These in a manner be their strongest sort of reasons, howbeit they are very weak. For they which oppose themselves against them, do say, and that truly; 1that A man may find where auricular confession had his beginnings, which seemeth wholly to be from man. In the decrees, in the title De remissione peccatorum & poenitentia, in the chapter Omnis utriusque sexus, there was a law of Innocent the third, which ordained; that As well men as women, if they came to the years of discretion, should confess all their sins, & that even once in the year: and he added; Unto their own priest. Further, let them take upon them a satisfaction: but if so be they shall do otherwise, let them be driven from the church, and let burial be denied them. Further, they show out of Sozomenus, in the sixth book, 16. chapter, that There was a beginning of this confession, by the constitution of bishops, specially of the bishops of the West parts: and they add, that it was taken away by Nectarius. 2These be tokens, that they were devised by man. They add further, that there is no commandment extant thereof in the holy scriptures. For the forgiveness of sins is no judgment of ministers of the church, but only an executing of the benefits of God. Their office they may do, without any acknowledgement of particular sins, either of this person, or of that: a commandment they have to forgive sins, but not to take knowledge of them. Otherwise the whole state of salvation would be made uncertain, no man should be sure of a full confession. Christ saith, 3that All judgement is given unto him: why then will they judge of particular facts, as to ordain certain years, and penance for particular faults; and for deadly sin, seven years penance? So great account they make of their own decrees, as for the breach of them they exclude men out of the church, and consequently from everlasting salvation. God saith in the prophet Isaiah; 4I am he who do forgive sins, and besides me there is none other. Wherefore, seeing this matter is so intricate, and as it were a certain tyranny; it is not free to take the use of it from such men, because some think that they do very well, if they do make themselves subject unto such tyranny.
These in a maner be their strongest sort of reasons, howbeit they are verie weake. For they which oppose themselues against them, doo saie, and that truelie; 1that A man may find where auricular confession had his beginnings, which séemeth wholie to be from man. In the decrées, in the title De remissione peccatorum & poenitentia, in the chapter Omnis vtriusque sexus, there was a lawe of Innocent the third, which ordeined; that As well men as women, if they came to the yéeres of discretion, should confesse all their sinnes, & that euen once in the yéere: and he added; Vnto their owne priest. Further, let them take vpon them a satisfaction: but if so be they shall doo otherwise, let them be driuen from the church, and let buriall be denied them. Further, they shew out of Sozomenus, in the sixt booke, 16. chapter, that There was a beginning of this confession, by the constitution of bishops, speciallie of the bishops of the West parts: and they adde, that it was taken awaie by Nectarius. 2These be tokens, that they were deuised by man. They adde further, that there is no commandement extant thereof in the holie scriptures. For the forgiuenesse of sinnes is no iudgment of ministers of the church, but onelie an executing of the benefits of God. Their office they may doo, without anie acknowledgement of particular sinnes, either of this person, or of that: a commandement they haue to forgiue sinnes, but not to take knowledge of them. Otherwise the whole state of saluation would be made vncerteine, no man should be sure of a full confession. Christ saith, 3that All iudgement is giuen vnto him: whie then will they iudge of particular facts, as to ordeine certeine yéeres, and penance for particular faults; and for deadlie sinne, seuen yéeres penance? So great account they make of their owne decrées, as for the breach of them they exclude men out of the church, and consequentlie from euerlasting saluation. God saith in the prophet Esaie; 4I am he who doo forgiue sinnes, and besides me there is none other. Wherefore, séeing this matter is so intricate, and as it were a certeine tyrannie; it is not frée to take the vse of it from such men, bicause some thinke that they doo verie well, if they doo make themselues subiect vnto such tyrannie.
- 1That auricular confession is an invention of man.That auricular confession is an inuention of man.
- 2That there is no commandment hereof in the scriptures.That there is no commandement hereof in the scriptures.
- 3John. 5. 22.Iohn. 5. 22.
- 4Isaiah. 43, verse 11. & 43.Esaie. 43, verse 11. & 43.