pp. 1406–14831,935 passagespart 23 of 49
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Moreover, in these words [as well as] it may be doubted whether they be spoken in mockage, as men are wont to say in sport of a foolish and ignorant person, that he is apt as well in conditions as in knowledge: being apt in deed in neither of them both.
Moreouer, in these wordes [as well as] it may be doubted whether they be spoken in mockage, as men are wont to say in sport of a foolish and ignoraunt person, that he is apt as well in conditions as in knowledge: being apt in deede in neither of them both.
1There is also a doubt in the world [Propitiable] whether it signify here, that which taketh away sin, or that which may be made available for the taking away of sin: that is to say, whether it is to be taken in the active or in the passive signification.
1There is also a doubt in the world [Propitiable] whether it signifie heere, that which taketh away sinne, or that which may be made auayleable for the taking away of sin: that is to say, whether it is to be taken in the actiue or in the passiue signification.
Now the falseness of the proposition, after the meaning of the Schoolmen and the Romish Church, & impiety in that sense which the words seem to import, is this: that they leaning to the foundation and their fond transubstantiation, would make the quick and lively body of Christs flesh (united and knit to the divinity) to lye hid under the accidents,1 and outward shows of bread and wine. Which is very false, as I have said afore, and they building upon this foundation, do hold that the same body is offered unto God by the Priest in his daily massings to put away the sins of the quick and the dead,2 Whereas by the Apostle to the Hebrews it is evident, that there is but one oblation, and one true and lively sacrifice of the Church offered upon the altar of the cross, which was, is, and shall be for ever the propitiation for the sins of the whole world: and where there is remission of the same, there is (saith the Apostle) no more offering for sin.
Now the falsenes of the proposition, after the meaning of the Schoolemen and the Romishe Church, & impiety in that sense which the wordes seeme to import, is thys: that they leaning to the foundation and their fond trāsubstantiation, would make the quick and liuely body of Christes flesh (vnited and knit to the diuinitie) to lye hid vnder the accidents,1 and outward shewes of bread and wine. Which is very false, as I haue said afore, and they building vpon this foundation, do hold that the same body is offered vnto God by the Priest in his daily massings to put away the sinnes of the quicke and the dead,2 Whereas by the Apostle to the Hebrewes it is euident, that there is but one oblation, and one true and liuely sacrifice of the Church offered vpon the aultar of the crosse, which was, is, and shall be for euer the propitiation for the sinnes of the whole world: and where there is remission of the same, there is (sayth the Apostle) no more offering for sinne.
Ce- No sacrifice ought to be done but where the Priest is meet to offer the same.1 la- All other Priests be unmeet to offer sacrifice propitiatory for sin, save only Christ: rent. Ergo, no other Priests ought to sacrifice for sin, but Christ alone.
Ce- No sacrifice ought to be done but where the Priest is meete to offer the same.1 la- All other Priests be vnmeete to offer sacrifice propitiatory for sinne, saue only Christ: rent. Ergo, no other Priests ought to sacrifice for sinne, but Christ alone.
The second part of my argument is thus proved.
The second part of my argument is thus proued.
Fe- No honour in Gods Church ought to be taken whereunto a man is not called, as Aaron. ri- It is a great honour in Gods Church to sacrifice for sin: 1son. Ergo, No man ought to sacrifice for sin but only they which are called. But only Christ is called to that honour: Ergo, no other priest but Christ ought to sacrifice for sin. That no man is called to this degree of honour but Christ alone,2 it is evident: For there are but two only orders of Priesthood allowed in the word of God: namely, the order of Aaron, and the order of Melchizedek. But now the order of Aaron is come to an end, by reason that it was unprofitable, and weak, and of the order of Melchizedek there is but one Priest alone, even Christ the Lord, which hath a priesthood that can not pass to any other.
Fe- No honour in Gods Church ought to be takē whervnto a man is not called, as Aaron. ri- It is a great honor in Gods Church to sacrifice for sin: 1son. Ergo, No man ought to sacrifice for sinne but onely they which are called. But onely Christ is called to that honour: Ergo, no other priest but Christ ought to sacrifice for sin. That no man is called to this degree of honour but Christ alone,2 it is euident: For there are but two onely orders of Priesthood allowed in the word of God: namely, the order of Aaron, and the order of Melchisedech. But now the order of Aaron is come to an ende, by reason that it was vnprofitable, and weake, and of the order of Melchisedech there is but one Priest alone, euen Christ the Lord, which hath a priesthoode that can not passe to any other.
