pp. 1406–14831,935 passagespart 21 of 49
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Rid. I have no more to say concerning my explication. If you will give me leave and let me alone, I will but speak a word or two for my confirmation.
Rid. I haue no more to say concerning my explication. If you will geue me leaue and let me alone, I wil but speake a woord or two for my confirmation.
West. Go to: say on.
Fes- There ought no Doctrine to be established in the church of God,1 which dissenteth from the word of God, from the rule of faith, and draweth with it many absurdities, that cannot be avoided.
Fes- THere oughte no Doctrine to bee established in the church of God,1 which discenteth from the word of God, from the rule of faith, and draweth with it many absurdities, that cannot be auoided.
ti- But this doctrine of the first proposition is such.
no. Ergo,1 it ought not to be established and maintained in the Church of God.
The Major or first part of my argument is plain, and the Minor or second part is proved thus.
The Maior or first part of my argument is plaine, and the Minor or second part is prooued thus.
This doctrine maintaineth a real, corporal, and carnal presence of Christs flesh, assumed and taken of the word to be in the Sacrament of the Lords Supper, & that not by virtue & grace only, but also by the whole essence and substance of the body and flesh of Christ.1
This doctrine maintaineth a real, corporal, and carnal presence of Christes flesh, assumed and taken of the woorde to be in the Sacrament of the Lordes Supper, & that not by vertue & grace onely, but also by the whole essence and substance of the body and flesh of Christ.1
But such a presence disagreeth from Gods word, from the rule of faith, and cannot but draw with it many absurdities.
But such a presence disagreeth from Gods word, from the rule of faith, and cannot but drawe wyth it manye absurdities.
Ergo, the second part is true.
The first part of this argument is manifest, and the second may yet further be confirmed thus.
The first part of thys argument is manifest, and the second may yet further be confirmed thus.
West. Thus you consume time, which might be better bestowed on other matters.1 Master Opponent, I pray you to your arguments.
West. Thus you consume time, which might be better bestowed on other matters.1 Maister Opponent, I pray you to your arguments.
Smith. I will here reason with you upon transubstantiation, which you say is contrary to the rule and Analogy of faith. The contrary whereof I prove by the Scriptures and the doctors. But before I enter argumentation with you, I demand first whether in the 6. chap. of John, there be any mention made of the sacrament, or of the real presence of Christ in the sacrament.
Smith. I will heere reason with you vppon transubstantiation, which you say is contrary to the rule and Analogy of faith. The contrary whereof I proue by the Scriptures and the doctors. But before I enter argumentation wyth you, I demaund first whether in the 6. chap. of Iohn, there be any mention made of the sacrament, or of the reall presence of Christ in the sacrament.
Rid. It is against reason that I should be impeached to prosecute that which I have to speak in this assembly, being not so long, but that it may be comprehended in few words.
Rid. It is againste reason that I shoulde bee impeached to prosecute that which I haue to speake in this assembly, being not so long, but that it may be comprehended in few woordes.
West. Let him read on.
West. Let him reade on.
Rid. First of all, this presence is contrary to many places of the holy Scripture. 1Secondly, it varieth from the articles of the faith. Thirdly, it destroyeth and taketh away the institution of the Lords supper. Fourthly, it maketh precious things common to profane and ungodly persons: for it casteth that which is holy unto dogs, and pearls unto swine. Fifthly, it forceth men to maintain many monstrous miracles without necessity and authority of Gods word. Sixthly, it giveth occasion to the heretics which erred concerning the two natures in Christ, to defend their heresies thereby. Seventhly, it falsifieth the sayings of the godly fathers: it falsifieth also the Catholic Faith of the Church, which the Apostles taught, the martyrs confirmed, and the faithful (as one of the Fathers sayeth) do retain and keep until this day. Wherefore the second part of mine argument is true.
