nor foundy it in the ⟨p. 142⟩books of the Fathers that were before him; and thus at length, have you finished this long catalogue of the Fathers. The reason I would fain know, that moved you to go thorough them on this manner. For what? are you so blockish your self to think, or hope you, that any others will like of this kind of reasoning: viz. Luther, Calvin and their confederates, do write that Irenaus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Chrysostom, Augustine, Hierome, Ambrose, Gregory, Basil, and Nazi zen, do otherwhiles err in some questions in this or that book, and they saw not the true meaning of some Scripture, but were sometimes deceived, that is, they were men: therefore they banish, reject and condemn all these Fathers? Is this your meaning, Campian? why then do you your selves, being very often by plain authorities of the Fathers convinced, deny flatly that you are tied to the authority of any father, and from them you appeal to the judgment of the Church? Would you not think your self hardly dealt withal, if hence I should infer, that you disallow the Fathers whole volumes?
They sing (say you) in their Churches, the Creed of Athanasius, but they fauour him not; and why? because he praiseth Antony the Hermit. You speake wisely; ast though we were so enuious, that we could not with patience endure any man to be praised: nay there is somewhat else.2 He with his Synode of Alexandria, humblie appealed vnto the sentence of the Apostolike Sea: this Epistle is all counterfeit, compacted of many lies, and monstrous flattery. Prudentius I grant as au Poet, sometimes called vpon the Martyrs, whose acts he describes in verse, and the superstitious ⟨p. 141⟩custome of praying to Saints had now taken deepe roote in the Church: which as a Tyrant haled sometimes the holy Fathers into the same error. As for Vigillantius and Iouinian, against whom Hirr•••• writeth most bitterly; if they taught those things that are laid to their charge, we maintaine them not. That* Ambrose should be carefull, to commend and set sorth the praises of his friends Geruasius and Protasius, we willingly permit. Neither doe we wholy mislike Gregory, with whom surely you haue more cause to be offended, then we. But wheras he said that Images were lay-mens bookes, hee neither learned inx the schoole of the holy Ghost, nor foundy it in the ⟨p. 142⟩books of the Fathers yt were before him; and thus at length, haue you finished this longe catalogue of the Fathers. The reason I would faine know, that moued you to go thorough them on this manner. For what? are you so blockish your selfe to thinke, or hope you, that any others will like of this kind of reasoning: viz. Luther, Caluin and their confederates, doe write that Irenaus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Chrysostome, Augustine, Hierome, Ambrose, Gregory, Basil, and Nazi•• zen, do otherwiles erre in some questions in this or that booke, and they saw not the true meaning of some Scripture, but were sometimes deceiued, that is, they were men: therefore they banish, reiect and condemne all these Fathers? Is this your meaning, Campian? why then do you your selues, being verie often by plaine authorities of the Fathers cōuinced, deny flatly that you are tyed to the authority of any father, and from them you appeale to the iudgment of the Church? Would you not thinke your self hardly dealt withal, if hence I should inferre, that you disallow the Fathers whole volumes?
tDVR. But do you think Hermits are worthy of any praise, whom Athanasius praised in the person of Antony? WHIT. pag. 391. Grant we well approve of the old Hermits, yet may we think bad enough of your Monks, as we have done and profess it for just causes, seeing they differ both so much in manners and judgements. Antonius the Hermits grandfather was wont to say, that it was as dangerous for a Monk to go out of his hermitage, as for fishes to leave the water. If you praise Antony so much, why do you not follow him? why do you swarm in all cities and famous places, and do not rather live in some remote wilderness, as fishes swim in the Sea? so should you be more like to Antony, and free these parts from great damage.DVR. But doe you thinke Hermits are worthy of any praise, whom Athanasius praised in the person of Antony? WHIT. pag. 391. Graunt vve vvell approue of the old Hermits, yet may we thinke bad enough of your Monkes, as vve haue done and professe it for iust causes, seeing they differ both so much in manners and iudgements. Antonius the Hermits grandfather vvas vvont to say, that it was as dangerous for a Monke to go out of his hermitage, as for fishes to leaue the water. If you praise Antony so much, vvhy do you not follovv him? vvhy do you svvarme in all cities and famous places, and doe not rather liue in some remote wildernesse, as fishes swim in the Sea? so should you be more like to Antony, and free these parts from great damage.
2Athan. Ep. ad Fel. 2.
uDVR. Because he was a Poet, forgot he to be a Christian? or did he any thing in verse, which infinite & learned •athers have not done before in prose? WHIT. pag. 392. Who knoweth not that Poets were wont to weigh what the verse required, more then what piety called for, and to follow the elegance of poetry more then the streight doctrine of the Scriptures? And such liberty of Poets men commonly find no great fault with: yet see how foolish it is to avow poetical exornations for reasons in the controversies of religion. And if Prudentius followed so many Fathers, why name you not one of them▪ For 300. years after Christ there was no such custom in the Church, which you affirm so infinite a number of Fathers used: and it rose up in the Church but a little before Prudentius days; but both this and all other superstitions must be corrected by the authority of the word.DVR. Because he was a Poet, forgate hee to be a Christian? or did he any thing in verse, which infinit & learned •athers haue not done before in prose? WHIT. pag. 392. Who knovveth not that Poets vvere vvont to vveigh vvhat the verse required, more then vvhat piety called for, and to follovv the elegancy of poetry more then the streight doctrine of the Scriptures? And such liberty of Poets men commonly find no great fault vvith: yet see hovv foolish it is to auovv poeticall exornations for reasons in the controuersies of religion. And if Prudentius follovved so many Fathers, vvhy name you not one of them▪ For 300. yeares after Christ there vvas no such custome in the Church, vvhich you affirme so infinite a number of Fathers vsed: and it rose vp in the Church but a little before Prudentius daies; but both this and all other superstitions must be corrected by the authority of the vvord.
*DVR. It seemeth you have nothing to answer to Ambrose at all. WHIT. pag. 393. Have I answered nothing, when a few lines before I affirmed that this superstition had got great footing in the Church? was it not answer enough to show I allowed not the corrupt judgement of some Fathers? What gain you by this, if we profess freely that some Fathers were infected with the errors of the time, who yet kept sound doctrine in the fundamental points; whereas notorious corruption hath spread it self over your whole Church & consumed it, & the beginnings of corruptions in them, is grown to an height in you without hope of cure?DVR. It seemeth you haue nothing to answere to Ambrose at all. WHIT. pag. 393. Haue I answered nothing, when a few lines before I affirmed that this superstition had got great footing in the Church? was it not answere enough to shew I allowed not the corrupt iudgement of some Fathers? What gaine you by this, if we professe freely that some Fathers were infected with the errors of the time, who yet kept sound doctrine in the fundamentall points; whereas notorious corruption hath spread it selfe ouer your whole Church & cōsumed it, & the beginnings of corruptions in them, is growne to an height in you without hope of cure?
xDVR. Answer me, in what school did you learn to break down Images? not in the schools of Christians, but of Jews. WHIT. pag. 395. I learned it out of the school of the holy Ghost, Deut 5.8. Josh. 24.23. where we are taught to worship one God with religious worship, and to cast out of the Church, to break and burn the Images of men, though never so holy. Moses beat the Calf to powder, & the holy Ghost commended Hez•••a for breaking asunder the brazen Serpent, though it was set up by God• authority, when the Israelites abused it to super•••ion; how much more ought we to destroy profane Images & monuments of cursed idolatry? Epiphanius being taught in this school rent the veil which was hung up in the temple, having painted innt the picture of Christ or some Saint. As also Serenus Bishop of Massilia, who took down & broke the Images of his time. I have learned this then not out of the schools of the Jews, •innike• and Idolaters, but out of the schools of Christians, which may not be polluted with Images.DVR. Answere me, in vvhat schoole did you learne to breake downe Images? not in the schooles of Christians, but of Iewes. WHIT. pag. 395. I learned it out of the schoole of the holy Ghost, Deut 5.8. Iosh. 24.23. where wee are taught to worship one God with religious worship, and to cast out of the Church, to breake and burne the Images of men, though neuer so holy. Moses beate the Calfe to powder, & the holy Ghost commended Hez•••a for breaking asunder the brazen Serpent, though it was set vp by God• authority, when the Israelits abused it to super•••ion; how much more ought we to destroy prophane Images & monuments of cursed idolatrie? Epiphanius being taught in this schoole rent the vaile which was hung vp in the temple, hauing painted innt the picture of Christ or some Saint. As also Serenus Bishop of Massilia, who tooke downe & broke the Images of his time. I haue learned this then not out of the schooles of the Iewes, •innike• and Idolaters, but out of the schooles of Christians, which may not be polluted with Images.
yDVR You show your ignorance or impudency, when you know not, or deny that which is every whereto be read among the Fathers, as in Theodoret, Domasen, Augustine, Gregory Nissen. Metaphrastes, Athanasius and others. WHIT. pag. 399. These testimonies do rather show your rashness & desire to deceive; for they are partly faired, as that of Gregory Nissen and Athanasius, & partly not to the purpose by them I understand that Images were made, but they prove not that they were placed in the churches & worshipped. Your reason concludeth not, There were Images among the Christians before the times of Gregory: therefore they placed them in their churches to teach the people, and to be worshipped of them with holy worship.DVR You shevv your ignorance or impudency, vvhen you knovv not, or deny that vvhich is euery vvhereto be read among the Fathers, as in Theodoret, Domasen, Augustine, Gregory Nissen. Metaphrastes, Athanasius and others. WHIT. pag. 399. These testimonies do rather shew your rashnes & desire to deceiue; for they are partly faired, as that of Gregory Nissen and Athanasius, & partly not to the purpose by them I vnderstand that Images were made, but they proue not that they were placed in the churches & worshipped. Your reason concludeth not, There were Images among the Christiās before the times of Gregory: therfore they placed them in their churches to teach the people, and to be worshipped of them with holy worship.
But this is the issue of your disputation, and the mark whereat all this your discourse aimeth, namely, that because we dislike some things in the Fathers, which in their writings cannot be defended, therefore we violate all, we offer great wrong and reproach to the Fathers, we commit a heinous and unheard-of wickedness.
But this is the issue of your disputation, and the marke whereat all this your discourse aymeth, namely, that because we dislike some things in the Fathers, which in their writings cannot be defended, therefore we violate all, we offer great wrong and reproach to the Fathers, we commit a hainous and vnhard-of wickednes.
Think not (Campian) our University to be so childish that they cannot discern the indifferency of our proceeding herein, from your unjust calumniation. The Fathers we esteem highly, we peruse them daily, we commend them to the reading of all such as exactly and diligently study Divinity. By this means we increase our knowledge, and are better furnished with armour of defence against you. You are afraid to want time, and therefore you omit many things, Epistles, Sermons, Homilies, ⟨p. 143⟩Orations, Works, Disputations of Fathers, by which the Catholics opinions are confirmed. Some fragments perhaps, say you, thrown in corners, which without much pains and weariness you could not collect, yet your fellows of late years have diligently sought out and published: Whilst they (say you) are to be sold at the Stationers, so long our mens books are in vain prohibited: we are sorry you should write such things, as we must of necessity restrain, your books are such as it behooveth us to stop their passage, unless we would suffer the State to be stirred to sedition, the Church in danger of heresy, and mens minds filled with cursed opinions. For if Magistrates ought carefully to prevent, lest the infection of the plague, be from other places brought into their cities; much more care is to be had, that pestilent and pernicious books be nor openly spread abroad, out of which simple and unlearned men do suck poison of deadly error. Neither are we the first that have taken this course. You may remember in Queen Mary's time, that they proceeded by marshal law against all those, with whom any of our books were found. If this were in us a matter worthy of death, so that we were by and by drawn to punishment, as men guilty of high treason, and that without any jud•••al proceedings, small reason have you to look, that your books now, should have such free liberty, to be every where publicly sold. We take order, that the books of the holy Fathers, are brought unto us from every matte, we buy them, we have them in our private studies and public Library a wo• place them in open view, that they be known; nor only by face, but by daily familiarity. Where you affirm, that neither Sanders, nor Harding, nor Allen, nor Stapleton, nor Bristol, do more ••gerly inveigh against those dreams, then the Fatherd before mentioned:
Thinke not (Campian) our Vniuersitie to be so childish that they cannot discerne the indifferencie of our proceeding herein, from your vniust calumniation. The Fathers wee esteeme highly, wee peruse them daily, we commend them to the reading of all such as exactly and diligently studie Diuinitie. By this meanes we encrease our knowledge, and are better furnished with armour of defence against you. You are afraide to want time, and therefore you omit many things, Epistles, Sermons, Homilies, ⟨p. 143⟩Orations, Works, Disputations of Fathers, by which the Catholikes opinions are confirmed. Some fragments perhaps, say you, throwne in corners, which without much paines and wearines you could not collect, yet your fellowes of late yeares haue diligently sought out and published: Whilest they (say you) are to be solde at the Stationers, so long our mens bookes are in vaine prohibited: we are sorry you should write such things, as we must of necessitie restraine, your bookes are such as it behooueth vs to stoppe their passage, vnlesse we would suffer the State to be stirred to sedition, the Church in danger of heresie, and mens minds filled with cursed opinions. For if Magistrates ought carefully to preuent, lest the infection of the plague, be from other places brought into their cities; much more care is to be had, that pestilent and pernicious bookes bee nor openly spread abroad, out of which simple and vnlearned men doe sucke poyson of deadly error. Neither are we the first that haue taken this course. You may remember in Queene Maries time, that they proceeded by marshall law against all those, with whom any of our bookes were found. If this were in vs a matter worthie of death, so that we were by and by drawne to punishment, as men guiltie of high treason, and that without any iud•••al proceedings, small reason haue you to looke, that your bookes now, should haue such free libertie, to bee euery where publikelie solde. We take order, that the bookes of the holy Fathers, are brought vnto vs from euery matte, we buie them, we haue them in our priuate studies and publike Liberarie a wo• place them in open view, that they be knowns; nor onely by face, but by dailie familiaricie. Where you affirme, that neither Sanders, nor Harding, nor Allen, nor Stapleton, nor Bristol, doe more ••gerly inneigh against those dreames, then the Fatherd before mentioned:
you have ⟨p. 144⟩added this saying as an overplus to the things that went before. These your old soldiers have employed in this case, whatsoever, either reading or leisure, or cunning, or wit, or diligence, or malice, could supply unto them, and for all this have gained nothing: and hope you, that are not worthy to be compared with these, to perform that, wherein they have failed? yet you said, that thinking of these things, your courage increased, and you desired the combat. I bewail (Campian) your rashness, and foolish hardiness, which will needs take upon you, the patronage of a desperate cause, with the undoubted loss of your credit and safety; and I wish that the day may once come, wherein you may make trial of your strength in the combat which you desire.
you haue ⟨p. 144⟩added this saying as an ouerplus to the things that went before. These your old souldiers haue imployed in this case, whatsoeuer, either reading or leysure, or cunning, or wit, or diligence, or malice, could supply vnto them, and for all this haue gained nothing: and hope you, that are not worthy to be compared with these, to performe that, wherein they haue failed? yet you said, that thinking of these things, your courage increased, and you desired the combate. I bewaile (Campian) your rashnes, and foolish hardines, which will needs take vpon you, the patronage of a desperate cause, with the vndoubted losse of your credit and safety; and I wish that the day may once come, wherin you may make triall of your strength in the combate which you desire.
John Jewel (say you) challenged the Catholics, when you were a young student, calling upon and desiring the help of the Fathers, as many as flourished 600. years after Christ. That worthy man, did that he knew himself able to perform: he had read over all the Fathers with special judgement and diligence; he saw how you deceived the ignorant, he had a care to preserve his countrymen from your dangerous error. And hereupon without any boasting, as you would have it, but trusting only in the power of God, and the truth of the cause, he calleth forth all the generation of Papists unto this trial, viz. if they could confirm their opinions by the holy Scriptures, or by the witness of Fathers and Councils, they should overcome: if they failed, they should confess themselves were vanquished. Certain renowned men (say you) living as Exiles as Lo•ane, entertain th• offer, and allow of the condition. Harding was the captain of these, he adventured himself hand to hand, in this combat, but how worthily performed he the condition? Jewel calleth for Fathers; Harding produceth certain Clements, Abdies, Martials, Hippolyes, Amphilochytes, ⟨p. 145⟩and others of this rank, Fathers of worshipful antiquity: If all the ancient Fathers of the Church, be (as you brag) of your side, why should Harding turn his back so cowardly, bringing in for witnesses in a most weighty cause wherein we demanded the judgement of antiquity, a company of upstart bastards, I know not from whence, whom no man before had saluted, seen or heard of, passing by of purpose, the known and truly noble Fathers? Is this the reverend antiquity you talk of? must we have these fellows digged out of their graves, to help you in your desperate cause? hear me (Campian) that which Jewel then said most truly and confidently, challenging you to the trial of six hundred years antiquity, offering also to yield you the victory, if you brought one plain and manifest authority, out of any Father or Council; that same we do all profess and promise, and will surely perform it.
Iohn Iewel (say you) challenged the Catholikes, when you were a young student, calling vpon and desiring the helpe of the Fathers, as many as flourished 600. yeares after Christ. That worthy man, did that he knew himselfe able to performe: he had read ouer all the Fathers with speciall iudgement and diligence; hee saw how you deceiued the ignorant, he had a care to preserue his countrimen from your dangerous error. And hereupon without any boasting, as you would haue it, but trusting only in the power of God, and the truth of the cause, he calleth forth all the generation of Papists vnto this triall, viz. if they could confirme their opinions by the holy Scriptures, or by the witnes of Fathers and Councels, they should ouercome: if they failed, they should confesse themselues were vanquished. Certeine renowmed men (say you) liuing as Exiles as Lo•ane, entertaine th• offer, and allow of the condition. Harding was the captaine of these, he aduentured himselfe hand to hand, in this combate, but how worthily performed he the condition? I•wel calleth for Fathers; Harding produceth certeine Clements, Abdies, Martials, Hippolyes, Amphilochytes, ⟨p. 145⟩and others of this rancke, Fathers of worshipfull antiquitie: If all the auncient Fathers of the Church, be (as you bragge) of your side, why should Harding turne his backe so cowardly, bringing in for witnesses in a most waighty cause wherin we demaunded the iudgement of antiquitie, a company of vpstart bastards, I know not fromwhence, whom no man before had saluted, seene or heard of, passing by of purpose, the knowne and truly noble Fathers? Is this the reuerend antiquity you talke of? must wee haue these fellowes digged out of their graues, to helpe you in your desperate cause? heare me (Campian) that which Iewel then said most truly and confidently, challenging you to the triall of sixe hundred yeares antiquity, offering also to yeeld you the victory, if you brought one plaine and manifest authority, out of any Father or Councell; that same we do all professe and promise, and will surely performe it.
Twenty years are expired, and not one of you hitherto could perform the condition: if you persuade your self to have more sufficiency hereunto, then your masters before have had, why stay you? why sit you still? why discontinue you the defence of so good a cause? But alas, you are no body, you have read nothing, you have no strength answerable to such an endeavour. The learned Humphrey did not tax Jewel, as if he had too liberally undertaken for the Fathers, or performed less then he promised; but only that he had yielded further unto you, then he needed, and called back the cause which was already determined by the Scriptures, to the authorities of the Fathers; which yet he did not, as though he distrusted any thing, the trial of Scriptures; for he knew that they were sufficient to refute all popish errors: but that hereby he might beat down that their insolent and most false brag of antiquity, which prevailed with many. You say further that you ⟨p. 146⟩have conferred sometimes familiarly with To•y Matthew, and w••led him to answer freely, whether he that read the Fathers diligently, could be of that part which •e favoured. Although in private and familiar conference we say many things, which we would not have further reported, or dispersed, yet I doubt not, but the worthy Matthew gave you such an answer, as was both agreeable to the truth, and fit for his judgement and wisdom. We must not in all things believe the Fathers, nor doth our faith depend upon their word. Sometimes they have erred and been the occasion of errors unto others; yet may we read them, & by their truths be more learned, by the contrary more wary. And this also thinketh Matthew Hutton that famous man, whom you surmise to be the only man amongst us conversant in the Fathers. And this also is all our opinions. After you have thus finished your discourse, you will now (as you say) without fear come into the battle and fight with us. You are still telling us of armies, skirmishes, wars, camps and of your battles: but you should remember that the trial of war is common to both sides, and the issues of battles uncertain. The and of war lieth in the strength of arms, not in the stoutness of words.