Another Argument. Ba- That thing is in vain and to no effect, where no necessity is wherefore it is done. ro- To offer up any more sacrifice propitiatory for the quick and the dead, there is no necessity: for Christ our saviour did that fully and perfectly once for all: co. Ergo, to do the same in the Mass, it is in vain.
Another Argument. Ba- That thing is in vaine and to no effect, where no necessitie is wherefore it is done. ro- To offer vp any more sacrifice propitiatory for the quicke and the dead, there is no necessitie: for Christ our sauiour did that fully and perfectly once for all: co. Ergo, to do the same in the Masse, it is in vayne.
1Another Argument. Fe- After that eternal redemption is found and obtained, there needeth no more daily offering for the same:2 ri- But Christ coming an high Bishop, &c. found and obtained for us eternal redemption. o. Ergo, there needeth now no more daily oblation for the sins of the quick and the dead.
1Another Argument. Fe- After that eternall redemption is found and obtained, there needeth no more dayly offering for the same:2 ri- But Christ comming an high Bishop, &c. found and obteined for vs eternall redemption. o. Ergo, there needeth now no more daily oblation for the sinnes of the quicke and the dead.
Another Argument. Ca- All remission of sins cometh only by shedding of blood. mes- In the Mass there is no shedding of blood: tres. Ergo, in the Mass there is no remission of sins: and so it followeth also that there is no propitiatory sacrifice.
Another Argument. Ca- All remission of sinnes commeth only by shedding of bloud. mes- In the Masse there is no shedding of bloud: tres. Ergo, in the Masse there is no remission of sinnes: and so it foloweth also that ther is no propitiatory sacrifice.
Another Argument. In the Mass, the passion of Christ is not in verity, but in a mystery representing the same: yea even there where the Lords supper is duly ministered. But where Christ suffereth not, there is he not offered in verity:1 for the Apostle sayeth: Not that he might offer up himself often times (for then must he have suffered often times sith the beginning of the world) now where Christ is not offered, there is no propitiatory sacrifice: Ergo, in the Mass there is no propitiatory sacrifice: For Christ appeared once in the latter end of the world, to put sin to flight by the offering up of himself. And as it is appointed to all men that they shall once dye, and then cometh the judgement: even so Christ was once offered to take away the sins of many. And unto them that look for him, shall he appear again without sin, unto salvation.
Another Argument. In the Masse, the passion of Christ is not in verity, but in a mistery representing the same: yea euen there where the Lords supper is duly ministred. But where Christ suffereth not, there is he not offered in verity:1 for the Apostle sayeth: Not that he might offer vp himselfe often times (for then must he haue suffered often times sith the beginning of the world) now where Christ is not offered, there is no propitiatory sacrifice: Ergo, in the Masse there is no propitiatory sacrifice: For Christ appeared once in the latter end of the world, to put sin to flight by the offering vp of himselfe. And as it is appoynted to all men that they shall once dye, and then commeth the iudgement: euen so Christ was once offered to take away the sinnes of many. And vnto them that looke for him, shall he appeare agayne without sinne, vnto saluation.
Another Argument. Da- Where there is any sacrifice that can make the comers thereunto perfect, there ought men to cease from offering any moe expiatory and propitiatory sacrifices. ri- But in the new testament there is one only sacrifice now already long since offered, which is able to make the comers thereto perfect for ever. j. Ergo, in the new testament they ought to cease from offering any more propitiatory sacrifice.
Another Argument. Da- Where there is any sacrifice that can make the commers thereunto perfect, there ought men to cease from offering any mo expiatory and propitiatory sacrifices. ri- But in the new testament there is one onely sacrifice now already long since offered, which is able to make the commers thereto perfect for euer. j. Ergo, in the new testament they ought to cease from offering any more propitiatory sacrifice.
BY the which will (saith the Apostle) we are sanctified by the offering up of the body of Jesus Christ once for all. 1And in the same place: But this man after that he had offered one sacrifice for sin, sitteth for ever at the right hand of God, &c. For with one offering hath he made perfect for ever them that are sanctified, and by himself hath he purged our sins. 2I beseech you to mark these words [by himself] the which well weighed, will without doubt cease all controversy.
