pp. 1406–14831,935 passagespart 35 of 49
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
West. How say you to the sacrifice for the dead.
Lat. I say that it needeth not, or it booteth not.
West. Augustine in his Enchiridion, the 110. chap. sayeth: Non est negandum defunctorum animos pietate suorum viventium relevari, quum pro illis sacrificium Mediatoris offertur: 1That is, We must not deny, that the souls of the dead are relieved by the devotion of their friends which are living,2 when the sacrifice of the Mediator is offered for them. Where he proveth the verity of Christs body, & praying for the dead. And it is said, that the same Augustine said mass for his mother.
West. Augustine in his Enchiridion, the 110. chap. sayeth: Non est negandum defunctorum animos pietate suorum viuentium releuari, quum pro illis sacrificium Mediatoris offertur: 1That is, We must not deny, that the soules of the dead are relieued by the deuotion of their friends which are liuing,2 when the sacrifice of the Mediatour is offered for them. Where he prooueth the veritie of Christes body, & praying for the dead. And it is sayd, that the same Augustine sayd masse for his mother.
Lat. But that mass was not like yours, which thing doth manifestly appear in his writings, which are against it in every place. And Augustine is a reasonable man, he requireth to be believed no further, then he bringeth scripture for his proof, and agreeth with Gods word.
Lat. But that masse was not like yours, which thing doth manifestly appeare in his writings, which are agaynst it in euery place. And Augustine is a reasonable man, he requireth to be beleued no further, then he bringeth scripture for his proofe, and agreeth with Gods word.
West. In the same place he proveth a propitiatory sacrifice and that upon an altar, and no Oyster board.1
West. In the same place he proueth a propiciatorie sacrifice and that vpon an aulter, and no Oyster boord.1
Lat. It is the Lords table, and no Oyster board. It may be called an altar, and so the doctors call it in many places: but there is no propitiatory sacrifice, but only Christ. The doctors might be deceived in some points, though not in all things. * I believe them when they say well.
Lat. It is the Lords table, and no Oyster boord. It may be called an aultar, and so the doctors call it in many places: but there is no propiciatorie sacrifice, but only Christ. The doctors might be deceiued in some points, though not in all things. * I beleeue them when they say well.
Lat. I am of their faith when they say well. I refer my self to my L. of Canterburies book wholly herein.
Lat. I am of their faith when they say well. I referre my selfe to my L. of Caunterburies booke wholy herein.
Smith. Then are you not of Chrysostoms faith, nor of S. Augustine's faith.
Smyth. Then are you not of Chrysostomes faith, nor of S. Augustines fayth.
Lat. I have said, when they said well, and bring scripture for them, I am of their faith, and further Augustine requireth not to be believed.
Lat. I haue said, when they said well, and bring scripture for them, I am of their faith, and further Augustine requireth not to be beleeued.
West. Origen. Hom. 13. upon Leviticus.
West. Origen. Hom. 13. vpon Leuiticus.
Latimer. I have but one word to say, Panis Sacramentalis, ⟨p. 1459⟩the Sacramental bread, is called a Propitiation, because it is a Sacrament of the Propitiation. What is your vocation?
Latimer. I haue but one worde to say, Panis Sacramentalis, ⟨p. 1459⟩the Sacramentall bread, is called a Propitiation, because it is a Sacrament of the Propitiation. What is your vocation?
West. My vocation is at this time to dispute, otherwise I am a Priest, and my vocation is to offer.
West. My vocation is at this tyme to dispute, otherwise I am a Priest, and my vocation is to offer.
Lat. Where have you that authority given you to offer?
Lat. Where haue you that authorttie geuen you to offer?
West. Hoc facite, Do this, for facite in that place is taken for offerte, that is, offer you.
Lat. 1Is Facere nothing but sacrificare to sacrifice? Why then no man must receive the sacrament but priests only: for there may none offer but priests. Ergo, there may none receive but priests.
Lat. 1Is Facere nothing but sacrificare to sacrifice? Why then no man must receiue the sacrament but priestes onely: for there may none offer but priests. Ergo, there may none receiue but priests.
West. Your argument is to be denied.
Lat. 1Did Christ then offer himself at his supper?
Lat. 1Did Christ then offer himselfe at his supper?