Twentie yeares are expired, and not one of you hitherto could performe the condition: if you perswade your selfe to haue more sufficiency hereunto, then your masters before haue had, why stay you? why sit you still? why discontinue you the defence of so good a cause? But alas, you are no body, you haue read nothing, you haue no strength answerable to such an endeuor. The learned Humphrey did not taxe Iewel, as if he had too liberally vndertaken for the Fathers, or performed lesse then he promised; but only that he had yeelded further vnto you, then he needed, and called backe the cause which was already determined by the Scriptures, to the authorities of the Fathers; which yet he did not, as though he distrusted any thing, the triall of Scriptures; for hee knew that they were sufficient to refute all popish errors: but that hereby he might beate downe that their insolent and most false bragge of antiquitie, which preuailed with many. You say further that you ⟨p. 146⟩haue conferred sometimes familiarly with To•y Matthew, and w••led him to answere freely, whether hee that read the Fathers diligently, could bee of that part which •e fauoured. Although in priuate and familiar conference wee say many things, which we would not haue further reported, or dispersed, yet I doubt not, but the worthy Mathew gaue you such an answere, as was both agreeable to the truth, and fit for his iudgement and wisdome. Wee must not in all things beleeue the Fathers, nor doth our faith depend vpon their word. Sometimes they haue erred and been the occasion of errors vnto others; yet may we reade them, & by their truthes be more learned, by the contrary more wary. And this also thinketh Matthew Hutton that famous man, whom you surmise to bee the only man amongst vs conuersant in the Fathers. And this also is all our opinions. After you haue thus finished your discourse, you will now (as you say) without feare come into the battell and fight with vs. You are still telling vs of armies, skirmishes, warres, campes and of your battailes: but you should remember that the triall of warre is common to both sides, and the issues of battailes vncerteine. The and of warre lieth in the strength of armes, not in the stoutnes of words.
IF ever that saying (a search the Scriptures) was loved, and liked of by any, which was greatly regarded and ought to be amongst us; the holy Fathers assuredly herein excelled and exceeded: for by their labour and cost were the Bibles copied out, and conveyed to so many countries and nations of strange languages; by their great perils and torments were they delivered from burning by the enemies, and from destruction; by their pains and teachings, have they been throughout expounded most faithfully; they spent whole days and nights in the study of holy Scriptures; they preached out of every Pulpit the holy Scriptures; they enriched long volumes with holy Scriptures; with most faithful Commentaries they explained the holy Scriptures; they seasoned as well their feasting as their fasting, with holy Scriptures. And finally they exercised themselves, even until crooked old age crept upon them in holy Scriptures. And although they grounded their reasons also upon the authority of their Ancestors, upon the common practise of the Church, upon the succession of Bishops, upon general Councils, upon Traditions of the Apostles, upon the bloodshedding of Martyrs, upon the decrees of Pre•••s, upon strange signs and marn••••us •••racles, yet their greatest desire was, especially to fill their treatises, with store of testimonies out of the holy Scriptures. These they urge, upon these they make ⟨p. 148⟩their habitation, to these Scriptures as unto the coatb armour of valiant soldiers, they worthily yield the highest and most honourable place, like noble captains, daily defending the Catholic Church, which is the city of God, by them kept in good repair, against all mischievous assaults of her enemy: the which thing maketh me the more to marvel, at that proud and foolish exception of the adversary, who like one that seeketh for water in the running river, complaineth for the scarcity of Scriptures, where greatest store of Scriptures are alleged. So long he saith he is content to be judged by the Fathers as they swerve not from the Scriptures. Doth he speak as he thinketh? I will see then that these most famous writers, most ancient Fathers, and most holy men, Saint Denis, S. Cyprian, S. Athanasius, S. Basil, S. Gregory Nazianzen, S. Ambrose, S. Hierome, S. Chrysostom, S. Augustine, and S.
IF euer that saying (a search the Scriptures) was loued, and liked of by any, which was greatly regarded and ought to be amongst vs; the holy Fathers assuredly herein excelled and exceeded: for by their labour and cost were the Bibles copied out, and conueyed to so many countries and nations of strange languages; by their great perils and torments were they deliuered from burning by the enemies, and from destruction; by their paines and teachings, haue they been throughout expounded most faithfully; they spent whole daies and nights in the study of holy Scriptures; they preached out of euery Pulpit the holy Scriptures; they enriched long volumes with holy Scriptures; with most faithful Commentaries they explained the holy Scriptures; they seasoned as well their feasting as their fasting, with holy Scriptures. And finally they exercised themselues, euen vntill crooked old age crept vpon them in holy Scriptures. And although they grounded their reasons also vpon the authority of their Auncestors, vppon the common practise of the Church, vpon the succession of Bishops, vpon generall Councels, vpon Traditions of the Apostles, vpon the bloodshedding of Martyrs, vpon the decrees of Pre•••s, vpon strange signes and marn••••us •••racles, yet their greatest desire was, especially to fill their treatises, with store of testimonies out of the holy Scriptures. These they vrge, vpon these they make ⟨p. 148⟩their habitation, to these Scriptures as vnto the coateb armor of valiant souldiers, they worthily yeeld the highest and most honorable place, like noble captaines, daily desending the Catholike Church, which is the citie of God, by them kept in good repaire, against all mischeeuous assaults of her enemie: the which thing maketh me the more to maruell, at that proud and foolish exception of the aduersarie, who like one that seeketh for water in the running riuer, complaineth for the scarsity of Scriptures, where greatest store of Scriptures are alleadged. So long he saith he is content to be iudged by the Fathers as they swarue not from the Scriptures. Doth he speake as he thinketh? I will see then that these most famous writers, most auncient Fathers, and most holy men, Saint Denys, S. Cyprian, S. Athanasius, S. Basil, S. Gregory Nazianzen, S. Ambrose, S. Hierome, S. Chrysostome, S. Augustine, and S.
Gregory the great shall come forth well armed and upholden with Christ, with the Prophets, with the Apostles, and with the whole furniture of the Bible. Grant good Lord, that, that religion may* reign in England, I say good Christ grant, that, that religion may reign in England, that these Fathers that embrace the Scriptures, so lovingly have builded up out of the Scriptures. Look what Scriptures they bring, we will bring the same; look what Scriptures they confer, we will confer the same; look what Scriptures they allege, we will allege the same. Art thou also contented with this? cough out Sir a Gods name, and tell me plainly what you think. I like them not thou wilt say except they interpret the said Scriptures rightly; what meanest thou by saying rightly? ô now I know, after thy own fancy. Art thou not ashamed of this blind entreat dealing? Then for as much as I am in good hope, that in the foresaid Universities, that most freshly flourish, there will join together a great number of such as will look into these controversies; not grossly, but with sharp ⟨p. 149⟩judgement, and will weigh these mens trifling answer not partially, but in equal balance; I will therefore, with a cheerful courage expect this day of battle, as one that mindeth to march forward with the nobility, & force of Christs Church, against a monkest multitude of ragged Rogues.
Gregory the great shall come forth wel armed and vpholden with Christ, with the Prophets, with the Apostles, and with the whole furniture of the Bible. Grant good Lord, that, that religion may* raigne in England, I say good Christ grant, that, that religion may raigne in England, that these Fathers that embrace the Scriptures, so louingly haue builded vp out of the Scriptures. Looke what Scriptures they bring, wee will bring the same; looke what Scriptures they conferre, we will conferre the same; looke what Scriptures they alleadge, we will alleadge the same. Art thou also contented with this? cough out Sir a Gods name, and tell me plainly what you thinke. I like them not thou wilt say except they interpret the said Scriptures rightly; what meanest thou by saying rightly? ô now I know, after thy owne fancy. Art thou not ashamed of this blind intreate dealing? Then for as much as I am in good hope, that in the foresaid Vniuersities, that most freshly flourish, there will ioyne together a great number of such as will looke into these controuersies; not grosely, but with sharpe ⟨p. 149⟩iudgement, and wil weigh these mens trifling answere not partially, but in equall ballance; I will therefore, with a chearefull courage expect this day of battell, as one that mindeth to march forward with the nobility, & force of Christs Church, against a monkes• multitude of ragged Rogues.
*And at this day the same faith flourisheth in England, which those Fathers did had and defended.
I Cannot well conjecture, Campion, what these new foundations of the fathers may be, which you propound unto us. As touching the fathers we have given you your answer, and have plainly proved, that they afford no foundation for you to build your cause upon. And it is probable that you thought so your self; therefore you judged it not safe for you to rest in them, unless you brought forth certain foundations by which you might strengthen the fathers themselves. For after you had said what you could remember touching the fathers, that you might show you esteemed their sayings as divine Oracles, because you saw that was too slender, and that no man would jump with you in that point, you now endeavour by certain foundations to fortify and strengthen the authority of the Fathers. Now the strength, and as it were the bond and sinews of this disputation is this ⟨p. 150⟩aThe Fathers have searched the Scriptures most diligently, they have heaped up store of testimonies out of the holy Scriptures, they have attributed the chief place to these: therefore we ought to be content with their exposition of Scriptures; and without sin we may desire no better. This either is the sense of this place, or else there is no sense in it. And verily I profess you have laid these things down so faintly and loosely, that I can hardly discern their scope: for what, I pray you, can be spoken more loosely? The fathers have diligently laboured to understand the Scriptures: therefore in their exposition of them they have never erred. But we find many strange differing and dissenting expositions in the Fathers; which all may well be false, but more then one of them cannot be true. I will give you one example for a thousand.b S. Paul writeth,3⟨p. 151⟩that at Antioch he withstood Peter to his face: what a kind of opposition this was you would know, but cannot of your self find it out. You wonder that Paul would oppose Peter, one Apostle another, and haply you suspect some mystery may be hid in it: you go to the fathers, you enquire of Hierome, 4and of Augustine, two very famous lights of the Latin Church. What do they tell you? Augustine think that S. Paul spoke ingenuously and as he thought Hierome that he spoke feignedly. If you approve the one, you must needs reject the other; for you cannot consent with both. Six hundred of this kind I could propound unto you.
I Cannot wel cōiecture, Campion, what these new foundations of the fathers may bee, which you propound vnto vs. As touching the fathers we haue giuen you your answere, and haue plainely prooued, that they affoord no foundation for you to build your cause vpō. And it is probable that you thought so your self; therefore you iudged it not safe for you to rest in them, vnlesse you brought foorth certaine foundations by which you might strengthen the fathers themselues. For after you had said what you could remember touching the fathers, that you might shew you esteemed their sayings as diuine Oracles, because you saw that was too slender, and that no man would iumpe with you in that point, you now indeuour by certaine foundations to fortifie and strengthen the authoritie of the Fathers. Now the strength, and as it were the bond and sinewes of this disputation is this ⟨p. 150⟩aThe Fathers haue searched the Scriptures most diligently, they haue heaped vp store of testimonies out of the holy Scriptures, they haue attributed the chiefe place to these: therefore wee ought to bee content with their exposition of Scriptures; and without sinne wee may desire no better. This either is the sense of this place, or else there is no sense in it. And verely I professe you haue laid these things downe so faintlie and looselie, that I can hardlie discerne their scope: for what, I pray you, can bee spoken more loosely? The fathers haue diligently laboured to vnderstand the Scriptures: therefore in their exposition of them they haue neuer erred. But we find many strange differing and dissenting expositions in the Fathers; which all may well be false, but more then one of them cannot be true. I will giue you one example for a thousand.b S. Paul writeth,3⟨p. 151⟩that at Antioch hee withstood Peter to his face: what a kinde of opposition this was you would know, but cannot of your selfe find it out. You wonder that Paul would oppose Peter, one Apostle another, and happely you suspect some mystery may be hid in it: you goe to the fathers, you enquire of Hierome, 4and of Augustine, two very famous lights of the Latine Church. What do they tell you? Augustine thinke that S. Paul spoke ingenuously and as he thoughte Hierome that he spoke fainedly. If you approue the one, you must needs reiect the other; for you cannot consent with both. Sixe hundred of this kind I could propound vnto you.
aDVR. Campian doth not dispute so; but say he do, what reprove you? for he speaketh not of one Father, but of the consent of all, who flourished in one age, whom Saint Paul saith, Christ hath made Pastors and teachers of his Church, Eph. 4.11. WHIT. pag. 408. Then, as you confess, I swerved not much from his sense. But think you the reason is of force? The ancient Fathers have diligently read and searched the Scriptures, therefore they never erred in their interpretation. If i• hold in the Fathers, why not in others which do search the Scriptures as well as they? which if you once grant, you overturn your own cause. And though they were Pastors of the Church, yet were there many other Pastors and teachers of the Church, who either writ nothing at all, or their writings are perished; so that what they delivered, we possibly cannot know: what a vain thing is it then to brag of the consent of all, when you can hardly name twenty in the most flourishing age that ever was, whose books came to our hands. Besides, the consent of all in one age in no controversy can you bring against us, except it were in the most corrupt ages. Lastly, the Pastors Christ gave to his Church, were men, such as might err, and who had no promise to be kept from error, if at any time they turned aside from the Scriptures.DVR. Campian doth not dispute so; but say he do, what reproue you? for he speaketh not of one Father, but of the consent of all, vvho flourished in one age, whom Saint Paul saith, Christ hath made Pastors and teachers of his Church, Eph. 4.11. WHIT. pag. 408. Then, as you confesse, I swarued not much from his sense. But thinke you the reason is of force? The auncient Fathers haue diligently read and searched the Scriptures, therefore they neuer erred in their interpretation. If i• hold in the Fathers, why not in others vvhich do search the Scriptures as vvell as they? vvhich if you once grant, you ouerturne your owne cause. And though they were Pastors of the Church, yet vvere there many other Pastors and teachers of the Church, vvho either vvrit nothing at all, or their vvritings are perished; so that vvhat they deliuered, vve possibly cannot knovv: vvhat a vaine thing is it then to bragge of the consent of all, vvhen you can hardly name tvventy in the most flourishing age that euer vvas, vvhose bookes came to our hands. Besides, the consent of all in one age in no controuersie can you bring against vs, except it vvere in the most corrupt ages. Lastly, the Pastors Christ gaue to his Church, vvere men, such as might erre, and vvho had no promise to be kept from error, if at any time they turned aside from the Scriptures.
I know how, saith Hierome, otherwise to account of the Apostles, then of other writers. 1They ever sp••k• the tr•••, these as man have erred in some things. Yet they read the Scriptures, they were conversant in them, and spent themselves wholly in meditating upon them. From these you may discern how your accusation is most unjust, and our defence most equal and just. I desire not to diminish the fathers due and worthy commendations: so you will confess they are men, extol them with all the praises you can to the very heavens, where they are now free Denizens. I could wish, that that which they constantly did, either you would do, search the Scripture, or suffer us to do: then I doubt not but this fight would have a good issue. But the Scriptures which Christ ratified with his own voice, and commended to our diligent search, you fly from and abhor, as thieves do the gallows, ⟨p. 152⟩you abandon them out of mens sight, and yet you have never done searching; for you compass sea and land to find out old traditions and customs long ago dead and buried, mens inventions, decrees of Popes, the corruptions of Churches, feigned and forged books, diriges, scraps; dreams and fables, but the holy Scripture you touch not at all, lest, as I suppose, they would make against you. At length for shame cast away those your trifles which you so busily hunt after, and search the Scriptures, cas Christ hath commanded,3 and the ancient fathers have done. And would to God (as Origen writeth) we all would do that which is written, Search the Scriptures) If we were commanded to search the fathers of the Church, unwritten verities, the Popes Canons, we would willingly set up our rest there; but when we are called from them to the diligent search of the Scriptures, do not much blame us, if we so far, as you speak, subscribe to the fathers, as they agree with the Scriptures. For you cannot justly blame that in us which you confess is commendable in them.d For Christ commanded us aswell as them, to search ⟨p. 159⟩the Scriptures. That therefore which is enjoined us both, to search, it ought to be the purpose of both to find out. And do you judge it equal,e that if they have erred in searching, we should tread in their steps, and reject the trueth we have found out? For wheresoever they find out the truth they sought after, we receive it and consent with them.
I know how, sayth Hierome, otherwise to account of the Apostles, then of other writers. 1They euer sp••k• the tr•••, these as man haue erred in some things. Yet they read the Scriptures, they were conuersant in them, and spent themselues wholly in meditating vpon them. From these you may discerne how your accusation is most vniust, and our defence most equall and iust. I desire not to diminish the fathers due and worthy commendations: so you will confesse they are men, extoll them with all the prayses you can to the very heauens, where they are now free Denizens. I could wish, that that which they constantly did, either you would do, search the Scripture, or suffer vs to do: then I doubt not but this fight would haue a good issue. But the Scriptures which Christ ratified with his owne voice, and commended to our diligent search, you flie from and abhorre, as theeues doe the gallowes, ⟨p. 152⟩you abandon them out of mens sight, and yet you haue neuer done searching; for you compasse sea and land to find out old traditions and customes long ago dead and buried, mens inuentions, decrees of Popes, the corruptions of Churches, fained and forged bookes, diriges, scrappes; dreames and fables, but the holy Scripture you touch not at all, lest, as I suppose, they would make against you. At length for shame cast away those your trifles which you so busily hunt after, and search the Scriptures, cas Christ hath commaunded,3 and the ancient fathers haue done. And would to God (as Origen writeth) we all would doe that which is written, Search the Scriptures) If we were commanded to search the fathers of the Church, vnwritten verities, the Popes Canons, wee would willingly set vp our rest there; but when wee are called from them to the diligent search of the Scriptures, doe not much blame vs, if we so farre, as you speake, subscribe to the fathers, as they agree with the Scriptures. For you cannot iustly blame that in vs which you confesse is commendable in them.d For Christ commanded vs aswell as them, to search ⟨p. 159⟩the Scriptures. That therefore which is inioyned vs both, to search, it ought to be the purpose of both to finde out. And doe you iudge it equall,
1Hieron. in Epist. ad Theophilis.
cDVR. We allow all to read the Scriptures, as many as can well and safely do it. And then we account the search good and sound, when men are able to interpret them not out of their own heads, but by the authority of the ancient Fathers. WHIT pag. 415. You show your good nature, that you will not reprove that which is well done. But may none else read the Scriptures, but men qualified as you write? then very few must spend their labour in them. But Christ commanded to search the Scriptures, not the opinions and exposition of the Fathers, yea and he commanded all whosoever to seek eternal life, and desire to know Christ, Joh. 5.39. and not the learned only.DVR. VVe allow all to read the Scriptures, as many as can vvell and safely do it. And then vve account the search good and sound, vvhen men are able to interpret them not out of their ovvne heads, but by the authority of the auncient Fathers. WHIT pag. 415. You shew your good nature, that you will not reproue that which is well done. But may none else reade the Scriptures, but men qualified as you write? then very few must spend their labour in them. But Christ commanded to search the Scriptures, not the opinions and exposition of the Fathers, yea and he commaunded all whosoeuer to seeke eternall life, and desire to know Christ, Joh. 5.39. and not the learned only.
3Origen. in Isas. hom. 1.
dDVR. If you think Christ commanded all, you are greatly deceived, for how should the rude and ignorant search the Scriptures? who as Augustine witnesseth must be saved, not by sharpness of understanding, but by simplicity of believing. Moreover Christ gave unto the people, Pastors and Doctors, and not the books of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 417. Christ verily spake to the people, not to the learned, and if he commanded all the Jews to search the Scriptures, why not all Christians? but that they ought, is proved by these places, Act. 17.11. Coll. 3.16. Chrysostom upon that place, Hom. 9. Hierome upon the same. Origen. in Jsaiam hom. 2. Chrysost. in Evangel. Joan. hom. 13. Further if the people be ignorant, you take the way to keep them so. But they verily ought to have knowledge; and you very learnedly make an argument from their defect. Augustine as you would have it, doth not maintain the ignorance of the people, only he requireth not of them any subtle knowledge: all must believe, which none can do without the knowledge of the Scripture, but the same quickness of understanding is not required in all. Finally Christ who gave them teachers, gave them also the Word; neither were the Pastors to teach them any thing, but the Scriptures; why then speak you thus? as if these things ordained one under another were contrary: It is worthy the observing, that in your judgement Christ gave not the Scriptures unto the people; if then they read them, they meddle with other mens right.
And therefore, Campian, make you no doubt, we speak unfeignedly; we will subscribe to the fathers, while they consent to the Scriptures. Doth this thing please you? so it seemeth. For you say, You will see that these most ancient writers, S. Denis, S. Cyprian, S. Athanasius, S. Basil, S. Gregory Nazianzene, S. Ambrose, S. Hierome, S. Chrysostom, S. Augustine, and S. Gregory the great, shall come forth well armed with the whole furniture of the bible. But what if they will not obey your commandment, neither serve for wages in your tents? will you compel them against their wills to bear arms in your camps? It is more then you can do: they will not endure themselves to be thus compelled or forced. You call them man by man, but they will not answer to those names: yea, both these now named by you, and all ancient fathers do proclaim open war against ⟨p. 160⟩you, and if you please, let us spend a little time in the trial of it.