BY the which will (sayth the Apostle) we are sanctified by the offering vp of the body of Iesus Christ once for all. 1And in the same place: But this man after that he had offered one sacrifice for sinne, sitteth for euer at the right hand of God, &c. For with one offering hath he made perfect for euer them that are sanctifyed, and by himselfe hath he purged our sinnes. 2I beseech you to marke these wordes [by himselfe] the whiche well wayed, will without doubt cease all controuersie.
The Apostle plainly denieth any other sacrifice to remain for him that treadeth under his feet the blood of •e testament by the which he was made holy. Christ will not be crucified again, he will not his death to be […] derision.
The Apostle playnely denieth any other sacrifice to remaine for him that treadeth vnder his feete the bloud of •e testament by the which he was made holy. Christ wil not be crucified againe, he will not his death to be 〈…〉 derision.
If any man sin, we have an advocate with the father, 1Jesus Christ the righteous, and he is the propitiation for our sins, not for ours only, but for the sins of the ••ole world.
If any man sinne, we haue an aduocate with the father, 1Iesus Christ the righteous, and he is the propitia•ion for our sinnes, not for ours only, but for the sinnes of the ••ole world.
I know that all these places of the Scripture are avoided by two manner of subtle shifts:1 the one is by the distinction of the bloody and unbloody sacrifice, as though our unbloody sacrifice of the Church were any other then the sacrifice of praise and thanksgiving, then a commemoration, a showing forth, and a sacramental representation of that one only bloody sacrifice offered up once for all.
I know that all these places of the Scripture are auoyded by two maner of subtile shiftes:1 the one is by the distinction of the bloudy and vnbloudy sacrifice, as though our vnbloudy sacrifice of the Church were any other then the sacrifice of praise and thankesgeuing, then a commemoration, a shewing foorth, and a sacramētall representation of that one only bloudy sacrifice offred vp once for all.
The other is by depraving and wresting the sayings of the ancient Fathers unto such a strange kind of sense,1 as the Fathers themselves in deed never meant. For what the meaning of the Fathers was, it is evident by that which S. Augustine writeth in his Epistle to Boniface, & in the 83. chapter of his 9. book against Faustus, the Manichee, besides many other places, likewise by Eusebius, Emisene, Cyprian, Chrysostom, Fulgentius, Bertram, and others,2 which do wholly concord and agree together in this unity in the Lord, that the redemption once made in verity for the salvation of man, continueth in full effect for ever, and worketh without ceasing unto the end of the world, that the sacrifice once offered can not be consumed: that the Lords death and passion is as effectual, the virtue of that blood, once shed, as fresh at this day for the washing away of sins, as it was even the same day that it flowed out of the blessed side of our saviour: and finally, that the whole substance of our sacrifice which is frequented of the Church, in the Lords Supper,3 consisteth in prayers, praise, and giving of thanks, and in remembering and showing forth of that sacrifice once offered upon the altar of the cross: that the same might continually be had in reverence by mystery, which once only, and no more, was offered for the price of our redemption.
The other is by deprauing and wrasting the sayings of the auncient Fathers vnto such a straunge kinde of sense,1 as the Fathers themselues in deede neuer ment. For what the meaning of the Fathers was, it is euidente by that which S. Augustine writeth in his Epistle to Boniface, & in the 83. chapter of his 9. booke against Faustus, the Manichee, besides many other places, likewise by Eusebius, Emisene, Cyprian, Chrysostome, Fulgentius, Bertram, and others,2 which do wholy concord and agree together in this vnity in the Lord, that the redemption once made in verity for the saluation of man, continueth in full effect for euer, and worketh without ceassing vnto the end of the world, that the sacrifice once offered can not be consumed: that the Lords death and passion is as effectuall, the vertue of that bloud, once shead, as freshe at this day for the washing away of sinnes, as it was euen the same day that it flowed out of the blessed side of our sauiour: and finally, that the whole substance of our sacrifice which is frequented of the Church, in the Lords Supper,
These are the things (right worshipful M. Prolocutor, and ye the rest of the Commissioners) which I could presently prepare to the answering of your three foresaid propositions: being destitute of all help in this shortness of time, sudden warning, and want of books.1 Wherefore I appeal to my first protestation, most humbly desiring the help of the same (as much as may be) to be granted unto me. And because ye have lately given most unjust and cruel sentence against me, I do here appeal (so far forth as I may) to a more indifferent & just censure & judgement of some other superior, competent, & lawful judge, & that according to the approved state of the church of England. Howbeit, I confess that I am ignorant what that is at ⟨p. 1446⟩this present, through the trouble and alteration of the state of the Realm.2 But if this appeal may not be granted to me upon earth, then do I fly (even as to my only refuge and alone haven of health) to the sentence of the eternal judge, that is, of the almighty God, to whose most merciful justice towards his & most just mercifulness, I do wholly commit my self and all my cause, nothing at all despairing of the defence of mine Advocate and alone Saviour, Jesus Christ, to whom, with the everlasting Father, and the holy Spirit, the sanctifier of us all, be now, and for ever, all honour and glory, Amen.