Rid. First of all, this presence is contrary to many places of the holy Scripture. 1Secondly, it varieth from the articles of the faith. Thirdly, it destroyeth and taketh awaye the institution of the Lordes supper. Fourthly, it maketh precious thinges common to prophane and vngodly persones: for it casteth that whyche is holy vnto dogs, and pearles vnto swine. Fiftly, it forceth men to maintaine many mōstruous miracles without necessitie and authoritie of Gods worde. Sixtly, it geueth occasion to the heretickes which erred concerning the two natures in Christe, to defend their heresies thereby. Seuenthly, it falsifieth the sayings of the godly fathers: it falsifieth also the Catholike Faith of the Church, whyche the Apostles taught, the martyrs confirmed, and the faithfull (as one of the Fathers sayeth) doe retaine and keepe vntill this day. Wherefore the second parte of mine argument is true.
This carnal presence is contrary to the word of God, as appeareth,1 John. 16. I tell you the trueth. It is profitable to you that I go away, for if I go not away, the comforter shall not come unto you. Acts 3. Whom the heavens must receive until the time of restoring of all things which God hath-spoken. 2Math. 9. The children of the Bridegroom cannot mourn so long as the Bridegroom is with them: But now is the time of mourning. John 16. But I will see you again, and your hearts shall rejoice. 3John 14. I will come again and take you to my self. Math. 24. If they shall say unto you, behold, here is Christ, or there is Christ, believe them not: for wheresoever the dead carcass is, thither the Eagles will resort.
THis carnall presence is contrary to the worde of God, as appeareth,1 Iohn. 16. I tell you the trueth. It is profitable to you that I goe away, for if I goe not away, the comfortour shall not come vnto you. Actes 3. Whome the heauens must receaue vntill the time of restoring of all thinges which God hath-spoken. 2Math. 9. The children of the Bridegrom cannot mourne so long as the Bridegrome is with them: But nowe is the time of mourning. Iohn 16. But I will see you againe, and your heartes shall reioyce. 3
1It varieth from the articles of the faith: He ascended into heaven, and sitteth on the right hand of God the Father. From whence (and not from any other place, sayeth S. Augustine) he shall come to judge both the quick and the dead.
1It varyeth from the articles of the faith: He ascended into heauen, and sitteth on the right hande of God the Father. From whence (and not from any other place, sayeth S. Augustine) he shall come to iudge both the quicke and the deade.
1It destroyeth and taketh away the institution of the Lords supper, which was commanded only to be used and continued until the Lord himself should come. If therefore he be now really present in the body of his flesh, then must the supper cease: For a remembrance is not of a thing present, but of a thing past and absent. And there is a difference between remembrance and presence, and (as one of the Fathers sayeth) A figure is in vain where the thing figured is present.
1It destroyeth and taketh awaye the institution of the Lordes supper, which was commaunded onely to be vsed and continued vntill the Lorde himselfe shoulde come. If therefore he be nowe really present in the body of his flesh, then must the supper cease: For a remembraunce is not of a thing present, but of a thing past and absent. And there is a difference betwene remembraunce and presence, and (as one of the Fathers sayeth) A figure is in vaine where the thing figured is present.
It maketh precious things common to profane and ungodly persons, & constraineth men to confess many absurdities.1 For it affirmeth that whoremongers and murderers, yea and (as some of them hold opinion) the wicked and faithless, mice, rats, & dogs also may receive the very real and corporal body of the Lord, wherein the fullness of the spirit of light and grace dwelleth: contrary to the manifest words of Christ in six places & sentences of the sixth chap. of S. John.
It maketh precious things common to prophane and vngodly persons, & constraineth men to confesse many absurdities.1 For it affirmeth that whoremongers and murtherers, yea and (as some of them hold opinion) the wicked and faithles, mise, rattes, & dogs also may receiue the verye real and corporal body of the Lord, wherin the fulnes of the spirite of light and grace dwelleth: contrary to the manifest wordes of Christ in sixe places & sentences of the sixt chap. of S. Iohn.