And therefore, Campian, make you no doubt, we speake vnfeinedly; wee will subscribe to the fathers, while they consent to the Scriptures. Doth this thing please you? so it seemeth. For you say, You will see that these most ancient writers, S. Denys, S. Cyprian, S. Athanasius, S. Basil, S. Gregory Nazianzene, S. Ambrose, S. Hierome, S. Chrysostome, S. Augustine, and S. Gregory the great, shall come foorth well armed with the whole furniture of the bible. But what if they will not obey your commandement, neither serue for wages in your tents? will you compell them against their willes to beare armes in your campes? It is more then you can doe: they will not indure themselues to bee thus compelled or forced. You call them man by man, but they wil not answere to those names: yea, both these now named by you, and all auncient fathers doe proclaime open warre against ⟨p. 160⟩you, and if you please, let vs spend a little time in the triall of it.
This Denis whosoever he was cannot be on your side, while you maintainf private Mass. For he hath described the public communion of the whole Church, such as Christ at the first instituted, and the ancient Church ever held. The very same thing doth Justine the Philosopher and martyr,2 who in his Apology before Anthony the Emperor, laid open the order of discipline, which Christ held in his holy assembly. At that time the whole people receivedg bread & wine, now with you they receive neither.h Cyprian makes all the Apostles equal with Peter, 5and directly affirmeth that they have like honour and authority with him, and forbids all appeals to the Bishop of Rome. Therefore he must needs deest your Pope, who preferreth himself both in dignity ⟨p. 161⟩& authority before all other Bishops, & from all parts draws unto his courts all appeals.i Lactantius writeth that it is a thing without question.7kThere can be no religion wheresoever there is an image. If he now lived and saw your Churches full of images, would he acknowledge any sign of true Religion? Athanasius affirmeth,9 That the holy Scriptures given by inspiration are sufficient to instruct men in all trueth: wherein with one word he hath put to slight the whole armies of yourl traditions. Epiphanius sharply reproveth certain foolish women,11 who worshipped the virgin Mary with a certain new kind of worship, and condemneth all that superstition. ⟨p. 160⟩[…] ⟨p. 161⟩[…] ⟨image 100⟩mLet none, saith he, worship the Virgin Mary. What would he say if he now saw not only foolish women, but also men, and all mortal wightsn offering up sacrifices and vows to the Virgin Mary? 14Basil is the author, that in his days there was ao custom in all Churches, that the people repeated the Psalms in the holy assemblies. But in your Churches the people canp neither hear nor understand those things which are read; but are only deluded with ridiculous gestures and pompous shows.q18Nazianzene speaketh no less honourably of this civill and sociable life, than of the solitary life of Monks: which ⟨image 100⟩your cloister men cannot endure.19rAmbrose inveigheth bitterly against them, who think it necessary for them, when they would go to God to use some mediators, as men do in courts of Princes, before they can be brought to the King himself, they must seek the favour of some of his near attendants.
This Deuis whosoeuer he was cannot be on your side, while you maintainef priuate Masse. For he hath described the publike communion of the whole Church, such as Christ at the first instituted, and the ancient Church euer held. The very same thing doth Iustine the Philosopher and martyr,2 who in his Apologie before Anthony the Emperour, layd open the order of discipline, which Christ held in his holy assembly. At that time the whole people receiuedg bread & wine, now with you they receiue neither.h Cyprian makes all the Apostles equall with Peter, 5and directly affirmeth that they haue like honour and authoritie with him, and forbids all appeales to the Bishop of Rome. Therefore he must needes deest your Pope, who preferreth himselfe both in dignity ⟨p. 161⟩& authority before all other Bishops, & from all parts drawes vnto his courts all appeales.i Lactantius writeth that it is a thing without questiō.7kThere can be no religion wheresoeuer there is an image. If hee now liued and saw your Churches full of images, would he acknowledge any signe of true Religion? Athanasius affirmeth,9 That the holy Scriptures giuen by inspiration are sufficient to instruct men in all trueth: wherein with one word hee hath put to slight the whole armies of yourl traditions. Epiphanius sharply reprooueth certaine foolish women,11 who worshipped the virgine Mary with a certaine new kind of worship, and condemneth all that superstition. ⟨p. 160⟩
fDVR. We Catholics neither defend nor acknowledge a private Mass•, for all Masses are said by a public Minister of the Church, in the name of the whole, and for the salvation of all the children of the Church is it offered. WHIT. pag. 428. It is childish to contend about the Word, you defend such a Mass as the Church knew not in the days when Denis lived; for your Masses are performed by one, but the form he speaketh of, is performed by many. And what if a public Minister do it, yet that being done of one must needs be private, specially when either there are no people present, or if they be present, yet they do nothing but look on: and what profit can come to them by that he doth? as if that meat the Priest eateth feedeth the people. Besi•es Christ never ordained such an offering, himself once offered, is the sacrifice which is profitable to the whole Church. Again, what needeth the people once to communicant with him, or what greater fruits shall they have by it, if they do? Lastly if the whole people may receive salvation from that Mass which they neither taste, see, nor yet dream of, why will you not grant that Christ may be present to our faith, though we be far disjoined from his body.DVR. VVe Catholikes neither defend nor acknowledge a priuate Mass•, for all Masses are said by a publike Minister of the Church, in the name of the whole, and for the saluation of all the children of the Church is it offered. WHIT. pag. 428. It is childish to contend about the Word, you defend such a Masse as the Church knew not in the daies when Denys liued; for your Masses are performed by one, but the forme he speaketh of, is performed by many. And what if a publike Minister do it, yet that being done of one must needs be priuate, specially when either there are no people present, or if they be present, yet they do nothing but looke on: and what profit can come to them by that hee doth? as if that meate the Priest eateth feedeth the people. Besi•es Christ neuer ordained such an offering, himselfe once offered, is the sacrifice which is profitable to the whole Church. Againe, what needeth the people once to communicant with him, or what greater fruits shall they haue by it, if they doe? Lastly if the whole people may receiue saluation from that Masse which they neither tast, see, nor yet dreame of, why will you not grant that Christ may be present to our faith, though we be farre disioyned from his body.
2Justin. Apol. 2.Iustin. Apol. 2.
gDVR. Jf you had but lightly read over Justine, you would never have been so impudent, for he altogether alloweth our judgement, and no where speaketh he of bread and wine given to the people. WHIT. pag. 430. If you had read the place, you might have seen the contrary to your opinion and to all that you say, his own words shall manifest all. They, who with us are called Deacons, give to every one that is present part of the bread, wine and water, for which thanks are given. Can any thing be said more contrary to your, and more manifest for our opinion.
Doth not this thing touch you, doth not this speech draw blood of you? who never ask any thing of God in your prayers, but first you seek some of the Saints to be a mediator for you, to whom you commend the care of your business and requests.1sHierome did too much contemn your Pope, and other your glorious Bishops, when he writeth that a Priest and a Bishop, by the law of God ⟨image 101⟩are all one; do you judge him worthy to be a Father of the Romish Church, the Bishop whereof you make not only to be far above all Priests, but also all Bishops?t Gelasius who himself was a Bishop of Rome, condemneth your dry and maimed supper as Sacrilegious, and strictly commandeth, 4that either the whole be received, or it be wholly omitted. Will the authority of the Pope move you no whit at all? Vigilius writeth that Christ is departed from us in his humane nature.u The Son of God in his humane nature is gone from us: but in his divine nature he is always with us, whereas you say Christ is present in both natures.* Chrysostom exhorteth lay men and all the people that they would get them Bibles,7 read the Scriptures, and that at home in their houses the husband with the wife, the father with his children, would confer among themselves of the ⟨p. 165⟩Scriptures. But this neither can, nor lawfully may be done in your Church, yea, it is a certain proof of an heretic, for any to have the Bible in his house. What shall I say of Augustine, who in the greatest and most principal controversies, as of grace, predestination, free will, justification, the Scripture, the Law, the Gospel, sin, good works, Sacraments, and Church is wholly and fully ours. I should never make an end if I should pursue particulars, and collect but a little of every thing.8 Gregory the great, though he was a Bishop of Rome, yet will he take our part against you: For tell me, doth he not touch your Pope to the quick, when peremptorily he affirmed, that whosoever should call himself thex universal Bishop, undoubtedly was the forerunner of Antichrist? Touching which title there hath been deadly hatred and bloody contentions betwixt the Bishops of Constantinople and Rome. John of Constantinople being a proud man, and very insolent, and ambitious, first challenged this unto himself: Gregory while he lived earnestly and constantly withstood him.
Doth not this thing touch you, doth not this speech draw blood of you? who neuer aske any thing of God in your prayers, but first you seeke some of the Saints to bee a mediatour for you, to whom you commend the care of your businesse and requests.1sHierome did too much contemne your Pope, and other your glorious Bishops, when hee writeth that a Priest and a Bishop, by the law of God ⟨image 101⟩are all one; doe you iudge him worthy to bee a Father of the Romish Church, the Bishop whereof you make not onely to be farre aboue all Priests, but also all Bishops?t Gelasius who himselfe was a Bishop of Rome, condemneth your drie and maimed supper as Sacrilegious, and strictly commandeth, 4that either the whole be receiued, or it be wholly omitted. Will the authoritie of the Pope moue you no whit at all? Vigilius writeth that Christ is departed from vs in his humane nature.u The Sonne of God in his humane nature is gone from vs: but in his diuine nature hee is alwayes with vs, whereas you say Christ is present in both natures.* Chrysostome exhorteth lay men and all the people that they would get them Bibles,7 reade the Scriptures, and that at home in their houses the husband with the wife, the father with his children, would conferre among themselues of the ⟨p. 165⟩Scriptures. But this neither can, nor lawfully may be done in your Church, yea, it is a certaine proofe of an heretique, for any to haue the Bible in his house. What shall I say of Augustine, who in the greatest and most principall controuersies, as of grace, predestination, free will, iustification, the Scripture, the Law, the Gospel, sinne, good workes, Sacraments, and Church is wholly and fully ours. I should neuer make an end if I should pursue particulars, and collect but a little of euery thing.8 Gregory the great, though he was a Bishop of Rome, yet will he take our part against you: For tell mee, doth hee not touch your Pope to the quicke, when peremptorily he affirmed, that whosoeuer should call himselfe the
1Hieron. Ep.
sDVR Hierome never writeth thus, but affirmeth that there is the like difference betwixt a Bishop a Priest, and a Deacon, as was betwixt Aaron, and his sons and the Levites. Epist. ad Evagr. And if there be equality, it is in jurisdiction, not in power of order. WHIT. pag. 447. It is strange that you deny that which Hierome directly affirmeth in the beginning of the same Epistle namely, that the Apostle doth plainly teach, that a Bishop, and a Priest are all one: and this he proveth by many testimonies of the Scripture. And upon the 1. chap. to Titus, he affirmeth plainly that a Bishop is above a Priest by custom, not by Gods ordinance. And so must that be understood you bring out of the forenamed Epistle. And where you acknowledge the same jurisdiction of both by the law of God (which haply slipped from you unawares) their unequal power must needs be only by the law of man.DVR Hierome neuer vvriteth thus, but affirmeth that there is the like difference betwixt a Bishop a Priest, and a Deacon, as was betwixt Aaron, and his sonnes and the Leuites. Epist. ad Euagr. And if there be equality, it is in iurisdiction, not in povver of order. WHIT. pag. 447. It is strange that you deny that which Hierome directly affirmeth in the beginning of the same Epistle namely, that the Apostle doth plainly teach, that a Bishop, and a Priest are all one: and this he proueth by many testimonies of the Scripture. And vpon the 1. chap. to Titus, hee affirmeth plainly that a Bishop is aboue a Priest by custome, not by Gods ordinance. And so must that be vnderstood you bring out of the forenamed Epistle. And where you acknowledge the same iurisdiction of both by the law of God (which happely slipped from you vnawares) their vnequall power must needs be only by the law of man.
tDVR Leo the Pope did decree this first of all, and Gelatius the fourth after him confirmed it, least any of the Manichees. who superstitiously and wickedly abstained from blood, might look among the Catholics. WHIT pag. 451. I will accept your answer, though your Gratian be against it. But who seeth not what a goodly patron you are of the popish cause, who make the Manichees the first author of the dismembering of the Supper. But whosoever did it, Gelatius censureth it thus. The division of one and the same mystery cannot be without great sacrilege. And so by a Pope is the whole Popish Church condemned of sacrilege.DVR Leo the Pope did decree this first of all, and Gelatius the fourth after him confirmed it, least any of the Manichies. vvho superstitiously and vvickedly abstained from blood, might looke among the Catholikes. WHIT pag. 451. I will accept your answere, though your Gratian bee against it. But who seeth not what a goodly patron you are of the popish cause, who make the Manichies the first author of the dismembring of the Supper. But whosoeuer did it, Gelatius censureth it thus. The diuision of one and the same mystery cannot bee without great sacriledge. And so by a Pope is the whole Popish Church condemned of sacriledge.
And within a while after this title was taken from the Bishop of Constantinople, and given to the Bishop of Rome. Leave trifling, Campian, and even tell me plainly,y if that name in the Bishop of ⟨p. 166⟩Constantinople was a sign of the approaching of Antichrist, why may we not judge it in the Bishop of Rome, a notable ensign of the same Antichrist? now I have given you a taste by which you may judge other things: you must either get you other fathers, or for all these you must needs yield as overcome. Do we at length speak without riddles? what is it you else desire of us? wherefore Campian, get you into this camp, and show forth all your valour: you shall verily find you have to deal, not with naked and unarmed beggars, but with well appointed and well harnessed adversaries.
And within a while after this title was taken from the Bishop of Constantinople, and giuen to the Bishop of Rome. Leaue trifling, Campian, and euen tell me plainely,y if that name in the Bishop of ⟨p. 166⟩Constantinople was a signe of the approching of Antichrist, why may wee not iudge it in the Bishop of Rome, a notable ensigne of the same Antichrist? now I haue giuen you a taste by which you may iudge other things: you must either get you other fathers, or for all these you must needes yeeld as ouercome. Doe wee at length speake without riddles? what is it you els desire of vs? wherefore Campian, get you into this campe, and shew forth all your valour: you shall verily finde you haue to deale, not with naked and vnarmed beggars, but with well appointed and well harnessed aduersaries.
yDVR. Who seeth not in what sense th•se Bishops of Rome would not this name unto themselves, though they always professed them Bishops of the universal and Catholic Church, and the Vicars of Christ. WHIT pag. 463. It seemeth you did not mean to be understood of any who speak on this manner: but tell us, is the Pope universal Bishop or no? If he be, how cometh the change, that, that which was Antichristian in the Patriarch of Constantinople by the judgement of Pelagius & Gregory, both Bishops of Rome, should be Catholic and holy in the Pope? For that which so insolently John of Constantinople took unto himself, and enjoyed for a while, not long after Boniface the third earnestly took unto himself, and translated to his successors, as saith Platina in vita Bonifac. 3. & Sabellicus Ennead. 8. lib. 6. Vispergensis in Phoca. They then have not only the thing, but the name, and so are Antichristian.DVR. VVho seeth not in vvhat sense th•se Bishops of Rome vvould not this name vnto themselues, though they alwaies professed them Bishops of the vniuersall and Catholike Church, and the Vicars of Christ. WHIT pag. 463. It seemeth you did not meane to be vnderstood of any who speake on this manner: but tell vs, is the Pope vniuersall Bishop or no? If he be, how commeth the change, that, that which was Antichristian in the Patriarke of Constantinople by the iudgement of Pelagius & Gregorie, both Bishops of Rome, should be Catholike and holy in the Pope? For that which so insolently Iohn of Constantinople tooke vnto himselfe, and enioyed for a while, not long after Boniface the third earnestly tooke vnto himselfe, and translated to his successors, as saith Platina in vita Bonifac. 3. & Sabellicus Ennead. 8. lib. 6. Vispergensis in Phoca. They then haue not only the thing, but the name, and so are Antichristian.
The ancient Histories of former times, do plainly discover the true form of the Primitive Church, thither do I appeal: as for the ancient Historiographers,1 whose authority all the adversaries do sometime usurp, these are well nigh all of them. Eusebius, Damasus, Hierome, Ruffinus, Orosas, Socrates, Sozomenus, Theodoretus, Cassiodorus, Gregory of Tours, Oswaldus, Regino, Marianus, Sigibertus, Sonoras, Cedrenus, Nicephorus. ⟨p. 167⟩What song, I pray you, do these men sing? a song in praise of Catholics of their prosperous proceedings, of their interchangeable alterations, & what enemies they had; yea moreover (which I would have you well to mark) these men which are our daily enemies for our Religion sake,2 to wit, Philip Melanchthon, Pantalion, Functius, and the Magdeburgeans, when they went about, to write either Chronicle or Ecclesiastical History, they should have had nothing at all to write of for the space of 1500. years after Christ, except they had gathered together the acts of those men, that take our part, and put in writing the treacheries and outrages of the enemies of our Church. Consider also the particular Historiographers of some special countries,3 who bended themselves curiously and busily to search out the special affairs of every such people as they undertook to write of. These as men desirous by all means they possibly could to enrich and beautify that work they had in hand, omitted not so much as banqueting feasts, or long sleeved coats, or strange hafts of daggers, or gilded spurs, and such like trifles, but they made mention thereof, if it had any smack of novelty. These men doubtless, if there had been any alteration in religion, or any digression, from their former faith, which was in the Primitive Church, that had come to their ears, many of them would have recorded it: if not many, yet some few of them at the least; if not some few, yet some one or other doubtless would have made mention thereof.* But no body at all, neither friend nor foe, made any muttering, or gave any inkling of any such matter. As for example sake, the adversaries grant (because they cannot otherwise choose) that the Church of Rome, was once an holy Catholic and Apostolic Church, even then when it deserved these commendations ofa S. Paul, Your faith is spoken of throughout the whole world. I cease not to remember you in my prayers.
THe auncient Histories of former times, do plainly discouer the true forme of the Primitiue Church, thither doe I appeale: as for the auncient Historiographers,1 whose authority all the aduersaries doe sometime vsurpe, these are well nigh all of them. Eusebius, Damasus, Hierome, Ruffinus, Orosas, Socrates, Sozomenus, Theodoretus, Cassiodorus, Gregory of Tours, Oswaldus, Regino, Marianus, Sigibertus, Sonoras, Cedrenus, Nicephorus. ⟨p. 167⟩What song, I pray you, doe these men sing? a song in praise of Catholikes of their prosperous proceedings, of their interchangeable alterations, & what enemies they had; yea moreouer (which I would haue you wel to mark) these men which are our daily enemies for our Religion sake,2 to wit, Philip Melangthon, Pantalion, Functius, and the Magdeburgeans, when they went about, to write either Chronicle or Ecclesiasticall History, they should haue had nothing at all to write of for the space of 1500. yeares after Christ, except they had gathered together the acts of those men, that take our part, and put in writing the treacheries and outrages of the enemies of our Church. Consider also the particular Historiographers of some speciall countries,3 who bended themselues curiously and busily to search out the speciall affaires of euery such people as they vndertooke to write of. These as men desirous by all meanes they possibly could to enrich and beautifie that worke they had in hand, omitted not so much as banquetting feasts, or long sleeued coates, or strange haftes of daggers, or gilded spurres, and such like trifles, but they made mention thereof, if it had any smacke of noueltie. These men doubtlesse, if there had been any alteration in religion, or any digression, from their former faith, which was in the Primitiue Church, that had come to their eares, many of thē would haue recorded it: if not many, yet some few of them at the least; if not some few, yet some one or other doubtlesse would haue made mention thereof.* But no body at all, neither friend nor foe, made any muttering, or gaue any inkling of any such matter. As for example sake, the aduersaries grant (because they cannot otherwise chuse) that the Church of Rome, was once an holy Catholike and Apostolike Church, euen then when it deserued these commendations ofa S. Paul, Your faith is spoken of throughout the whole world. I cease not to remember you in my prayers.
1Generals Historici.Generales Historici.
2Hareticorū Chronica & Historica. Anno Dom. 1500.Hareticorū Chronica & Historica. Anno Dom. 1500.
3Historici certarum Gentium.
*This is false, for many have made mention of the corruption of the Church.This is false, for many haue made mention of the corruption of the Church.
