¶The Confutation of the second book.¶The Confutation of the second booke.
pp. 250–381543 passagespart 12 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
And where you grant that accidents to be without substance, is against the common course of natural things, but it is done by a spiritual miracle, this is but a cloud to darken the light. For accidents to be without ⟨p. 350⟩substances, is not only against the common course of natural things, but also against the very nature of accidents (which have none other being, but in substances as they be defyned, accidentis esse, estinesse) and is also against all philosophy, reason and working of god sithens the world began. For God never created nor made (with miracle nor without miracle) substances without accidents, nor accidents without substances, as some vaynely phantasy de materia prima. It is against also the doctrine of the old catholic authors, for never none wrote that accidents were without substances, until the Bishop of Rome with his Monks and Fryers defined the contrary.
And where you graunt that accidentes to be without substaunce, is agaynst the common course of naturall thinges, but it is done by a spiritual miracle, this is but a cloud to darken the light. For accidents to be without ⟨p. 350⟩substaunces, is not onely agaynst the cōmon course of natural things, but also against the very nature of accidentes (which haue none other being, but in substaunces as they be defyned, accidentis esse, estinesse) and is also against all philosophy, reason and working of god sithens the world begā. For God neuer created nor made (with miracle nor without miracle) substaunces without accidentes, nor accidents without substaunces, as some vaynely phantasy de materia prima. It is agaynst also the doctrine of the old catholicke authors, for neuer none wrote that accidentes were without substaunces, vntill the Bishop of Rome with his Monkes and Fryers defyned the contrary.
But note well here good reader the end of wit, when it is not staid by §7Gods word, but shooteth at rovers or runneth at large, as it were a young colt without a bridle. That nothing is broken but the accidents, this is denied. Then would I fain learn of this great wise man, (that so well can dissever substances from accidents) what substance it is that is broken? Not the body of Christ, (saith he, for that is whole in every part) nor the bread is not broken (saith he, for our faith teacheth us contrary) then must it be either Christs divinity or soul, that is broken, or else is some other substance there which never man heard of before.