Pie. Yea, he offered himself for the whole world.
Pye. Yea, he offred himselfe for the whole world.
Latimer. Then if this word (Facite) Do ye, signify Sacrificate, Sacrifice ye, it followeth, (as I said) that none but Priests only ought to receive the Sacrament, to whom it is only lawful to sacrifice: and where find you that, I pray you?
Latimer. Then if this worde (Facite) Do ye, signifie Sacrificate, Sacrifice ye, it followeth, (as I sayd) that none but Priestes onely ought to receiue the Sacrament, to whom it is onely lawfull to sacrifice: and where find you that, I pray you?
West. Forty year ago, whether could you have gone to have found your doctrine?
West. Fourty yeare agone, whether could you haue gone to haue found your doctrine?
Lat. The more cause we have to thank God, that hath now sent the light into the world.
Lat. The more cause we haue to thanke God, that hath now sent the light into the world.
West. 1The light? Nay lite and lewd Preachers: for you could not tell what you might have: Ye altered & changed so often your communions and altars, and all for this one end, to spoil and rob the Church.
West. 1The light? Nay lite and lewd Preachers: for you could not tell what you might haue: Ye altered & changed so often your communions and altars, and all for this one end, to spoile and rob the Church.
Latimer. These things pertain nothing to me. I must not answer for other mens deeds, but only for mine own.
Latimer. These things pertayne nothyng to mee. I must not aunswere for other mens deedes, but onely for myne owne.
West. Well, M. Latimer, this is our intent, to will you well, and to exhort you to come to your self, and remember that without Noes Ark, there is no health. Remember what they have been that were the beginners of your doctrine, none but a few flying Apostates, running out of Germany for fear of the fagot. Remember what they have been which have set forth the same in this Realm: A sort of flyngbraines and light heads, which were never constant in any one thing, as it was to be seen in the turning of the Table, where like a sort of Apes, they could not tell which way to turn their tails,1 looking one day West, and another day East, one that way, and an other this way. They will be like (they say) to the Apostles, they will have no Churches. A hovel is good enough for them. They come to the Communion with no reverence. They get them a Tankard, and one saith, I drink, and I am thankful:2 the more joy of thee, saith another. And in them was it true that Hillary saith: Annuas & menstruas de deo fides facimus▪ id est, We make every year and every month a faith. A runagate Scot did take away the adoration or worshipping of Christ in the Sacrament: by whose procurement that heresy was put into the last Communion book:3 so much prevailed that one mans authority at that time. You never agreed with the Tygurines or Germans, or with the Church, or with your self. Your stubbornness cometh of a vain glory, which is to no purpose: for it will do you no good when a fagot is in your beard. And we see all by your own confession, how little cause you have to be stubborn, for your learning is in scoffers hold. The Queens grace is merciful, if ye will turn.
West. Well, M. Latimer, this is our entent, to wyll you well, and to exhort you to come to your selfe, and remember that without Noes Arke, there is no health. Remember what they haue bene that were the beginners of your doctrine, none but a few flying Apostataes, runnyng out of Germany for feare of the fagot. Remember what they haue bene which haue set forth the same in this Realme: A sort of flyngbraines and light heads, which were neuer constant in any one thyng, as it was to be seene in the turnyng of the Table, where lyke a sort of Apes, they coulde not tell which way to turne their tailes,
Lat. You shall have no hope in me to turn, I pray for the Queen daily even from the bottom of my hart, that she may turn from this religion.
Lat. You shall haue no hope in me to turne, I pray for the Queene daily euen from the bottome of my hart, that she may turne from this religion.
West. Here you all see the weakness of heresy against the truth: he denieth all truth, and all the old fathers.
West. Here you all see the weakenes of heresie against the truth: he denieth all truth, and all the old fathers.
Here all good Readers may see how this glorious Prolocutor triumpheth: but whether he hath the victory or no, that I suppose they have not yet, neither heard nor seen. And give that he had the victory, yet what great marvel was it, disputing as hee dyd, Non sine suo Theseo: that is, not without his tippling cup standing at his elbow all the time of his disputation, not without a privy noting and smiling of them that beheld the matter, but specially at that time, when Doctor Ridley disputing with one of the Opponents, the said Prolocutor took the cup, and holding it in his hand, said to the Opponent: Urge hoc. urge hoc: Nam hoc facit pro nobis. In which words as he moved no little matter of laughter to the beholders thereof:1 so I thought here also not to leave the same unmentioned, somewhat also to delight the Reader withal, after his tedious weariness in reading the story thereof.