Ib know that when I come ⟨p. 168⟩unto you; I shall come in the abundance of the blessings of cChrist. All the Churches of Christ do greet you, for your obedience is spread abroad in all places. Then also, when S. Paul having freed liberty of the prison, there preached the Gospel abroad. Then also, when S. Peter governed the Church, gathered together long ago in that City of Rome, which he called by thee name of Babylon.* The when that same S. fClement, whom theg Apostle so highly commendeth, was chief head of that Church: then also, whenh Heathen Emperors, as Domitian, Nero, Trajan, and Antonius most cruelly murdered the Bishops of Rome. Then also,* Calvin himself doth witness,* when Damasus, Syticius, Anastasius, and Innocentius were governors of the Sea Apostolic. For at this time he freely confesseth that men nothing swerved, especially at Rome from the true doctrine of the Gospel. At what time then hath Rome lost this faith so highly commended by S. Paul? when fainted faith which before so flourished? In what age, under what Pole, upon what occasion, by whose compulsion, by whose power, hath a new strange Religion invaded, not only that city of Rome, but the whole world besides? what outcries, what rufflings, what weeping and wailing hath it caused? were all men in all the world besides in a dead sleep, while Rome, I say, Rome brought forth new Sacraments, new sacrifice, and new doctrine of religion? There hath not been found any one Historiographer either Latin or Greek, neither abroad nor at home, which hath vouchsafed so much as to make a little note in his books of so notable a matter, though it had been never so slenderly. Wherefore this is a matter manifest enough, if the History which is a faithful witness of antiquity, and the life of memory, do in many and sundry places copiously entreat and spoke of that faith which we profess: and if no History at all since the creation of the world do affirm, that, that faith which the adversaries ⟨p. 169⟩do thrust upon us, was […] allowed in the Catholic Church; then are all the Historiographers on our part, and the invasions of the adversaries are not frivolous, and such as can make no man afraid, except it be first granted, that all Christians throughout every age, have fallen to gross infidelity and consequently into the deep pit of hell;
Ib know that when I come ⟨p. 168⟩vnto you; I shall come in the abundance of the blessings of cChrist. All the Churches of Christ do greet you, for your obedience is spread abroad in all places. Then also, when S. Paul hauing freed liberty of the prison, there preached the Gospell abroad. Then also, when S. Peter gouerned the Church, gathered together long agoe in that Citie of Rome, which hee called by thee name of Babylon.* The whē that same S. fClement, whom theg Apostle so highly commendeth, was chiefe head of that Church: then also, whenh Heathen Emperours, as Domitian, Nero, Traiane, and Antonius most cruelly murthered the Bishops of Rome. Then also,* Caluin himselfe doth witnes,* when Damasus, Syticius, Anastasius, and Innocentius were gouernours of the Sea Apostolike. For at this time he freely confesseth that men nothing swarued, especially at Rome from the true doctrine of the Gospell. At what time then hath Rome lost this faith so highly commended by S. Paul? when fainted faith which before so flourished? In what age, vnder what Pole, vpon what occasion, by whose compulsion, by whose power, hath a new strange Religion inuaded, not only that citie of Rome, but the whole world besides? what outcries, what rufflings, what weeping and wailing hath it caused? were all men in all the world besides in a dead sleepe, while Rome, I say, Rome brought forth new Sacraments, new sacrifice, and new doctrine of religion? There hath not been found any one Historiographer either Latin or Greeke, neither abroad nor at home, which hath vouchsafed so much as to make a little note in his bookes of so notable a matter, though it had been neuer so slenderly. Wherefore this is a matter manifest enough, if the Historie which is a faithfull witnes of antiquity, and the life of memory, do in many and sundry places copiously entreate and spoake of that faith which we professe: and if no History at all since the creation of the world do affirme, that, that faith which the aduersaries
Now you call us to History, the witness of times and reporter of Antiquity: and all that have taken pains in publishing the Ecclesiastical History, their names you set down, and like dumb shows, you carry them in great pomp: as though, Campian, the particular naming of all that have published any History were sufficient for the remembrance, and searching out the monuments of Antiquity. What insolent new kind of Logic is this, to reckon up the Historians of the whole world, and of particular countries, and then conclude they are your own? Have you of late from above procured this privilege, that whatsoever you lay your hands upon, shall by and by become yours? we have long since perused the ancient Chronicles, wherein the beginning and proceeding of the Church is set ⟨p. 170⟩down, and we find not that they favour you more then us. If in them be some things against us, many moe, and more weighty testimonies they have against you, and such as give you a deadly wound; else would we never have collected the Histories of the ancient Church so accurately, and diligently, penning them exactly, and distinguishing the several ages and times; neither would we have published them in the world, if they were so contrary unto us, as you surmise: for who have taken more pains to find out, or more faithfully restored the Ecclesiastical Histories, then our men, without whose labours many monuments of Antiquity had been buried in darkness? We therefore will never deny this trial of Antiquity, and seeing you appeal to ancient Histories, we condescend; yet with this caution, that we be not tied to those things which were apparently blemishes in the ancient Church. Especially seeing that writers of Histories intending to make a narration of things done, do not so much teach us what ought to be done, but have an eye to that which was then performed, and by that means set down many things worthy of reprehension, rather than imitation: and for the most part it happens, that Historiographers are possessed with the errors of the times wherein they writ; and ever the later writer the more corrupt. But here you exclaim that we seek evasions, and very perversely you slander us, that because we do not allow all, we refuse all. They that reform what is amiss, do not blame the rest that is not faulty.
NOw you call vs to Historie, the witnes of times and reporter of Antiquity: and all that haue taken paines in publishing the Ecclesiasticall Historie, their names you set downe, and like dumbe showes, you carry them in great pompe: as though, Campian, the particular naming of all that haue published any Historie were sufficient for the remembrance, and searching out the monuments of Antiquitie. What insolent new kind of Logicke is this, to recken vp the Historians of the whole world, and of particular countries, and then conclude they are your owne? Haue you of late from aboue procured this priuiledge, that whatsoeuer you lay your hands vpon, shall by and by become yours? we haue long since perused the auncient Chronicles, wherein the beginning and proceeding of the Church is set ⟨p. 170⟩downe, and we find not that they fauour you more then vs. If in them be some things against vs, many moe, and more waightie testimonies they haue against you, and such as giue you a deadlie wound; else would wee neuer haue collected the Histories of the auncient Church so accuratelie, and diligentlie, penning them exactlie, and distinguishing the seuerall ages and times; neither would wee haue published them in the world, if they were so contrarie vnto vs, as you surmise: for who haue taken more paines to finde out, or more faithfullie restored the Ecclesiasticall Histories, then our men, without whose labours many monuments of Antiquitie had been buried in darlinesse? We therefore will neuer denie this triall of Antiquitie, and seeing you appeale to auncient Histories, wee condiscend; yet with this caution, that we be not tied to those things which were apparantly blemishes in the auncient Church. Especially seeing that writers of Histories intending to make a natration of things done, doe not so much teach vs what ought to bee done, but haue an eye to that which was then performed, and by that meanes set downe many things worthie of reprehension, rather than imitation: and for the most part it happens, that Historiographers are possessed with the errors of the times wherein they writ; and euer the later writer the more corrupt. But here you exclaime that wee seeke euasions, and very peruersly you slaunder vs, that because wee doe not allowe all, wee refuse all. They that reforme what is amisse, doe not blame the rest that is not faultie.
Strive while you list (Campian) and cry out of mazes and labyrinths, at length will you, nill you, by the cares must we bring you to the judgement of the Scriptures.
Striue while you list (Campian) and crie out of mazes and labyrinths, at length will you, nill you, by the cares must wee bring you to the iudgement of the Scriptures.
And herein, Campian, you very mucha triumph, when you demand at what time, under what Bishop, by what way, and proceeding, was a new religion spread over the City of Rome, and the whole world: and do not doubt, but that if any change and declining had been, many writers would have made mention of it, or divers, or one at the least. It is hard for us to answer at what time, neither is it necessary to set down the very instant of time. All things were not at once overturned in the Church of Rome, sin and wickedness came to his height by degrees, and by leisure to ripeness; the hairs of our head are not all grey of a sudden, neither doth any thing suddenly come to his maturity, and the growth of every thing appeareth long after. This is manifest in such things, as having small beginning go on forward unto a greater quantity, until they come to perfection; you cannot deny, but there was a great alteration of Religion, in the Church of ⟨p. 172⟩bJerusalem, what then? was the change all at once? show us then how those novelties entered into the Church, what time, what way, who was Bishop, and by what proceedings it increased. You Romanis• condemn the Greek Church, and yet it is nothing so corrupt as yours.c Declare now unto me those circumstances of time in the declining of this Church, which you demand for your own. Point out the time, the Bishop, and the growth of their Apostasy. As the alteration of these Churches was then easy to be discerned when it first began, though now it be very hard to find out those circumstances: so we see plainly a great change in the Church of Rome, yet can we not certainly pronounce the several times of their several declining. Many are manifest, which were too long to rehearse, and those are distinguished according to their times and seasons. The case was with the Church of Rome, as we see it is in a great building: for as a house which is strongly built at the first, continueth so of it self a long time after sound and whole; but if for a time it be left and neglected, it beginneth in some place to decay, and to be full of chinks, which in time wax big by degrees, till they threaten ruin to the posts and roofs themselves, and at length by this means, the whole building is ruinated and falleth down:
And herein, Campian, you very mucha triumph, when you demaund at what time, vnder what Bishop, by what way, and proceeding, was a new religion spread ouer the Citie of Rome, and the whole world: and doe not doubt, but that if any change and declining had been, many writers would haue made mention of it, or diuers, or one at the least. It is hard for vs to answere at what time, neither is it necessarie to set downe the very instant of time. All things were not at once ouerturned in the Church of Rome, sinne and wickednes came to his height by degrees, and by leisure to ripenes; the haires of our head are not all gray of a suddaine, neither doth any thing suddainely come to his maturitie, and the growth of euery thing appeareth long after. This is manifest in such things, as hauing small beginning goe on forward vnto a greater quantitie, vntill they come to perfection; you cannot deny, but there was a great alteration of Religion, in the Church of ⟨p. 172⟩bIerusalem, what then? was the change all at once? shew vs then how those nouelties entred into the Church, what time, what way, who was Bishop, and by what proceedings it increased. You Romanis• condemne the Greeke Church, and yet it is nothing so corrupt as yours.c Declare now vnto me those circumstances of time in the declining of this Church, which you demaund for your owne. Poynt out the time, the Bishop, and the growth of their Apostasie. As the alteration of these Churches was then easie to bee discerned when it first beganne, though now it be very hard to finde out those circumstances: so we see plainely a great change in the Church of Rome, yet can we not certainely pronounce the seuerall times of their seuerall declining. Many are manifest, which were too long to rehearse, and those are distinguished according to their times and seasons. The case was with the Church of Rome, as we see it is in a great building: for as a house which is strongly built at the first, continueth so of it selfe a long time after sound and whole; but if for a time it be left and neglected, it beginneth in some place to decay, and to bee full of chinkes, which in time waxe big by degrees, till they threaten ruine to the posts and roofes themselues, and at length by this meanes, the whole building is ruinated and falleth downe:
aDVR. And why may not Campian trumph, for what impudency is this to cry out that the Church of Rome is full of innumerable heresies; and yet you cannot tell, when one of them ever began, in what Popes time, by what means, how it increased in the Church? WHIT. pag. 477. A good cause would be defended by reasons, not railings. But doth it follow that the Church of Rome is not corrupt, because we cannot tell the moment of time when it began to be corrupt? but being so manifest as it is, what need we search the Histories to show the beginning? what I pray? if you see a man sick of the pestilence, a city corrupt with riot and wickedness, a house ruinous and ready to fall, a ship sinking; will you deny all these, unless one can tell you the time when he began to be sick, the means how the city grew corrupt, who was ownet and in what year the house grew ruinous, and in what da•e the ship began first to leak? And what is the force of your reason and demand other then this? But, do not your own Histories tell when and by whom innovations and corruptions entered? see a few of them. He that first usurped authority over other Churches was Pope Victor, after him Zozimus, Boniface, Celestive, and the• successura. Pope Syricius first forbade Priests marriages. The Manichees first denied the Cup to the people. The Nicene Councell first ordained worshipping of Images. Pope Nicolas the second, first taught: the body of Christ must carnally be handled, broken and eaten. Pope Jnnocent the third, first established the doctrine of Transubstantiation. Boniface the third, that the Pope was the head of all Churches. Gregory the great taught Purgatory first for a certain truth. The Florentine Councell, that the Pope was above Councels. Jnnocent the third, brought in auricular confession. If these were not sufficient I could produce sire hundred more.DVR. And vvhy may not Campian trumph, for what impudencie is this to cry out that the Church of Rome is full of innumerable heresies; and yet you cannot tell, vvhen one of them euer began, in vvhat Popes time, by vvhat meanes, hovv it increased in the Church? WHIT. pag. 477. A good cause would be defended by reasons, not raylings. But doth it follow that the Church of Rome is not corrupt, because wee cannot tell the moment of time when it began to be corrupt? but being so manifest as it is, what need we search the Histories to shew the beginning? what I pray? if you see a man sicke of the pestilence, a citie corrupt with riote and wickednesse, a house ruinous and readie to fall, a shippe sincking; will you deny all these, vnlesse one can tell you the time when he began to be sicke, the meanes how the city grew corrupt, who vvas ovvnet and in vvhat yeare the house grevv ruinous, and in vvhat da•e the shippe began first to leake? And vvhat is the force of your reason and demaund other then this? But, doe not your owne Histories tell vvhen and by vvhom innouations and corruptions entred? see a fevv of them. Hee that first vsurped authoritie ouer other Churches vvas Pope Victor, after him Zozimus, Boniface, Celestiue, and the successura. Pope Syricius first fobad Priests marriages. The Manichies first denied the Cup to the people. The Nicene Councell first ordained vvorshipping of Images. Pope Nicolas the second, first taught: the bodie of Christ must carnally be handled, broken and eaten. Pope Jnnocent the third, first established the doctrine of Transubstantiation. Boniface the third, that the Pope vvas the head of all Churches. Gregorie the great taught Purgatorie first for a certeine truth. The Florentine Councell, that the Pope was aboue Councels. Jnnocent the third, brought in auricular confession. If these vvere not sufficient I could produce sire hundred more.
so the Roman Church in process of ⟨p. 173⟩time declined from her ancient estate, and by the infection of error and superstition daily prevailing, at length she lost the very spirit and life of the Church. Eusebius reporteth, that one Polycrates Bishop of Ephesus, had written of the Church, that she was, whilst the Apostles lived, a chaste and undefiled Virgin. For then they that would have altered the holy pattern of sound doctrine, did it faintly and fearfully, not daring to creep out of their holes.d But after that the Apostles departed unto the heavenly mansions, and none of that age left, that had been hearers of Christ himself, neither any of the Apostles living, then began abominable error to gather strength, and openly in the Churches to advance it self. What more pregnant testimony of antiquity and history can you desire? Whilst the Apostles lived the Church was a Virgin, as soon as they were dead, she became corrupted, and the mischief no doubt in time increased and spread it self ⟨p. 174⟩abroad. But I wonder that thise Polycrates, was either so ignorant or forgetful that he considered not this, that the Pope of Rome was left unto the Church, in the Apostles rooms, to defend this Virgin, and preserve her chastity. Why calleth he the Church a Virgin? Because the Apostles were living, by whom her audacious adversaries were always discouraged and discomforted. But either in this respect the Church now wanteth a Pope, or else she needs him not at all. But Polycrates, although there were none left to preserve the purity of this Virgin, bewaileth her want as you see, which surely had been unadvisedly done, if his opinion had been, that this charge belonged to the Bishop of Rome. The Church then from the Apostles time began to decline, and inclined to the apostasy, which the Apostle did foretell should be, and we see now fulfilled. Then those Wolves of whom the Apostle did forewarn,3 came into the Church and ceased not to destroy the flock. Then those Antichrists, whereof John affirmeth some were in his time,4 began to undertake the work, which after was perfected and accomplished: I might here show you many evident tokens of your Churches Apostasy, out of these your own Chronicles: they are no secrets, but such as any man that will read and observe, may easily discern.
so the Romane Church in processe of ⟨p. 173⟩time declined from her auncient estate, and by the infection of error and superstition daily preuailing, at length shee lost the very spirit and life of the Church. Eusebius reporteth, that one Polycrates Bishop of Ephesus, had written of the Church, that she was, whilest the Apostles liued, a chaste and vndefiled Virgin. For then they that would haue altered the holy paterne of sound doctrine, did it faintly and fearefully, not daring to creepe out of their holes.d But after that the Apostles departed vnto the heauenly mansions, and none of that age left, that had been hearers of Christ himselfe, neither any of the Apostles liuing, then began abhominable error to gather strength, and openly in the Churches to aduaunce it selfe. What more pregnant testimonie of antiquitie and historie can you desire? Whilest the Apostles liued the Church was a Virgin, assoone as they were dead, she became corrupted, and the mischiefe no doubt in time increased and spread it selfe ⟨p. 174⟩abroade. But I woonder that thise Polycrates, was either so ignorant or forgetfull that hee considered not this, that the Pope of Rome was left vnto the Church, in the Apostles roomes, to defend this Virgin, and preserue her chastitie. Why calleth hee the Church a Virgin? Because the Apostles were liuing, by whom her audacious aduersaries were alwaies discouraged and discomforted. But either in this respect the Church now wanteth a Pope, or else shee needes him not at all. But Polycrates, although there were none left to preserue the puritie of this Virgin, bewaileth her want as you see, which surely had been vnaduifedly done, if his opinion had been, that this charge belonged to the Bishop of Rome. The Church then from the Apostles time began to decline, and inclined to the apostasie, which the Apostle did foretell should be, and we see now fulfilled. Then those Wolues of whom the Apostle did forewarne,3 came into the Church and ceased not to destroy the flocke. Then those Antichrists, whereof Iohn affirmeth some were in his time,4 began to vndertake the worke, which after was perfected and accomplished: I might heere shew you many euident tokens of your Churches Apostasie, out of these your owne Chronicles: they are no secrets, but such as any man that will reade and obserue, may easilie discerne.
dDVR. O horrible fact! ó intolerable wickedness! with what face can you thus speak, if you remember how Christ promised his spouse perpetual preservation? Hose. 2.20. Isa, 59.21. Psal. 131.17. and such like WHIT pag. 4•8. If your arguments were as great as your outeries, who could deal with you? That the Church may be corrupted, see these places Matth. 13.25. 1. Cor. 5.6. 2. Cor. 11.3. Isay. 1.21. Gal. 1.6. and 2.1. Further what have I else spoken that Eusebius lib. 3. cap. 32. and Nicephorus lib. 3. cap. 7. & 10. have not before time written? And when I writ these things, I remembered well those promises and many other of that kind. But I know that they belong to the Church of the elect, and hinder not, but that particular Churches may be corrupted by error and false doctrine. DVR. Eusebius doth not anouch these from Polycrates, but from Hegesippus, who called the Church a Virgin, because heretics as yet had not openly opposed her, and corrupted the seats of the Apostles: and did not say that she was corrupted after them. WHIT. pag. 490. The matter is not great which of them spake the words, for whosoever shall wergh the words, shall see that the sense of them is as I have said. And if the Church was ever to remain a chaste and pure Virgin, how foolish should that Hegesippus be in affirming that hitherto she remained a Virgin, or what may his meaning be else then that the Apostles being dead, she began to be corrupted, which the words following prove, when that age was overpassed; then she began to be corrupted with impious error? Yea and when you say that as yet heretics had not assaulted her, nor invaded the tents of the Apostles, either you say nothing, or you grant that after the Apostles time, they did assault her, and prevail against her.DVR. O horrible fact! ó intolerable vvickednes! vvith vvhat face can you thus speak, if you remember hovv Christ promised his spouse perpetuall preseruation? Hose. 2.20. Isa, 59.21. Psal. 131.17. and such like WHIT pag. 48. If your arguments vvere as great as your outeries, vvho could deale vvith you? That the Church may be corrupted, see these places
And since you call us unto Histories,f I will put ⟨p. 175⟩you in mind of one thing related in an ancient story, consider it well whether it touch your Pope, or no, and then answer fully concerning the whole matter. A Council was assembled in Africa, of 217.2 Bishops; whereof Augustine himself was one, the glory and star of Africa: I will set down the story briefly. Zozimus Bishop of Rome sent thither his Legates, which should persuade the Fathers of Africa, that appeals might be made to the Bishop of Rome from all other Bishops. The Legates make relation hereof unto the Fathers, and withal produce a Canon of the Council of Nice, wherein the privilege was recorded: the Fathers wonder at this new decree, and answer the Legates that they never saw any such Canon in any copy Greek or Latin, and that, as they thought, the true and perfect copy of that Council remained with them, which Cecilianus Bishop of Carthage, which was himself present at that Council, had brought into Africa; notwithstanding they determine to send to Constantinople, Alexandria, and Antioch, such as might receive the true and natural copies, from the Bishops of those cities. The Popes Legates would fain have stayed them from sending, but could not. Cyril Bishop of Alexandria, and Atticus of Constantinople deliver unto the messengers the copies with letters to the Fathers of Afric, wherein they do avouch that those copies were most true and sincere.3 Then at length the forgery appeareth in the Canon of the Council of Nice no such thing can be found: so they writ to Celestine then Pope, and command him to surcease from making any such claim ever after ⟨p. 176⟩and not to send abroad his Collectors, lest thereby they may seem to bring the presumptuous smoky pride of the world into the Church of Christ. The Pope for the time yielded not voluntarily, but perforce: for an hundred years after Boniface the second in an Epistle unto Eulalius inveigheth bitterly against Aurelius Bishop of Carthage, which was now President of the African Council, and affirmeth that he and his fellows, whereof Augustine was the chief, were all moved by the devil to withstand the Church of Rome; thus Pope Boniface censureth as schismatics, Aurelius of Carthage, & other the African Bishops, yea and Augustine himself among the rest, because they resisted the Bishop of Rome in that matter:
And since you call vs vnto Histories,f I will put ⟨p. 175⟩you in mind of one thing related in an auncient storie, consider it well whether it touch your Pope, or no, and then answere fully concerning the whole matter. A Councell was assembled in Africke, of 217.2 Bishops; whereof Augustine himselfe was one, the glorie and starre of Africke: I will set downe the story briefly. Zozimus Bishop of Rome sent thither his Legates, which should perswade the Fathers of Africke, that appeales might be made to the Bishop of Rome from all other Bishops. The Legates make relation hereof vnto the Fathers, and withall produce a Canon of the Councell of Nice, wherein the priuiledge was recorded: the Fathers wonder at this new decree, and answere the Legates that they neuer saw any such Canon in any copie Greeke or Latin, and that, as they thought, the true and perfect copie of that Councell remained with them, which Cecilianus Bishop of Carthage, which was himselfe present at that Councell, had brought into Africke; notwithstāding they determine to send to Constantinople, Alexandria, and Antioch, such as might receiue the true and naturall copies, from the Bishops of those cities. The Popes Legates would faine haue stayed them from sending, but could not. Cyrill Bishop of Alexandria, and Atticus of Constantinople deliuer vnto the messengers the copies with letters to the Fathers of Africk, wherin they do auouch that those copies were most true and sincere.3 Then at length the forgery appeareth in the Canon of the Councell of Nice no such thing can be found: so they writ to Celestine then Pope, and command him to surcease from making any such claime euer after ⟨p. 176⟩and not to send abroad his Collectors, lest thereby they may seeme to bring the presumptuous smokie pride of the world into the Church of Christ. The Pope for the time yeelded not voluntarily, but perforce: for an hundred yeeres after Boniface the second in an Epistle vnto Eulalius inueigheth bitterly against Aurelius Bishop of Carthage, which was now President of the African Councell, and affirmeth that hee and his fellowes, whereof Augustine was the chiefe, were all moued by the deuill to withstand the Church of Rome; thus Pope Boniface censureth as schismatikes, Aurelius of Carthage, & other the African Bishops, yea and Augustine himselfe among the rest, because they resisted the Bishop of Rome in that matter:
fDVR. Two things here are, of which you would persuade the Reader, one that the Fathers of the Councell allowed not that which the Pope affected by his Legates: another that the Legates did maliciously produce a forged Canon. What would you do if you could find any thing of weight in any story against us? WHIT pag. 494. They are the things indeed wherein I would instruct the Reader, and what can any story afford us more solid and perspicuous, for whether you respect the a•• bition and fraud not used in former times by the Bishops of Rome, or the authority of the Councell, or that famous sentence given against the Bishops of Rome, there is no man so ignorant and unexperienced, but he will confess that they enacted and decreed a great matter, and of no small importance.DVR. Two things here are, of which you would persvvade the Reader, one that the Fathers of the Councell allovved not that vvhich the Pope affected by his Legates: another that the Legates did malitiously produce a forged Canon. What vvould you doe if you could find any thing of vvaight in any storie against vs? WHIT pag. 494. They are the things indeed wherein I would instruct the Reader, and what can any storie afford vs more solide and perspicuous, for whether you respect the a•• bition and fraud not vsed in former times by the Bishops of Rome, or the authority of the Councell, or that famous sentence giuen against the Bishops of Rome, there is no man so ignorant and vnexperienced, but he will confesse that they enacted and decreed a great matter, and of no smale importance.