It confirmeth also and maintaineth that beastly kind of cruelty of the Anthropophagi, that is, the devourers of mans flesh: for it is a more cruel thing to devour a quick man,1 then to slay him.
It confirmeth also and maintaineth that beastly kinde of crueltie of the Anthropophagi, that is, the deuourers of mans flesh: for it is a more cruel thing to deuoure a quicke man,1 then to slay him.
Pie. He requireth time to speak blasphemies. Leave your blasphemies.
Pie. He requireth time to speake blasphemies. Leaue your blasphemies.
Rid. I had little thought to have had such reproachful words at your hands.
Rid. I had little thought to haue hadde such reprochefull woordes at your handes.
West. All is quiet. Go to the arguments M. Doctor.
West. All is quiet. Goe to the arguments M. Doctor.
Rid. I have not many moe things to say.
Rid. I haue not many moe things to say.
West. You utter blasphemies with a most impudent face: leave off (I say) and get you to the argument.
West. You vtter blasphemies with a most impudent face: leaue off (I say) and get you to the argument.
Rid. It forceth men to maintain many monstrous miracles, without all necessity and authority of Gods word.1 For at the coming of this presence of the body and flesh of Christ, they thrust away the substance of bread, and affirm that the accidents remain without any subject, and in the stead thereof, they place Christs body without his qualities and the true manner of a body. And if the Sacrament be reserved so long until it mould, & worms breed some say that the substance of bread miraculously returneth again, and some deny it.2 Other some affirm that the real body of Christ goeth down into the stomach of the receivers, & doth there abide so long only as they shall continue to be good, but another sort hold that the body of Christ is carried into heaven, so soon as the forms of bread be bruised with the teeth. O works of miracles: Truly & most truly I see that fulfilled in these men, whereof S. Paul prophesied. 2. Thess. 2. Because they have not received the love of the trueth, that they might be saved, God shall send them strong delusions, that they should believe lies, and be all damned which have not believed the truth. This gross presence hath brought forth that fond fantasy of concomitance, whereby is broken at this day and abrogated the commandment of the Lord for the distributing of the Lords cup to the laity. It giveth occasion to heretics to maintain and defend their errors: as to Martion, which said that Christ had but a fantastical body: and to Eutiches which wickedly confounded the two natures in Christ. Finally, it falsifieth the sayings of the godly fathers and the Catholic faith of the church, which Vigilius a Martyr, and grave writer sayeth was taught of the Apostles, confirmed with the blood of Martyrs, and was continually maintained by the faithful, until his time. By the sayings of the fathers, I mean of Justine, Irenee, Tertullian, Origene, Eusebius, Emisene, Athanasius, Cyril, Epyphanius, Hierome, Chrysostom, Augustine, Vigilius, Fulgentius, Bertram, and others most ancient fathers. All those places, as I am sure I have read, making for my purpose, so am I well assumed that I could show the same, if I might have the use of mine own books, which I will take on me to do, even upon the peril of my life, and the loss of all that I may lose in this world.
Rid. It forceth men to maintaine many monstrous myracles, wythout all necessitie and authoritie of Gods worde.