HEre all good Readers maye see how this glorious Prolocutor triumpheth: but whether he hath the victorye or no, that I suppose they haue not yet, neyther heard nor seene. And geue that he had the victory, yet what great meruayle was it, disputyng as hee dyd, Non sine suo Theseo: that is, not without his tipplyng cuppe standing at his elbow all the time of his disputation, notwithout a priuy notyng and smilyng of them that beheld the matter, but specially at that tyme, when Doctour Ridley disputyng with one of the Opponentes, the sayd Prolocutor tooke the cuppe, and holding it in hys hand, sayd to the Opponent: Vrge hoc. vrge hoc: Nam hoc facit pro nobis. In which wordes as he mooued no little matter of laughter to the beholders thereof:1 so I thought here also not to leaue the same vnmentioned, somwhat also to delight the Reader withal, after his tedious wearines in reading the story therof.
And thus hast thou (loving Reader) the whole action and stage of this Doctorly disputation showed forth unto thee, against these three worthy Confessors and Martyrs of the Lord, wherein thou mayest behold the disordered usage of the University men, the unmannerly manner of the School, the rude tumult of the multitude, the fierceness and interruption of the Doctors, the full pith and ground of all their arguments, the censures of the Judges, the railing language of the Oblocutor, with his blast of triumph in the latter end, being both the actor, the moderator, and also Judge himself. And what marvel then if the courage of this victorious Conqueror, having the law in his own hands, to do and say what him li•ted, would say for himself, Vicit veritas, although he said never a true word, nor made never a true conclusion almost in all that disputation.
And thus hast thou (louyng Reader) the whole action and stage of this Doctourly disputation shewed foorth vnto thee, against these three woorthy Confessours and Martyrs of the Lorde, wherein thou mayest behold the disordered vsage of the Uniuersitie men, the vnmannerly manner of the Schoole, the rude tumult of the multitude, the fiercenes and interruption of the Doctors, the full pith and ground of all their argumēts, the censures of the Iudges, the railyng language of the Oblocutor, with his blast of triumph in the latter ende, being both the actor, the moderator, and also Iudge himselfe. And what maruell then if the courage of this victorious Conquerour, hauyng the lawe in his owne handes, to doe and say what him li•ted, would say for himself, Vicit veritas, although he sayd neuer a true word, nor made neuer a true conclusion almost in al that disputation.
It followed furthermore after disputation of these three days being ended, that M. Harpsfield the next day after,1 which was the xix. of April, should dispute for his form, to be made Doctor. To the which disputation the Archb. of Cant. was brought forth, and permitted among the rest to utter an argument or two, in defence of his cause. As in sequel hereof may appear.
It followed furthermore after disputation of these three dayes being ended, that M. Harpsfield the next day after,1 which was the xix. of Aprill, should dispute for his forme, to be made Doctor. To the which disputation the Archb. of Cant. was brought forth, and permitted among the rest to vtter an argument or two, in defence of his cause. As in sequele hereof may appeare.
Harpesfield. I Am not ignorant what a weighty matter it is, to entreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures:1 and most hard it is to, in the great contention of Religion, to show the ready way, whereby the scriptures may be best understanded. For the often reading of them doth not bring the true understanding of them. What other thing is there then? Verily this is the ready way, not to follow our own heads and senses, but to give over our judgement unto the holy catholic Church, who hath had of old years the truth, and always delivered the same to their posterity: but if the often reading of scriptures, and never so painful comparing of places should bring the true understanding, then divers heretics might prevail even against whole general Councils. The *Jews did greatly brag of the knowledge of the law, and of the Saviour that they waited for. But what availed it them? Notwithstanding, I know right well, that divers places of the scripture do much warn us of the often reading of the same, and what fruit doth thereby follow: as Scrutamini, &c. Search the scriptures: for they do bear witness of me, &c. Lex Domini, &c. The law of the Lord is pure, able to turn souls. And that saying of S. Paule: Omnis Scriptura, &c. All Scripture inspired from above, doth make that a man may be instructed to all good works. Howbeit, doth the law of the Jews convert their souls? are they by reading instructed to every good work? The letter of the old Testament, is the same that we have. The heretics also have ever had the same scriptures which we have that be Catholics. But they are served as Tantalus that the Poets do speak of, who in the plenty of things to eat and drink, is said to be oppressed with hunger and thirst. The swifter that men do seek the Scriptures without the Catholic church, the deeper they fall, and find hell for their labour. Saint Cyprian never swerving from the Catholic Church, saith: He that doth not acknowledge the Church to be his mother, shall not have God to be his father. Therefore it is true Divinity,* to be wise with the Church, where Christ sayeth: Nisi manducaveritis, &c. Unless ye eat my flesh, and drink my blood, ye have no life in you. If he had meant of only eating bread, and drinking wine, nothing had been more pleasant to the Capernaites, neither would they have forsaken him.