These are the things (right worshipfull M. Prolocutor, and ye the rest of the Commissioners) which I could presently prepare to the aunswering of your three foresayde propositions: being destitute of all helpe in this shortnes of time, sodaine warning, and want of bookes.1 Wherefore I appeale to my first protestation, most humbly desiring the helpe of the same (as much as may be) to be graunted vnto me. And because ye haue lately giuen most vniust and cruell sentence against me, I do heere appeale (so farfoorth as I may) to a more indifferent & iust censure & iudgemēt of some other superiour, competent, & lawful iudge, & that according to the approued state of the church of England. Howbeit, I confesse that I am ignoraunt what that is at ⟨p. 1446⟩
Albeit this learned Bishop was not suffered to read all that is above prefixed before the Disputations, yet because he had it then ready, and offered it up to the Prolocutor after the Disputations & sentence pronounced: I thought here the place not unmeet to annex the same together with the rest. Now let us hear the Arguments and answers between Doctor Smith and him.
Albeit this learned Byshop was not suffered to reade all that is aboue prefixed before the Disputations, yet because he had it then ready, and offered it vp to the Prolocutour after the Disputations & sentence pronounced: I thought heere the place not vnmeete to annexe the same together with the rest. Now let vs heare the Arguments and aunsweres betweene Doctour Smith and him.
Smith. You have occasioned me to go otherwise to work with you, then I had thought to have done. Me seemed you did in your supposition abuse the testimonies of scripture concerning the Ascension of Christ, to take away his presence in the Sacrament, as though this were a strong Argument to enforce your matter withal: 1Christ did ascend unto heaven. Ergo, he is not in the Sacrament. Now therefore I will go about to disprove this reason of yours. Christs Ascension is no let to his real presence in the Sacrament. Ergo, you are deceived, whereas you do ground your self upon those places.
SMith. You haue occasioned me to go otherwise to worke with you, then I had thought to haue done. Me seemed you did in your supposition abuse the testimonies of scripture concerning the Ascension of Christ, to take away hys presence in the Sacrament, as though this were a strong Argument to inforce your matter withall: 1Christ did ascend vnto heauen. Ergo, he is not in the Sacrament. Now therefore I will go about to disproue this reason of yours. Christes Ascension is no let to his reall presence in the Sacrament. Ergo, you are deceiued, whereas you do grounde youre selfe vpon those places.
Rid. You import as though I had made a strong Argument by Christs going up into heaven. But howsoever mine Argument is made,1 you collect it not rightly. For it doth not only stay upon his Ascension, but both upon his Ascension, and his *abiding there also.
Rid. You import as though I had made a strong Argument by Christes going vp into heauen. But howsoeuer mine Argument is made,1 you collect it not rightly. For it doth not only stay vpon his Ascension, but both vpon hys Ascension, and his *abiding there also.
Smith. Christs going up to heaven, and his abiding there, hinder not his real presence in the Sacrament. Ergo, you are deceived.
Smith. Christes going vp to heauen, and his abiding there, hinder not his reall presence in the Sacrament. Ergo, you are deceiued.
Rid. Of Christs real presence there may be a double understanding, if you take the real presence of Christ according to the real and corporal substance which he took of the virgin: that presence being in heaven, can not be on the earth also. But if you mean a real presence, secundum rem aliquam quae ad corpus Christi pertinet. i. according to some thing that appertaineth to Christs body, certes the Ascension and abiding in heaven are no let at all to that presence. Wherefore Christs body after that sort is here present to us in the Lords supper: by grace I say as Epiphanius speaketh it.
Rid. Of Christes reall presence there may be a double vnderstanding, if you take the reall presence of Christ according to the reall and corporal substance which he tooke of the virgine: that presence being in heauen, cā not be on the earth also. But if you meane a reall presence, secūdum rem aliquam quae ad corpus Christi pertinet. i. according to some thing that appertaineth to Christes body, certes the Ascension and abiding in heauen are no let at all to that presence. Wherefore Christes body after that sort is heere present to vs in the Lords supper: by grace I say as Epiphanius speaketh it.