But now (my brethren) think not, because I disallow that presence which this first proposition maintaineth (as a presence which I take to be forged, fantastical, and besides the authority of Gods word, perniciously brought into the Church by the Romanists) that I therefore go about to take away the true presence of Christs body in his Supper rightly and duly ministered,1 which is grounded upon the word of God, and made more plain by the commentaries of the faithful fathers: They that think so of me, the Lord knoweth how far they are deceived. And to make the same evident unto you. I will in few words declare what true presence of Christs body in the sacrament of the Lords supper I hold and affirm with the word of God and the ancient fathers. I say and confess with the Evangelist Luke,2 and with the Apostle Paul, that the bread on the which thanks are given, is the body of Christ in the remembrance of him and of his death, to be set forth perpetually of the faithful until his coming. I say and confess the bread which we break to be the Communion and partaking of Christs body, with the ancient and the faithful fathers. I say and believe that there is not only a signification of Christs body set forth by the sacrament,3 but also that therewith is given to the godly and faithful, the grace of Christs body, that is, the food of life & immortality. And this I hold with Cyprian. I say also with S. Augustine, that we eat life, and we drink life: with Emisene, that we feel the Lord to be present in grace: with Athanasius, that we receive Celestial food, which cometh from above: the property of natural Communion, with Hyllarius: the nature of flesh and benediction which giveth life in bread and wine, with Cyril: and with the same Cyril, the virtue of the very flesh of Christ, life and grace of his body, the property of the only begotten, that is to say, life, as he himself in plain words expoundeth it. I confess also with Basil, that we receive the mystical Advent and coming of Christ, grace, & the virtue of his very nature: the sacrament of his very flesh, with Ambrose: the body by grace, with Epiphanius: spiritual flesh, but not that which was crucified, with Hierome: Grace flowing into a sacrifice, and the grace of the spirit, with Chrysostom:
But now (my brethren) thinke not, because I disalow that presence which this first proposition maintaineth (as a presence which I take to be forged, phantasticall, and besides the authoritie of Gods worde, pernitiously broughte into the Church by the Romanistes) that I therefore go about to take away the true presence of Christes body in his Supper rightly and duely ministred,
grace and invisible verity, grace and society of the members of Christs body, with Augustine. Finally, with Bertram (which was the last of all these) I confess that Christs body is in the Sacrament in this ⟨p. 1444⟩respect:1 namely (as he writeth) because there is in it the spirit of Christ, that is, the power of the word of God, which not only feedeth the soul, but also cleanseth it. Out of these I suppose it may clearly appear unto all men, how far we are from that opinion, whereof some go about falsely to slander us to the world, saying we teach that the godly and faithful should receive nothing else at the Lords table, but a figure of the body of Christ.
grace and inuisible veritie, grace and societie of the members of Christes body, with Augustine. Finally, with Bertram (which was the last of all these) I confesse that Christes body is in the Sacrament in thys ⟨p. 1444⟩respect:1 namely (as he writeth) because there is in it the spirite of Christ, that is, the power of the worde of God, which not onely feedeth the soule, but also clenseth it. Out of these I suppose it may clearely appeare vnto al mē, how farre we are frō that opinion, wherof some go about falsly to slaunder vs to the world, saying we teach that the godly and faithfull shoulde receiue nothing else at the Lordes table, but a figure of the body of Christ.
After the consecration there remaineth no substance of bread and wine, neither any other substance, then the substance of God and man.
After the consecration there remayneth no substaunce of bread and wine, neyther any other substaunce, then the substaunce of God and man.
1THE second conclusion is manifestly false, directly against the word of God, the nature of the Sacrament, and the most evident testimonies of the godly Fathers: and it is the rotten foundation of the other two conclusions propounded by you,2 both of the first, and of the third. I will not therefore now tarry upon any further explication of this answer, being contented with that which is already added afore to the answer of the first proposition.
1THE seconde conclusion is manifestly false, directly against the word of God, the nature of the Sacramente, and the most euident testimonies of the godly Fathers: and it is the rotten foundation of the other two conclusions propounded by you,2 both of the first, and of the third. I will not therefore now tary vpon any further explication of this aunswere, being contented with that which is already added afore to the aunswer of the first proposition.
IT is very plain by the word of God, that Christ did give bread unto his Disciples, and called it his body.
IT is very playne by the worde of God, that Christ did geue bread vnto his Disciples, and called it his body.
Therefore the conclusion is false.
The second part of mine argument is plain, and the first […] proved thus:
The second part of mine argument is playne, and the first 〈…〉 proued thus: