A SHORT INTRODUCTION TO the Controversy of the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, unfolding the substance of the chiefest questions controversed or not controversed therein between the professors of the Gospel.A SHORT INTRODVCTION TO the Cōtrouersie of the Sacramēt of the Lords Supper, vnfolding the substaunce of the cheifest questions cōtroversed or not controuersed therin b•tweene the professors of the Gospell.
pp. 153–16690 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The objection of Papists for their Transubstantiation drawn out of the words of the Supper.
The obiection of Papists for their Transubstantiation drawne out of the words of the Supper.
The argument holds from the rule of things different; as if a man should say, This is a man, therefore it is not an Ox.
The argument holdes from the rule of thinges different; as if a man should say, This is a man, therfore it is not an Oxe.
We deny that this argument is framed, as you say,1 from the inducing of one special by the removing of the contrary of the same kind: because it is rather a faulty process in argumentation from the inducing of a sacramental respect which is but an Accident, to the displacing and denial of the subject & substance; such as this is, if I should say, This man is a Father; Therefore he is not a man. For so they argue, This bread is the body of Christ therefore it is not bread. There is therefore in this argument a Fallacy of Accident no less absurd the if you should thus conclude This thing is a table therefore it is not wood. For although the body of Christ be not the form or Accident of bread yet the Relation and respect which the bread