as for Eulalius then Bishop of Carthage, he giveth him great thanks because he made friendship with the Church of Rome, that is he willingly permitted the immediate power of the Bishop of Rome over the Church of Africa. These things I have related out of their truest records, and of this kind I could rehearse many more, so little cause have you to promise your self much help out of History.
as for Eulalius then Bishop of Carthage, he giueth him great thankes because he made friendship with the Church of Rome, that is he willingly permitted the immediate power of the Bishop of Rome ouer the Church of Africke. These things I haue related out of their truest records, and of this kind I could rehearse many more, so little cause haue you to promise your selfe much helpe out of Historie.
Hence may be perceived what the purpose and endeavour of the Bishops of Rome have bin these many years, viz. to make themselves Lords of all Churches, which also at length they obtained. But because you ask the question and desire answer, when Rome lost her faith so much commended, and what that, which once was; ceased to be? I may truly affirm that though in many things she had made shipwreck of faith before, yet then did it begin to be the seat of Antichrist, when Phocas the murderer granted unto Boniface the third, that the Church of Rome should be head of all Churches, and the Bishop of Rome should be called Universal Bishop. I will not too curiously search into the moments of times, a mischief creepeth privily, for a time unespied ⟨p. 177⟩of men. But the common opinion which men conceived of those times was, that Gregory the great was the last good, and the first ill Bishop of Rome. He was no better then he should be, and all that succeeded him were stark nought, every one striving to go beyond his predecessor in all lewdness: so that, now a sink of all wickedness hath violently burst into the Church, and hath possessed all the parts thereof. You force me, Campian, to open the sores of your Church, which I had rather not touch, but you are so unreasonable, that you neither spare us nor your selves. Barnard, who was the only religious man, your Church had for many years, how often, and how grievously, doth he bewail, the most desperate estate of your Church?g A shameful contagion sprea•••h over the body of the whole Church: 2the servants of Christ serve Antichrist. From the sole of the foot to the crown of the head nothing is sound. With these and the like speeches used Bernard to bewail and complain of the intolerable wickedness of your Church, which he would never have done without sufficient reason, moving thereunto.3 Aeneas Syluius, afterwards Pope, writeth that charity was waxed cold, and faith utterly gone, and what manner of Church shall we judge this to have been, when she had lost both faith and charity? But it may be you will say that he wrote this of malice unto the Church, and that after he changing his opinion, when of Aeneas he was made Pius, for that was ever his usual speech. Cast away Aeneas & take Pius.
Hence may bee perceiued what the purpose and endeuour of the Bishops of Rome haue bin these many yeares, viz. to make themselues Lords of all Churches, which also at length they obtained. But because you aske the question and desire answere, when Rome lost her faith so much commended, and what that, which once was; ceased to be? I may truly affirme that though in many things she had made shipwracke of faith before, yet thē did it begin to be the seate of Antichrist, when Phocas the murderer granted vnto Boniface the third, that the Church of Rome should be head of all Churches, and the Bishop of Rome should be called Vniuersall Bishop. I will not too curiously search into the moments of times, a mischiefe creepeth priuily, for a time vnespied ⟨p. 177⟩of men. But the common opinion which men conceiued of those times was, that Gregory the great was the last good, and the first ill Bishop of Rome. He was no better then he should be, and all that succeeded him were starke nought, euery one striuing to goe beyond his predecessor in all lewdnes: so that, now a sincke of all wickednes hath violently burst into the Church, and hath possessed all the parts therof. You force me, Campian, to open the sores of your Church, which I had rather not touch, but you are so vnreasonable, yt you neither spare vs nor your selues. Barnard, who was the only religious man, your Church had for many yeares, how often, and how grieuously, doth he bewaile, the most desperat estace of your Church?g A shamefull contagion sprea•••h ouer the body of the whole Church: 2the seruants of Christ serue Antichrist. From the sole of the foote to the crowne of the head nothing is sound. With these and the like speeches vsed Bernard to bewaile and complaine of the intolerable wickednes of your Church, which he would neuer haue done without sufficient reason, mouing thereunto.3 Aeneas Syluius, afterwards Pope, writeth that charity was waxed cold, and faith vtterly gone, and what manner of Church shall we iudge this to haue been, when shee had lost both faith and charity? But it may be you will say that he wrote this of malice vnto the Church, and that after hee changing his opinion, when of Aeneas he was made Pius, for that was euer his vsuall speech. Cast away Aeneas & take Pius.
gDVR. Bernard speaketh not of the doctrine of the Church, but of the manners of the wicked. and in the Church the evil men were ever mixed among the good. WHIT. pag. 504. I wonder what was in your mind, when you confess that the manners of your predecessors were such, as he describeth both heere, and ad Eugen. lib. 4. Amongst these you being their Pastor, walk decked with much precious apparel. If I durst speaze it; these are rather pa••ors for devils then for Christs sheep, Your Court usually receiveth good men, but maketh sew good. There the wicked are not made better, but the good far worse. A number of such places I could allege out of him, neither bewaileth l•ethe mixture of the bad, as you say, but the perishing of the good, and the ru•ne of the Church.DVR. Bernard speaketh not of the doctrine of the Church, but of the manners of the vvicked. and in the Church the euill men were euer mixed among the good. WHIT. pag. 504. I wonder vvhat was in your mind, when you confesse that the manners of your predecessors were such, as he describeth both heere, and ad Eugen. lib. 4. Amongst these you being their Pastor, vvalke decked vvith much pretious apparell. If I durst speaze it; these are rather pa••ors for diuels then for Christs sheepe, Your Court vsually receiueth good men, but maketh sevv good. There the vvicked are not made better, but the good farre worse. A number of such places I could alledge out of him, neither bewail•th l•ethe mixture of the bad, as you say, but the perishing of the good, and the ru•ne of the Church.
What shall I further recite Petrarch, Mantuan, and other Poets both learned and famous, ⟨p. 178⟩which feared not with Satirical verses to inveigh against the Pope and Cardinals and the whole clergy? all things were then so out of order, that all sins might without controlment both be practised and openly blamed. I need not to seek far, remember what Cornelius Bishop of Bicontine, not many years ago, at the Council of Trent spake openly in the presence and audience of the whole Church: whose witness must needs be strong and effectual against you, though of it self it be little worth. Thus he saith,1 Would to God they had not all with one consent turned from religion to superstition, from faith to infidelity, from Christ to Antichrist, from God to Epicurism. Behold the Marks of your Church, su•••stition, infidelity, Antichrist, Epicure, for all this you are not ashamed to affirm that no History either yours or ours hath bewrayed or testified any such matter. But Campian, the more you defend the integrity of your Church, the more you cause us to manifest the corruptions of it.
What shal I further recite Petrarch, Mantuan, and other Poets both learned and famous, ⟨p. 178⟩which feared not with Satiricall verses to inueigh against the Pope and Cardinals and the whole clergie? all things were then so out of order, that all sinnes might without controul••ent both be practised and openly blamed. I need not to seeke farre, remember what Cornelius Bishop of Bicontine, not many yeares agoe, at the Councell of Trent spake openly in the presence and audience of the whole Church: whose witnes must needs be strong and effectuall against you, though of it selfe it bee little worth. Thus he saith,1 Would to God they had not all with one consent turned from religion to superstition, from faith to infidelity, from Christ to Antichrist, from God to Epicurisme. Behold the Marks of your Church, su•••stition, infidelity, Antichrist, Epicure, for all this you are not ashamed to affirme that no Historie either yours or ours hath bewrayed or testified any such matter. But Campian, the more you defend the integrity of your Church, the more you cause vs to manifest the corruptions of it.
Our adversaries, say you, do grant that the Roman Church was once a holy Church. This we confess, and that then it was holy when Paul published those her worthy praise, which you remember; and yet those praises by you mentioned, do not belong to that Church alone, but were given also to other Churches.1 For what if the faith of the Romans were published in the whole world? this was no proper or peculiar privilege of that Church. Hath not the Apostle written as much of the Church of Thessalonica,2 Your faith to wards God is spread in all places? What if he made mention of the Romans without ceasing? 3so did he also incessantly remember the Thessalonians. 4What though he doubted not but he should come unto the Romans in abundance of the blessing of Christ? 5think you his coming into other Churches was less fruitful?6 What if all Churches saluted the Romans, ⟨p. 179⟩and their obedience was every where spoken of? know you not that all the Saints used to salute one another? or suppose you that other Churches were not as obedient to the Apostles as this? But we grant you, that at this time it was holy: what would you more?7 Then also when Paul preached the Gospel there in his favourable restraint. This also we grant: what more?8 And then also when Peter gathered and governed the Church there, calling it Babylon. We deny not this. And though I can be well content that you call Rome Babylon, for I doubt not, but it is the same of whichh John writes so much in the Revelation, the mother of whoredoms, and abominations of the earth; yet I cannot be so easily persuaded thati Peter ⟨p. 180⟩means Rome in this place; here Campian you are always at a nonplus, & could yet never prove that Peter was at Rome. But you take this for granted, and as already proved; which if any man once deny, then like the Mathematicians, you have done, and can go no further. But why may I not reasonably think, that Peter meaneth that Babylon, which once was the chief City of the Assyrians, in which City certainly were many Jews,11 unto whom Peter was appointed Apostle peculiarly. If I should set down that which I could allege in this cause, I fear I should try your patience too much. In the mean time I allow well your confession that Rome is Babylon, and hereafter, at your leisure, you may declare upon what occasion the name of it was altered.
Our aduersaries, say you, doe grant that the Romane Church was once a holy Church. This we confesle, and that then it was holy when Paul published those her worthie praise, which you remember; and yet those praises by you mentioned, doe not belong to that Church alone, but were giuen also to other Churches.1 For what if the faith of the Romanes were published in the whole world? this was no proper or peculiar priuiledge of that Church. Hath not the Apostle written asmuch of the Church of Thessalonica,2 Your faith to wards God is spread in all places? What if hee made mention of the Romanes without ceasing? 3so did he also incessantly remember the Thessalonians. 4What though he doubted not but hee should come vnto the Romanes in abundance of the blessing of Christ? 5thinke you his comming into other Churches was lesse fruitfull?6 What if all Churches saluted the Romanes, ⟨p. 179⟩and their obedience was euery where spoken of? know you not that all the Saints vsed to salute one another? or suppose you that other Churches were not as obedient to the Apostles as this? But we grant you, that at this time it was holy: what would you more?7 Then also when Paul preached the Gospell there in his fauourable restraint. This also wee grant: what more?8 And then also when Peter gathered and gouerned the Church there, calling it Babylon. We deny not this. And though I can be well content that you call Rome Babylon, for I doubt not, but it is the same of whichh Iohn writes so much in the Reuelation, the mother of whoredomes, and abominations of the earth; yet I cannot be so easily perswaded thati Peter ⟨p. 180⟩
hDVR. Saint John speaketh of Rome when it yet abhorred the saith of Christ, a•d persecuted Christians. WHIT. pag. 512. Nay S. J••n described Rome as it was restored and reedified by Antichrist, for when •e w••teth Apoc. 18.•. who seeth not that this cannot be understood of ancient Rome, but of Rome when it was the habitation of Saints rather then Devils, and the hold of the Spirit of God rather then foul spirits.DVR. Saint Iohn speaketh of Rome vvhen it yet abhorred the saith of Christ, a•d persecuted Christians. WHIT. pag. 512. Nay S. J••n described Rome as it was restored and reedified by Antichrist, for when •e w••teth
Now I hope at length you will rest and be satisfied. Nay, but you proceed still unto the ages that succeeded: Then when Clemens governed the Church: then also, when the Heathen Emperors massacred the Bishops of Rome: Even then I confess, Rome was an excellent Church of Christ. Will this content you? Nay further you say; Then also when Damasus, Siricius, Anastasius, Innocentius executed the Apostolic function. This is not to descend by degrees, but to ⟨p. 181⟩leap; for you hasten too fast from the forenamed to these. But how will you persuade us to yield you thus much; Because Calvin (as you say) frankly confesseth, 1that as yet they had not digressed from the doctrine of the Gospel: Do not you, Campian, catch hold of that which no man will give you, nor be too confident of others liberality? Calvin doth not grant that which you take for granted: therefore you must redeliver it. Calvin in that place answereth to your overworn argument of succession, and she weth that the purpose of the Fathers, when they alleged the succession of Bishops, was not to prove those to be true Churches, where Bishops succeeded one another: but this first they assumed as most certain, that from the beginning of the Church unto the ages, whereof they speak, there was no alteration in religion; and thus they opposed to the new broached errors that doctrine which from the times of the Apostles was still preserved in the Church. Calvin then saith not that they hadk altered nothing in any point of faith, but that the Fathers used this argument of succession only in those cases, wherein it might appear they had innovated and altered nothing. Wherefore as we grant that the Church of Rome in the time of these Bishops was the true Church of Christ; but that they in nothing digressed from the doctrine of the Gospel, that Calvin never confessed, and we constantly deny. To say nothing of the rest. Thusl Syricius swerved from the ⟨p. 182⟩doctrine of the Gospel, when he entangled the Ministers of the word with the snares of enforced continency: and this doubtless was no small digression, but a plain departing from them Apostolic doctrine.5 Now at length you make a stay, and pursue the histories of the Church no further: only you demand, when Rome ceased to be as formerly it had bin; unto which question we have sufficiently answered.
Now I hope at length you will rest and be satisfied. Nay, but you proceed still vnto the ages that succeeded: Then when Clemens gouerned the Church: then also, when the Heathen Emperours massacred the Bishops of Rome: Euen then I confesse, Rome was an excellent Church of Christ. Will this content you? Nay further you say; Then also when Damasus, Siricius, Anastasius, Innocentius executed the Apostolike function. This is not to discend by degrees, but to ⟨p. 181⟩leape; for you hasten too fast from the forenamed to these. But how will you perswade vs to yeeld you thus much; Because Caluin (as you say) frankly confesseth, 1that as yet they had not digressed from the doctrine of the Gospell: Doe not you, Campian, catch hold of that which no man will giue you, nor be too confident of others liberalitie? Caluin doth not grant that which you take for granted: therefore you must redeliuer it. Caluin in that place answereth to your ouerworne argument of succession, and she weth that the purpose of the Fathers, when they alleaged the succession of Bishops, was not to proue those to be true Churches, where Bishops succeeded one another: but this first they assumed as most certaine, that from the beginning of the Church vnto the ages, whereof they speake, there was no alteration in religion; and thus they opposed to the new broched errors that doctrine which from the times of the Apostles was still preserued in the Church. Caluin then saith not that they hadk altered nothing in any point of faith, but that the Fathers vsed this argument of succession onely in those cases, wherein it might appeare they had innouated and altered nothing. Wherefore as we grant that the Church of Rome in the time of these Bishops was the true Church of Christ; but that they in nothing digressed from the doctrine of the Gospell, that Caluin neuer confessed, and wee constantly denie. To say nothing of the rest. Thusl Syricius swarued from the ⟨p. 182⟩doctrine of the Gospell, when he intangled the Ministers of the word with the snares of inforced continencie: and this doubtlesse was no small digression, but a plaine departing frō them Apostolike doctrine.5 Now at length you make a stay, and pursue the histories of the Church no further: only you demaund, when Rome ceased to be as formerly it had bin; vnto which question we haue sufficiently answered.
1I•st. lib. 4. cap. 2. s•ct. 3 & Epist. ad Sad•l.
kDVR. Do you acknowledge it to be the Church of Christ, which swerveth and strayeth from the Apostles doctrine▪ what can be spoken more absurdly. WHIT. pag. 513. You that object absurdity to others are most absurd your self, for w•• not the Church of the lewes even then when it abounded with many errors, the Church of God. The Corinthians and Galatians, when they had many ways declined from the doctrine of the Gospel, yet S. Paul saluted them […] Churches, 1 Cor. 1.2. Gal. 1.2. which he would not have done, if he had not acknowledged them to be Churches for all their errors.DVR. Do you acknowledge it to bee the Church of Christ, vvhich swarueth and strayeth from the Apostles doctrine▪ vvhat can be sp•ken more absurdly. WHIT. pag. 513. You that obiect absurditie to others are most absurde your selfe, for vv•• not the Church of the lewes euen then when it abounded with many errors, the Church of God. The Corinthians and Galathians, when they had many waies declined from the doctrine of the Gospell, yet S. Paul saluted them 〈…〉 Churches, 1 Cor. 1.2. Gal. 1.2. which he would not haue done, if he had not acknowledged them to be Churches for all their errors.
lDVR. This error is common to you and many of your fello•es: for Syricius was not the first, we ha•e a direct Canon of the Councell of Carthage, which numbereth this among the Apostolic traditions, Carthag. 1. Can. 2. so hath Clemen• it in his Epistle to S. James the Lords brother. Amongest the Grecians the custom of the Priests wa• not to keep their wives as wives which they bad before their Priest-bood, Epiphan. hrel. 59. And Hierome against Viilantius vigeth this ancient custom of the Church. WHIT. pag. 514. But your Gratian writeth that Syritius was the first maker of this impious law. The which many Priests before him of their own acccrd embraced single life, yet none was compelled by law against his will: and as for the Councell of Carthage, it was held in the time of this Syricius. And so not before him, for your Clemens you know he is of no worth, but a mere counterfeit. That you report of the Grecians is incredible, when as in the Councell of Nice Paphuntius hindered this law, neither would the Grecians ever endure this snare: Hierome indeed produceth an old custom, but no Apostolic, nor yet perpetual custom.