West. I will cut off from henceforth all equivocation and doubt. For whensoever we speak of Christs body, we mean that which he took of the Virgin.
West. I will cut off from hencefoorth all equiuocation and doubt. For whensoeuer we speake of Christes body, wee meane that which he tooke of the Uirgin.
Rid. Christs Ascension and abiding in heaven can not stand with this presence.
Rid. Christes Ascension and abiding in heauen can not stand with this presence.
Smith. Christ appeared corporally and really on the earth for all his Ascension and continual abode in heaven unto the day of Dome.1 Ergo, his Ascension and abiding in heaven, is no let to his real presence in the Sacrament.
Smith. Christ appeared corporally and really on the earth for all his Ascension and continuall abode in heauen vnto the day of Dome.1 Ergo, his Ascension and abiding in heauen, is no let to his reall presence in the Sacrament.
Rid. 1Master Doctor, this Argument is nothing worth I do not so straightly tie Christ up in heaven, that he may not come into the earth at his pleasure. For when he will, he may come down from heaven, and be on the earth, as it liketh himself. Howbeit I do affirm that it is not possible for him to be both in heaven and earth at one time.
Rid. 1Maister Doctour, this Argument is nothing worth I do not so straightly tye Christ vp in heauen, that he may not come into the earth at his pleasure. For when he will, he may come downe from heauen, and be on the earth, as it liketh himselfe. Howbeit I do affirme that it is not possible for him to be both in heauen and earth at one tyme.
Smith. Mark I pray you my Masters, diligently that be here, what he answereth. First he saith, that the sitting of Christ at the right hand of his father, is a let to the real presence of his body in the Sacrament: and then afterward he flieth from it again.
Smith. Marke I pray you my Maisters, diligently that be here, what he aunswereth. First he saith, that the sitting of Christ at the right hande of his father, is a let to the reall presence of his body in the Sacrament: and then afterward he flyeth from it agayne.
Rid. I would not have you think that I do imagine or dream upon any such manner of sitting, as these men here sit in the School.
Rid. I woulde not haue you thinke that I do imagine or dreame vpon any such maner of sitting, as these men heere sit in the Schoole.
Smith. Ergo, it is lawful for Christ then to be here present on the earth, when he will himself.
Smith. Ergo, it is lawfull for Christ then to be heere present on the earth, when he will himselfe.
Rid. Yea when he will, it is lawful indeed.
Rid. Yea when he will, it is lawfull indeede.
Smith. Ergo, his ascending into heaven, doth not restrain his real presence in the Sacrament.
Smith. Ergo, his ascending into heauen, doth not restrayne his reall presence in the Sacrament.
Rid. I do not gainsay, but that it is lawful for him to appear on the earth, when he will: but prove you that he will.1
Rid. I do not gaynesay, but that it is lawfull sor hym to appeare on the earth, when he wil: but proue you yt he wil.1
Smith. Then your answer dependeth upon the will of Christ, I perceive, Therefore I will join again with you in this short argument. Christ, albeit he doth alway abide in heaven after his ascension, was seen really and corporally on the earth. Ergo, not withstanding his Ascension and continual sitting at the right hand of the father, he may be really and corporally in the sacrament.
Smith. Then your aunswere dependeth vppon the will of Christ, I perceiue, Therfore I will ioyne agayn with you in this short argument. Christ, albeit hee doth alway abide in heauen after hys ascension, was seene really and corporally on the earth. Ergo, not withstanding his Ascen•ion and continuall sitting at the right hand of the father, hee may be really and corporally in the sacrament.
Rid. If the Notaries should so record your Argument, as you have framed it, you peradventure would be ashamed thereof hereafter.
Ryd. If the Notaries should so recorde your Argument, as you haue framed it, you peraduenture woulde be ashamed thereof hereafter.
Smith. Christ after his Ascension was seen really and corporally upon the earth. Ergo, notwithstanding his Ascension and abiding with his father, he may be corporally in the Sacrament.
Smith. Christ after his Ascention was seen really and corporally vpon the earth. Ergo, notwithstanding his Ascention and abiding with his father, he may be corporally in the Sacrament.
Rid. I grant the antecedent: but I deny the consequent.
Ryd. I graunt the antecedent: but I deny the consequent.