Harpesfield. I Am not ignoraunt what a weighty matter it is, to entreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures:
The flesh profiteth nothing to them that do so take it. For the Capernaites did imagine Christ to be given in such sort as he lived. But Christ spake high things: not that they should have him as flesh in the market, but to consider his presence with the spirit, * under the forms whereby it is given. As there is an alteration of bodies by courses and times of ages, so there is no less * variety in eating of bodies. These things which I have recited briefly. M. Harpsfield did with many more words set out: and hereupon D. Weston disputed against him.
The fleshe profiteth nothing to them that doe so take it. For the Capernaites did imagine Christ to be geuen in such sorte as he lyued. But Christ spake high thinges: not that they should haue hym as fleshe in the market, but to consider his presence with the spirite, * vnder the formes whereby it is geuen. As there is an alteration of bodies by courses and tymes of ages, so there is no lesse * varietie in eatyng of bodies. These things which I haue recited briefly. M. Harpsfield did with many more wordes set out: and hereupon D. Weston disputed against hym.
West. Christs real body is not in the sacrament: Ergo, you are deceived.
West. Christes real body is not in the sacrament: Ergo, you are deceyued.
Harps. I deny the antecedent.
West. John the 6. Dico veritatem vobis, &c. I speak the truth unto you: It behooveth me that I go away from you. For unless I do depart, that comforter cannot come, &c. 1Upon this I will make this argument. Christ is so gone away as he did send the holy Ghost. But the holy Ghost did verily come into the world: Ergo, Christ is verily gone.
West. Iohn the 6. Dico veritatem vobis, &c. I speake the truth vnto you: It behooueth me that I go away from you. For vnlesse I do depart, that comforter cannot come, &c. 1Upon this I will make this argument. Christ is so gone away as he did send the holy Ghost. But the holy Ghost did verily come into the world: Ergo, Christ is verily gone.
Harps. He is verily gone, and yet remaineth here.
West. S. Augustine saith, that these words: Ego ero, &c. I will be with you even to the end of the world, are accomplished, secundum maiestatem, According to his maiestie: But secundum praesentiam carnis, non est hic, By the presence of his flesh, he is not here. The Church hath him not in flesh, but by belief.
West. S. Augustine sayth, that these wordes: Ego ero, &c. I wyll be with you euen to the end of the world, are accomplished, secundum maiestatem, According to his maiestie: But secundum praesentiam carnis, non est hic, By the presence of hys flesh, he is not here. The Church hath hym not in flesh, but by beliefe.
Harps. We must diligently weigh that there are two natures in Christ: the divine nature, & humane nature. The divine nature is of such sort, that it cannot choose but be in all places. The humane nature is not such, that of force it must be in all places, although it be in divers, after a divers manner. So where that the doctors do entreat of his presence by majesty, they do commend the majesty of the Divine nature not to hinder us of the * natural presence here in the sacrament.
Harps. We must diligently weigh that there are two natures in Christ: the diuine nature, & humane nature. The diuine nature is of such sort, that it cannot chuse but bee in all places. The humane nature is not such, that of force it must be in all places, althogh it be in diuers, after a diuers maner. So where that the doctors do entreat of hys presence by maiestie, they do commend the maiestie of the Diuine nature not to hinder vs of the * natural presence here in the sacrament.