If you make doubt whether it now be the same it was, you may also if you list doubt whether the sun shine at noon. For this is as clear and without question, as that the present city of Rome, is become unlike the ancient flourishing Romans common wealth. And as he could not find Samnius in Samnius, and the other of whom the Epigram speaketh ⟨p. 183⟩wittily, who found nought of Rome in the middest of Rome. So if you would now in the presentn Romish Church, seek for the ancient Church of Rome, you shall never find it, for she hath now lost, not the life only, but the very colour and appearance of the true Church.
If you make doubt whether it now bee the same it was, you may also if you list doubt whether the sunne shine at noone. For this is as cleere and without question, as that the present citie of Rome, is become vnlike the auncient flourishing Romans common wealth. And as hee could not find Samnius in Samnius, and the other of whom the Epigram speaketh ⟨p. 183⟩wittily, who found nought of Rome in the middest of Rome. So if you would now in the presentn Romish Church, seek for the auncient Church of Rome, you shall neuer find it, for shee hath now lost, not the life only, but the very colour and appearance of the true Church.
nDVR. What impudency is this? there was never heresy that assaulted this Church, of which it carried not the victory. As over the Donatists, Jovinian, Pelagius the Britain and others. WHIT. pag. 521. I contempe your reproaches, and stand to that I have said. The Church of Rome which once flourished is now so oppressed with Antichrist, that besides the outward face, image, countenance of a Church, & a vain pomp, there is nothing else left in it. There is no word but it is corrupted with pestiferous leaved, no Sacrament but polluted with sacrilege and corruption, no discipline but Antichristian: I pass not for your Popes chair; your College of Cardinals, the glory of your Bishops, your Priests, Monks, Temples, riches, nothing move me; I search for a living Church, not bare walls, for a man, not a picture, for a body, not a shadow: as for your criumphes you boast of, they are no more proper to the true Church, then the triumphs of old Rome over Pyrrhus, Hannibal, Perses, Antiochus, are to be esteemed the triumphs of Rome now being. Finally as for Pelagius, he triumphed over the whole Popish kingdom. For did he not teach that grace was inbred in nature? and your Popish crew defendeth the same; who seeth not then Pelagius sitting in your triumphant chariot?DVR. VVhat impudencie is this? there vvas neuer heresie that assaulted this Church, of vvhich it caried not the victorie. As ouer the Donatists, Iouinian, Pelagius the Britaine and others. WHIT. pag. 521. I contempe your reproches, and stand to that I haue saide. The Church of Rome vvhich once flourished is novv so oppressed vvith Antichrist, that besides the outvvard face, image, countenance of a Church, & a vaine pompe, there is nothing else left in it. There is no vvord but it is corrupted vvith pestiferous leaued, no Sacrament but polluted vvith sacriledge and corruption, no discipline but Antichristian: I passe not for your Popes chaire; your Colledge of Cardinals, the glorie of your Bishops, your Priests, Monkes, Temples, riches, nothing moue me; I search for a liuing Church, not bare walles, for a man, not a picture, for a body, not a shadow: as for your criumphes you boast of, they are no more proper to the true Church, then the triumphes of old Rome ouer Pyrrhus, Anniball, Perses, Antiochus, are to be esteemed the triumphes of Rome novv being. Finally as for Pelagius, he triumphed ouer the whole Popish kingdome. For did he not teach that grace was inbred in nature? and your Popish crevv defendeth the same; who seeth not then Pelagius sitting in your triumphant chariot?
Seeing therefore all other things fail you, and also Histories themselves, on which you seemed much to rely, help you nothing, what remaineth but one of these two? either must you yield before the battle, or die in the battle. I wish you would once at length take knowledge of that which Nazianzen writeth. We have learned it to be commendable, aswell to yield unto reason, as with reason to overcome.
Seeing therefore all other things faile you, and also Histories themselues, on which you seemed much to relie, helpe you nothing, what remaineth but one of these two? either must you yeeld before the battaile, or die in the battaile. I wish you would once at length take knowledge of that which Nazianzen writeth. We haue learned it to bee commendable, aswell to yeeld vnto reason, as with reason to ouercome.
When that (most excellent men) I revolve in my mind amongst many heresies wherewith I have to do, certain monstrous opinions of such as are fantastically given; I could not but condemn my self of slothfulness and cowardliness, if making trial thereof, I should be afraid of any mans activity and strength: let him be as eloquent as ye would wish, let him be as much exercised as you would desire, yea let him be one that hath throughly studied all sorts of books, yet must he needs be to seek, both for matter and words also when he shall undertake to maintain those his unpossible propositions as follow: for (if he perhaps will give his consent) we will dispute of God, of Christ, of Man, of sin, of Justice, of Sacraments, and of Manners, I will try whether they dare maintain their opinions, & such sayings, as they, lingering after their own lure, have bruited abroad by their writings. God grant they will acknowledge these their owna axioms:* God is the author and cause of sin, willing, prompting, making, commanding, and working it, and their governing the wicked counsels of naughty men.* The adultery of David, and the treason of the Traitor Judas, was as properly the work of God, as the calling of S. Paul was. This monstrous doctrine, whereof Philip, Melanchthon was once ashamed, yet Martin Luther from whose breast Philip sucked the same, as highly extolleth, as though it had been some heavenly oracle, and therefore matcheth his said scholar in a manner with the Apostle S. Paul. I will ⟨p. 185⟩demand also what mind Luther was of whom the English Calvinists affirm to have been a man sent from God to lighten the Word, when he razed out of the Litany used in the Church this verse, O blessed Trinity, and one God have mercy upon us: then in order I will proceed to the person ofo Christ, & demand of them, what these Paradoxes mean, whereas the Catholic Church holdeth that Christ is the Son of God, and God of God.* Calvin saith that Christ is God of himself, and Beza affirmeth that he was not begotten of the substance of the Father: also be it agreed (saith he) that there are in Christ two unions consisting in one substance, the one of the soul with the flesh, and the other of the Divinity with the humanity. That place of S.c John, I and the Father are one, doth not prove that Christ is God of one substance with God the Father:
WHen that (most excellent men) I reuolue in my mind amongst many heresies wherewith I haue to doe, certaine mōstrous opinions of such as are fantasticallie giuen; I could not but condemne my self of slouthfulnes and cowardlines, if making triall thereof, I should bee afraid of any mans actiuitie and strength: let him be as eloquent as yee would wish, let him be as much exercised as you would desire, yea let him be one that hath throughly studied all sorts of books, yet must he needs be to seeke, both for matter and words also when he shall vndertake to maintaine those his vnpossible propositions as follow: for (if he perhaps will giue his consent) we will dispute of God, of Christ, of Man, of sinne, of Iustice, of Sacraments, and of Manners, I will trie whether they dare maintaine their opinions, & such sayings, as they, lingring after their owne lure, haue bruted abroad by their writings. God graunt they will acknowledge these their ownea axiomes:* God is the author and cause of sinne, willing, prompting, making, commaunding, and working it, and their gouerning the wicked counsels of naughty men.* The adultery of Dauid, and the treason of the Traitor Iudas, was as properly the worke of God, as the calling of S. Paul was. This monstrous doctrine, whereof Philip, Melancthon was once ashamed, yet Martin Luther from whose brest Philip suckt the same, as highly extolleth, as though it had been some heauenly oracle, and therefore matcheth his said scholler in a manner with the Apostle S. Paul. I will ⟨p. 185⟩demaund also what mind Luther was of whom the English Caluinists affirme to haue been a man sent from God to lighten the Word, when hee razed out of the Letany vsed in the Church this verse, O blessed Trinitie, and one God haue mercy vpon vs: then in order I will proceed to the person ofo Christ, & demaund of them, what these Paradoxes meane, whereas the Catholike Church holdeth that Christ is the Son of God, and God of God.* Caluin saith that Christ is God of himselfe, and Beza affirmeth that he was not begotten of the substance of the Father: also be it agreed (saith he) that there are in Christ two vnions consisting in one substance, the one of the soule with the flesh, and the other of the Diuinity with the humanity. That place of S.c
aDe Deo. Cal. Inst. lib. 1. cap. 18. lib 2. cap. 4. lib. 3. cap. 23. & 24. Pet. Mart. in 1. Sam. 2. Methanct. in cap. Rom. 8. Wittem. 1524. Sic docet Luther. in asser. 36. & in resol. asser. 36. & in lib. de ser. arbit. Praesat. in anno Phil. In Apol. Eccl. Ang. Vide Ench. pre. an. 1543De Deo. Cal. Inst. lib. 1. cap. 18. lib 2. cap. 4. lib. 3. cap. 23. & 24. Pet. Mart. in 1. Sam. 2. Methanct. in cap. Rom. 8. VVittem. 1524. Sic docet Luther. in asser. 36. & in resol. asser. 36. & in lib. de ser. arbit. Praesat. in anno Phil. In Apol. Eccl. Ang. Vide Ench. pre. an. 1543
*This is most false, not any one of our men have affirmed that God is the author of sin.This is most false, not any one of our men haue affirmed that God is the author of sinne.
*This is false, we do not so compare together.This is false, we do not so compare togither.
oDe Christ. Inst. lib. 1. c. 13. nu. 23. & 24. Beza in Hess. Beza contra Schmidel. lib. de unit. Hypost. dua. in Christ. not.De Christ. Inst. lib. 1. c. 13. nu. 23. & 24. Beza in Hess. Beza contra Schmidel. lib. de vnit. Hypost. dua. in Christ. nat.
*Christ is Son of the Father, but God of himself.Christ is Son of the Father, but God of himselfe.
yea and my soul (* saithd Luther) cannot brook this word (Homovotin.) Proceed ye forward,e Christ from his infancy was not full of grace, but daily increased in gifts of the mind, as other men usually do, and waxed wiser through experience every day more then other, so that in his childhood he was subject tof ignorance, which is all one as if they should say that Christ was corrupted, with the spot and stain of* original sin. But listen and you shall know more pernicious doctrine then this. Christ when he prayed in the garden, and plentifully sweat both water and blood, trembled through fear, and sensibly feeling of eternal damnation, uttered certain speeches without reason, and without consent of the inward spirit, yea speeches without consideration through the vehemency of his grief: the which speeches as unadvisedly spoken, he quickly corrected. Is there any more such stuff? give diligent ear: Christ, when he cried out with a loud voice, hanging on the Cross, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me, was tormented with the flames of hell fire, he let over-slip* himg desperate speeches, being no otherwise affectioned, then if he should have died an eternal ⟨p. 186⟩death; if they have any worse stuff then this, let them empty their gorge. Christ they say, descended into hell, that is, Christ after he was dead, tasted of the pains of hell, no whith less then the damned souls do, saving that he was to be restored again; for as much as by his corporal death, he could have profited us nothing, it was therefore requisite that hisi soul also should strive with eternal death, and in this manner to tolerate the pain, and pay the ransom of our sins. And lest peradventure any man should suspect, that this escaped Calvin by oversight, the saidk Calvin calleth you all forlorn knaves, if any of you, have debated upon this* comfortable doctrine, oh cursed times! oh cursed days! what miserable doctrine have you bred up?
yea and my soule (* saithd Luther) cannot brooke this word (Homouotin.) Proceed yee forward,e Christ from his infancie was not full of grace, but daily encreased in gifts of the mind, as other men vsually doe, and waxed wiser through experience euery daie more then other, so that in his childhood he was subiect tof ignorance, which is all one as if they should say that Christ was corrupted, with the spot and staine of* originall sinne. But listen and you shall know more pernitious doctrine then this. Christ when he praied in the garden, and plentifully sweat both water and blood, trembled through feare, and sensiblie feeling of eternall damnation, vttered certaine speeches without reason, and without consent of the inward spirit, yea speeches without consideration through the vehemencie of his griefe: the which speeches as vnaduisedly spoken, he quickly corrected. Is there any more such stuff? giue diligēt eare: Christ, whē he cried out with a loud voice, hanging on the Crosse, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me, was tormented with the flames of hell fire, he let ouer-slip* himg desperate speeches, being no otherwise affectioned, then if he should haue died an eternall ⟨p. 186⟩death; if they haue any worse stuffe then this, let them emptie their gorge. Christ they saie, descended into hell, that is, Christ after he was dead, tasted of the paines of hell, nowhith lesse then the damned soules doe, sauing that he was to be restored againe; for as much as by his corporall death, he could haue profited vs nothing, it was therefore requisit that hisi soule also should striue with eternall death, and in this manner to tolerate the paine, and paye the ransome of our sins. And lest peraduenture any man should suspect, that this escaped Caluin by ouersight, the said
*This is false, read the answer.This is false, reade the answere.
fLuth. Loss. Hem. Mela. in Evang. de. 1. post. Epist. Marl. in Matt. 26. Call. in Har. Evan Brentius in Luc. par. 2. Hom. 65. & in Catech. an. 1551. & in Joh. Hom. 54.Luth. Loss. Hem. Mela. in Euang. de. 1. post. Epist. Marl. in Matt. 26. Cal. in Har. Euan Brentius in Luc. par. 2. Hom. 65. & in Catech. an. 1551. & in Ioh. Hom. 54.
*This is false, for all ignorance riseth not from original corruption.This is false, for all ignorance riseth not from originall corruption.
*This is false, neither Birutius nor any of our men ever said so.This is false, neither Birutius nor any of our men euer said so.
gCalvin. in Har. Evang. in eand. sent. Loss. in Matth. 26.Caluin. in Har. Euang. in eand. sent. Loss. in Matth. 26.
hSchmidel. conci. de Pass & c•• ua Dom. Aepinus Come. in Psal. 16.Schmidel. conci. de Pass & c•• ua Dom. Aepinus Com. in Psal. 16.
iCalvin. Instit lib. 2. cap. 16. Burn. in Catechis. 1551.
Hath that precious and princely blood, which gushed out of the torn pierced side of that most innocent Lamb Christ Jesus (every little drop of which blood, for the worthiness of the sacrifice, was sufficient to have redeemed a thousand worlds) relieved mankind nothing at all,1 except the man Christ Jesus the mediator between God and man had suffered also the* second death, the death of the soul, the want of grace, which is due only for sin, and detestable blasphemy? In comparison of this madness.3 Bucer shall seem modest, though absolutely he is indeed very impudent in that he taketh this word Infernus in the Creed only to signify Sepulchrum, that is, a grave, by a very over thou art figure Epexegesis, (which is a latter recital, or rather by a foolish and fond figure, which is commonly called Tautologia,) that is an idle and superfluous telling of one•tale often. Of the English sectaries, some are accustomed to hang upon Calvin, whom they make their God, and some to take part with Bucer their great master. Some also mutter in their sleeves against this article, devising with themselves how without causing of an uproar, it may be quite cut out of the Creed, that it molest them no more. That, that also was* attempted in a certain assembly at London, I remember one Richard ⟨p. 187⟩Chenie, a miserable old man, that was amongst them told me, who though he was evilly entreated of thieves abroad, yet did he not repair home into his fathers house. And thus far, as concerning Christ his own person: now what say they of man? marry that thel Image* of God is clean blotted out of a man, so that there is not so much as one spark of goodness remaining in him. His whole nature as touching all the whole faculties of the soul, is so quite altered, that no man not even he that is lately christened, nor any holy virtuous man, is any thing else inwardly, but mere corruption and contagion; but whereto tendeth this? forsooth to no other purpose, but that they who will snatch at heaven, by their only faith, leading their lives in loosest sort, may accuse nature, may despair to attain to virtue, and cast off the burden of the holy Commandments from their backs.
Hath that precious and princely blood, which gushed out of the torne pierced side of that most innocent Lambe Christ Iesus (euery little drop of which blood, for the worthines of the sacrifice, was sufficient to haue redeemed a thousand worlds) reliened mankind nothing at all,1 except the man Christ Iesus the mediator betweene God and man had suffred also the* second death, the death of the soule, the want of grace, which is due only for sinne, and detestable blasphemie? In comparison of this madnes.3 Bucer shall seeme modest, though absolutely he is indeed very impudent in that he taketh this word Infernus in the Creed only to signifie Sepulchrum, that is, a graue, by a very ouer thou art figure Epexegesis, (which is a latter recitall, or rather by a foolish and fond figure, which is commonly called Tautologia,) that is an idle and superfluous telling of one•tale often. Of the English sectaries, some are accustomed to hang vpon Caluin, whom they make their God, and some to take part with Bucer their great master. Some also mutter in their slieues against this article, dewising with themselues how without causing of an vproare, it may be quite cut out of the Creed, that it molest them no more. That, that also was* attempted in a certaine assemblie at London, I remember one Richard ⟨p. 187⟩Chenie, a miserable old man, that was amongst them told mee, who though hee was euilly intreated of theeues abroad, yet did hee not repaire home into his fathers house. And thus farre, as concerning Christ his owne person: now what say they of man? marry that thel Image* of God is cleane blotted out of a mā, so that there is not so much as one spark of goodnes remaining in him. His whole nature as touching all the whole faculties of the soule, is so quite altered, that no man not euen he that is lately christened, nor any holy vertuous man, is any thing else inwardly, but meere corruption and contagion; but whereto tendeth this? forsooth to no other purpose, but that they who will snatch at heauen, by their onlie faith, leading their liues in loosest sort, may accuse nature, may despaire to attaine to vertue, and cast off the burden of the holy Commandements from their backes.
*This is most false, this was never assayed in our Church.This is most false, this was neuer assayed in our Church.
lDe Homine Illyri. in par. lib. de ••t. Pec. col. Inst. lib. 2. ca. 3 Sacer. de cons. ve. Eccl. Aepin. de ••b. & Pecc. Sanct. Rem. contra Cens. Col. De peccato.
To this hathm Illyricus the standard bearer to the Magdeburgeans annexed, that his devilish decree of original sin, which he holdeth to be the most inward substance of mens souls, because (saith he) after the fall of Adam, the very Devil himself doth shape them anew, & transform them into his own substance. This is also an usual saying amongst these abjects, that* all sins are equal; but with this condition, (lest peradventure the Stoics do quicken again▪) that they be weighed in the balance of Gods just judgement: as though God, which is as a most gentle judge, would rather aggravate, then ease our burden; and notwithstanding that he is most righteous, he would yet exaggerate the offence, & make it more then it is in very deed. By this balance a silly poor Taverner that killeth a cock when there is no need, offendeth God no lee, if he give judgment in his fury, then did that vile butcherly fellow being great with child of Beza his doctrine, that secretly with a pistolet most treacherously murdered that great nobleman of France, the Duke of Guise, a Prince of rare virtue, which was the most horrible, & lamentable deed, that ever was dove in any time, within ⟨p. 188⟩the compass of the wide world. But peradventure those men that are set so eagerly in handling of the nature of sin,3 will show themselves great Philosophers in disputing of Gods grace, which will help to heal and cure this malady.n Good offices it seemeth, that they appoint for this grace, the which they impudently cry out to be poured into our harts, or to have sufficient ability, to withstand all sorts of sins: and place it altogether out of our reach, in the only favour of God: which favour (they say)* doth neither amend the wicked, nor purify the corrupted, nor lighten those that be in darkness, nor enrich them that want good works, but only doth hide that old heap of sins still remaining and sticking within us, by Gods winking thereat, to the intent that it be not imputed as deformed and odious in his sight: with which their vain imaginations they are so well pleased, that even* Christ himself, for no other cause in their judgements may be said to be full of grace and truth: but because that God the Father did wonderfully favour him. What manner of thing then is Justice? a certain respective relation:
To this hathm Illyricus the stādard bearer to the Magdeburgeans annexed, that his diuellish decree of originall sinne, which he holdeth to bee the most inward substance of mens soules, because (saith he) after the fall of Adam, the very Diuel himselfe doth shape them anew, & transforme them into his owne substance. This is also an vsuall saying amongst these abiects, that* all sinnes are equall; but with this condition, (lest peraduēture the Stoickes do quicken againe▪) that they be weighed in the ballance of Gods iust iudgement: as though God, which is as a most gentle iudge, would rather aggrauate, then ease our burden; and notwithstanding that he is most righteous, he would yet exaggerate the offence, & make it more then it is in very deed. By this ballāce a silly poore Tauernour that killeth a cock whē there is no need, offēdeth God no lee, if he giue iudgment in his furie, then did that vile butcherly fellow being great with child of Beza his doctrine, that secretly with arpistolet most treacherously murdred that great noblemā of Frāce, the Duk of Guise, a Prince of rare vertue, which was the most horrible, & lamētable deed, that euer was doue in any time, within ⟨p. 188⟩the compasse of the wide world. But peraduenture those men that are set so eagerly in handling of the nature of sinne,3 will shew themselues great Philosophers in disputing of Gods grace, which wil helpe to heale and cure this maladie.n Good offices it seemeth, that they appoint for this grace, the which they impudently crie out to be powred into our harts, or to haue sufficient ability, to withstand all sorts of sinnes: and place it altogeter out of our reach, in the only fauour of God: which fauour (they say)* doth neither amend the wicked, nor purifie the corrupted, nor lighten those that bee in darknes, nor inrich them that want good workes, but only doth hide that old heape of sinnes still remaining and sticking within vs, by Gods wincking thereat, to the intent that it be not imputed as deformed and odious in his sight: with which their vaine imaginations they are so well pleased, that euen* Christ himselfe, for no other cause in their iudgements may be said to be full of grace and truth: but because that God the Father did wonderfully fauour him. What manner of thing then is Iustice? a certaine respectiue relation:
mJllyri. in vari. lib. de peccat. orig. vide Heshis. in Epist. ad Illyr. An peccatū sit substantia. Call. in Antid. Conc. Trid. idem docuerat Wiclef apud Wald. lib. 2. de Sacra. c. 154. De gratia.Jllyri. in vari. lib. de peccat. orig. vide Heshis. in Epist. ad Illyr. An peccatū sit substātia. Cal. in Antid. Conc. Trid. idem docuerat VViclef apud VVald. lib. 2. de Sacra. c. 154. De gratia.
*This is most false, our men ever abhorred this doctrine.This is most false, our men euer abhorred this doctrine.
3De Gratia.
nLuth. in resp. contra Lovan. Bucer. in Joh. 1 Well. in nat. Christi. Brent. hom. 12. in Joh. Cent. lib. 1. cap. 4. De Justitia.Luth. in resp. contra Louan. Bucer. in Ioh. 1 VVel. in nat. Christi. Brent. hom. 12. in Ioh. Cent. lib. 1. cap. 4. De Iustitia.
*This is false, the grace of God begeteth justification, and sanctification followeth justification always, and necessarily.This is false, the grace of God begeteth iustification, and sanctification followeth iustification alwaies, and necessarily.
*This is false, we confess Christ is every way full of grace.This is false, we confesse Christ is euery way full of grace.
not composed of the three Theological virtues, Faith, Hope, and Charity, which do close the soul with their beauty, but only a cloaking of sin, the which whosoever can apprehend by his bare faith, that man is as sure of his salvation, as if he were already in present possession of the endless joys of heaven: but go to, let him dream of this, yet how can he assure himself of future perseverance until his death? whicho gift of perseverance whosoever wanteth; he cometh to most miserable end, though for a season he embraced justice both sincerely and zealously. Nay verily, except this thy faith (saithp Calvin) doth foreshow thee thy perseverance so infallibly, that thou canst not be deceived therein, thou oughtest to account it as a weak and feeble faith. By this point I know him to be Luther's own scholar: for aq Christian man (saith he) though he would, cannot* damn himself, but only by incredulity. I ⟨p. 189⟩will make hast to the sacraments:5 they have lest (O blessed Christ) no Sacrament, I say none, not two, not one; for their breadr is stark poison. Their Baptism, though it be true Baptism, by their judgement is nothing at all: It is not water of salvation, it is not a conduit of grace, and doth not make us partakers of Christs merits, it is but* only a bare sign of salvation. Therefore as concerning the nature of the thing, they esteem Christs Baptism no more then the outward ceremony of Saint John. If thou have it, it is well,* if thou want it, it is no hurt at all: only believe, and thou art sure to be saved before thou be baptized. What then shall we say of silly young Infants, who except they be holpen by the virtue of this Sacrament, can purchase nothing by their own faith? Rather (say the Magdeburgeans) then we will attribute any virtue to the Sacraments of Baptism, let us grant that there is faith in such infants sufficient whereby they may be saved, certain secret motions of which faith they feel in themselves; whereas without doubt, as yet they cannot discern by any sense whether they live or no. A hard case surely for poor Infants: but if this seem so hard, mark what medicines Luther will minister for it.* Better it were, saith he, to omit Baptism altogether, for except the infant believe himself, the washing of him in water is to no purpose at all.
not composed of the three Theologicall vertues, Faith, Hope, and Charitie, which do close the soule with their beautie, but only a cloaking of sinne, the which whosoeuer can apprehend by his bare faith, that man is as sure of his saluation, as if hee were already in present possession of the endlesse ioyes of heauen: but go to, let him dreame of this, yet how can hee assure himself of future perseuerance vntill his death? whicho gift of perseuerance whosoeuer wanteth; he commeth to most miserable end, though for a season hee embraced iustice both sincerely and zealously. Nay verily, except this thy faith (saithp Caluin) doth foreshew thee thy perseuerance so infalliblie, that thou canst not be deceiued therin, thou oughtest to account it as a weake and feeble faith. By this point I know him to be Luthers owne scholler: for aq Christian man (saith he) though he would, cannot* damne himselfe, but only by incredulitie. I ⟨p. 189⟩will make hast to the sacraments:5 they haue lest (O blessed Christ) no Sacrament, I say none, not two, not one; for their breadr is starke poyson. Their Baptisme, though it be true Baptisme, by their iudgement is nothing at all: It is not water of saluation, it is not a conduite of grace, and doth not make vs partakers of Christs merits, it is but* onely a bare signe of saluation. Therefore as concerning the nature of the thing, they esteeme Christs Baptisme no more then the outward ceremonie of Saint Iohn. If thou haue it, it is well,* if thou want it, it is no hurt at all: onely beleeue, and thou art sure to be saued before thou be baptized. What then shall wee say of sillie yong Infants, who except they be holpen by the vertue of this Sacrament, can purchase nothing by their owne faith? Rather (say the Magdeburgeans) then wee will attribute any vertue to the Sacraments of Baptisme, let vs grant that there is faith in such infants sufficient whereby they may be saued, certaine secret motions of which faith they feele in themselues; whereas without doubt, as yet they cannot discerue by any sense whether they liue or no. A hard case surely for poore Infants: but if this seeme so hard, marke what medicines Luther will minister for it.
*Luther speaketh of the grace of Baptism which is not lost by sin.Luther speaketh of the grace of Baptisme which is not lost by sin.
5De Sacramentis.
rCalvin. Instit. lib. 4. cap. 15. Cent. 1. lib. 1 cap. 16. Luth. lib. de cap. Babyl. Cent 2. & 5. cap. 4. Luth. aduer. Gochl. item Epist. ad Melanct. 10.2. & in Epist. ad Wald. Anabaptistas.Caluin. Instit. lib. 4. cap. 15. Cent. 1. lib. 1 cap. 16. Luth. lib. de cap. Babyl. Cent 2. & 5. cap. 4. Luth. aduer. Gochl. item Epist. ad Melanct. 10.2. & in Epist. ad VVald. Anabaptistas.
*This is false, we say not that they are only signs.This is false, we say not that they are only signes.
*This is false, he speaketh not so of Baptism.This is false, he speaketh not so of Baptisme.
*This Luther speaketh upon their supposition, who affirm that children want all faith.This Luther speaketh vpon their supposition, who affirme that children want all faith.
bDVR. We confess every Father may err•, but we deny that all the Fathers of one age did ever fall into any error, which was contrary to faith. WHIT. pag. 412. As if this were not a matter of faith, whether S. Paul lied, or whether he ingenuously reproved S. Peter as he professed he did. For if S. Paul did it dissemblingly, then may it be lawful for us to dissemble, and after confirm it with a lye; both which are contrary to sound doctrine. But particular dissentions you stand not upon, you desire to see some general, when you grant every particular may err, vvill it not follow that all may? But see an example. In the Councell of Constantinople held under Leo the Pope, the Fathers there decreed to abolish Images out of Churches. But the Nicene Councell under Iren. condemned this Canon, yea and by a third Councell held in Germany, this decree was again condemned. One of these certainly must needs be deceived. Again, have you forgotten that Augustine with Innocent the Bishop of Rome, & other Bishops of the Church, did think it necessary that the Eucharist should be given to Infants? which error continued a long time in the Church. Think you these are not points of faith?DVR. VVe confesse euery Father may err•, but we deny that all the Fathers of one age did euer fall into any error, which vvas contrary to faith. WHIT. pag. 412. As if this vvere not a matter of faith, vvhether S. Paul lyed, or vvhether he ingenuously reproued S. Peter as he professed he did. For if S. Paul did it dissemblingly, then may it be lavvfull for vs to dissemble, and after confirme it vvith a lye; both vvhich are contrary to sound doctrine. But particular dissentions you stand not vpon, you desire to see some generall, vvhen you grant euery particular may erre, vvill it not follovv that all may? But see an example. In the Councell of Constantinople held vnder Leo the Pope, the Fathers there decreed to abolish Images out of Churches. But the Nicene Councell vnder Iren. condemned this Canon, yea and by a third Councell held in Germany, this decree vvas againe condemned. One of these certeinly must needs be deceiued. Againe, haue you forgotten that Augustine vvith Innocent the Bishop of Rome, & other Bishops of the Church, did thinke it necessary that the Eucharist should be giuen to Infants? vvhich error continued a long time in the Church. Thinke you these are not points of faith?
that if they haue erred in searching, wee should treade in their steps, and reiect the trueth wee haue found out? For wheresoeuer they find out the truth they sought after, wee receiue it and consent with them.
DVR. If you thinke Christ commanded all, you are greatly deceiued, for hovv should the rude and ignorant search the Scriptures? vvho as Augustine vvitnesseth must be saued, not by sharpnesse of vnderstāding, but by simplicity of beleeuing. Moreouer Christ gaue vnto the people, Pastors and Doctors, and not the bookes of the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 417. Christ verily spake to the people, not to the learned, and if he commanded all the Iewes to search the Scriptures, why not all Christians? but that they ought, is proued by these places, Act. 17.11. Coll. 3.16. Chrysostome vpon that place, Hom. 9. Hierome vpon the same. Origen. in Jsaiam hom. 2. Chrysost. in Euangel. Ioan. hom. 13. Further if the people be ignorant, you take the way to keepe them so. But they verily ought to haue knowledge; and you very learnedly make an argument from their defect. Augustine as you would haue it, doth not maintaine the ignorance of the people, only he requireth not of them any subtile knowledge: all must beleeue, vvhich none can doe vvithout the knovvledge of the Scripture, but the same quicknes of vnderstanding is not required in all. Finally Christ who gaue them teachers, gaue them also the Word; neither vvere the Pastors to teach them any thing, but the Scriptures; vvhy then speake you thus? as if these things ordeined one vnder another vvere contrary: It is vvorthy the obseruing, that in your iudgement Christ gaue not the Scriptures vnto the people; if then they reade them, they meddle vvith other mens right.
eDVR. Who vvill believe that you have found out, that they could not? or who are you that accuse them of ignorance and error? WHIT. pag. 423. I verily acknowledge that the Fathers excelled in all kind of learning, I am so far from accusing them of ignorance. But if the Fathers have often and greatly erred, which you must confess whether you vvill or no: why may not we, who are commanded to read the Scriptures aswvell as they, hold fast the truth we have found, and reject the errors they have delivered? who while they lived, ingenuously confessed themselves ignorant of many things, and that they erred not in a few, and would also do no less if they were alive again.DVR. VVho vvill beleeue that you haue found out, that they could not? or vvho are you that accuse them of ignorance and error? WHIT. pag. 423. I verily acknowledge that the Fathers excelled in all kind of learning, I am so farre from accusing them of ignorance. But if the Fathers haue often and greatly erred, which you must confesse vvhether you vvill or no: vvhy may not vve, vvho are commanded to reade the Scriptures asvvvell as they, hold fast the truth vve haue found, and reiect the errors they haue deliuered? vvho vvhile they liued, ingenuously confessed themselues ignorant of many things, and that they erred not in a fevv, and vvould also doe no lesse if they vvere aliue againe.
Ambrose enueigheth bitterly against them, who thinke it necessary for them, when they would goe to God to vse some mediatours, as men doe in courts of Princes, before they can bee brought to the King himselfe, they must seeke the fauour of some of his neere attendants.
DVR. Jf you had but lightly read ouer Iustine, you would neuer haue been so impudent, for hee altogether alloweth our iudgement, and no vvhere speaketh he of bread and wine giuen to the people. WHIT. pag. 430. If you had read the place, you might haue seene the contrary to your opinion and to all that you say, his owne words shall manifest all. They, who with vs are called Deacons, giue to euery one that is present part of the bread, wine and water, for which thankes are giuen. Can any thing be said more contrary to your, and more manifest for our opinion.
hDVR. Yet Cyprian writ thus Epist. 55. The premacie is given to S. Peter that it might appear there is one Church and one chair. WHIT. pag. 433. They are not Cyprians words, but Pamelius who hath corrupted Cyprian, bringing out of the margin into the text, as appeareth by ancient copies. And Gratian also observed the same, Causa. 24.9.1. loquitur.DVR. Yet Cyprian vvrit thus Epist. 55. The premacie is giuen to S. Peter that it might appeare there is one Church and one chaire. WHIT. pag. 433. They are not Cyprians words, but Pamelius vvho hath corrupted Cyprian, bringing out of the margent into the text, as appeareth by auncient copies. And Gratian also obserued the same, Causa. 24.9.1. loquitur.
5Cyprian. de Simplicitat. praelat. Lib. 1. Epist. 4.
iDVR. Cyprian in this place speaketh not at all touching any appeal. WHIT. pag. 434. If you consider the place well, you shall find that he inveigheth against certain false Bishops, who being condemned by the voices and censures of the Bishops of Africa for just causes, would have the causes pleaded again at Rome before Cornelius the Bishop. And in his discourse. 1. He showed that causes ought to be heard where the crimes are committed. And so not things done in Africa, at Rome. 2. He affirmeth that every Bishop hath his portion of the flock, for which he must give an account. Then not the Bishop of Rome the whole, nor the administration of all causes: finally he calleth them desperate and forlorn men, who thought the authority of the Bishops of Africa to be less then of the Bishops of other countries, and so with reproach he rejecteth the supreme authority of the Bishop of Rome. Is there here any thing less then we have affirmed?DVR. Cyprian in this place speaketh not at all touching any appeale. WHIT. pag. 434. If you consider the place well, you shall find that he inueigheth against certaine false Bishops, who being condemned by the voices and censures of the Bishops of Afrike for iust causes, vvould haue the causes pleaded againe at Rome before Cornelius the Bishop. And in his discourse. 1. He shevved that causes ought to be heard vvhere the crimes are committed. And so not things done in Afrike, at Rome. 2. He affirmeth that euery Bishop hath his portion of the flocke, for which he must giue an account. Then not the Bishop of Rome the vvhole, nor the administration of all causes: finally he calleth them desperate and forlorne men, vvho thought the authority of the Bishops of Afrike to bee lesse then of the Bishops of other countries, and so vvith reproach hee reiecteth the supreame authoritie of the Bishop of Rome. Is there heere any thing lesse then vve haue affirmed?
7Lactan. 2. cap. 19.
kDVR. Lactantius speaketh not of the Images of Christians, but of the Idols of the Heathen, which he condemneth because they are made of the earth: besides the Jeves had their Cherubins. WHIT. pag. 436. He nameth not Idols, but Images, such as your Church is full of, and so can there be no religion in it. Besides your Images are no more heavenly then theirs, but made of the earth as theirs, who pretended for themselves, as he writeth lib. 2. cap. 2. as you do, that they worshipped not the Images, but the God, expressed by them. Further for the Cherubins, they were placed in the most holy place, into which the people might not enter, not yet look in: and show us particular precepts for yours, as they had for theirs, and we have done. But he that commanded theirs, forbiddeth every where all others.DVR. Lactantius speaketh not of the Images of Christians, but of the Idols of the Heathen, vvhich he condemneth because they are made of the earth: besides the Ieves had their Cherubins. WHIT. pag. 436. He nameth not Idols, but Images, such as your Church is full of, and so can there be no religion in it. Besides your Images are no more heauenly then theirs, but made of the earth as theirs, who pretended for themselues, as he vvriteth lib. 2. cap. 2. as you do, that they vvorshipped not the Images, but the God, expressed by them. Further for the Cherubins, they were placed in the most holy place, into vvhich the people might not enter, not yet looke in: and shevv vs particular precepts for yours, as they had for theirs, and vve haue done. But he that commanded theirs, forbiddeth euery vvhere all others.
9Athanas. conts a Gentas.
lDVR. VVill not all your University men account you a cosener, when Athanasius joineth the books of the Fathers with the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 438. If Athanasius, say asmuch as I affirm: The Scriptures are sufficient of themselves, why do you reptoach me? but he addeth the books of the Fathers: he doth, but not as traditions differing from the Scriptures, but as Commentaries upon them. For, saith he, by reading of them a man may in some measure understand the sense of the Scripture. These words make not for you, neither against us, therefore I used neither cozening nor deceit.DVR. VVill not all your Ʋniuersity men account you a cosener, vvhen Athanasius ioyneth the bookes of the Fathers with the Scriptures. WHIT. pag. 438. If Athanasius, say asmuch as I affirme: The Scriptures are sufficient of themselues, vvhy do you reptoach me? but he addeth the bookes of the Fathers: he doth, but not as traditions differing from the Scriptures, but as Commentaries vpon them. For, saith he, by reading of them a man may in some measure vnderstand the sense of the Scripture. These vvords make not for you, neither against vs, therefore I vsed neither cosening nor disceite.
11Epipham. lib. 3. Haeres. 79.
mDVR. Epiphanius speaketh nothing of the adoring of the Saints, but reproveth •omen for offering up sacrifices to the Virgin Mary a• to a G••ld•••e. WHIT. pag. 440. Nay he speaketh against the adoration and honouring of Saints and not of sacrificing only; his words are plain. •et none of the Saints be adored. The word he useth signifieth to bow and prostrate our selves, and to worship one with Divine honour; which being proper to God you impiously give to the Virgin Mary and to other innumerable SaintsDVR. Epiphanius speaketh nothing of the adoring of the Saints, but reproueth •omen for offering vp sacrifices to the Virgin Mary a• to a G••ld•••e. WHIT. pag. 440. Nay he speaketh against the adoration and honoring of Saints and not of sacrificing only; his vvords are plaine. •et none of the Saints be adored. The vvord he vseth signifieth to bovv and prostrate our selues, and to vvorship one vvith Diuine honor; vvhich being proper to God you impiously giue to the Virgin Mary and to other innumerable Saints
nDVR No C•t•o•ike doth offer up sacrifice or perform vows to the Virgin Mary. WHIT. Yet you confess you do such things to the honour of the Virgin and other Saints: I pray you what may be the meaning of this; you offer up sacrifices and vows to God in honour of the Saints? let me demand of you as Epiphanius of these women; what Scriputre •peaketh any thing of this matter? Then answer; your Masses are they offered to the Virgin Mary, or for her? whether soever, Epiphanius saith It is foolish, strange, and that which proceeded from the spirit of Devils Again, who knoweth not that you offer up prayers and intercessions to the Virgin Mary and all Saints? And no man is found either so greatly covetous, or so little superstitious, but he voweth somewhat to some Saint, specially to the Virgin MaryDVR No C•t•o•ike doth offer vp sacrifice or performe vowes to the Virgin Mary. WHIT. Yet you confesse you do such things to the honor of the Virgin and other Saints: I pray you what may be the meaning of this; you offer vp sacrifices and vowes to God in honor of the Saints? let me demaund of you as Epiphanius of these women; what Scriputre •peaketh any thing of this matter? Then answere; your Masses are they offered to the Virgin Mary, or for her? whether soeuer, Epiphanius saith It is foolish, strange, and that vvhich proceeded from the spirit of Diuels Againe, who knoweth not that you offer vp prayers and intercessions to the Virgin Mary and all Saints? And no man is found either so greatly couetous, or so little superst•tious, but he voweth somewhat to some Saint, specially to the Virgin Mary
14Basil. in Epist. ad Cleric Neocaesariae.
oDVR. Basil doth not say it was the custom of all Churches. WHIT. pag. 442. It seemeth you have not read Basil, read the place and you shall find these words there. The c••ome we now keep, is consonant and agreeable to all the Churches of God. And he reckoneth the Churches of Egypt, Africa, Thebes, Palestine, and all who use singing of Psalms.DVR. Basil doth not say it was the custome of all Churches. WHIT. pag. 442. It seemeth you haue not read Basil, reade the place and you shall find these words there. The c••ome we now keepe, is consonant and agreeable to all the Churches of God. And he reckoneth the Churches of Aegypt, Afrike, Thebes, Palestine, and all who vse singing of Psalmes.
pDVR. As if the public prayers of the Church did not profit the people, unless they understand the […]: what a foolish dream is this. WHIT. pag. 443. We had rather dream with the Apostle, then watch with you; for thus S. Paul speaketh 1. Cor. 14 4.5.6. He that speaketh a strange tongue, speaketh not unto men, but unto God, vers. 6. If I come unto you speaking divers tongues, what shall I profit you? Strange tongues then profit not, unless your tongues have some more Divine power then the Apostles tongue had.DVR. As if the publike prayers of the Church did not profit the people, vnlesse they vnderstand the 〈…〉: what a foolish dreame is this. WHIT. pag. 443. We had rather dreame with the Apostle, then watch with you; for thus S. Paul speaketh 1. Cor. 14 4.5.6. He that speaketh a strange tongue, speaketh not vnto men, but vnto God, vers. 6. If I come vnto you speaking diuers tongues, what shall I profit you? Strange tongues then profit not, vnlesse your tongues haue some more Diuine power then the Apostles tongue had.
qDVR. Gregory never thought so, but in the same place he commendeth the solitary life as more excellent then any humane condition; neither speaketh he of the common life of Christians, but of that which is spent in the duties of charity. WHIT. pag. 444. I prove it easily out of his words. Hierome the Philosopher, saith he, proposed unto himself to know whether of our lives was more to be wished for, and more profitable, to the end he might make choice of it. And when he knew that every man was not borne for himself only, but for all others, who bear the same nature with him, he embraced this common life rather then that solitary life. Doth he not now prefer this life? and from the praise he giveth the other, he hath somewhat detracted, when he showeth that it is only for themselves, and so less profitable and fruitful? Finally what is a Christian life, but that which is spent in the duties of charity, for all Christians are bound unto these duties. Then notwithstanding all these, Gregory is still with us.DVR. Gregorie neuer thought so, but in the same place he commendeth the solitary life as more excellent then any humane condition; neither speaketh he of the common life of Christians, but of that vvhich is spent in the duties of charity. WHIT. pag. 444. I proue it easily out of his words. Hierome the Philosopher, saith he, proposed vnto himselfe to know whether of our liues vvas more to be vvished for, and more profitable, to the end he might make choice of it. And when he knew that euery man was not borne for himselfe only, but for all others, who beare the same nature with him, he embraced this common life rather then that solitary life. Doth he not now preferre this life? and from the praise he giueth the other, he hath somewhat detracted, when he sheweth that it is only for themselues, and so lesse profitable and fruitfull? Finally what is a Christian life, but that which is spent in the duties of charity, for all Christians are bound vnto these duties. Then notwithstanding all these, Gregorie is still with vs.
rDVR. Ambrose codemneth suffragators, not intercessors, that is, such as might inform God, what we are, not such as might commend our wants to him. WHIT. pag. 446. As if God did not know as well our wants, without an intercessor, as what we are without a suffragator. If he do, why should the one be allowed more then the other? This new distinction of yours, I think our University men, neither know, not will acknowledge: or what is intercession but a suffragation? or what do you else desire of the Saints, but that they would speak favourably for you to God?DVR. Ambrose codemneth suffragators, not intercessors, that is, such as might informe God, what we are, not such as might commēd our vvants to him. WHIT. pag. 446. As if God did not know as well our wants, without an intercessor, as what we are without a suffragator. If he do, why should the one be allowed more then the other? This new distinction of yours, I thinke our Vniuersity men, neither know, not wil acknowledge: or what is intercessiō but a suffragation? or what do you els desire of the Saints, but that they would speake fauourablie for you to God?
vniuersall Bishop, vndoubtedly was the forerunner of Antichrist? Touching which title there hath been deadly hatred and bloody contentions betwixt the Bishops of Constantinople and Rome. Iohn of Constantinople being a proud man, and very insolent, and ambitious, first challenged this vnto himselfe: Gregory while hee liued earnestly and constantly withstood him.
uDVR. Vigilius meaneth that Christ withdrew from the world the visible presence of his humanity, and not the humane nature himself. WHIT. pag. 453. But the words that follow after show the clean contrary. He therefore is with us, and not with us, because whom he left, and from whom he departed in his humanity, he hath not left, nor forsaken in his Divinity. And again, in lib. 4. contr. Eutych. when he was in the earth, he was not in heaven: and now that he is in heaven, he is not in the earth. And again: he was circumscribed in a place according to his humane nature, and not contained in a place according to his Divinity: this is the Catholic confession and faith, which the Apostles have delivered; the Martyrs have confirmed, and the faithful have kept to this day. If this be the Catholic faith, then are not you Catholics who judge far otherwise of the humanity of Christ.DVR. Vigilius meaneth that Christ withdrevv from the vvorld the visible presence of his humanity, and not the humane nature himselfe. WHIT. pag. 453. But the words that follow after shew the cleane contrary. He therfore is vvith vs, and not vvith vs, because whom he left, and from whom he departed in his humanity, he hath not left, nor forsaken in his Diuinity. And againe, in lib. 4. contr. Eutych. vvhen he vvas in the earth, hee vvas not in heauen: and novv that he is in heauen, hee is not in the earth. And againe: hee vvas circumscribed in a place according to his humane nature, and not conteined in a place according to his Diuinity: this is the Catholike confession and faith, vvhich the Apostles haue deliuered; the Martyrs haue confirmed, and the faithfull haue kept to this day. If this be the Catholike faith, then are not you Catholikes vvho iudge farre othe•vvise of the humanity of Christ.
*DVR. Chrysostom, because he saw many so addicted and given to theatres, stage plays, and impious Interludes, did thus admonish them, lest they should distaste the reading of the Scriptures. WHIT pag. 458. Be it so: have you also no impious places and spectacles and profane exercises? And yet with you any thing is lawful, save reading of the Scriptures. But who so readeth Chrysostom, in Joan. hom. 13. in Epist. ad Coloss. hom. 9. de Lazaro hom. 3. shall find that he required this simply, necessarily, and generally of all men.DVR. Chrysostome, because hee savv many so addicted and giuen to theaters, stage plaies, and impious Interludes, did thus admonish them, lest they should distast the reading of the Scriptures. WHIT pag. 458. Be it so: haue you also no impious places and spectacles and prophane exercises? And yet vvith you any thing is lawfull, saue reading of the Scriptures. But vvho so readeth Chrysostome, in Ioan. hom. 13. in Epist. ad Coloss. hom. 9. de Lazaro hom. 3. shall find that he required this simplie, necessarily, and generally of all men.
7Chrysost ad Coloss. hom. 9. & in Joan. hom. 8.Chrysost ad Coloss. hom. 9. & in Ioan. hom. 8.
8Gregor. lib. 4. Epist. 30. & 34.
xDVR. Gregory condemned John, because he sought for such an authority over all Bishops, as the Emperor had over the Kings, who are subject unto them. WHIT. pag. 460. Whether John of Constantinople sought such a power or no; it is not certain: but no man can be ignorant, how the Pope affecteth it: And long ago hath not only got authority over the Bishops, but hath subdued the Emperor himself: which John of Constantinople never once assayed to do. Gregory telleth us what he meaneth by universal Bishop, he who endeavoureth to bring into subjection to himself all the members of Christ by the title of universal. Whereby he toucheth home your Pope, who subjecteth all the members of Christ to himself as to their head: neither did ever any Emperor rule more tyrannously over his Kings and vassals, then the Pope hath over the Bishops of all Churches.DVR. Gregory condemned Iohn, because he sought for such an authority ouer all Bishops, as the Emperour had ouer the Kings, vvho are subiect vnto them. WHIT. pag. 460. Whether Iohn of Constantinople sought such a povver or no; it is not certaine: but no man can be ignorant, how the Pope affecteth it: And long ago hath not only got authority ouer the Bishops, but hath subdued the Emperour himselfe: which Iohn of Constantin•ple neuer once assayed to do. Gregory telleth vs what he meaneth by vniuersall Bishop, he vvho endeuoureth to bring into subiection to himselfe all the members of Christ by the title of vniuersall. Whereby he toucheth home your Pope, who subiecteth all the members of Christ to himself as to their head: neither did euer any Emperour rule more tyrannously ouer his Kings and vassals, then the Pope hath ouer the Bishops of all Churches.
⟨p. 169⟩
do thrust vpon vs, was 〈…〉 allowed in the Catholike Church; then are all the Historiographers on our part, and the inuasions of the aduersaries are not friuolous, and such as can make no man afraid, except it bee first granted, that all Christians throughout euery age, haue fallen to grosse infidelity and consequently into the deepe pit of hell;
•
•
bDVR. It is not hard to know the heresies of the Jews, for Philastrius, Epiphanius, Josephus, have written of them. WHIT pag. 484. It is as easy to know the heresies of Christians, being more in the Christian Church then ever were in the Church of Jerusalem, and of these also have many books been written.DVR. It is not hard to knovv the heresies of the Ievves, for Philastrius, Epiphanius, Iosephus, haue vvritten of them. WHIT pag. 484. It is as easie to know the heresies of Christians, being more in the Christian Church then euer vvere in the Church of Ierusalem, and of these also haue many bookes been vvritten.
cDVR. You require an easy thing; for the authors of the heresies of the Greek Church, we can easily number out of their stories, Samosatenus, Eutyches, Sergius, Arrius, Nestorius, Macedonius, and such like. WHIT. pag. 486. It is a wonder that you vvill object these heresies unto the Greek Church: when you cannot be ignorant but that moe and more horrible heresies sprung up in the Romish Church, and almost in the middest of Rome: For Valentinus, Marcion, Cerdon, Florentius, Blasius, Tatianus, Novatus, Pelagius, Julianus, Celestinus, and other such did broach most pestiferous heresies in Rome. If you answer the Latin Church condemned these; I can answer so for the Greek Church. And if you think you have objected well in numbering certain heresies of the Greek Church, you may think I have answered aswell in reckoning the heresies of the Latin Church.DVR. You require an easie thing; for the authors of the heresies of the Greeke Church, vve can easily number out of their stories, Samosatenus, Eutyches, Sergius, Arrius, Nestorius, Macedonius, and such like. WHIT. pag. 486. It is a vvonder that you vvill obiect these heresies vnto the Greeke Church: vvhen you cannot bee ignorant but that moe and more horrible heresies sprung vp in the Romish Church, and almost in the middest of Rome: For Valentinus, Marcion, Cerdon, Florentius, Blasius, Tatianus, Nouatus, Pelagius, Julianus, Celestinus, and other such did broach most pestiferous heresies in Rome. If you ansvvere the Latin Church condemned these; I can ansvvere so for the Greeke Church. And if you thinke you haue obiected vvell in numbring certeine heresies of the Greeke Church, you may thinke I haue ansvvered asvvell in reckoning the heresies of the Latin Church.
. Further vvhat haue I else spoken that Eusebius lib. 3. cap. 32. and Nicephorus lib. 3. cap. 7. & 10. haue not before time vvritten? And vvhen I vvrit these things, I remembred vvell those promises and many other of that kind. But I knovv that they belong to the Church of the elect, and hinder not, but that particular Churches may bee corrupted by error and false doctrine. DVR. Eusebius doth not anouch these from Polycrates, but from Hegesippus, vvho called the Church a Virgin, because heretikes as yet had not openly opposed her, and corrupted the seates of the Apostles: and did not say that shee vvas corrupted after them. WHIT. pag. 490. The matter is not great vvhich of them spake the vvords, for vvhosoeuer shall vvergh the vvords, shall see that the sense of them is as I haue said. And if the Church vvas euer to remaine a chast and pure Virgin, hovv foolish should that Hegesippus be in affirming that hitherto she remained a Virgin, or vvhat may his meaning bee else then that the Apostles being dead, she began to be corrupted, vvhich the vvords follovving proue, vvhen that age vvas ouerpassed; then she began to be corrupted vvith impious error? Yea and vvhen you say that as yet heretikes had not assaulted her, nor inuaded the tents of the Apostles, either you say nothing, or you graunt that after the Apostles time, they did assault her, and preuaile against her.
eDVR. Nay rather if he were living he would wonder at your fo•lie, who are either so ignorant or so forgetful, that you observe not, how Polycrates sent letters to Pope Victor touching the new controversy about the celebration of the Passover. WHIT. pag. 492. It seemeth in policy you pass over this place in silence, without answer; and tell us a tale of another different thing, which affordeth us a strong argument against the tyranny of the Pope: for if the most learned and holy Bishops of the Greek Churches, dissented greatly from the Pope in the celebration of Easter, and would not follow the custom of the Pope and Romish Church, though the Pope sought it by all means, who can doubt, but that this supreme power of the Pope over all Churches under Christ as his Vicar, was unknown and unheard of among them?DVR. Nay rather if hee were liuing hee would wonder at your fo•lie, who are either so ignorant or so forgetfull, that you obserue not, hovv Polycrates sent letters to Pope Victor touching the new cōtrouersie about the cele bration of the Passeouer. WHIT. pag. 492. It seemeth in policie you passe ouer this place in silence, without answere; and tel vs a tale of another different thing, which affordeth vs a strong argument against the tyranny of the Pope: for if the most learned and holy Bishops of the Greeke Churches, dissented greatly from the Pope in the celebration of Easter, and would not follow the custome of the Pope and Romish Church, though the Pope sought it by all meanes, who can doubt, but that this supreame power of the Pope ouer all Churches vnder Christ as his Vicar, was vnknowne and vnheard of among them?
3Act. •0.19.
41. Joh. •.18.1. Ioh. •.18.
meanes Rome in this place; here Campian you are alwaies at a nonplus, & could yet neuer pro•ue that Peter was at Rome. But you take this for granted, and as alreadie prooued; which if any man once deny, then like the Mathematicians, you haue done, and can goe no further. But why may I not reasonably think, that Peter meaneth that Babylon, which once was the chiefe Citie of the Assi•ians, in which Citie certeinly were many Iewes,
vnto whom Peter was appointed Apostle peculiarly. If I should set downe that which I could alleage in this cause, I feare I should trie your patience too much. In the meane time I allow well your confession that Rome is Babylon, and hereafter, at your leisure, you may declare vpon what occasion the name of it was altered.
.•. who seeth not that this cannot be vnderstood of auncient Rome, but of Rome when it was the habitation of Saints rather then Diuels, and the hold of the Spirit of God rather then foule spirits.
iDVR. Yet Oecumenius, Hierome, Eusebius. Tertullian, to say nothing of others, do grant it And to make question of Peters being at Rome, is as if you should doubt, whether ever Romulus, Julius Caeser, or Pompey was there. For if Cyprian, Eusebius, Do•o•heus, Epiphanius, Optatus, Hicrom, and many others may not be believed, what shall ever be certain in any History? WHIT pag. 508. All these testimonies prove nothing that I have either doubted of or denied; for I desire authority of Scriptures, not the opinions of men; I desire every man who desireth salvation to weigh this one thing well. That whereas the whole government & Hierarchy of the Papacy hangeth on this foundation, that S. Peter was Bishop of Rome, yet they have no word in the Scriptures to show that he ever was so: and so the whole Papacy is hanged upon the conjectures of men, as upon a rotten thread; for what if many Histories say he was there, if the Scripture say no such thing, what assurance can be of it for matter of faith, the mind must needs be suspicious and doubtful; it is true that the received opinion is that he was there. But who knoweth not that, that which one delivereth at the first, may increase by fame, and be by many reserved to posterity. At the first an ancient writer mentioned S. Peters apposing of Simon Magus and saith it was at Rome, and him have many followed since: and hence from the common rumours and suspicions of men sprung up the Popes chair•. And who shall then give assurance of faith in this thing, when there is no place of Scripture for it, nay when many places are against it. These specially Galat. 2.7.9. Now if S. Peter should be Bishop of Rome & for so many years, it was against both his order of life and his faith. Act. 28.22.23. Now they could not be so ignorant, if that S. Peter for so many years before had governed that Church: S. Paul abode in Rome two years and thence writ many Epistles, and in them spake of many of the brethren, but never once named S. Peter; supole you he would be two years from his Church? Galat. 2.1.2. But he ought rather to have been at Rome, as a good Bishop ought to be with his flock, unless you can prove he might substitute a Vicar. Besides the Histories themselves are in such variety of opinions, that you can hardly tell whom to follow: some say he came •o Rome in the first year of Claudius the Emperor, some in the second, some in the fou•••, and some in the tenth year: and it may be that none of these is true, sure it is all cannot be true.DVR. Yet Oecumenius, Hierome, Eusebius. Tertullian, to say nothing of others, do graunt it And to make question of Peters being at Rome, is as if you should doubt, whether euer Romulus, Iulius Caeser, or Pompeie was there. For if Cyprian, Eusebius, Do•o•heus, Epiphanius, Optatus, Hicrom, and many others may not be beleeued, vvhat shall euer be certeine in any History? WHIT pag. 508. All these testimonies proue nothing that I haue either doubted of or denied; for I desire authority of Scriptures, not the opinions of men; I desire euery man who desireth saluation to weigh this one thing well. That whereas the whole gouernment & Hierarchy of the Papacie hangeth on this soundation, that S. Peter was Bishop of Rome, yet they haue no word in the Scriptures to shew that he euer was so: and so the whole Papacie is hanged vpon the coniectures of men, as vpon a rotten threed; for what if many Histories say he was there, if the Scripture say no such thing, what assurance can be of it for matter of faith, the mind must needs bee suspicious and doubtfull; it is true that the receiued opinion is that hee was there. But who knoweth not that, that which one deliuereth at the first, may increase by fame, and be by many reserued to posterity. At the first an auncient writer mentioned S. Peters apposing of Symon Magus and saith it was at Rome, and him haue many followed since: and hence from the common rumors and suspi•ions of men sprung vp the Popes chair•. And who shall then giue assurance of faith in this thing, when there is no place of Scripture for it, nay when many places are against it. These specially Galat. 2.7.9. Now if S. Peter should be Bishop of Rome & for so many yeares, it vvas against both his order of life and his faith. Act. 28.22.23. Novv they could not be so ignorant, if that S. Peter for so many yeares before had gouerned that Church: S. Paul abode in Rome tvvo yeares and thence writ many Ep•stles, and in them spake of many of the brethren, but neuer once named S. Peter; supole you hee vvould bee tvvo yeares from his Church? Galat. 2.1.2. But he ought rather to haue been at Rome, as a good Bishop ought to be vvith his flocke, vnlesse you can proue he might substitute a Vicar. Besides the Histories themselues are in such •ariety of opinions, that you can hardly tell vvhom to follovv: some say he came •o Rome in the first yeare of Claud•us the Emperour, some in the second, some in the fou, and some in the tenth yeare: and it may be that none of these is true, sure it is all cannot be true.
DVR. This error is common to you and many of your fello•es: for Syricius vvas not the first, vve ha•e a direct Canon of the Councell of Carthage, vvhich numbreth this among the Apostolike tr•ditions, Carthag. 1. Can. 2. so hath Clemen• it in his Epistle to S. Iames the Lords brother. Amongest the Grecians the custome of the Priests wa• not to keepe their wiues as wiues which they bad before their Priest-bood, Epiphan. h••rel. 59. And Hierome against Vi•ilantius vigeth this auncient custome of the Church. WHIT. pag. 514. But your Gratian writeth that Syritius was the first maker of this impious law. The which many Priests before him of their owne acccrd embraced single life, yet none was compelled by law against his will: and as for the Councell of Carthage, it was held in the time of this Syricius. And so not before him, for your Cleme•s you knovv hee is of no vvorth, but a meere counterfeite. That you report of the Grecians is incredible, vvhen as in the Councell of Nice Paphuntius hindred this lavv, neither vvould the Grecians euer endure this snare: Hierome indeed produceth an old custome, but no Apostolike, nor yet perpetuall custome.
mDVR. What Catholic ever said that marriage was evil? S. Paul teacheth us to take beedo of the Manichees and Gnostics, and other heretics of that sort. WHIT. pag. 516. To your question my answer is easy: your Syricius and Innocent when they feared Ministers from marriage, used those reasons which either condemned marriages simply, or else they conclude nothing. For when they thus reason, Priests may not marry, because they must be the temple and the vessel of the Lord, and the Chapel of the holy Ghost, therefore they ought not to give themselves to chambering and uncleanness, because they ought to be holy: because they shall be polluted with carnal concupiscence, and to the unclean all things are unclean: because they who are in the flesh cannot please God. What I pray you is this else but to affirm that marriages are evil, impure, and wicked? Make these then no Catholics, or else your question is answered. To tie S. Paul to those ancient heretics only, is absurd, as if he delivered not a perpetual doctrine for all times: yea and he hath taxed not those only who condemn marriage, but who forbid them, which cannot be denied but your Pope and Church doth.DVR. VVhat Catholike euer said that marriage was euill? S. Paul teacheth vs to take beedo of the Manichies and Gnostikes, and other heretikes of that sort. WHIT. pag. 516. To your question my ansvvere is easie: your Syricius and Innocent vvhen they feared Ministers from marriage, vsed those reasons vvhich either condemned marriages simplie, or els they conclude nothing. For vvhen they thus reason, Priests may not marrie, because they must be the temple and the vessell of the Lord, and the Chappell of the holy Ghost, therefore they ought not to giue themselues to chambering and vncleannes, because they ought to be holy: because they shall bee polluted vvith carnall concupiscence, and to the vncleane all things are vncleane: because they vvho are in the flesh cannot please God. What I pray you is this else but to affirme that marriages are euill, impure, and vvicked? Make these then no Catholikes, or else your question is ansvvered. To tye S. Paul to those auncient heretikes only, is absurde, as if he deliuered not a perpetuall doctrine for all times: yea and he hath taxed not those only vvho condemne marriage, but vvho forbid them, vvhich cannot be denied but your Pope and Church doth.